Jill Tarter & Douglas Vakoch - Why Do We Search for Intelligent Aliens?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 23 кві 2024
  • Listen to new episodes of the Closer To Truth podcast every Wednesday: shorturl.at/hwGP3
    Why does alien intelligence hold such fascination? Can we even conceive of what they might be like? To appreciate intelligent, sentient life in the universe, right now we have only one data point: ourselves. We would love more. Is it realistic to suppose we will find intelligent aliens?
    Jill Tarter is the former Director of the Center for SETI Research at the SETI Institute.
    Douglas Vakoch is the Director of Interstellar Message Composition at the SETI Institute, as well as the only social scientist employed by a SETI organization.
    Register for a free account to get exclusive subscriber benefits like early access to new episodes: bit.ly/3He94Ns
    Closer To Truth, hosted by Robert Lawrence Kuhn and directed by Peter Getzels, presents the world’s greatest thinkers exploring humanity’s deepest questions. Discover fundamental issues of existence. Engage new and diverse ways of thinking. Appreciate intense debates. Share your own opinions. Seek your own answers.

КОМЕНТАРІ • 53

  • @browngreen933
    @browngreen933 14 днів тому +3

    Unless in our literal backyard, everything is too far away in space and time to hear aliens talking.

  • @Minion-kh1tq
    @Minion-kh1tq 14 днів тому

    Thanks, guys. That was a hoot.

  • @Idlewyld
    @Idlewyld 14 днів тому +4

    We already know another intelligence exists. We recovered a craft in Kingman AZ May 1953.

    • @alyuksel348
      @alyuksel348 14 днів тому +2

      Why is intelligent life always found in the “United States“

    • @tomjackson7755
      @tomjackson7755 14 днів тому +1

      @@alyuksel348 We've got the best trailer parks for the 'probing'. LOL

    • @nuquenilex3188
      @nuquenilex3188 13 днів тому

      @@alyuksel348 who says there wasnt anything found in other countries?

    • @peppi1974
      @peppi1974 12 днів тому

      lol how does a craft travel the speed of light and crash in the usa conspiracies are an American phenomenon they all crash in the usa how convenient

  • @mickeybrumfield764
    @mickeybrumfield764 14 днів тому +3

    It seems to me it is more likely that more advanced living beings should discover us before we discover them. There is an immense amount of time for a more advanced being to have evolved to the extent that they could perceive us. It is likely that in a relatively short period of time, maybe 500 years, we will have the ability to reach out ourselves and make contact with intelligent beings, perhaps even in other galaxies. People object that it is not possible due to the universal speed limit being the speed of light, and the distances are just too great. I see this as less of an obstacle of getting around in perhaps 500 years than it was 200 years in the past at speculating about the possibility of going to the moon. Going to the moon was thought of as impossible, and that made sense. After all, we didn't even have wings like a bird. Today, at least, we have ideas like worm holes that could lead us to having the ability to travel vast distances without being bound by light speed limit. We simply underestimate how much things can change and how much they do change with technology and time. I do find it somewhat troubling that more advanced beings in our vast universe have not reached out and made contact with us.

    • @stinkertoy4310
      @stinkertoy4310 12 днів тому +1

      Yes. And still undetected, oddly enough. Why? We don’t get to play with the “big kids” until we can play nice.

    • @mickeybrumfield764
      @mickeybrumfield764 12 днів тому

      @@stinkertoy4310
      Okay, I like that better than it being our body odor.

  • @oldschool8432
    @oldschool8432 15 днів тому +3

    Apparently UA-cam doesn't think i have the intelligence to figure out how to turn on/off close captioning

  • @seanmckenna6122
    @seanmckenna6122 15 днів тому +2

    We don't have to look to space too find other intelligent beans. Theres lots of them in the aminal kingdom here on earth

  • @ansleyrubarb8672
    @ansleyrubarb8672 14 днів тому

    ...It is awesome & amazing if you think back to Mans knowledge how far we have come, in a very short time. The things we have as yet to discover, respectfully, Chuck,...captivus brevis...you tube...Blessings...

  • @pandoraeeris7860
    @pandoraeeris7860 14 днів тому

    We are not alone.

  • @djgroopz4952
    @djgroopz4952 14 днів тому

    It's like asking for the truth and someone asking why do want the truth.
    The truth about about our universe is good enough on it's own as justification for wanting to know it.
    We want to know the truth about our universe because it's the truth about universe.

  • @jamesruscheinski8602
    @jamesruscheinski8602 12 днів тому

    might it be possible to send communication back through dark energy expansion of space?

  • @carlosalbertolcolombo8711
    @carlosalbertolcolombo8711 12 днів тому

    Sospecho que estamos desesperados buscando inteligencia alienigena porque , como van las casas aquí, en la Tierra no hay.

  • @TheTimeOfThePlace
    @TheTimeOfThePlace 13 днів тому

    We search for intelligent life because we must, just as we try to increase our intelligence and improve our lives, we try to find others who are doing the same. At this point in Earth's evolution, intelligent people realize that we are limited. We will not find it here. We have to look elsewhere.

  • @willyh.r.1216
    @willyh.r.1216 13 днів тому

    If they exist, likely not all of them are more intelligent than humans.
    Human's default thought is always assuming that all ET are smarter than us.

  • @djgroopz4952
    @djgroopz4952 14 днів тому

    Lol, she started off quite apprehensive 😅😅😅. She probably thought it was gonna be one of those interviews.

  • @jamesruscheinski8602
    @jamesruscheinski8602 12 днів тому

    finding intelligent aliens helps determine how life and intelligence develop in universe?

  • @RT-hh3vl
    @RT-hh3vl 15 днів тому +1

    ... because of the time involved... billions of years for life to evolve... 🙄

  • @Jinxed007
    @Jinxed007 14 днів тому +1

    "We found one! It's 20 light-years away! Let's send a message! "
    "Hello, our alien neighbors!"
    ...40 years later...
    "GLLEP SNORF FLETGY."
    "Sorry, didn't get that... what were you saying? "
    ...40 years later...
    "GLLEP SNORF FLETGY!"
    ... everyone from the original message is now dead....

  • @feltonhamilton21
    @feltonhamilton21 14 днів тому

    The universe is in the galactic measurements and because of this
    I believe it is best to advance within the perimeter using a nuclear power engine with a built-in satellite and laser that can be sent to its destination and stop on target and open up and use its electric magnetic proportion system to direct it around in the facility to search for life.
    A human lifespan energy drive is only 60 years or more humanity would need to start building spaceships that can support generations of humans and other biological systems to overcome galactic years of deep space radiation rain and radiation clouds and storms and tornadoes because when raw radiation comes into contact with a spaceship it begins digesting things especially if it's forever out in deep space carrying warm bodies, but my point is without the right protection for the outside perimeter and the inside lining, everything inside would begin emanating radio waves and begin slowly disintegrating things under that much pressure.
    For better bubble protection. Paint made with magnetic dust and cement made with magnetic dust and wallpaper made with magnetic dust all clothing and furniture have to have a little magnetism to help maintain a constant geometry of flowing magnetism all around the inside and to help keep the radiation out and to protect the electrons inside our bodies.

  • @claudetaillefer1332
    @claudetaillefer1332 14 днів тому

    A plausible explanation for Fermi's paradox: AI destroys advanced technological civilizations! This is what might happen to us. Chronicle of a death foretold.

  • @nesiansides7133
    @nesiansides7133 8 днів тому

    The architects of our own ancient technology present a challenge to replicate with our current tech, and the data of that history would have earth riddled of several million years of ancient infrastructural evidence. All we have is pyramids, which is the evidence.
    We are more than one kind of civilization. We were supposed to advance our spiritual evolution, thus progressing to technological advancements and material technologies... what happened?
    Religion.

  • @d_s_x414
    @d_s_x414 14 днів тому

    This might be an old one.

  • @S3RAVA3LM
    @S3RAVA3LM 15 днів тому +1

    Why is film alien: covenant 2 not already here. David will be the main character of it. He might do what the engineers decided to do: extinguish the human race.

    • @tomjackson7755
      @tomjackson7755 14 днів тому

      Because it is just a fantasy, just like almost everything you post.

    • @digitalfootballer9032
      @digitalfootballer9032 14 днів тому

      ​@@tomjackson7755Of course it's a fantasy, it's a movie. What a dumb comment.

    • @tomjackson7755
      @tomjackson7755 14 днів тому

      @@digitalfootballer9032 LOL I know it is a fantasy. You seem to know it is a fantasy He asked why hasn't it happened.
      I agree you made a dumb comment with your attempt to troll.

  • @S3RAVA3LM
    @S3RAVA3LM 15 днів тому +1

    4:22 is true. Bible as an example, you can make it into whatever you want - it can be a tool, or can be made into a weapon. Even scientific data, can be interpreted in many ways, either favoring nihilism/atheism, or as an expression of the omniscient and omnipotence of God.

  • @browngreen933
    @browngreen933 14 днів тому

    Considering how quickly humans developed species-erasing nuclear weapons, technological intelligence may be the "great filter" everyone talks about. 😢

  • @wordzfailmebro
    @wordzfailmebro 15 днів тому

    Non Human 👉👽👈 Intelligence?

  • @MegaRulos
    @MegaRulos 14 днів тому

    Why look for a dumb one?

  • @Maxwell-mv9rx
    @Maxwell-mv9rx 15 днів тому +1

    Frank Drake equation to fund alien is N igual exfpfefifcl. Guys shows fundamental alien It is NOT Science proceendings. But show rubbish sentences keep out Frank equation .

  • @scott-qk8sm
    @scott-qk8sm 14 днів тому

    SETI has failed miserably, how about you talk to a scientist from SCU ?

  • @christoronaldo7673
    @christoronaldo7673 14 днів тому

    Seek Truth in Jesus not in "aLiEns"

    • @tomjackson7755
      @tomjackson7755 14 днів тому

      Your shift key seems to be broken, along with your thinking.

    • @digitalfootballer9032
      @digitalfootballer9032 14 днів тому

      ​@@tomjackson7755Someone made a reference to religion...better cry about it.

    • @tomjackson7755
      @tomjackson7755 14 днів тому

      @@digitalfootballer9032 Someone made a comment, you better troll and whine about it.