I have seen many claim that The Journal of the Two Sisters confirms that Celestia and Luna were born Alicorns, so much so that I finally bought it and read it. The only facts regarding this topic in the book are: -Alicorns are a race of ponies (this is self-evident) -Alicorns age slower than other ponies (but no details on exactly how their aging works) -Celestia and Luna were Alicorns before they got their Cutie Marks -Due to slower aging Alicorns can end up getting their Cutie Marks at a later age than other pony races -Celestia and Luna were raised by Alicorns -Alicorns are an amalgamation of Unicorns, Earth Ponies, and Pegasi -Alicorns have far more magic than Unicorns Nowhere in this book does it state that Celestia and Luna were born Alicorns, or for that matter that any Alicorn society existed. Certainly you can interpret the facts in such a way to back up that assumption, but it could just as easily be interpreted the other way; that they were shepherded into their ascension to alicorns by other alicorns just as Celestia did for Twilight and they happened to ascend at a very young age.
3:20 ... wait a sec here. Twilight literally said "first pony you ever cared about". either that means Starlight never felt anything for her family... or she's an orphan who never got close to anypony at the orphanage and Sunburst was the only pony she clicked with in all her life. ...... 😐 suddenly her thought process from when Sunburst got his mark, her reasons for fearing losing another friend from a Cutie Mark and where she went after make a disturbing and really depressing amount of sense
It makes more sense when you see that Starlight had a goth phase before she left home. Combine it with her father constantly babying her, and it's not wonder her emotional growth was a bit, behind.
To answer your question at 4:52 - walking down the street, walking down the stairs, at the bus stop, at church, at the doctor's office/waiting room, in biology class, in cooking class, in the car while driving, in a random hallway. To summarize, anywhere there isn't a bed.
i tried really hard not to laugh at the opening bit, also i don't know how but you made me feel sorry for map not being able to sing the opener. I hate the opener LOL.
HAHAHAHAHA!!!!! That beginning! Brilliant!! Oh props to the Irish John short too, that was funny also. Omg this was funny as hell. About time Misanthro and you collabed lol.
Magic Note Not to my knowledge he hasn't. They don't work in the same Analysis circles. They were in a video together but that was Redcord's Meanwhile video and their parts didn't interact at all.
Love the SpongeBob reference.4:03 Answer: No, because Ms. Pretentious Purple Princess is too wrapped up in her own ego to consider Starlight's feelings.
The Katana of Friendship Beatings should make a reappearance for sheer irony levels. "Not unless you consider they were born before the founding of Equestria." Oh my actual, this is actually the best reasoning I've heard yet for this line, thank you, why hasn't everyone else figured this out. "Now...KISS!!!! >///>" "You're not helping." *immediately transition to aria* Everything about these three seconds is beautiful. Aaaaaah, it's been too long since I've heard your Leroy Jenkins style "PRINCEEEEEEEEEESS CELESTIAAAAAAA". Good times. FINALLY, someone else who accepts the "Celestia was giving Twilight space to make her own decisions" theory! SEE PEOPLE THE SHOW GAVE YOU A REASON TO STOP BASHING CELESTIA LIKE AN ABSENTEE PARENT
Just to answer your question, Anthro Pony: If you look closely as the camera enters the train, you see Pinkie has a gift-wrapped box next to her, then whe it shifts to Rarity sewing the blanket with Fluttershy next to her, you see a stuffed bunny at her left side. Hope that clears things up! ^^
"Friendship beatings." I can see value in those! Ah, Biblical Scripture Study. I need a cheat sheet of points to remember when reading through the Bible right now. It helps. (Who the passages are addressed to, which Biblical Administration/Era in takes place in, and more! All are necessary to understanding the Bible, for those looking in from the outside.) Oh, Starlight's panic attack. Very real, according to many who know panic attacks. Lots of laughs, and some good insight too. :)
The child with eyes that peer in one's soul. The child with wings of icy winds cold. With the power to leave all kingdoms all crippled. The one who leaves life dead and all who breaths shriveled. The one that tricks the eyes of the fool. The Princess of Tartarus, the devil's deceiving tool.
It's pretty curious view on wisards moral compass: both Twilight and glorious goatee place magical achievements above possible catastrofic consequences. And you see other graduates of school for gifted unicorns (namely Twilight herself) that use magic rather irresponsibly from non-spellcasters point of view.
9:10 I noticed that was an odd thing for him to note too. (Though I'm still betting Starswirl turns out to be his and Starlight's son--combine the one stallion with more magical know-how than Twilight and the one mare with more raw power, you'd get one god-tier mage)
What if there is a place out of Equestria where alicorns are born and when there older if they do not deserve to be one they become one of the three tribes They must choose unicorn, Pegasus, or earth pony
8:07 to 8:12 Wow it only took five seconds for something to go wrong after twilight in a way says "what could possibly go wrong"......that's a new record
6:28 hahahaha we did the same why are many analists crying about the "equestria has never seen the born of an alicorn before"? the "journal of the two sisters" is a book... not part of the show. All is headcannon until the show proves it. Also the thing for alicorns... why everyone complains about that. We are like really new in this fandom, and we don't understand why that happens.
Celestia needs to give twilight teaching lessons. Also, when starlight said "right, genius" when reacting to spike I realized right then and there I was going to like her because she has one personality trait that the the rest of the main characters are lacking, Snark, sarcasm in a little bit of deviousness. That also made me realize that the creators have done a fantastic job of having so many characters while keeping one unique in terms of their personality. For all the talk of starlight being a twilight clone every single one of the twilight series (Trixie, Sunset, starlight,) have completely unique sets of personalities and the same can be said for all characters. Speaking from somebody who has tried making his own stories before I can honestly say to keeping unique personalities in between each character can be a little bit more difficult than some would think. Also, twilights parents Finally have got dialogue. and Finally, maybe chrysalis now has a morality pet?
Now that I think about it, you've just perfectly described how I feel about the current state of Super Saiyans when compared to how Alicorns were popping up left and right as well.
Tis tis, of course it counters the Journal of the Two Pony Sisters. It's about time that historical fantasy be disproven. Actual Equestrian historians have known that was a crock of crap since it's announcement. Just look at the journal it self. It does not have any citations. And don't tell me that it's a primary source. The fucking book was written from a type writer on some finely crafted paper. It's practically telling you it's a fake.
Even though this is two years old, Id like to defend alicorn OCs. Sure some are caused with a power obsession, but not all. Heck, I have a couple of balanced alicorn OCs and people find tgem likeable and well rounded
Sooo... Sunburst has a beard, doesn't really understand friendship, understand magic better then he can preform it, has a recently reunion with a unicorn who really powerful and can travel through time. Headcanon accepted, Sunburst is Starswirl.
+EmeraldDragon Starswirl was good with magic as well. A mix of Sunburst and Starlight. Sunburst deep understanding of magic with Starlight's Magic power and understanding of time magic. So it looks like Starlight is Starswirl's mom. We know from the book that Starswirl traveled in time a lot. So he could have been born in any time.
+TheHokorippoi Do we know that, really? We only know that he was a great wizard because legends say so. There's no reason that they could not have time traveled to the past used Sunburst's knowledge and starlight's power, and over time become one pony in history.
IrishJohn - "When I say 'secret identity', I *mean* 'secret identity.'" :D (Please tell me some pony's old enough to get that quote!) 9:45 Yeah... the "The Lion King" reference was kinda blinding there.
Brawny: Quick! Get the super glue!
(Heart shatters!)
MisAnthro: That's why I use Legos. They're easier to put back together.
94: You're not helping!!!
Equestira Girls Fan 94! LOL!
Well that was fun
GoldenFox hi goldenfox
Hello
GOLDIE!!! Sorry, I love your vids and I hope you don't stop after season nine.
MisAnthro Pony and Brawny Buck finally teamed up...and it was GLORIOUS!!
I have seen many claim that The Journal of the Two Sisters confirms that Celestia and Luna were born Alicorns, so much so that I finally bought it and read it.
The only facts regarding this topic in the book are:
-Alicorns are a race of ponies (this is self-evident)
-Alicorns age slower than other ponies (but no details on exactly how their aging works)
-Celestia and Luna were Alicorns before they got their Cutie Marks
-Due to slower aging Alicorns can end up getting their Cutie Marks at a later age than other pony races
-Celestia and Luna were raised by Alicorns
-Alicorns are an amalgamation of Unicorns, Earth Ponies, and Pegasi
-Alicorns have far more magic than Unicorns
Nowhere in this book does it state that Celestia and Luna were born Alicorns, or for that matter that any Alicorn society existed. Certainly you can interpret the facts in such a way to back up that assumption, but it could just as easily be interpreted the other way; that they were shepherded into their ascension to alicorns by other alicorns just as Celestia did for Twilight and they happened to ascend at a very young age.
3:20 ... wait a sec here. Twilight literally said "first pony you ever cared about". either that means Starlight never felt anything for her family... or she's an orphan who never got close to anypony at the orphanage and Sunburst was the only pony she clicked with in all her life.
......
😐
suddenly her thought process from when Sunburst got his mark, her reasons for fearing losing another friend from a Cutie Mark and where she went after make a disturbing and really depressing amount of sense
nOpe she has a dad
Twilight, why do you have to confuse us like this
I have it in my head that she might’ve lost her mom to a cutie mark occupation that’s life threatening
It makes more sense when you see that Starlight had a goth phase before she left home. Combine it with her father constantly babying her, and it's not wonder her emotional growth was a bit, behind.
To answer your question at 4:52 - walking down the street, walking down the stairs, at the bus stop, at church, at the doctor's office/waiting room, in biology class, in cooking class, in the car while driving, in a random hallway. To summarize, anywhere there isn't a bed.
3:57 :a Pegasus hides in the clouds making sure that the letter got to its place:
1:23, "That's adora-SHIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIT!!" would have been better
Princess Cadence: Do you think we should call it off?
MisAnthro Pony: What and ruin the plot?
Me: Buttered Toast.
Brawny Buck: You're not helping.
i tried really hard not to laugh at the opening bit, also i don't know how but you made me feel sorry for map not being able to sing the opener. I hate the opener LOL.
Finally FINALLY some one remembers that Equestria is the name of the country not the planet!!
I think this is the First time I ever saw Misanthropony in a Collab!
Nice to see you posting again Buck
His name is brawny
+anime lover 17 brawny buck.
pokehunterhd I know who he is
anime lover 17 i'm correcting you.
pokehunterhd and I'm correcting him. So we're both achieving the same thing.
as you can see that "ball" at the end was chrisallys in the shape of a ball not a ball of igneous or sedementary
Twilight: “The baby is an Alicorn?! I blame you for this, Squidward!”
Squidward: 0_0
Me: 😂😂😂😂
HAHAHAHAHA!!!!! That beginning! Brilliant!! Oh props to the Irish John short too, that was funny also.
Omg this was funny as hell. About time Misanthro and you collabed lol.
+Zodia195 Has he done one with Silver Quill? If not, he should!
Magic Note
Not to my knowledge he hasn't. They don't work in the same Analysis circles. They were in a video together but that was Redcord's Meanwhile video and their parts didn't interact at all.
Bravo BRAWNY! Show them sniveling stupid alicorns that they suck!
Yeah! Too many alicorns around here! We should do something about it! *
(In Plankton's voice)
What's it's just an ordinary baby
(Flurry Heart's wings appear)
OH MY GOODNESS!!! LARSON!
But Larson doesn't write for MLP anymore
Doctor Digi
I remember, my comment was merely a reference to those who first complained about Twilight being an alicorn
Love the SpongeBob reference.4:03 Answer: No, because Ms. Pretentious Purple Princess is too wrapped up in her own ego to consider Starlight's feelings.
7:15 and PRIIIINCEEEEESS LUNA!
grekoy im with you
BEST PRINCESS EVER (even if she DOES get captured just as easily as princess peach)
OH MY GOD! MISANTHRO PONY IN A COLLAB! THAT IS SOOOOOOO AWESOME!!! AMAZING JOB, GUYS!
The Katana of Friendship Beatings should make a reappearance for sheer irony levels.
"Not unless you consider they were born before the founding of Equestria." Oh my actual, this is actually the best reasoning I've heard yet for this line, thank you, why hasn't everyone else figured this out.
"Now...KISS!!!! >///>"
"You're not helping."
*immediately transition to aria*
Everything about these three seconds is beautiful.
Aaaaaah, it's been too long since I've heard your Leroy Jenkins style "PRINCEEEEEEEEEESS CELESTIAAAAAAA". Good times.
FINALLY, someone else who accepts the "Celestia was giving Twilight space to make her own decisions" theory! SEE PEOPLE THE SHOW GAVE YOU A REASON TO STOP BASHING CELESTIA LIKE AN ABSENTEE PARENT
I love it when you yell Princess Celestial its so funny
I think it would be
" crystal ponies, crystal bees,
Restore the heart before we freeze "
"ego stroking much?" considering the Crystal Empire is one of the only places where Spike can get respect...
Yah.... he really can't have an ego anywhere else
These collabs are awesome. So much fun to watch everytime
Just to answer your question, Anthro Pony:
If you look closely as the camera enters the train, you see Pinkie has a gift-wrapped box next to her, then whe it shifts to Rarity sewing the blanket with Fluttershy next to her, you see a stuffed bunny at her left side.
Hope that clears things up! ^^
"Friendship beatings." I can see value in those!
Ah, Biblical Scripture Study. I need a cheat sheet of points to remember when reading through the Bible right now. It helps. (Who the passages are addressed to, which Biblical Administration/Era in takes place in, and more! All are necessary to understanding the Bible, for those looking in from the outside.)
Oh, Starlight's panic attack. Very real, according to many who know panic attacks.
Lots of laughs, and some good insight too. :)
Bold of you to keep this ep up after all the crap about anthropony
Also another April 1st video that isn't a bad joke thank you Brawny! Praise the Moon and Sun!
Brawny you had to taste a rainbow in the opening
"He's got the magical punch of a salted slug" That's because he's a wizard, not a warlock or sorcerer.
The child with eyes that peer in one's soul.
The child with wings of icy winds cold.
With the power to leave all kingdoms all crippled.
The one who leaves life dead and all who breaths shriveled.
The one that tricks the eyes of the fool.
The Princess of Tartarus, the devil's deceiving tool.
+Helmar Soul I have no idea what I just read, but I like it.
Thats amazing! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!.
here's a little theory.... what if Sunburst is Star Swirl's relative of some kind?
6:31. Does anyone know which song that came from.
It's pretty curious view on wisards moral compass: both Twilight and glorious goatee place magical achievements above possible catastrofic consequences. And you see other graduates of school for gifted unicorns (namely Twilight herself) that use magic rather irresponsibly from non-spellcasters point of view.
I am kind of new so can somebody explain to me why he was yelling PRINCESS CELESTIA
It’s his version of LEEROY JENKIIIIIIINS!!!
9:10 I noticed that was an odd thing for him to note too. (Though I'm still betting Starswirl turns out to be his and Starlight's son--combine the one stallion with more magical know-how than Twilight and the one mare with more raw power, you'd get one god-tier mage)
5:08 LOL!
Best use of a Spongebob clip ever.
+Lambeo Rolfe My friends make that reference in school all the time so that just made it even funnier to me!
"What it's just an ordinary po-"
*sees the horn and big wings*
"Oh my goodness. LARSON!!!"
NO! WE NEED MORE RECURRING PONIES WITH FACIAL HAIR! MORE MANLINESS!
"No, none of that. Shame on you."
10:27 is that thorax or Sawtooth that I just saw?
When I was watching the episode I swear "Circle of Life" started playing in my head during the Crystalling!
+Calliope Pony Firing images: derpiboo.ru/images/1117211?scope=scpe91d813750380822238704c555c3c5a3e2903b006 derpiboo.ru/images/1117171?scope=scpe91d813750380822238704c555c3c5a3e2903b006 Images fired, Mission Accomplished
D HAROLD Images received, lulz achieved. Many thanks.
I love that pink pony stalion
It's the Circle of Life, and it moves us all
Lion Guard, eat your heart out, this makes you look smaaaaaaaaaaaaaall.....
Flurry truly is magic.... she can sneeze with her eyes open.
how does he eat with all those bandannas?
What if there is a place out of Equestria where alicorns are born and when there older if they do not deserve to be one they become one of the three tribes
They must choose unicorn, Pegasus, or earth pony
i would have loved if his beard grew when he lied
Brawny : "I'm not takeing it back"
I would have said the same thing
Love IrishJohn's new intro ^_^
1:21 Hey you forgot about Mad Munchkin's Alicorn OC! I love Mary Sue's prissy attitude and grumpy face.
8:07 to 8:12
Wow it only took five seconds for something to go wrong after twilight in a way says "what could possibly go wrong"......that's a new record
I didn't noticed that it was a reference of Lion King and Atlantis
This is the first time I've seen Brawny buck near Lightning Bliss. Awesome. Also Very nicely done Drawny!
I am really hopeing to see brawny and blissy do a review together this season. anypony else out there agree with me?
I agree with you.
should've used the "machine gun eddie" scream
10:28 Is...is that a....changeling?
6:28 hahahaha we did the same
why are many analists crying about the "equestria has never seen the born of an alicorn before"? the "journal of the two sisters" is a book... not part of the show. All is headcannon until the show proves it.
Also the thing for alicorns... why everyone complains about that. We are like really new in this fandom, and we don't understand why that happens.
Celestia needs to give twilight teaching lessons. Also, when
starlight said "right, genius" when reacting to spike I realized right then and
there I was going to like her because she has one personality trait that the the
rest of the main characters are lacking, Snark, sarcasm in a little bit of
deviousness. That also made me realize that the creators have done a fantastic
job of having so many characters while keeping one unique in terms of their
personality. For all the talk of starlight being a twilight clone every single
one of the twilight series (Trixie, Sunset, starlight,) have completely unique
sets of personalities and the same can be said for all characters. Speaking from
somebody who has tried making his own stories before I can honestly say to
keeping unique personalities in between each character can be a little bit more
difficult than some would think. Also, twilights parents Finally have got dialogue. and Finally, maybe chrysalis now
has a morality pet?
6:38...and somewhere, Angel Island falls into the ocean....again.
Na, not really
@MisAnthro Pony As much as Sigma coming back from the dead, or Dr. Wily trying to take over the world... 😂
I don't get to do this often, at least not with the right context, but...
*Ahem*
PRINCEEEEEEEEESS CELESTIA!
I'm glad that everyone (and I mean EVERYONE) agrees with me that the Crystalling sequence in this two-parter was an allusion to The Lion King.
is it just me or do they work great together :-O
5:41 was that an ed,edd, and eddy reference?
OKAY, WHAT THE **** WAS THAT THING!?!?!?!?
was that the sieriens or sombra
After seeing Blissy's cameo, I can only wonder what her reaction was to a natural born alicorn was
I lost it at the lion king joke! La sapenya la dise Tia!!!!!
I lost it at the Spongebob and JonTron jokes.
10:26 umm, who?
Now that I think about it, you've just perfectly described how I feel about the current state of Super Saiyans when compared to how Alicorns were popping up left and right as well.
That must be the headcanon that people talk about the alicorn since I believe in season 3 I think
Nice collab MAP and Brawny!
Holy shit... I just noticed the similarities between Sun Burst and Star Swirl......
Does any pony else know what the black thing was at the end?
5:09 your welcome
The biggest shock of the ep for me was that Twilight's and Shining Armor's parents talked.
Me too that's was something I wasn't expecting to happen. If you see my reaction to this episode I exploded big time.
5:28 Then Maybe Luna and Celestia were born alicorn but before equestria was even...um,how do you say it.Created,made?
10:25 Thorax! The writers were planning something!I didnt even see that changeling!
IM not taking it back. LOL right their with you!
That spell brawny said i know ive heard it somewhere but where
Now kiss!
ITS AN ALIEN!
5:40 You son of a b*tch, referencing Ed Edd N Eddy....WOOOO!!
Friendship beatings. Gotta remember that one.
How do you keep a library inside a library? Very easily, considering every modern library does it.
Also, HOW IS THAT BATHROOM SO CLOSE TO THE LIBRARY?
Dang John, how many of them things do you have?
Pretty nice overview of the two-parter, and it was great to see Misanthropony in a collab with you.
Tis tis, of course it counters the Journal of the Two Pony Sisters. It's about time that historical fantasy be disproven. Actual Equestrian historians have known that was a crock of crap since it's announcement. Just look at the journal it self. It does not have any citations. And don't tell me that it's a primary source. The fucking book was written from a type writer on some finely crafted paper. It's practically telling you it's a fake.
Even though this is two years old, Id like to defend alicorn OCs. Sure some are caused with a power obsession, but not all. Heck, I have a couple of balanced alicorn OCs and people find tgem likeable and well rounded
you gotta give cadence some credit for not having her gut skeward but flurry's freakishly long horn
2:10 oh come on brawny don't be a party pooper I kinda like the theme song at least so much better than the g3 themes
Sooo... Sunburst has a beard, doesn't really understand friendship, understand magic better then he can preform it, has a recently reunion with a unicorn who really powerful and can travel through time. Headcanon accepted, Sunburst is Starswirl.
+EmeraldDragon Starswirl was good with magic as well. A mix of Sunburst and Starlight. Sunburst deep understanding of magic with Starlight's Magic power and understanding of time magic.
So it looks like Starlight is Starswirl's mom.
We know from the book that Starswirl traveled in time a lot. So he could have been born in any time.
+TheHokorippoi Do we know that, really? We only know that he was a great wizard because legends say so. There's no reason that they could not have time traveled to the past used Sunburst's knowledge and starlight's power, and over time become one pony in history.
IrishJohn - "When I say 'secret identity', I *mean* 'secret identity.'" :D (Please tell me some pony's old enough to get that quote!)
9:45 Yeah... the "The Lion King" reference was kinda blinding there.
Foreshadowing the finely 10:26
7:15 Ppprrriiiinnncceesss Lllluunnnaaa!(Princess Luna)
Hey look it's kakashi senseis son
it's about time someone called lightingbliss out on her OC
Can somepony explain that last segment for me?
Oh cool misanthro finally uses those poses goldenfox made
@MisAnthro Pony you were really funny in this, I love that! And I heard alot more emotion in this, witch is always fun. Great colab missanthro
so is Criselis mad that she was not invited??
just a thought
4:42 - 4:44 You said it wrong. It's "Hint hint. Wink wink. Nudge Nudge. Say no more".