There’s a recording of soldiers from different confederate battalions doing their battalions version of the rebel yell and goodnights version was very similar to one done by a confederate veteran from North Carolina which makes me wonder if they used the same recording I listened to as a reference for it
@@user-Bass_and_bucks42 1:02 It's rare for the Rebel Yell to appear in cinema in any capacity and it's nice of this film to make use of a historical fact of the time.
Fun fact: the Gatling Gun was invented by Dr. Richard Jordan Gatling during the Civil War, who believed if he could invent a weapon that could replace the firepower of an entire battalion, less men would be drafted into war.
i am a lawyer (a young one and a public defender) and i intend to push for legislation someday, locally and hopefully through the international community, that instead of drafting people for war, let countries fight through FPS games instead in winning wars and focus on rebuilding humanity thru such effort and focus on defenses instead of offending and destroying one another. let fictional lives be lost for purpose of preserving actual ones.
This scene is like that Story Mission on RDROnline "Bring a Goddamn Posse" where you have to defend Valentine with Horley then that War Wagon rolls up towards the end in which you gotta dynamite.
Dan Rob and at a lot closer range, that gun was at least a mile away. They would want to have been close enough for the gattling gun operator to be within range of the rifle men.
cattlewrangler walsh Nope. Gatling Guns were considered part of the artillery and were deployed and used alongside them in batteries of five or more. Something has gone terribly wrong if infantry close to within rifle distance of your Gatling battery.
One person turned the crank and the other person fed fresh magazines into the gun. They could change magazines while still firing and never miss a beat because you had to load up all barrels before it would fire. So take out a mag and the gun is still loaded. This is because there are 6 to 12 barrels, or guns theirself. Back then with blackpowder the gun was accurate for about 250 to 300 yards before bullet drop was huge. This was before they came out with the .30 caliber version. which were accurate at 1000 yards. This one was probably 45 or 50 caliber, early ones were 56 caliber.
Gatling gun magazines could have between 240 to 400 rounds depending on the mag size, and the caliber of the ammunition that the barrels were chambered in.
What gets me is the fact that it’s kinda accurate. People who could afford to did wear black and gray three piece suits. From Texas to California; The mad lads. Colors you’d think would be more comfortable like tan, white, taupe, light blue, hell even navy, were rarer. Thankfully they did usually take them off when “on the trail” as it were.
Imagine seeing the gatling gun for the first time on the battlefield and knowing there is nothing you can do to stop it. Much like the first soldiers who saw the first German gas attack
Like a .50 cal sniper rifle, the real influence of a Gatling gun (esp. on former Civil War vets) is pyschological on those caught downrange. Goodnight calls it "the devil's breath" both for its speed and its capacity to keep firing without burning out a barrel and losing accuracy. Relative to the other weapons, it feels as if its assault won't end.
I think a lot of problems with this scene could have been fixed in a way that also made the villain much more frightening: instead of one gatling gun just sitting on a flat wagon, give us a few of them. Give us enough of them that the rate of fire and the number of bullets is, if not accurate, than at least believable. IF the max number was six, I think that could be enough. Maybe also throw in some armor plates, too. Just a couple armor panels stuck on either side of each gun to excuse why it's hard to just shoot the guys operating the gun. And, speaking of the ones manning the gun, I think it would be interesting to give them a mix of Union _and_Confederate uniforms. It would give not only help explain why the villain's goons had access to such heavy military hardware, but it would also drive home how mercenary they are. They were on opposite sides of a brutal, bloody war...but after it was done, they were the kind of people that wouldn't care about fighting alongside people that were literally wearing the same uniforms as their enemies, so long as they could keep fighting.
Gatling guns weren't exclusively military hardware. You can *build* one at home easier than an actual rifle. Also, One Gatling Gun with continuous reloads could easily suppress the entire town, they had a long effective range, and nobody would even dare take a shot at them when they were stuck in a sardine can like that.
@@lego007guym8 Oh, so if you had a modern hardware store filled with prefab materials and tools, all of them built to modern specifications and with modern amenities in mind, it wouldn't be that difficult to self-construct a Gatling gun on your own.......if you were suddenly in the old west with none of those things? Okay.
"The weapon of continuous attack is a weapon of a coward, not relying on skill or talent, but instead on the endless fear and pain it produces. It is the weapon of a tyrant and will never be respected in the same glory as those who must rely on the power they must harness to use a weapon of skill." Read those words tyrants XD
When it comes to honor, well said, though of course when it comes to survival, different story. As long as you haven't done wrong yourself and it's not at the expense of others who haven't, if it's you or them, you do what you have to. But if not, you'd better check yourself or you could become the enemy.
You know what is more coward than using weapons of continuous attack?, WMD The way of war always change from time to time, unable to catch up then you'd be put in same faith as the satsuma rebellion.
It's interesting seeing how people who used guns much less than their ancestors criticize the way guns are used in a movie just because they happened to learn this stuff and have the technology now to analyze every movie to death.
Don't get me wrong I love this movie, but anyone else wonder why midnight didn't stay outside of town and use his sharpshooter skills to take out guys around the Gatling gun before goin in?
Denzel star power is so big that at the moment i totally missed that this movie reunited him not only with Antoine but with Ethan too since the days of Training Day.
many of us can fire 6 shots per second from autopistols or autorifles and we can change magazines in 1 second flat. There's 50 and 100 rd mags for the AR and 30 rd mags for the Glck pistols. So the Gatling didn't amount to much, except that the average guy had a muzzleloading rifle that offered at best two shots per MINUTE.
Everyone complaining about the Gatling gun. It’s a movie it’s meant to entertain if the gun was based of realism then the fight would be lame and less dramatic.
Hearing Goodnight’s Rebel Yell gave me goosebumps, so awesome
There’s a recording of soldiers from different confederate battalions doing their battalions version of the rebel yell and goodnights version was very similar to one done by a confederate veteran from North Carolina which makes me wonder if they used the same recording I listened to as a reference for it
@@user-Bass_and_bucks42 1:02 It's rare for the Rebel Yell to appear in cinema in any capacity and it's nice of this film to make use of a historical fact of the time.
Its the west Spirit . A war Scream .
Fun fact: the Gatling Gun was invented by Dr. Richard Jordan Gatling during the Civil War, who believed if he could invent a weapon that could replace the firepower of an entire battalion, less men would be drafted into war.
Yes and weirdly enough, he was a dentist
@@FableCountry So was Doc Holliday.
i am a lawyer (a young one and a public defender) and i intend to push for legislation someday, locally and hopefully through the international community, that instead of drafting people for war, let countries fight through FPS games instead in winning wars and focus on rebuilding humanity thru such effort and focus on defenses instead of offending and destroying one another. let fictional lives be lost for purpose of preserving actual ones.
@@pepehorhae haha i as a kid...i also had the same idea....no people will be killed...but it will be entertaining...
@@mr.nothing8031 ikr??? my teachers in college mocked me for it lol. but you gotta admit that its a cool idea what we thought 💡🌹
everyone cheered in the theater when ethan hawkes character came back
Goddamn right! Chills whenever I see it.
Dat rebel yell...
Dude, he blasts a guy while jumping his horse, god damn badass.
And died
I think you meant 'Handsome Hawke'
Rain fire!
But sire, our troops!
Just do it!
Archers!
I beg pardon Sire, won't we hit our own troops ?
Yes... but they'll hit theirs as well.
Leading a full assault on Valentine in RDR2 be like.
More like rhodes
@@Dutchman-2002 the soil in Rhodes is reddish
This scene is like that Story Mission on RDROnline "Bring a Goddamn Posse" where you have to defend Valentine with Horley then that War Wagon rolls up towards the end in which you gotta dynamite.
When I was playing that mission all I could think about was this scene
Plus unlike in the movie the sheriff actually assists in the mission
The return of Ethan Hawke entering like a boss. I loved💖
"I feel thin, sort of stretched, like a single magazine spread over too much town."
- Buffalo Bilbo
UNDERAPPRECIATED!
Thanks to Hickok45 I was able to recognize just about all those guns.
You watch him too? Nice.
Same
That mans a national treasure
Im sure this pleases him greatly
@@Horologist-zu5vq sure is
You'd need 30 of those gatling guns to have that kind of effect.
Dan Rob yeah, it would also need a much larger magazine as the one it uses looks like it’s the size of 4-5 SMG clips.
Took me right out of the movie.
jackvoodoo likes movies where the girls have penises. Realism be damned.
Dan Rob and at a lot closer range, that gun was at least a mile away. They would want to have been close enough for the gattling gun operator to be within range of the rifle men.
cattlewrangler walsh
Nope. Gatling Guns were considered part of the artillery and were deployed and used alongside them in batteries of five or more. Something has gone terribly wrong if infantry close to within rifle distance of your Gatling battery.
How tall was that Gatling mag? Was it touching clouds?
Not even to mention that those guns had a range of like 40 yards.
StratoScopes you mean how long?
One person turned the crank and the other person fed fresh magazines into the gun. They could change magazines while still firing and never miss a beat because you had to load up all barrels before it would fire. So take out a mag and the gun is still loaded. This is because there are 6 to 12 barrels, or guns theirself. Back then with blackpowder the gun was accurate for about 250 to 300 yards before bullet drop was huge. This was before they came out with the .30 caliber version. which were accurate at 1000 yards. This one was probably 45 or 50 caliber, early ones were 56 caliber.
Gatling gun magazines could have between 240 to 400 rounds depending on the mag size, and the caliber of the ammunition that the barrels were chambered in.
Chris Mills All of that logic for one simple joke, thats nerd for you.
No offense
that scream gives me chills
Adara I kind of felt how he actually cared for the people
Rebel yell
I think it's a Rebel yell and according to the journals of Union soldiers said "A man has never seen real fear until he has heard the Rebel yell."
@John T I'm only saying what I have found in research.
0:15 Heh, He didn't have his Tomahawk so he took out a pistol and still made a war cry lol.
It was because he was out of arrows, lol
They are the biggest campers ever
It's a legitimate strategy!
Someone should have snuck up behind using stealth mode
A barrage of longbows would have got them too
🤣
COD players be like
Love when Hawk comes in with that war cry
This movie was so amazing, I remember seeing it. The ending was very sad 😢 but at least three of them survived.
I wish you've seen the original if you recognize the actors becoming future spaghetti western stars.
3 survived in original too
@@RicJiang Maybe I’ll watch the original someday 👍🏻
Not only three of the seven survived in the original but in the sequels as well. There were three sequels from the original movie.
Action packed, love it.
Dude goodnights rebel yell gives me chills
Man, must be awful to wear a suit in this weather
Denzel and Pratt did an interview where they talk about just burning through shirts, especially Denzel in all black, through takes.
What gets me is the fact that it’s kinda accurate. People who could afford to did wear black and gray three piece suits. From Texas to California; The mad lads.
Colors you’d think would be more comfortable like tan, white, taupe, light blue, hell even navy, were rarer. Thankfully they did usually take them off when “on the trail” as it were.
Hello there
Imagine seeing the gatling gun for the first time on the battlefield and knowing there is nothing you can do to stop it. Much like the first soldiers who saw the first German gas attack
if it werent for goodnight they be dead.
That rebel yell is such a good touch.
Like a .50 cal sniper rifle, the real influence of a Gatling gun (esp. on former Civil War vets) is pyschological on those caught downrange. Goodnight calls it "the devil's breath" both for its speed and its capacity to keep firing without burning out a barrel and losing accuracy. Relative to the other weapons, it feels as if its assault won't end.
Love the rebel yell when he rides back in
how convenient that the guy swinging the gatling gun around appeared to know exactly where to shoot when he can't even see half the town
Hax! I call hax!
He's just going left to right
the devil's breath completely missed the horses. Lucky bastards.
Goodnight’s entrance was… Magnificent
That rebel yell though
Don’t matter the reason, doesn’t matter the outcome. Ten of thousands of men screaming that yell running full bore at you would’ve been terrifying.
I think a lot of problems with this scene could have been fixed in a way that also made the villain much more frightening: instead of one gatling gun just sitting on a flat wagon, give us a few of them. Give us enough of them that the rate of fire and the number of bullets is, if not accurate, than at least believable. IF the max number was six, I think that could be enough.
Maybe also throw in some armor plates, too. Just a couple armor panels stuck on either side of each gun to excuse why it's hard to just shoot the guys operating the gun. And, speaking of the ones manning the gun, I think it would be interesting to give them a mix of Union _and_Confederate uniforms. It would give not only help explain why the villain's goons had access to such heavy military hardware, but it would also drive home how mercenary they are. They were on opposite sides of a brutal, bloody war...but after it was done, they were the kind of people that wouldn't care about fighting alongside people that were literally wearing the same uniforms as their enemies, so long as they could keep fighting.
Gatling guns weren't exclusively military hardware. You can *build* one at home easier than an actual rifle. Also, One Gatling Gun with continuous reloads could easily suppress the entire town, they had a long effective range, and nobody would even dare take a shot at them when they were stuck in a sardine can like that.
You could probably build a galling gun at Menards or Lowes.. They aren't that complicated.
Back then if you had enough money anyone could buy a Gatling gun
@@lego007guym8 Oh, so if you had a modern hardware store filled with prefab materials and tools, all of them built to modern specifications and with modern amenities in mind, it wouldn't be that difficult to self-construct a Gatling gun on your own.......if you were suddenly in the old west with none of those things?
Okay.
@@bradyteets3426 I agree.
Not gonna lie goodnights entrance was kinda badass when it shows the horse in slow motion
injun guy pulling arrow from behind then realize he run out is literally mee :3
Yo when’s the nerf to the Gatling gun coming out?
Nah, they just outdated they became irrelevant (see mg42 and mini gun)
@@zzzlulzzz5080 that wizzing noise was the joke going over your head
the angel of death is back with a message
When goodnight rides in its pure chills
"The weapon of continuous attack is a weapon of a coward, not relying on skill or talent, but instead on the endless fear and pain it produces. It is the weapon of a tyrant and will never be respected in the same glory as those who must rely on the power they must harness to use a weapon of skill."
Read those words tyrants XD
When it comes to honor, well said, though of course when it comes to survival, different story.
As long as you haven't done wrong yourself and it's not at the expense of others who haven't, if it's you or them, you do what you have to. But if not, you'd better check yourself or you could become the enemy.
tell that to heavy from tf2
You know what is more coward than using weapons of continuous attack?, WMD
The way of war always change from time to time, unable to catch up then you'd be put in same faith as the satsuma rebellion.
Not when it's on an A-10 Thunderbolt!
Brrrt brrrt brrrt!!
*Samurai during the Boshin War*
This was a great movie!
It was ok,bit simplistic
mediocre at best compared to the oringal
@@brandonk8948 nah, i'd say its almost on the same level as the original
@@prskaMy poor boy Chico got left out tho
1:03
¡¡¡YEEEEEEEEEEELL!!
¡AHORA!
Lo más épico de la película
"THEY GOT A GODAM GATLING GUN!"
Legend has it the Gatling is still foreign with that 42 mag 😂
Horner's music. No words.
I love the moment when they were all using the rifles
It's interesting seeing how people who used guns much less than their ancestors criticize the way guns are used in a movie just because they happened to learn this stuff and have the technology now to analyze every movie to death.
Horses are impervious to Gatling Gun bullets 🙂.
Magazine of eternity 🤣
Ethan Hawks is an OG Regulator 💯
Minus the magazine size that gun could definintly do that within that distance. Especially against cheap wood like these small villages would pop up.
Movies like this and RDR2 inspired me to study westerns more.
Wtf is RDR2
1:53 Me when the enemy team has a Bastion
Play of the Game!
as a bastion main........ yeah..... i kinda feel people do this when they see me behind an orisa bunker. ^_^
Even though people nowadays can’t make good western movies, I have to say this one hit the fuckn fields
Best red dead redemption 2 gameplay ever
Dude it's the trailer of RDR3 XD
@@alifaheem1917 it more like a new mission coming to rdr2 online where you need to co op with 6 more ppl to defend a town from a gang :v
1:02 that scene always gives me the chills
Should have hid behind the horses. Those animals were surviving those barrage of bullets rather well.
This clip reminds me of my neighborhood on a Monday night.
Kinda a silly move, ain't it? Killing everyone in the town you're trying to conquer: who's going to provide you with stuff if everyone's dead?
It's not the town they wanted, they wanted the land for oil or gold apparently.
They wanted the territory, not the people in it.
That first drag on a cigarette after not having one for a week lol
That’s one accurate Gatling gun.
Don't get me wrong I love this movie, but anyone else wonder why midnight didn't stay outside of town and use his sharpshooter skills to take out guys around the Gatling gun before goin in?
@Andrei Blanca wouldn’t be much of a movie then sadly.
Lol that Gatling gun wouldn’t be anywhere near that effective
Empty Wendy's Bag ikr
I mean it would if it were a little closer and had an army of loaders on standby.
3:00 when you smoke for the first time
1:03 Goooooodnight Robicheaux it back!!!! 💪💪
The AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH meme fits perfectly here
Awesome... I remember seeing the original Magnificent Seven👍🎥
Denzel star power is so big that at the moment i totally missed that this movie reunited him not only with Antoine but with Ethan too since the days of Training Day.
2:34 The bell popped his eardrums lol
Longest range I ever seen on a Gatlin Gun! And that clip musta been crammed with xtra bullets! lol. Still a cool scene though.
I get chills when goodnight screams “they got the devils grip they got a god dam Gatling gun!!”
“Devils breath” …which makes it that much better
@@TannerMizell-ib6wn your right is breath I always thought he said grip
When the whole squad is online and everyone is on one team in ranked
They started freaking out when they brought out the Gatling gun
me in red dead redemption 2 0:10
That shot for a min and a half straight with no jams? Damn!
when a 150 year old gun is more powerful than a modern gun ship ha ha
Richard Jordan Gatling: It's free real estate. My gun is being advertised in a movie!
To those who know the new western update in totally accurate battle simulator this where they got the gatling gun design :)
people talking about how this scene is inaccurate
me and my simple mind just enjoying it
I just noticed that the Gatling gun was ejecting blanks, tiny thing but it gets me. (i mean the casings on the ground around it)
They make the mid western time look cool.
0:15 when I noticed my paper is due in 10 minutes and only have a sentence down
love to see him shooting at aboslutely nothing but hits everything even inside and outside the building
やっぱりイーサン・ホークが一番かっこいい！クリスは、みんな大好き❤
*Range* : about 100 yards away from the town
*Gating Gun* : shoots like its right in front of the town
Its movie realism dont matter
Jake Hoyt and Alonzo at it again!
Ft. Det. Goren and Star-Lord!
Damn, maybe open with that one next time.
no horses were harmed during this scene
0:51 Mares leg!!! My favorite gun!!!
0:59 best part
danm you milton
Amazing all that fire power from a single magazine
I never knew Gatling guns were that effective. :o
As soon as he told them to fetch the cart I knew what would be rolling up. I have played Red Dead Redemption.
Where Hickok45 when you need him, with all that shoo sting he does he’s got the accuracy of John Wayne.
I’ve shot one of those a few times, and you can’t crank it so fast. Those gravity fed magazines are a little touchy
Imagine if they only had more than just one Gatling Gun?
Good night coming back gave me chills
Quick draw mag+ powerup in call of duty be like.
many of us can fire 6 shots per second from autopistols or autorifles and we can change magazines in 1 second flat. There's 50 and 100 rd mags for the AR and 30 rd mags for the Glck pistols. So the Gatling didn't amount to much, except that the average guy had a muzzleloading rifle that offered at best two shots per MINUTE.
0:28 hold on, did Vas call Faraday 'guerito' just then? I never caught that the first few watches XD that's cute
Everyone complaining about the Gatling gun. It’s a movie it’s meant to entertain if the gun was based of realism then the fight would be lame and less dramatic.
It is a good thing horses are immune to gatling guns!
1:03 Rebel Yell!
What a powerful gun! Awesome tech in 1800s
Yeah that caliber and distance nope 🙂↔️ but I love that they put old western movie logic in it 🤷♂️
Goodie is my favorite character in this movie