On the contrary safety is the point here , we want safe autonomous vehicles this is how they figure it all out because let’s face it this is the future of human travel on the ground I myself prefer to be in control of the vehicle 100% but in the future are children’s children are going to be in autonomous vehicles Trial and Error
AI racing, eh?! sounds just as exiting as watching "bots" fight each other in a shooter game -.- might be fun for a while, but gets stale pretty quickly! *BUT* for long-time endurance testing of the vehicles, it could be really nice actually!
Most people with a high level of mastery in any field have weak social abilities compared to their dumber peers. A friend to all is a friend to no one.
This is a great showcase. If we don't stand up and realise how our jobs and interests are going to be taken with robotic artificial intelligence like this, nothing is gonna open your eyes
It's going to be "interesting" when Bots become "intelligent" enough on their own to figure out humans are as dumb as they come, cause more problems than they're worth & need to go. 🤔
@@toekkababy5329 Brother. They said the exact same thing about chess 10 years ago. I'm not saying it will happen soon, but the fact that it will happen is simply a matter of time. There will never be anything that an AI can't do better than a human as technology gets better.
A lot of the difficulty of autonomous driving is all the random events that can happen like pedestrians unexpectedly crossing or a blockage in the road. With a pre determined circuit it probably isn't as difficult, but obviously even if they managed to make driverless cars faster it would still be boring.
Brutally honest opinion about this, it’s scary, it makes racing a snoozefest in the future, and it seems shit for something like legit AI racing, just no
The world will be much better when AI has replaced everyone working at universities, and especially everyone "working" as an editor of an academic journal.
Racing needs superhuman reaction speed (robots are good at that) but not superhuman intelligence to deal with new situations (current algorithms are not good at that).
Украинский дипломат призвал Шольца не звать Путина на пиво, но поговорить. p.s. - "эй, фуфел! сарделька баварская! я те че сказал?! иди к Путину и за нас говори! ну и да, и мне за пивом сбегай!"
“Once you get to 100 or 130 mph, unless you’re a professional race car driver, you really shouldn’t be driving at that speed.” Meanwhile on Texas highways… 🚗🚙🚕💨💨
From the video: "The goal of the project is to advance understanding around vehicle autonomy, with the aim of ultimately making self-driving cars operate more safely at higher speeds." But also, imagine these cars get good enough to beat human world champions, every single time. I would watch the shit out of it
@@GiDaOne You wouldn't watch the shit out of it, you'd watch it once and then get bored. How often do people watch AI chess tournaments? The feat of engineering is only half of Motorsport, for it to be entertaining you need to see a driver try to wrestle with the power of engineering.
@@Dorgpoop For me it would be amazing to see self-driving cars do things we wouldn't have thought possible with physics, and just get better and better. It would be great to see them compete with humans. Of course, humans bring their personalities and their stories to the sport, something that AI cannot do. But for me it's a different kind of attraction. As for chess, I love to watch AI games too, preferably with expert commentary since some of those ideas are so out of the league of anybody else. And it's also great to see engines compete and overtake each other for the first spot and just get better.
This isn't AI, it's pre-programmed, with sh!tload of sensors that give a certain value, that is then corresponding with the programmed responses to those values... A lot of calculations per second for sure, but AI....no...
Then there's no point cheering them on. Because "With no driver, no cheering, no enthusiasm". Might as well call this event , "Life Sized Remote Cars Moving". Crowds might as well save their money and buy tickets for real F1 racing. With Drivers.
These are not "Remote Drivers"....the cars are deciding for themselves what lines to take, when to overtake, and when to defend...it would be pretty insane to even imagine humans could control race cars remotely like a RC toy at these speeds.
Possibly fun for Computer Nerds? Now, what could be fun is put a high zoot receiver in it, grab a Radio Transmitter & you got one heck of an awesome 1:1 scale competition RC Car. 😁
That is not AI. Those cars are following a highly sophisticated set of instructions. If it was AI, there wouldn't be a young fellow sitting there in a red hooded sweatshirt crouched over a laptop writing code; the car would be teaching itself. And that technology is still some years away.
It's a marketing stunt aimed at promoting the safety of autonomous vehicles? You'll need to have motorcycles, pedestrians and junctions to deliver that message to the families of people already killed by autonomy.
This is not a sport and will never be one. It’s purely a commercialized incentive for engineering schools to advance their research. That’s all. People only care about racing because the human driver is taking a risk. Remove that risk and you won’t find enough engineers who care to fill the stands. “Robot Wars” was a televised example of how unappealing it is to most. Lastly, why are we spending TRILLIONS trying to get contemporary tech to work on contemporary roads, when it would only cost billions to embed magnetic sensors into all public roads, eliminating half of the complexity behind automated driving? Current self-driving research is an exercise in stupidity, with everyone trying to Rube Goldberg a solution while ignoring the obvious one. Also, speed isn’t the danger. It’s the sudden stop at the end that kills, not speed. Differential in speed, combined with slow human reactions, is the danger on public highways. The only way automated driving will work is if all cars use it all the time on highways or you will always have fatal errors
The humans are the students who are programming the AI software...motorsport is as much a team sport as it is centered around drivers...autonomous racing emphasizes the team aspects
Whats the point ? you might as well turn it into 'robot wars' or something cooler , Automatic cars going fast in a big circle with 0 danger is only good for gathering data ...Nobody is gonna get gripped by this
@@AstroBear11 Considering they're open wheel racing cars going around a circuit with no real corners it's not that fast, especially considering they don't have to worry about safety.
This will only be fun to watch if the cars can go ludicrous speeds. No real need to think about safety.
Yeah but then they couldn't have anybody in the stands because the cars would go flying into them when they go over the fence
And should breathe new life into older tracks that are no longer deemed safe for human drivers.
shut up
On the contrary safety is the point here , we want safe autonomous vehicles this is how they figure it all out because let’s face it this is the future of human travel on the ground I myself prefer to be in control of the vehicle 100% but in the future are children’s children are going to be in autonomous vehicles Trial and Error
WALL.E Disney Pixar. = Future of humanity
3:26 talks about Lidar, proceeds to show a camera.
I've seen it coming and now it is here. Scary. Exiting.
AI racing, eh?!
sounds just as exiting as watching "bots" fight each other in a shooter game -.-
might be fun for a while, but gets stale pretty quickly!
*BUT* for long-time endurance testing of the vehicles, it could be really nice actually!
Driverless races... viewerless events.
I think the point is to advance autonomous driving using extreme conditions to advance the tach further not to replace drivers in races
This is a technology demonstration not meant to replace NASCAR.
I bet you hate video games then
Its done for AI research and testing. The teams are made up from universities...
Skynet is slowly being built!
Brilliant idea just need to name one kitt name one karr
3:40 Looks like Tron! 😁
Won't be long before the bots take over writing the commentary here.
Dallara indy light car?
But still more personality than the average F1 driver
Most people with a high level of mastery in any field have weak social abilities compared to their dumber peers. A friend to all is a friend to no one.
Lmfa😂
The reporter might like to think about becoming a Jockey in Horse Racing
Key word coded not AI
Meaning?
@@richardlehoux code is a line command which is not true AI
They call everything AI nowadays. Code a calculator and when 1+1=2 is the answer, AI did it!! 🤦🏾♂️
Tron @ 3:45.
In theory these cars could go around tracks much faster than any human driver could.
This just isn't AI though it's coded. There are far too many variable conditions for this to work on anything other than a dry oval
this is insane, its like as if these drivers aren't human!
This is a great showcase.
If we don't stand up and realise how our jobs and interests are going to be taken with robotic artificial intelligence like this, nothing is gonna open your eyes
It's going to be "interesting" when Bots become "intelligent" enough on their own to figure out humans are as dumb as they come, cause more problems than they're worth & need to go. 🤔
Everyone just wants more and better public transportation, not cars and trucks that can obliterate pedestrians and other drivers on the road
💯💯
How soon before they can beat a F1 driver?
I was thinking the exact same thing! :D
Never,ai cant feel the road like a prof f1 driver can never drive on the limit
@@toekkababy5329 Brother. They said the exact same thing about chess 10 years ago. I'm not saying it will happen soon, but the fact that it will happen is simply a matter of time. There will never be anything that an AI can't do better than a human as technology gets better.
A lot of the difficulty of autonomous driving is all the random events that can happen like pedestrians unexpectedly crossing or a blockage in the road. With a pre determined circuit it probably isn't as difficult, but obviously even if they managed to make driverless cars faster it would still be boring.
Certainly not in my lifetime and possibly not in the lifetimes of most commenters on this video (even if they're 5 year olds).
The 2050 Olympic games will have athletics without people. Boston dynamics with take care of the rest 😂
Or Skynet 😂
Funny how this content released a week after Lewis' announcement to move to Ferrari.
F1 drivers would always be the reason people watch this sport IMO
IoT
It's like an adaptation of Disney's Fantasia: The Sorcerer's Apprentice.
Why did the autonomous racing car get pulled over by the computer police? It was caught exceeding the "byte" limit!
When will the day come when policies are formulated without questionable politicians?
Brutally honest opinion about this, it’s scary, it makes racing a snoozefest in the future, and it seems shit for something like legit AI racing, just no
Awesome baby, love that beard and stach!❤
The world will be much better when AI has replaced everyone working at universities, and especially everyone "working" as an editor of an academic journal.
Racing needs superhuman reaction speed (robots are good at that) but not superhuman intelligence to deal with new situations (current algorithms are not good at that).
In this age the engineers are now the superstars.
Not interested, bring the humans back!
i'm a car enthusiast from jamaica and i'm fine with going 130mph cause I know I have control; this tech is pretty cool to see in action though
They somehow made racing even more boring.
I would absolutely love the addition of driverless cars to formula 1
What the hell for?
In the future they will have
this will be as fun to watch as robot football just give up
Украинский дипломат призвал Шольца не звать Путина на пиво, но поговорить.
p.s.
- "эй, фуфел! сарделька баварская! я те че сказал?! иди к Путину и за нас говори! ну и да, и мне за пивом сбегай!"
это немного о том а че эт Киев нахрен все послали и столицу в Москву перенесли...
your mom drive faster son
Yeah fast with safety can save time
I wish the challenge is developing a smart Autonomous system that works well in chaotic environments rather than a fast Autonomous system
I need the need for speed ✖️ I meant automation
It's like horse racing... driverless lol
Interesting how the new consumerism is working its way into human work camps for those not in the 1% who own or program these new techs.
“Once you get to 100 or 130 mph, unless you’re a professional race car driver, you really shouldn’t be driving at that speed.”
Meanwhile on Texas highways…
🚗🚙🚕💨💨
As a German, I couldn't help but smirk a little at that statement. But actually, I agree. Those speeds on public roads is a little bonkers.
So why are you making them run? Just watch on your screens generated by AI.
We could watch this... or just watch paint dry... Seems about the same level of excitement...
Well there’s no personality in f1 nowadays might as well have AI racing
they look painfully slow
Why stop there, why not have underwater robot races and into the air and then the surface of water and then to outer space.
What’s the point
Keep people busy, spend money. The point of a lot of jobs.
@@Reprint001 watching a pre coded race. What fun
Formula None?
Amazing 😍
So whats the point. No winners, no losers, no competition. Human stupidity reaching new highs
Without Lewis Hamilton? 😂
brilliant, I'd watch this live on an F1 circuit!
OT: Benny Hill considered funnier than Monty Python by two TV stations --WOR and WLVI!
Very interesting, but look at something that affects our communities, like drug dealers!
The future has arrived
Whats the point then?
From the video: "The goal of the project is to advance understanding around vehicle autonomy, with the aim of ultimately making self-driving cars operate more safely at higher speeds." But also, imagine these cars get good enough to beat human world champions, every single time. I would watch the shit out of it
@@GiDaOne
You wouldn't watch the shit out of it, you'd watch it once and then get bored. How often do people watch AI chess tournaments? The feat of engineering is only half of Motorsport, for it to be entertaining you need to see a driver try to wrestle with the power of engineering.
@@Dorgpoop For me it would be amazing to see self-driving cars do things we wouldn't have thought possible with physics, and just get better and better. It would be great to see them compete with humans. Of course, humans bring their personalities and their stories to the sport, something that AI cannot do. But for me it's a different kind of attraction. As for chess, I love to watch AI games too, preferably with expert commentary since some of those ideas are so out of the league of anybody else. And it's also great to see engines compete and overtake each other for the first spot and just get better.
Perfect, less stupid haircuts and virtue signalling
freight
This isn't AI, it's pre-programmed, with sh!tload of sensors that give a certain value, that is then corresponding with the programmed responses to those values... A lot of calculations per second for sure, but AI....no...
The perception uses DNNs and AI sensor fusion algorithms so you don't know what you're talking about.
Aliens 😂
ILFORD
NEWS REPORTER SEEN ILFORD
NEWSREPORTER SMALL INDIAN OLD MAN ON CHAIR MUMBLING
2008-2011
Then there's no point cheering them on. Because "With no driver, no cheering, no enthusiasm". Might as well call this event , "Life Sized Remote Cars Moving". Crowds might as well save their money and buy tickets for real F1 racing. With Drivers.
These are not "Remote Drivers"....the cars are deciding for themselves what lines to take, when to overtake, and when to defend...it would be pretty insane to even imagine humans could control race cars remotely like a RC toy at these speeds.
where‘s the fun?
Into making it work.
Possibly fun for Computer Nerds?
Now, what could be fun is put a high zoot receiver in it, grab a Radio Transmitter & you got one heck of an awesome 1:1 scale competition RC Car. 😁
Lewis Hamilton just got a whole lot cheaper
That is not AI. Those cars are following a highly sophisticated set of instructions. If it was AI, there wouldn't be a young fellow sitting there in a red hooded sweatshirt crouched over a laptop writing code; the car would be teaching itself. And that technology is still some years away.
It's a marketing stunt aimed at promoting the safety of autonomous vehicles? You'll need to have motorcycles, pedestrians and junctions to deliver that message to the families of people already killed by autonomy.
28 January 2024 // 28 January 2024 # // PERSPECTIVE "OUT" // PIC VIEW: 0.33
No human drivers = Insanely boring.
Boycott it 👍 life's so much better with humans
Humans are boring
Doubly so. Indycar = Insanely boring.
People don't want this, they want to see people getting hurt in high speed crashes.
thu cho may chiec nay chay tren duong xa o vit di la biet ngay hay do the nao lien DDD
YAWN
This is not a sport and will never be one. It’s purely a commercialized incentive for engineering schools to advance their research. That’s all.
People only care about racing because the human driver is taking a risk. Remove that risk and you won’t find enough engineers who care to fill the stands. “Robot Wars” was a televised example of how unappealing it is to most.
Lastly, why are we spending TRILLIONS trying to get contemporary tech to work on contemporary roads, when it would only cost billions to embed magnetic sensors into all public roads, eliminating half of the complexity behind automated driving? Current self-driving research is an exercise in stupidity, with everyone trying to Rube Goldberg a solution while ignoring the obvious one.
Also, speed isn’t the danger. It’s the sudden stop at the end that kills, not speed. Differential in speed, combined with slow human reactions, is the danger on public highways. The only way automated driving will work is if all cars use it all the time on highways or you will always have fatal errors
Famously, Elon Musk doesn’t like LIDAR and even removed/disabled RADAR from Teslas, leading to some “interesting” new behaviours in them. 🤔
who needs working, figured out tech, when he can try & reinvent the wheel?! -.-
Whatever. The whole point of motorsport or sport of any kind is direct human participation. This is pointless.
The humans are the students who are programming the AI software...motorsport is as much a team sport as it is centered around drivers...autonomous racing emphasizes the team aspects
@@emmbee6711 Don't give a damn unless the vehicle is actually driven or ridden by a person.
And nobody gives a damn about what you give a damn about @@VinayakPande53
Ai muppets
One of the more stupid things I’ve seen people come up with
only 2 cars per race....boring
Is this sport for nerds?
Fart
Tfou 😢😢😢 vous race
What a load of bollocks
bbc, what if there will be no human viewers of these races?
Boooooooo !!!!!!! This is pointless.
High speed racing cars are a total waste of time, money and energy!
😴😴😴🤡🤡🤡🤡
Why would anybody want to see a race without drivers. I would rather play computer games
This is about as exciting as women's football 😄
Whats the point ? you might as well turn it into 'robot wars' or something cooler , Automatic cars going fast in a big circle with 0 danger is only good for gathering data ...Nobody is gonna get gripped by this
Boring ... Sports without real heroes of flesh & blood.
I already play video games with almost the same perceptions and experience.
High speed?
@@AstroBear11
Considering they're open wheel racing cars going around a circuit with no real corners it's not that fast, especially considering they don't have to worry about safety.
Then I might as well watch a movie about someone racing cars..
Or watch sim racing.
Or Saudi Arabian football.
It would be just as boring
Hmm they found away to make f1 even more boring
This is incredibly dull, where is the excitement? Trust the BBC to promote this garbage.
Will Putin send you golden eggs? He won't do it! He can only give you a gesture! Unfortunately, this gesture cannot replace Golden Egg!
High-speed racing cars are a total waste of time, money and energy !