Magic Foundations Commander | Commander VS | Magic: the Gathering Gameplay

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 3 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 99

  • @SCGCommander
    @SCGCommander  Місяць тому +1

    HOT AND FRESH DECKLISTS
    articles.starcitygames.com/magic-the-gathering/commander-vs-415-legends-of-foundations/

  • @ChrisLovesYahweh
    @ChrisLovesYahweh Місяць тому +102

    My wife has breast cancer. I play magic with my wife. Magic has made us both smile during these times. Much love Carlos.

  • @atticus009
    @atticus009 Місяць тому +21

    Thank y'all for shouting out Carlos! He traveled with me and our other friend Johnathan to Magic Con Vegas, and it really was the trip of of a lifetime. So many people loved on Carlos and gave him and us memories we'll cherish forever. Over 30 Magic content creators signed his Dragonshield playmat - which Jeremy sold him at the Dragonshield booth. We love this community and all the awesome people in it!

  • @ChestnutBaron
    @ChestnutBaron Місяць тому +14

    Corey not hitting Niv with the Swords to Plowshares he had in hand is peak Commander Vs foundations.😃

  • @tripdowney9175
    @tripdowney9175 Місяць тому +12

    You guys are awesome and was a great honor to meet 3/4 of you in Vegas. Thx for always providing great content for us to enjoy. I’ll catch Corey one of these days so he can sign my mat as well.

  • @evanbruno9648
    @evanbruno9648 Місяць тому +19

    What would be cool is if a season winner gets to pick everyone's commander for one game of the next season.

  • @Qdrew78
    @Qdrew78 Місяць тому +1

    My heart, thoughts, and prayers for all those with cancer! I am dealing with bone cancer for the second time. It is 100% treatable which is cool but after already taking 13 doses my body cannot take chemo properly. So we are letting it fill up and then will roll the dice to see if I can make it through treatment another time. Yet I find no sadness In any of this!
    I have had the honor of serving and being medically retired, loved my family and worked for those in the community, specifically those at risk and homelessness. Part of my recovery in life was found through magic and the community found within the gathering. It makes my heart so happy to see all the new players, the excitement, and accessibility magic has become.
    Always love and laughter in your lives and cheers my friends :)
    Last but most importantly, so much love to those who work within the treatment of cancer! From doctors, to those amazing angels known as nurses who administer the chemo, and to the unsung hero’s that work both the front end and behind the scenes managing billing and meds. ❤❤❤

  • @WayneyMTG
    @WayneyMTG Місяць тому

    Such a heartfelt shoutout at the opening there, love goes out to Carlos 🫶🏼

  • @carloderkinderen68
    @carloderkinderen68 Місяць тому +6

    Best wishes for Carlos.
    Xtra point at end of each game for sportsmanship, each vote on another player.

  • @rainblue9810
    @rainblue9810 Місяць тому +2

    Appreciated all of the preamble. Keep being great! I say dont be afraid to put in interesting new rules. This is commander and it should always stay fun and interesting.

  • @TheDivineHysteria
    @TheDivineHysteria Місяць тому +1

    Cancer sucks, what a great episode truly great. Watching over the years this show has brought me so much joy, miss Justin's shenanigans. Cannot wait for marvel!

  • @David_Stevens
    @David_Stevens Місяць тому +3

    Winning without messing with life total (decking, alternate win conditions)

  • @wintersmonologue
    @wintersmonologue Місяць тому +10

    My rule would be something around Cheatyface. Get 1 point for cheating Cheatyface out successfully or lose 1 point for failure (triggers once per game).

  • @meta4thoughts
    @meta4thoughts Місяць тому +2

    Love for Carlos and all those who find joy being here!

  • @oldmanaaron
    @oldmanaaron Місяць тому +3

    usually I don't start crying until the end of a commander game.

  • @famousstranger8468
    @famousstranger8468 Місяць тому +1

    Point for introducing monarch/initiative
    Just to encourage better gameplay & social aspect in the format

  • @PapaBlessMTG
    @PapaBlessMTG Місяць тому +2

    That would actually be absolutely hilarious delivery of such a random rule of every episode. Steven Green loses a point so in response, Steven Green comes in disguise every single week as another person, would be comedy gold😂

  • @RabbitsRi
    @RabbitsRi Місяць тому +1

    I love how Corey was all like, "I'm casting a counterspell on John's thing! It's the only thing I can do!"
    Stephen, "So you're telling me there's not a counterspell in Corey's hand AND John only has 1 open mana?"

  • @brandondyer2792
    @brandondyer2792 Місяць тому +1

    next rule should be +1 if you stop someone from saving someone else (countering the lifesaving fog ect)

  • @NoName-vo3nf
    @NoName-vo3nf Місяць тому +3

    I remember as a kid sitting in Jeremys parents house and listening to a story of his friend group pulling a bird of paradise. I also rember the bangle tiger story lol the tiger story was the best for a long time but getting to watch the guy that taught me to play magic live his dreams is better then any memorys . Thanks for being a good guy cayne lindsey

  • @Miztickow
    @Miztickow Місяць тому +2

    Rule suggestion: First player to sacrifice a Treasure for mana loses a point.

  • @TheGreatGreylagGoose
    @TheGreatGreylagGoose Місяць тому +1

    Possible rule. "Before the game the last player in point, may secretly guess the order of elimination of all player, if he is correct he win 2 points "

  • @tomcadden8054
    @tomcadden8054 Місяць тому

    Much love going out to Carlos and you guys🤗

  • @BloodMoonGo
    @BloodMoonGo Місяць тому +6

    +2 points for killing with commander damage. Incentivize more commander combat

  • @DarthTUK
    @DarthTUK Місяць тому

    Oh I would 100% establish a rule "You get a point WHENEVER you catch John cheating". Easiest point farm in history. Did anybody else notice how that Frantic Search went back to the graveyard after being flashed back? Corey caught the Mystic Sanctuary. Stuff like that.

  • @shuichigojo415
    @shuichigojo415 Місяць тому

    It was awesome meeting 3/4 of you guys at MCVegas

  • @Alejandrodemontana
    @Alejandrodemontana Місяць тому

    1:08:16 all parents in the audience collectively agreed that Elmo runs the show.

  • @benmanchester7671
    @benmanchester7671 Місяць тому

    Love the Home Alone reference Jeremy!!😂

  • @RyuPlaneswalker
    @RyuPlaneswalker Місяць тому +1

    Here is a suggestion for a point : "You get a point each episode if you haven't played a deck with that previous color identity in this season."

  • @HexproofButHopeless
    @HexproofButHopeless Місяць тому

    Corey pecking Stephen cracked me up 😂

  • @shinobihouzin
    @shinobihouzin Місяць тому

    Corey touching those full art islands being like , these don't make white ... 😅 too good

  • @nathand6467
    @nathand6467 Місяць тому

    Enjoyed seeing Niv-Mizzet pop off. Knew it was good, but for 6 mana commander that seemed fast. Didn't recognize it was THAT good.

  • @jaredstivers
    @jaredstivers Місяць тому

    We need to do a season with the wheel of the basic colors, and each week, you spin to see which color must be played that week

  • @kylemartin7871
    @kylemartin7871 Місяць тому

    In the second game when Corey had indestructible I'm surprised he didn't attack all at John? He only had one blocker, it wouldn't have killed him but would have at least maimed him.

  • @SpirkSpirk
    @SpirkSpirk Місяць тому +1

    First! Love watching you guys, also liking the video as to not receive universal spite from Mr.Green!

  • @dwchief
    @dwchief Місяць тому

    42:27 Insert the I Think You Should Leave "You sure about that?" meme here. (In the most loving way possible, of course Corey! Just funny to say a few minutes after realizing you got 0 points for the game 😂)

  • @Okamithegod
    @Okamithegod Місяць тому

    Love you Carlos!

  • @CptObvs408
    @CptObvs408 Місяць тому

    Second Place Suarez strikes twice😂

  • @GrandDungeonDad
    @GrandDungeonDad Місяць тому

    Corey you got the second wind in your sails nice job bud

  • @evancarter4234
    @evancarter4234 Місяць тому

    I would love to see a gimmick where every week all four players start with a coin/ticket that they can tip the other players with.
    They can then tip one of the other players for sabotaging a big play.
    At the end of the match, each player gets a point for any tips they've received.
    This incentivizes making impactful plays even when you're headed out in last.

  • @GrandDungeonDad
    @GrandDungeonDad Місяць тому +1

    Corey way to go underachiever of all time on Commander VS😂

    • @CoreyBMTG
      @CoreyBMTG Місяць тому +1

      My dreams have finally come true!

    • @GrandDungeonDad
      @GrandDungeonDad Місяць тому +1

      @ Corey I know there is a magic monster in there this season just waiting to be unleashed. I know your trying to let the other guys have a few wins but its ok to flex once in a while too.

    • @CoreyBMTG
      @CoreyBMTG Місяць тому +1

      @@GrandDungeonDad Have you made it to the second game yet?! :P

    • @GrandDungeonDad
      @GrandDungeonDad Місяць тому

      @@CoreyBMTG I saw well played sir.

  • @alucarddelta6576
    @alucarddelta6576 Місяць тому +1

    U guys gunna play with the jumpstart commanders?

  • @Rafeki97
    @Rafeki97 Місяць тому +1

    Possible rule. "Resolve the most expensive spell"

  • @Milohenry13
    @Milohenry13 Місяць тому

    Ooooo!! I have a great idea for a new Rule!!
    *When a second game is played: The player who wins said second game gets 2 points. All other rules DO NOT apply.

  • @gamepro_awsome2948
    @gamepro_awsome2948 Місяць тому

    Big bird is green (Mexico) depending on where the show was aired

  • @dominiclouer3344
    @dominiclouer3344 Місяць тому +1

    +1 or 2 if you kill the leading player first

  • @Ben-cv7pg
    @Ben-cv7pg Місяць тому

    Rule idea: group votes for the player who made the most clutch play (thinking things like countering a 5+ cost spell or killing a creature before it would swing in for a kill. Can't vote for your own play.

  • @rocketrae21
    @rocketrae21 Місяць тому +10

    +2 at the end of the season if you play no Sol Ring in any of your decks. You can replace it with a land of your choice for the fan submitted deck or random deck episodes

  • @dvader831
    @dvader831 Місяць тому

    My suggestion is if you gain 10 life in one turn, +1 point, and this can continue upwards for each ten life, so gaining 50 life would give the player +5 points.

  • @DarkPikachuYTV
    @DarkPikachuYTV Місяць тому +1

    Am building around Corey deck

  • @christopherscoggins1772
    @christopherscoggins1772 Місяць тому

    If everything is Plains, nothing is Plains.

  • @keithzoller4063
    @keithzoller4063 Місяць тому +1

    @SCGcommander didnt jeremy also not cast his commander?

    • @aaroncrandall3281
      @aaroncrandall3281 Місяць тому

      You are correct. I think points should have been Stephen +3 (1st but killed everyone in 1 turn), Jon +1 (4th place), Jeremy +1 (4th place, no commander, first blood), Corey +0 (4th place, no commander) So everyone should have a total of 5 points except Corey with 1.

  • @Kell_of_Kellers
    @Kell_of_Kellers Місяць тому

    RULE IDEA: “Fair Magic” two options: either A) +1 point: play a deck without sol ring. OR B) +1 point: play a deck with NO ramp in it.

  • @mynamesmitchell
    @mynamesmitchell Місяць тому

    "This is otterly ridiculous"

  • @trevorpeters4976
    @trevorpeters4976 Місяць тому

    Like, comment, share, subscribe, binge, and ring in new combat bells

  • @dominiclouer3344
    @dominiclouer3344 Місяць тому

    In the Netherlands Big bird is blue

  • @djhull569
    @djhull569 Місяць тому

    Jeremy sound exhausted

  • @DarkPikachuYTV
    @DarkPikachuYTV Місяць тому

    32:31 could play in your deck Corey though to trigger you commander for free

  • @alucarddelta6576
    @alucarddelta6576 Місяць тому

    Idk if it mattered but steven forgot to exile 3 to jeskas will xD

  • @lukeroden3593
    @lukeroden3593 Місяць тому

    I both loved and hated this episode 😂.

  • @xSNAKE2423x
    @xSNAKE2423x Місяць тому +4

    Ohh new rule
    ☆☆☆ If you put the episode in risk of being Demonetized -2points! ☆☆☆
    Lol sorry Corey... 5:03

  • @buckle9733
    @buckle9733 Місяць тому

    +1 point if you can manage 15 or more creatures in play.

  • @Target008
    @Target008 Місяць тому

    Core sets have always been my favorite

  • @chris_in_a_box
    @chris_in_a_box Місяць тому +1

    I haven seen the end yet but people are suggesting rules so I'm gonna join in. How about at any point in the game you can wager 1 point to search for a basic land and put it in your hand, if you lose the game you lose 2 points if you win you don't lose any points. You can only do this once per game and maybe with the caviot that first place can't do this.

    • @SCGCommander
      @SCGCommander  Місяць тому +1

      Corey is about to lose all his points with this one!

  • @LoydHuhn
    @LoydHuhn Місяць тому +1

    39:38 He's right. It's not that it's a tier 1/bracket 1 issue, its that y'all let it happen.

  • @joshuaseburn4545
    @joshuaseburn4545 Місяць тому

    Team green

  • @michaelm1209
    @michaelm1209 Місяць тому

    +1 point or more for killing someone with there own commander

  • @spacetimebear3272
    @spacetimebear3272 Місяць тому

    1st Combination of the game to be successfully completed gets a point. But you lose a point if it gets stopped or interrupted one turn cycle around

  • @MrPinkpanzer
    @MrPinkpanzer Місяць тому

    Another broken niv mizzet that can't be allowed to live through an untap step one time. Great design by wizards.

  • @daithomas1430
    @daithomas1430 Місяць тому +1

    I'd say if you accidentally cheated and it affected the outcome of the game remove all positive points for that episode (still lose points for searching, etc)

  • @timothybrown1020
    @timothybrown1020 Місяць тому

    My thought for rules changes would be “+1 point for favorite/most flavorful deck votes on by viewers”
    Put out a UA-cam vote each week after the game to vote on everybody’s favorite deck. Winner gets a point.

  • @cameronneveu7277
    @cameronneveu7277 Місяць тому

    Ok, Point suggestion: It was right on Top! - Pay 1 Point to Draw a Card.

  • @vyg55
    @vyg55 Місяць тому

    ree reeeeeeeeeeee🙃

  • @moldytaters4190
    @moldytaters4190 Місяць тому

    I really hope Carlos gets to visit all the places he wants to, Cancer is evil...
    I vote for -1 point for every time you play the exact same deck over and over (i.e. playing another blink deck with just a different commander). Or -1 point every time you pump fake/stall with nothing.

  • @DarkPikachuYTV
    @DarkPikachuYTV Місяць тому

    If RC didn’t step down that Niv would get banned it’s Nadu looks like

  • @christianschmitz8395
    @christianschmitz8395 Місяць тому

    Corey baumeister everyone....incredible magic player....atrocious commander player😂😂

  • @Gratuitous_D
    @Gratuitous_D Місяць тому

    I would not be surprised if that new Niv gets banned

  • @OhMightyONE234
    @OhMightyONE234 Місяць тому

    if you cast sol ring losee a point

  • @satheran12
    @satheran12 Місяць тому

    Azorious decks are such snoozefests. Probably the worst decks to play against time-wise.

  • @dragoonofdeath8033
    @dragoonofdeath8033 Місяць тому +2

    Lose a point every pump fake

  • @Noganite
    @Noganite Місяць тому

    Steven is playing a T1.5 or T2 deck, Cory. It is nice, but still a little slow. Well done Mr. Green Bird! Sesame Street got nothing on you!

  • @remembertobreathe66
    @remembertobreathe66 Місяць тому

    Rule change: Cast any ramp spell for 2 mana or less is -1 point. Get them Sol Rings outta here! More early first blood drops instead. Honest Magic in the red zone.

  • @folderrr
    @folderrr Місяць тому

    -1 to whoever ramps first
    -1 if the game ends and you control a sol ring (-2 if you get first)
    +1 upon declaring your commander tax to be 3 colorless mana and 3 life instead of 2 colorless mana before the game begins
    much love to carlos!

  • @justinkubik686
    @justinkubik686 Місяць тому

    Like I get John checked out, and stopped caring but you don't even have a response, stop acting like that.

  • @gildarmesh3809
    @gildarmesh3809 Місяць тому

    the first person to play a mana rock or ramp spell -1 point