Loved the old gymnastics!! They have difficult routines today, but they all look so stiff, so rigid... Back in the days they seemed like they were floating!! It is mesmerizing to watch the old routines! Nadia Comăneci and Olga Korbut were perfect!
I also miss some things about the old gymnastics. However, the modern style seems healthier for the gymnasts - they can be on top of their game even in their late 20s and early 30s. And luckily there still are other forms of gymnastics with the gracefulness gymnasts used to have
This admiration for thinness is what forces these women to starve themselves to 💀th. ALL of them are pressured to maintain thinness. You could’ve just praised her grace and skill without saying anything about her body.
Nadia's movements have impeccable grace and Simone's have incredible power. Both are admirable in their own way. For me, gymnastics means more grace than strength and that's why number 1 for me is Nadia. She was also noted for her incredible strength which explains the stability of her movements, but she still had grace. Many times she looked like she was flying, it's incredible to see.
Simone Biles has incredible power because she executes her exercises on completely different equipment. The modern floor exercises f.e are executed on an elastic floor. So the comparison between these two is not fair.
Both great....but Nadia is more enjoyable to watch. There was a more youthful innocence to her. Biles though is athlete extraordinaire. Amazing agility and power.
Your comment is about as racist and biased and unable to accept reality as it comes!!! You my friend is why God made Black Strong Beautiful Elegant and Royalty!!! In a League of Their Own and You Too Racist to Admit and Admire!!! The actual more hate the stronger and more beautiful black woman becomes it’s a scientific equation now!!!!!!!
@@estrellitasyduendes. Olga y Elena también tienen elegancia y fueron las únicas que hicieron el truco más peligroso, hasta la rutina de Elena en esos tiempos fue mucho mejor que Nadia
I have loved Nadia Comaneci since a child but these two Athletes are just the best with in there era . Nadia has this grace a style & unique power to her delicate physic and Simone is just a super talented power house whose abilities are just shockingly beautiful . They are just the best and the compilation was awesome in reflecting that. No one can replace Olga charm& courage , Nadia perfect grace & strength, Simone power & talent. Three beautiful women & Amazing women forever holding them to high to high esteem ❤❤❤❤🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌 unforgettable talent
Nadia, it is harder to move slower more graceful. When I am working out it way harder do do an exercise if i slow it down, than if I do it fast. Nadia could have added force or more speed, but it was different back then. It was more about grace and like floating. Simone could never execute such an exercise like Nadia did. Anyway, different scorings nowadays. It was about more about rhythmicity.
Both Are Legends !!!!! But you can't compare Gymnists from different decades. If it were Not For NADIA and others we would not have been Blessed to see Simone Biles and others who came before her .
Yeah, they go for difficulty to get higher scores, but the roughness and mistakes this comes with, though the score is good, almost make it look like a different sport, there is balance but no grace. The gymnasts are impressive of course, these are just the rules of the game they choose to play by. I have huge respect for the gymnasts who try to achieve both by keeping the grace and artistry.
Nadia remains a 'Perfect 10' in the world's history books with her natural, fluid, and graceful moves. Simone on the other hand is an amazing athlete proclaimed by major 10-second tic-toc media outlets as a 'goat' so they can cut to commercials and sell us more products and feelings. The winner here is clear: Nadia! Good luck to the hard working athletes of tomorrow that may one day make history again!
@@febe11111 non si può paragonare perché attrezzi moderni, tappeti con molle oggi molto imbottiti, cavallo facile da prendere, la tecnica si è evoluta soprattutto per questi nuovi attrezzi. Nadia alla trave e alle parallele è perfetta, la Biles pesante, storta e può solamente fare più evoluzioni e numeri di salti, ma con una qualità molto molto inferiore. Meglio al corpo libero e cavallo, ma appunto gli attrezzi sono moderni e in quelli degli anni settanta si sarebbe ammazzata.
@cippycippy123 SPOKEN LIKE A TRUE RACIST! THEY ARE BOTH GOOD. POWER IS ALWAYS MAGNIFICENT! NADIA WAS EXCELLENT FOR HER TIME. TIME CHANGES NOTHING STAYS THE DAME EXCEPT WHITE PEOPLE AND THEIR EVIL RACISM, JEALOUSY, AND HATRED!
@@Trent-ls6em It doesn't at all. Her movements don't look effortless and sound and look heavy despite being under 5 foot, Nadia looks ethereal in how she moves.
Las dos son grandes, pero Nadia revolucionó este deporte. Viendo sus videos parecía una mariposa revoloteando con gracia y hacía ver ejercicios complejos como si fueran fáciles. Una artista en cada aparato. En cambio Biles es una pequeña fisioculturista con una fuerza bruta increíble, pero sin gracia. La Gimnasia Artistica debería llamarse solo Gimnasia porque la parte artística se ha perdido para siempre. Nadia será por siempre la cara de la gimnasia, la chica 10…La mejor de todos los tiempos.
After 2024 Simone is the Goat and Nadia would have been 2nd or third- the lift, power, landing, DIFFICULTY of Simone is next level for now! And No Drugs Just God given DNA!! I know it’s hard for some people to Believe Believe Believe!!!!!!!!
@@xana5649 It's normal that Nadia's record is beaten because we're talking about 1976. I know you're Romanian and she's your idol, but the truth hurts. It's up to you to dream. Open your eyes and see what Simone is doing! Nadia is a legend who was the first to set this record, but every record will be broken one day. If Nadia were judged in 2024 with her performances, she wouldn't get 10/10. The world evolves, and so do techniques
Nadia is the absolute best, so sad to see what gymnastics has become nowadays, acrobatics not gymnastic, these are two separate concepts. It was amazing to watch gymnastics in the past, now not so much!
Today's Olympic gymnastics floors are more bouncy compared to those used in the 1970s. The floors have evolved significantly over the decades to enhance performance and safety. Modern gymnastics floors are spring-loaded, which provides more bounce and allows gymnasts to achieve greater height and power in their routines. This change not only enables more complex and dynamic skills but also helps in reducing the impact on gymnasts' bodies, thereby minimizing the risk of injuries. In contrast, the floors used in the 1970s were less advanced, offering less rebound and shock absorption.
How anyone can say Simone is better is beyond me. Nadia is surefooted with incredible muscular strength. Anyone who performs exercises slowly will know how much strength and control is required to execute the movement
Champions vary in their expressions like no two women are alike. Sometimes I am a graceful warrior, sometimes, a graceful butterfly. I don't believe in one "goat". More like a level of genius to be shared and that will be added to.
What I notice about older gymnastics is less teetering on balance beam and more overall flexibility. I still havent seen anyone move like Nadia, that's just so different. Simones complexity and power is revolutionary to the sport of modern era.
Au J.O 2024, combien de déséquilibre pour Simone Biles, des sauts très hauts et très techniques car plus d'évolution au niveau des praticables. Des entrées où je t'en mets plein la vue, mais pas très élégantes. Nadia avait 14 ans à Montréal et 10 sur tous les agrès. Et si j'écris ceci c'est qu'une commentatrice vient de dire de Simone Biles, "c'est la nouvelle Nadia Comaneci", Au secours! Comparer des réceptions parfaites, des notes parfaites et je parle des J.O, avec Simone Biles au J.O 2024, qui à la barre plie ses jambes, réceptionne mal ou est déséquilibrée souvent. Qui est cette commentatrice qui n'a jamais dû flouer un tapis, une poutre, un tremplin, ou même connaitre et seulement voir les J.O de Montréal en replay, quelqu'un qui en tous les cas pense que la gymnastique c'est sauter, plus haut et plus fort que tous, lol
Simone Biles à 27 ans, comparez NADIA au même âge, elles n'ont pas n'ont plus la même hauteur... Simone peut s'envoler très haut car elle a 1 grande puissance qui peut causer qq déséquilibres... Mais déjà, on ne compare pas ces 2 immenses athlètes ou alors c'est comparer le parfum d'1 rose odorante avec 1 jasmin odorant, c'est 1 question de gout personnel...
Gymnastics today and gymnastics yesterday are very different, so direct comparison is difficult. Nadia was more graceful and more fun to watch. It also seems effortless when watching the great gymnast of yesterday. Today’s gymnastics look like they are muscling and powering their way through the routines
@@kreishaushaile4129A person of Color was president of the United States. What the fuck are you on? Victim juice? Nadia grew up with Nicolae Ceaușescu as Dictator of Romania and behind the Soviet iron Curtain on Foodstamps and zero Freedom. You must be a really special kind of stupid if you think Nadia didn't have it 100 X harder.
@@kreishaushaile4129 Nadia grew up in Europe's North Korea at that time, Romania, with one of the most brutal communist regimes. Funny how you're playing the race card
Both are great, but Nadia was a graceful ballerina, an artist. While Biles is a tiny bodybuilder with a lot a power but no grace at all. The sport should be called Gymnastics only, not longer Artiistic Gymnastics since the artistic part of the sport is lost forever. Nadia is the face of Gymnastics, the perfect 10 girl…The GOAT.
After 2024 Simone is the Goat and Nadia would have been 2nd or third- the lift, power, landing, DIFFICULTY of Simone is next level for now! And No Drugs Just God given DNA!! I know it’s hard for some people to Believe Believe Believe!!!!!!!!
@@anomali3779 siamo seri, Biles è pesantissima e storta, ha potenza nel salto ma negli anni settanta con i vecchi attrezzi e il tappeto senza molle si sarebbe ammazzata. La Comaneci non aveva il cavallo nuovo largo e con la pedana a molla, ma uno stretto e lungo che se sbagliavi ad arrivare con le mani era finita. Non aveva il tappeto imbottito di molle per fare le evoluzioni della Biles, nella trave che forse è rimasta più simile la Biles ha pure perso, storta di gambe, caduta...Nadia era impeccabile e faceva salti mortali perfetti, con gambe dritte da manuale.
For the foolish people saying simone is the goat, I suggest you check routines from 70s-90s. She should stand in line after eastern european swans. Nadia and Olga in particular.
@@capeverdeanprincess4444Biles is not a goat but a bull with brute force. Nadia looks like a graceful leopard if I have to compare their movements to wild animals
@@capeverdeanprincess4444 Simone is the best tumbler, not so great on the floor or uneven bars. The sport is called artistic gymnastics, not power gymnastics. The scoring was changed to benefit tumblers and viewers are getting bored of the same repetitive tricks.
I wasnt even part of this life oww nadia like a balleria gentle fragile soft delicate 2024 not one gymnast could never top her she was unique and rare she will go dowm in history as the best
Nadia had absolutely perfect body proportions. Light as a feather and with pure perfection. I don’t cry when I watch Simone. I always do watching Nadia. Perfection and grace touch your soul! I sat up on an island in Canada in our summer home with a very old black-and-white television (that got one channel) watching the Montreal Olympics in July 1976. Who would’ve thought back then that we’d ever see it replayed, but now we can watch her all day and night if we want to!
Last time,Simone landings almost on the reffs table,out of the carpet and still win the ol silver !!! I've never seen somenthing like this in the gymnastic history!
If Simone or Nadia were both born in the same generation (whether it have been during Nadia's era or Simone's) It's really difficult to determine who would have been better. Had Nadia been born in modern day where we are currently her routine probably would have been completely different, same for Simone had she been born during Nadia's time. The flare and power they both display is just amazing.
Nadia’s moves has more art and elegance; biles’ is more like sporty and athletic; the way it was filmed also affects how we view it- compared to 1976; video technology has become more refined so the tone; pace; definition impacts the video presentation and lastly, biles’ uses bouncier floors that’s why she reaches greater heights; Nadia’s time it was all “raw” - no facility support. Hence NADIA IS THE GREATEST OF ALL TIME. ❤
@@zimunda3252 Mate it's note about hate, I appreciate Simone, but the two have very different styles. I simply like Nadia's fluency and I believe gymnastics is more about elegance and not about force (not circus acrobatics).
@@AdrialiciouS-JoyNadia is just slower which gives a more fluid illusion. Simone is doing more with the same amount of time so things are quicker. Otherwise, how exactly is Nadia more graceful?
A ginástica americana é muito forte com sautos altíssimos e com um grande grau de dificuldade, já a ginástica Européia decende da escola soviética com a ginástica mais próxima ao balét e a leveza na execução dos movimentos, não há como comparar a ginástica dos atletas de difentes gerações por quê mudam sérias questões como critério de avaliações elementos com dificuldade e a própria genética. hj em dia tanto as mulheres como os homens possuem o corpo mais fortes!
Oggi hanno attrezzi più facili, tappeti con molle, cavallo largo facile da individuare, pedana a molla, molte cose che aiutano nel salto e nel controllo, che permettono evoluzioni che prima non si potevano fare. Nadia avrebbe potuto fare molto di più con questi attrezzi moderni, ma di base avrebbe avuto la grazia e il fisico per eseguire da manuale come sempre. La Biles è storta, spesso pesante, tremolante e sbilanciata e questo con i vecchi attrezzi avrebbe peggiorato ulteriormente la situazione non permettendo di saltare come fa oggi. Ha potenza nel salto, ma come si è visto soprattutto nella trave è imprecisa, storta, anche brutta da vedere.
then we should go to definitions. for instance the floor routine. the definitions says: The routine is choreographed in advance, and is composed of acrobatic and dance elements. Above all others, this event allows the gymnast to express their personality through their dance and musical style. The moves that are choreographed in the routine must be precise, in sync with the music, and entertaining. the same goes for balance beam routine. elements of BALANCE, flexibility and...DANCE. it s not about "soviet school". it s about what sport is meant to be. speaking about schools...let s not forget that the usa began to matter in elite competitions after bella karoly [the romanian coach] had defected to the usa.
Naďa měla vyhodu dlouhých nohou , ale to vo předváděla ve srovnání s dnešními gymnastkami , by nestačilo. Je to legenda , ale všechno se vyvíjí... To je normální evoluce)
Las dos son excelentes Nadia en su momento se convirtió en un icono que hasta las nuevas generaciones respetan y admiran, Simone tiene ahora su momento y es extraordinaria y ha logrado ser también una de las más respetadas
Basta vedere il video la Nadia Comaneci era più elegante e raffinata in tutto quello che faceva la Biles è potente e non ha eleganza nei movimenti la Rumena e bella e sinuosa della statunitense ❤
Los estilos son diferentes, supongo que también por la complexión de cada una. Nadia es elegante, suave y fluida. Pero Billies es enérgica, fuerte y poderosa. Bien por las dos 🤗
Yo lo que noto desde mí total ignorancia es que Nadia literalmente era como una pluma, esos movimientos tan suaves, esas terminaciones súper delicadas... Y a Simón la veo como muy potente, con mucha fuerza, realmente muy genia pero sus movimientos son más bruscos, sus terminaciones son con mucha fuerza.
Ce que propose Simone est plus spectaculaire on va dire et la difficulté dans ses exécutions est supérieure Nadia est élégante, soignée et semble si légère Ça n'a rien à voir, ce n'est pas du tout la meme gymnastique Nadia restera à mes yeux la référence de la gym Mais j"aime beaucoup la technicité de Simone ce qu'elle accompli est d'une telle diffuculté ...
È molto più difficile fare tutto da manuale e preciso e leggero, che fare i salti della Biles storti e con le gambe tremolanti nonostante oggi poi ci siano attrezzature molto moderne e migliori. La Biles non potrebbe mai riuscire a fare le cose come le fa Nadia. Nadia potrebbe invece fare quasi tutto quello che fa la Biles, con una precisione e fluidità molto migliori.
Please, Nadia IS PURE GRACE AND BEAUTY... SHE IS THE BEST! Gmnastics isn't just a heavy klunk doing circus tumbling. Join the circus if that is what you want to do. Tourescheva, Nadia, Olga, Rhetton - the BEST!
After 2024 Simone is the Goat and Nadia would have been 2nd or third- the lift, power, landing, DIFFICULTY of Simone is next level for now! And No Drugs Just God given DNA!! I know it’s hard for some people to Believe Believe Believe!!!!!!!!
![[HD] Tonya Harding - 1994 Lillehammer Olympic - Free Skating](/img/n.gif)
Loved the old gymnastics!! They have difficult routines today, but they all look so stiff, so rigid... Back in the days they seemed like they were floating!! It is mesmerizing to watch the old routines!
Nadia Comăneci and Olga Korbut were perfect!
Oui même teodora
Agree!!
Theodora Ungureanu was great too. No one like Comaneci, Korbut, Ponor and Ungureanu Actual gimnasts are heavier and less artistic
Veja a história de Elena então.
I also miss some things about the old gymnastics. However, the modern style seems healthier for the gymnasts - they can be on top of their game even in their late 20s and early 30s. And luckily there still are other forms of gymnastics with the gracefulness gymnasts used to have
Simone is perfect and hard like a rock.But Nadia is a beautiful dream of elegance and perfection.
Always Nadia.❤❤❤
I've loved Nadia since I was a child, she has the body of a ballerina and just melts you with her grace
This admiration for thinness is what forces these women to starve themselves to 💀th. ALL of them are pressured to maintain thinness. You could’ve just praised her grace and skill without saying anything about her body.
@xMUNECAx a lot of them were naturally thin and petite. They had grace and elegance. Biles looks like a dwarf with big muscles.
Nadia flies like a bird ora an angel. She defies gravity with elegance and grace. Perfection
Nadia is a queen..🎉❤
Nadia's movements have impeccable grace and Simone's have incredible power. Both are admirable in their own way.
For me, gymnastics means more grace than strength and that's why number 1 for me is Nadia. She was also noted for her incredible strength which explains the stability of her movements, but she still had grace. Many times she looked like she was flying, it's incredible to see.
Reality 🎉❤
Totally agree. I don’t cry when I watch Simone. I always do watching Nadia. Perfection and grace touch your soul
Simone Biles has incredible power because she executes her exercises on completely different equipment. The modern floor exercises f.e are executed on an elastic floor. So the comparison between these two is not fair.
Both great....but Nadia is more enjoyable to watch. There was a more youthful innocence to her. Biles though is athlete extraordinaire. Amazing agility and power.
Watching Nadia is like watching preschoolers do gymnastics.
Your comment is about as racist and biased and unable to accept reality as it comes!!! You my friend is why God made Black Strong Beautiful Elegant and Royalty!!! In a League of Their Own and You Too Racist to Admit and Admire!!! The actual more hate the stronger and more beautiful black woman becomes it’s a scientific equation now!!!!!!!
@@eddiejames9827Zici? Preferi achetul de mușchi, fără gât, fără grație, fără eleganță!???
Ignorant@@eddiejames9827
@@eddiejames9827tie iti plac muschii si anabolizantele?
Para mí NADiA es la mejor siempre será es única
Cierto. Demasiado sobrevaloran a la morena sin gracia de Biles. Toda tosca y robótica sus movimientos.
@@brucegeminis2008 Ay callate. No es necesario derribar a alguien para elevar a otro. Hablar de su raza es un asco. 👉🏽🚪
☹️☹️☹️☹️
Nadia has elegance of an angel
No entiendo tanta publicidad a Nadia siendo que Elena y Olga fueron mejores
@@Ttrttr-i2q ya te respondieron. Tiene la elegancia de un ángel.
@@estrellitasyduendes. Olga y Elena también tienen elegancia y fueron las únicas que hicieron el truco más peligroso, hasta la rutina de Elena en esos tiempos fue mucho mejor que Nadia
she won four gold medals and two silver medals at the Summer Olympic Games, in which she competed in 1972 and 1976@@Ttrttr-i2q
@@Ttrttr-i2qElena Muckina 😢RIP she's Angel now ❤️ 🙏
I have loved Nadia Comaneci since a child but these two Athletes are just the best with in there era . Nadia has this grace a style & unique power to her delicate physic and Simone is just a super talented power house whose abilities are just shockingly beautiful . They are just the best and the compilation was awesome in reflecting that. No one can replace Olga charm& courage , Nadia perfect grace & strength, Simone power & talent. Three beautiful women & Amazing women forever holding them to high to high esteem ❤❤❤❤🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌 unforgettable talent
Nadia is unique.
Nadia, it is harder to move slower more graceful.
When I am working out it way harder do do an exercise if i slow it down, than if I do it fast.
Nadia could have added force or more speed, but it was different back then. It was more about grace and like floating. Simone could never execute such an exercise like Nadia did.
Anyway, different scorings nowadays.
It was about more about rhythmicity.
Nadia was more gentle than Simone, but Simone has real power. Both of them are amazing in their own way :)
👍👍
After 2024 Simone is the Goat and Nadia would have been 2nd or third- the lift, power, landing, DIFFICULTY of Simone is next level for now!
@@anomali3779Bouncy floors helped Biles jump higher. Nadia didn’t use such floors. So Nadia is the perfect 10 girl. Full stop.
@@margui6224Agree, the greatest of all time, but since 2020 we’re probably not allowed to give it to her!
@@margui6224Nadia is simply not as athletic as Simone.
Both Are Legends !!!!! But you can't compare Gymnists from different decades. If it were Not For NADIA and others we would not have been Blessed to see Simone Biles and others who came before her .
True! Thanks for watching!
thanks but if not Nadia there would not be a Simone Nadia still the G.O.A.T.
I agree hon!
Uneven bar in the past were more difficult and dangerous
The grace is gone from it, all current competitors. None of them float like a feather the way these old Soviet girls did. It's all acrobatics now.
I agree. Olga Korbut and Nadia Comaneci were elegant, artistic queens.
I agree!
Yeah, they go for difficulty to get higher scores, but the roughness and mistakes this comes with, though the score is good, almost make it look like a different sport, there is balance but no grace.
The gymnasts are impressive of course, these are just the rules of the game they choose to play by.
I have huge respect for the gymnasts who try to achieve both by keeping the grace and artistry.
Agreed but Nadia is Romanian
Nadia remains a 'Perfect 10' in the world's history books with her natural, fluid, and graceful moves. Simone on the other hand is an amazing athlete proclaimed by major 10-second tic-toc media outlets as a 'goat' so they can cut to commercials and sell us more products and feelings. The winner here is clear: Nadia! Good luck to the hard working athletes of tomorrow that may one day make history again!
Knock it the hell off,Simone is outstanding,Nadia was good in her time but their is no comparison between the too.
@@febe11111 non si può paragonare perché attrezzi moderni, tappeti con molle oggi molto imbottiti, cavallo facile da prendere, la tecnica si è evoluta soprattutto per questi nuovi attrezzi. Nadia alla trave e alle parallele è perfetta, la Biles pesante, storta e può solamente fare più evoluzioni e numeri di salti, ma con una qualità molto molto inferiore. Meglio al corpo libero e cavallo, ma appunto gli attrezzi sono moderni e in quelli degli anni settanta si sarebbe ammazzata.
@cippycippy123 SPOKEN LIKE A TRUE RACIST! THEY ARE BOTH GOOD. POWER IS ALWAYS MAGNIFICENT! NADIA WAS EXCELLENT FOR HER TIME. TIME CHANGES NOTHING STAYS THE DAME EXCEPT WHITE PEOPLE AND THEIR EVIL RACISM, JEALOUSY, AND HATRED!
Nadia❤
Nadia had grace. #1.
What is your definition of grace? She just moves slower
@@Trent-ls6em let me help you out. Definition of Grace. noun
1.
simple elegance or refinement of movement.
"she moved through with effortless grace"
@israel8847 perfect so you can see how with that definition, it applies to both Simone and Nadia.
@@Trent-ls6em It doesn't at all. Her movements don't look effortless and sound and look heavy despite being under 5 foot, Nadia looks ethereal in how she moves.
@@Trent-ls6emNadia is sure footed and light footed. Controlled
Las dos son grandes, pero Nadia revolucionó este deporte. Viendo sus videos parecía una mariposa revoloteando con gracia y hacía ver ejercicios complejos como si fueran fáciles. Una artista en cada aparato. En cambio Biles es una pequeña fisioculturista con una fuerza bruta increíble, pero sin gracia. La Gimnasia Artistica debería llamarse solo Gimnasia porque la parte artística se ha perdido para siempre.
Nadia será por siempre la cara de la gimnasia, la chica 10…La mejor de todos los tiempos.
Nadia floated on the beam. Simone is a great athlete but lacks artistry.
Nadia has absolutely no equals. 🐐
😂🤦♂️
After 2024 Simone is the Goat and Nadia would have been 2nd or third- the lift, power, landing, DIFFICULTY of Simone is next level for now! And No Drugs Just God given DNA!! I know it’s hard for some people to Believe Believe Believe!!!!!!!!
@@anomali3779hahahahaha, keep dreaming.
Simone so fat. No elegance there.
@@xana5649 It's normal that Nadia's record is beaten because we're talking about 1976. I know you're Romanian and she's your idol, but the truth hurts. It's up to you to dream. Open your eyes and see what Simone is doing! Nadia is a legend who was the first to set this record, but every record will be broken one day. If Nadia were judged in 2024 with her performances, she wouldn't get 10/10. The world evolves, and so do techniques
Nadia is the absolute best, so sad to see what gymnastics has become nowadays, acrobatics not gymnastic, these are two separate concepts. It was amazing to watch gymnastics in the past, now not so much!
Nadia is untouchable. #1
Please it's not even close and you know it. They hate is spewing from your veins
Agreed Wendell. Nadia=🐐
@@zimunda3252agreed Simone=🐐
I agree with you Wendell. Nadia has no equals.
@@DonJuan-my2rz You're right!! Simone is far above her. 😂
Today's Olympic gymnastics floors are more bouncy compared to those used in the 1970s. The floors have evolved significantly over the decades to enhance performance and safety. Modern gymnastics floors are spring-loaded, which provides more bounce and allows gymnasts to achieve greater height and power in their routines. This change not only enables more complex and dynamic skills but also helps in reducing the impact on gymnasts' bodies, thereby minimizing the risk of injuries. In contrast, the floors used in the 1970s were less advanced, offering less rebound and shock absorption.
The same applies to the balance beam, uneven bars and horse. All are springier now with more flex and rebound.
How anyone can say Simone is better is beyond me. Nadia is surefooted with incredible muscular strength. Anyone who performs exercises slowly will know how much strength and control is required to execute the movement
Because people are not blind.
Poate că gimnastica a evoluat, dar nu în bine! A pierdut eleganța, dansul la sol, frumusețea. A câștigat acrobație de circ!
Champions vary in their expressions like no two women are alike. Sometimes I am a graceful warrior, sometimes, a graceful butterfly. I don't believe in one "goat". More like a level of genius to be shared and that will be added to.
Nadia's gymnastic looks so graceful and light as a feather. Absolutely beautiful to watch
What I notice about older gymnastics is less teetering on balance beam and more overall flexibility. I still havent seen anyone move like Nadia, that's just so different. Simones complexity and power is revolutionary to the sport of modern era.
Au J.O 2024, combien de déséquilibre pour Simone Biles, des sauts très hauts et très techniques car plus d'évolution au niveau des praticables. Des entrées où je t'en mets plein la vue, mais pas très élégantes. Nadia avait 14 ans à Montréal et 10 sur tous les agrès. Et si j'écris ceci c'est qu'une commentatrice vient de dire de Simone Biles, "c'est la nouvelle Nadia Comaneci", Au secours! Comparer des réceptions parfaites, des notes parfaites et je parle des J.O, avec Simone Biles au J.O 2024, qui à la barre plie ses jambes, réceptionne mal ou est déséquilibrée souvent. Qui est cette commentatrice qui n'a jamais dû flouer un tapis, une poutre, un tremplin, ou même connaitre et seulement voir les J.O de Montréal en replay, quelqu'un qui en tous les cas pense que la gymnastique c'est sauter, plus haut et plus fort que tous, lol
Simone Biles à 27 ans, comparez NADIA au même âge, elles n'ont pas n'ont plus la même hauteur... Simone peut s'envoler très haut car elle a 1 grande puissance qui peut causer qq déséquilibres... Mais déjà, on ne compare pas ces 2 immenses athlètes ou alors c'est comparer le parfum d'1 rose odorante avec 1 jasmin odorant, c'est 1 question de gout personnel...
Gymnastics today and gymnastics yesterday are very different, so direct comparison is difficult.
Nadia was more graceful and more fun to watch. It also seems effortless when watching the great gymnast of yesterday. Today’s gymnastics look like they are muscling and powering their way through the routines
Nadia was the turning point in gymnastics, the best in history, just like Pelé, Federer, and so on
I mean, Nadia and all her generation is far ahead. Just considering the conditions they had to face...
You talk about Nadia’s conditions,ha did you forget Simon is a person of Color.Please give it a rest .Give Praise and let it go!
Without Nadia the difficulty wouldn’t be where it’s at today.Now we have Simone that has pushed the level of difficulty for the next Generation.
@@kreishaushaile4129and? Americans worship blacks anyway.
@@kreishaushaile4129A person of Color was president of the United States. What the fuck are you on? Victim juice? Nadia grew up with Nicolae Ceaușescu as Dictator of Romania and behind the Soviet iron Curtain on Foodstamps and zero Freedom. You must be a really special kind of stupid if you think Nadia didn't have it 100 X harder.
@@kreishaushaile4129 Nadia grew up in Europe's North Korea at that time, Romania, with one of the most brutal communist regimes. Funny how you're playing the race card
Both are great, but Nadia was a graceful ballerina, an artist. While Biles is a tiny bodybuilder with a lot a power but no grace at all. The sport should be called Gymnastics only, not longer Artiistic Gymnastics since the artistic part of the sport is lost forever.
Nadia is the face of Gymnastics, the perfect 10 girl…The GOAT.
Nadia extraordinaria, elegante y delicada
Nadia era uma bailarina. Biles é uma atleta de verdade!
Las dos son extraordinarias, muchas gimnastas son excelentes, Catalina ponor y tantas fueron perfectas !
Incomparables cada una fue la mejor en su época.... la gimnasia evoluciono mucho. Vivan las dos por ser únicas
Nadia is a feather, Simone is a sledgehammer. No comparison.
After 2024 Simone is the Goat and Nadia would have been 2nd or third- the lift, power, landing, DIFFICULTY of Simone is next level for now! And No Drugs Just God given DNA!! I know it’s hard for some people to Believe Believe Believe!!!!!!!!
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂best comment
@@anomali3779I think Simone is awesome but she's a little too stiff as compared to how graceful Nadia was.
@@anomali3779 siamo seri, Biles è pesantissima e storta, ha potenza nel salto ma negli anni settanta con i vecchi attrezzi e il tappeto senza molle si sarebbe ammazzata. La Comaneci non aveva il cavallo nuovo largo e con la pedana a molla, ma uno stretto e lungo che se sbagliavi ad arrivare con le mani era finita. Non aveva il tappeto imbottito di molle per fare le evoluzioni della Biles, nella trave che forse è rimasta più simile la Biles ha pure perso, storta di gambe, caduta...Nadia era impeccabile e faceva salti mortali perfetti, con gambe dritte da manuale.
Nadia. #1
For the foolish people saying simone is the goat, I suggest you check routines from 70s-90s. She should stand in line after eastern european swans. Nadia and Olga in particular.
@@capeverdeanprincess4444Biles is not a goat but a bull with brute force. Nadia looks like a graceful leopard if I have to compare their movements to wild animals
@@margui6224 Well, Gymnastics is a sport. Simone is both powerful and graceful.
If you want grace go watch dancing.
@@capeverdeanprincess4444 figure skating and rhythmitic gymnastics are also sports but requires more grace than power
@@capeverdeanprincess4444 Simone is the best tumbler, not so great on the floor or uneven bars. The sport is called artistic gymnastics, not power gymnastics. The scoring was changed to benefit tumblers and viewers are getting bored of the same repetitive tricks.
@@anastasiyadimitrova-ff9qi In what universe is she graceful? Triangle shaped with huge back and shoulders, no balance, no soft landing.
A mí me encanta nadia y creo que es la mejor
Não há o que comparar! Nádia é a perfeição, simplesmente a melhor do mundo! Ainda está para nascer alguém que se compare a ela!
Exatamente
Biles humilha Nadia em todos os quesitos 😅
Nadia indudablemente
Nádia ❤
Nadia
There’s no real competition, Nadia is perfection, while Biles is strong but lacks elegance and finesse. Just my opinion.
Gimnastele de azi sunt ,,niște roboti" executa tehnic perfect dar nu ah fluiditate, gratie.
Dar asa sunt timpurile,și merita respectul meu. ❤❤❤❤❤
I can’t be impartial, I am able to judge a football match but not gymnastics, I rather Nadia….
NADIA ES UN ANGEL.....❤...Y SIMONE ES UN GRANDIOSA ATLETA
I wasnt even part of this life oww nadia like a balleria gentle fragile soft delicate 2024 not one gymnast could never top her she was unique and rare she will go dowm in history as the best
Nadia elengance and Simone power and strenght, both are wonderful
Nadia elegante. Simone super fuerte.
Both so amazing.
NADIA COMANECI ......NO ONE EQUALIZES HER AND LESS BEATS HER... THERE IS NO POINT OF COMPARISON......NADIA'S BODY IS THAT OF A GYMNAST
Nadia era un ángel, tenía una gracia y carisma inigualable, sin dudas la mejor de todos los tiempos
They are unique in their own way ❤ both enjoyable to watch. They are each like a different flower in the garden. And they both shine ✨ and amaze me.
Nadia had absolutely perfect body proportions. Light as a feather and with pure perfection. I don’t cry when I watch Simone. I always do watching Nadia. Perfection and grace touch your soul! I sat up on an island in Canada in our summer home with a very old black-and-white television (that got one channel) watching the Montreal Olympics in July 1976. Who would’ve thought back then that we’d ever see it replayed, but now we can watch her all day and night if we want to!
Last time,Simone landings almost on the reffs table,out of the carpet and still win the ol silver !!! I've never seen somenthing like this in the gymnastic history!
If Simone or Nadia were both born in the same generation (whether it have been during Nadia's era or Simone's) It's really difficult to determine who would have been better. Had Nadia been born in modern day where we are currently her routine probably would have been completely different, same for Simone had she been born during Nadia's time. The flare and power they both display is just amazing.
Nadia for sure
Definitivamente Nadia elegancia estética y fuerza Simón es solo fuerza bruta
Nadia’s moves has more art and elegance; biles’ is more like sporty and athletic; the way it was filmed also affects how we view it- compared to 1976; video technology has become more refined so the tone; pace; definition impacts the video presentation and lastly, biles’ uses bouncier floors that’s why she reaches greater heights; Nadia’s time it was all “raw” - no facility support. Hence NADIA IS THE GREATEST OF ALL TIME. ❤
Sorry guys but to compare Simone with Nadia is blasphemy.
Natia is much more gentle, elegand and fluent. ❤
Of course you say something like . Good thing numbers don't lie and it's not even close. The hate is coming out of your skin😂😂😂
@@zimunda3252 Mate it's note about hate, I appreciate Simone, but the two have very different styles. I simply like Nadia's fluency and I believe gymnastics is more about elegance and not about force (not circus acrobatics).
@@AdrialiciouS-Joynot true. Give credit when it’s due, will ya! Simone is the Goat. Numbers don’t lie.
@@as1rainbowThey do lie when the athlete uses drugs.
@@AdrialiciouS-JoyNadia is just slower which gives a more fluid illusion. Simone is doing more with the same amount of time so things are quicker. Otherwise, how exactly is Nadia more graceful?
NADIA ES LA PERFECCIÓN 🎉
Simone biles # 1 ❤ porque hace los mejores giros y es unica . Admiro a Nadia pero como Simone Biles no hay ninguna ❤❤🎉🎉
Nadia the best❤
NADIA .... of course
Nadia. End of.
A ginástica americana é muito forte com sautos altíssimos e com um grande grau de dificuldade, já a ginástica Européia decende da escola soviética com a ginástica mais próxima ao balét e a leveza na execução dos movimentos, não há como comparar a ginástica dos atletas de difentes gerações por quê mudam sérias questões como critério de avaliações elementos com dificuldade e a própria genética. hj em dia tanto as mulheres como os homens possuem o corpo mais fortes!
Oggi hanno attrezzi più facili, tappeti con molle, cavallo largo facile da individuare, pedana a molla, molte cose che aiutano nel salto e nel controllo, che permettono evoluzioni che prima non si potevano fare. Nadia avrebbe potuto fare molto di più con questi attrezzi moderni, ma di base avrebbe avuto la grazia e il fisico per eseguire da manuale come sempre. La Biles è storta, spesso pesante, tremolante e sbilanciata e questo con i vecchi attrezzi avrebbe peggiorato ulteriormente la situazione non permettendo di saltare come fa oggi. Ha potenza nel salto, ma come si è visto soprattutto nella trave è imprecisa, storta, anche brutta da vedere.
then we should go to definitions. for instance the floor routine. the definitions says: The routine is choreographed in advance, and is composed of acrobatic and dance elements. Above all others, this event allows the gymnast to express their personality through their dance and musical style. The moves that are choreographed in the routine must be precise, in sync with the music, and entertaining.
the same goes for balance beam routine. elements of BALANCE, flexibility and...DANCE.
it s not about "soviet school". it s about what sport is meant to be.
speaking about schools...let s not forget that the usa began to matter in elite competitions after bella karoly [the romanian coach] had defected to the usa.
Nadia for sure!
Simone has a shorter more ‘solid’ physique. Nadia looks more graceful.
Naďa měla vyhodu dlouhých nohou , ale to vo předváděla ve srovnání s dnešními gymnastkami , by nestačilo.
Je to legenda , ale všechno se vyvíjí...
To je normální evoluce)
Nadia. The original, with Olga. They are just so elegant.
The interesting thing here is that Nadia is artistic but dressed modestly. At the same time Simone is muscular but dressed in sequins :-/
Simone has great jumping skills, but has the grace of a cannonball compared to Nadia..
Las dos son excelentes Nadia en su momento se convirtió en un icono que hasta las nuevas generaciones respetan y admiran, Simone tiene ahora su momento y es extraordinaria y ha logrado ser también una de las más respetadas
Nadia #1.
Nadia Comaneci and Olga Korbut were incredibly feminine and elegant. Simone is great but does not have that special kind of the female elegance.
Nadia has elegance and grace. Most of new gymnasts lost this feminine attitude and gymnastic now looks like strength athletics. Who is stronger wins
Arabian horse and Percheron. That's the difference.
Well said
Nadia had the grace, precision, and elegance like she defied gravity. While Simone has the power and looks heavy.
Basta vedere il video la Nadia Comaneci era più elegante e raffinata in tutto quello che faceva la Biles è potente e non ha eleganza nei movimenti la Rumena e bella e sinuosa della statunitense ❤
Los estilos son diferentes, supongo que también por la complexión de cada una. Nadia es elegante, suave y fluida. Pero Billies es enérgica, fuerte y poderosa. Bien por las dos 🤗
Até hoje não vi uma ginasta pra se comparar com Nadia sempre será a melhor e minha opinião
Not comparing both. Are good
Nadia is a feather , and perfect.
Yo lo que noto desde mí total ignorancia es que Nadia literalmente era como una pluma, esos movimientos tan suaves, esas terminaciones súper delicadas... Y a Simón la veo como muy potente, con mucha fuerza, realmente muy genia pero sus movimientos son más bruscos, sus terminaciones son con mucha fuerza.
Just astonishing ! Both of them! 😊
Simon no estetik...Nadia ❤❤❤❤❤❤
Masculinity vs Elegance
Nadia comaneci y olga korbut son una leyenda: y simone biles es excelente gimnasta
Nadia will always be the best.💖
Ce que propose Simone est plus spectaculaire on va dire et la difficulté dans ses exécutions est supérieure
Nadia est élégante, soignée et semble si légère
Ça n'a rien à voir, ce n'est pas du tout la meme gymnastique
Nadia restera à mes yeux la référence de la gym
Mais j"aime beaucoup la technicité de Simone ce qu'elle accompli est d'une telle diffuculté ...
È molto più difficile fare tutto da manuale e preciso e leggero, che fare i salti della Biles storti e con le gambe tremolanti nonostante oggi poi ci siano attrezzature molto moderne e migliori. La Biles non potrebbe mai riuscire a fare le cose come le fa Nadia. Nadia potrebbe invece fare quasi tutto quello che fa la Biles, con una precisione e fluidità molto migliori.
I prefer Nadia, Shes graceful, eretheral and it feels like you are watching a ballet as well. She's thevG O A T
I prefer the dangerous skills and ballet style then just the power moves
If Nadia and Simone compete with the old scoring system, Nadia wins.
If Nadia and Simone compete with the new scoring system, Simone wins.
Nadia floats like a feather Simone like a cannonball.
Please, Nadia IS PURE GRACE AND BEAUTY... SHE IS THE BEST! Gmnastics isn't just a heavy klunk doing circus tumbling. Join the circus if that is what you want to do. Tourescheva, Nadia, Olga, Rhetton - the BEST!
After 2024 Simone is the Goat and Nadia would have been 2nd or third- the lift, power, landing, DIFFICULTY of Simone is next level for now! And No Drugs Just God given DNA!! I know it’s hard for some people to Believe Believe Believe!!!!!!!!
Nadia was a ballerina and Biles is a real athlete.
Nadia ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤