LIVE: House probes alleged Duterte-China ‘gentleman’s agreement’ | May 21

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 2 жов 2024
  • LIVE: The House of Representatives probes into the alleged gentleman’s agreement between former President Rodrigo Duterte and China regarding the West Philippine Sea on Tuesday, May 21, 2024 | 📹: House of Representatives
    Visit us at www.inquirer.net
    Facebook: / inquirerdotnet
    Twitter: / inquirerdotnet

КОМЕНТАРІ • 940

  • @jorgeamata7139
    @jorgeamata7139 4 місяці тому +96

    If there was an agreement for a status quo during the PNoy admin in 2013, it was already invalidated by the Arbitral ruling from UNCLOS that was obtained by PNoy in 2016. So, any agreement for a status quo entered by PDuterte was clouded by doubt, if not legally null and void. What the Duterte admin should have been done was to enforce the arbitral ruling. That was his responsibility under our constitution as president.

    • @NathaliaGo-k6b
      @NathaliaGo-k6b 4 місяці тому

      Dapat ang ipatawag niyan yung pasimuno former SND delfin lorenzana, Gen. Carlito GalvezGen. andres centeno!
      Lalabas din mga baho nyo!!

    • @graceoropesa791
      @graceoropesa791 4 місяці тому +3

      Exactly

    • @reynosocustodio
      @reynosocustodio 4 місяці тому +1

      A

    • @judalindawelsh6157
      @judalindawelsh6157 4 місяці тому

      16:04

    • @EbonFernando
      @EbonFernando 3 місяці тому +1

      Nag sasayang lang kayo Ng Oras at Pera sa mga hearing nyo? Bat di nyo direct ipatawag si duterte dahil sya lang ang makakapag bigay Ng liwanag sa usaping ito.

  • @JessNazareno-hr3fn
    @JessNazareno-hr3fn 4 місяці тому +29

    I think Justice Antonio Carpio has a good memory about the issue. He fully knows the nuances of the situatio about Ayungin Shoal

    • @regztipz5400
      @regztipz5400 4 місяці тому +1

      isa rin un , , ,

    • @fordymac-zy8ge
      @fordymac-zy8ge 4 місяці тому

      🤣🤣🤣🤣

    • @gregorioempleojr9783
      @gregorioempleojr9783 4 місяці тому

      Inililihis lang ninyo ang tunay na issue dito. Kasi hindi ninyo matutugunan ang mga problema ng bayan. Ang issue ay ang bangag na presidente na ayaw mag pa drug test at ang pdea leaks.

    • @ReneMaghanoy-l7y
      @ReneMaghanoy-l7y 4 місяці тому

      And you believe it

  • @lindoseguritan3187
    @lindoseguritan3187 4 місяці тому +39

    I believe that the best thing to do is to ask the Chinese Ambassador to put in writing what was discussed in the gentleman's agreement meeting with Digong Duterte and Xi Jinping!

    • @markanthonylumaban1238
      @markanthonylumaban1238 4 місяці тому +4

      Meron nga daw Sabi ng ambassador ng China

    • @rexgumban7058
      @rexgumban7058 4 місяці тому +5

      Saan si former president duterte,bakit wala sya?

    • @NathaliaGo-k6b
      @NathaliaGo-k6b 4 місяці тому

      Dapat ang ipatawag niyan yung pasimuno former SND delfin lorenzana, Gen. Carlito GalvezGen. andres centeno!
      Lalabas din mga baho nyo!!

    • @yousufgolle9556
      @yousufgolle9556 4 місяці тому +1

      ​@@rexgumban7058tatlo lang po yan: may respeto sila kay digong or takot sila or hindi na kailangan.

    • @Winph-d4m
      @Winph-d4m 4 місяці тому

      Hindi Kaba nonood Nagyari agreement noong 2013 walang secret agreement walang magawa Si President Duterte kundi sumabagay ng agos para Hindi magkagulo Wala tayong Armas. sos maria

  • @dr.kwik2x537
    @dr.kwik2x537 4 місяці тому +16

    Ipatawag niyo si duterte😂😂😂 para diretso niyo itanong sa kanya kong meron ba or wla

    • @itukmolklix7392
      @itukmolklix7392 4 місяці тому

      Tama yan, tingnan natin kung tunay magtanong ang mga mukhang bading na mga kongresista na ito.

  • @VoletzkySB
    @VoletzkySB 4 місяці тому +82

    Wag ninyong ipasa kay PNoy ang agreement - kc 2016 nanalo tyo sa Arbitral Ruling

    • @debbiedebbie5977
      @debbiedebbie5977 4 місяці тому +4

      Nanalo tayo arbitral sa salita lang

    • @9.1Zie
      @9.1Zie 4 місяці тому +8

      Hello! Itanong mo yan kay Trillianes!

    • @manuelestrella9107
      @manuelestrella9107 4 місяці тому

      Gagabkaba

    • @manuelestrella9107
      @manuelestrella9107 4 місяці тому

      Tumingin ka rin... San tayo ngayun

    • @VoletzkySB
      @VoletzkySB 4 місяці тому +2

      @@manuelestrella9107 ako pa gaga ? Well informed ako noon galing pa ng Philippine Embassy ng Vienna at galing din kay Carpio kc ako ang nag organise ng 2 rallies dito intront of China Embassy at sa UN sa Vienna .
      Bago ko pinasukan yan pinag aralan ko at may pre consultation ako sa Embassy natin ! May mga videos akong ginawa noon about WPS !!!!

  • @LightSayings-kb3xi
    @LightSayings-kb3xi 4 місяці тому +51

    How can Gazmin negotiate disadvantageously when Aquino was filing a case against China?

    • @jenniferinocencio8945
      @jenniferinocencio8945 4 місяці тому +5

      Correct!!

    • @jenniferinocencio8945
      @jenniferinocencio8945 4 місяці тому +4

      Exactly

    • @regsragnarok
      @regsragnarok 4 місяці тому

      Pinaatras daw sila ng America, si Amb Del Rosario ang nagpa atras ng mga barko natin. Yun yata ang utos sa kanya dahil naka file na kaso sa UNCLOS

    • @PuritaBrinas
      @PuritaBrinas 4 місяці тому +3

      Right! Unbelievable!

    • @AngeloFamanilay
      @AngeloFamanilay 4 місяці тому +4

      Parang isinisisi Kay pnoy porke wala na siya…

  • @GracetaManos
    @GracetaManos 4 місяці тому +33

    Why don't you invite the Chinese embassy people.......merpn din statement si Vice Admiral Carlos who is now unavailable

    • @lakwatserongmekaniko5312
      @lakwatserongmekaniko5312 4 місяці тому +4

      hindi daw pwede kz mapapahiya ang current admin kz cla ang may new model agrement😂😂

    • @diosapicache832
      @diosapicache832 4 місяці тому

      ​@@lakwatserongmekaniko5312tsekwaNgaling!!

    • @kaagapay_nyo
      @kaagapay_nyo 4 місяці тому

      ​@@lakwatserongmekaniko5312 makinig ka na lang sa marites. Kung sino ang may gentlemans aggreement. Ang current admin ay lahat ng aggreement ng mga nakaraang admin kung meron man ipinawalang bisa nya hanggang last day nya sa office. 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 nag marites kalang malimali pa...

    • @jugygalalabalan5775
      @jugygalalabalan5775 4 місяці тому

      CHINESE IMBASSY HINDI IYAN CLA MAG-AMIN... KAHIT GUMUHO ANG MUNDO BASTAT MGA SINUNGALING NA MGA CHINESE HINDI IYAN CLA AAMIN... THAT IS THEIR MOTTO NOT TO CONFESS THE TRUTH... THAT IS THEIR REGULATIONS FROM THEIR COUNTRY... 😮

    • @KathDelaCruz-q1n
      @KathDelaCruz-q1n 4 місяці тому

      Dapat ang ipatawag niyan yung pasimuno former SND delfin lorenzana, Gen. Carlito GalvezGen. andres centeno!
      Lalabas din mga baho nyo!!

  • @teacherviolavlogs
    @teacherviolavlogs 4 місяці тому +16

    That could be the reason why PNoy sought for the arbitration. So that we should not ask permission from China to work in our territory. Gazmin might just being diplomatic prior to the decision of the case to avoid escallation if any conflict of unterest

  • @ViCal-sz7th
    @ViCal-sz7th 4 місяці тому +29

    To : Philippines Legislature both lower and senate, don’t waste your time about gentleman!a agreement. Nobody is strong enough to admit mistakes. Instead strengthen our lawful claims with documents available to support our claims and make it known to all countries and possible trusted countries for development.

    • @madzbautista6391
      @madzbautista6391 4 місяці тому +3

      You are very right waste if time and money talk about economy and works that the pilipino needed not that none sence agreement.

    • @asidjw
      @asidjw 4 місяці тому +1

      Ang mahal ng mga bilihin dapat yan nalng unahin nila and help the farmers to promote locally produce vegetables/fruits etc.

    • @RolandRivera-hx2lj
      @RolandRivera-hx2lj 3 місяці тому

      Yes there's more gentle leaders of nations support favor for the Philippines since then up to present especially the UNCLOS favors arbitrary ruling as aprove at the Hague.. In favor to the Philippines..

  • @consuelocorpuz5554
    @consuelocorpuz5554 4 місяці тому +45

    Bakit kaya parang halos lahat ng mga humaharap sa hearing parang May mga amnesia

    • @philipanselmomixtv217
      @philipanselmomixtv217 4 місяці тому +3

      Tulad rin sa hearing ni Bato,ang taga PDEA,si Ochoa at si Maricel Soriano ay biglang nagka amnesia😂

    • @rodrigobattad7755
      @rodrigobattad7755 4 місяці тому

      weeehh puro hersey nman kc samantala yon tinatanung ehh may pisition sa nakaraan na administration​@@philipanselmomixtv217

    • @cgm_76
      @cgm_76 4 місяці тому +14

      ​@@philipanselmomixtv217parang di naman nagka amnesia si Maricel at ochoa.nasagot nilang dalawa ang tanong. Wala ako nadinig na sinabi ni Maricel na hindi k maalala.

    • @patriciajm1535
      @patriciajm1535 4 місяці тому +5

      ​​@@cgm_76hnd na maalala ni Maricel na vangag cya

    • @cgm_76
      @cgm_76 4 місяці тому +10

      @@patriciajm1535 tinanong ba sya ng ganon di ba hindi naman. Kaya di nya linyahan yung "di ko na po maalala "na linya ni Guo at Morales. Sila yung mga nagka amnesia.

  • @lawrencesantaana3901
    @lawrencesantaana3901 4 місяці тому +3

    REAL TALK:BAKIT HINDI NYO INIMBITA SI DUTERTE,SYA ANG INDESPENSABLE RESOURCE PERSON SA HEARING NA IYAN,DAHIL SYA ANG MAY PERSONAL KNOWLEDGE SA AGREEMENT SA CHINA.🤑

  • @GracetaManos
    @GracetaManos 4 місяці тому +18

    Also invite Trillanes who went to China for more than 30x

    • @kuerttv2601
      @kuerttv2601 4 місяці тому +1

      may resibo ka ba na pumunta si trillans sa china kung meron dapat ipatawag karin 😂😂😂😂😂

    • @regztipz5400
      @regztipz5400 4 місяці тому +6

      ​@@kuerttv2601resibo ba hanap mu , , , kaya nag walk out sa tanung ni Enrile , , kc wala cyang masagot , , tinanung lang cya bakit pa balik balik cya sa china sabay walk out , , , kc hnd nya inasahan itanung ni enreli , hnd pa naka gawa ng script sa sagot , walk out muna baka magka mali sa sagot

    • @user-mj8zf4qq7u
      @user-mj8zf4qq7u 4 місяці тому

      Bakit hindi pina imbestiga ni Digong si Trillanes? Dahil parehas silang tuta

    • @rainbow33404
      @rainbow33404 3 місяці тому

      So what are you trying to say?

    • @cesartelen8948
      @cesartelen8948 2 місяці тому

      e invite nyo si sundalong kanin 16x yung nagpunta sa china

  • @donndelfin1312
    @donndelfin1312 4 місяці тому +6

    pasalamat kayo sa Sierra Madre pasalamat kayo kay Erap at DND Sec. Mercado sila ang matapang na nag lagay nyan dyan kahit nagagalit ang China.

  • @melanieazada6386
    @melanieazada6386 4 місяці тому +8

    la ninyo na hindi kayo sa isang tao nanunungkulan kundi sa taong bayan kaya please lang wag mo ng ipagtanggol si Duterte.

    • @debbiedebbie5977
      @debbiedebbie5977 4 місяці тому

      Dapat lang ipagtanggol c duterte wala namang nangyayaring bombahan ng tubig noong c duterte

    • @tragicevans4157
      @tragicevans4157 4 місяці тому

      Haha buma backfire ba boss? 2013 pa pala Yan panahon ni Pinoy.

    • @Marlon-yc5ld
      @Marlon-yc5ld 4 місяці тому

      Detected n trillanes may alam Yan dahil sila ay gentlemen sila da galaw at bunganga...gud agrimint...ha ha

    • @Marlon-yc5ld
      @Marlon-yc5ld 4 місяці тому

      Duterte..

    • @Marlon-yc5ld
      @Marlon-yc5ld 4 місяці тому

      ...sayang lang ang time nyo mga folks...communist mindset dapat pag aralan nyo po...

  • @rodolfoolmoguez3124
    @rodolfoolmoguez3124 4 місяці тому +2

    It is but necessary to invite the officials of the officials of the Aquino Administration to give light to what kind of agreement tbey entered into with the chinese government for clarification.

  • @SavetheSharks007
    @SavetheSharks007 4 місяці тому +6

    Correction please😮 the erbitral ruling never stated as to who owns what..it only ruled that the nine dash line that china is not valid as far ss the unclos is concernd😮fyi

  • @joebensalem1987
    @joebensalem1987 4 місяці тому +2

    ISA LANG PO ANG IBIG SABIHIN NYAN... ANG MGA KONGESMAN NGAYON AY MAHILIG MANIWALA SA MGA MARITES😂😂😂😂

    • @roseannetalavera3913
      @roseannetalavera3913 4 місяці тому

      Teodoro umpisa yan dapat patawag nila sec.defence dfa ngayon at roque bbm pati pres.duterte
      Mag kaalaman n. Sinabe ng china diba pag ginalaw sea bed west philippines sea mag kagulo. Ano gagawin mo bilang presidente pinas tumahimik s ngayon kse d kaya bansa natin maki gera ano panama mo military china pangalawa sila mataas alam nmn asa k s america dame problema pinasok nila andiya ukraine estrael iran p ano at taiwan sagipin tayo nila ano superman america. Kaya manahimik palakasin natin military defence natin.

  • @mrhanchan
    @mrhanchan 4 місяці тому +7

    Na utal utal ka ngayon Cong Castro sa sagot ni Gen Espiron. Kinilabotan ka sa sinabe ni PRRD. The best parin PRRD. 👊👊👊

    • @romeocaldillero
      @romeocaldillero 4 місяці тому

      Hahaha the most corrupt and murderer, Shabu Davao lord and dirty mouthed. What qualification are you basing on your impression? The ICC coming action substantially prove his criminal liabilities! Gising na kabayan. Huwag Pepe bingi at bulag

    • @blessica-l2g
      @blessica-l2g 4 місяці тому

      the best sinungalng na president ever.. no to DUTAE again..

  • @alenetan2466
    @alenetan2466 4 місяці тому +11

    Hope this hearing is not a white wash of what Harry Roque state as during Duterte time na may gentlemans agreement.

    • @GawisYDagem
      @GawisYDagem 4 місяці тому +5

      Malinaw naman na ang sinasabing Gentlemans Agreement ay ang "Agreed Status Quo by both party"

    • @regsragnarok
      @regsragnarok 4 місяці тому

      Walang whitewash dyan kasi gusto nila magkaroon sila na makita na pagkakamali ng past administration kaso wala talaga kasi kung meron, documented lahat.

    • @Ehvtesha78
      @Ehvtesha78 4 місяці тому +2

      gusto niyo lng gisahin mga tao kc na reveal ang New Model niyo

  • @junl8376
    @junl8376 4 місяці тому +1

    Can anyone explain why the house seal is leaning to the right? Ask ko lang...

  • @junnetpascual9836
    @junnetpascual9836 4 місяці тому +7

    china even don't follow the status quo they destroy our bajo de masinlok building a man made island and assuming it's theirs only their fisherman are allowed and not our filipino fisherman when in fact they should not be because it is our west philippine sea

  • @GracetaManos
    @GracetaManos 4 місяці тому +9

    Invite DFA officials concerned both current amd past administrations (imcluding Noynoy Aquino's time)

    • @daisysee2935
      @daisysee2935 4 місяці тому

      nagawa na ni Pres Pnoy ang dapat nya gawin… july yun , nanalo na si Duterte, ano nga ginawa nila? truth will still prevail.

  • @Ehvtesha78
    @Ehvtesha78 4 місяці тому +5

    ano bang gusto niyong gawin e may new model nman ang PBBM ADMIN kalokohan

  • @MarcusAntoninusPandes
    @MarcusAntoninusPandes 4 місяці тому +2

    Gazmin is being pinned by Medialdea is a passing the ball.

  • @virgiliobrosoto
    @virgiliobrosoto 4 місяці тому +4

    Sa meron man o walang gentleman’s agreement Ang kinarroonan ng barkong siera madre ay ating NASA’da kupan kaya yun Ang ating dapat ipaglaban sa mga switik na intsik.

  • @RolandoRelucio
    @RolandoRelucio 4 місяці тому +1

    Ano po ba ang ibig sabihin ng Secret Deal?Kailangan siguro invite the person involve.

  • @melanieazada6386
    @melanieazada6386 4 місяці тому +4

    agsabi na kasi kayo ng tutoo at wag na nonyong ipagtanggol ang may sala!!!!!

  • @JoseHermosa-b1h
    @JoseHermosa-b1h 4 місяці тому +2

    How come it did not go through the House of Representative and the Senate!
    What was agreed upon if it is true, it is/was UNCONSTITUTIONAl!!!!!!!’n

  • @thecritics5831
    @thecritics5831 4 місяці тому +4

    Matikas talaga mga secretary ni prrd

  • @magsaysaysabang6732
    @magsaysaysabang6732 4 місяці тому +2

    Wait nyo c roque kundi tameme kayo lahat jan

    • @watiwatdavygie71702
      @watiwatdavygie71702 4 місяці тому

      Kaya nga e...Ibang iba kse ang former cab.sec mga Atty at PMaErs

    • @blessica-l2g
      @blessica-l2g 4 місяці тому

      tameme? tameme dahil sa mga kasinungalingan nyang statement? o come on, wg na mgpaloko sa butanding na yan..

  • @NoorMohammad-ih7bk
    @NoorMohammad-ih7bk 4 місяці тому +7

    🫵🏻Dito natin malalaman kung anong level ang IQ ng mga nagtatanong(representatives)at sa mga resource person..👈🏻

    • @ryannah78
      @ryannah78 4 місяці тому

      Korek! 😂😂 nagpakulaw sa ilng self..ipatawsg nila si prrd atong ma supalpal ang mga nagmamarumong😂😂

  • @rodolfoolmoguez3124
    @rodolfoolmoguez3124 4 місяці тому +1

    You have to invite also the chinese representative together with harry roque to have a substantial argument in your investigation.

  • @JosephEntero-yb1sy
    @JosephEntero-yb1sy 4 місяці тому +14

    Even if there was a gentleman's agreement, the same is not valid and binding to the Philippines. The President has already stated that he does not recognize it; if there is any, he rescinds it. So, why bother investigate? Matutuwa lang ang China that Congress reacted about its announcement.

    • @magdalenavillanueva8951
      @magdalenavillanueva8951 4 місяці тому

      correct mga uto uto nmn mga senador na to hindi nga kinilala ni digong ang arbitral na yan isang papel lang daw yan pinaka ob ob si duterte na presidente..sa pinas...traidor sa bansa

    • @maviccalibara3625
      @maviccalibara3625 4 місяці тому

      Trap lang yan para ipit8n Aarestohin lang nla Duterte

    • @romeocaldillero
      @romeocaldillero 4 місяці тому +1

      The effect of the so called gentleman’s agreement which was not to repair the sierra madre or to withdraw is almost happening

    • @eddieking1778
      @eddieking1778 3 місяці тому

      Previous administration if Duterte vibal secret gentleman agreement it not valid n yet it must clarify by Duterte in senate hearing n china empassy to face each other?

  • @fudsamp0426
    @fudsamp0426 4 місяці тому +2

    you are wasting people's money to this non sense hearing!

  • @joeyiguban8428
    @joeyiguban8428 3 місяці тому +1

    Ay nako aksayalang kayo ng oras mag stick natayo sa pag award ng international arbitrial rolling kaya e rebook na yang mga gentleman agreement.

  • @Haida011
    @Haida011 4 місяці тому +12

    Dapat imbestigahan din yung new model ni pbbm MAs malala yun 😂

    • @soniadarnayla7917
      @soniadarnayla7917 4 місяці тому

      Talaga lng?? Mga tso ni fentagong nakipa usap..kung.meron.man...😅

    • @soniadarnayla7917
      @soniadarnayla7917 4 місяці тому

      Binenta na wps kya vhina nasusunod😡😡

    • @Mariasarah129
      @Mariasarah129 4 місяці тому

      Humarap ka sa salamin tapos sampalin mo 😂😂😂

    • @asuncional
      @asuncional 4 місяці тому

      Naniwala ka naman sa new model?

    • @asuncional
      @asuncional 4 місяці тому

      Si duterte nga lang ang may gentlemens aggrenent. Kaya hindi alam ng mga tso niya

  • @RodolfoArcilla-zw4ug
    @RodolfoArcilla-zw4ug 4 місяці тому +3

    Ano kaya mangyayari pagkatapos ng imbestigasyon..positive/negative ang result..WALA DIN....

    • @LjenJulianYson
      @LjenJulianYson 4 місяці тому

      ZERO BALANCE..WALA NAMAN NANNGYAYARI SA MGA GINAGAWA NILANG IMBESTIGASYON.MASKI NOON..

  • @lindadelosreyes2310
    @lindadelosreyes2310 4 місяці тому +6

    Did the Duterte administration ever find out whether there was actually an agreement or not? Hindi ba tinanong man lamang ni Duterte from Aquino if there was an agreement? And granted that there was an agreement in 2013, but we won the Arbitral ruling. In that is the case, it was clear that the West Phil. Sea belongs to us. Therefore the previous agreement no longer holds true.

    • @lycheetychee1702
      @lycheetychee1702 4 місяці тому

      C Duterte lng Ang gumawa noon gusto lng ipasa Ang sisi k Pinoy c Pinoy nga Ang lumaban s china,sya Ang ngpanalo n s pilipinas Ang WPS n binalewala n digong Kasi tuta sya ng china

    • @regztipz5400
      @regztipz5400 4 місяці тому +4

      WPS hnd po yan sa atin, , , , may vietnam taiwan indo china , , , , , kung mapa alis mu lahat yan atin na ang wps , ,

    • @fordymac-zy8ge
      @fordymac-zy8ge 4 місяці тому +1

      korek maraming claimant yan ang mahirap!

    • @sun2356
      @sun2356 4 місяці тому +2

      The other problem was china didn’t recognized that ruling so if that time du30 admin choose to repair the sierra madre it will be disaster to us that’s why du30 improve the military power of PH by buying those military equipment. If you insisting that ruling is ours why MARCOS DIDINT FIX the VESSEL OF SIERRA MADRE now we have AMERICANS BASES RIGHT now so why DIDINT FIX it NOW?

    • @ahnsarambot9964
      @ahnsarambot9964 4 місяці тому

      Ang WPS ay ang portion ng karagatan sa South China Sea.Na sakop mg atin exclusive economic zone na 200 nautical miles mula sa mainland na kalupaan ng pilipinas.Kaya hindi mo pwd sabihin na hindi sa atin iyan.

  • @roseannetalavera3913
    @roseannetalavera3913 4 місяці тому +2

    Diba kita sinabe ng china january 2024. Gentle agreement bbm

    • @anitacalautit4649
      @anitacalautit4649 4 місяці тому

      Pordios kong ano ano nlang

    • @watiwatdavygie71702
      @watiwatdavygie71702 4 місяці тому

      May model agreement namn ngayun si PbBM sa China..ayun ata yung na wire tap na balita

  • @tpain5
    @tpain5 4 місяці тому +4

    Ayan kasi...ano kayo ngayon mga Tonggressman..

  • @franciscogamus8507
    @franciscogamus8507 4 місяці тому +17

    Savethsharkes007. The arbitral ruling stated that our country has sovereign rights in our EEZ in the West Philippine Sea. The 9 dash line which China claims has no basis. You sound like a China mouthpiece or know nothing about the 2016 arbitral rulling. Stop confusing people.

    • @guardianmindanao2.058
      @guardianmindanao2.058 4 місяці тому +4

      Know the difference between sovereign rights & sovereign territory. EEZ is not territory but only economic rights.

    • @mercyojerio290
      @mercyojerio290 4 місяці тому +3

      rights and sovereignty are not the same. we aren't the only country who claims it. DISPUTED AS IT IS.

    • @franciscogamus8507
      @franciscogamus8507 4 місяці тому +2

      In our EEZ that is 200 nautical mines from our mainland, we exclusively enjoy its economic resources, there in that area we enjoy the exclusive right to exploit its resources, therefore no country can dictate us on what to to with our EEZ. It is an irony some of our countrymen are ignorant about this.9

    • @aritaofarmervlog9253
      @aritaofarmervlog9253 4 місяці тому

      Khit ilang beses mong sabihin na nanalo ang pinas sa arbitral ruling, sa di nga tinatangap ng Chinese ang arbitral ruling na yan, ...sabihin mo nlang nag sampa ang pinas sa u n.. ang respondent ay china ngaun di umatend ang china sa hearing,,,, den all of the sudden nag roll l out ang u n , na nanalo ang pinas sa arbitral ruling na di man lang nakuha ang panig ng respondent,(china) kong ikaw na respondent tatanggapin mo nlang ba basta basta na ikaw ay natalo .... Dmo ba ipag lalaban din ang claims mo..lalo na ikaw na bansa eh high tech na ang mga kagamitan at almost kumpleto kna sa gamit na kahit magkaroon ng geyera dmo ba ilalaban din ang rights mo ... Kaya ngaun ganyan ang china palaban

    • @pamdecena4742
      @pamdecena4742 4 місяці тому

      when was the eez granted to pH?, how did it came about?, is it acknowledged by ASEAN? ​@@franciscogamus8507

  • @jesusvaldez2336
    @jesusvaldez2336 3 місяці тому

    The right track is to submit resibo

  • @melanieazada6386
    @melanieazada6386 4 місяці тому +4

    Generaloremzana you are a respected military man ang we hope that you still nkow the Rule of payriotism!!!!!

  • @mommyworks287
    @mommyworks287 4 місяці тому +1

    Bakit Kaya biglang kulang sa conviction mga kasagutan Ng DOJ Representative kaysa sa kahapon..🤔

  • @bernietapinz
    @bernietapinz 4 місяці тому +14

    How come there was..?? When both are.. not gentlement..why discuss gentleman agreement , such agreement if there was ., is null and void because we won on UNCLOS..

    • @ranzkenmangubat-r7m
      @ranzkenmangubat-r7m 4 місяці тому +1

      Kagagawan lang yan sa tamaan ni polboron🤣🤣🤣dati wala pang Eleksyon kakampi pero nong nanalo na, wala mga trydor...

    • @daisychavez9356
      @daisychavez9356 4 місяці тому +1

      Kayo ba ang involve sa gentlemen agreement ? C duterte tanungin,i think you need to go home

  • @GracetaManos
    @GracetaManos 4 місяці тому +2

    PBBM rescinded everything even not knowing what these ahreements he rescinded.

  • @noelqtv2280
    @noelqtv2280 4 місяці тому +3

    Yong new model secret agreement ang imbistigahan nyo kasi mas malala

  • @WilfredoRuiz-ex6qk
    @WilfredoRuiz-ex6qk 4 місяці тому +2

    I like to Congress mag imbestegation kay sa mga senador...

  • @Maai.C.P
    @Maai.C.P 4 місяці тому +7

    Mas magaling talaga taga congress kesa senate

    • @January0915
      @January0915 3 місяці тому

      Oo nga. Kaya nga d nalalaman nang taongbayan kung san napupunta Ang budget nang congress. Pakapalan eh😂😂😂

  • @GTV-jm2np
    @GTV-jm2np 4 місяці тому

    Sana makakuha tayo ng hustisya sa traidor ng bansa natin..

  • @Mju629
    @Mju629 4 місяці тому +3

    Pag usapan nyo klng mga sir kung paano matulungan mngisda ang kbbyan nteng mga Pilipino . hirap npo silang pumalaot

  • @hermied2708
    @hermied2708 4 місяці тому

    dapat lang marefair ang sieramadre para maging maganda ang anyo ng barko at para magamit pa ng mahabang panahon

  • @ened1299
    @ened1299 4 місяці тому +4

    SANA magkaroon din ng WIRE TAPPING hearing tungkol sa ADMIN.

    • @diosapicache832
      @diosapicache832 4 місяці тому

      Tsismosa! 😂

    • @georgevictorcabasa4204
      @georgevictorcabasa4204 4 місяці тому

      Bbm at china hindi mag kaibigan. Duterte at xi jin ping BEST FRIENDS cla ang may agreement. Kung cnu ang nag aakusa kay pbbm un ang may gawa . DRUG LORD

  • @GracetaManos
    @GracetaManos 4 місяці тому +2

    Why don't you invite the Chinese embassy people.......merpn din statement si Vice Admiral Carlos who is now unavailable

  • @4Boy64
    @4Boy64 4 місяці тому +3

    Mahirap mag imbistiga pag walang katutuhanan..gusto lng siraan si ex.prrd basi sa mga sismosong .politico..

  • @robertcabalquinto8399
    @robertcabalquinto8399 4 місяці тому +1

    Nag sisinungaling si former es

  • @outtube56789
    @outtube56789 4 місяці тому +7

    what a waste of time and money tong mga crocodile congressman.

    • @anitacalautit4649
      @anitacalautit4649 4 місяці тому +2

      Ha ha ha di mas lalo doon sa pdea hearing ni bato ang wasting time

  • @skydanceritmo8970
    @skydanceritmo8970 4 місяці тому

    napaka simple ipatawag nyo lahat ng involve magharap harap sila dyan 🤷🏻‍♂️ we need to know as a filipino
    citizen 🤷🏻‍♂️

  • @RickBugayong
    @RickBugayong 4 місяці тому +4

    Why not prioritize changing the leadership of lower chamber as well for the common good

  • @reynaldoambrocio6281
    @reynaldoambrocio6281 4 місяці тому

    At sa mga nakaparti na
    Opisyal

  • @lindadelosreyes2310
    @lindadelosreyes2310 4 місяці тому +3

    If Gen Gazmin is invited, perhaps the Executive Secretary andx DFA Sec of then Pres. Aquino shound be invited too.

  • @edgarcampos4362
    @edgarcampos4362 4 місяці тому +1

    Mismo ang China Embassy ang nagsasabi na mayrong Gentledog's Agreement of previous Adninistration.

  • @GawisYDagem
    @GawisYDagem 4 місяці тому +3

    The agreement of STATUS QUO is what Atty. Roque is referring to.

  • @quiricotupingan1173
    @quiricotupingan1173 4 місяці тому

    Bakit di imbitahan si roque, Digong at chinese ambassador ng China pra malaman kung meron nga agreement

  • @magsaysaysabang6732
    @magsaysaysabang6732 4 місяці тому +9

    Ang dami nila mgtulong tulong ang sisipag basta duterte ang topic

    • @lycheetychee1702
      @lycheetychee1702 4 місяці тому

      Dahil lahat ng problema lumalakatiwalian dang kit Ang Chinese o china ay dumami at nmayagpag s panahon n Duterte hnggang ngaun ,tuta ng china

    • @regztipz5400
      @regztipz5400 4 місяці тому

      objective dyan hnd ang agreement kung hnd ang masiraan ang mga du30 , , too lng wala naman kwnta yang pinag usapan nila dyan verbal nila narinig d verbal din ang result , , ,

    • @watiwatdavygie71702
      @watiwatdavygie71702 4 місяці тому +3

      Syempre paano n amg pondo s bayan nila ...alam n this

  • @joeymodi2328
    @joeymodi2328 4 місяці тому +6

    Will this hearing solve the WPS issue?

    • @philipanselmomixtv217
      @philipanselmomixtv217 4 місяці тому +4

      Hindi...dahil, hindi kinilala ng China ang arbitral ruling

    • @joebensalem1987
      @joebensalem1987 4 місяці тому

      NO, IT WILL NOT SOLVE THE ISSUE IN WPS. WHY? SOME CONGRESMEN JUST TO MAKE "PABANGO" TO THE PRESENT GOVERNMENT TO HAVE MORE ELECTION FUND...😂😂😂😂
      PORKET NABANGGIT LANG SA INTERVIEW NG ISANG DATING SPOX.. PINATULAN NA... IN OTHER WORDS "TSISMIS"😂😂😂😂

    • @whitehairedspecs
      @whitehairedspecs 4 місяці тому

      para maliwanag kung kaninong administration at sino ang kumausap sa chinese government para dyan sa "gentleman's deal" recorded naman yan.

    • @joeymodi2328
      @joeymodi2328 4 місяці тому

      And...Kung naka-record what else is there to prove? Past administration, Aquino through Trillanes, went on a mission. See what happened, evidently, now.
      This, to me, is another exercise of blaming someone, and maliciously throwing dirt.

    • @fordymac-zy8ge
      @fordymac-zy8ge 4 місяці тому

      tama! yon mahirap jan dahil may claim din ang China sa lugar!

  • @ntagoncillo
    @ntagoncillo 4 місяці тому +2

    As fqr as i can remember..duterte mentioned to xi jin ping about the WPS sovereignty and pres xi jin ping said " that will be a problem/trouble" as stated by duterte

  • @Phejay-z1d
    @Phejay-z1d 4 місяці тому +4

    Tama nga Nag e imbestigasyon sila sa maling termino...hahahaha Hearsay...

    • @AceYorkForonda
      @AceYorkForonda 4 місяці тому

      that is not hearsay, because there is letter coming from China embassy and there is admission coming from previous officials to support the claims..

    • @Phejay-z1d
      @Phejay-z1d 4 місяці тому

      @@AceYorkForonda so naniniwala kana ngayon sa China?

    • @BobbieAwAw
      @BobbieAwAw 4 місяці тому

      ​@@AceYorkForonda lol mas naniwala kpa sa China

    • @AceYorkForonda
      @AceYorkForonda 4 місяці тому

      nabasa mo ba comment ko, admission coming from PREVIOUS ADMIN AND CHINA, my God dali namang intindihin eh

    • @AceYorkForonda
      @AceYorkForonda 4 місяці тому

      hearsay pa ba sayo yan kung may pag-amin naman galing sa kanila

  • @lolitacummings1648
    @lolitacummings1648 2 місяці тому +1

    Formula 112024 happybirthday americathephillipine❤

  • @ermelovertucio9318
    @ermelovertucio9318 4 місяці тому +9

    Very emphatic reaction, comments & real talk lang from you Tamzky! Thanks, Keep going !

  • @elizabueno3995
    @elizabueno3995 3 місяці тому

    ALLAN CAYETANO IS WITH RO DUTERTE AS WE HEARD, BAKIT HINDI TANUNGIN HE IS THE FOREIGN AFFAIRS!

  • @GracetaManos
    @GracetaManos 4 місяці тому +3

    Maintained due to status quo agreed upon

  • @itukmolklix7392
    @itukmolklix7392 4 місяці тому +1

    NPA nagtatanong sa mga dating kawal heneral ng bansa! Kangaroo court!

  • @magsaysaysabang6732
    @magsaysaysabang6732 4 місяці тому +8

    Wait nyo c roque kundi tameme kayo lahat jan

    • @rappdiver
      @rappdiver 4 місяці тому +2

      Kakainin Yan lahat ni roque,😂😂,.pinipilit na e Sisi LAHAT sa duterte admin..😂😂

    • @rosalindacatubig4246
      @rosalindacatubig4246 4 місяці тому +4

      Madaldal lang si roque kaya dami mga sinasabi hindi angkop sa subject

    • @rosalindacatubig4246
      @rosalindacatubig4246 4 місяці тому

      ​@@rappdivertotoo naman panahon ni duterte nangyari ang gentleman's agreement at roque ang ng sabi niyan mayron video pro duterte ka siguro kaya yan ang comment mo anyway, ICC WARRANT IS COMING hope ipagtatangol mo si duterte at kanyang mga alipores

    • @rosalindacatubig4246
      @rosalindacatubig4246 4 місяці тому +3

      I don't think so tameme silang lahat mga lawyers din yan sila only that neophyte pa pero tingin ko may mga ibubuga sila

    • @rosalindacatubig4246
      @rosalindacatubig4246 4 місяці тому

      ​@@rappdivercannibal na pala si roque kumakain na ng mga congresista kaya huwag mo ipagyabang si roque mga lawyers din yan pinag sabihin mo kakainin lang sila hindi lang si roque ang may ibubuga

  • @geminianomaurejr7399
    @geminianomaurejr7399 4 місяці тому +3

    Hehe.iwas pusoy ang pervious officer.obviously nman,ngsabi ang china na may gentlemans aggreement.dpt imbetahan ang china embassy opisyal din

    • @philipanselmomixtv217
      @philipanselmomixtv217 4 місяці тому +2

      Iwas pusoy ngah sina Teodoro na may "new model" agreement kung di pa inanunsiyo ng Chinese Embassy wala tayong ka alam-alam😂

  • @watiwatdavygie71702
    @watiwatdavygie71702 4 місяці тому +1

    Feeling matalino itong Tongressman .kailangan galingan nya magtanong utos ni Tamba yan..ksamahan yan ni Nograles nung nagtatanong sa SMNI staff haha

  • @SoniaBogarin-iu7yq
    @SoniaBogarin-iu7yq 4 місяці тому +3

    This must be done earlier hearing on secret deal and gentlemens agreement

  • @Clipsinbitz
    @Clipsinbitz 4 місяці тому +2

    If there was a gentlemen’s agreement did we lost an inch of our territory.. and what about your new model agreement why are you denying it

  • @JunVillaLlamera
    @JunVillaLlamera 4 місяці тому +6

    Parang aksaya ng pera at panahon tong hearing na ito . Pwedi ba sa mga issue ng siguridad , drugs ,at kahirapan ang kanilang bigyang pansin baga purely politicking most ang issue ba gets ko.

    • @cordfalsado1928
      @cordfalsado1928 4 місяці тому +5

      This is a must to investigate kabayan since it concerned of our sovereign rights, our fishing rights within our EEZ and as well the Oil and Gas Exploration within our EEZ.
      Please be informed that Malampaya will only be last on 2027 kaya need to exhaust na other sources such as Reed Bank which again allegedly China was having interest also.

    • @pamdecena4742
      @pamdecena4742 4 місяці тому

      ​@@cordfalsado1928ay ang malampaya po up and running naman, lam nyo po kung kanino nabigay ang project?, sa mga aboitiz for the next 15 years, no bidding Yun and Alam nyo din?, syempre pag private partnership with government, ang mag popondo gobyerno in the form of a loan 😑, yan ang leadership ni BBM, pabor sa lahat ng gusto nyang bigyan wag lang sa taumbayan, kasi baka lumakas ang mga Pilipino pag nakakakain ng sapat at may sustansya, hindi pde yun, dapat manatili ang taumbayan na patay gutom at mangmang, yung antay biyaya lang, dapat masaya na sa ayuda 😶

    • @Mariasarah129
      @Mariasarah129 4 місяці тому +1

      GRABE SA TA..NGA...HOY ..BUONG BANSA SINASAKOP NA INSTIK TULOG KA BA LASING O BALIW

    • @pamdecena4742
      @pamdecena4742 4 місяці тому

      @@Mariasarah129 asan???, ano naman mapala nila kung sakupin tayo?, puro base na ng amerika ang tinayo, hala tingin mo sa mga Kano singit?, ayayay🤭😶

  • @CUTIEbetrice12
    @CUTIEbetrice12 4 місяці тому

    Dapat ipatawag si Roque siya ang nag expose ng Gentleman Agreement siya ang may alam

  • @jongayala4911
    @jongayala4911 4 місяці тому +5

    Yan ang magigiting na leaders ng Duterte admin. Solid Duterte.

    • @watiwatdavygie71702
      @watiwatdavygie71702 4 місяці тому

      Mas gusto ko ang mga cabinet sec ng previous Admin...mga Atty at PMAers.....

  • @dominiclebadesos2220
    @dominiclebadesos2220 4 місяці тому +1

    Secret agreement ng Marcos admis ang dapat imbestigasyon.

  • @toxtrillanos4185
    @toxtrillanos4185 4 місяці тому +2

    Whether or not there was a commitment by former Sec Voltaire Gazmin to deliver only food & water to Ayungin agrounded Sierra Madre is immaterial,in fact a "NON SIQUITOR" forn three (3) irrefutable reasons,asf:
    1. The disputed territory falls within Ph EEZ, & therefore sovereignty resides to Filipinos, and as decidrd by UNCLOS tribunal. Sovereigntybis absolute, and non-negotiable as per constitutional & political principles,
    2. NO other authority holds the power to commit or allow, much less cipher foreign policy; including to rescind whatever related comity existed,not even a Defence Secretary...but only the President.
    3. Predecessor's admin's comity can at any point be rescinded,abolished,or vanguished by a new sitting president with the imprimatur of Senate,
    4. Even granting arguendo there really was a "Gentleman's Agreement";as China cajoled, it barked only the silhouetes of the moon,precisely because the now sitting President has publicly RESCINDED" it.

  • @JaphetJadulco-nl4oo
    @JaphetJadulco-nl4oo 4 місяці тому +3

    Mayroon palang NEW MODEL agreement si Bbm ,dapat imbistigahan ito,pagtratraydor ito!😮

    • @georgevictorcabasa4204
      @georgevictorcabasa4204 4 місяці тому

      Meron ba ? Ano un? C bbm di kaibigan ng china kaya walang agreement . C duterte best friend niya c c jin ping kaya cla may agreement .

    • @gloriakobayashi8979
      @gloriakobayashi8979 4 місяці тому

      Huwag mong ilipat ang sakit toxic ng digong mo faked news,! How can BBM can have a new agreement when previous agreement is not been cleared between china and digong,?

  • @jaimeuy2866
    @jaimeuy2866 4 місяці тому +1

    Sana MAGTAGALOG kayo.. kaSI ang issue na discussion ninyo ay very important sa MGA PILIPINO.. lahat naman kayo ay Pilipino - for sure marunong kayong lahat sa ating sariling WIKA -TAGALOG !!! Hindi po Engles..

  • @renz5300
    @renz5300 4 місяці тому +5

    2013 administration nangyari ang aggreement. Pero ang gustong kausapin at imbestigahan 2016-2022 na administration. Parang mali.

  • @balbinobenitez5967
    @balbinobenitez5967 4 місяці тому +2

    Hindi nyo pwde pakialaman ang foreign policy ng President

    • @oriemcewen435
      @oriemcewen435 4 місяці тому

      True! Foreign policy of the President is only good during his term. After his term is done his foreign policies are no longer good.

  • @manuelballega2986
    @manuelballega2986 4 місяці тому +4

    How about the agreement ng Marcos admi may voice call Yan dapat investigation

  • @rodrigobattad7755
    @rodrigobattad7755 4 місяці тому +1

    sinabi lng trouble natakot na hehe akla ko matapang yon idol nila

  • @balbinobenitez5967
    @balbinobenitez5967 4 місяці тому +12

    Imbestigahan nyo angNewModel Agreement ni PBBM

    • @agentvoid6692
      @agentvoid6692 4 місяці тому

      Hindi with PBBM ang claim ng China na kausap nila sa alleged leaked convo re: the New Model..it was with then AFP Wescom Vice Admiral Alberto Carlos daw kaya nga sya pinalitann ni Alfonso Torres nung May 7th dahil sa ongoing investigation.
      Kaya nga ang nilalaban ng current administration na granting na authentic ang conversatuion bet China & former Vice Admiral Alberto Carlos, hindi din pwede maging legally binding since walang ibang pwede makipag agreement kundi ang President lang.
      Again, ang alleged na kausap DAW e si Mr Carlos not PBBM...

    • @fhel1224
      @fhel1224 4 місяці тому +2

      Korek pilit nilang didiin si duterte e wala nga status quo nga..

    • @rosalindacatubig4246
      @rosalindacatubig4246 4 місяці тому

      Not true china lang ng sabi niyan mayron new model agreement pinapasama lang si PBBM

    • @user-mj8zf4qq7u
      @user-mj8zf4qq7u 4 місяці тому +2

      ano ang iimbestigahan kung wala naman talagang agreement??

    • @joemarielibo-on3527
      @joemarielibo-on3527 4 місяці тому

      Nilimit nla gang duterte term lng daw, napasobra si Castro

  • @Delio-cj9ss
    @Delio-cj9ss 4 місяці тому +1

    Bakit di ipitawag up Ang maglinaw si Voltaire gasmin tungkol sa issue Ng agreement kung totoo at sinong nagdesisyon para usaping iyon

  • @roseannetalavera3913
    @roseannetalavera3913 4 місяці тому +3

    Gentleman agreement ang dapat bbm ask mo ano agreement

  • @BenjaminMateo-i4v
    @BenjaminMateo-i4v 4 місяці тому

    Kasalanan ng taong nakipagusap sa tsina hindi nang yari yan jkung hindi niya ginanon

  • @sagittarius4449
    @sagittarius4449 4 місяці тому +3

    Malaking Pera Involved Diyan ! Tiba Tiba Si Dodirty .

  • @VictoriaSantos-by5vb
    @VictoriaSantos-by5vb 4 місяці тому

    Bakit kailangan tayong dictahan ng china about the repair & bringing foods for the people staying 😊there

  • @xtian55
    @xtian55 4 місяці тому +1

    Pilit na pilit! Sus maryosep.

  • @MarcusAntoninusPandes
    @MarcusAntoninusPandes 4 місяці тому +2

    Medialdia is deflecting

  • @normaguimte6036
    @normaguimte6036 4 місяці тому

    Mga congressmen, women! You're investigating the duterte and china gentlemen' s agreement? Hope we, the people finally get an honest to goodness investigation that will finally establish whether or not there really was that kind of agreement because there should have been signed documents between the signatories : fpRRD AND CHIN'A'S REPRRESENTATIVE!

  • @antoniogorne5271
    @antoniogorne5271 4 місяці тому

    Yung sabi ni Mayor na kasambahay mali xa ng kanyang interpretation...kc nasa form yan under occupation at nilagay jan Housewife......hindi ibig sabihin Kasambahay yan

  • @ImeldaMurayama
    @ImeldaMurayama 4 місяці тому +1

    Syempre me amnisia Kasi di nila akalain na Malaki naging ptoblema