Your recommendation was - don't increase the Capex, increase access to credit, reduce tax so that people have more money = and see , first time in 10 years Capex decreased, acces to credit increase, tax decrease
absolutely true me jab 3 din pahle podcast dekh raha tha Budget ke 3 din pahle tab lag raha tha ki ye jo bol rahe hai suggestion achhe hai par BJP kuch nahi karegi as a BJP supporter muje bahut gussa aa raha tha ki kuch achha nahi kar rahi aur 3 din pahle ye baat kon manega ye kuch nahi hoga par budget me ye sab hua matlab ab koi achhe economist aaye hai jo ground level ki reality government ko bata rahe hai jisse kuch improvement ho paye
Prasanna sir....is one person where i dont miss..and also always curious to listen....what i understand from him is "spend the money where it is necessary which adds value to the economy and society which solves the issues on daily basis rather than spending on target basis".
Prasanna is my batchmate from ISB .. Sitting and listening this as an investment banker in the US ! This what you call teaching ! He should be teaching econ to Indians on National TV !! 📺 what genius.. thats why I consider him guruji 🎉 In bharatiya culture, the teacher doesnt go looking for a student, charging him tuition fee .. When the student is ready, the teacher shows up !!
he changed my whole mind set, on tax and borrowing done by govt. 1. "sarkar tax sar pe gun rak ke lati hai and they start treating it as free money, but if they borrow they will become more accountable". 2. the exception being for necessary things like defense. 3. tax creates a dead weight cost. 4. not all capex in good and not all revenue exp is bad.
Simplicity in explanation comes from depth of knowledge. Always a pleasure to listen to Professor Tantri. You inspire us sir. Thank you @Vaad for hosting this.
Kudos to vaad and arihant. I would love to have an entire podcast dedicated to urban land and real estate issues in India and how this governement has backtracked from urban land reforms and why they are important, especially from middle class pov.
Intzaar khtm!!🙏 Analysis sun ke achha lga 👌 (2 hr lg gya 😅) Itna boring hota nhii h economics jitna socha tha (due to lack of knowledge of technical terms)....sari theories chal practical nuances pr hi h. Prasanna sir 🙏 knows ki ab DOSA,FARMER lana padega inko technicality samjhane ke liye nhii to sab upr se jayega😅 Dhanyawad VAAD team🙏 Just a suggestion Arihant bhai debate podcast show bhi host kr sakte ho ...for getting more contradictory views and will add more dimensions to discussion. Try to have a RBI guy in your podcast next time 🫣😅
This budget has shown that It is important that podcaster like you should get people like Dr Prasanna Tantri regularly. because this can influence policy.
Pata lag raha hai li Bharat ki kyu lanka lagti hai kyuki sahi knowledge vale bande decission making mai hai nahi. Or esa nahi hai ki talent nahi hai. Best example hai ye banda. Bhut important baat boli hai storage ki problem hai. Ager govt esko address ker le to inflation kabhi hogi nahi. But chakker yahi hai ki esa karenge to bade log paisa kaise banayenge.
Very good discussion. Made clarity regarding inflation trends, structural efficiency developments which will further reduce the red tape in the system. Subsequently attract private investment and our hopefully an inflow of our lost youth who migrated to other countries…. High hopes😅
Big fan of Prof.Prasanna sir…..but sir, if interest rate will go down the rupee will fall like anything…..don’t you think sir…. US fed rate is also very high
Thank you so much for clarifying that point Sir. But now you gave me new doubt. 1- You said that "Controlling Inflation means higher Unemployment." Theoretically it's logical but It's a disturbing calculation. Could you please explain why this factor is so important and how govt implements this. 2- In previous video you said that 1₹ of IT reduces aprx 2.5₹ of GDP while 1₹ of Infra CapEx multiplier is only aprx 1.5₹. Could you please explain this point, coz it is running in my mind with multiple permutation and combination. Thank you in advance.
Excellent explanation specially on interest rate cuts by Rbi. Kindly also discuss in upcoming videos how social sector spending can be improved with more optimized budgetary allocation.
Prasanna Sir Nimma Tayinadu Karnataka ge vapas banni sir.. We require people like you to contribute to our state.. fix our state economy.. hope you take special intrest and do a dedicated analysis on Karnataka state and gift us with ur inputs..
The growth of the economy will happen only with basic structural reform of contract & labour law along with land acquisition. The development of the fixed income market holds the key to competitive infrastructure financing.
Prasanna sir has always been in favor of improving 80C but this budget doesn't do that and that question is missed . If 80c bracket was increased that could also be spent in infra projects
here we are facing (Structural inflation) where food prices are spikes suddenly due to lack of connects that could be (storage , black marketing by middle man in mandis) OUR and GOV. focus should be tackle that problem
Please cover these points next time - 1. On rbi - forex rate 2. Judiciary - being the biggest burden on economic growth. Many people avoid getting into transactions just bcs they know if they get cheated, they will be stuck in judiciary process for 20 years 3. If economic activity worldover is stagnant, how can the growth rate of india be immune to those headwinds
Loved the talk. Pls have a talk on can govt use Subvention to increase skill India. Like Banks will lend money at less interest if the Industry train students and hire them for at least 18months.for the same. This Subvention can be based on skill level and salary paid to newly trained worker.
Like in all the project reports, an acid test is applied, i.e., a presumption that there is a sudden drop in GST collection and the economy suffers because of war/ strikes/ civil disobedience/ change of weather bringing lots of destruction etc etc.
I fail to understand The natural law is more risk bring more reward Politician and businessman always take high risk hence they get higher rewards But public want they should get all the rewards without taking risks Government has removed all the risk of the farmers by giving subsidies and created fixed mandi etc .They are suppose to be businessman but they have been converted into dependent on government and traders but they are still in poor condition till now
This guy speaks more sense than some of the economic advisors of Modi govt. The fact that rich and upper middle class is leaving India is worrisome . They are leaving with money which means less jobs here + big it spenders leaving which will affect the neighborhood for sure . How much effort it takes for the govt to clean and neat footpath - just footpath as roads don't need cleaning ? I see that Dubai is planting flower plants on a daily basis on divider areas and cleaning even roads ! Manpower is cheap in India ,why can't they do it just in cities .Dubai 's 50+℅ revenue is fines and fees. Why can't govt fine people who are dirtying the public places - fine based on income or some other factor of forget fine ,make him clean entire public area as a service and give one award also as a public campaign ? Bring college/school kids to clean up - not really to clean up but as an awareness campaign to stop littering and to stare/wonder at people who are littering.
Governments have to be business friendly, and enterprenurs should be able to increase export, that alone can grow economy, instead of budget juggalary by Governments.
हमने इस बार गाजर की बिजाई की थी। फसल कटाई के टाइम price ड्रॉप हो गया। हमारे गांव में cold storage नहीं है। सो, हमने उस टाइम कटाई नहीं की, सोचा जब भाव बढ़ेंगे तब फसल बेचेंगे।अब गाजर जमीन में पड़ी पड़ी बहुत ज्यादा पक गई है कि सिर्फ गाय भैंस के चारे के लिए लोग खरीद रहें है। पूरी फसल का नुकसान हो गया। लागत भी ना निकली।
Govt should increase expenditure in r&d and sectors indian private players are not moving in. That is to invest 1 trillion dollars in GPU, quantum, space, fission, med api manufacturing, commercial aircraft manufacturing technology. And then transfer this technology to private players with licencing fees. These technologies will make life cheaper because of deflationary pressure. Meanwhile govt should stop spending money on artificial intelligence, wind farms, ev and other nonsense unscientific projects like hyperloop... Let private players take the risk and invest.
Your recommendation was - don't increase the Capex, increase access to credit, reduce tax so that people have more money = and see , first time in 10 years Capex decreased, acces to credit increase, tax decrease
Yes
absolutely true me jab 3 din pahle podcast dekh raha tha Budget ke 3 din pahle tab lag raha tha ki ye jo bol rahe hai suggestion achhe hai par BJP kuch nahi karegi as a BJP supporter muje bahut gussa aa raha tha ki kuch achha nahi kar rahi aur 3 din pahle ye baat kon manega ye kuch nahi hoga par budget me ye sab hua matlab ab koi achhe economist aaye hai jo ground level ki reality government ko bata rahe hai jisse kuch improvement ho paye
Pro. Prasanna Sir आपने बहुत अच्छे से समझाया, मेरी अभी तक की जिंदगी में पहली बार मुझे ऐसा लगा कि मैं भी इकोनॉमिक्स समझ सकता हूं।
Prasanna sir....is one person where i dont miss..and also always curious to listen....what i understand from him is "spend the money where it is necessary which adds value to the economy and society which solves the issues on daily basis rather than spending on target basis".
Prasanna is my batchmate from ISB .. Sitting and listening this as an investment banker in the US ! This what you call teaching ! He should be teaching econ to Indians on National TV !! 📺 what genius.. thats why I consider him guruji 🎉 In bharatiya culture, the teacher doesnt go looking for a student, charging him tuition fee .. When the student is ready, the teacher shows up !!
just listens halfway, he is practical in approach and talks sense and good that he stayed back - not everyone has that luxury/mind/situations .
Best podcast or informative video on budget I have ever seen. Thanks Professor and Vaad for delivering this content.
.....wow..!!
WHAT A DOSA-YUKT PRECIOUS 💞💞💞 TALK SESSION....😊😊
{ KUDOS...BOTH OF YOU.}
Arihant, you are setting benchmark of podcast. Prasanna Sir, salute
he changed my whole mind set, on tax and borrowing done by govt.
1. "sarkar tax sar pe gun rak ke lati hai and they start treating it as free money, but if they borrow they will become more accountable".
2. the exception being for necessary things like defense.
3. tax creates a dead weight cost.
4. not all capex in good and not all revenue exp is bad.
Kudos to Vaad team for consistently putting up quality content. Thoroughly enjoyed both the episodes with Prof Saab. Please keep up the good work
Simplicity in explanation comes from depth of knowledge. Always a pleasure to listen to Professor Tantri. You inspire us sir. Thank you @Vaad for hosting this.
Excellent Discussion!! Loved it. Looks like someone in PMO or in Finance ministry is definitely listening 😜
Kudos to vaad and arihant. I would love to have an entire podcast dedicated to urban land and real estate issues in India and how this governement has backtracked from urban land reforms and why they are important, especially from middle class pov.
A privilege to listen to educators like you. Thank you for doing this for us.
Mr Prasanna should be made economic advisor to our central govt.
Maybe. Only expert in banks and banking operations
Intelligent people can't work with BJP
😂 But government takes advice from dilip mandal..
IAS lobby doesn't let good professors get into govt
He already is a member of an gov expert committee which focuses solely on Banking. He already mentioned it in his previous podcasts.
Love for prassanna sir from Assam ❤❤❤..I am learning so much on economics from all his youtube vedios..
I am a huge fan of prasanna sir 😊
Intzaar khtm!!🙏
Analysis sun ke achha lga 👌
(2 hr lg gya 😅)
Itna boring hota nhii h economics jitna socha tha (due to lack of knowledge of technical terms)....sari theories chal practical nuances pr hi h.
Prasanna sir 🙏 knows ki ab DOSA,FARMER lana padega inko technicality samjhane ke liye nhii to sab upr se jayega😅
Dhanyawad VAAD team🙏
Just a suggestion Arihant bhai debate podcast show bhi host kr sakte ho ...for getting more contradictory views and will add more dimensions to discussion.
Try to have a RBI guy in your podcast next time 🫣😅
Great person with practical experience, he is great teacher and researcher
True instead of Udaan....increase Railway Tracks....
Amazing content rich podcast.kudos
Good thing u called him again.
Wow woww I really wanted Prasanna sir's review of the budget ❤❤❤
As always great to hear Prasanna Sir. Bring him more often on your podcast
This budget has shown that It is important that podcaster like you should get people like Dr Prasanna Tantri regularly. because this can influence policy.
Pata lag raha hai li Bharat ki kyu lanka lagti hai kyuki sahi knowledge vale bande decission making mai hai nahi. Or esa nahi hai ki talent nahi hai. Best example hai ye banda. Bhut important baat boli hai storage ki problem hai. Ager govt esko address ker le to inflation kabhi hogi nahi. But chakker yahi hai ki esa karenge to bade log paisa kaise banayenge.
Very good discussion. Made clarity regarding inflation trends, structural efficiency developments which will further reduce the red tape in the system. Subsequently attract private investment and our hopefully an inflow of our lost youth who migrated to other countries…. High hopes😅
Why is this professor not in some economic advisory council or something, rare academic with common sense and ear and eyes to the ground!!
Because Modi just loves" Yes sir" and not intellects
Thanks Prof. Prasanna. Very helpful.
Yeh professor best
Excellent analysis ever. Thanks
Excellent podcast. Lots of learning. ❤
Big fan of Prof.Prasanna sir…..but sir, if interest rate will go down the rupee will fall like anything…..don’t you think sir…. US fed rate is also very high
Prof saab is gold in this conv. Very fair and objective is ctriticism and praise. Insightful.
Amazing podcast. In an easy way he explained things
Jai Bharat 🇮🇳🔥🗿📈 Good job BJP govt 👍 a great relief for middle class ❤
Very informative
Please bring him every 3 months time period
Thank you so much for clarifying that point Sir.
But now you gave me new doubt.
1- You said that "Controlling Inflation means higher Unemployment."
Theoretically it's logical but It's a disturbing calculation.
Could you please explain why this factor is so important and how govt implements this.
2- In previous video you said that 1₹ of IT reduces aprx 2.5₹ of GDP while 1₹ of Infra CapEx multiplier is only aprx 1.5₹. Could you please explain this point, coz it is running in my mind with multiple permutation and combination.
Thank you in advance.
I think I ❤ n understanding economy now
Conspiracy theories is correct ✅
Respect for prassans sir... His videos are so informative
Excellent points @prasannatantri
Excellent explanation specially on interest rate cuts by Rbi.
Kindly also discuss in upcoming videos how social sector spending can be improved with more optimized budgetary allocation.
Prasanna Sir Nimma Tayinadu Karnataka ge vapas banni sir.. We require people like you to contribute to our state.. fix our state economy.. hope you take special intrest and do a dedicated analysis on Karnataka state and gift us with ur inputs..
Don't worry about criticism
Excellent discussion
Best in my life time
Udaan and highways contribute to ease of living. Incentive to live in Tier-2&3 cities and rural areas and produce without extra investment.
Was waiting for this
Good erudite discussion
The growth of the economy will happen only with basic structural reform of contract & labour law along with land acquisition. The development of the fixed income market holds the key to competitive infrastructure financing.
Prasanna sir has always been in favor of improving 80C but this budget doesn't do that and that question is missed . If 80c bracket was increased that could also be spent in infra projects
Excellent analysis. Kudos to the professor 👏
Very informative
Very simplified explanation of budget, totally loved it 👏
here we are facing (Structural inflation) where food prices are spikes suddenly due to lack of connects that could be (storage , black marketing by middle man in mandis) OUR and GOV. focus should be tackle that problem
Please cover these points next time -
1. On rbi - forex rate
2. Judiciary - being the biggest burden on economic growth. Many people avoid getting into transactions just bcs they know if they get cheated, they will be stuck in judiciary process for 20 years
3. If economic activity worldover is stagnant, how can the growth rate of india be immune to those headwinds
Very good please keep this talk every three months so evey on understand the how economic works ❤
Very nice discussion on Budget which is not there in mainstream media.
Great 👍
Loved the talk. Pls have a talk on can govt use Subvention to increase skill India. Like Banks will lend money at less interest if the Industry train students and hire them for at least 18months.for the same. This Subvention can be based on skill level and salary paid to newly trained worker.
Great podcast ..❤
Arihant and Dr. Prasanna
Superb
Thanks for this video
Waiting for this only
Very Informative
Arihant & team, please invite Ankit Shah for a podcast.👍
Nice analysis
Awesome podcast
I am Just apolwed by the Statement that Babu's in our Government not able to spend the budget allocated
Amazing analysis and explanation...
Investment in planning and execution of projects is need of the hour. Lot of transparency.
Like in all the project reports, an acid test is applied, i.e., a presumption that there is a sudden drop in GST collection and the economy suffers because of war/ strikes/ civil disobedience/ change of weather bringing lots of destruction etc etc.
thank you for making this
I fail to understand
The natural law is more risk bring more reward
Politician and businessman always take high risk hence they get higher rewards
But public want they should get all the rewards without taking risks
Government has removed all the risk of the farmers by giving subsidies and created fixed mandi etc .They are suppose to be businessman but they have been converted into dependent on government and traders but they are still in poor condition till now
Plz rename the title : Budget masterclass with Dr Prasanna
This guy speaks more sense than some of the economic advisors of Modi govt. The fact that rich and upper middle class is leaving India is worrisome . They are leaving with money which means less jobs here + big it spenders leaving which will affect the neighborhood for sure .
How much effort it takes for the govt to clean and neat footpath - just footpath as roads don't need cleaning ?
I see that Dubai is planting flower plants on a daily basis on divider areas and cleaning even roads ! Manpower is cheap in India ,why can't they do it just in cities .Dubai 's 50+℅ revenue is fines and fees. Why can't govt fine people who are dirtying the public places - fine based on income or some other factor of forget fine ,make him clean entire public area as a service and give one award also as a public campaign ? Bring college/school kids to clean up - not really to clean up but as an awareness campaign to stop littering and to stare/wonder at people who are littering.
In economic activities, nothing can be forecasted exactly , it may only be proved true, if every things remains same.
Do a podcast on role of Family Planning and Savings (Traditionalism) in Economics.
Wow that was a great interview.
podcast working well.
RBI has reduced repo rate by 0.25%
Not good enough, they were asking for 1%
Governments have to be business friendly, and enterprenurs should be able to increase export, that alone can grow economy, instead of budget juggalary by Governments.
Plus increase the value of rupee in international market
Thanks Vaad.
Commenting to increase visibility. Will later comment again after finishing the video
Good insightful podcast.
great insight
thanks a lot for this discusiion
Wow! So many are already advising to move out of stocks into debt/FDs, when the expected action from RBI is to reduce interest rates.
Very informative
हमने इस बार गाजर की बिजाई की थी। फसल कटाई के टाइम price ड्रॉप हो गया। हमारे गांव में cold storage नहीं है। सो, हमने उस टाइम कटाई नहीं की, सोचा जब भाव बढ़ेंगे तब फसल बेचेंगे।अब गाजर जमीन में पड़ी पड़ी बहुत ज्यादा पक गई है कि सिर्फ गाय भैंस के चारे के लिए लोग खरीद रहें है। पूरी फसल का नुकसान हो गया। लागत भी ना निकली।
Govt should increase expenditure in r&d and sectors indian private players are not moving in.
That is to invest 1 trillion dollars in GPU, quantum, space, fission, med api manufacturing, commercial aircraft manufacturing technology. And then transfer this technology to private players with licencing fees.
These technologies will make life cheaper because of deflationary pressure.
Meanwhile govt should stop spending money on artificial intelligence, wind farms, ev and other nonsense unscientific projects like hyperloop... Let private players take the risk and invest.
It is high time India govt neee DOGE department😅 It will really solve waste expenditure and unproductive budgets !! With all due respect to Freebies😢
On what capital we are paying 12•5%of the budget? Is it foreign exchange or internal loans?
It's what government borrows by issuing bonds, it could be from RBI, Market, bonds etc
Amazing
Agree that the cities are really really bad. No attention to middle class life standards
Good analysis
Please keep the format in Hindi, that makes you unique. There are already various podcasts available in the English language.
What drastic steps need to be taken to bring back black money in the economy... Make an episode on bringing back black money...
new background looks good
Great
Vandematram
Can the host please stop interrupting and let the guest complete..
Giving free ration to people and those people dont work any more, how this will effect gdp. I want to hear Prof opinion on that😅
Prof Prasanna Tantri is amazing. The host interrupted too much.