Sir Am Watching Your Video From 1 years On Daily Basis And Also Really Thanks To Umair Bhai But I Have A Question About Future Trading That There Is Two Options Of Trading Sell Short Or Buy Long Is It Speculation And If This Then Speculation Is Haram In Islam Kindly Clear My Points About Future Trading
Why do you buy Gold? Or any other valuable product? To hedge Inflation right .. in other words you are speculating their future price.. is it haram or halal then? If is it haram then why we pay fixed Zakat on our valuables like gold? I'm also looking answers to these questions
@@ilmeaalim Hazoor os ma gold (asset) humary pass tu hota ha. Future trading ma hun just betting lga rhy hoty hain. Assets (coins) to nhe hoty humary pass.
@@ilmeaalim zakat ap fix islita dety hain k apki ownership m hoti hai wo chz wo b km sy km 1 saal tak reti h. Future trading m pli bt ap to owner ho he ni. Apne tu 4X money borrow ki hai . Ab borrow py ap intrest pay kr rhy ho
Crypto in general is halah to buy, sell or keep as an asset, but for binance (or any other exchange) only spot trading is halal, so margin trading, futures, staking, defi staking, earn services, loans, dual investments, borrowing ALL are Haram, and binance in particular even for normal staking gives you the rewards
Quran (Surah Al Baqarah 2:278-9) "O those who believe; fear Allah and give up what still remains of the Riba if you are believers. But if you do not do so, then be warned of war from Allah and His Messenger. If you repent even now, you have the right of the return of your principal; neither will you do wrong nor will you be wronged."
Jo log samjhte hain spot trading main profit bhot kam ha , wapis research karen . Doosra get Rich quick ka pecha na jayen ese koi cheez nahin hote . Time lagta ha har ache cheez main , jese aik fruit to pakne main time lagta ha
Sir je 3 points bhot important hain in future / margin trading 1- interest ha = haram 2- aap gambling karte hain = haram . Kionke market manipulation hote ha aur aap liquidate . 3- aap futures / margin main asset khud OWN nahin karte like spot main . = haram Jitna maine parha ha sab scholars ne future / margin trading haram karar de ha . Baki aap sab apne research zaroor karen
Phly muj b 80% haram lgti thi.. Future trading........ But yaha pa jo point muj ky dekhy agr leverage lety hy tu agr ap profit ma ja rhy phr tu nahi na aap un ko pay kr rhy.. I mean yaha pa simple ly ly ap ka. Luck pa depend hy.. Agr ap. Loss ma ho tu pay warna Profit... Mean fix nai hy ky un ko wapis krna
1. Question: (Futures/ Forward Contracts) i) Two individuals, A and B enter into a contract on 1st January, 1996 under which A would sell a stock of company X at a price of $100 to B after an expiry of six months. B has an obligation to purchase at this price irrespective of the market price on 30th June 1996. Is this contract permissible in Shariah? ii) Can this contract or the rights and obligations of A and B be transferred by either of them to a third party C? iii) If the object of transaction is any commodity, or gold, silver or currency and not stocks, as in the case above, in what way is the validity or otherwise of the contract affected? It may be noted that the non- transferability of rights and obligations severely limits the possibility of speculation on Futures Exchanges. A commonly held belief is that Futures contracts are prohibited when they are used for speculation. Does this imply that Futures contracts are permissible when these are used for hedging? Comments by Mufti Taqi Usmani: i) This is an example of a Futures transaction. The Futures transaction as in vogue in stock and commodities markets today are not permissible for two reasons. Firstly, it is a well recognised principle of the Shariah that sale or purchase cannot be affected for a future date. Therefore, all Forward and Futures transactions are invalid in Shariah. Secondly because in most of the Futures transactions, delivery of the commodities or their possession is not intended. In most cases, the transactions end up with the settlements of difference of prices only, which is not allowed in the Shariah. ii) As Futures are not permissible, no rights or obligations can emanate therefrom. Therefore the question of transfer- ring these rights and obligations does not arise. International Journal of Islamic Financial Services Vol. 1 No.1 iii) Futures transactions as explained above, are totally impermissible regardless of their subject matter. Similarly, it makes no difference whether these contracts are entered into for the purpose of speculation or for the purpose of hedging.
Crypto in general is halah to buy, sell or keep as an asset, but for binance (or any other exchange) only spot trading is halal, so margin trading, futures, staking, defi staking, earn services, loans, dual investments, borrowing ALL are Haram, and binance in particular even for normal staking gives you the rewards
Excellent bhai , Q k us main interest hain , aur easy konci ches hain jis k grny se bnda faida hota hain , mtlab Short ye sub hram hain , First of all ye jo Hr 8 Hour k bad fee lety hain ye sood hain...
Quran clearly mentioned gambling is prohibited Future trading and margen trading are also type of gambling ... In simple words Satie bazi ..... Surat No 2 : سورة البقرة - Ayat No 219 یَسۡئَلُوۡنَکَ عَنِ الۡخَمۡرِ وَ الۡمَیۡسِرِؕ قُلۡ فِیۡہِمَاۤ اِثۡمٌ کَبِیۡرٌ وَّ مَنَافِعُ لِلنَّاسِ ۫ وَ اِثۡمُہُمَاۤ اَکۡبَرُ مِنۡ نَّفۡعِہِمَا ؕ وَ یَسۡئَلُوۡنَکَ مَا ذَا یُنۡفِقُوۡنَ ۬ ؕ قُلِ الۡعَفۡوَؕ کَذٰلِکَ یُبَیِّنُ اللّٰہُ لَکُمُ الۡاٰیٰتِ لَعَلَّکُمۡ تَتَفَکَّرُوۡنَ ﴿۲۱۹﴾ۙ پوچھتے ہیں : شراب اور جوئے کا کیا حکم ہے؟ : ان دونوں چیزوں میں بڑی خرابی ہے ۔ اگرچہ ان میں لوگوں کے لیے کچھ منافع بھی ہیں ، مگر ان کا گناہ ان کے فائدے سے بہت زیادہ ہے ۔ Surat No 5 : سورة المائدة - Ayat No 90 یٰۤاَیُّہَا الَّذِیۡنَ اٰمَنُوۡۤا اِنَّمَا الۡخَمۡرُ وَ الۡمَیۡسِرُ وَ الۡاَنۡصَابُ وَ الۡاَزۡلَامُ رِجۡسٌ مِّنۡ عَمَلِ الشَّیۡطٰنِ فَاجۡتَنِبُوۡہُ لَعَلَّکُمۡ تُفۡلِحُوۡنَ ﴿۹۰﴾ اے لوگو جو ایمان لائے ہو ، یہ شراب اور جوا اور یہ آستانے اور پانسے ، یہ سب گندے شیطانی کام ہیں ، ان سے پرہیز کرو ، امیّد ہے کہ تمہیں فلاح نصیب ہوگی ۔
All assets in world are speculative in nature. The concept of assets have changed in the modern world. Its not the physical nature but your virtual buying power that matters. Digital wallets like easypaisa are case in point. We need to do Ijtehad after studying the new form of Internet economy. I fully agree with the suppressive rental models.
I ma trader technical analysis meine kiya hai Sl hunting and market psychology ke courses kiya hai meri accuracy 90%.But ap future mein apni zati amount kam karen leverage na lein
Most huge important video. Should be make more video specific on this topic. Halaal haram its important. 85% people are confused and not coming in crypto only for this.
Mere hyal say jis chez mai apko loss hota hai to woh halal hota hai Awr binance mai loss hota hai Agar apko serf profit milta ho toh phir chances haram ki hai
Lakin sir ismain ek or ehem point he kisi coin k sath apney munafey k liyain trade karna aisa hi he jaisy kisi karobari farm k sath karobar karaa.. Islammain ek point ye bhi he k aap jis k saath karobar karo investment karo to un k kaam dakho wo halal he ya haram... ager wo hamara paisa kisi haram karobar main laatey hain to yaqeenan wo haram hi hoga.. ab ye kistarha maloom karain k jis coin main hum invests kartey hain ... unka ka koi na koi bissiness to hoga wo kia he kisy pata karain..??
Muqaddas bhai, Interest (Sood) is Haram for both individual and Corporation as it lead to inflation, recession whereas rental model have asset between two people rent is the fee of using the place. Future trading is Haram as it involves interest rate.
How inflation in bigger picture, If bread company borrow loan from bank for expansion, he will add interest payment in Selling price of bread leading to inflation.
Beshak crypto physical form me nahi hai lekin ye digitally to maujood hai.....isse spot me buy karne par turant aapka kabza ho jaata hai....aur aap usse jaha chahe send kar sakte hai
Dealings with cryptocurrency futures contracts often involve paying or charging interest, buying or selling your financial obligations under the futures contract, and cash settlement of the futures contract which are all haram
Hello 👋 how can future trading be halal? Like when we buy or sell we don’t actually buy the coin itself you are just bitting on the price in futures without holding the coin means we don’t have ownership of the coin Islam clearly says that you can't buy or sell what you don’t have ownership of Second thing is that in the future we can do a short sale how can you explain that to us? How can you sell when you don’t even have ownership of an asset? Please explain
Sir Sell trade halal hai ya haram? Q ke agr 1 cheez hum ne 10 per buy ki thi or iski price 20 ho gye to Hume profit ho jata hai. Lakin sell ki trade Mai Jub 1 cheez ki price 10 thi or uski price 5 ho gye to phir kesi profit ho gya. Pochne Ka maqsad yai hai ke sell ki trade ke peche logic kya hota hai?
For example aik coin ki price 10rs hai .Sell walai case mein Ap exchange ko kehtai Kai wo aik coin beich dein apkai nam ka aur 10rs apko dein dei.Aur jub price nechai ati for example 7rs Pai tu Ap aik coin khareed Kai exchange ko wapis kr detai aur 3rs apka profit hota .
sir Future ek kism ka betting hain or agr future trading halal hai to phr betting bhi halal huwa us m bhi do bndy ek dosry ko paise deten or dosri bt future m jo funding aati hai wo interest hai to kindly logo ko gumrah na kren ap ki jo raaye hai wo ap apny pass rkho baki public m share krna munasib nh q k log ap ki bato ko follow krty hain
Dear Qudoos Bhai, My opinion on 7:31 is that Future Trading is Haram. Let me explain why i think so.. Let’s suppose i put a long (buy) order at Market price. The amount is deducted from my balance which means i am now in buy position. For a trade to happen, it’s necessary that I should own that commodity in exchange of the money i have paid. Kindly explain, do i own / custody of BTC or whatever coin that i made long (buy)? I think NO. Because it’s neither in my wallet nor i can send it to anyone else because i don’t own it. Similarly, in opening a Short (sell) position, how is it possible that can i sell the coin, when I don’t already have it in my possession to make a sell trade?
Agreed, but sir please clear it that we actually dont owns assets or commodities in futures contract, so how can we trade something that we dont owns. Is this halal?
Sir future Trading ma agar ham funding rate nikal bhi dein tou usme ye masla ha k log khete hain woh contract based trading hain aur islam ma woh mana ha yani ap future ma ap price fix nhi karsakte. Iss k bare ma clear karne k liye zarori ha ap kisi scholar se jaldi rapta karein.
Disagree. Nabi SAW ka wo farman k "ek wakt ae ga k har banda sood me invlove hoga jo na le khae us tak uski boo pohnch jae ge". Ye Hadith clear banking ki taraf jati he. So banking wala sood b sood hi he.
OR AGR KOI YEH KAAM KRRAHA HAI TOU KUCH SOCH SMJH KR HI KRRAHA HOA Q K INTEREST DENE WALAI KI ALLAH OR HAMARE NABI SE KHOLI JANG HAI AP ALLAH SE DILL SE ISHARA MANGO KAI JO KAAM MIEN KRNE JARAHA HN WO MERE DEEN KE CIRCLE MIEN ATA HAI YAA NH ALHAMDULILLAH MEENE DILL SE PHUCHA THA ALLAH SE ISHARA BHI MILA ALLAH KI TARAF SE KE YEH JAIZ HAI FUTURE TRADING KI BAAT KRRAHA HN MIEN I KNOW YOU ALL CAN'T BELIEVE THAT BUT IT'S TRUE
Few examples here,,Email bhi physical nhi hai, Hawa bhi dekhayi nhi deti , internet ko Kitne logo ne physical dekhta hai,online banking transition bhi physically nhi Hoti ,to sawal yeh hy, kia in sab ka wajood nhi hai🤔🤔
Assalamualaikum Sir ap ne yaha logo ko ik bt misguide kia pase k badly pesa hai wala kam thik hy or rent wagaira wala jo system hy wo thik nhi ap k nazriye k mutabiq Jnb jis business me commodity involved ho wo halal hy jase hmny koi ghr ya dukan rent pe di tu yeh halal jb k pase k badly pesa sood hy Baki ap ne bohat achy se guide kia hy viewers ko
Assalam O Alaikum Sir Future trading ma price ki prediction pr betting lgai jati ha. Humary wallet ma koe assets nhe aty ya hum koe assets buy nhe krty. Jaha tak mujhy lgta ha humy iss sy kinara krna chaye Hazoor. May Allah forgive us. 🙏
@@StopandAct brother yahan do points hain . 1- Aap asset khud own nahin karte poora , ye aik rule ha Islamic law main . 2- market manupilations ke jate hain , exchanges ki taraf se uske waja se aap liquidate hote ho .
@@StopandActbrother still it would be considered gambling . example Len , real estate ki .kuch bhe ho jaye value zero hosakte ha lekin property aap ki hi hoge .
Muqadda bhai please make a video on how to make our metamask wallet secure to avoid being hacked. I think it's most important for us to learn about this topic for protecting our life savings. Please consider my request. Thanks
In Islam you can not trade that is not yours. There is a hadith on this you guys can search. Doing Future trade is 100% haram. It include interest it does not matter in what form the interest is. In future trade you don’t own anything like you do in spot trade that is all borrow and it is in just a form of contract. You take/borrow coin/currency from exchange and do trade on that this is not allowed in islam.
Asalam o Aliekum.. humble request plzzz read ... Umeed hy Ap khairiyat sy ho gay Allah k fazal o karam sy.. newly mamlat chahy kisi bi Field sy releted ho un py haraaam k fatway lgny ki bari waja knowledge ki kami hy kyo k kisi bi mufti k samny jo sawal krne wala hy wo jo situation rakhy ga mufti sahib usy py fatwa dy gay ab to na sawal krne waly ko pora knowledge hy aur na mufti sahib ko. .... Ap engineer Muhammad Ali mirza sath podcast kry bht asani sy available hy wo har Sunday ko online ya academy me ...aur wo bht already janty bi hy like forex crypto wagera to ap un sath discuss kry ap apny sawalo k sath sath un ko btay bi k kon si market kaesy chlti hy aur sb k mutaliq un ka point of view lain jaesy k forex aur stock market aur share market aur crypto aur en sb me he margin aur future trading sy mutaliq...lakin plzzzz sawal kry aur phly unhy btay k es sawal k sath ye details hy ... JazakAllah
The banks are going to die .The cryptos overcome . Levarage (Sood) is a guilty whether it is in solid form (like banking and rentle system ) or in digital form (like future trading ) The main purpose of it is decentralizatiin. All kind of leverages support centralization so ,they oppose the opinion of wellfare
Sir as for as this question is concerned, in person I think it as none of your business... Let the Islamic scholars i.e "scholars=Islamic Studies + Finance & Account". If I am wrong, I want you to correct me.
Hazoor meri aap sy request ha aap apni community ko future trading sy dur kr dyn. Allah Kareem aap ko bhot ajar dyn gy. May Allah bless us, May Allah forgive us.
Brother Hamri qoom kabhi b profit mai sy persantage nhi dy gi ya tw time pay kabhi rent nhi dyti agree krta h. Apki baat sy but Haji saab kon bany ga . Pakistaniyon ny hamesa ya hi kaha ha k loss/guzara hi ho raha ha. Sb asy nhi hoty but 80% liar's hi hain jinka kabhi profit nhi ho skta jo kaha hi nhi skty ha profit howa ha....
@@thenaildesigns3821 to bhai yehi bat hai wohi fee agar pay karni ho future me har 4 hours me or wo fix nai hoti agar long ki positions zyada hai to wo short walo fee dete or short ki positions zyada hai to wo long walo ko fee dete
مارجن کے ساتھ ساتھ فیوچر ٹریڈنگ بھی بغیر شک و شبہ کے حرام ہے۔ محترم، یہاں ایک پہلو آپ نے چھوڑ دیا۔ آپ یہاں سود کو ڈسکس کر رہے ہیں۔ حالانکہ ایک مفتی صاحب کا کہنا تھا کہ فیوچر ٹریڈنگ میں ٹریڈر، ایکسچینج کے ساتھ شرط لگاتا ہے کہ ریٹ فلاں پرائس تک جائے گا۔ اگر یہ شرط جیت گیا تو پرافٹ اگر آپ شرط ہار گئے تو پرافٹ میں ایکسچینج ہوگی۔
Sir 1 bat clear ker de. Forex mein jo lot size hota us mein bhi to loan le ker hi lot buy ki jati hai. Usa sab halal khte hai or crypto mein future trading ko haram.
Sir Khudar jis bat ka ilam na ho to chup rahna he bahtr hota hai mai or ap Kon hoty hai halal ko haram ya haram ko halal kahny waly i hope do you understand
Sir Am Watching Your Video From 1 years On Daily Basis And Also Really Thanks To Umair Bhai But I Have A Question About Future Trading That There Is Two Options Of Trading Sell Short Or Buy Long Is It Speculation And If This Then Speculation Is Haram In Islam Kindly Clear My Points About Future Trading
Good point
Why do you buy Gold? Or any other valuable product? To hedge Inflation right .. in other words you are speculating their future price.. is it haram or halal then? If is it haram then why we pay fixed Zakat on our valuables like gold?
I'm also looking answers to these questions
@@ilmeaalim Hazoor os ma gold (asset) humary pass tu hota ha.
Future trading ma hun just betting lga rhy hoty hain. Assets (coins) to nhe hoty humary pass.
@@ilmeaalim zakat ap fix islita dety hain k apki ownership m hoti hai wo chz wo b km sy km 1 saal tak reti h. Future trading m pli bt ap to owner ho he ni. Apne tu 4X money borrow ki hai . Ab borrow py ap intrest pay kr rhy ho
Crypto in general is halah to buy, sell or keep as an asset, but for binance (or any other exchange) only spot trading is halal, so margin trading, futures, staking, defi staking, earn services, loans, dual investments, borrowing ALL are Haram, and binance in particular even for normal staking gives you the rewards
Quran (Surah Al Baqarah 2:278-9)
"O those who believe; fear Allah and give up what still remains of the Riba if you are believers. But if you do not do so, then be warned of war from Allah and His Messenger. If you repent even now, you have the right of the return of your principal; neither will you do wrong nor will you be wronged."
thank you for sharing
Jo log samjhte hain spot trading main profit bhot kam ha , wapis research karen . Doosra get Rich quick ka pecha na jayen ese koi cheez nahin hote . Time lagta ha har ache cheez main , jese aik fruit to pakne main time lagta ha
Sir je 3 points bhot important hain in future / margin trading
1- interest ha = haram
2- aap gambling karte hain = haram . Kionke market manipulation hote ha aur aap liquidate .
3- aap futures / margin main asset khud OWN nahin karte like spot main . = haram
Jitna maine parha ha sab scholars ne future / margin trading haram karar de ha . Baki aap sab apne research zaroor karen
thank you for guiding
Phly muj b 80% haram lgti thi.. Future trading........ But yaha pa jo point muj ky dekhy agr leverage lety hy tu agr ap profit ma ja rhy phr tu nahi na aap un ko pay kr rhy.. I mean yaha pa simple ly ly ap ka. Luck pa depend hy.. Agr ap. Loss ma ho tu pay warna Profit... Mean fix nai hy ky un ko wapis krna
1. Question: (Futures/ Forward Contracts)
i) Two individuals, A and B enter into a contract on 1st January, 1996 under which A would sell a stock of company X at a price of $100 to B after an expiry of six months. B has an obligation to purchase at this price irrespective of the market price on 30th June 1996. Is this contract permissible in Shariah?
ii) Can this contract or the rights and obligations of A and B be transferred by either of them to a third party C?
iii) If the object of transaction is any commodity, or gold, silver or currency and not stocks, as in the case above, in what way is the validity or otherwise of the contract affected? It may be noted that the non- transferability of rights and obligations severely limits the possibility of speculation on Futures Exchanges.
A commonly held belief is that Futures contracts are prohibited when they are used for speculation. Does this imply that Futures contracts are permissible when these are used for hedging?
Comments by Mufti Taqi Usmani:
i) This is an example of a Futures transaction. The Futures transaction as in vogue in stock and commodities markets today are not permissible for two reasons. Firstly, it is a well recognised principle of the Shariah that sale or purchase cannot be affected for a future date. Therefore, all Forward and Futures transactions are invalid in Shariah. Secondly because in most of the Futures transactions, delivery of the commodities or their possession is not intended. In most cases, the transactions end up with the settlements of difference of prices only, which is not allowed in the Shariah.
ii) As Futures are not permissible, no rights or obligations can emanate therefrom. Therefore the question of transfer- ring these rights and obligations does not arise.
International Journal of Islamic Financial Services Vol. 1 No.1
iii) Futures transactions as explained above, are totally impermissible regardless of their subject matter. Similarly, it makes no difference whether these contracts are entered into for the purpose of speculation or for the purpose of hedging.
Crypto in general is halah to buy, sell or keep as an asset, but for binance (or any other exchange) only spot trading is halal, so margin trading, futures, staking, defi staking, earn services, loans, dual investments, borrowing ALL are Haram, and binance in particular even for normal staking gives you the rewards
Thank you for the feedback
Excellent bhai , Q k us main interest hain , aur easy konci ches hain jis k grny se bnda faida hota hain , mtlab Short ye sub hram hain , First of all ye jo Hr 8 Hour k bad fee lety hain ye sood hain...
Tumhare jahilpano ko jarur noble milna chahie.
To staking may coin ke value down aur up hute hai na jahil hu tum
Staking is a different thing
Interest itself is haram whether its fixed or not
Quran clearly mentioned gambling is prohibited
Future trading and margen trading are also type of gambling ... In simple words Satie bazi .....
Surat No 2 : سورة البقرة - Ayat No 219
یَسۡئَلُوۡنَکَ عَنِ الۡخَمۡرِ وَ الۡمَیۡسِرِؕ قُلۡ فِیۡہِمَاۤ اِثۡمٌ کَبِیۡرٌ وَّ مَنَافِعُ لِلنَّاسِ ۫ وَ اِثۡمُہُمَاۤ اَکۡبَرُ مِنۡ نَّفۡعِہِمَا ؕ وَ یَسۡئَلُوۡنَکَ مَا ذَا یُنۡفِقُوۡنَ ۬ ؕ قُلِ الۡعَفۡوَؕ کَذٰلِکَ یُبَیِّنُ اللّٰہُ لَکُمُ الۡاٰیٰتِ لَعَلَّکُمۡ تَتَفَکَّرُوۡنَ ﴿۲۱۹﴾ۙ
پوچھتے ہیں : شراب اور جوئے کا کیا حکم ہے؟ : ان دونوں چیزوں میں بڑی خرابی ہے ۔ اگرچہ ان میں لوگوں کے لیے کچھ منافع بھی ہیں ، مگر ان کا گناہ ان کے فائدے سے بہت زیادہ ہے ۔
Surat No 5 : سورة المائدة - Ayat No 90
یٰۤاَیُّہَا الَّذِیۡنَ اٰمَنُوۡۤا اِنَّمَا الۡخَمۡرُ وَ الۡمَیۡسِرُ وَ الۡاَنۡصَابُ وَ الۡاَزۡلَامُ رِجۡسٌ مِّنۡ عَمَلِ الشَّیۡطٰنِ فَاجۡتَنِبُوۡہُ لَعَلَّکُمۡ تُفۡلِحُوۡنَ ﴿۹۰﴾
اے لوگو جو ایمان لائے ہو ، یہ شراب اور جوا اور یہ آستانے اور پانسے ، یہ سب گندے شیطانی کام ہیں ، ان سے پرہیز کرو ، امیّد ہے کہ تمہیں فلاح نصیب ہوگی ۔
what is benifit of exchanges in providing leverages to uss?
Excellent video on a sensitive issue . You explained it very well. I am totally agreed with you.
All assets in world are speculative in nature. The concept of assets have changed in the modern world. Its not the physical nature but your virtual buying power that matters. Digital wallets like easypaisa are case in point. We need to do Ijtehad after studying the new form of Internet economy. I fully agree with the suppressive rental models.
I ma trader technical analysis meine kiya hai Sl hunting and market psychology ke courses kiya hai meri accuracy 90%.But ap future mein apni zati amount kam karen leverage na lein
Most huge important video. Should be make more video specific on this topic. Halaal haram its important. 85% people are confused and not coming in crypto only for this.
tottaly agreee also enginear saab same answer sir and logo ki tenshion ni laa ya sab khud matric fail ha or kabi crypto ka name ni suna
Mere hyal say jis chez mai apko loss hota hai to woh halal hota hai
Awr binance mai loss hota hai
Agar apko serf profit milta ho toh phir chances haram ki hai
Lakin sir ismain ek or ehem point he kisi coin k sath apney munafey k liyain trade karna aisa hi he jaisy kisi karobari farm k sath karobar karaa.. Islammain ek point ye bhi he k aap jis k saath karobar karo investment karo to un k kaam dakho wo halal he ya haram... ager wo hamara paisa kisi haram karobar main laatey hain to yaqeenan wo haram hi hoga.. ab ye kistarha maloom karain k jis coin main hum invests kartey hain ... unka ka koi na koi bissiness to hoga wo kia he kisy pata karain..??
I really don't have any idea
Ap be acha aik jahil hu
Nice question
sir i have a request plz aik brief video bana den coinglass aur bitnodes pa ye ham jese beginners ka liye benefit hoga
Muqaddas bhai,
Interest (Sood) is Haram for both individual and Corporation as it lead to inflation, recession whereas rental model have asset between two people rent is the fee of using the place.
Future trading is Haram as it involves interest rate.
How inflation in bigger picture,
If bread company borrow loan from bank for expansion, he will add interest payment in Selling price of bread leading to inflation.
Thank you for helping
I agree with u islam may jo cheez haram hoti uskay pechay ek reason hoti ha
Beshak crypto physical form me nahi hai lekin ye digitally to maujood hai.....isse spot me buy karne par turant aapka kabza ho jaata hai....aur aap usse jaha chahe send kar sakte hai
You're right
Dealings with cryptocurrency futures contracts often involve paying or charging interest, buying or selling your financial obligations under the futures contract, and cash settlement of the futures contract which are all haram
Hello 👋 how can future trading be halal? Like when we buy or sell we don’t actually buy the coin itself you are just bitting on the price in futures without holding the coin means we don’t have ownership of the coin
Islam clearly says that you can't buy or sell what you don’t have ownership of
Second thing is that in the future we can do a short sale how can you explain that to us? How can you sell when you don’t even have ownership of an asset?
Please explain
Points to be noted
Ap plz moulana Tariq Masood Sahab ko plz es per invite kren yeh bt unsy puchain naa k Mirza Ali ko bula krr unsy puchy
Sir Sell trade halal hai ya haram? Q ke agr 1 cheez hum ne 10 per buy ki thi or iski price 20 ho gye to Hume profit ho jata hai. Lakin sell ki trade Mai Jub 1 cheez ki price 10 thi or uski price 5 ho gye to phir kesi profit ho gya. Pochne Ka maqsad yai hai ke sell ki trade ke peche logic kya hota hai?
For example aik coin ki price 10rs hai .Sell walai case mein Ap exchange ko kehtai Kai wo aik coin beich dein apkai nam ka aur 10rs apko dein dei.Aur jub price nechai ati for example 7rs Pai tu Ap aik coin khareed Kai exchange ko wapis kr detai aur 3rs apka profit hota .
sir Future ek kism ka betting hain or agr future trading halal hai to phr betting bhi halal huwa us m bhi do bndy ek dosry ko paise deten or dosri bt future m jo funding aati hai wo interest hai to kindly logo ko gumrah na kren ap ki jo raaye hai wo ap apny pass rkho baki public m share krna munasib nh q k log ap ki bato ko follow krty hain
Dear Qudoos Bhai,
My opinion on 7:31 is that Future Trading is Haram.
Let me explain why i think so..
Let’s suppose i put a long (buy) order at Market price. The amount is deducted from my balance which means i am now in buy position.
For a trade to happen, it’s necessary that I should own that commodity in exchange of the money i have paid.
Kindly explain, do i own / custody of BTC or whatever coin that i made long (buy)?
I think NO. Because it’s neither in my wallet nor i can send it to anyone else because i don’t own it.
Similarly, in opening a Short (sell) position, how is it possible that can i sell the coin, when I don’t already have it in my possession to make a sell trade?
bilkul sahi kaha bhai aap ne....ilmi aalim ne sahi research ni kiya islamic pov se...inhon ne sirf apna pov dy diya
Muqaddas Bhai aap bilkul sahi hai
Sir ye jo spot 3x aor 5 x aor ETH pa 10 x dekhata ha ye keya ha?hm tu spot mai lethy hn tu 3x 4x q?
iska matlab hai k aaap itna le sakte hayn
Agreed, but sir please clear it that we actually dont owns assets or commodities in futures contract, so how can we trade something that we dont owns. Is this halal?
According to him
interest in not haram
and rent is haram
" Kya baat hai paaji maza agay "
Sir future Trading ma agar ham funding rate nikal bhi dein tou usme ye masla ha k log khete hain woh contract based trading hain aur islam ma woh mana ha yani ap future ma ap price fix nhi karsakte. Iss k bare ma clear karne k liye zarori ha ap kisi scholar se jaldi rapta karein.
مزید برآں ، بنکنگ سیکٹر کو سود نہ کہنا اور رینٹ لینے پر آپ کو شبہ ہونا غلط ہے۔
یہ اپنا فلسفہ آپ کسی مفتی صاحب کے سامنے رکھیں وہ آپ کو سمجھا دیں گے۔
MashaAllah,
Disagree. Nabi SAW ka wo farman k "ek wakt ae ga k har banda sood me invlove hoga jo na le khae us tak uski boo pohnch jae ge". Ye Hadith clear banking ki taraf jati he. So banking wala sood b sood hi he.
Sir g Aoa. sir ap k ilm may izafa krtay huway ya kehna chahta hu k soood jo ha ya ghareeb banday ko or gareeb krta ha or ameer ko or ameer.
OR AGR KOI YEH KAAM KRRAHA HAI TOU KUCH SOCH SMJH KR HI KRRAHA HOA Q K INTEREST DENE WALAI KI ALLAH OR HAMARE NABI SE KHOLI JANG HAI AP ALLAH SE DILL SE ISHARA MANGO KAI JO KAAM MIEN KRNE JARAHA HN WO MERE DEEN KE CIRCLE MIEN ATA HAI YAA NH ALHAMDULILLAH MEENE DILL SE PHUCHA THA ALLAH SE ISHARA BHI MILA ALLAH KI TARAF SE KE YEH JAIZ HAI FUTURE TRADING KI BAAT KRRAHA HN MIEN I KNOW YOU ALL CAN'T BELIEVE THAT BUT IT'S TRUE
Bro. Bas ya bta do k kya ishara milla ha
Mera b khuj asa hi scen ha
Ap khuch bta sakte hn
@@ahtshamulhaq1763 bhai apko kia ishara mila please tell
Very gooddear sir bohut achy tarekhai sy samjaya Allah jaza e khair dhy ameen♥️
sood gareeb ke lie ho ya ameer k lie sood haram he. Jo sood pay krta he ammer ho ya gareeb sood pay krte waqt dono ko taqleef hoti he
Only spot trading is halal in binance
Kia binance future trading walon se sood nahi leta ?
I don't think so
Few examples here,,Email bhi physical nhi hai, Hawa bhi dekhayi nhi deti , internet ko Kitne logo ne physical dekhta hai,online banking transition bhi physically nhi Hoti ,to sawal yeh hy, kia in sab ka wajood nhi hai🤔🤔
Good points
Sir kuch kahtai hain kai yai physical nahi to it i value kaisai hai bitcoin
Because they don't understand it properly...
I think only spot trading is halal.
❤❤❤ great work
Sir,How it is possible to earn in short trade in future trading while the coin is dumping is it considerd as joa..
Same Question
Assalamualaikum
Sir ap ne yaha logo ko ik bt misguide kia pase k badly pesa hai wala kam thik hy or rent wagaira wala jo system hy wo thik nhi ap k nazriye k mutabiq
Jnb jis business me commodity involved ho wo halal hy jase hmny koi ghr ya dukan rent pe di tu yeh halal jb k pase k badly pesa sood hy
Baki ap ne bohat achy se guide kia hy viewers ko
Assalam O Alaikum Sir
Future trading ma price ki prediction pr betting lgai jati ha. Humary wallet ma koe assets nhe aty ya hum koe assets buy nhe krty. Jaha tak mujhy lgta ha humy iss sy kinara krna chaye Hazoor.
May Allah forgive us. 🙏
Agar technical , fundamental analysis or proce action ata hu phir kis tarhah bet lagate he ?
@@StopandAct brother yahan do points hain .
1- Aap asset khud own nahin karte poora , ye aik rule ha Islamic law main .
2- market manupilations ke jate hain , exchanges ki taraf se uske waja se aap liquidate hote ho .
@@mafiadesneakers bnda leverage kam rkhe ke liquidate na ho ?
@@StopandActbrother still it would be considered gambling . example Len , real estate ki .kuch bhe ho jaye value zero hosakte ha lekin property aap ki hi hoge .
Muqadda bhai please make a video on how to make our metamask wallet secure to avoid being hacked. I think it's most important for us to learn about this topic for protecting our life savings. Please consider my request. Thanks
Search on UA-cam ilmeaalim metamask
You are great.
I agree 💯 with your point of view
Can u please share your contact number to talk
Sir your teaching method is outstanding I am waiting for next analysis update
Great Effort Sir JazakAllah
I think you should invite eng. Mirza Ali on your youtube channel on this topic
Inshallah
@@ilmeaalim Muqasdas bhai ap unse please Contact kare aur un k sath aik Dedicated Crypto ka session kare
Hn ye thek rahy ga onko koi samjhanee wala nhi crypto ke baryy me
@@ilmeaalimYes Please Eagerly waiting for this.
In Islam you can not trade that is not yours.
There is a hadith on this you guys can search.
Doing Future trade is 100% haram.
It include interest it does not matter in what form the interest is.
In future trade you don’t own anything like you do in spot trade that is all borrow and it is in just a form of contract. You take/borrow coin/currency from exchange and do trade on that this is not allowed in islam.
Asalam o Aliekum.. humble request plzzz read ... Umeed hy Ap khairiyat sy ho gay Allah k fazal o karam sy.. newly mamlat chahy kisi bi Field sy releted ho un py haraaam k fatway lgny ki bari waja knowledge ki kami hy kyo k kisi bi mufti k samny jo sawal krne wala hy wo jo situation rakhy ga mufti sahib usy py fatwa dy gay ab to na sawal krne waly ko pora knowledge hy aur na mufti sahib ko. .... Ap engineer Muhammad Ali mirza sath podcast kry bht asani sy available hy wo har Sunday ko online ya academy me ...aur wo bht already janty bi hy like forex crypto wagera to ap un sath discuss kry ap apny sawalo k sath sath un ko btay bi k kon si market kaesy chlti hy aur sb k mutaliq un ka point of view lain jaesy k forex aur stock market aur share market aur crypto aur en sb me he margin aur future trading sy mutaliq...lakin plzzzz sawal kry aur phly unhy btay k es sawal k sath ye details hy ... JazakAllah
you don't teach spot trading in this course whyy??
Sir assalamualaikum sir Babydogeswap ae hai us main staking wagera ki video banae please ❤️💯
Inshallah
@@ilmeaalim 🥰🥰🙏❤️
Best your opinion great
AGREE 💯👍❤️ FROM KPK NOWSHERA FALAK NAZ.
The banks are going to die .The cryptos overcome
.
Levarage (Sood) is a guilty whether it is in solid form (like banking and rentle system ) or in digital form (like future trading )
The main purpose of it is decentralizatiin.
All kind of leverages support centralization so ,they oppose the opinion of wellfare
Shukriya sir from Saudia
Sir islamic banking aur nornal banking m play ap farak kern kindly . Ap donu ko 1 samj rhy hain.
Sir ap Khan rehty hain mujhy app say trading learn karna chata hon
you said right
thank you so much sir
Sir as for as this question is concerned, in person I think it as none of your business... Let the Islamic scholars i.e "scholars=Islamic Studies + Finance & Account". If I am wrong, I want you to correct me.
amazing video sir.
Great Sir
Lekin illm e aalim bhai very well explained but future is haraam
Hazoor meri aap sy request ha aap apni community ko future trading sy dur kr dyn. Allah Kareem aap ko bhot ajar dyn gy. May Allah bless us, May Allah forgive us.
Thanks for the feedback
We should stop others what they're doing specially if they think they're doing right and not harming us in anyway
Well done bro
Brother Hamri qoom kabhi b profit mai sy persantage nhi dy gi ya tw time pay kabhi rent nhi dyti agree krta h. Apki baat sy but Haji saab kon bany ga . Pakistaniyon ny hamesa ya hi kaha ha k loss/guzara hi ho raha ha. Sb asy nhi hoty but 80% liar's hi hain jinka kabhi profit nhi ho skta jo kaha hi nhi skty ha profit howa ha....
Sir Future trading me maker or taker fee hoti hai
fee to spot me bi dena hoti hai
@@angrywolverine1150 yes but Muqadas bhai keh rhy wo interest hai
I think wo interest ni exchange fee hai
@@angrywolverine1150 Ye ase hi hai jese mene koi platform dia logo k ap apna karobar kren or Khuxh hissa mjy b pay kren. Tou isme koi galt bat ni
@@thenaildesigns3821 If you search Funding rate formula. Us ma clear interest rate include hy
@@thenaildesigns3821 to bhai yehi bat hai
wohi fee agar pay karni ho future me har 4 hours me or wo fix nai hoti
agar long ki positions zyada hai to wo short walo fee dete
or short ki positions zyada hai to wo long walo ko fee dete
You must watch Zakir Nayak video about your bank interest.
Thank you
Bhai Mining par aik vedio bana ly...
Already avl search on UA-cam
Ilmeaalim mining
سر مفتی حضرات نے سپاٹ ٹریڈنگ کو
جأز قرار دیا ہے مفتی ارشاد اعجاز کا بیان سنیں
Link
مارجن کے ساتھ ساتھ فیوچر ٹریڈنگ بھی بغیر شک و شبہ کے حرام ہے۔
محترم، یہاں ایک پہلو آپ نے چھوڑ دیا۔ آپ یہاں سود کو ڈسکس کر رہے ہیں۔ حالانکہ ایک مفتی صاحب کا کہنا تھا کہ فیوچر ٹریڈنگ میں ٹریڈر، ایکسچینج کے ساتھ شرط لگاتا ہے کہ ریٹ فلاں پرائس تک جائے گا۔ اگر یہ شرط جیت گیا تو پرافٹ اگر آپ شرط ہار گئے تو پرافٹ میں ایکسچینج ہوگی۔
I think keh ye baat AP crypto battles ki kar rahay han
Kyun keh battle ma shart lagai jati ha keh price up jei ge ya down .
Thanks
@@hamzagraphicdesign8940 فیوچر میں ایسا نہیں ہوتا؟
@@rashidfarman Nhi
Future ma sirf AP leverage letay ho
Bhai app leverage na lo Apne paiso se trade kar lo simple
@@tipusultan-yv4nx best spot hi ha lalach ka chakar ma Future ma na Jao tou acha ha
Sir 1 bat clear ker de. Forex mein jo lot size hota us mein bhi to loan le ker hi lot buy ki jati hai. Usa sab halal khte hai or crypto mein future trading ko haram.
Good point
Bhai sab bol rahy hain Future is Haram....waja btao sath ke kesy Haram hei
because that's what they believe .. and I do respect them
Please 🙏 sir bc game earning app ky bary ma video bna Dy full detail ma
Inshallah
Soood ka nazam ni laya gya thaa tb zakat ka kaha gya tha...
Agar aap ko 1000 chahiye or aap k pas 900 hai and you want 100 more, aap ko bank se qarz lena pr rha
To technically aap ghareeb hi hai.
Maybe
Your logic didn't apply on all millionaires and billionaires who always raise funding before and after launching their businesses and expansion
@@ilmeaalim ni smj aai ye
But chill
Cuz na aap mufti hai na me 🙂
Love you sir
1st one
Hilal or haram par or sood par aap ka nazria munasib nai
nice sooch
You doing good educating people baki hamary mulla or mufti bhee bss name ke ha pata inkow bhee kuch nahi
Acha rich lah tu sood nahi our garib lah tu sood ...wah
Saving account Jo hota Hy wo Haram Hy
Lovw u😊
future is haram.
Sir great
Butt sahib app crypto k shabaz Sharif hai good job sir g
Nice dress Butt sahib nice colour
Sir Khudar jis bat ka ilam na ho to chup rahna he bahtr hota hai mai or ap Kon hoty hai halal ko haram ya haram ko halal kahny waly i hope do you understand
Future trade juwa haa juwaa Islam maa haram haa...
Bai criptocurrency bg to ni jata
Disagree bro, I think you rethink over riba concept
bro aap kisi aalim se es barai mai comfirm karle buhut acha hoga
ulama main itfaaq nai .. gamdi sab shayd agree hayn meri approach se .. lakin dosre gamdi saab ko kafir kehte hayn ... karayn tu kya karayn
Future trading haram ha bilkul
Brother in Islam you don't know
Thank you