Help! My Comping Is Boring!

Поділитися
Вставка

КОМЕНТАРІ • 21

  • @pastafarian2046
    @pastafarian2046 14 годин тому +1

    Thank god for this video, answers so many of my questions. Everytime I watched your videos it makes me want to practice, this time it's no different. Just want to put the appreciation out there. Thank you Jeremy, I really appreciate what you are doing here.

    • @JeremySiskind
      @JeremySiskind  13 годин тому

      Yay, I'm so glad you're feeling inspired! I'm honored it's inspiring you to practice!

  • @dangfd551
    @dangfd551 3 дні тому +4

    Thanks Jeremy! Fingerings seem first like just a practical concern, but it also informs the voicings and how they move.

  • @sheilamacdougal4874
    @sheilamacdougal4874 3 дні тому +3

    This is lovely, thank you. Very basic, yet useful to hear and to focus on instead of relying solely on intuition and hearing.

  • @joesauvage1165
    @joesauvage1165 День тому

    No joshing here…this is an awesome lesson! Deepest thanks Jeremy!

  • @willzang3000
    @willzang3000 2 дні тому

    you make this sound a LOT easier than it is mate !!! well done

  • @javilalima
    @javilalima 2 дні тому

    Josh is lucky to have you as a teacher!

  • @Ludada101
    @Ludada101 2 дні тому +2

    My book arrived today

  • @jarkkojanhunen6121
    @jarkkojanhunen6121 3 дні тому +1

    Great stuff, Josh!😊

  • @alphaomega6062
    @alphaomega6062 3 дні тому +2

    You joshin' me bro? It's that simple!

  • @BusyCasual
    @BusyCasual 14 годин тому +1

    Hello, thanks for this video! Can I ask what you are using to write this out? I've been looking for a good alternative to manuscript paper for sooo long but everything I have found people say is not really that great.

    • @JeremySiskind
      @JeremySiskind  13 годин тому

      Sure! I'm just using the app Forscore - I upload my own manuscript paper.

  • @humblemai2211
    @humblemai2211 3 дні тому +1

    😅thanks a lot

  • @javilalima
    @javilalima 2 дні тому

    Quick question: for sude-stepping, do you recommend different fingers for the chromatic chords, or the same fingers that you use in the diatonic chords?

  • @AnotherMomentWithDave
    @AnotherMomentWithDave 2 дні тому

    Hi Jeremy! In your lesson you took the 4 note voicing of a CMaj9 7 3 9 5 and converted into an Em7 first and then you created the normal 3 inversions of that Em7 to find the 3 other vocings which when the chord is arranged in 3rds I understand. This is what hangs me up.... If you had a 4 note F7 voicing like Eb A D G (b7 3 13 9) how would I find the other 3 vocings? I cannot think of a way to arrange those notes in thirds to invert it? Do you have a section in one of your books that teaches how to do that or am I missing something?

    • @cabijista1
      @cabijista1 2 дні тому +3

      So the Cma voicing here is really a E minor 7 in drop 2. The dominant voicing that you mentioned for a F7 is also a drop 2 of the standard rootless type B voicing for a Dominant 13, that is A D Eb G. Drop the 2nd note from the top and you get your voicing of Eb A D G. You can think of the shape as a Ma7#11 a whole step below the root, that is Ebma7#11 (with the 5th omitted ) over F. You’ll find however, that inverting this chord only really works with the chord in its standard type A or B drop 2 positions. If for example we go to the next inversion from your starting chord (Eb A D G) we would get G D Eb A. That’s not a great voicing owing to the peculiar arrangement of intervals (5th, minor 2nd, tritone).
      If you want to play around with creating melodies on dominant chords with inversions of drop 2 voicings, you’re better off simplifying the dominant chord to a 9th, rather than a 13th. So take your voicing but replace the D (the 13th) with a C (the 5th). Now you have what is essentially a C-6 over F voicing (what Barry Harris called the “6th on the 5th”) and all 4 inversions of that work just fine.
      For a more altered dominant sound you can also use the minor 6th chord a half step above the root of the dominant, so in this case, (enharmonically) F#-6 over F. This will give you a F# (b9) A (3rd) C# (#5) and D# (b7). This also works fine in drop 2 and all 4 inversions.

    • @AnotherMomentWithDave
      @AnotherMomentWithDave 2 дні тому +1

      @@cabijista1 Thank you so much my friend great info!!

    • @cabijista1
      @cabijista1 2 дні тому +1

      @@AnotherMomentWithDave no worries :)

  • @davidmiller3927
    @davidmiller3927 2 дні тому

    Yup. You lost me! But that's OK. I am at the beginning of book 1. It is all about the journey. Someday I will understand this lesson. 🙂

  • @MarkEisenman
    @MarkEisenman 3 дні тому +4

    FOLKS this is gold.
    OMG, this is a lesson that is very similar to what I do,
    FINGERING is crucial, and you are the only other person I've seen who addresses this - what seems to be big "secret".