Through the Griffin Door Supercut: Prisoner of Azkaban Chapters 13-15

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 13 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 71

  • @LunaLupin
    @LunaLupin 2 місяці тому +11

    Hi Johnathon and Benjamin, Greetings from the fair city of Edinburgh in Scotland!!! I have always been a big fan of yours as i used to listen to your theories when i was a teenager, so a long time ago now!! Decided to give you guys another look the other day and was amazed art the content. Watched all of What if Harry was in Slytherin in one day!! Am now working my way through your Through the Griffin Door series and am about to start chapter 7 but thought i'd leave you guys a review. Your new series is a godsend!!!! I work in a very busy charity shop (you'd call it a thrift store} and it can get very chaotic and loud, so my manager lets me wear earbud so the noise of the shop isnt as intense. I was listening to you guys at work today whilst serving the customers, and it was amazing. Your theories are sometimes mind blowing in their brilliance, but also it was like you were both natterng in my ear and keeping me company as surprisingly working behind a till all day can sometimes be a remarkably lonley job. Thank you so much for that!! I'm glad you've made it as far as Prisoner of Azkaban, its always been my favourite. I do have a theory for you to consider if you're intrested. So it is hinted that Dean Thomas may be a halfblood rather than a muggle-born, his dad ran off before he was on born and his mum was a muggle. I beleive that it is possible that Dean's father was a wizard, however he got killed by the deatheaters, possibly because of his pro-muggle sentiments, before he could tell Dean's mum he was magic. There is a further level to this theory, I believe that Dean's father was actually the younger brother of Kingsley Shacklebolt, however both Dean and Kingsley are both unaware of this relationship. Perhaps once Kingsley meet Dean he recogonises his lost brother in Dean, Dean and Kingsley seem to have a very good relationship with each other during the Battle of Hogwarts in the movie. Thank you for reading, I look forward to your thoughts, LunaLupin1999

  • @FenixTheDon
    @FenixTheDon 2 місяці тому +3

    REST IN PEACE to Dame Maggie Smith, aka Professor Minerva McGonagall, she just passed away this morning (09/27).
    A Legend to be remembered for years to come.

    • @jenniedarling3710
      @jenniedarling3710 28 днів тому

      For a minute I was so confused thinking "how can there be a 27th month". Then I realised this is written month then date.

  • @jaredcole5818
    @jaredcole5818 2 місяці тому +8

    I think the footrests on the brooms are for more than just comfort or luxury I think they're also for performance. what's stronger your arms or your legs? your legs. if you need to make a sharp turn you can use the footrests as something to push your legs against while you're also steering the broom with your arms for sharper and more agile maneuvers.

    • @saraboyer5348
      @saraboyer5348 29 днів тому +1

      Agreed - since its a racing broom I thought maybe the footrests would allow the rider to push against them to lean farther forward for more speed. AND they would also work like when a motorcyclist puts a foot down on the pavement during a sharp turn. (or even like a rudder, you push more on one side and it swings the front of the broom around)

  • @UnfazedPhoenix
    @UnfazedPhoenix 28 днів тому

    J quietly giving Ben the time and space to get this thought back about triathlon bikes was so respectful and wholesome. Part of the reason I love everything SCB. They are both genuinely awesome people.

  • @likecascade7015
    @likecascade7015 2 місяці тому +6

    I swear, these Quidditch matches were one of the many best things in this book.

    • @KnobleSloth
      @KnobleSloth 2 місяці тому

      Wait until you read the rest of the books.

    • @likecascade7015
      @likecascade7015 2 місяці тому

      @@KnobleSloth oh I’ve already read them. I’m on the seventh book again.

    • @kiddbuu5178
      @kiddbuu5178 2 місяці тому

      ​@@likecascade7015i read the 7th book the night it came out in a little under 20 hours. I wish I had taken my time a bit more.

  • @danielsantiagourtado3430
    @danielsantiagourtado3430 2 місяці тому +4

    LOVE your compilations guys! Keep up the good work 😊😊😊

  • @kwstasapostolou6823
    @kwstasapostolou6823 Місяць тому +1

    I love book Harry and ginny relationship but I got to speak my truth. Harry and cho obviously didn’t work out but you gotta wonder what could have been if Harry had gotten to her first. Cho wasn’t in the proper state of mind in order of the phoenix and that kinda dented their chances. We don’t know how she would have acted otherwise with Harry if she wasn’t mourning or even had gotten together with Cedric at all. Makes you wonder what if

  • @EmilyCrocettiTV
    @EmilyCrocettiTV 2 місяці тому +4

    I just thought… Lupin helped make the map and therefore knew off by heart where all of the hidden passageways are, why didn’t he tell Dumbledore to place security at the one-eyed witch statue? Harry makes a point in saying it’s not being guarded

  • @undrhil
    @undrhil 8 днів тому

    3:54:31 it also explains how she was able to open the trapdoor from her desk, which is why I had this thought about trelawny having a Time Turner way back when you first read the chapter where they go to their first divination class:-)

  • @danielrhouck
    @danielrhouck Місяць тому

    1:53:28 Sure, they use *castle-internal* Floo powder. I think that doesnʼt necessarily mean it goes outside the castle.
    2:46:55 Thatʼd be an interesting What If series. What if James had not heard about Sirius telling Snape this until it was too late?
    3:55:40 Yes. Step 0: acquire invisibility cloak or master Disillusionment. Step 1: hide, watch class. Step 2: Go back in time to start of class. Step 3: Teach class. Optional bonus step: have invisible you from step one open the trapdoor, while teacher you from step 3 hides in shadows; I still think the trapdoor just automatically responds to the question but this makes it work the way you thought, where she mysteriously reveals herself twice.
    4:02:29 I expect that the Hogwarts students *do* have to learn cursive, actually. Because cursive works better for quills and fountain pens, which run more, while print works better for ballpoint pens. This is *why* cursive exists and some people (especially older ones) swear itʼs easier, and many kids find it harder.
    4:27:05 Nope, Zacharias, like Hepzibah, is a Hufflepuff. I donʼt know if theyʼre related or not, but Hepzibah might help you remember Zachariasʼs house better.
    4:43:02 That does make a lot of sense, but I think you are putting too little weight on the possibility itʼs his. He lives in an orphanage; probably they have a christmas present budget or something and got him a cheap generic diary. His name is on the diary, and not wiped clear like everything else, which is my main problem; if heʼd label it *as his* after stealing it then yeah I think that makes sense.

  • @Catsforeveryone
    @Catsforeveryone 2 місяці тому +1

    Ruddy means reddish and blotchy fyi. That’s why they say it turned the color of parchment. It’s a color change. He went from red and flushed to pale.

  • @shubhangiraghuvanshi779
    @shubhangiraghuvanshi779 2 місяці тому +1

    I ❤❤❤❤❤these guys

  • @Daddyoh94
    @Daddyoh94 2 місяці тому +1

    Jim Dale: Harryyyy Haaarryyyyy...
    Cats are very nimble in the air, I could see the core of a broom utilizing this trait.
    Snitches maybe have to heal their wings, and the newer they are, the faster they fly. In PS the snitch in the basement has a broken wing?
    Percy is such a politician

  • @leoizumi8480
    @leoizumi8480 Місяць тому

    2:15:44 I can understand the point of her cat being a cat. But my main issue withthis entire situation is the fact that Hermione KNOWS cats will be cats and still buys crookshanks when her best friend for the last two years owns a rat. And then proceeds to downplay the attacks on said rat while letting the cat roam about. It seems very inconsiderate on behalf of Hermione regardless of the rat being Pettigrew.

  • @Pixiemage
    @Pixiemage Місяць тому

    The Trelawney time turner concept would actually be fairly simple. The present version of her wouldn’t be the one teaching the class, the future version would travel back in time to teach. In the present, she’d already be up in the classroom prior to the start of class, hide away somewhere to watch, and the trapdoor opens to let students in AFTER her future self appears in the classroom via timeturner. Future Trelawney teaches, then at the end of class Present Time Trelawney travels back in time to teach the class she just watched. “Future” Trelawney picks up where her past self left off and carries on with her day.
    She’d basically be repeating the same script to the class that she watched herself say the first time around, but it wouldn’t be hard to do lol. Watch, then go back and teach it. Easy!
    Granted I think she has too much pride and belief in her abilities to actually do that, but it could be done!

  • @jagannathan8879
    @jagannathan8879 2 місяці тому +1

    Love ur content keep it going!❤😂

  • @charazord1
    @charazord1 2 місяці тому

    1:35:32 keep in mind the fact that there's two possible families in hiding because of it. And he can be taking the memory part very deliberately because the long bottoms are not dead but they are "vegetables" so to him it is true. We can't be sure if the potters and long bottoms were told or not.

  • @charazord1
    @charazord1 2 місяці тому

    It might be foreshadowing the reveal of the patrones in this book, and it would be something like a vision in his dreams 1:13:46.

  • @ryanpratt6993
    @ryanpratt6993 2 місяці тому +1

    Does using or creating amagical object imbue it with some manner of sentience? With all the spells Mr Weasley put on his car, maybe that’s why it became fully sentient to the point it decided to run off into the Forbidden Forest.
    It certainly seems to have inherited Ron’s intense dislike for spiders.

    • @ryanpratt6993
      @ryanpratt6993 2 місяці тому

      Wands choose their wizards. The Firebolt, which is I think the most advanced broom at that point, obeys his thoughts.
      Then there’s the story of the Wizard and the Hopping Pot where it makes a point of saying that the pot had been used by the old mentor for his whole life, so maybe that’s how that object became sentient, too.

    • @saraboyer5348
      @saraboyer5348 29 днів тому

      @@ryanpratt6993 like droids that don't get regular memory wipes - they start to develop personality

  • @miles951
    @miles951 16 днів тому

    I would love to listen to the Harry potter books narated by you two!

  • @charazord1
    @charazord1 2 місяці тому

    1:32:53 the fact that black did not have a trial meaning that in the case of the night James and black both are sent to prison. And that is the smallest change. If there is an auror who would listen then a bigger change happens.

  • @ajaxsuperbest1
    @ajaxsuperbest1 2 місяці тому

    1:13:18 talking about the dream, I always kinda thought this was one of the first (maybe the actual first) times of him dreaming voldermorts movements, as he is chasing a unicorn (silvery white) through the forests of albania (where pettigrew finds him i believe?) voldemort must again be the shadowy wraith like before quirrell finds him right? Living on unicorn blood to survive?

  • @charazord1
    @charazord1 2 місяці тому

    18:07 with the Peter biting, remember that it might be the case of Peter just not liking the father since school and Peter's bravery is only shown in the crime that black is committed for. Up until this point.

  • @undrhil
    @undrhil 9 днів тому

    2:08:34 I'm not sure which Percy Jackson books you are reading, but all I ever hear referred to are generic snacks and fast food wrappers, never any specific brands

  • @undrhil
    @undrhil 8 днів тому

    3:47:09 so does this mean that most people are intimidated by Hermione and can't do their magic when she's around or is she somehow sabotaging everyone else?

  • @charazord1
    @charazord1 2 місяці тому

    19:17 that's is the first time that she's able to see it in a non clinical atmosphere. Yes she is apart of the vetting process but now seeing it flown by a student is a different way to see it.

  • @undrhil
    @undrhil 8 днів тому

    3:14:18 I think the TV show would be amazing if they could get the original golden Trio to play some of the characters, such as Daniel Radcliffe playing Snape which would be an amazing Portland to of the actor and have Ruford Grint play as Arthur Weasley

  • @ryanpratt6993
    @ryanpratt6993 2 місяці тому

    As for the horcrux, Dumbledore says the horcrux latched onto the closest living thing in the room. So it would definitely have still latched onto Harry, since he’s still the closest living thing

  • @ForeverKite42
    @ForeverKite42 2 місяці тому +1

    Has anyone explained why Harry represents Slytherin within his friend group? Even when I was a child, I had always assumed that since Harry was 'marked as the Dark Lord's equal' that the sorting hat was sensing that when it was suggesting Slytherin house. I always felt Ron was more of a Slytherin with his constant want for fame and validation.

    • @kiddbuu5178
      @kiddbuu5178 2 місяці тому +2

      Ron wants glory. Which is more gryffindor where as Harry has pride and ambition not so much for attention which is more slytherin.

  • @bradleylong1727
    @bradleylong1727 2 місяці тому +1

    Would James blame Dumbldor for Lilys death if he survived? If James hadn’t lent him the cloak she could have survived

  • @charazord1
    @charazord1 2 місяці тому

    1:25:09 also there's more than the magical cat on the grounds of hogwarts 1:25:09, so is it impossible to communicate with the spiders as an animagus? Or the other magical beasts? Or is it that the magical cat is Harry's by birthright and black is a known being from beforehand and he passed the test?

  • @Leviticus_Prime
    @Leviticus_Prime 2 місяці тому

    I think it's more that Hermione refuses to keep Crookshanks away from Scabbers and seems to not care that Scabbers is in danger. It's like if your neighbor refuses to properly secure their dog and their dog attacks your pet. Hermione comes off as someone who doesn't care if Scabbers gets killed and won't take the time to ensure Crookshanks can't get to Scabbers.

  • @charazord1
    @charazord1 2 місяці тому

    In 1:43:56 this what if could we have a Ron who instead of meeting Harry at 11yo, grows up having extended sleep overs at Ron's house or something like that may be Molly watches Harry whenever the three aren't able to. There for the twins are the ones that get jealous of the fact that Ron has access to newer stuff from the potters. So they're even worse to Harry than Molly.

  • @charazord1
    @charazord1 2 місяці тому

    58:03 the main thing that the points do is not determine wins of games but wins of seasons/years.

  • @bhavens9149
    @bhavens9149 2 місяці тому +1

    Max Miller of Tasting History has a fairly recent episode on corn flakes, you might look it up.

    • @jenniedarling3710
      @jenniedarling3710 28 днів тому +1

      I don't understand why Ben and Jay think we don't have corn flakes in the UK.

    • @bhavens9149
      @bhavens9149 28 днів тому

      @@jenniedarling3710 since HP is so very British it seems like they'd delve deeper into the culture? I mean since this is not just a casual subject for them? anyway nobodies perfect I suppose. :)

  • @charazord1
    @charazord1 2 місяці тому

    32:27 I don't know if J.K. Knew at the time of writing, about athletes and the zone, where they did instinctive actions. So I think that Harry having three years of training and on top of that having the summer to mental work on that so that he can put up with the dursleys, would have felt the zone as the broom reactioning at the highest rate of speed to the instinctive actions that he was doing, to compare it to car racing, if the driver gets into a faster gear changing car then they may have some times that they feel like the car is changing gears achording to their mind when in reality they are doing it in the zone.

  • @1goofydude
    @1goofydude 2 місяці тому +1

    About the 200 people wearing green. It's not all students, it's also parents, family, and alumni. Where I live a ton of alumni go to every football game, and this is the game that settles the champions. Definitely some nonstudents in that 200.

  • @dragoscristea7827
    @dragoscristea7827 2 місяці тому

    What if Voldemort was born a squib? How would that change the course of history?

  • @KnobleSloth
    @KnobleSloth 2 місяці тому

    J "im not wrong, I'm misunderstood"

  • @susanboylan469
    @susanboylan469 2 місяці тому

    Could you guys please make a video about triple r ranch and how Andy's cowboy camp shirt is from Triple R Ranch?

  • @tahirahussain7175
    @tahirahussain7175 2 місяці тому

    I know this is kinda random but I really want to know what would happen if Harry had a twin sis and I think it would be more interesting if she was in slytheren
    I under stand if you can't do it especially because your currently doing 'what if ron was in hufflpuff' but I would really appreciate of you could because I am quite curious

  • @Leviticus_Prime
    @Leviticus_Prime 2 місяці тому

    I think the current plan is to focus on licensing and drop most in house I p development for non- movie/she related thing.

  • @drewbrown3629
    @drewbrown3629 2 місяці тому +1

    Timestamps please?

  • @lissaweers346
    @lissaweers346 2 місяці тому

    do all the rider have to bow to the hippogriff?

  • @JDS51
    @JDS51 2 місяці тому

    First!!! See you Monday 🔥🔥

  • @undrhil
    @undrhil 9 днів тому

    I was just talking to someone about how I could go through this video and have the chapters so that I could go to chapter 13 or chapter 14 after having watched the video for a while in case I have to stop. And this video doesn't have chapter tags?

  • @lissaweers346
    @lissaweers346 2 місяці тому

    can they make it look like james kills lily?

  • @RilianSharp
    @RilianSharp 2 місяці тому

    you can't just let your pet attack other people's pets. that's not acceptable.

  • @stu2tru
    @stu2tru 2 місяці тому

    unfortunately i don't think the people that do the art are really interested it the book from how it feels to me

  • @emre_ez
    @emre_ez 2 місяці тому

    There is a tab called podcasts in their channel page and this isnt in it

    • @wandering_butnotlost
      @wandering_butnotlost 2 місяці тому

      Can you give them a minute to add it to the playlist or are you not okay

    • @emre_ez
      @emre_ez 2 місяці тому

      @@wandering_butnotlostno you misundersyood me, i didnt mean the _playlist_ theres a tab on the channel (at least on mobile) literally called "podcasts" it has stuff like j vs ben and what if but not through the griffin door

  • @Emily09876g
    @Emily09876g 2 місяці тому

    Yikes, the stash. I hope you shave soon.

  • @zorkin2013
    @zorkin2013 2 місяці тому

    I used to watch a lot of these videos about a year or two ago but stopped after I started feeling they were just milking Harry Potter way to hard. I cannot believe you are still at it and now with the worlds most awful mustache.

  • @shinystarmiestudios4179
    @shinystarmiestudios4179 2 місяці тому

    20:29 approximately Silver Arrows were the names of the Mercedes Formula One racing team cars during the Hamilton and Rosberg era

  • @charazord1
    @charazord1 2 місяці тому

    1:03:06 it might be that just a deer patrones wood not be the correct answer to the question it might have to clarify that it was James patrones.

  • @AirDave15
    @AirDave15 2 місяці тому

    I just opened up an Oliver and James Phelps interview and for a split second I thought it was a SCB’s video. You guys are the real life Fred and George imo 🪄

  • @sarahab6497
    @sarahab6497 2 місяці тому

    1:39:00. Wouldn't they know Harry could talk to snakes, could that tip them off?

    • @ashleywalla4087
      @ashleywalla4087 2 місяці тому +1

      If we just base the situation off canon, Harry, apparently, never comes in contact with a snake until he's almost 11 years old so while it would be a head start, it wouldn't be much of one. I guess you could argue being raised by some combination of his dad and uncles he would go to the zoo earlier in life but I don't see any of the remaining 3 Marauders bringing Harry to a reptile exhibit for any longer than its a shortcut to somewhere else in the zoo and Harry starts talking to snakes in those like, 20 seconds.