It is One Direction vs Kelly Clarkson. And yes, Kelly wins. But it is not right to fight for the 'picture.' I love Kelly Clarkson, but other people think other things.
Your comment is completely contradictory. Also, the reason there is no point in comparing them is because they are two completely different acts! One Direction are a BOYBAND and Kelly Clarkson is a SOLO ARTIST. They obviously have different styles and talents! There IS NO COMPARISON! ~ A Kelly fan and a 1D fan
HA 1D BETTER THAN KELLY?! THAT IS THE FUNNIEST SHIT I HAVE HEARD IN MY LIFE. KELLY HAS MORE TALENT IN HER PINKIE FINGER, THEN ALL FIVE OF THEM COMBINED.
well from what i've read, and just to throw some more fire on the debate, since kelly gave this song to 1D, then i'd go out on a branch and say that she is the better artist considering it was her song to begin with. But then again, i'm just here to make a cd for my gf so i really have no idea what i'm talking about :D seahorses rule!
Don't get me wrong, 1D has some pretty good vocalists, but the only one who can even remotely hold a candle to Kelly is Zayn. So to say 1D is BETTER than Kelly is astonishing..
![Kelly Clarkson - Tell Me A Lie [LYRICS] NEW SONG 2011/2012 [HQ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/4EDBrx-LqPs/mqdefault.jpg)
![Kelly Clarkson - Tell Me A Lie [LYRICS] NEW SONG 2011/2012 [HQ]](/img/tr.png)
She should use her demos which she recorded. Sometimes , it better than a song released. ( Like So Far Apart or Racehorse )
It is One Direction vs Kelly Clarkson. And yes, Kelly wins. But it is not right to fight for the 'picture.' I love Kelly Clarkson, but other people think other things.
four wild 1D fangirls appeared
I love both really. With a song this good it’s hard to choose a favorite.
Your comment is completely contradictory. Also, the reason there is no point in comparing them is because they are two completely different acts! One Direction are a BOYBAND and Kelly Clarkson is a SOLO ARTIST. They obviously have different styles and talents! There IS NO COMPARISON!
~ A Kelly fan and a 1D fan
obviously the song fits kelly more because she wrote it, but i like a lot of the changes 1D made to it. both versions are good!
I actually was looking fiestas to this more than stronger but stronger is my favorite now
HA 1D BETTER THAN KELLY?! THAT IS THE FUNNIEST SHIT I HAVE HEARD IN MY LIFE. KELLY HAS MORE TALENT IN HER PINKIE FINGER, THEN ALL FIVE OF THEM COMBINED.
Kelly & 1D should release this song as a duo.
a person in germany accessed kellys computer and copied it along with a bunch more songs which are circulating around the internet .
I love Kelly Clarson's version better she should of used it for her album ive listened to this son a million times its my ringrone
I TOTALLY agree with LalalaAbi! Well said!!
was this her song or one directions or what?
She wrote it, but deciding after listening to one direction that she would give them this song.
I agree, her version is a million times better than 1D's.
@keepboouncing yeah it's real, I didn't edit anything.
Where do you find all these??? I want them!
well from what i've read, and just to throw some more fire on the debate, since kelly gave this song to 1D, then i'd go out on a branch and say that she is the better artist considering it was her song to begin with. But then again, i'm just here to make a cd for my gf so i really have no idea what i'm talking about :D seahorses rule!
Can u send me this song? I'll pm u- but can u tell me what the subject of the message should be?
Dont hate on 1D.....Or Kelly...They both sing good...but 1D is alittle bit better
Kelly made this song for other singers to buy, & one direction bought it for their own.
of course 1d version is better , but i thank to kelly cus she wrote it. :)
I wanted to mean not as good. I never said that they were untalented.
I love this song like i remember i found it accidentally
@shapeofmyheart414 I found them on various sites. If you send me your e-mail in a pm, I'd be willing to send them too you.
Do you have a download link for this?
Is this real? or you just edited the voices?
heck yea gurl
Hmm bn pero one direction ganaa
i agree!!!
i dont like her version like 1D version
1D sings it better they sing it,its on there album alot of people love it end of story
That doesn’t make any sense at all but ok..
La version de One Direction es mejor :/ Aun que los dos la cantan re bien (: Le ponen mas power c: Es mi opinion (:
Don't get me wrong, 1D has some pretty good vocalists, but the only one who can even remotely hold a candle to Kelly is Zayn. So to say 1D is BETTER than Kelly is astonishing..
No. 1D is only good because they are a group, so if someone sings off key, not many people will notice. They aren't good when they sing individually.
1D ruined this?!!!
Kelly liked their version better so are you saying her choice is bad? They’re both amazing why do you guys have to bring them up just to hate on them?
One Direction Is Better
Lol