This is the first song I came to when I heard the news. I'm just sorry I wasn't able to help him in any way. Dear Jonghyun, I love you so much. It's only been a few hours but I've grieved too much and cried too much. Listening to you sing hurts. I didn't know such pain was possible to exist just by loving you. It's alright. I understand. It's been hard for you. My sunshine. You've done well. You've lived well. Rest in peace, my sunshine. I love you.
Skeleton flower -describing jonghyun oppa's emotion Lonely -describing that he has none left except him in his own depressed world and there was none to help him out from there. Let me out - it describes that he was crying out for help .He was telling us to help him but no one noticed. Sorry -he was telling us that he is sorry to us for leaving us . End of a day-It is really a comforting song but this song is sad also .it is describing that in the end of a day he was alone ,no one was there for him to tell him that he well .he had worked hard. Jonghyun oppa you are really amazing . don't worry we know why you had to take that step .you don't need to apologise for what you have done we just want you just want to to be happy.. You did well You have worked hard. Saranghae ❤️❤️❤️
The lyrics are so deep, sad, yet very meaningful. His voice sounds absolutely beautiful. You can hear so much emotions through his voice in this song. Also knowing the characteristics of the actual flower diphylleia grayi which is a flower that turns translucent within the rain, it's really is admirable with all the references in this song. A masterpiece and beautiful piece of music.
Words can't describe how beautiful and emotional this song is. It's simply _genius_ which isn't simple at all. The first time I heard it I just stopped doing everything else and sat down and listened because it had that big of an impact. Songs like this one is the reason I sing and compose music of my own. Jonghyun is an amazing person and artist and I'm speaking the strong truth when I say that I love all, _all_ of his songs.
same here ; v ; although im not a hardcore shawol but all of his songs speak volume, and his lyrics are beautiful too, plus that voice and the melody, the story op.1 is super sad that i cried while listening to it :((( later i read some extracts from his books, and really, it's genius
That heavenly voice, that sweet breathing, and that bright smile will forever remain in my heart. I had wished he received the happiness he well deserved. Such a beautiful person gone too soon.
His depression and saddnes was translusent like that flower.... You don't see the tears and suffering because it's 'translusent' but when the person smiles and laughs, it seems strong, just like this flower when it's dry. Jonghyun.... I hope you know how special you were. Not because you were famous, but because you were such a romantic, fragile person. I'm sorry this world was too cruel for a soul like yours. Hope you found that peace you've been looking for.... ❤ rest in peace
I updated my SNS listening to the song with caption "This song makes you suicidal" a year ago and now I feel so sorry for him. I should have known but I don't follow any of his social media to leave a comforting message. 😭😭😭
When i was a kid, i use to climb on to a mountain in my hometown, it was beautiful, there were two artificial lakes, a small one and a bigger one, the biggest one was natural and the hardest to reach, climbing in the morning, pretty early, there was a beautiful valley plenty of this flowers, they shined, as diamonds, there were a lot, wet, cold, translucent... When we got down, hours later, they wer all white, the translucent valley became white, pure... Any time i listen this song i remember about hose days .. no matter how much wet one of this flowers can be, they aren't invisible, we can see them even while the rain is heavy, we can see them shining, we can appreciate they beauty and uniqueness even during the worst of the storms, we treasure them, in both their facades.
I was the same way - also when I heard Chen and Baekhyun on Immortal Song (Really I Didn't Know). Made me cry every time I heard it. Skeleton Flower is just amazing, as is Jonghyun. I got the book too. Can't even read it yet, my Korean is so limited.
bye bye jonghyun. i had no idea about you when you were still here, but i've been listening to your beautiful, soulful and wonderfully personal music and listening to little extracts from your radio show, and i can honestly say i regret not knowing about you when you were still with us so, _so_ much. you did so well, jonghyun. i hope wherever you are now, it's beautiful, and sunny, and filled with little flowers just like you're singing about. rest well, angel.
Well said. I discovered Jonghyun and SHINee just seven months ago. I am mourning this young man as if I knew him personally and with an intensity that has me shaken. First time listening to this song with the English subs and I'm sitting here with tears running down my face. How I wish I could reach back through time and bring him back to us. How those around him apparently remained unaware of his struggle is a mystery to me. So many signs right out in the open and no one reacted with the necessary. aggressive action required. I hate SM.
Beautiful song, beautiful voice, beautiful Angel... You left us a month ago today...we miss you so much... We love you all... Rest in peace Jonghyun...
he told us how depress he was through his song but we never notice it..We're sorry Jonghyun..We're sorry cuz never notice how hurt you are..we just enjoy listening to your song without feel curious why you wrote that kind of song..we're sorry..you already did well dear..it's not your fault..you already worked hard and all of your songs are the proof..you left us such a beautiful song
I have great respect and admiration for so many Kpop artists. The sheer talent and hard work is mind boggling. People like Jong Hyun, and Yong Hwa and Lay (Yixing), who not only perform vocals but dance, play several instruments, speak multiple languages, take on acting careers AND compose omg. Profoundly thankful they have shared themselves with the world. Skeleton Flower is beautiful. I'll go looking for the book.
I did. Its in Hangul and my Korean is in baby stage - BUT there is a blog link that translated parts. Each chapter begins with a poem and then tells part of the story. A sad love story about a man, a woman and a dog. Here is link. omonatheydidnt.livejournal.com/17324885.html
I am trying to learn Korean language. My friend bought the book in Korea for me, but they sold it on amazon.com too. Here is link www.amazon.com/SHINee-JONGHYUN-Novel-Book-Skeleton/dp/B018L8V7X6/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1470464335&sr=1-1&keywords=Skeleton+Flower
+Linda Harris do you go to classes or do you study it on your own? I'm trying to study the language but I don't have time for more classes. I just want to know if it's possible to learn the language oneself. Thanks for the link!!
He was sad ,lonely and hurting his voice as if he is asking for help ,so sorry we don't know that you are in this kind of emotions. Indeed we are like a petal that will fade someday. Rest thank you for entertaining us without knowing deep in your heart you re in pain.😅😅
rest in peace 김종현 exactly 2 months since you left us and it still hurts so much we will never forget you will cry and dance to your songs and will always love you... thank you
Such a sad and emotional song.. Jong Hyun this song is such a masterpiece. You are describing your life like the skeleton flower. You had done so well. Rest In Peace.
Haunting... to think that he was smiling on all these variety shows but was hurting deep down.... Jonghyun, you made beautiful music and this is proof of that. I'll never forget you. Rest In Peace 1990-2017💕
He was such an amazing artist, but most importantly, an amazing person... he always shined the brightest and is shining the brightest in the sky... Thank you Jonghyun, for giving us so much comfort and these beautiful songs with precious meanings and revelations... I'm sorry we didn't comfort you.... REST IN PEACE, OUR ANGEL
ohmygod. idk. this is just... so beautiful. like, so so SO beautiful. i cant even describe it in words. such a masterpiece. he is truly a music genius. i love this talented guy so much. T^T
So very lovely and sad. Painfully beautiful. Oh Jonghyun, you were magical. Your voice is one for the ages and I am so grateful that your songs are all over the Internet so I can hear and enjoy your legacy. Thank you for working so hard and producing so much. How I wish you could have felt the monumental degree to which you were loved. I hope you feel it now.
This is my favorite song from jonghyun, I had to come back here I needed to hear him again, feel like he isn't gone just yet, it's so hard to let go of him, I didn't know him personally but why does it hurt so much? You were loved you still are, I hope you know you did well in this life and that you'll do well in the next too. I hope you won't suffer as much, good bye.
The masterpiece of Kim Jonghyun this is really sad and have a really deep meaning i can't stop myself from being crying again Jonghyun ahh your voice are so beautiful it make me crying a lot because you have leave too soon if someone notice your sign of your depression this will never be happen hmm rest well dear Jong Hyun you have done a great work :'(
Your not hurting anymore baby as long as we still breath on this cruel world you will still receive our love. Because even though you are not walking on this world you still need us and we still need you my perfect rose you will always be remembered as the ""perfect rose" to me. R.I.P Jjong you did well and Im very proud of you!
I feel like this is so hauntingly beautiful that almost no one would appreciate this song in a right way... Idk, i, myself don't even know if i can appreciate it in a proper way... Only few songs can make me feel like this. Thank u Jonghyun for this, u have left spechless.
Jonghyun-ah, I became haunted by your voice. I have been listening to your songs nonstop since you left.. They touch my soul in a way that I can't describe and they inspire me If I ever finish whatever I am working on right now, just know that I am grateful for you as your music plays a huge role in the process I did not know where else I would write these words, I hope you get my message somehow
This is not only remarkable, but beautiful. In depth with feelings, and being vulnerable with one self and singing for everyone to hear. Enough to look within yourself. Thank you, Kim Jonghyun. For this beautiful song.
![[VOSTFR] Jonghyun 샤이니 종현 - Skeleton Flower / Diphylleia Grayi ( 산하엽 ) KOREAN ROMANIZED FRENCH](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/aR9HRJM0bPg/mqdefault.jpg)
![[VOSTFR] Jonghyun 샤이니 종현 - Skeleton Flower / Diphylleia Grayi ( 산하엽 ) KOREAN ROMANIZED FRENCH](/img/tr.png)
![JONGHYUN (종현) - Fine (그래도 되지 않아?) lyrics [eng/rom/han]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/HEJDd8R6H8s/mqdefault.jpg)
![Jonghyun[종현] - Sorry[미안해](Kor/Eng Lyrics.ver)](/img/n.gif)
This is the first song I came to when I heard the news. I'm just sorry I wasn't able to help him in any way. Dear Jonghyun, I love you so much. It's only been a few hours but I've grieved too much and cried too much. Listening to you sing hurts. I didn't know such pain was possible to exist just by loving you. It's alright. I understand. It's been hard for you. My sunshine. You've done well. You've lived well. Rest in peace, my sunshine. I love you.
Just reading your comment I can tell you cried while writing it and every sentence stung.
투명해지는꽃. 종현은사라지지않은투명한꽃으로존재합니다.
Skeleton flower -describing jonghyun oppa's emotion
Lonely -describing that he has none left except him in his own depressed world and there was none to help him out from there.
Let me out - it describes that he was crying out for help .He was telling us to help him but no one noticed.
Sorry -he was telling us that he is sorry to us for leaving us .
End of a day-It is really a comforting song but this song is sad also .it is describing that in the end of a day he was alone ,no one was there for him to tell him that he well .he had worked hard.
Jonghyun oppa you are really amazing . don't worry we know why you had to take that step .you don't need to apologise for what you have done we just want you just want to to be happy..
You did well
You have worked hard.
Saranghae ❤️❤️❤️
종현아 그립다 너의 웃음소리와너의미소가보고싶어
The lyrics are so deep, sad, yet very meaningful. His voice sounds absolutely beautiful. You can hear so much emotions through his voice in this song. Also knowing the characteristics of the actual flower diphylleia grayi which is a flower that turns translucent within the rain, it's really is admirable with all the references in this song. A masterpiece and beautiful piece of music.
Suki Kirai he is gone 💔💔💔
N Chu forever..
It's 2018 without him :")
Maya Chandra Dewi and it hurts
2023, still missing you so much our Angel, Rest in heavenly peace dear😢🕊️🥀 I love you
This song hurts more than it did yesterday
From my point of view, now that we know it's just so obvious how can people didn't notice...
It still hurt the same
Words can't describe how beautiful and emotional this song is. It's simply _genius_ which isn't simple at all. The first time I heard it I just stopped doing everything else and sat down and listened because it had that big of an impact. Songs like this one is the reason I sing and compose music of my own. Jonghyun is an amazing person and artist and I'm speaking the strong truth when I say that I love all, _all_ of his songs.
same here ; v ; although im not a hardcore shawol but all of his songs speak volume, and his lyrics are beautiful too, plus that voice and the melody, the story op.1 is super sad that i cried while listening to it :(((
later i read some extracts from his books, and really, it's genius
That heavenly voice, that sweet breathing, and that bright smile will forever remain in my heart. I had wished he received the happiness he well deserved. Such a beautiful person gone too soon.
His depression and saddnes was translusent like that flower.... You don't see the tears and suffering because it's 'translusent' but when the person smiles and laughs, it seems strong, just like this flower when it's dry. Jonghyun.... I hope you know how special you were. Not because you were famous, but because you were such a romantic, fragile person. I'm sorry this world was too cruel for a soul like yours. Hope you found that peace you've been looking for.... ❤ rest in peace
My sunshine is gone.
My sunshine isn't suffering anymore.
I am. More than anything. Rest in peace, you were too great for this world.
My heart still flutters Everytime I hear your voice,
My heart still beats faster Everytime I here your name.
I still love you.
his voice fading out into a whisper affected me on a spiritual level
Spicy Tots (":
Time passes but you will never be forgotten jonghyun🌼
This song is so.. strong and sad... kind of worried about Jonghyun writing a lot of sad songs lately...
You were right to be worried 😢😢😢 #RIPJONGHYUN
💔💔💔
I updated my SNS listening to the song with caption "This song makes you suicidal" a year ago and now I feel so sorry for him. I should have known but I don't follow any of his social media to leave a comforting message. 😭😭😭
When i was a kid, i use to climb on to a mountain in my hometown, it was beautiful, there were two artificial lakes, a small one and a bigger one, the biggest one was natural and the hardest to reach, climbing in the morning, pretty early, there was a beautiful valley plenty of this flowers, they shined, as diamonds, there were a lot, wet, cold, translucent... When we got down, hours later, they wer all white, the translucent valley became white, pure... Any time i listen this song i remember about hose days .. no matter how much wet one of this flowers can be, they aren't invisible, we can see them even while the rain is heavy, we can see them shining, we can appreciate they beauty and uniqueness even during the worst of the storms, we treasure them, in both their facades.
Life will never be the same without our dear Jonghyun...
I miss you dear kim jonghyun.
rest in peace, jonghyun. you didn’t deserve any of this. thank you for everything.
He left us with great art and went to heaven 💔
R.i.p im sorry ..
This song shook me up emotionally when I didn't even know the lyrics. Now...I don't even know how to deal with everything I'm feeling right now...
I was the same way - also when I heard Chen and Baekhyun on Immortal Song (Really I Didn't Know). Made me cry every time I heard it. Skeleton Flower is just amazing, as is Jonghyun. I got the book too. Can't even read it yet, my Korean is so limited.
This song is a masterpiece
Its my favorite peace I've learned on piano
For my first ever tattoo I got one for Jonghyun. This flower with diphylleia grayi written above it
This is so pure ... raw beauty ... deep lyrics. Thank u Kim jonghyun for this moment
He is my favourite poet.
bye bye jonghyun.
i had no idea about you when you were still here, but i've been listening to your beautiful, soulful and wonderfully personal music and listening to little extracts from your radio show, and i can honestly say i regret not knowing about you when you were still with us so, _so_ much.
you did so well, jonghyun. i hope wherever you are now, it's beautiful, and sunny, and filled with little flowers just like you're singing about.
rest well, angel.
Well said. I discovered Jonghyun and SHINee just seven months ago. I am mourning this young man as if I knew him personally and with an intensity that has me shaken. First time listening to this song with the English subs and I'm sitting here with tears running down my face. How I wish I could reach back through time and bring him back to us. How those around him apparently remained unaware of his struggle is a mystery to me. So many signs right out in the open and no one reacted with the necessary. aggressive action required. I hate SM.
I want this to be played at my funeral where it will be held at night, under the dark sky, mesmerizing moon, and blue stars.
Beautiful song, beautiful voice, beautiful Angel...
You left us a month ago today...we miss you so much...
We love you all...
Rest in peace Jonghyun...
he told us how depress he was through his song but we never notice it..We're sorry Jonghyun..We're sorry cuz never notice how hurt you are..we just enjoy listening to your song without feel curious why you wrote that kind of song..we're sorry..you already did well dear..it's not your fault..you already worked hard and all of your songs are the proof..you left us such a beautiful song
I have great respect and admiration for so many Kpop artists. The sheer talent and hard work is mind boggling. People like Jong Hyun, and Yong Hwa and Lay (Yixing), who not only perform vocals but dance, play several instruments, speak multiple languages, take on acting careers AND compose omg. Profoundly thankful they have shared themselves with the world. Skeleton Flower is beautiful. I'll go looking for the book.
Did you get the book?
I did. Its in Hangul and my Korean is in baby stage - BUT there is a blog link that translated parts. Each chapter begins with a poem and then tells part of the story. A sad love story about a man, a woman and a dog. Here is link. omonatheydidnt.livejournal.com/17324885.html
+Linda Harris thank you so much!! Where did you buy the book? Is it sold along with the album? And are you learning korean language?
I am trying to learn Korean language. My friend bought the book in Korea for me, but they sold it on amazon.com too. Here is link www.amazon.com/SHINee-JONGHYUN-Novel-Book-Skeleton/dp/B018L8V7X6/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1470464335&sr=1-1&keywords=Skeleton+Flower
+Linda Harris do you go to classes or do you study it on your own? I'm trying to study the language but I don't have time for more classes. I just want to know if it's possible to learn the language oneself. Thanks for the link!!
He was sad ,lonely and hurting his voice as if he is asking for help ,so sorry we don't know that you are in this kind of emotions. Indeed we are like a petal that will fade someday. Rest thank you for entertaining us without knowing deep in your heart you re in pain.😅😅
rest in peace 김종현
exactly 2 months since you left us and it still hurts so much
we will never forget you
will cry and dance to your songs
and will always love you...
thank you
Such a sad and emotional song.. Jong Hyun this song is such a masterpiece. You are describing your life like the skeleton flower. You had done so well. Rest In Peace.
Haunting... to think that he was smiling on all these variety shows but was hurting deep down.... Jonghyun, you made beautiful music and this is proof of that. I'll never forget you. Rest In Peace 1990-2017💕
He was such an amazing artist, but most importantly, an amazing person... he always shined the brightest and is shining the brightest in the sky...
Thank you Jonghyun, for giving us so much comfort and these beautiful songs with precious meanings and revelations...
I'm sorry we didn't comfort you....
REST IN PEACE,
OUR ANGEL
삼가 고인의 명복을 빕니다.
Rest in peace.
You have worked so hard jonghyun oppa..rest well now dear😢
ohmygod. idk. this is just... so beautiful. like, so so SO beautiful. i cant even describe it in words. such a masterpiece. he is truly a music genius. i love this talented guy so much. T^T
His emotions were so true and raw within these lyrics. You did so well, Jonghyun.
So very lovely and sad. Painfully beautiful. Oh Jonghyun, you were magical. Your voice is one for the ages and I am so grateful that your songs are all over the Internet so I can hear and enjoy your legacy. Thank you for working so hard and producing so much. How I wish you could have felt the monumental degree to which you were loved. I hope you feel it now.
This is my favorite song from jonghyun, I had to come back here I needed to hear him again, feel like he isn't gone just yet, it's so hard to let go of him, I didn't know him personally but why does it hurt so much? You were loved you still are, I hope you know you did well in this life and that you'll do well in the next too. I hope you won't suffer as much, good bye.
Just become so emotional after knowing that he just left us... Thanks for giving us so many happy memories and hope you are happy there :')
Today is exactly one year after he left and still is as painful...I miss you♡,
I can FEEL the sadness in his voice 😢 Rest in peace beautiful love ❤❤❤
Since that day, I keep coming everyday here...
The saddest and the most beautiful song I've heard this year. ♥♥♥
I wish you'd come back. Too many tears right now RIP Jonghyun💙
Thank you For being who you are R.I.P Jonghyun
The masterpiece of Kim Jonghyun this is really sad and have a really deep meaning i can't stop myself from being crying again Jonghyun ahh your voice are so beautiful it make me crying a lot because you have leave too soon if someone notice your sign of your depression this will never be happen hmm rest well dear Jong Hyun you have done a great work :'(
Jonghyun left so many masterpieces...
it´s hurt... I can´t stop crying while I listening this song... My favourite song by Jong.. Mi little puppy, you're now an angel...
I thought I cried enough the past few days, but this topped it for me. I still can't believe you're gone. You did well Jonghyun ♡
Your not hurting anymore baby as long as we still breath on this cruel world you will still receive our love. Because even though you are not walking on this world you still need us and we still need you my perfect rose you will always be remembered as the ""perfect rose" to me. R.I.P Jjong you did well and Im very proud of you!
I feel like this is so hauntingly beautiful that almost no one would appreciate this song in a right way... Idk, i, myself don't even know if i can appreciate it in a proper way... Only few songs can make me feel like this. Thank u Jonghyun for this, u have left spechless.
Please rest in peace, thank you for all the beautiful music. You did well, an artist we won't forget.
I still miss you jonghyun oppa 😭😭😭
one of the sweetest souls to have ever existed..
Jonghyun always delivers such amazing works, I truly am never disappointed.. 💕
RIP Kim Jonghyun
Your songs are still helping me to sleep and get rid of my headache
Thank you Jonghyun ♥ #RIP
Mizune x Why does my heart hurt?
I know it's hard to accept, i cried a lot too but now he's able to rest and let go his demons
I miss him
Such a deep meaning 😍jonghyun
Now that he is gone I can't help but feel that the flower he is referring to is actually himself )':
For anyone who doesn't know skeleton flower is also the name of his book.
18.12.17
It's a very difficult day............
Rip.
Lina The Original KpopAirConditioner that date will always be remembered 😭😭😭😭
i cryed looking at the lyrics and the tone of the beat
Such a beautiful song. Love the melody, the lyrics and especially Jonghyun singing it.
he sounds like he's crying at the end and it's so so sad
We will miss you, angel 💕💕 you touched so many hearts, and we are sorry we couldn't help you
BEAUTIFUL!!💖 BEAUTIFUL VOCAL!💖 BEAUTIFUL LYRICS!💖 BEAUTIFUL SOUND!💖 It sounded so Angelic.💖💖✨✨ Jonghyun I'm so proud of you. 😊😊
ardlse ale SHAWOL EXO L A.R.M.Y CARAT Now He's not here. OMG that hurts
it's so beautiful... u just need to cry with it
This is definitely my new favorite song.
Come back to this song again. Goodbye jonghyun. Gonna miss u
I always come back to this. Absolutely beautiful to hear such a powerful voice sound so vulnerable here. I love you, Jjong.
I love this song 🌸
rest in peace jonghyun 💓
Jonghyun-ah, I became haunted by your voice. I have been listening to your songs nonstop since you left.. They touch my soul in a way that I can't describe and they inspire me
If I ever finish whatever I am working on right now, just know that I am grateful for you as your music plays a huge role in the process
I did not know where else I would write these words, I hope you get my message somehow
I can listen to this on loop for hours
R.I.P
A legend that alone went through what none knew..May he find peace at last..I hope he is happy.
In retrospect I feel like he's singing about his own soul.
This song is the hardest to listen to. But so devastatingly beautiful. I know those feelings too. I’m sorry. I love you.
i miss you, kim jonghyun.
あなたは、何を求めて、何処へ、旅立ったのでしょう
今は、幸せですか、あなたのいない世界は、淋しいです
🌸🌸🌸🍀🍀🍀❤️🩹❤️🩹❤️🩹
jonghyunnie my dear i hope you’re resting well. you have worked hard, thank you and i love you. goodbye until i can see you again.
This song has more than just this. It's full of emotions and feelings, it makes feel heavy inside
Rip Jonghyun 💔😞 ~ you're music will live on forever
This is not only remarkable, but beautiful. In depth with feelings, and being vulnerable with one self and singing for everyone to hear. Enough to look within yourself. Thank you, Kim Jonghyun. For this beautiful song.
"I'm living a healthy lonliness" Skeleton flower (the book)
This song is unbearable. Too sad.. but it is such a piece of pure art that i keep listening to it until cry
the lyrics & music is so deep 😢 and jonghyun's voice is just so angelic...i can't 😭 thank you for the eng lyrics 💜
This song made me cry. 😢
Beautiful MV, simple but meaningful 🌸🌷🌺🌹🌼
If only we noticed sooner that he was calling for help...😭 rip you did well Jjong
Jonghyun you did well. Rest your heart now. You are so loved.
Thank you for sharing the English translation it means so much to us !
beautiful lyrics beautiful vocal, just beautiful😂😂
I’ll miss him so much
Standing listen to this song in the blow wind with tears.
We Love You, Jjong
we love you jonghyun. we love you so much