One of the few really dramatic scene I really liked Rip otherwise I consider him as bastard character writers simultaneously try cheat in as badass with hearth of gold.
4:10 actually puts hands on John while shouting at him ‘Mr Dutton!!!’…… Not Sir…Mr Dutton… This reaction from Rip more than anything I think is what brought John back from the ‘red mists’
I feel bad for Jamie and kinda angry that everyone mistreats, pushes, and uses Jamie but are all surprised and upset when he does something for himself for once and becomes the threat they built and created him to be with their actions. Treat Jamie with respect and kindness and 90% of Yellowstones problems wouldn’t exist
The character of Jamie, is just like his biological father. Which he proves, again and again. Being adopted by the Duttons afforded him a great many niceties. And he doesn't appreciate, or respect, the family and the family business that despite not being a Dutton by birth, is intended to be left in his hands when John dies. Which is something that rarely happens in wealthy, established, family businesses. Especially businesses like ranching, and farming. When people's livelihoods depend upon their land, and its natural resources, they tend to develop a very deep attachment to that land. And with every generation, that attachment grows deeper. Jamie would never have lasted, working on the ranch. He was weak, and selfish, despite trying to make out as though he was doing everything he could for the family. The character was deeply flawed. Even more so than the other family member characters. He felt no real attachment to the land. And much of the angst, was brought on by his own decisions, and actions. All of the characters were, in my opinion, well written, and acted. It was an amazing series. And now that it's over, will spawn a couple of spinoffs which, if successful, will likely have some crossover. It'll be interesting to see how well they do.
@@trudyisaacs840 Respect has to go both ways. Before Beth's return (and long after), Jamie dutifully covers up all the ranch's illegal activities and keeps their behinds out of jail but he is nevet treated well despite this. He does do some terrible things himself but none more deplorable than any other of his family members' misdeeds. Also, Jamie enjoyed working on the ranch and he did a well enough kob as a wrangler, but John needed him as a lawyer again and that was the end of that. And Beth didn't give a damn about keeping the land either. Had it been for her, she would've sold it long ago. Only her blind devotion to her father kept her from doing it. As for Kayce, well we all saw what he did with the land after John died...
I love how this show portrays Jamie to be the bad guy. Yes he’s done some bad things but who hasn’t in this show, he most definitely should have told her about the operation cost beforehand but he was a scared kid who SHE came to. She has 0 accountability in that whole situation. Jamie was happy trying to become a cowboy and JOHN created him as the lawyer, John created this Jamie and now everyone’s acting all surprised when Jamie does the things their father made him to be. Again Jamie has done bad things but I truly hate how they twist this narrative protecting their sweet Beth 😂..
It’s an issue with the writing for sure. Love the show but this has always been a weird part of it. We are supposed to see Jamie as this evil corporate asshole but 90% of the characters are fucking murders and blackmailers. Then we find out that the only reason Jamie adopted this lifestyle that John hated is because John made him do it. The only truly bad thing you have him on is the Beth stuff but even then you could argue he was young and scared and thought he was doing the right thing.
Jamie was willing to fork over the land to paradise valley and market equities in a heartbeat, knowing full well that if you give land developers an inch, they’ll take every acre they want, fucking over everyone.
Beth came to Jamie begging for his help. It's not like she was noncalpable in what happened at the clinic. I'd be asking what they were gonna do to me before they put me under.
Jamie's suicide attempt scene always brings me to tears because I've been there. John absolutely did not handle it well, he said some of the worst things you can say to a suicidal person, but that scene really had me empathizing with Jaime, especially when he said "I cannot be fixed." To anyone struggling right now reading this: you can be fixed, you can get better, and feeling suicidal isn't selfish. It's just pain, and we can heal from pain. I'm living proof of that. Stay strong, friends.
They call him family but have never treated him as such. They berate, belittle, and beat him. Sabotage him any time he wants something for himself. And they're shocked when he turns away from them lol.
True, but, he's free to do that WITHOUT his dad's backing or name. That's what you miss there. The only reason he had a chance was the support, the money, the fear that came with the Dutton name.
I don't know, I have to heavily disagree. I think John loves all his children but his way of showing love in the beginning of the show left a lot to be desired. It also didn't help that Jaime tried to approve the selling of the land to build an airport, conspired against him to a reporter, etc. I'm glad it got better down the line
@@demonictelevision9427 Jamie approved the selling of the land because it would have made the ranch more money than the ranch has made from the beginning in a single day. With half a billion dollars you dont lose the ranch, you keep going somewhere else. When he conspired against him with the reporter it was right after john just beat the crap out of him for campaigning with johns approval. That also happened when john threatened to put Jamie's head through a wall for hitting his sister who lets not forget was beating the crap out of him until he defended himself. I know you may say Jamie deserved it, I dont think he did. Beth made choices and unfortunately her hysterectomy was the result. Lets not forget she was evil long before that happened. If Jamie is the villain for season 5 part 2, if it ever happens even though I paid for it 2 years ago, John and Beth made him that way.
Seriously, its all obligation to him. Jamie's spent his whole life trying to make that man happy and the old jackass thought desiring a father's love was somehow selfish. Screw John Dutton
When John said it isn't his name it's mine that summed up his feelings for Jaimie whether he calls him son or not he's not blood so he'll never truly be a Dutton
Jamie would actually be a good governor doing what’s best for Montana John just didn’t want him because he thought the ranch would go away when at the time there wasn’t a way to save it
He forced Jamie into a profession he didn't respect and then proceeded to not respect him when he came back. And it wasn't even because "he wasn't a Real Man" or some cowboy bullshit like that -- he could do all the cowboy shit.
@@lizzymatheson6487 yea they stuck him in the bunk house making it seem like he didn’t know how to cowboy but then in the next season show he was raised as a Cowboy that part didn’t make sense
Sometimes it does not matter who throws the first punch or the last punch. John only knew how to break horses and heard cattle. That mentality was applied to how he interacted with people as well. See a wolf, kill the wolf to protect the flock. A horse bucks, you break it. I do not know how he acted when his wife was in the picture, but it was clear that afterwords, he saw everyone around him as either asset or enemy. He did not allow Jamie to grow into his own man, he tried to break him to his will. Jamie could not defend himself from Beth without John and Rip bringing him to the train station, they always forgave her everything. For Jamie, the smart choice would have been to walk away like his brother. Unfortunately, he was never given the chance.
The target audience of this show was assumed to have an attitude that precluded the possibility of Jamie ever being seen in a good light("dayum big city lawyers!"), therefore they didn't actually need to make him do anything that was worse than anyone else.
The real villain is John, not only did he isolate his adopted son from him but also severed any chance of him growing to love his adopted dad, and i know why, he resents jamie for his dad that killed his wife. so the issue is that john created the monster because he is stubborn and could not let go of the murder of his wife. based on jamies phycological behavior he is being pushed into a direction of hared because ive not seen any time his dad show love or effection of a hug or i love you son, they blame him almost always. he was 17 with the situation with his sister do any 17 year old's know about that stuff? no they probably dont. however upon watching this series, john is the culprit for jamies betrayal because jamie seeks his love even with the abuse or his approval. this ladies and gentleman is what happens when you treat your children this way. i honestly hope jamie wins because in the end one mans pride is a whole family's end. pisses me off! However on other note when his biological dad showed him that love that john couldnt thats what won jamie over. in the end based on the story all jamie wants is to be loved and appreciated and acknowledged.
I don't think it's that clear but it's not really our fault for not knowing, because the series doesn't show his childhood.... i actually assumed they were a very happy family, growing up(from glimpses of stuff like family fishing or camping trips and their reminiscing)... i also assumed that BEFORE THE WIFE DIED (this is the crucial thing, that started the problems for John Dutton), Jaime got all the love he needed (from John too)!....
@OldManPaxusYT a good assumption but we see that john is very stern and almost cold for example when Rip killed that man when he was younger and the way john handles that situation can show a very big shift in his value, not only that but sending jamie to the train station there's alot we don't really know but I can see johns not been the best father we can all agree.
I agree. I absolutely hate how this show is going. It’s just Jamie being shit on and blamed, all he’s wanted is the love you speak of. And we’re not seeing John be corrected
Do you guys realize that Jamie’s biological father killed his own wife, not John’s wife. The original post said something about John resenting Jamie because his dad killed his wife. After Jamie’s dad killed his own wife he went to prison and Jamie was adopted by John and Evelyn and then his new mom Evelyn died in a horse riding accident. I do agree that it seems like Jamie has been treated like shit his whole life but it’s not because John hates him for what his dad did.
I don’t think these two characters have had a meaningful conversation since Jamie confronted John about the adoption. That was season 3. Everything since then has been too brief or in front of other characters
John is the real antagonist of this series. Everyone says it’s Beth but really she’s just a pawn for John. Jamie didn’t deserve any of the treatment he received from the Duttons. He did everything for them just for them to hate him.
The scene when jamie is gonna commit suicide. John still has no compassion for jamie. He said no one would care for jamie even if he offed himself. What a horrible father.
I always felt bad for Jamie because he was a kid himself when he had to make that dreadful decision for Beth. SHE is the one that came to him asking for help. SHE didn't want to tell her parents. SHE didn't want him to go to town because they would recognize her. So her only other option was to go to the reservation for an abortion, but order for her to get one she she had to be sterilized. He didn't ask for it- it was protocol. . If she hadn't put herself in that situation, Jamie would never have been in the position to have to make such a drastic decision. Again, he was just a kid himself! People seem to forget that, especially Beth. What Jamie did was wrong- he should've just told their father at that point. But he didn't, and Beth blames him entirely for ruining her life when in reality, she was just as responsible but conveniently forgets that.
I agree. She did go to him and ask for help. Yes what he did was wrong, but it’s obvious he feels terrible for what he did. Beth shouldn’t be blaming him for everything that goes wrong in her life.
Beth was partially at fault but keep a few things in mind: 1)When she became a teen until the point that her mom died, her mom mentally and emotionally abused her. Her mom even warned her that she was going to do it. Her mom also let her think that it was Beth's fault that she died when that wasn't true at all. It all messed her up which was why she started drinking and sleeping around. 2) Rip was the dad. If John knew he had gotten Beth pregnant, off to the train station Rip would have went. Mind you, she didn't know about the train station but she did know the ranch was all Rip had. She at least had an idea of the things her dad could do to Rip. 3)Beth is someone who would die for John so she would rather not upset him if possible. But back then, he made it so she couldn't go to him about it. John admitted that part of the blame was on himself. The family name was also at risk and that was another reason why Jaime & Beth didn't go to him. They were practically the founders of the area. John understood the legacy of the family and made it a point to tell them to protect it at all costs. 4)What Beth is really upset about was the fact that she was sterilized without her knowledge. Had Jamie told her about that aspect, she may have changed her mind. The woman at the clinic begged Jamie to take Beth somewhere else and he said "No"-family name, scandel, their legacy, etc. She asked him if it was ok and he said "yes" without batting an eye. At that moment, he was thinking more about John than Beth. She took his word that everything was going to work out. If she had known and made the choice, she would have taken the blame onto herself. But Jamie made that decision for her. She wanted an abortion not sterilization, she never agreed to the second aspect of the procedure.
@@kerriethompson2073 🎯 No native abortion clinic wouldn’t have talked it over before the procedure, esp to a white woman . Also a hysterectomy which she had is major surgery to an abortion. No way she would have been able to go about as she did. Unfortunately her father doesn’t see any of them as children needing love or help , after the loss of his wife he closes off . Instead their relationships become fractured . John is horrible to Jamie even before the mother’s death . He treats all his son’s as transactions to further his agenda. With Jamie as the scapegoat. Hopefully Jamie tells his ex baby momma about the train station ,before they put him in it . Only way Beth bonds with John is by becoming invested in the farm & business. Which is the only currency she knows to get by . Beth has no friends, close friendship’s, extended family ie aunts ,uncles ,cousins . To Learn the layers of normal relationships , instead all her relationships become transactional. John allows her independence , he also allows her disrespect for everyone , which becomes worse as an adult . She behaves like a psychopath with a personality disorder. Even Rip pulls her up on her behaviour, especially when Carter cones along despite the trauma his childhood had . He knows it’s not normal.
I have to wonder: Did John stop Jamie from killing himself because he genuiely cared for him or because he had more use for him? And would he have let Jamie kill himself if he knew sooner about what happened between him and Beth?
@@Caffeine-Queen John’s family is cursed , hope Jamie wakes up and unravels their evil cabal. My hope is Kaycee family takes over brings peace & healing to the cursed land . So the tapu is lifted .
John has failed as a father let’s recap all he ever has done is use His children for his own benefit and all his children are a product of his failure. Beth is a psychopath and a narcissist, and she would do anything to please him considering that he sees her as a disappointment and Lee was his personal bodyguard/murderer, and Jamie was his own personal lawyer/go to guy just in case he needs him. And the only pure child of the family is Casey but overall his legacy is nothing but a failed father
I love how Beth is acting like Killing Jaimie is something John has to do to protect the family. Trying to manipulate him into doing something she's wanted for years and that's Killing Jaimie
Can we talk y'all? Is this a safe space? I hope so cause John treated Jamie so wrong. He never loved him in the first place. I don't think he's ever supported any of his real wishes, which was unfair. In terms of Beth, who I love so much, I can understand her fury, but she shouldn't have put it all on Jamie. They were both kids who made wrong choices. I think the only one in this family who loved Jamie was Kayce.
If you watch this compilation without seeing the rest of the show, Jamie is the protagonist and John and Beth are despicable people continually humiliating him and running his life into the ground for no reason
Why doesn't Jaimie just leave the ranch? the guy is a good lawyer, let him just go to New York or Washington to build a political or legal career, and let him stay away from this sick family that despises him.
@@Peter-vg4sx he rejects John he loses his protection from Beth. Can you honestly look at Beth Dutton and tell me that she wouldn’t arrange for Jamie to have an “accident” if John thought Jamie wasn’t essential to the ranch. Besides regardless of John and Beth, Lee and Kayce did and do love him as a brother and the feeling was very much mutual. Jamie grew up believing his devotion and hard work would be rewarded despite all the pain he went through. He was proven wrong, he realized that unless he did something their would not be a ranch to inherit. I do not know whether his choice comes from a place of love betrayed or to protect what he loves, maybe some combination of the two, either way, he decided the only way forward was war. Knowing Beth, there was never another choice for Jamie to survive, even if he stayed loyal.
@@denverbritto5606 Beth does not care what happens to herself. Or at least that is the image she projects. Whatever the truth, everyone who knows her would believe she would die with a smile on her face if it meant her target died too. Does not matter where you are if your assassin does not care if they die too.
Jamie was asked by Beth to handle a situation that no child should ever be asked to do. If Jamie told the truth to John, Rip would’ve been dead by John’s hand. Beth has held it over Jamie’s since, because she was too afraid to face the music.
I haven’t watched the prequel’s to Yellowstone, but it would be pretty cool to see Lee and the rest of the family who passed away along side the cast in a spinoff
13:57 i enjoy how jamie tells john whats he could lose if he doesn't take the deal and who is responsible for putting him in that position all while appearing objective
@@VanessaCurry711to a certain extent yes, but he is what his father made him become. When it came time to “take him to the train station” I believe Lee would have protected Jamie as his older brother.
Yeah, I’ve heard of it! They help you book reservations to meet celebrities, right? Sounds pretty wild, but also kind of amazing for fans who want to connect with their favorite stars.
Exactly! It’s such a game-changer. Instead of just hoping for a chance encounter, you can actually book a spot to meet celebrities like Beth, or whoever you’re into. It’s such a unique way to get that one-on-one experience with someone you admire.
I love that they’ve made it so much more accessible. I mean, before, it was almost impossible to meet someone unless you were in the right place at the right time. Now you can plan it, and it feels a lot more personal.
I totally agree. Plus, they offer a variety of options, like backstage passes, private dinners, and even one-on-one meetups. It’s perfect for superfans who want that special moment with their idols.
I had the chance to book a reservation with my favorite celebrity through them, and it was such an unforgettable experience. Definitely worth it if you're a true fan!
I mean I know the Market Equities lady is playing Jamie, but she is right. John lowkey does fear Jamie, because he surpassed him. Jamie is honestly the only one of them with the skills to run the ranch successfully, but it involves change and John can’t stand that. Jamie had proven to be better than John at a number of things.
Jamie was easily influenced by the idea of self-preservation. As soon as he found out he was adopted after everything he did to reconnect with himself, he went back down the wrong path. He convinced himself that he was no longer John's son and that was just not true. Watch John's interaction with Jamie's birth father, and tell me he didn't love Jamie.
John was nasty to him. Rather you love someone or not. If you fail to show them, they'll never know. Love is an action word. John even admitted he refused to show Jamie love.
@@laniquegolphin5004 Jamie is all about protecting himself. He was all ready to grovel and get back in John's good graces until he realized that he was cut out of the trust fund and even John said the only reason he did what he did was because he stood to inherit part of the ranch. Sooooo do with that what you will. Jamie is just as wrong.
@@laniquegolphin5004 He admitted to Beth that AFTER what happened. Jamie went against him TWICE. Tried to destroy him more than once. Yes, I would feel some pain for that too.
I cannot get enough of this show, this work of art. I understand how some will find that statement offensive, perhaps as offensive as much of the storyline and violence portrayed. My reality remains... Yellowstone, the trilogy, is the closest thing to depicting the realities of my childhood. Yes, the amount of violence is unsettling; however, for those raised under similar conditions in parts of the World such as Montana, Wyoming, North Dakota, and others, it's relatable. "Like or accept" it or not, much of the Pioneer Family Histories are much more similar to the Duttons' than today's "Soy-Boys" and the liberal beta males sculpted by a Nation that turned "Masculinity" into a slur, and replacing it with the label of "Toxic Masculinity." Taylor Sheridan and John Linson really created a masterpiece with this series, and I, for one, hope they will continue bringing us raw perspectives on how the West was Won. In a word, BRAVO!!!
@@Ca-SandraMorris-That's difficult to answer. However, most days, I'd like to embody the qualities and demeanor of John Dutton. On others, I'd enjoy tapping into my "Inner Beth Dutton" and all of her "Specia Qualities."
Ofc someone had to bring politics in it unprompted. Masculinity isn’t toxic, the way you treat people who don’t ascribe to your particular idea of it is nothing more or less.
One thing that always stood out to me is Jamie's name. If John really didnt see Jamie as his son why not let him keep his original name Michael? If he really didnt see him as his blood, why give him the name of the man who founded Yellowstone in the first place?
As someone who grew up with a separate father the way they treat Jaime, is the way my family treated me, it go so bad I hit my "dad" with a shovel, it was justified and even the cop said, how did you piss off a 15 year old so much that he hit you with a shovel? 😂
Say what you want about him but John really did treat him like total crap. He never "loved" him. All he did was use him. Dont get me started with Beth. I realize Jamie made a big mistake, but that was years ago. You can't treat him like crap every time you see him.
Everyone who is saying how awful John is to Jamie he did apply to law school for him bc he knew he wouldn’t leave the ranch I know he wanted a lawyer fir the family but he had plenty of money to just hire one
John Dutton is such a shit father. He is an excellent villain protagonist and character but is a dreadful human being. John Dutton is a feudal landlord who's pretense to be a decent person. But will crush anyone who does not bow down to him. He's closer to Walter White of Breaking Bad defending his Empire. Than any John Wayne-type character
I think that's false. On _all_ counts! 😮 He isn't a feudal landlord. He isn't just _pretending_ to be a decent person. He wasn't crushing ppl who do not 'bow' down to him. _Everything_ you said was wrong. Did you even watch all of it? Assuming you did - Just a few 'in a nutshell' points: (1) Learn what a feudal landlord really is. (2) 'Decent Person' as a pretense only? He _was_ always a decent man! The only 'kinks' in his armour started when his wife died and even then, he was always as decent as he _could_ be to the best of his abilities. He's human, like all of us. To say anything else is holding him to unrealistic standards. He, always, tried to do the right thing. That's the whole thing that makes this show great! (Showing how it's impossible to be perfect. Showing how GOOD PPL do bad things and bad ppl do good things. What happens when GOOD ppl are faced with IMPOSSIBLE challenges). OK, i'm rambling but that he was not 'decent' is ludicrous. He's as 'stand up' a guy, as could be! (3) Crushing ppl who don't bow down to him?.... Again, patently false. Crushing 'enemies' (i.e those who attack you 1st), is not attacking ppl for now 'bowing down' to you!.... He was ruthless in self-defense, which is often the right choice, or rather, the rather, the 'practical' choice. Even then, he tried, many times, *_not_* to crush, more than once, before he _would_ crush - especially when ppl deserved a 2nd (or even 3rd) chance. You are making these quick judgements, without much explanation.... I think the whole point, was to explore what happens to humans who _are_ 'decent', 'good fathers', 'land owners/employers' etc when faced with impossible situations!
@@OldManPaxusYT I like John but he's a horrible father he does not give unconditional love to any of his children. He only sees his children as tools and what they can do for him and then gives them his love. He is a very rich man who murders literally anyone who steps on his property and then Brands those reviews are loyal. You brand what you own. He is not a simple man defending his land is a wealthy man defending his Empire. He's closer to Walter White of Breaking Bad defending his Empire. Than any John Wayne-type character. Are they are worst people in the show, absolutely. He cultivates Rick into a hardened attack dog to kill his enemies. He is one of the richest landowners in the entire state fiction. He runs for governor to maintain his own personal power. Not to benefit his fellow citizens but to benefit themselves he's as greedy as any politician infection similar to House of Cards.
I stopped watching this trainwreck of a show awhile back, but my take is that Jamie should have cut all ties and walked as soon as he found out he wasn't blood related to the Duttons. That was his cue to leave Montana for good and start his own law practice somewhere far, far away from the toxic environment he was raised in. The only explanation is that the constant abuse and humiliation he suffers at the hands of this despicable hillbilly crime family has afflicted him with some kind of stockholm syndrome where he seeks acceptance and approval from his captors. Sadly, I predict that will be his undoing.
Thank god the comment section is like that. I love the show, with immaculate writing and acting, but thank god so many people understand that John Dutton is the villain here. The more I watched the show, the less I could root for any of the characters but fucking hell, I wished Jamie could have gotten out of there. None of them is a good person but it's all justified with it 'being for the family'. Beth proposing to kill Jamie because his now 'an enemy of the family' destroys every logic behind that.... It's just for the approval of one person, John Dutton. They don't even value the literal members of their family but justify every heinous act as doing it for the family. What Jamie did to Beth was also horrible but saying they should kill him now over this all this political and financial drama is so freaking low...That was honestly the last straw for me.
You're going to get strong and be a man and do what a man does. Which is sacrifice any and all ambition and do what you father tells you to do every time.
...yes, you're right, that it's not 'fair'... I hope you mean that as praise for "Yellowstone" the series though! 😉 Your point about it being 'not fair', *is **_exactly_** what makes this show good!* It's realistic. That, kind of thing, is _exactly_ what happens in life, *_all the time._*
@@denniswyatt6418 Lmao, you sure we watched the same show? She was an asshole to everyone including Rip, like kissing other men in front of him while she was young fully knowing he loves her. That's just the tip of the iceberg.
@@denniswyatt6418 of course when raised by a toxic narcissist its no surprise he turned out a narcissist psychopath like Beth character. Kaycee is nothing like either , older brother we only got a glimpse of his character. Jamie is product of being raised in such toxic masculinity & narcissistic abuse . In real life Jamie of this world would be addicted to drugs & alcohol to get through .
The more I see the more I dislike John. He is such a hypocrite He would bury everything just to keep that Ranch. He murdered and has others murder. He lies manipulates and pits his children against each other
Lynelle should have told Jamie, that she was endorsing John and not Jamie; so sad to see how hurtful that was. Jamie, wants to do the best for the Ranch, John and Beth don't see that. Pretty sad considering all Jamie has done for John. I hope with John out of the picture now, that some miracle helps Jamie rise above and save the Ranch, even if it's for the First Nations.
Sometimes committing suicide can be understood in a state of desperation. Will one then receive help, that question is asked in an unrealistic manner,it helps for once. it could still turn out differently.
I'll always be on team Jamie. They never loved him, and they used him numerous times while he bailed them out of so many situations. Wish he stayed with Randal and his son.
Jamie was at his best living the cowboy life in season 2 and when he's defending the family, love seeing those times during the marathons, hate that he turned on them again!
Jamie Dutton was right From Bethany Dutton she's not the only one who protecting her father's legacy and his ranch and his family she's just protecting herself and that's it Jamie was right a course
I just don’t understand these comments. Jamie has great qualities.. intelligent and skillful. But his Dad is right. He has no heart. Everything he does is for himself. He could’ve so dang good for their family. He could’ve saved them so many times and did it at times. With a man of his skill, the Dutton family could be so protected. But he always wants to sell or lease portions of his family’s land for money. I get that it might be the smart move temporarily, but it’s clear to everyone except him that once you give a piece, they’ll want it all. And he just wants his own success and is willing to jeopardize their given rights to do so. I don’t respect Jamie as a man at all. I respect his capability, but no heart at all. He should’ve worked on himself and became stronger and learned from his Dad. It would’ve paid off dividends.
Everything JOHN does is for himself. Sending Jamie to law school because HE needed a lawyer. Holding Evelyn's death over Beth's head to keep her beholden to HIM. Waging HIS war that killed Lee. And if HE had his way, and Kayce had Beth's parental instincts, there wouldn't even be a Tate. Jamie was loyal to John for decades, but got beat and kicked out for not answering his phone. Jamie had enough heart to become the best lawyer he could for his "father", but it went unrecognized and unappreciated.
John's biggest mistake was taking that riffle away from Jamie. The attack might not have happened, the impeachment and everything else Jamie's weakness brought to their home.
If I were Jamie- I’d pack my bags and leave everything behind to disappear and start a new life elsewhere. All of this family drama is exhausting. After all- he isn’t their real kid.
I think Kaycee and Jamie have gotten the raw end of the stick for the sole fact that they wanted to what was best for themselves and they were at lifes best when they werent at the ranch. But then the cancerous tentacle's of the ranch pull them back in and enslave everyone just because an overzealous man doesnt want to lose his ranch and the skeletons come out of the closet.
3:57 when Rip nonchalantly walks in between the fight as if to remind them they’re family. Love the writing
One of the few really dramatic scene I really liked Rip otherwise I consider him as bastard character writers simultaneously try cheat in as badass with hearth of gold.
Even when Jaime says it’s between family he still is on his side and tells him to calm down and get a hotel
4:10 actually puts hands on John while shouting at him ‘Mr Dutton!!!’……
Not Sir…Mr Dutton…
This reaction from Rip more than anything I think is what brought John back from the ‘red mists’
This is why ive always and will always like Rip more. And now he's the lead like he deserves.
I feel bad for Jamie and kinda angry that everyone mistreats, pushes, and uses Jamie but are all surprised and upset when he does something for himself for once and becomes the threat they built and created him to be with their actions. Treat Jamie with respect and kindness and 90% of Yellowstones problems wouldn’t exist
I can assure you, most women do not concur.
@@alyssaxxy How so?
I agree...the Jamie character was doomed the moment he was adopted into the diabolical Dutton family.
The character of Jamie, is just like his biological father. Which he proves, again and again. Being adopted by the Duttons afforded him a great many niceties. And he doesn't appreciate, or respect, the family and the family business that despite not being a Dutton by birth, is intended to be left in his hands when John dies. Which is something that rarely happens in wealthy, established, family businesses.
Especially businesses like ranching, and farming. When people's livelihoods depend upon their land, and its natural resources, they tend to develop a very deep attachment to that land. And with every generation, that attachment grows deeper. Jamie would never have lasted, working on the ranch. He was weak, and selfish, despite trying to make out as though he was doing everything he could for the family.
The character was deeply flawed. Even more so than the other family member characters. He felt no real attachment to the land. And much of the angst, was brought on by his own decisions, and actions. All of the characters were, in my opinion, well written, and acted. It was an amazing series. And now that it's over, will spawn a couple of spinoffs which, if successful, will likely have some crossover. It'll be interesting to see how well they do.
@@trudyisaacs840 Respect has to go both ways. Before Beth's return (and long after), Jamie dutifully covers up all the ranch's illegal activities and keeps their behinds out of jail but he is nevet treated well despite this. He does do some terrible things himself but none more deplorable than any other of his family members' misdeeds.
Also, Jamie enjoyed working on the ranch and he did a well enough kob as a wrangler, but John needed him as a lawyer again and that was the end of that.
And Beth didn't give a damn about keeping the land either. Had it been for her, she would've sold it long ago. Only her blind devotion to her father kept her from doing it. As for Kayce, well we all saw what he did with the land after John died...
The way John talked to Jaimie right in front of Beth. Calling him weak I mean that's cold hearted and Beth was just loving every second of it
I love Jamie. He’s definitely the scapegoat. They are so cruel to him. But, it’s all part of the story.
Love the character of Jamie, he’s my favourite
Definitely a tortured soul
Thank you for your kindness
@@Caffeine-Queen me too.
Awwwwe stop it! He’s a wussy!😂😂😂😂 just joking! Not my favorite but Jamie has done tons for the ranch!💪🏼💪🏼
I love how this show portrays Jamie to be the bad guy. Yes he’s done some bad things but who hasn’t in this show, he most definitely should have told her about the operation cost beforehand but he was a scared kid who SHE came to. She has 0 accountability in that whole situation. Jamie was happy trying to become a cowboy and JOHN created him as the lawyer, John created this Jamie and now everyone’s acting all surprised when Jamie does the things their father made him to be. Again Jamie has done bad things but I truly hate how they twist this narrative protecting their sweet Beth 😂..
Jamie has done bad things but they can all be traced back to John or Beth. He’s the most deserving of a happy ending.
I don’t know about you guys, but Jamie is my favorite character
It’s an issue with the writing for sure. Love the show but this has always been a weird part of it. We are supposed to see Jamie as this evil corporate asshole but 90% of the characters are fucking murders and blackmailers. Then we find out that the only reason Jamie adopted this lifestyle that John hated is because John made him do it. The only truly bad thing you have him on is the Beth stuff but even then you could argue he was young and scared and thought he was doing the right thing.
Jamie was willing to fork over the land to paradise valley and market equities in a heartbeat, knowing full well that if you give land developers an inch, they’ll take every acre they want, fucking over everyone.
Beth came to Jamie begging for his help. It's not like she was noncalpable in what happened at the clinic. I'd be asking what they were gonna do to me before they put me under.
Jamie's suicide attempt scene always brings me to tears because I've been there. John absolutely did not handle it well, he said some of the worst things you can say to a suicidal person, but that scene really had me empathizing with Jaime, especially when he said "I cannot be fixed." To anyone struggling right now reading this: you can be fixed, you can get better, and feeling suicidal isn't selfish. It's just pain, and we can heal from pain. I'm living proof of that. Stay strong, friends.
Yup; that scene showed me that John only cares about appearances
As someone who has been there too , John was 💯 right
ty for this
John doesn’t handle any of his children well, he’s not exactly a great dad.
I don’t see what he did wrong
They call him family but have never treated him as such. They berate, belittle, and beat him. Sabotage him any time he wants something for himself. And they're shocked when he turns away from them lol.
I hate how John and Beth treat Jamie like crap. Jamie is an adult and is free to run for office or do whatever he wants without his dad's permission.
Jamie Took Beth To Some Mexican Who Removed Her Uterus With A Knife
True, but, he's free to do that WITHOUT his dad's backing or name. That's what you miss there.
The only reason he had a chance was the support, the money, the fear that came with the Dutton name.
When I suffered through 2.5 seasons of this show I desperately wanted Beth to die in every episode.
@@mactire6045 Still hoping she dies but I think we all know it will be Jamie who bites it.
This is a family that brands their hirelings, like cattle. I'm surprised he lived to adulthood
Jamie could've been a great character, they did him wrong. Beth was a problem for everyone.
John hates Jamie in my opinion he almost always has. Not one scene of love or compassion.
I don't know, I have to heavily disagree. I think John loves all his children but his way of showing love in the beginning of the show left a lot to be desired. It also didn't help that Jaime tried to approve the selling of the land to build an airport, conspired against him to a reporter, etc. I'm glad it got better down the line
@@demonictelevision9427 Jamie approved the selling of the land because it would have made the ranch more money than the ranch has made from the beginning in a single day. With half a billion dollars you dont lose the ranch, you keep going somewhere else. When he conspired against him with the reporter it was right after john just beat the crap out of him for campaigning with johns approval. That also happened when john threatened to put Jamie's head through a wall for hitting his sister who lets not forget was beating the crap out of him until he defended himself. I know you may say Jamie deserved it, I dont think he did. Beth made choices and unfortunately her hysterectomy was the result. Lets not forget she was evil long before that happened. If Jamie is the villain for season 5 part 2, if it ever happens even though I paid for it 2 years ago, John and Beth made him that way.
19:20 were you sleeping during thus scene.
Every scene is him being hard on Jaime. No scenes of support or love
Seriously, its all obligation to him. Jamie's spent his whole life trying to make that man happy and the old jackass thought desiring a father's love was somehow selfish. Screw John Dutton
When John said it isn't his name it's mine that summed up his feelings for Jaimie whether he calls him son or not he's not blood so he'll never truly be a Dutton
What about RIP he’s not blood related yet he gets treated better
we're all going to prison
best line ever
Hi how are you doing?
Jamie would actually be a good governor doing what’s best for Montana John just didn’t want him because he thought the ranch would go away when at the time there wasn’t a way to save it
He forced Jamie into a profession he didn't respect and then proceeded to not respect him when he came back. And it wasn't even because "he wasn't a Real Man" or some cowboy bullshit like that -- he could do all the cowboy shit.
@@lizzymatheson6487 yea they stuck him in the bunk house making it seem like he didn’t know how to cowboy but then in the next season show he was raised as a Cowboy that part didn’t make sense
John and Beth treated Jaimie like a dog his whole life. John treated Rip like he should have treated Jaimie
Beth standing so smug next to John. She was never made accountable to anything and Jaimie got it for everything
Sometimes it does not matter who throws the first punch or the last punch. John only knew how to break horses and heard cattle. That mentality was applied to how he interacted with people as well. See a wolf, kill the wolf to protect the flock. A horse bucks, you break it. I do not know how he acted when his wife was in the picture, but it was clear that afterwords, he saw everyone around him as either asset or enemy. He did not allow Jamie to grow into his own man, he tried to break him to his will. Jamie could not defend himself from Beth without John and Rip bringing him to the train station, they always forgave her everything. For Jamie, the smart choice would have been to walk away like his brother. Unfortunately, he was never given the chance.
“Break him into his will”
That sums it up…
Perfectly said
I feel like jamie didn't deserve all that he did fight for the ranch but no one thought so
The target audience of this show was assumed to have an attitude that precluded the possibility of Jamie ever being seen in a good light("dayum big city lawyers!"), therefore they didn't actually need to make him do anything that was worse than anyone else.
Thank God for these recaps. Helps curb the withdrawals ❤
The real villain is John, not only did he isolate his adopted son from him but also severed any chance of him growing to love his adopted dad, and i know why, he resents jamie for his dad that killed his wife. so the issue is that john created the monster because he is stubborn and could not let go of the murder of his wife. based on jamies phycological behavior he is being pushed into a direction of hared because ive not seen any time his dad show love or effection of a hug or i love you son, they blame him almost always. he was 17 with the situation with his sister do any 17 year old's know about that stuff? no they probably dont. however upon watching this series, john is the culprit for jamies betrayal because jamie seeks his love even with the abuse or his approval. this ladies and gentleman is what happens when you treat your children this way. i honestly hope jamie wins because in the end one mans pride is a whole family's end. pisses me off!
However on other note when his biological dad showed him that love that john couldnt thats what won jamie over. in the end based on the story all jamie wants is to be loved and appreciated and acknowledged.
I don't think it's that clear but it's not really our fault for not knowing, because the series doesn't show his childhood....
i actually assumed they were a very happy family, growing up(from glimpses of stuff like family fishing or camping trips and their reminiscing)...
i also assumed that BEFORE THE WIFE DIED (this is the crucial thing, that started the problems for John Dutton), Jaime got all the love he needed (from John too)!....
@OldManPaxusYT a good assumption but we see that john is very stern and almost cold for example when Rip killed that man when he was younger and the way john handles that situation can show a very big shift in his value, not only that but sending jamie to the train station there's alot we don't really know but I can see johns not been the best father we can all agree.
❤❤ agree completely
I agree. I absolutely hate how this show is going. It’s just Jamie being shit on and blamed, all he’s wanted is the love you speak of. And we’re not seeing John be corrected
Do you guys realize that Jamie’s biological father killed his own wife, not John’s wife. The original post said something about John resenting Jamie because his dad killed his wife. After Jamie’s dad killed his own wife he went to prison and Jamie was adopted by John and Evelyn and then his new mom Evelyn died in a horse riding accident. I do agree that it seems like Jamie has been treated like shit his whole life but it’s not because John hates him for what his dad did.
More like a devolution. By season 5, the two of them had no relationship
I don’t think these two characters have had a meaningful conversation since Jamie confronted John about the adoption. That was season 3. Everything since then has been too brief or in front of other characters
John is the real antagonist of this series. Everyone says it’s Beth but really she’s just a pawn for John. Jamie didn’t deserve any of the treatment he received from the Duttons. He did everything for them just for them to hate him.
The scene when jamie is gonna commit suicide. John still has no compassion for jamie. He said no one would care for jamie even if he offed himself. What a horrible father.
And what John said wasn't true. Kayce would care.
You missed the point 😂
I always felt bad for Jamie because he was a kid himself when he had to make that dreadful decision for Beth. SHE is the one that came to him asking for help. SHE didn't want to tell her parents. SHE didn't want him to go to town because they would recognize her. So her only other option was to go to the reservation for an abortion, but order for her to get one she she had to be sterilized. He didn't ask for it- it was protocol. . If she hadn't put herself in that situation, Jamie would never have been in the position to have to make such a drastic decision. Again, he was just a kid himself! People seem to forget that, especially Beth. What Jamie did was wrong- he should've just told their father at that point. But he didn't, and Beth blames him entirely for ruining her life when in reality, she was just as responsible but conveniently forgets that.
I agree. She did go to him and ask for help. Yes what he did was wrong, but it’s obvious he feels terrible for what he did. Beth shouldn’t be blaming him for everything that goes wrong in her life.
Agree. I like other aspects of Beth but fk the way she treated Jamie.
Only person to blame for Beth getting sterilized is Beth herself
Beth was partially at fault but keep a few things in mind:
1)When she became a teen until the point that her mom died, her mom mentally and emotionally abused her. Her mom even warned her that she was going to do it. Her mom also let her think that it was Beth's fault that she died when that wasn't true at all. It all messed her up which was why she started drinking and sleeping around.
2) Rip was the dad. If John knew he had gotten Beth pregnant, off to the train station Rip would have went. Mind you, she didn't know about the train station but she did know the ranch was all Rip had. She at least had an idea of the things her dad could do to Rip.
3)Beth is someone who would die for John so she would rather not upset him if possible. But back then, he made it so she couldn't go to him about it. John admitted that part of the blame was on himself. The family name was also at risk and that was another reason why Jaime & Beth didn't go to him. They were practically the founders of the area. John understood the legacy of the family and made it a point to tell them to protect it at all costs.
4)What Beth is really upset about was the fact that she was sterilized without her knowledge. Had Jamie told her about that aspect, she may have changed her mind. The woman at the clinic begged Jamie to take Beth somewhere else and he said "No"-family name, scandel, their legacy, etc. She asked him if it was ok and he said "yes" without batting an eye. At that moment, he was thinking more about John than Beth. She took his word that everything was going to work out. If she had known and made the choice, she would have taken the blame onto herself. But Jamie made that decision for her. She wanted an abortion not sterilization, she never agreed to the second aspect of the procedure.
@@kerriethompson2073 🎯
No native abortion clinic wouldn’t have talked it over before the procedure, esp to a white woman . Also a hysterectomy which she had is major surgery to an abortion. No way she would have been able to go about as she did.
Unfortunately her father doesn’t see any of them as children needing love or help , after the loss of his wife he closes off . Instead their relationships become fractured .
John is horrible to Jamie even before the mother’s death .
He treats all his son’s as transactions to further his agenda. With Jamie as the scapegoat. Hopefully Jamie tells his ex baby momma about the train station ,before they put him in it .
Only way Beth bonds with John is by becoming invested in the farm & business. Which is the only currency she knows to get by . Beth has no friends, close friendship’s, extended family ie aunts ,uncles ,cousins .
To Learn the layers of normal relationships , instead all her relationships become transactional.
John allows her independence , he also allows her disrespect for everyone , which becomes worse as an adult . She behaves like a psychopath with a personality disorder.
Even Rip pulls her up on her behaviour, especially when Carter cones along despite the trauma his childhood had . He knows it’s not normal.
I have to wonder: Did John stop Jamie from killing himself because he genuiely cared for him or because he had more use for him? And would he have let Jamie kill himself if he knew sooner about what happened between him and Beth?
Cynically: I think John only stopped him because he thinks a son dying by suicide would reflect poorly on John as a father.
@@Caffeine-Queen John’s family is cursed , hope Jamie wakes up and unravels their evil cabal.
My hope is Kaycee family takes over brings peace & healing to the cursed land . So the tapu is lifted .
@@Caffeine-Queen a good ending would be Jamie taking John to the "train station"
John has failed as a father let’s recap all he ever has done is use His children for his own benefit and all his children are a product of his failure. Beth is a psychopath and a narcissist, and she would do anything to please him considering that he sees her as a disappointment and Lee was his personal bodyguard/murderer, and Jamie was his own personal lawyer/go to guy just in case he needs him. And the only pure child of the family is Casey but overall his legacy is nothing but a failed father
I love how Beth is acting like Killing Jaimie is something John has to do to protect the family. Trying to manipulate him into doing something she's wanted for years and that's Killing Jaimie
She's a psychopath.
Can we talk y'all? Is this a safe space? I hope so cause John treated Jamie so wrong. He never loved him in the first place. I don't think he's ever supported any of his real wishes, which was unfair. In terms of Beth, who I love so much, I can understand her fury, but she shouldn't have put it all on Jamie. They were both kids who made wrong choices. I think the only one in this family who loved Jamie was Kayce.
I agree. I also think that their late mom and late big brother Lee did to.
If you watch this compilation without seeing the rest of the show, Jamie is the protagonist and John and Beth are despicable people continually humiliating him and running his life into the ground for no reason
"Yellowstone" is marvelous! I keep watching it!"
Loved it.
Who is your favourite actor? And why
Jamie winning at the end would be an awesome twist ending
14:48 im surprised John didn't throw any punches. He held that back like a champ
Why doesn't Jaimie just leave the ranch? the guy is a good lawyer, let him just go to New York or Washington to build a political or legal career, and let him stay away from this sick family that despises him.
@@Peter-vg4sx he rejects John he loses his protection from Beth. Can you honestly look at Beth Dutton and tell me that she wouldn’t arrange for Jamie to have an “accident” if John thought Jamie wasn’t essential to the ranch. Besides regardless of John and Beth, Lee and Kayce did and do love him as a brother and the feeling was very much mutual. Jamie grew up believing his devotion and hard work would be rewarded despite all the pain he went through. He was proven wrong, he realized that unless he did something their would not be a ranch to inherit. I do not know whether his choice comes from a place of love betrayed or to protect what he loves, maybe some combination of the two, either way, he decided the only way forward was war. Knowing Beth, there was never another choice for Jamie to survive, even if he stayed loyal.
Revenge. He can't get that in New York.
Why is Beth considered some superpowerful person to kill him in NY?
@@denverbritto5606 Beth does not care what happens to herself. Or at least that is the image she projects. Whatever the truth, everyone who knows her would believe she would die with a smile on her face if it meant her target died too. Does not matter where you are if your assassin does not care if they die too.
Jamie was asked by Beth to handle a situation that no child should ever be asked to do. If Jamie told the truth to John, Rip would’ve been dead by John’s hand. Beth has held it over Jamie’s since, because she was too afraid to face the music.
Greetings from Yellowstone Fans in germany.
That’s pretty cool it has a reach all the way over there
So curious on how Jamie’s storyline plays out in the second half of Season 5. Have to wait, & see…
Well?
John could have maintained Jamie's love and loyalty if he'd shown an ounce of the care he has for Beth and Kayce.
John punching Jaime caused his long term downfall and future death change my mind.
I haven’t watched the prequel’s to Yellowstone, but it would be pretty cool to see Lee and the rest of the family who passed away along side the cast in a spinoff
13:57 i enjoy how jamie tells john whats he could lose if he doesn't take the deal and who is responsible for putting him in that position all while appearing objective
I saw Episode 1 narration without the last part. Liked it very much.
Interesting 😊
Are you a fan?
Yes, more then you think
Thank you for your kindness
The best dialogues! Bravo
If Lee was alive, he would be on Jamie’s side
ITA. Like his little brother Kayce. He's on Jamie's side and cares for him.
I doubt it Jamie is literally a traitor to his family Lee was nicer and more understanding than John but he would NEVER have been on Jamie’s side!
@@VanessaCurry711to a certain extent yes, but he is what his father made him become. When it came time to “take him to the train station” I believe Lee would have protected Jamie as his older brother.
Have you guys heard about Radiant Reservation? I’ve been seeing a lot of buzz about it lately.
Yeah, I’ve heard of it! They help you book reservations to meet celebrities, right? Sounds pretty wild, but also kind of amazing for fans who want to connect with their favorite stars.
Exactly! It’s such a game-changer. Instead of just hoping for a chance encounter, you can actually book a spot to meet celebrities like Beth, or whoever you’re into. It’s such a unique way to get that one-on-one experience with someone you admire.
I love that they’ve made it so much more accessible. I mean, before, it was almost impossible to meet someone unless you were in the right place at the right time. Now you can plan it, and it feels a lot more personal.
I totally agree. Plus, they offer a variety of options, like backstage passes, private dinners, and even one-on-one meetups. It’s perfect for superfans who want that special moment with their idols.
I had the chance to book a reservation with my favorite celebrity through them, and it was such an unforgettable experience. Definitely worth it if you're a true fan!
I mean I know the Market Equities lady is playing Jamie, but she is right. John lowkey does fear Jamie, because he surpassed him. Jamie is honestly the only one of them with the skills to run the ranch successfully, but it involves change and John can’t stand that. Jamie had proven to be better than John at a number of things.
Interesting and nice work of art 🎉😊
Jamie's bio dad was right. John may have raised Jamie, but he didn't love him.
Beth at the end going into little girl mode in order to manipulate her father. She's a true psychopath.
19:50 that’s Weller bourbon hun 😂
Jamie was easily influenced by the idea of self-preservation. As soon as he found out he was adopted after everything he did to reconnect with himself, he went back down the wrong path. He convinced himself that he was no longer John's son and that was just not true. Watch John's interaction with Jamie's birth father, and tell me he didn't love Jamie.
Hello
John was nasty to him. Rather you love someone or not. If you fail to show them, they'll never know. Love is an action word. John even admitted he refused to show Jamie love.
@@laniquegolphin5004 Jamie was no better. He was almost always out for himself. He even tried to get John to sell land even when he said no twice.
@@laniquegolphin5004 Jamie is all about protecting himself. He was all ready to grovel and get back in John's good graces until he realized that he was cut out of the trust fund and even John said the only reason he did what he did was because he stood to inherit part of the ranch. Sooooo do with that what you will. Jamie is just as wrong.
@@laniquegolphin5004 He admitted to Beth that AFTER what happened. Jamie went against him TWICE. Tried to destroy him more than once. Yes, I would feel some pain for that too.
Should of included that scene where Beth asked John to tell her that he honestly loved Jamie as much as her and Kayce, and John said nothing.
Should HAVE.
John isn't a feelsy person. I don't think he doesn't love Jamie. I think he's not affectionate and tender with his children.
John got that old man dad strength 60+ years old and still whoops his sons ass I love it 😂
Jamie is not Johns son; John tolerated him for his wives sake. He never saw him as a son.
Which makes it strange that John insisted that he would still call him son after Jamie discovered that he was adopted.
@@mysticalmargaret6105textbook manipulation
I cannot get enough of this show, this work of art. I understand how some will find that statement offensive, perhaps as offensive as much of the storyline and violence portrayed. My reality remains... Yellowstone, the trilogy, is the closest thing to depicting the realities of my childhood. Yes, the amount of violence is unsettling; however, for those raised under similar conditions in parts of the World such as Montana, Wyoming, North Dakota, and others, it's relatable. "Like or accept" it or not, much of the Pioneer Family Histories are much more similar to the Duttons' than today's "Soy-Boys" and the liberal beta males sculpted by a Nation that turned "Masculinity" into a slur, and replacing it with the label of "Toxic Masculinity."
Taylor Sheridan and John Linson really created a masterpiece with this series, and I, for one, hope they will continue bringing us raw perspectives on how the West was Won. In a word, BRAVO!!!
Hello
@@KonaMan62 the Dutton Crime Family is due a visit from the FBI.
Jamie is the only one with any integrity left.
❤ what is your favourite actor
@@Ca-SandraMorris-That's difficult to answer. However, most days, I'd like to embody the qualities and demeanor of John Dutton. On others, I'd enjoy tapping into my "Inner Beth Dutton" and all of her "Specia Qualities."
Ofc someone had to bring politics in it unprompted. Masculinity isn’t toxic, the way you treat people who don’t ascribe to your particular idea of it is nothing more or less.
One thing that always stood out to me is Jamie's name. If John really didnt see Jamie as his son why not let him keep his original name Michael? If he really didnt see him as his blood, why give him the name of the man who founded Yellowstone in the first place?
As someone who grew up with a separate father the way they treat Jaime, is the way my family treated me, it go so bad I hit my "dad" with a shovel, it was justified and even the cop said, how did you piss off a 15 year old so much that he hit you with a shovel? 😂
John hates jamie for being a dark reflection of himself
Wes Bentley ❤❤❤
He has done a great job here. I liked him before Yellowstone and I love him now.
Great Serie
"My wifes heart must break when she looks down and see what i mess iv made of this family"
J'ai fini de regarder les 5 saisons et je suis furieuse !! Mais comment se finie cette serie ?
Hello
I don't think I disagreed with anything Jamie said
Say what you want about him but John really did treat him like total crap. He never "loved" him. All he did was use him. Dont get me started with Beth. I realize Jamie made a big mistake, but that was years ago. You can't treat him like crap every time you see him.
I have a feeling that Beth is going to do something to Jamie’s son. I feel like the only Dutton member that loves him and respects him is Kayce.
Everyone who is saying how awful John is to Jamie he did apply to law school for him bc he knew he wouldn’t leave the ranch I know he wanted a lawyer fir the family but he had plenty of money to just hire one
4:07 Even Rip new John went too far with Jamie.
John Dutton is such a shit father.
He is an excellent villain protagonist and character but is a dreadful human being. John Dutton is a feudal landlord who's pretense to be a decent person. But will crush anyone who does not bow down to him. He's closer to Walter White of Breaking Bad defending his Empire. Than any John Wayne-type character
I think that's false. On _all_ counts! 😮
He isn't a feudal landlord. He isn't just _pretending_ to be a decent person. He wasn't crushing ppl who do not 'bow' down to him.
_Everything_ you said was wrong. Did you even watch all of it?
Assuming you did - Just a few 'in a nutshell' points:
(1) Learn what a feudal landlord really is.
(2) 'Decent Person' as a pretense only? He _was_ always a decent man! The only 'kinks' in his armour started when his wife died and even then, he was always as decent as he _could_ be to the best of his abilities. He's human, like all of us. To say anything else is holding him to unrealistic standards. He, always, tried to do the right thing. That's the whole thing that makes this show great! (Showing how it's impossible to be perfect. Showing how GOOD PPL do bad things and bad ppl do good things. What happens when GOOD ppl are faced with IMPOSSIBLE challenges).
OK, i'm rambling but that he was not 'decent' is ludicrous. He's as 'stand up' a guy, as could be!
(3) Crushing ppl who don't bow down to him?.... Again, patently false. Crushing 'enemies' (i.e those who attack you 1st), is not attacking ppl for now 'bowing down' to you!....
He was ruthless in self-defense, which is often the right choice, or rather, the rather, the 'practical' choice. Even then, he tried, many times, *_not_* to crush, more than once, before he _would_ crush - especially when ppl deserved a 2nd (or even 3rd) chance.
You are making these quick judgements, without much explanation....
I think the whole point, was to explore what happens to humans who _are_ 'decent', 'good fathers', 'land owners/employers' etc when faced with impossible situations!
@@OldManPaxusYT I like John but he's a horrible father he does not give unconditional love to any of his children. He only sees his children as tools and what they can do for him and then gives them his love. He is a very rich man who murders literally anyone who steps on his property and then Brands those reviews are loyal. You brand what you own. He is not a simple man defending his land is a wealthy man defending his Empire. He's closer to Walter White of Breaking Bad defending his Empire. Than any John Wayne-type character. Are they are worst people in the show, absolutely. He cultivates Rick into a hardened attack dog to kill his enemies. He is one of the richest landowners in the entire state fiction. He runs for governor to maintain his own personal power. Not to benefit his fellow citizens but to benefit themselves he's as greedy as any politician infection similar to House of Cards.
@Cowboy-crown 100%, I love the character and I love show
I stopped watching this trainwreck of a show awhile back, but my take is that Jamie should have cut all ties and walked as soon as he found out he wasn't blood related to the Duttons.
That was his cue to leave Montana for good and start his own law practice somewhere far, far away from the toxic environment he was raised in.
The only explanation is that the constant abuse and humiliation he suffers at the hands of this despicable hillbilly crime family has afflicted him with some kind of stockholm syndrome where he seeks acceptance and approval from his captors.
Sadly, I predict that will be his undoing.
It’s crazy he treats him like shit and expected loyalty😅
Thank god the comment section is like that. I love the show, with immaculate writing and acting, but thank god so many people understand that John Dutton is the villain here. The more I watched the show, the less I could root for any of the characters but fucking hell, I wished Jamie could have gotten out of there. None of them is a good person but it's all justified with it 'being for the family'. Beth proposing to kill Jamie because his now 'an enemy of the family' destroys every logic behind that.... It's just for the approval of one person, John Dutton. They don't even value the literal members of their family but justify every heinous act as doing it for the family. What Jamie did to Beth was also horrible but saying they should kill him now over this all this political and financial drama is so freaking low...That was honestly the last straw for me.
Jamie is no saint, but he is who is father shaped him to be. I wish John had just let Jamie be a wrangler. He seemed so much happier.
"WE ARE ALL GOING TO PRISON"🤣🤣🤣
W comments for empathizing with Jamie btw
Here, I don't like his reaction, but of course, father knows how to handle it.
Off course Father knows how to handle it
You're going to get strong and be a man and do what a man does. Which is sacrifice any and all ambition and do what you father tells you to do every time.
I like jamie and felt sorry for all his bad choices. Its not fair that he end as the bad guy.
john is the bad guy not jamie or beth
I’ve only seen clips of this show, and as much as I love Beth I feel that the family used Jamie as their scapegoat.
...yes, you're right, that it's not 'fair'...
I hope you mean that as praise for "Yellowstone" the series though! 😉
Your point about it being 'not fair', *is **_exactly_** what makes this show good!*
It's realistic. That, kind of thing, is _exactly_ what happens in life, *_all the time._*
No, it’s not fair. As I see it, Jamie is the best equipped to keep the ranch in the family, but John won’t consider any ideas apart from his own.
Beth is the worst, literally such a horrible person.
She would do anything for her family you must not follow the storyline she's true to her family
@@denniswyatt6418 Lmao, you sure we watched the same show?
She was an asshole to everyone including Rip, like kissing other men in front of him while she was young fully knowing he loves her.
That's just the tip of the iceberg.
@@denniswyatt6418 of course when raised by a toxic narcissist its no surprise he turned out a narcissist psychopath like Beth character. Kaycee is nothing like either , older brother we only got a glimpse of his character.
Jamie is product of being raised in such toxic masculinity & narcissistic abuse . In real life Jamie of this world would be addicted to drugs & alcohol to get through .
@@mohammadalloush8636yep, the character is horrible.
Yup and yet some woman want to be like her in real life 😂
The more I see the more I dislike John. He is such a hypocrite
He would bury everything just to keep that Ranch. He murdered and has others murder. He lies manipulates and pits his children against each other
I agree with you 👍 Mohamed
What would you say the MAIN problem with their relationship is?
Jamie being adopted. I think John subconsciously treated him differently and Jamie felt it.
Lynelle should have told Jamie, that she was endorsing John and not Jamie; so sad to see how hurtful that was. Jamie, wants to do the best for the Ranch, John and Beth don't see that. Pretty sad considering all Jamie has done for John. I hope with John out of the picture now, that some miracle helps Jamie rise above and save the Ranch, even if it's for the First Nations.
People who think John was in the wrong have no idea what it’s like to someone, a friend, or even a family member to suicide.
Sometimes committing suicide can be understood in a state of desperation. Will one then receive help, that question is asked in an unrealistic manner,it helps for once. it could still turn out differently.
Actually the devolution of John and Jamie.
"You don't get to tell me what to do anymore"
"Then get the f*ck out of my house!"
Outstanding acting in that scene 👏
its cringe asl
@@Leeterthanthouthen why u watching
@@Leeterthanthouyes your comment is
I'll always be on team Jamie. They never loved him, and they used him numerous times while he bailed them out of so many situations. Wish he stayed with Randal and his son.
Jamie was at his best living the cowboy life in season 2 and when he's defending the family, love seeing those times during the marathons, hate that he turned on them again!
Hard not to turn against a family that treats you like shit
They left him no reason to stay in their corner. There needs to be some incentive to cooperate and all he got was more threats and abuse.
Jaime's comeback will be deadly
Jamie Dutton was right From Bethany Dutton she's not the only one who protecting her father's legacy and his ranch and his family she's just protecting herself and that's it Jamie was right a course
I was right a course that Bethany won't protecting her father's ranch and his legacy she'll never look after anything
Interesting
I just don’t understand these comments.
Jamie has great qualities.. intelligent and skillful. But his Dad is right. He has no heart. Everything he does is for himself.
He could’ve so dang good for their family. He could’ve saved them so many times and did it at times. With a man of his skill, the Dutton family could be so protected. But he always wants to sell or lease portions of his family’s land for money. I get that it might be the smart move temporarily, but it’s clear to everyone except him that once you give a piece, they’ll want it all. And he just wants his own success and is willing to jeopardize their given rights to do so.
I don’t respect Jamie as a man at all. I respect his capability, but no heart at all.
He should’ve worked on himself and became stronger and learned from his Dad. It would’ve paid off dividends.
Everything JOHN does is for himself. Sending Jamie to law school because HE needed a lawyer. Holding Evelyn's death over Beth's head to keep her beholden to HIM. Waging HIS war that killed Lee. And if HE had his way, and Kayce had Beth's parental instincts, there wouldn't even be a Tate.
Jamie was loyal to John for decades, but got beat and kicked out for not answering his phone. Jamie had enough heart to become the best lawyer he could for his "father", but it went unrecognized and unappreciated.
7:30 does anyone get emotional during this scene
Only the ones who have been there brother
Not his place to decide what he's earned. What a crock of shit, John.
John's biggest mistake was taking that riffle away from Jamie. The attack might not have happened, the impeachment and everything else Jamie's weakness brought to their home.
If you need Yellowstone membership card comments
If I were Jamie- I’d pack my bags and leave everything behind to disappear and start a new life elsewhere. All of this family drama is exhausting. After all- he isn’t their real kid.
Jaime was always rejected by the Duttons and that led him to do things wrong
I think Kaycee and Jamie have gotten the raw end of the stick for the sole fact that they wanted to what was best for themselves and they were at lifes best when they werent at the ranch. But then the cancerous tentacle's of the ranch pull them back in and enslave everyone just because an overzealous man doesnt want to lose his ranch and the skeletons come out of the closet.
Ohhh i hate John as a father toward Jamie. Nobody supported and take his side - his family treated him the worst
Oh you b_______!
Ending, even a compilation, on a cliff-hanger?!!! Come on!
What kind of rifle is that? A marlin?
At this point why bother? Yellowstone, 1883, 1923 WERE great. But you lost my attention. I assume we'll watch at some point. But really, who cares.