The PPS is a much smoother shooting pistol. I love the trigger and the thin grip. It feels like a much bigger gun than it really is. The Shield is a great gun, and I trust their revolvers above all others, but in this single-stack format, the Walther is just an overall better gun and a great value for $ spend. The fit and finish really show in its action and the way the slide operates. My PPS is now my EDC gun and will remain so for the foreseeable future. I was carrying a Springfield XD subcompact, and I love its 16+1 capacity, but its just too heavy for EDC. I also get much tighter groups with the Walther. Great review KSGunGuy!! Informative and entertaining.
Fantastic comparison. You have a way of knowing what we want to know and delivering that info in a straightforward and enjoyable manner. I always look forward to your videos! Thanks!
I'll admit I have a bit of bias to Smith and Wesson for a Model 19 .357 saving my life a few years ago, and I see the Shield pistols as the next Model 36. A small, concealable, simple, and affordable firearm with outstanding reliability that has sold in the millions and for good reason. As far as I'm concerned, they have a lifelong customer with me for providing outstanding products that are high quality, American made, and have saved my life before.
You really can't go wrong with either of these firearms.I owned both in the past(original versions) and they're the two best single/staggered stacks on the market imo. Now with the upgraded versions, it would be a tough choice between the two.However, if i decided to purchase one again, it would be the PPS.
I’ve owned both but now I only own the PPS M2. For me I shot the PPS constantly better all the way around, like its trigger better and it feels more like I’m shooting a gun that is larger than it is. Can’t go wrong with either gun however.
Great review KS ! It's so crazy to hear people complement Smith and Wesson guns for having good triggers. I'm glad that the 2.0 models are getting so much praise. I guess Apex won't be selling as many triggers for the 2.0 Smiths as they did for the original M&P'S.
Dave Gas66 I have 1.0 double stack....love the trigger...apex will stay in business with Ruger alone....those SUCK, my LC9 was a POS b4 I swapped it out
Kevin Howard I have a new Ruger american pistol 9mm and a ruger mark iv target stainless. I am very happy with those two guns. I'm sure you are right on your ruger comments.
Great comparison! Just picked up the PPS M2 LE yesterday. Always loved the Walther ergonomics and the way they shoot. Father in law bought the Shield, so looking forward to doing my own side by side comparison. Thanks for the video. Very informative.
Sandy Weeks I really liked both guns. The shield is a great subcompact 9mm. I do favor the Walther though. I prefer the trigger and sights on the Walther, but either gun is a solid choice. I have since started carrying the Glock 43x though. That is my favorite in the subcompact 9 class. The added capacity (15 if I can ever get my hands on the shield arms mag) and full size grip make this a better choice in my opinion. I tend to shoot it better as well. Ultimately go with whatever you feel most comfortable with.
Great job! I had a PPSM2 for several months, and then came home to a Performance Center Shield in 9mm. That said, the trigger on the 2.0 is SUPERB!! I heartily agree with your choice!
Have been shooting the PPS m2 for months and love it. It broke in beautifully and there's nothing I don't like about it. The Shield was my runner-up choice. Was at my local gun store and they had a practically new Shield in the used case for a fantastic price. Box, 3 mags, everything. Can't wait to do some side-by-side comparisons with them.
The Walther PPS M2 LE sights are amazing in extreme low light. Also pricing was $100 cheaper than the S&W Shield, at least it was when I priced them both on the day of PPS purchase. Your mileage may vary.
I agree. The PPS M2 is an excellent cc handgun at $250 (I've seen it as low as 219 before). The PPS M2 LE is worth the extra money in my opinion. I've seen those at $295-319 often. I recently bought the Shield M2.0 for my grandmother after she was robbed in her drive way (and a concealed carry permit course). She wanted to buy from an American company so we got the Shield. However, if it was up to me and both handguns were the same price, I would get the PPS M2 because of the ergonomics and tigger. While you would be happy with either handguns, the drastic price difference (less if you're getting the LE PPS) was just the icing on the cake.
Great video KS! I don't have any experience with the walther but the shield is a fantastic gun...... and I was able to mess around with the 2.0 at my LGS yesterday and loved it! The texture is awesome and the trigger is definitely improved over the 1.0's!
Thanks Nolan! Both are great for sure but the Shield has really impressed me. That trigger is tough to beat and it keeps getting better. That would be awesome if you picked one up! Cheers brother
One small thing to consider about the PPS is the physical striker indicator. If you've ever trained with a double-action, hammer-fired pistol before, it's fairly common safety practice to reholster with your thumb over the hammer. If for whatever reason the trigger begins to creep back while reholstering like this, you get immediate tactile feedback that something is wrong, giving you that extra split second to pause and clear any obstructions before an accidental discharge. Though not as large as a hammer, the striker indicator can perform the same safety function. Just something to consider, especially with those wanting to appendix carry. This, and similar grip feel to my existing PPQ, are the reasons I went the PPS route.
I've had both the M1&M2 PPS, and I owned the original 9mm Shield the first week they came out. I think you did an awesome job with this review, as usual. If I hadn't just gotten the two M&P 2.0's I would probably have gone with the PPS. However, after shooting both of mine, and the fact that I no longer own my PPS M2 I think I would also choose the Shield 2.0. If it's anything like it's bigger siblings, I know it must be fantastic. Have a great weekend my friend.
Thank you Fu! Your 2.0 collection is awesome! I think the Shield 2.0 is a great addition to the lineup. The trigger is outstanding and well worth checking out! Thank you as always and cheers brother
I really love how you don't say "this is a clear handgun" you just remove the empty mag and show the empty chamber right in the middle of the frame, thank you, subbed.
I admit, in older vids I do it too though I try not to, lol. Some people jump all over you if you don't. Not sure why they are worried as I can't hurt anyone through a camera! Thank you and welcome to the channel. Cheers!
@@KSGunGuy01personally I think it's mental illness. You watch these videos for the information you are looking for and anyone who needs to be shown or told that they are clear should probably get on a mental health medication.
The 2.0 Shield has a better grip, crowned barrel, better trigger w/a Great Wall before the trigger break-same as the former performance shield version, has a 7+1 and 8+1 capacity with standard magazines and is just overall a better version than the first generation Shield that is already a very proven platform. It is the best hands down. If tritium night sights and a Hogue Handall beavertail grip were added as well, it would be the ultimate 9mm single stack by a large margin over Glock, Sig, Walther and Kahr. I can say this definitively, because I did just this to my 2.0 Shield 9mm, and I own Glocks and a Kahr PM9 and other than my Performance Center Shield in 45 acp, this is by far my favorite carry pistol. Good video my friend!!
Great comparison but I'm a Walther fan, so I would have gone the other way. You do provide a fair and equal comparison on both guns. Thanks for taking the time to do so...
i like how you take a position with your reasoning and opinion. other reviewers often time wimp out and do not tell you what they would choose for whatever reason. good job.
Nice battle of a couple of very good pistols...Always good and detailed info sir....Love to own either...Wow, did not see that choice coming....Good stuff...
great review brother thank you again . both really good handguns I do own the shield my self with a few upgrades of course , but I am really interested in getting a pps. and like always thanks for a great review and all the useful info .
My first handgun purchase was a S&W SD9VE. I'm very pleased with it's performance for intended use of home defense and plinking. I then wanted a great range gun + uspsa competition, so I purchased a CZ custom Shadow 2, which I really enjoy shooting. I'm looking for a ccw with my next firearm purchase and considering both the Walther PPS and M&P shield. Thank you for the comparison. Looks like I can't go wrong with either, so I think I may just have to try both in my hands at the local range.
As a lefty I learned how to release the magazine with my middle finger when I was five years old on toy cap guns. If the release was ambidextrous i wouldn't even change it. the slide stop on the other hand I would use.
Great review as always...I would agree with you, I would choose the Shield 2.0 over the PPS, but only if I didn't already have the original Shield. The 2.0 trigger might be a tiny bit smoother, but nothing great...and, just not enough other upgrades. I think the trigger on the PPS is nice, but it feels a bit "toyish" to me. So, if you don't have a either now, then I would definitely go with the new Shield 2.0 over the PPS. But, it still needs the Apex trigger.
Excellent points Mean! I agree, the changes in the 2.0 are minor but so far, I have been really impressed. I like the analogy of the toy feeling trigger in the PPS. Hand’t thought of it that way but I think you’re on to something. I agree, an Apex would still be awesome. Thank you and cheers!
Great review and comparison! I have the original shield and liked it so much that I treated myself to a PC shield with tritium night sights..Its heartening to see an American manufacturer make a world class gun! I'm sure the wealthier is also world class, but S&W has a rep for taking care of owners.
Thank you very much Bill! I agree, the Smiths are great guns and the new 2.0 series has really impressed me. As for the Walther, it's no slouch either. Thank you and cheers!
The problem I have with the shield, is I'm is quick to rust. Now if you use the shield as a everyday carry this is a problem for me. Looking forward to getting the walther.
I owned the first model PPS in 40CAL. I loved everything about the gun. I just wished the smaller clip had the same ergonomic bottom as the 7 round clip. It was a great carry gun. After a couple of surgeries I will buy another PPS but in 9MM. I do this because of two rotator cuff surgeries on my right shoulder and 1 on my left one.
Nice review. I actually own both, the M&P 2.0 with the laser. I researched the PPS M2 before getting it but for some reason I cannot shoot it well. I thought my sights were off but range guy confirmed it was ok. I rented a first gen Shield that same day and was shooting bulls! Go figure. Hence, leading me to getting the new Shield. I just shoot it better.
Some pistols will just surprise you. I was surprised to consistently be hitting old empty propane tanks at 20 yards and a little further with no problem and I thought I would be able to hit jack with it like I do with snub nose revolvers.
I own both and have shot both a number of times and I find the PPS to be more accurate for me and the build feels more solid. The mag seems to fit better too. Don't get me wrong, I love both of them and enjoy shooting either one but for my daily CCW I grab the PPS. On top of everything else, the Shield has that grip which is nice when firing but the texture rubs against the skin if you have it touching. I use a waste strap and when I carry the Shield it rubs rough whereas the PPS doesn't irritate, but once again that depends on who is carrying it and where and how they are carrying it. In all honesty I would trust either one in a self defense situation. I picked the PPS up for about half the price of the Shield on sale too which makes it even more appealing. EDIT: I forgot to add that my Shield has the Crimson Trace laser and manual safety as well. It still has the articulating trigger.
Thanks Funky! I agree, both are probably my two favorite single stacks. That Compact is really sweet thought. It’s really impressed me. Thank you and cheer brother!
Needs more Ammo, I like the Double Stack 9MM PPQ M2 and a spare 17 round Mag. Great review on 2 similar pistols really depends on which one you personally shoot the best.
Well said Gary! I agree, capacity is great though it’s nice to have options when larger guns aren’t a good fit for the occasion. Thank you very much and cheers!
I don't think you understand the purpose of these guns. If you need to carry 17 rounds then you'll carry a full size handgun. If you want something you can carry in your pocket you have to sacrifice capacity. It's pretty simple actually
Great video. I personally would have gone with the Walther simply because the front serrations are way more functional. As well, I would forgo the Shield altogether and just get an m&p 2.0 Compact.
Great point Pipe! There's no doubt, the PPS is a great option and one of my favs. I agree, the 2.0C is awesome and one of my top picks for the year. Thank you and cheers!
Great review, I looked at both and fired both. The PPS M2 was more accurate with less recoil. Also, the gun feels and look better IMO. Sooo, I purchased the PPS :)
I have a Glock 17 and a Px4 storm I’m looking for a small firearm my first choice was going to be the sig 365 but I see they have a lot off issues so after watching your videos I’ might get the Walter PPS M2 or the Glock 43
I have a Shield 2.0 40 caliber. It is phenomenal on the way the trigger breaks. It is my first 40 and I was apprehensive. But, just go slow with a firm grip and feel the break...bullseye! High Quality firearm. I want the 9mm for the extra capacity as well, plus I have the holster for it. Great review.
In my opinion I like the shield alot better, especially the performance center version. The Walther was my first single stack 9mm for carry, and I enjoyed it, but had trouble practicing with it. I never felt consistent with my draws and grouping. I sold it for a Performance Center Shield for a killer deal which feels less snappy and easier to grip to me. Just my opinion but I think they are both great choices.
On par with previous comments, g43, PPS M2 or shield is a great choice. I carry the PPS M2 because of the trigger, grip and *more importantly* how I shoot with it. I’ve shot all the other variants and honestly get consistently better groups with the PPS M2. Your experience may differ, but I’m Walther all the way now when it comes to single stack 9mm.
Started with a G43 because I'm very petite and short and it is easy to hide, but I stunk at shooting it. Tested a Shield at my range and loved it, shot it so well, and could keep shooting it. Bought a Shield 9 2.0 and gave my 43 to my husband 😁.
Looking at these two guns to carry. I have a Walther PPQ and am very happy with it. At the end of the day probably cannot go wrong with either one of them.
Just bought the S&W shield 2.0 It's the best carry semi I have ever felt out of the box. I would recommend it to anyone. Just be aware that it's tight, meaning it like any new gun needs a break in to allow easer racking and command of the levers...This is a quality gun....!
Again...Great job on the comparison video. I admire your profsionally produced videos. How long have you been creating videos if I may ask? I pick Shield...as it is the only one I am familiar with.
Well done review. I love my shield (gen 1). I think you hit it on that they are on par with each other. I ended up putting on talon sandpaper grips on the Shield, so I'm appreciating the changes for the 2.0. I agree these are comparable; buy the one on sale, with more mags, or other incentive.
Thank you very much Neil! They really are both great shooters and at the top of my list for single stacks. The 2.0 is really fantastic. I agree about buying on sale! Cheers brother
Great presentation. Its took guts for u to do it. I have both guns and the Walther to me is a better gun. I choose the Walther because I have owned a .380 PPK for 30yrs, have no issues and would never sell it. u, on the other hand, may have a preference because u carried a Shield .45, more familiar with it and Shield also looks better than the Walther. Nevertheless, the trigger is better on the Walther (opinion) and I like the trigger travel indicator on the rear because an experienced shooter can now Gage single action shooting. There is also 3 magazines. Good job.
Thank you Sam! Both are definitely great shooters. It’s one of the tougher I’ve done in the series and would really be happy with either. Thank you for watching and cheers!
Never owned or shot a Walther PPS. Looks like a great edc carry option. But I trust my life and that of my family to a Shield 9 every day...All it does is dissapear on your body, shoots anything you load it with... every single time, and hits everything you point it at...without fail, without breakage (I've dropped it so many times). And they are dirt cheap!...So perhaps not 007's 1st choice..but then again...The Shield is a 100 percent American made little can of whoop ass...
Well said Glockster! The Walther is a great gun and won’t be leaving the collection any time soon. I agree that we are living in good times with the choices we have! Cheers brother
Nice video and well produced. My only critique would be that you not mention all of your previous experience with S&W M&P guns. I strongly suspected right from the start that you would pick the S&W because of those comments. If you had left out the comments about your experience with S&W, your choice would have been completely uncolored and (seemingly) more objective, but I must say that you did give each gun a very nice analysis and clearly mentioned that the final choice was your opinion only. Keep the videos coming, since you’re doing a great job and of course take my comments with a grain of salt because they are just my opinion as well.
I have both LE version and the shield 2.0 with the crimson trace. They both fire very well. I've put over 1000 rounds through each, and they hold up well. Both are easy to maintain, but I've turned the PPS into my EDC. It feels better to carry and Alien Gear makes the shape shift for it so I barely feel it there. I have not yet found a holster that feels comfortable for the shield. I'm not a fan of kydex. Both are amazing CCW options though.
All else being equal, seems like an extra round and slightly less weight would put the Shield ahead. I have the original, but I also have a PPQ and man is that a fantastic gun. If they could drop that trigger into the PPS there'd be no competition.
Can u do a video like this with the Taurus millennium g2 9mm and the scy spx 2 to of the best budget 9mm guns and it would be awsome cuz a lot of people want to pick a good gun that doesn't break the bank and still runs good. Ps the Taurus millennium g2 if think is way more reliable and runs better and feels and looks better. Just my ap. But it would be cool if u did. I think a lot of people now in days are trying to find a good low budget gun that runs like a glock or something and those to guns are like the king of the budget guns. Plzz think about it
I pocket carry my Shield and it fits perfect in my Wranglers. The little difference in the specs between the two guns. Makes a big difference for me,because of the way I carry.
I agree the Walther has awesome ergos and a great trigger! That said, the Shield 2.0 has really impressed me and the trigger is vastly improved over the previous model. Gives the Walther a run for the money. Thank you and cheers!
The PPS is a much smoother shooting pistol. I love the trigger and the thin grip. It feels like a much bigger gun than it really is. The Shield is a great gun, and I trust their revolvers above all others, but in this single-stack format, the Walther is just an overall better gun and a great value for $ spend. The fit and finish really show in its action and the way the slide operates. My PPS is now my EDC gun and will remain so for the foreseeable future. I was carrying a Springfield XD subcompact, and I love its 16+1 capacity, but its just too heavy for EDC. I also get much tighter groups with the Walther.
Great review KSGunGuy!! Informative and entertaining.
Out of curiosity, what makes you like S&W revolvers over Ruger?
Fantastic comparison. You have a way of knowing what we want to know and delivering that info in a straightforward and enjoyable manner. I always look forward to your videos! Thanks!
Thank you very much Nerdy! That means a lot brother. They are fun to do! Cheers
“No rail for lights, lasers, grenade launchers.” Lol.
Thanks!
I'll admit I have a bit of bias to Smith and Wesson for a Model 19 .357 saving my life a few years ago, and I see the Shield pistols as the next Model 36. A small, concealable, simple, and affordable firearm with outstanding reliability that has sold in the millions and for good reason. As far as I'm concerned, they have a lifelong customer with me for providing outstanding products that are high quality, American made, and have saved my life before.
You really can't go wrong with either of these firearms.I owned both in the past(original versions) and they're the two best single/staggered stacks on the market imo. Now with the upgraded versions, it would be a tough choice between the two.However, if i decided to purchase one again, it would be the PPS.
Well said CWB! I agree that they are probably two of the best single stacks out there. You can’t go wrong with either. Thank you and cheers brother!
I’ve owned both but now I only own the PPS M2. For me I shot the PPS constantly better all the way around, like its trigger better and it feels more like I’m shooting a gun that is larger than it is. Can’t go wrong with either gun however.
Great points and the PPS is a fantastic gun! The ergos alone are second to none for many shooters. Thank you and cheers!
NIce comparison video, I like the way you integrate the shooting and talking segments, blends nicely...still like my PPS M2 .....
Thank you NC! Both are great shooters for sure. I still love the PPS too! It won’t be going anywhere. Cheers brother!
Great review KS ! It's so crazy to hear people complement Smith and Wesson guns for having good triggers. I'm glad that the 2.0 models are getting so much praise. I guess Apex won't be selling as many triggers for the 2.0 Smiths as they did for the original M&P'S.
Thanks David! Don't get me wrong, an Apex would still improve the trigger, but not as much as the 1.0. Cheers brother!
Dave Gas66 I have 1.0 double stack....love the trigger...apex will stay in business with Ruger alone....those SUCK, my LC9 was a POS b4 I swapped it out
Kevin Howard I have a new Ruger american pistol 9mm and a ruger mark iv target stainless. I am very happy with those two guns. I'm sure you are right on your ruger comments.
Walther PPS M2 all day, every day.
Except on those days that the Shield is better....which is like...everyday.
@@southsidejohnny3712 defintely not...
lol I have the PPS M2 and the M&P EZ, I love them both
Great comparison! Just picked up the PPS M2 LE yesterday. Always loved the Walther ergonomics and the way they shoot. Father in law bought the Shield, so looking forward to doing my own side by side comparison. Thanks for the video. Very informative.
Thank you very much! Both are definitely great guns. Keep me posted on what you think when you compare them! Cheers!
How did your comparison work out with your father-in-law?
Sandy Weeks I really liked both guns. The shield is a great subcompact 9mm. I do favor the Walther though. I prefer the trigger and sights on the Walther, but either gun is a solid choice. I have since started carrying the Glock 43x though. That is my favorite in the subcompact 9 class. The added capacity (15 if I can ever get my hands on the shield arms mag) and full size grip make this a better choice in my opinion. I tend to shoot it better as well. Ultimately go with whatever you feel most comfortable with.
Great job! I had a PPSM2 for several months, and then came home to a Performance Center Shield in 9mm. That said, the trigger on the 2.0 is SUPERB!! I heartily agree with your choice!
Thank you very much Henry! That PC version is awesome for sure. Cheers brother!
Have been shooting the PPS m2 for months and love it. It broke in beautifully and there's nothing I don't like about it. The Shield was my runner-up choice. Was at my local gun store and they had a practically new Shield in the used case for a fantastic price. Box, 3 mags, everything. Can't wait to do some side-by-side comparisons with them.
The Walther PPS M2 LE sights are amazing in extreme low light. Also pricing was $100 cheaper than the S&W Shield, at least it was when I priced them both on the day of PPS purchase. Your mileage may vary.
Both are great guns indeed. The ergos on the PPS are hard to beat, Thank you and cheers!
I agree. The PPS M2 is an excellent cc handgun at $250 (I've seen it as low as 219 before). The PPS M2 LE is worth the extra money in my opinion. I've seen those at $295-319 often. I recently bought the Shield M2.0 for my grandmother after she was robbed in her drive way (and a concealed carry permit course). She wanted to buy from an American company so we got the Shield. However, if it was up to me and both handguns were the same price, I would get the PPS M2 because of the ergonomics and tigger. While you would be happy with either handguns, the drastic price difference (less if you're getting the LE PPS) was just the icing on the cake.
Great video KS! I don't have any experience with the walther but the shield is a fantastic gun...... and I was able to mess around with the 2.0 at my LGS yesterday and loved it! The texture is awesome and the trigger is definitely improved over the 1.0's!
Thanks Nolan! Both are great for sure but the Shield has really impressed me. That trigger is tough to beat and it keeps getting better. That would be awesome if you picked one up! Cheers brother
Nice Review, didn’t think you would pick that one. Good Stuff Brother! Carry On
Thanks brother! I was a bit surprised as well. Both are great but the Shield has really impressed me! Cheers
One small thing to consider about the PPS is the physical striker indicator. If you've ever trained with a double-action, hammer-fired pistol before, it's fairly common safety practice to reholster with your thumb over the hammer. If for whatever reason the trigger begins to creep back while reholstering like this, you get immediate tactile feedback that something is wrong, giving you that extra split second to pause and clear any obstructions before an accidental discharge. Though not as large as a hammer, the striker indicator can perform the same safety function. Just something to consider, especially with those wanting to appendix carry. This, and similar grip feel to my existing PPQ, are the reasons I went the PPS route.
I've had both the M1&M2 PPS, and I owned the original 9mm Shield the first week they came out. I think you did an awesome job with this review, as usual. If I hadn't just gotten the two M&P 2.0's I would probably have gone with the PPS. However, after shooting both of mine, and the fact that I no longer own my PPS M2 I think I would also choose the Shield 2.0. If it's anything like it's bigger siblings, I know it must be fantastic. Have a great weekend my friend.
Thank you Fu! Your 2.0 collection is awesome! I think the Shield 2.0 is a great addition to the lineup. The trigger is outstanding and well worth checking out! Thank you as always and cheers brother
I really love how you don't say "this is a clear handgun" you just remove the empty mag and show the empty chamber right in the middle of the frame, thank you, subbed.
I admit, in older vids I do it too though I try not to, lol. Some people jump all over you if you don't. Not sure why they are worried as I can't hurt anyone through a camera! Thank you and welcome to the channel. Cheers!
@@KSGunGuy01personally I think it's mental illness. You watch these videos for the information you are looking for and anyone who needs to be shown or told that they are clear should probably get on a mental health medication.
Thanks for the video man!! Looking to own both, but I think I’ll buy me the PPS first!
Right on! Thank you and cheers!
The 2.0 Shield has a better grip, crowned barrel, better trigger w/a Great Wall before the trigger break-same as the former performance shield version, has a 7+1 and 8+1 capacity with standard magazines and is just overall a better version than the first generation Shield that is already a very proven platform. It is the best hands down.
If tritium night sights and a Hogue Handall beavertail grip were added as well, it would be the ultimate 9mm single stack by a large margin over Glock, Sig, Walther and Kahr. I can say this definitively, because I did just this to my 2.0 Shield 9mm, and I own Glocks and a Kahr PM9 and other than my Performance Center Shield in 45 acp, this is by far my favorite carry pistol. Good video my friend!!
Well said about the Shield! It’s a favorite of mine for sure. I agree about the tritium sights as standard. Thank you and cheers!
Nice. I like both of those guns. Good review, as always.
Thank you very much Nalrah! Cheers!
Great comparison but I'm a Walther fan, so I would have gone the other way. You do provide a fair and equal comparison on both guns. Thanks for taking the time to do so...
Thank you very much Blake! The Walther is a great gun indeed. Cheers!
i like how you take a position with your reasoning and opinion. other reviewers often time wimp out and do not tell you what they would choose for whatever reason. good job.
Thank you very much! Cheers!
I own both and prefer the Walther if I had to choose between them for my daily carry. Both are great compacts 9s
SHIELD ALL DAY BABY
Excellent comparison my friend! Will be picking up a M&P Shield 2.0 within the next week!
Thank you Stephen! That’s awesome and congrats! Enjoy brother. Cheers!
Nice battle of a couple of very good pistols...Always good and detailed info sir....Love to own either...Wow, did not see that choice coming....Good stuff...
Thank you very much Scott! I was surprised too. Either way, both are awesome. Thank you and cheers brother!
Just got a 2.0 shield and I love it!
That’s awesome Jared! It’s a sweet shooter for sure. Thank you and cheers!
great review brother thank you again . both really good handguns I do own the shield my self with a few upgrades of course , but I am really interested in getting a pps. and like always thanks for a great review and all the useful info .
Thank you very much Sergio! I agree, they both are fantastic and you can't go wrong with either. Cheers brother!
My first handgun purchase was a S&W SD9VE. I'm very pleased with it's performance for intended use of home defense and plinking. I then wanted a great range gun + uspsa competition, so I purchased a CZ custom Shadow 2, which I really enjoy shooting. I'm looking for a ccw with my next firearm purchase and considering both the Walther PPS and M&P shield. Thank you for the comparison. Looks like I can't go wrong with either, so I think I may just have to try both in my hands at the local range.
That’s awesome Matt! I agree, you really can’t go wrong with either. Keep me posted on your choice! Thank you and cheers brother
That's funny my first gun is the sd9ve but I want a ccw as well and now I'm here. Just like you. Deciding on the same guns lol
Both guns are winners. It depends on the one you shoot better.
Well said Jeff! I 100% agree brother. Cheers!
I too would lean towards the Shield, but my problem would be considering w/ or without the safety.
It's nice to have the options for sure. Thank you and cheers!
Going to pick one up to go with/my 2.0 Compact.
The Walther PPS is a nice gun too,though.
Excellent video!
Thank you very much and well said! Cheers!
Couple of nice looking pistols!
Thank you very much Rich!
As a lefty I learned how to release the magazine with my middle finger when I was five years old on toy cap guns. If the release was ambidextrous i wouldn't even change it. the slide stop on the other hand I would use.
Love ur videos keep it up man ✌
Thank you very much Andrew! Cheers!
Great comparison! I thought for sure since you've been carrying the pps that would win. Totally surprised.
Thank you Chris! I was surprised too. The Shield has really impressed me but both are top self for sure. Cheers!
Owned my Shield for 5 years now and purchased the PPS for EDC. Anxious to do some side-by-side range shooting when the PPS M2 LE arrives.
Great review....plus Centerfire....best range in JOCO. Thanks for the vid
Thank you very much Kevin and I agree 100%! Cheers
My PPS M2 is awesome. My first gun. Bought it for Christmas AND found it for $270 online
Nice Job !! makes me want to get both. as far as carrying.............. I don't think an attacker will care which one he/she gets shot with.
Thank you very much Hill and great point! Cheers
Great review as always...I would agree with you, I would choose the Shield 2.0 over the PPS, but only if I didn't already have the original Shield. The 2.0 trigger might be a tiny bit smoother, but nothing great...and, just not enough other upgrades. I think the trigger on the PPS is nice, but it feels a bit "toyish" to me. So, if you don't have a either now, then I would definitely go with the new Shield 2.0 over the PPS. But, it still needs the Apex trigger.
Excellent points Mean! I agree, the changes in the 2.0 are minor but so far, I have been really impressed. I like the analogy of the toy feeling trigger in the PPS. Hand’t thought of it that way but I think you’re on to something. I agree, an Apex would still be awesome. Thank you and cheers!
Great review and comparison! I have the original shield and liked it so much that I treated myself to a PC shield with tritium night sights..Its heartening to see an American manufacturer make a world class gun! I'm sure the wealthier is also world class, but S&W has a rep for taking care of owners.
Thank you very much Bill! I agree, the Smiths are great guns and the new 2.0 series has really impressed me. As for the Walther, it's no slouch either. Thank you and cheers!
Great video KSGG
Thank you very much CCC! Cheers brother
The problem I have with the shield, is I'm is quick to rust. Now if you use the shield as a everyday carry this is a problem for me.
Looking forward to getting the walther.
🤘👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 haha smith finally wins a one if I could have one comparison video...awesome vid
They were overdue! Thank you as always Chip. Cheers!
Great video man 👍
Thank you very much! Cheers!
I owned the first model PPS in 40CAL. I loved everything about the gun. I just wished the smaller clip had the same ergonomic bottom as the 7 round clip. It was a great carry gun.
After a couple of surgeries I will buy another PPS but in 9MM. I do this because of two rotator cuff surgeries on my right shoulder and 1 on my left one.
Nice review. I actually own both, the M&P 2.0 with the laser. I researched the PPS M2 before getting it but for some reason I cannot shoot it well. I thought my sights were off but range guy confirmed it was ok.
I rented a first gen Shield that same day and was shooting bulls! Go figure. Hence, leading me to getting the new Shield. I just shoot it better.
Thanks for sharing Ray! They are definitely both great but I agree, the Shield is awesome to shoot. Thank you and cheers!
Some pistols will just surprise you. I was surprised to consistently be hitting old empty propane tanks at 20 yards and a little further with no problem and I thought I would be able to hit jack with it like I do with snub nose revolvers.
I own both and have shot both a number of times and I find the PPS to be more accurate for me and the build feels more solid. The mag seems to fit better too. Don't get me wrong, I love both of them and enjoy shooting either one but for my daily CCW I grab the PPS. On top of everything else, the Shield has that grip which is nice when firing but the texture rubs against the skin if you have it touching. I use a waste strap and when I carry the Shield it rubs rough whereas the PPS doesn't irritate, but once again that depends on who is carrying it and where and how they are carrying it. In all honesty I would trust either one in a self defense situation. I picked the PPS up for about half the price of the Shield on sale too which makes it even more appealing. EDIT: I forgot to add that my Shield has the Crimson Trace laser and manual safety as well. It still has the articulating trigger.
I love my PPS M2 LE but I do wish the stock trigger was smoother. When I bought it I was hoping for more of a PPQ trigger in a more CC ready package
I completely agree! Thank you and cheers!
Very nice review. I have a original shield in 9mm and a 2.0 in 45acp... Also have a PPS 1st generation and plan to buy a PPS M2 fairly soon.
That's awesome Prop! I think you'll love the PPS M2. The ergos are tough to beat for a single stack. Thank you and cheers!
Nice look. I have the original Shield and the PPS M2. They both are great and I carry them both. I like the 2.0 but I’ll be going for the new compact.
Thanks Funky! I agree, both are probably my two favorite single stacks. That Compact is really sweet thought. It’s really impressed me. Thank you and cheer brother!
Needs more Ammo, I like the Double Stack 9MM PPQ M2 and a spare 17 round Mag. Great review on 2 similar pistols really depends on which one you personally shoot the best.
Well said Gary! I agree, capacity is great though it’s nice to have options when larger guns aren’t a good fit for the occasion. Thank you very much and cheers!
I don't think you understand the purpose of these guns. If you need to carry 17 rounds then you'll carry a full size handgun. If you want something you can carry in your pocket you have to sacrifice capacity. It's pretty simple actually
Great review KSGunGuy, the SHIELD gets my vote. *Would you review the RUGER LC9S please.? Thanks*
Thank you Ted! I’ll see what I can do! Cheers
Great video. I personally would have gone with the Walther simply because the front serrations are way more functional. As well, I would forgo the Shield altogether and just get an m&p 2.0 Compact.
Great point Pipe! There's no doubt, the PPS is a great option and one of my favs. I agree, the 2.0C is awesome and one of my top picks for the year. Thank you and cheers!
Great review, I looked at both and fired both. The PPS M2 was more accurate with less recoil. Also, the gun feels and look better IMO. Sooo, I purchased the PPS :)
I have a Glock 17 and a Px4 storm I’m looking for a small firearm my first choice was going to be the sig 365 but I see they have a lot off issues so after watching your videos I’ might get the Walter PPS M2 or the Glock 43
I have a Shield 2.0 40 caliber. It is phenomenal on the way the trigger breaks. It is my first 40 and I was apprehensive. But, just go slow with a firm grip and feel the break...bullseye! High Quality firearm. I want the 9mm for the extra capacity as well, plus I have the holster for it. Great review.
That’s awesome Blake! They are definitely high quality firearms. well said. Thank you and cheers!
In my opinion I like the shield alot better, especially the performance center version. The Walther was my first single stack 9mm for carry, and I enjoyed it, but had trouble practicing with it. I never felt consistent with my draws and grouping. I sold it for a Performance Center Shield for a killer deal which feels less snappy and easier to grip to me. Just my opinion but I think they are both great choices.
You gave me an idea: dabbing white phosphorescent paint on the Shield's steel sights as the next best thing to night sights.
Awesome! Thank you and cheers!
I own pps m2 and m&p 9mm and I love them both. So hard to choose. I think I just like the looks of the walther guns alot
On par with previous comments, g43, PPS M2 or shield is a great choice. I carry the PPS M2 because of the trigger, grip and *more importantly* how I shoot with it.
I’ve shot all the other variants and honestly get consistently better groups with the PPS M2. Your experience may differ, but I’m Walther all the way now when it comes to single stack 9mm.
Very well done...
Fair and balanced review...
Thank you very much Ray! I appreciate that my friend. Cheers!
Great review
Thank you very much Trell! Cheers
Started with a G43 because I'm very petite and short and it is easy to hide, but I stunk at shooting it. Tested a Shield at my range and loved it, shot it so well, and could keep shooting it. Bought a Shield 9 2.0 and gave my 43 to my husband 😁.
love my PPQ m2 w /xs sights.
You should also consider the price and total items included. Such as box, cleaning accessories, extra mags and capacity. Good job 👍🏾
I don’t go into those details in comparison videos. People generally don’t want that information. Thanks
Looking at these two guns to carry. I have a Walther PPQ and am very happy with it. At the end of the day probably cannot go wrong with either one of them.
Had the exact same situation, have a PPQ, ended up grabbing PPS M2, Walther has done so well by me, deserve my first choice.
Just ordered the Walther PPS M2 RMSc
Red dot should be cool
Wolfgagger takes some practice to get used to but is awesome when you get used to it
Just bought the S&W shield 2.0 It's the best carry semi I have ever felt out of the box. I would recommend it to anyone. Just be aware that it's tight, meaning it like any new gun needs a break in to allow easer racking and command of the levers...This is a quality gun....!
That’s awesome! Thank you and cheers!
Nice I might take a look at the 2.0 alot of people were fussing over the tightness. Good to hear it breaks in after awhile
Again...Great job on the comparison video. I admire your profsionally produced videos. How long have you been creating videos if I may ask? I pick Shield...as it is the only one I am familiar with.
Thank you G17! The channel is about 11 months old. I agree on the Shield! Cheers brother
Have them both plus many more over the years. The walther is only gun I have ever had problems with.
Thank you for sharing Bruce! Cheers brother
Well done review. I love my shield (gen 1). I think you hit it on that they are on par with each other. I ended up putting on talon sandpaper grips on the Shield, so I'm appreciating the changes for the 2.0. I agree these are comparable; buy the one on sale, with more mags, or other incentive.
Thank you very much Neil! They really are both great shooters and at the top of my list for single stacks. The 2.0 is really fantastic. I agree about buying on sale! Cheers brother
Great presentation. Its took guts for u to do it. I have both guns and the Walther to me is a better gun. I choose the Walther because I have owned a .380 PPK for 30yrs, have no issues and would never sell it. u, on the other hand, may have a preference because u carried a Shield .45, more familiar with it and Shield also looks better than the Walther. Nevertheless, the trigger is better on the Walther (opinion) and I like the trigger travel indicator on the rear because an experienced shooter can now Gage single action shooting. There is also 3 magazines. Good job.
Thank you Sam! Both are definitely great shooters. It’s one of the tougher I’ve done in the series and would really be happy with either. Thank you for watching and cheers!
This is like picking between Honda or Toyota. Can’t go wrong with either.
Never owned or shot a Walther PPS. Looks like a great edc carry option. But I trust my life and that of my family to a Shield 9 every day...All it does is dissapear on your body, shoots anything you load it with... every single time, and hits everything you point it at...without fail, without breakage (I've dropped it so many times). And they are dirt cheap!...So perhaps not 007's 1st choice..but then again...The Shield is a 100 percent American made little can of whoop ass...
I agree! The Shield is fantastic and still a carry gun foe me as well. Thank you and cheers!
Both are great guns...I will of course choose the walther...as that is what I carry and shoot...but today we have so many great choices out there.
Well said Glockster! The Walther is a great gun and won’t be leaving the collection any time soon. I agree that we are living in good times with the choices we have! Cheers brother
Make life easier by picking both or all.
Lol. No shame in that Vu! Thank you and cheers
Isn’t it great that we aren’t limited to just one? I have the original Shield and I like it. I’ve had my eye on the PPS M2 for a while, though.
Well said! The PPS is a great gun for sure. Thank you and cheers!
I want both....how do these compare to the Beretta apx carry or the canik elite SC??
I would like to get the shield. Friend of my mine has one. However I have a PPQ, it might be easier to go to the PPS being familiar with PPQ trigger.
Both are excellent guns and recommend either. Thank you and cheers!
Tim England I hear from other reviews that the PPS trigger is nothing like the PPQ. The body is just styled like the PPQ.
I would agree.My pps had better groups but the shield comes w an extra round.Both excellent, comes down to preference.
Well said Jeremy! Thank you and cheers
Nice video and well produced. My only critique would be that you not mention all of your previous experience with S&W M&P guns. I strongly suspected right from the start that you would pick the S&W because of those comments.
If you had left out the comments about your experience with S&W, your choice would have been completely uncolored and (seemingly) more objective, but I must say that you did give each gun a very nice analysis and clearly mentioned that the final choice was your opinion only.
Keep the videos coming, since you’re doing a great job and of course take my comments with a grain of salt because they are just my opinion as well.
What about canik elite sub compact?
Just bought the shield 2.0 with a laser guard pro green laser/light combo for $540. The bundle retails for $750!
Wow.. did you buy it used ?
alreso1rr brand new on sportsman outdoor sports
I have both LE version and the shield 2.0 with the crimson trace. They both fire very well. I've put over 1000 rounds through each, and they hold up well. Both are easy to maintain, but I've turned the PPS into my EDC. It feels better to carry and Alien Gear makes the shape shift for it so I barely feel it there. I have not yet found a holster that feels comfortable for the shield. I'm not a fan of kydex. Both are amazing CCW options though.
So close, it just depends on whats on sale that day.
Well said! Thank you and cheers!
All else being equal, seems like an extra round and slightly less weight would put the Shield ahead. I have the original, but I also have a PPQ and man is that a fantastic gun. If they could drop that trigger into the PPS there'd be no competition.
Can u do a video like this with the Taurus millennium g2 9mm and the scy spx 2 to of the best budget 9mm guns and it would be awsome cuz a lot of people want to pick a good gun that doesn't break the bank and still runs good. Ps the Taurus millennium g2 if think is way more reliable and runs better and feels and looks better. Just my ap. But it would be cool if u did. I think a lot of people now in days are trying to find a good low budget gun that runs like a glock or something and those to guns are like the king of the budget guns. Plzz think about it
Thank you for the suggestion! I'll see what I can do. Cheers!
I have both of these guns and I would agree. My shield has the laser on it though.
I pocket carry my Shield and it fits perfect in my Wranglers. The little difference in the specs between the two guns. Makes a big difference for me,because of the way I carry.
That’s awesome Road! Glad to know it works well in the pocket. Thank you and cheers!
Well if I had to choose. I go with the PPS. But it comes down to having to nitpick to make that decision. Either choice is really a win.
I totally agree Matteo! It's a tough call and either one fit the bill nicely. Thank you and cheers brother!
I own both. I prefer the walther. It carries easier and has a FAR better trigger. Shield is a nice price point alternative though.
I agree the Walther has awesome ergos and a great trigger! That said, the Shield 2.0 has really impressed me and the trigger is vastly improved over the previous model. Gives the Walther a run for the money. Thank you and cheers!
KSGunGuy but then for that price you can get the le version of the pps
@@kevinyoung947 which he had on the video he had pps m2 le
You didn't notice the quality difference between shield and PPS?
Easy decision get both like I did! Lovem!
Well said Joey! Thank you and cheers!
I own both. If I had to pick I would pick the pps but, like you said, slim margin. Both are great guns
Does the pps fit the s&w shield mags?
I bought a pps m2 yesterday
That’s awesome! They are great guns indeed
me too!
Just bought a pps m2 myself and I love it!
Also had the Glock 43 and I like the pps much better. Better ergos, better sights, less recoil.
Both are very excellent weapons but I carry the shield great video
Thank you Douglas! I agree, they are both great guns. Cheers brother!
Could you do a Beretta Nano review? I’m considering one for my fiancé
Thank you for the great suggestion! I'll do what I can. Cheers!
If you love her you will avoid the Nano. It is a turd with a trigger