are coalition governments USELESS? | LIVE DEBATE!

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 29 вер 2024
  • Debating with Trishy4 on whether Coalition Government are Ideal to run India or majority governments are better.
    FULL STREAM LINK: www.youtube.co...

КОМЕНТАРІ • 39

  • @vinaygawande9550
    @vinaygawande9550 4 місяці тому +20

    Perfectly said .
    Modi Government is a WhatsApp Uncle Government

  • @devendrasinghsisodiya7864
    @devendrasinghsisodiya7864 4 місяці тому +20

    Khichdi government is good for India. In the name of competing with the world and becoming world's largest economy we should not destroy our democracy by giving staunch majority.

    • @piya6929
      @piya6929 4 місяці тому +1

      i agree...specially with how diverse our people are, people in power also need to be diverse in culture and political ideologies...it's better if they debate cause no one would be able to pass bills unilaterally

  • @harshaldongre849
    @harshaldongre849 4 місяці тому +12

    India is itself a Khichdi in itself. A beautiful, tasty and rich Khichdi.
    So why can't the govt that represents this Khichdi be a Khichdi!

    • @curiosity_fan
      @curiosity_fan 4 місяці тому +5

      Becoz that sounds poetic but need not necessarily be logical. The rational, civil discussion on the topic in the video eventually made it logical.

    • @raidaiwik2006
      @raidaiwik2006 4 місяці тому +1

      @@curiosity_fan bihar nitish kumar loves to make khichdi everytime and see now the condition of bihar. everytime unstable govt

  • @rajput2736
    @rajput2736 4 місяці тому +1

    He defending bullshit point... Coalition govt is like...choro ki mandali...

  • @alex-z1q2g
    @alex-z1q2g 4 місяці тому +2

    Hmm, interesting. Please reply if you are reading this :)
    You are in favor of coalition government because you think it promotes discussion and debate among parties on controversial bills like the UCC, farm bills, etc., which ultimately benefits the citizens. However, there's another perspective to consider. It can be extremely difficult for a coalition government to pass even necessary bills, like the Women's Reservation Bill, which could be opposed by parties like AIMIM. If they were part of the coalition, passing the bill without meeting their demands (which I find extremely pointless) would be challenging. Additionally, the removal of Article 370 could not have been achieved by any coalition government, and from what I've read, the situation there seems better now than before.
    By the way, how do I join these debates?

  • @I_SAID_LET_HIM_COOK
    @I_SAID_LET_HIM_COOK 4 місяці тому +5

    Coalition will bring market down, because of political stability
    Kal uthake congress bolage "we are building SIT to investigate, how Adani got airport 😂 and if, modi is shareholder" and other Coalition will be gajani karne ka hai ya nahi?

  • @AyubKhan-md4km
    @AyubKhan-md4km 4 місяці тому +2

    Trisha.... were you really a real proponent to the opposing argument in the debate?
    Though I agree that he has valid points and I agree any right wing totalitarian govt is not good for secular India, but I also do believe there are so many important points that were not brought to the forefront.. horse trading (not a one sided problem now. Collation govt inspired ), dynastic rule (though it's not just a one sided problem now. collations govt inspired), arbitrary splinter political groups emerging in governance without valid backing from public on the new party formation in parliament, tainted political heads being entertained because of political necessities, no accountability or self regulatory body to access manifesto achievements when forming a collation govt, all is brushed under the carpet because of party being paramount.
    There are so many more points that could have been discussed and shown to be also evils of collations just like how brute majority has its own evils

  • @mihirpingle5067
    @mihirpingle5067 4 місяці тому +4

    It was a great convesation. Accoding to me coalition governemt works in ideal conditions like in Germany for example. But in a country like India where corruption is still rampant, it will do more harm than good. Becasue everyone will look for filling up their zola. That will happen in majority governemt too but in that case they will know that they dont have to worry about governement falling apart. Also policymaking is disastrous with colaitions in India. We can see many examples of this in the great coalition era.

  • @realsbs
    @realsbs 4 місяці тому +4

    Not useless but yes not that efficient

  • @rishabhtripathi3859
    @rishabhtripathi3859 4 місяці тому

    She sounds like tracy Alison

  • @kunalkashelani585
    @kunalkashelani585 4 місяці тому +2

    What an amazing conversation, loved it so much ✌️

  • @prdawa
    @prdawa 4 місяці тому

    I want to eat Khicchdi😭

  • @nikhilsahay895
    @nikhilsahay895 4 місяці тому +3

    Girl was right; Meghnerd is outright wrong.
    Take example of next implementation to come: If BJP comes, some of things like petrol sale which are not under GST yet would easily come under GST and correctly so as fossil fuel is national resource even if 3-4 states might have most to lose from revenue perspective.
    Now with Khichdi govt, this will never be implemented as those 2-3 regional party will never agree and let it be brought under GST.

    • @garyfern100
      @garyfern100 4 місяці тому +1

      bro.....10 years past ..... GST implementation 2018......couldnt agree to GST implementation in 6 years with this Govt.

    • @nikhilsahay895
      @nikhilsahay895 4 місяці тому +3

      @@garyfern100 can you write a whole sentence?

  • @SubhamPalcyd
    @SubhamPalcyd 4 місяці тому

    PM does not matter. What matters is the powerful group of the ruling party that decides everything. Ex The Gandhi gang of UPA-I and II. Even now if Modi doesn't become PM, Modi-Shah will still call the shots. Will any BJP- member do any thing without the say so of Duo.

  • @Dani4uNme
    @Dani4uNme 4 місяці тому

    @ meghnerd - you have got to jump on Abhi and Niyu shit, this is perfect time to increase your clout 😂 don’t miss it. You want to be big or not, bro 👊 go for it. Lafda is the new content

  • @faruqsha6456
    @faruqsha6456 4 місяці тому

    Very few youngers able to understand rest of are busy being Chapris 😂😂

  • @gamingwithlegendaryguys2519
    @gamingwithlegendaryguys2519 4 місяці тому

    Someone i know voted on bow and arrow shivsena when they wanted to vote for ubt government.

  • @AmrinderSinghHundal
    @AmrinderSinghHundal 4 місяці тому

    Why not review Kapil Sibal-Smita Prakash ANI interview?

    • @meghnerd
      @meghnerd  4 місяці тому

      video being editing. will be up this weekend

  • @Tremor-5.0
    @Tremor-5.0 4 місяці тому

    Did u do a podcaast on ani vs kapil sibal

  • @ants070
    @ants070 4 місяці тому

    Wouldn't secret voting lead to horse trading?

  • @Gaurav.P0
    @Gaurav.P0 4 місяці тому

    Very good conversation 👍

  • @yoyodude-aoe2726
    @yoyodude-aoe2726 4 місяці тому

    Such a good debate.

  • @rajparab5051
    @rajparab5051 4 місяці тому

    I don't know where is this coming from
    But muslims were have been voting for shivsena for many years
    Many people have been members of shivsena for many years
    And all this was way before modi

  • @huseintambawala4381
    @huseintambawala4381 4 місяці тому +2

    Ayega to Modi hi