Mohd Nazirul Mohd Norisham Jennie is just a vocalist and Jisoo, who is the lead vocalist, gets the short cut because of Jennie getting all these lines and that isn’t fair, also she prolly wasn’t hating on Jennie but yg, yg treating their main rapper better is true but that doesn’t justify it that argument made no sense, also Jennie doesn’t even get rapping lines even tho she is the main rapper. Stop overreacting.
@@milliecolon6171 people said that taht they love the song but mia have to many line im know she have many line But you love it and half of the song is mia line so if it's fair everthing would change and you wont like it as such as original
@@sanasana_5625 ikr people act like it's her line when in reality it's literally just mia stealing the chorus. She only sang the 2nd chorus but the 1st and 3rd chorus is mia
@@chulsoopasta Exactly! SHE HAS CLOSE TO NO LINES. At first I was a little upset Onda got so few lines than compared to Yiren, who got CLOSE TO NOTHING, she wasn't doing too bad. Company should do a better almost R&B concept to fit al the girls voices if they really want new fans and to make Everglow stans that have been with them since BBC less aggy. I died when someone was like : Mia and friends ft. Background noises from Yiren and Onda. I swear I wanted to cry 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@melon_ely They deserve a few lines but not as much as the vocalists and the rappers lol. shes neither and her lines are actually enough for a sub vocal
i think yiren should get more than just the hook, and the raps should be *much* longer!! solidifying that girl crush concept could be done with more raps for our rapline ㅠㅠ
Watch the Produce 48 videos, she gets real lines in them and it’s live. In the MR removed videos, she mostly has whispering lines or lines without music (ex: You’re so dun dun)
Fair treatment is 3 components: Lines, Center time and screen time. Yiren is the center and visual. It would make sense that she has more center time and screen time and less lines.
@@나연김-g2d Yuehua never said Onda is a lead vocalist. The official position is on Yuehua's weibo Acc. There it clearly says Onda is only a vocalist and lead dancer. As I remember, Sihyeon is the only lead vocalist (but I'm not sure, maybe Aisha is one too).
I do understands the "unfair" line distribution, just look at Adios demo ver. The members seemed really uncomfortable singing the lines they got, the producers try but the members must sing comfortable!
nah, this an an unpolished version, the song was not made and you can see how low the quality was. There was nothing wrong with the lines on the voice of other members. Stop acting like this demo justificate something.
Yes this would be an ideal distribution but they split the lines to make the best sounding song. If some members do not suit the sound, then they'll give it to another member. Its obvious how it works, and I don't understand why kpop fans these days focus so heavily on stuff like this. If you keep trashing the group over such little things they're going to be upset and will more likely fail to grow in the industry. Instead of spreading such negativity, why don't you try and promote them in a better light? For the girls sake. Thank you :)
For everglow it so dumb to put Mia in charge for the whole song.. I know she a main vocalist but at least pd should give others chance considering they are group. Even in chorus Mia should share lines with Sihyeon or maybe Yiren also can.. Cause Mia also sing bridge part
nah, this an an unpolished version, the song was not made and you can see how low the quality was. There was nothing wrong with the lines on the voice of other members. Stop acting like this demo justificate something. If the song doesn't fit everyone why they are even singing this song.
i did some research and the reason why the others get less lines is because their voices are not stable. I agree, it is not fair, the others need to shine too and mia is overworked (which is the thing i dont agree with) , the company must know better than us, we should just wait until their voices become more stable and maybe yunha ent will give them a special training
People saying "Onda is lead vocalist " she is not lead she is just vocalist.I'm their fan since debut and I never see any websites(official) saying Onda as lead vocalist, she is revealed as a lead dancer,visual and vocalist by her company
i love it, but sorry here's my opinion on the distribution, 1. Yeah, EVERGLOW (It's either Yiren or E:U) 2. Sihyeon still gets her 1st verse lines, E:U with backing "Oh yeah, oh yeah" 3. Same as Aisha and E:U raps 4. Mia and Onda only pre-chorus 5. Yiren does not lip the You're so dun 6. Chorus with Yiren's "you're so done!" screams and E:U's "Dun Dun!" 7. E:U and Aisha rap 8. Onda leading the prechorus, her original part can be took by Yiren 9. Yiren chorus, Sihyeon replacing Mia's line. Yiren replacing Sihyeon's line 10. Mia whole bridge 11. Sihyeon and Onda bridge 12. Yiren, you're so done done done~ 13. The youre so dun dun dun dun dun dun dun dun durara after Yiren's, can be lead by Onda and Yiren 14. The second one can be lead by Onda and Aisha 15. Mia still gets her line, E:U with Dun Dun! Onda and Yiren with that "dun dun dura dun dun duran" Sihyeon with her baby~ 16. Mia in the center, E:U and Onda dance breaks at the edge, followed by the other members 17. E:U backing vocals "Ha ha ha, you're so" 18. Sihyeon line
I love this line distribution and It would be better if they've done this, but yiren still doesn't have proper lines. but thank you for taking your time and making this video.
I hated their distributions but once I heard the demo for Adios I understand why the distribution is the way it is rn. Maybe if they composed a song in which has maybe like 30% rap for the rappers while the rest for vocals and if they made a song that fit the members comfortable range maybe then we will get a fair distribution. Of course Mia will probably get more lines since she is the Main Vocalist, E:U should get more center or center of dance break, Sihyeon and Onda getting decent lines, Aisha having longer raps and Yiren having the most center from the rest of the members.
For adios, here's my opinion on how it should have went Mia's verse: I changed that to Aisha bc I think she's the only other member who can do it Sihyeons verse: the same Aisha's rap: E:U. She needs for rap lines. Plus she can totally do it Mia's 'rap': same. Yirens verse: same Pre chorus: same Yiren's whisper thingy: onda. I feel like it was necessary Onda's verse: one for onda and one to yiren E:U's rap: same Aisha's rap: same Mia's rap: either keep it or e:u Aisha's rap: same Yiren's verse: onda Pre chorus: shiyeon and Mia switch. Mia gets the night note and shiyeon gets mia's part Whisper: yiren Onda's verse: you already know The rest is the same
nah, this an an unpolished version, the song was not made and you can see how low the quality was. There was nothing wrong with the lines on the voice of other members. Stop acting like this demo justificate something.
I do agree that everyone should get fair amount of lines, but maybe some parts are just not fit for some members. Like if you listen to adios original version it wasn’t really good and some of the members voices were akward in the song....you can tell the company was trying to make it more even in that version... Mias voice in particular fits lots of their songs so maybe that’s why the company gives her most of the lines? This is *my* opinion so don’t hate me for it pls.
I gotta question, how is sihyeon gonna sing the part at 1:56 if the choreography keeps her from doing that? She's not one of the four members dancing in the middle there so how? Also you guys have to realise that the choreography and the song goes together so most of these lines that were given to the girls dont even match up with the choreography at that point in the song. I understand everyone is upset about this but its nothing nobody can do. Mia is the main vocalist so its understandable for her to get as many lines as she did, im not going to ignore that she sung 90% of the song but its that way because she is the main vocalist so that means in terms that her voice is best suited for the song and she has a great balance between her dancing and singing.
That's cause she wouldn't sing the part right after, so she could be one of the members in the center. Also, the choreography follows the music, not the opposite. It could very well be all 6 girls doing the that laying down part and both Mia and sihyeon standing in the middle and Front.
The title gets me lol. I understand that mia is this talented to have such lines and She's the main vocalist. And Maybe, Yehua Ent. let Mia Have the lines that is for Yena. So if we insert Yena into the line distribution I think it'll be fair. But we have the other members, Like when it is a rap part they should let EU or Aisha do it and also let Onda and Yiren have fair share of lines as well. May be it's time for everglow to stray from empty choruses so that every member will have the chance to shine with their respective positions in the group 😊 edit: Great job for this.
Lol I can kinda see you wanted Mia and E.U to either share the solo dance or just plainly give it to E.U. Her solo will come! The Mia hate train has to to stop- but the company needs to know that why have members in a group to sing basically back up
guys, no hate, but you guys should go look at the adios demo. they don't just not give lines. they try and see what it would sound like and some members get different lines because it just fits their voice.
At the same time, Mia has dominated the past three eras. Yuehua needs to pick songs for Everglow that all the members to shine, not just one. Mia consistently gets the most lines and center time, and the other members rarely, if ever get a chance to shine. I think that's what the problem is.
@『JesuSaves』 Then give them more center time on stages. Mia is exhausted. Onda or E:U very easily could've had the dance break in Dun Dun, and if I'm not mistaken the dance break was supposed to be E:U's.
I’m gonna explain on how lines are *actually* distributed: The producers give each member fair lines. But if one member’s voice doesn’t fit the part they pass it on to the most vocally talented member. Visuals and Rappers always tend to get the least lines. Onda and Yiren are *visuals*. A visual’s role is to attract new and more fans with their looks and charms. That’s why visuals are always given the catchy lines. Ex. “Goodbye, au revoir, Adios” “See you later~” “SO YOU HAD BETTER RUN”.
But that still doesn't explain Onda's lines though?? If she's a visual, she should at least get centre time (she's a lead vocalist though). Also, if she can't sing properly, why would Yueha debut her as a lead vocalist???
@@divyamuthyala6815 most rookies dont sound good when they debut, they would learn and find their technique as they progress as an idol and some of the times the company is making the idol sing a way that isnt even in their vocal tone. Onda voice is higher than Mia's while Mia's is powerful than Onda's so until onda gets a proper song that shows off her vocal talent, Mia will continue to get lines because she has the stronger and stable voice
@@divyamuthyala6815 She isn't and never was a lead vocalist, which also lines up with her vocal ability. Lead vocalist doesn't mean "has longest timed lines" anyway, it means that they were chosen as one of the best vocalists and tend to get harder parts (not as hard as main vocal's parts)
I actually like this. This is a fair line distribution. I know people will find E:U and Aisha still short on the distribution of their lines but this is normal for rappers.
This will be a really long comment so you might not want to not read this Tbh I really wish that this was a real line distribution I'm so done with company's that put one idol in the spotlight because they have to do more work and that's probably worse for your voice and you are also giving that idol a nice big target for hate to hate he or she with . Yeah if their positions where treated well then this would probably become the lines . Companies will trash dungeon and throw away any idol and it's stupid. I'm done with one member in the spotlight like I know that like you want a face of the group yes you can have one but so many companys put one in spotlight and disrespect the other when they have trained so hard and long to get hate or be forgotten. Like I know that some parts might not fit the voice of the person but then make a song that does. I feel bad for these idol who do train so long just to get that stuff . I feel even worse to know its true .This isn't a hate comment I'm just so tired of seeing this all the time and I need somewhere to get it out Again I really wish this was a real line distribution Sorry this is long but if you read all this then thank you!
Don’t come at me but I’m alright with the original line distribution. Yes Mia did get a lot which cause her to get hate from people who don’t know that she doesn’t have anything to do with it. But, she’s the main vocalist, it’s normal for her to get most lines bc she has the best technique. And to look at it the other way, they have four members who’re just vocalists. Right above sub-vocal, if not basically the same. And everything in kpop isn’t about the songs. Like, you can be a terrific dancer with amazing visuals but terrible singing and still qualify to join the group. Yiren is still the most popular member and the only ‘bigger position’ she has is lead dancer.
what’s unfair is you guys don’t really do all this for guy groups. yeah i agree the line distribution is horrible but don’t give hate to her. give it to the company. they’re the ones doing it.
this is basically what we need,, the producers should also post the demo ver maybe its the same case as adios. Mia as the main vocalist deserves the most lines but not 1 min of the song...
That's really crazy how company not only do not treat members properly, but also creates the illusion that only Mia has vocal and dance abilities in group
I dislike the distribution and you made it way better. Mia had so much hate. People acted like she made the distribution. There is proof in the demo for Adios that the members who got the least lines had some of Mia's, but it was changed bc she fit them more. That was prob the case here to. Thanks for this distribution. I like it a lot.
Ok so I like the vid and everything but people say onda deserve more lines and it's true cause she'doesnt get line my .but yiren didn't get proper lines like she also deserves more lines though (btw yiren is my bias )
Honestly I agree with this video. I heard the demo version of adios and I can see why mia got most of the lines. Her voice just fit the sound better but hearing everyone's voices in dun dun, the members could have gotten have of mias lines, especially sihyeon and yiren since their voices fit really well in the parts they already have. Onda deserves more parts as well and I'm sure they could have fit her somewhere other than just doing ad libs but at the same time, companies don't wanna take the time for their idols and just want the music done asap
nah, this an an unpolished version, the song was not made and you can see how low the quality was. There was nothing wrong with the lines on the voice of other members. Stop acting like this demo justificate something.
i rarely see people talk about yiren's lack of lines but in dundun she only sings "yeah... everglow" as an intro and then the prechorus "you're so dun dun dududun dun dududun dun dududun"
These are their actual positions: Sihyeon: Vocalist and Visual E:U: Rapper and Lead Dancer Onda: Vocalist, Visual and Dancer Aisha: Rapper and Vocalist Yiren: Sub-Vocalist, Visual and Dancer Mia: Main Vocalist, Main Rapper, Main Dancer, Center and Face of the group
I really dont get yuehua for debuting mia with everglow. If she is that talented, wouldnt it be better if she debut as a solo artist instead of debuting her a group, just to have her group members be backup dancers for her?
dorotheia kim The companies haven’t confirmed that Yena is even joining lol and that’s dumb of them to “save lines” for if she was to join. The company/producers/choreographers are all just biased towards Mia and it shows through everything.
@@stxrryglxw1629 lets not conclude to that , we dont know that. Its not like Mia owns half the company or something, Mia is just the stronger vocal and dancer out of everglow. But also its not Mia's fault shes getting all these lines and screen time. Like i said, she is strongest when she is singing and dancing and some members arent, so that why they put her out like that. No hate to the other members though.
This Video: **Exists** YueHua Entertainment: 👁👄👁 *[For New ForEvers/EVERGLOW Fans: If you don't know who is YueHua Entertainment, YueHua Entertainment is the agency/company of EVERGLOW, I hope this helps ^-^]*
Their company is setting Mia up for a lot of hate that she doesn’t deserve
Saskia Carter True :(
Saskia Carter Just like Jennie from BLACKPINK. She gets more vocal lines than the main vocalist but she’s a main rapper🤨😕
@Mohd Nazirul Mohd Norisham exactly
Mohd Nazirul Mohd Norisham Jennie is just a vocalist and Jisoo, who is the lead vocalist, gets the short cut because of Jennie getting all these lines and that isn’t fair, also she prolly wasn’t hating on Jennie but yg, yg treating their main rapper better is true but that doesn’t justify it that argument made no sense, also Jennie doesn’t even get rapping lines even tho she is the main rapper. Stop overreacting.
Hobi‘s noudle soup
Ikr, lol also as a former jennie stan i don’t hate her but i just don’t see why they should give jisoo less singing lines than her
the shade on the title lol.
Ikr, we love a Shady facts spitting Queen
Lmao I was like: *Ö*
*wELL*
EunKi ARMY they didn’t get lines bc the song sounds terrible without mia getting what she did, go listen to the demo
i died laughing after reading that
@@teddybear3262 i dont get it what shade?
That title though :v
*YueHua is shaking*
They should be
@ღAsel Secret Angelღ true they are probably more successful then the big 3 companies in korea.
I'd prefer this over mia ft friends with background noises from Onda
I'll put
Mia & Sihyeon - DUN DUN (ft. Aisha, E:U [FT.! Yiren, Onda]) idk if everyone understand
Like the original name
E:U rap' rhythm
@Cathrielle Navarro LMAOOOOOO DRUM NOISES STOP
@@milliecolon6171 tbh same kpop was never about fair treatmeant in first place is about creating music that spund the best in public eyes
@@milliecolon6171 people said that taht they love the song but mia have to many line im know she have many line
But you love it and half of the song is mia line so if it's fair everthing would change and you wont like it as such as original
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
2:17 wish that line could be given to Yiren since she only sang dun dun ddada
Same
She didn't even get the dun dun da da dun line. Can't you hear Mia's natural tambour? She got that line as well.
@@sanasana_5625 ikr people act like it's her line when in reality it's literally just mia stealing the chorus. She only sang the 2nd chorus but the 1st and 3rd chorus is mia
Yiren just sings "you're so dun", "now you're dun" and the 2nd chorus :'v
@@chulsoopasta Exactly! SHE HAS CLOSE TO NO LINES. At first I was a little upset Onda got so few lines than compared to Yiren, who got CLOSE TO NOTHING, she wasn't doing too bad. Company should do a better almost R&B concept to fit al the girls voices if they really want new fans and to make Everglow stans that have been with them since BBC less aggy. I died when someone was like : Mia and friends ft. Background noises from Yiren and Onda. I swear I wanted to cry 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
i like the idea of having onda sing at 1:25 i feel like it would really suit her
@장윤우 agreed and she said she's uncomfortable at stages most times!!!
Panda can you send me a link?
@@winniejung Do you have the video where she said that?
Go watch the demo and the line distribution will make sense
@장윤우 If Onda were untalented or with a bad voice then, she wonn't be accepted by the agency
If it doesn't have a nanananananana, it's not an Everglow song.
0:03 if i saw the producer of everglow's songs i would look at them like how E:U looks at the screen
when you are sleepy but you have to finish the homeworks =))))
Z Í L D J Ì Å Ñ Ē Ñ R Í Q Ü Ē Z ̊ the difference is that I will never look as pretty as her
0:38
Lee Chaeryeong
I replied to the wrong person, sorry, lmao
Holiday Pup ok? lol
Yiren still doesn't get a proper line... People only pay attention to Onda but totally forget that Yiren doesn't get PROPER lines too..
SMH as long as it’s fair there shouldn’t be a problem. Be grateful they took the time and effort to try and please us
Shes not even in the vocal line nor in the rap line. Shes just in the visual line and dance line so she would be treated as just a Sub Vocalist
@@whyaminotkorean2340 So a sub vocal doesn't deserve any lines lol???
@@melon_ely They deserve a few lines but not as much as the vocalists and the rappers lol. shes neither and her lines are actually enough for a sub vocal
@@whyaminotkorean2340 exactly,is like Shuhua
**Yuehua left the chat**
Can you do No lie or Player? It was a b-side of them also
Kim Ahron i’d love to see no lie
@@ailatoivay same
Yess please
i think yiren should get more than just the hook, and the raps should be *much* longer!! solidifying that girl crush concept could be done with more raps for our rapline ㅠㅠ
Y’all are talking about Yiren getting more lines, but half of the time she doesn’t even sing the ones that she gets lol
Yeah she almost never sings live, Mia and Aisha/E.U are the most credible live performers.
@@alexblack4048 agree 3 of them is really stable idk how mia still stable with those line
Watch the Produce 48 videos, she gets real lines in them and it’s live. In the MR removed videos, she mostly has whispering lines or lines without music (ex: You’re so dun dun)
EXACTLYYYYY
She might not be confident in her voice, stop hating on her
the title- 💀🍵
Yiren does not have a full line
She’s also a sub vocal and is in 3rd place
Fair treatment is 3 components: Lines, Center time and screen time. Yiren is the center and visual. It would make sense that she has more center time and screen time and less lines.
Why people pay attention only to onda? I’m not hating on her but yiren has not proper lines too
But yiren is a visual and vocalist while onda is *lead* vocalist
Jennie is my bias y’all exactly
@@나연김-g2d Onda is not lead vocal, people just assumed she was but she's not.
@@나연김-g2d
Yuehua never said Onda is a lead vocalist. The official position is on Yuehua's weibo Acc. There it clearly says Onda is only a vocalist and lead dancer. As I remember, Sihyeon is the only lead vocalist (but I'm not sure, maybe Aisha is one too).
@@나연김-g2d onda isnt lead vocal
I do understands the "unfair" line distribution, just look at Adios demo ver. The members seemed really uncomfortable singing the lines they got, the producers try but the members must sing comfortable!
nah, this an an unpolished version, the song was not made and you can see how low the quality was. There was nothing wrong with the lines on the voice of other members. Stop acting like this demo justificate something.
so much better 😊
Please make many of these we forevers badly need it
P E R F E C T👍
Cool, I like and subscribe ❤️
i expected it was more fair, but it made a BIG difference, thank you for this i'm really grateful
Yes this would be an ideal distribution but they split the lines to make the best sounding song. If some members do not suit the sound, then they'll give it to another member. Its obvious how it works, and I don't understand why kpop fans these days focus so heavily on stuff like this. If you keep trashing the group over such little things they're going to be upset and will more likely fail to grow in the industry. Instead of spreading such negativity, why don't you try and promote them in a better light? For the girls sake. Thank you :)
For everglow it so dumb to put Mia in charge for the whole song.. I know she a main vocalist but at least pd should give others chance considering they are group. Even in chorus Mia should share lines with Sihyeon or maybe Yiren also can.. Cause Mia also sing bridge part
nah, this an an unpolished version, the song was not made and you can see how low the quality was. There was nothing wrong with the lines on the voice of other members. Stop acting like this demo justificate something. If the song doesn't fit everyone why they are even singing this song.
Onda and Yiren were literally just backup vocals the whole song, they dont deserve that :(
This will never happen but it looks so good
I subscribed before I even watched the vid purely because of the shade in the title lmao
i did some research and the reason why the others get less lines is because their voices are not stable. I agree, it is not fair, the others need to shine too and mia is overworked (which is the thing i dont agree with) , the company must know better than us, we should just wait until their voices become more stable and maybe yunha ent will give them a special training
I prefer E:U do the Dance break cause she gets less lines and it will be more fair if she gets more center distribution
same
SAME
exactly, if they didn't give her lines she should've done the dance break. she's the main dancer as well
People saying "Onda is lead vocalist " she is not lead she is just vocalist.I'm their fan since debut and I never see any websites(official) saying Onda as lead vocalist, she is revealed as a lead dancer,visual and vocalist by her company
i love it, but sorry here's my opinion on the distribution,
1. Yeah, EVERGLOW (It's either Yiren or E:U)
2. Sihyeon still gets her 1st verse lines, E:U with backing "Oh yeah, oh yeah"
3. Same as Aisha and E:U raps
4. Mia and Onda only pre-chorus
5. Yiren does not lip the You're so dun
6. Chorus with Yiren's "you're so done!" screams and E:U's "Dun Dun!"
7. E:U and Aisha rap
8. Onda leading the prechorus, her original part can be took by Yiren
9. Yiren chorus, Sihyeon replacing Mia's line. Yiren replacing Sihyeon's line
10. Mia whole bridge
11. Sihyeon and Onda bridge
12. Yiren, you're so done done done~
13. The youre so dun dun dun dun dun dun dun dun durara after Yiren's, can be lead by Onda and Yiren
14. The second one can be lead by Onda and Aisha
15. Mia still gets her line, E:U with Dun Dun! Onda and Yiren with that "dun dun dura dun dun duran" Sihyeon with her baby~
16. Mia in the center, E:U and Onda dance breaks at the edge, followed by the other members
17. E:U backing vocals "Ha ha ha, you're so"
18. Sihyeon line
I love this line distribution and It would be better if they've done this, but yiren still doesn't have proper lines. but thank you for taking your time and making this video.
You forgot E:U's "Ah Yeah" I Sihyeon's part
Even as a mia bias this is much better than the original
This is exactly what i am looking for. I need to see this.
This is better. I like this
I hated their distributions but once I heard the demo for Adios I understand why the distribution is the way it is rn. Maybe if they composed a song in which has maybe like 30% rap for the rappers while the rest for vocals and if they made a song that fit the members comfortable range maybe then we will get a fair distribution. Of course Mia will probably get more lines since she is the Main Vocalist, E:U should get more center or center of dance break, Sihyeon and Onda getting decent lines, Aisha having longer raps and Yiren having the most center from the rest of the members.
For adios, here's my opinion on how it should have went
Mia's verse: I changed that to Aisha bc I think she's the only other member who can do it
Sihyeons verse: the same
Aisha's rap: E:U. She needs for rap lines. Plus she can totally do it
Mia's 'rap': same.
Yirens verse: same
Pre chorus: same
Yiren's whisper thingy: onda. I feel like it was necessary
Onda's verse: one for onda and one to yiren
E:U's rap: same
Aisha's rap: same
Mia's rap: either keep it or e:u
Aisha's rap: same
Yiren's verse: onda
Pre chorus: shiyeon and Mia switch. Mia gets the night note and shiyeon gets mia's part
Whisper: yiren
Onda's verse: you already know
The rest is the same
nah, this an an unpolished version, the song was not made and you can see how low the quality was. There was nothing wrong with the lines on the voice of other members. Stop acting like this demo justificate something.
woah big update here even though yall probably know already the huge leap of onda getting a dance break and e:u getting those rap lines woah woah woah
@@ggstan2439 yeah, it was a demo and unpolished and even still Mia sound like the official version... You can really tell the difference.
I do agree that everyone should get fair amount of lines, but maybe some parts are just not fit for some members. Like if you listen to adios original version it wasn’t really good and some of the members voices were akward in the song....you can tell the company was trying to make it more even in that version...
Mias voice in particular fits lots of their songs so maybe that’s why the company gives her most of the lines? This is *my* opinion so don’t hate me for it pls.
I gotta question, how is sihyeon gonna sing the part at 1:56 if the choreography keeps her from doing that? She's not one of the four members dancing in the middle there so how?
Also you guys have to realise that the choreography and the song goes together so most of these lines that were given to the girls dont even match up with the choreography at that point in the song. I understand everyone is upset about this but its nothing nobody can do. Mia is the main vocalist so its understandable for her to get as many lines as she did, im not going to ignore that she sung 90% of the song but its that way because she is the main vocalist so that means in terms that her voice is best suited for the song and she has a great balance between her dancing and singing.
That's cause she wouldn't sing the part right after, so she could be one of the members in the center. Also, the choreography follows the music, not the opposite. It could very well be all 6 girls doing the that laying down part and both Mia and sihyeon standing in the middle and Front.
I think people need to realise even with a fair line distribution mia is more likely to have the most lines shes the bloody MAIN VOCALIST
thanks for that
The title gets me lol. I understand that mia is this talented to have such lines and She's the main vocalist. And Maybe, Yehua Ent. let Mia Have the lines that is for Yena. So if we insert Yena into the line distribution I think it'll be fair. But we have the other members, Like when it is a rap part they should let EU or Aisha do it and also let Onda and Yiren have fair share of lines as well. May be it's time for everglow to stray from empty choruses so that every member will have the chance to shine with their respective positions in the group 😊
edit: Great job for this.
Lol I can kinda see you wanted Mia and E.U to either share the solo dance or just plainly give it to E.U. Her solo will come! The Mia hate train has to to stop- but the company needs to know that why have members in a group to sing basically back up
To ya'll saying Yiren doesn't have a proper line, she sang the last part that was Sihyeon's originally
But she still didn't get proper lines no hate though since she only sang ur so dun dun dun dun dun dun dun dun🤣forgive me if this is hurtful😅🙏😂
*Yuehua left the chat*...
guys, no hate, but you guys should go look at the adios demo. they don't just not give lines. they try and see what it would sound like and some members get different lines because it just fits their voice.
At the same time, Mia has dominated the past three eras. Yuehua needs to pick songs for Everglow that all the members to shine, not just one. Mia consistently gets the most lines and center time, and the other members rarely, if ever get a chance to shine. I think that's what the problem is.
@『JesuSaves』 Then give them more center time on stages. Mia is exhausted. Onda or E:U very easily could've had the dance break in Dun Dun, and if I'm not mistaken the dance break was supposed to be E:U's.
No, I found a way to distribute it fairly
I’m gonna explain on how lines are *actually* distributed:
The producers give each member fair lines. But if one member’s voice doesn’t fit the part they pass it on to the most vocally talented member. Visuals and Rappers always tend to get the least lines. Onda and Yiren are *visuals*. A visual’s role is to attract new and more fans with their looks and charms. That’s why visuals are always given the catchy lines. Ex. “Goodbye, au revoir, Adios” “See you later~” “SO YOU HAD BETTER RUN”.
But that still doesn't explain Onda's lines though?? If she's a visual, she should at least get centre time (she's a lead vocalist though). Also, if she can't sing properly, why would Yueha debut her as a lead vocalist???
@@divyamuthyala6815 most rookies dont sound good when they debut, they would learn and find their technique as they progress as an idol and some of the times the company is making the idol sing a way that isnt even in their vocal tone. Onda voice is higher than Mia's while Mia's is powerful than Onda's so until onda gets a proper song that shows off her vocal talent, Mia will continue to get lines because she has the stronger and stable voice
@@quiseanamack6864 agree
@@divyamuthyala6815 She isn't and never was a lead vocalist, which also lines up with her vocal ability. Lead vocalist doesn't mean "has longest timed lines" anyway, it means that they were chosen as one of the best vocalists and tend to get harder parts (not as hard as main vocal's parts)
yiren still doesn't have lines in this video
she just sings ' you're so dun-"
Onda be like: *THANK YOU GOD*
I 100% agree with this video. They all have equal lines according to their positions.
E:U with the dance break tho
1 - Mia
2 - Sihyeon
3 - Aisha
4 - E:U
5 - Onda
6 - Yiren
me: slows it to 0.75x so i can enjoy the song while seeing the distribution
I actually like this. This is a fair line distribution. I know people will find E:U and Aisha still short on the distribution of their lines but this is normal for rappers.
mia doesn’t deserve the hate, it’s not her fault, she doesn’t give herself all the lines like soyeon does
I mostly agree with your distribution, but I would also give a few more lines to yiren, like for example maybe at 1:33
The title though hahahahahaha it's what we need.
Eu amei o vídeo! ♥️
Errrrr........+- perfect💖
This will be a really long comment so you might not want to not read this
Tbh I really wish that this was a real line distribution
I'm so done with company's that put one idol in the spotlight because they have to do more work and that's probably worse for your voice and you are also giving that idol a nice big target for hate to hate he or she with . Yeah if their positions where treated well then this would probably become the lines . Companies will trash dungeon and throw away any idol and it's stupid. I'm done with one member in the spotlight like I know that like you want a face of the group yes you can have one but so many companys put one in spotlight and disrespect the other when they have trained so hard and long to get hate or be forgotten. Like I know that some parts might not fit the voice of the person but then make a song that does. I feel bad for these idol who do train so long just to get that stuff . I feel even worse to know its true .This isn't a hate comment I'm just so tired of seeing this all the time and I need somewhere to get it out
Again I really wish this was a real line distribution
Sorry this is long but if you read all this then thank you!
Off topic but the way I can rap to the rap parts at this speed. My inner rapper is proud.
0,75 speed for normal speed
You're welcome
I’m just happy that Onda got more screen time 😂
On a positive note, this is very fun to dance to
finally onda is lead vocalist instead of main screamer
Don’t come at me but I’m alright with the original line distribution. Yes Mia did get a lot which cause her to get hate from people who don’t know that she doesn’t have anything to do with it. But, she’s the main vocalist, it’s normal for her to get most lines bc she has the best technique.
And to look at it the other way, they have four members who’re just vocalists. Right above sub-vocal, if not basically the same.
And everything in kpop isn’t about the songs. Like, you can be a terrific dancer with amazing visuals but terrible singing and still qualify to join the group. Yiren is still the most popular member and the only ‘bigger position’ she has is lead dancer.
sihyeon is the best singer
what’s unfair is you guys don’t really do all this for guy groups. yeah i agree the line distribution is horrible but don’t give hate to her. give it to the company. they’re the ones doing it.
*How would EverGlow sing Dun Dun if Mia doesn't sing the intire song, while the others dance in the background*
this is basically what we need,, the producers should also post the demo ver maybe its the same case as adios. Mia as the main vocalist deserves the most lines but not 1 min of the song...
If you listen to it at 2x speed sounds like if they were in a hurry to make the song LOLLLOLOLLOL
1.5x speed is a lot better because 2x would be too fast to be possible.
*RESPECT*
Pa mi que deberías de saber la que da líneas y que te contacten
THE TITLE SKSKSNSNSK BYE
THAT TITLE HITS HARD
Please make The Boots fair line distribution !!!!
I like it
i love this version so much and i would like to hear it if it could be made but i also wish Yiren to get a proper line too but this is amazign
I don’t get why Mia just HAS to get all the lines just like this it’s not hard to give everyone fair length lines
Yea idk why
That's really crazy how company not only do not treat members properly, but also creates the illusion that only Mia has vocal and dance abilities in group
Love this
Yiren: Youre so dun dun. For the whole song.
Yiren saying "you're so dun" is basically Nayeon's "I'm gonna be a star"
SOMEONE SEND THIS TO THEIR COMPANY
I dislike the distribution and you made it way better. Mia had so much hate. People acted like she made the distribution. There is proof in the demo for Adios that the members who got the least lines had some of Mia's, but it was changed bc she fit them more. That was prob the case here to. Thanks for this distribution. I like it a lot.
Everglow producer: *open UA-cam*
UA-cam: *this*
Everglow producer: ...later! 😁
Ok so I like the vid and everything but people say onda deserve more lines and it's true cause she'doesnt get line my .but yiren didn't get proper lines like she also deserves more lines though (btw yiren is my bias )
Yuahua looking at the title: 👁👄👁
Onda : vocalist, lead dancer , visuel
Onda cant sing mia's parts. It was proven on that leaked studio version of Adios
Oh wait really ? Do you have a link please ?
@@sosooya4895 ua-cam.com/video/EwN1foxAAEI/v-deo.html here it is :)
Mia’s pre chorus part in this song (Dun Dun) isn’t really high and is easy to sing compared to Adios’ prechorus
The demo was a demo lol, it wasn't even mastered well you don't even know how it would really sound with Onda.
@Abdulmuizz Elegbeji no it wasn't autotune it was a backup music her voice is actually shaku
Finally someone giving justice to Onda
Mia - Dun Dun (feat. Sihyeon with special appearance of 3 background dancers and weird noises of girl with orange hair)
This is so true
Honestly I agree with this video. I heard the demo version of adios and I can see why mia got most of the lines. Her voice just fit the sound better but hearing everyone's voices in dun dun, the members could have gotten have of mias lines, especially sihyeon and yiren since their voices fit really well in the parts they already have. Onda deserves more parts as well and I'm sure they could have fit her somewhere other than just doing ad libs but at the same time, companies don't wanna take the time for their idols and just want the music done asap
nah, this an an unpolished version, the song was not made and you can see how low the quality was. There was nothing wrong with the lines on the voice of other members. Stop acting like this demo justificate something.
i rarely see people talk about yiren's lack of lines but in dundun she only sings "yeah... everglow" as an intro and then the prechorus "you're so dun dun dududun dun dududun dun dududun"
Preach
if you set the speed to 0.75 it sounds like the real song
These are their actual positions:
Sihyeon: Vocalist and Visual
E:U: Rapper and Lead Dancer
Onda: Vocalist, Visual and Dancer
Aisha: Rapper and Vocalist
Yiren: Sub-Vocalist, Visual and Dancer
Mia: Main Vocalist, Main Rapper, Main Dancer, Center and Face of the group
Actual Yiren position (current 2022):
Lead Dancer, Sub Vocalist, Sub Rapper, Visual, Center, Face Of The Group, Maknae
The fact that Mia is main in all three LMAOO ☠️
I really dont get yuehua for debuting mia with everglow. If she is that talented, wouldnt it be better if she debut as a solo artist instead of debuting her a group, just to have her group members be backup dancers for her?
tbh, its sorta obvious that yena is gonna join everglow after izone so i think some of mia's lines right now are reserved for yena
dorotheia kim The companies haven’t confirmed that Yena is even joining lol and that’s dumb of them to “save lines” for if she was to join. The company/producers/choreographers are all just biased towards Mia and it shows through everything.
@@stxrryglxw1629 lets not conclude to that , we dont know that. Its not like Mia owns half the company or something, Mia is just the stronger vocal and dancer out of everglow. But also its not Mia's fault shes getting all these lines and screen time. Like i said, she is strongest when she is singing and dancing and some members arent, so that why they put her out like that. No hate to the other members though.
This Video: **Exists**
YueHua Entertainment: 👁👄👁
*[For New ForEvers/EVERGLOW Fans: If you don't know who is YueHua Entertainment, YueHua Entertainment is the agency/company of EVERGLOW, I hope this helps ^-^]*