@@Thoughtflux Wrong ! Presently "general" people are being discriminated. I know you love being a victim. But still do something rather than asking for extra advantage. Also you cannot reverse present discrimination by doing more discrimination.
The privileged hardly understand that they have privileges. You need a seperate episode explaining how and what privilege looks like or in what small forms it has been passed on to us! Because most urban kids have closed their eyes to look beyond what they see around themselves. :(
The very reason the so called urban kids know and despise reserved community is only because of reservation. This is only gonna get worse in the coming years. So much so for equality.
No. Need Dubbing in every major languages. Hindi doesn't even reach half of the population. And people who don't understand English, don't have time for these thoughts. They are at the lower portion of Maslow's Hierarchy.
This is best video ever on reservation! Tight slap on those who say that it's merit vs reservation but don't acknowledge their privileges...more power to u newslaundry👍
yes i am privilege that had 0 ft of land , my grand father has to work in farm for bare minimum wage but had higher privilege than lalu or sarad pawar , f off
Merit is wholly dependent upon opportunity. It might have been a case that if those, who are uneducated, had gotten a chance to study they might have been more successful than today's meritorious people. It's just that some people are at lack of something that could be in the form of money, social privilege or circumstances.
So the solution should be more focussed on providing quality education accessible to such people, right? Reservation is a pretty non-optimal way of solving that problem.
@@SarthakGupta259 These people don't want upliftment of poors otherwise how'll these educated, rich, elitist messiahs of downtrodden fool their own people in name of reservations !! This anchor also selectively uses Babasaheb's remarks while completely disregarding the temporary nature of the original provision !!
You should have talked about representation. How major institutions, corporates, judiciary, entertainment industry don't have dalit representation at all.
Recently, representative Alexandria Ocasio Cortez brought up scarcity mentality. The scarcity mentality that makes us fight amongst overselves for the crumbs instead of fighting upwards. We need to fight upwards, while acknowledging the privilege we carry with us.
I'm under OBC but I haven't applied for any post or seat under OBC category. I think reservation should only be given to SC and ST. Scrap the term OBC.
I happen to NOT use that category even though I was eligible for it too. Though I am not a professional on this subject, I would like to tell you that you might be living in a location where it is completely unnecessary and everyone is treated with dignity and respect, irrespective of their caste or religion. But there are certainly people who are at a disadvantage socially and educationally even today, who definitely need such provisions.
Damn Meghnad.. You make me feel that I am not alone. The unbelievable amount of whatsapp forwards I have received from relatives about merit, has always made me feel so depressed..
Should have talked about the concessions in marks cutoff in examinations, where the real heartburn begins. Clueless and socially illiterate students begin revolting against this disparity first.
there is no concession in marks. Reservation doesn't bring down marks required to pass. ANd talking about heartburn. You should see your privileges and be happy.
Pls brother dub it in hindi....this information is a gem...which had never been showed to the society...even to the upper caste society...pls dub it so that it can reach to wider sections of society...That 0.25% was the core point....hats off...
I rarely leave a comment. For the first time in the past 29 years of my life I feel there is hope for India. If a bunch of people on this youtube channel can understand and articulate one of the most polarized issues in India so well, I believe so can others if they choose to educate themselves. So glad I watched this video 🙂
There is 100% percent reservations for Brahmins in the priest profession, also 100% reservation for Dalits in the manual scavenging profession, even in today’s day & age. Let’s start by ending this reservation first & then focus on other aspects.
As election is around the corner .....next chapter should be Election and Electoral behaviour and reforms needed in election process ...hope you will read my comment ..... And thanks for this awesome work ,keep doing it ..I love all your content in your channel ... encourage and share with my frnds to watch them....
Socially and educationally backward classes is an open category and does not directly equate to OBCs. That is the only error I would like to point out. I really liked the video.
Don't you think these laws needs timely review, to see how many people equalled and how many left and give benefits to those?? Anyway in my view progressive mind is much required over progressive laws.. In India we give reservations not for equality just to address people differently and do politics over it..
Education GEN-EWS: 10% OBC-NCL: 27% SC: 15% ST: 7.5% In IIT GEN-EWS: 10% OBC-NCL: 27% SC: 15% ST: 7.5% in NEETs Now people talking about privilege i hope you are talking about yourself not because of some news you heard of attrocities against lower caste. Is it all about JOBs?? We even can not reach IIT how can we think of better JOB?? If this is privilege why would someone want it?? i am happy to be discriminated and not allowed entry in temple as long as iam getting reservation where i have to score 32 to clear JEE and not 91. Where i have to get 61 instead of 75 for clearing mains.
Thank you, NL! being a dalit, I want to thank you very much for this episode. I hope people will get why reservation was implemented rather than crying for it!
Reservation is not only for Job but it impacts the competitive exams as well. If you include that detail - basically all the institute giving 50% seats - those seats do translate to a job - mostly in the private sector. What is the harm in giving reservation only to economically backward class - even 50% - rather than making it caste based?
For that we need complete annihilation of caste. Why were reservations required in the first place? Because backward castes were economically backward. My mother is teacher in a semi-rural high school. The correlation between caste and economic state is painfully obvious there.
@@anweshaguha7366 Not sure I agree with the annihilation of caste concept - that is the idealistic approach. Discrimination finds a way - if not caste then it will be the region or the skin color or the education. The result of the current caste system is economic backwardness which can be answered using reservation for them which will also help them to grow. The social deformation hampers the poor most so that should be the priority. I do understand the rich Dalit also faces discrimination but that should be dealt with laws of the land - not reservation.
@@abhineshbachchan3212 That will be a dream to have an unfragmented society - what we need to strive are less hatred and more bonding. Probably education is the only answer - added with the law to handle discrimination.
It's not about merit! With the total reserved seats now - 79% in TN, Maharashtra- 78%, MP- 73% and so on and Moreover unreserved seats are also available for reserved groups. And most SC students in my colleage came in BMWs, Audi etc. What a social justice! India will be a superpower with substandard bureaucracy, doctors and engineers. I'll never treat my children with substandard doctors no matter their caste.
Funny though MH and TN are two of the most developed states in India.... Especially in case of TN...reservations helped lot of people and decreased the socioeconomic disparities.
@@srikk9 is the growth anything compared to South Korea, China etc which were behind India at the time of independence. Reservation did not cause growth they grew inspite of reservation. To improve socioeconomic condition focus should be on health and education investment of the needy and not giving benefit of reservation to only a few families generation after generation.
@@cutekitten4351 My friend reservations were best implemented in Tamil Nadu that's why it has best budding middle class...the principal of reservations is to include as many people as possible in higher strata of societies....look at all the politicians and top business personnel in India they are mostly from upper castes...this is because they enjoy the privilege of being part of high class societies for centuries at least. 90 % villages in India still practice cast discrimination....the houses of dalits are on outskirts....manual scavenging of sewage is still done by chamars....(is there any upper caste person who does this...I don't want any person to do this ..but till we get the equipment and resources to do it mechanically is it not good to share the burden) ..this hegemony cannot be corrected in few decades...it will take take a century or two create a level playing field with democracy.... China has an authoritarian government...we can't compare ourselves with China...we didn't give away our freedom of choice for development
Sri K Tamil Nadu is in no way any different than an average Indian state, even states like Himachal outperform it in most indicators. As far as domination of upper caste is concerned it is not due to privileges but the persuit of excellence that is embedded in their mindset. That is why they are successful all over the world. I got scholarship due to my caste? While my reserved category classmates even from better schools struggled. Did Ramanujam succeed due to his caste even after being poor? While there are people like Ambedkar who succeeded even after facing 19th century discrimination. What reservation has actually done is to make general category students more hard working and unreserved ones less competent thereby increasing inequality, this is also encouraging brain drain from India- from Indira Noyi to Sunder Pichai all are high caste. Instead of promoting excellence India is becoming a bastion of mediocrity while the world is marching ahead. Instead of reservation the depressed castes should be exposed to intense competition that is prevalent in the world and make them help themselves. What they need is support in form of best education and health and not substandard teachers and doctors which are going to service them again creating another generation of mediocres.
@@cutekitten4351 Weak sections of community cannot be thrown in competition without strengthening them first.... The pursuit excellence came in because of lower caste people had been subjugated to worst form of "Manuwadi"...im guessing you don't know how dalits were treated.... Please read Manu Smrithi.... Anyhow I will give personally account of my grandfather......he had to tie a broom to his waist which is used to erase his foot steps....his had carry his own container to spit into...he was not supposed to speak to upper cast people with his head up...mind you this was just 80 years ago...if a group of people were this kind of subjugation for thousands of years.....fear and risk aversion will be instilled in their genes.... Taking about privilege....why is that marwardies control most of the dealerships in consumer goods.....this is because they had social capital for lot of years...they rarely alllow people of other communities to enter the market (again there are exceptions everywhere) they have stronghold on.local markets and goods ...that's why you see big ecommerce entrepreneurs coming from these communities..... It takes people from subjugated castes lot of years to develop this level of confidence and hold on businesses.... All people did not start at zero from independence but most of dalits stated from negative at the time of independence...
you can study 'annihilation of caste' written by B.R.Ambedkar. in it’s penguin edition,you'll find a foreword written by arundhati roy,which will give a vivid picture of atrocities of castism in india. For more,you can read the writings of journalist p.sainath.
Devyani khobergade is case in point.. her father got into bureaucracy due to reservation and even she got into due to that... Result- numerous corruption cases against father and daughter almost broke down India-US relations because of her stupidity and playing dalit card. They don't need reservation as they can use the numerous constitutional and legal remedies available to them, who actually need are rural dalits who never get chance to break away from the I'll society. Truth remains that the elite dalits use the rural ones for gains.
Except reservation ...there is also EXPLOITATION ....example... In Bank exams fee structure For ST / SC : 00.00 INR For OBC/GENERAL : 750.00 INR ...also in other exams fee structure is like this ... NONSENSE ACT ... Who bstrd made these
newslaundary . team please release your video in hindi and other language too. At least in hindi I want to share it too my circle but most of them are not comfortable with english .
Its just an opinion, but i believe Reservation should be treated only as a counter measure, and not the solution to the problem of psudo-superiority, We have to try and stand above the concept or the need for reservation, should gradually take positive steps to curb cast descrimination...and not only that, we should provide better free, scientific and productive Education without discrimination... So that one day... Hopefully we will be known in our society by things we did, and not by our mere surnames. Untill then Reservation is a necessary evil, and its nothing to be Proud Of, because remember.. Merit to hona hi chahiye...😊😅
Just make an undercover series where you go to a village of Brahmin and upper caste dominance , with Dalit surname... show to the World where we are standing. In next part, go to a residential society ...live for few days with Dalit surname ..
Slightly disappointed as I was expecting some probable solutions to this hotly debated topic. While in theory, it does look good, in practice, the ones who deserve the reservation cannot utilize it because the "privileged" among the reserved are using it repeatedly. As a result only one small section among the weaker section keeps getting stronger, while it's status quo for the remaining lot. This pivotal point was missed. Secondly, only reservation in jobs was focused. Quality of the job opportunity depends on which college you've studied in. Rest is self explanatory.
A. Savarnas should stop boasting their caste status and marry their progeny into bahujan families in their economic (income)group. Such exogamous family can completely give up their caste instead of giving father's caste to the child. B. Or else wait till all Bahujan women end up marrying into Savarna families while Bahujan don't raise male child. But even then Brahmins discriminate among themselves too. So B option is not really an option.
This video series is about constitution, so the people who have reached here watching the entire series are either well educated or atleast well informed. And thus no need for scrolling through comments, I am damn sure that they are gonna be positive about reservation.
No u still haven't explained privilege vs reservation right. Also i think u should try to embrace in this video strongly that reservations is for representation so that my casteist uncle can understand it better. Some examples of how affermative action work should have been better.
@Arindam Das bt brahmins r not poor bcz of their caste. Bt a dalit is poor bcz of their caste, even though they work more. Thats how privilege work i think.
@Arindam Das vivek missed the point in that argument. Caste based violence is completely different. It should not come in accordance with reservations at present.
Why haven't they explained it? It's because there's no valid stand that they can take. Reservation was initially introduced to do away with the separation of people of the basis of economic benefit. It has now become the banner mark for creating the same alienation that it was meant to eradicate. Again i would still adress it as an issue, but those would be on communal grounds. And the people who endorse it for such reasons, let me be clear, i do not defend them. But as in my own case, when the 40 percentiles hold higher positions than the 90 percentiles, that it when you see problems such as inefficiency at typing, not being able to handle numbers, inability to interpret and analyse data. Need i elaborate further?
@Rohan D but one thing if an ST IAS officer has a child will u consider it from backward society. Does he deserve reservation to come forward. Instead he gets both Privelage + Reservation for which the STs who really deserve it suffer..
NEET now has 62.5% Reservations that means only 37.5% seats are based on merit ....The worst Happened to Middle class family From Unreserved category who are indirectly being sidelined from achieving their dreams.
Those who say reservations kill merit, ask them, if that's the case then why the state like TN is ahead on all socioeconomic indicators which has the largest representation and affirmative action (not reservation) compared to states like UP, Bihar, Rajasthan, MP or Uttarakhand.
Back than when I entered in medical college i get discriminated by teacher and students of general category (in a casual manner, indirectly/sometimes directly) that i m only here because of reservations and if reservations was not there I couldn’t be here and always see i am inferior intellectually . Before starting viva they used to ask name when i answer Priya they say tell full name so indirectly know the cast and then they start viva wd all the judgements……these are the professors who are well educated still illiterate.
Yeah I think the same ....so that the people in them only who are really poor can get the benefit... Otherwise it is like the same people are getting benefitted again and again.
No brother its based on DNA we have the best DNA thats why even poor people from our caste are intelligent but dalits even if they are rich have no talent because of DNA thats why SC/ST does not have creamy layer
Corruption is cancer and tolerance level has gone down and iam afraid to criticize current rulling party if i do so what if tomorrow people come lynch me
Meghnad bhai why don't you hire a hindi translator who can translate whatever is there in your pitch and another episode in hindi be shot so that our Hindi listeners could also have this precious knowledge of our Constitution??? Please think about it!!!
"Merit without understanding privilege is a hollow argument."
-this is the crux of the matter 👍
What privilege you are talking about ? You cannot reverse past discrimination by doing more discrimination.
@@SayanMaity-ri2nx no its to undo present discrimination.
@@Thoughtflux Wrong ! Presently "general" people are being discriminated. I know you love being a victim. But still do something rather than asking for extra advantage. Also you cannot reverse present discrimination by doing more discrimination.
@@Thoughtflux Equality of Opportunity is a liberal value. Equality of outcome is not liberal.
@@SayanMaity-ri2nx Go watch this video again. 0.25‰ of jobs is insignificant to justify your claims of discrimination.
The privileged hardly understand that they have privileges.
You need a seperate episode explaining how and what privilege looks like or in what small forms it has been passed on to us!
Because most urban kids have closed their eyes to look beyond what they see around themselves. :(
true
The very reason the so called urban kids know and despise reserved community is only because of reservation. This is only gonna get worse in the coming years. So much so for equality.
I'm just glad about the comments! Never seen so many informed people praising an argument in favour of reservation like this. Cheers to all of you!
U know there is an option to delete comments by creator of video.
@@knight_23 nope.
Thank you newslaundry, I'm so overwhelmed by this, thankyou
Need hindi dubbing/version for a wider audience reach. Must think
No. Need Dubbing in every major languages. Hindi doesn't even reach half of the population. And people who don't understand English, don't have time for these thoughts. They are at the lower portion of Maslow's Hierarchy.
@@rajadhirajmaharaj let provide funds to them to dub the content in every language Indian can understand
This is best video ever on reservation! Tight slap on those who say that it's merit vs reservation but don't acknowledge their privileges...more power to u newslaundry👍
Enlighten me with this 'privilge' which I hold.
yes i am privilege that had 0 ft of land , my grand father has to work in farm for bare minimum wage but had higher privilege than lalu or sarad pawar , f off
Merit is wholly dependent upon opportunity. It might have been a case that if those, who are uneducated, had gotten a chance to study they might have been more successful than today's meritorious people. It's just that some people are at lack of something that could be in the form of money, social privilege or circumstances.
So the solution should be more focussed on providing quality education accessible to such people, right? Reservation is a pretty non-optimal way of solving that problem.
@@SarthakGupta259 These people don't want upliftment of poors otherwise how'll these educated, rich, elitist messiahs of downtrodden fool their own people in name of reservations !!
This anchor also selectively uses Babasaheb's remarks while completely disregarding the temporary nature of the original provision !!
Then why have exams? scrap giving marks altogether naa!
Nerdy...😮
But very informative
Hope the majority gets the point...
You should have talked about representation. How major institutions, corporates, judiciary, entertainment industry don't have dalit representation at all.
Recently, representative Alexandria Ocasio Cortez brought up scarcity mentality. The scarcity mentality that makes us fight amongst overselves for the crumbs instead of fighting upwards. We need to fight upwards, while acknowledging the privilege we carry with us.
I'm under OBC but I haven't applied for any post or seat under OBC category. I think reservation should only be given to SC and ST. Scrap the term OBC.
I happen to NOT use that category even though I was eligible for it too. Though I am not a professional on this subject, I would like to tell you that you might be living in a location where it is completely unnecessary and everyone is treated with dignity and respect, irrespective of their caste or religion. But there are certainly people who are at a disadvantage socially and educationally even today, who definitely need such provisions.
There should be a new Mandal commission report. The previous one is out dated.
Only poor OBC were given reservation. It's shame that everybody takes it.
will u talk this same shit when ur denied opportunity by a brahmin (higher caste than u)???
Much needed episode, finally there!!!!
Padhe likhe anpadh logonko kitana sikhaoge? Ye bhi gyan waste jayega, janata pe.
I will forever share this to every family WhatsApp group that i am added to.
Damn Meghnad.. You make me feel that I am not alone. The unbelievable amount of whatsapp forwards I have received from relatives about merit, has always made me feel so depressed..
Keep it up meghnad..!! खूपच सुंदर विश्लेषण..!!!
Thanks for shedding light on this issue.
Should have talked about the concessions in marks cutoff in examinations, where the real heartburn begins. Clueless and socially illiterate students begin revolting against this disparity first.
there is no concession in marks. Reservation doesn't bring down marks required to pass. ANd talking about heartburn. You should see your privileges and be happy.
@@l4y3zY bruh that's what I am asking him to speak about
Love you Meghnad 😘
Explained very well
Epic research 😊😊😊
Excellent.................It is privilege vs reservation....and both must go....someday!
Pls brother dub it in hindi....this information is a gem...which had never been showed to the society...even to the upper caste society...pls dub it so that it can reach to wider sections of society...That 0.25% was the core point....hats off...
Just for information under the Justice party in Madras Brahmins had 16% reservation.
Opposed to that too.
@kritika singh yup still Justice party is called anti Brahmin.
These guys occupied more than 95% of the government jobs then.
But paarpanar's said that they need more percent instead of what given to them.
That's communal G.O not reservation do some homework
Brilliant presentation .
I rarely leave a comment. For the first time in the past 29 years of my life I feel there is hope for India. If a bunch of people on this youtube channel can understand and articulate one of the most polarized issues in India so well, I believe so can others if they choose to educate themselves. So glad I watched this video 🙂
Too good maaan thanku for providing the facts n not opinions
Very well researched and presented. Good job. Keep it up. Fantastic.
Much needed video! Great work guys!🌼
There is 100% percent reservations for Brahmins in the priest profession, also 100% reservation for Dalits in the manual scavenging profession, even in today’s day & age. Let’s start by ending this reservation first & then focus on other aspects.
Truth about India... Narrated in light humour !! Good one !!
As election is around the corner .....next chapter should be Election and Electoral behaviour and reforms needed in election process ...hope you will read my comment .....
And thanks for this awesome work ,keep doing it ..I love all your content in your channel ... encourage and share with my frnds to watch them....
0:10 pe Gautam Gambhir opportunity maang raha hain :D
Socially and educationally backward classes is an open category and does not directly equate to OBCs. That is the only error I would like to point out. I really liked the video.
I've could recommend this video to uncle but they don't understand english
Can you give the source for the data which you showed in pie charts?I would like to know that.
In Tamil Nadu they will not add cast name to the name. thanks to persist.
Just found this channel n I'm bowled 🙏
I am for reservations because this scheduled castes people still face discrimination & humiliation in today's 21st century.
Don't you think these laws needs timely review, to see how many people equalled and how many left and give benefits to those?? Anyway in my view progressive mind is much required over progressive laws.. In India we give reservations not for equality just to address people differently and do politics over it..
Education
GEN-EWS: 10% OBC-NCL: 27% SC: 15% ST: 7.5% In IIT
GEN-EWS: 10% OBC-NCL: 27% SC: 15% ST: 7.5% in NEETs
Now people talking about privilege i hope you are talking about yourself not because of some news you heard of attrocities against lower caste. Is it all about JOBs?? We even can not reach IIT how can we think of better JOB??
If this is privilege why would someone want it??
i am happy to be discriminated and not allowed entry in temple as long as iam getting reservation where i have to score 32 to clear JEE and not 91. Where i have to get 61 instead of 75 for clearing mains.
Nailed it.
deep thoughts and valid arguments
What an episode i keep coming back to this
This was very informative.
Please keep at it.
Newslaundry plz post this video in multiple languages at least in Hindi it's very hard to understand to everyone
Learn English. Teach who struggle.
Thank you, NL! being a dalit, I want to thank you very much for this episode. I hope people will get why reservation was implemented rather than crying for it!
Very good video, easy to understand, kudos to all team
small query- is informal jobs are 92% or 81%?
Reservation is not only for Job but it impacts the competitive exams as well. If you include that detail - basically all the institute giving 50% seats - those seats do translate to a job - mostly in the private sector.
What is the harm in giving reservation only to economically backward class - even 50% - rather than making it caste based?
The problem is then India will progress and these illiterate people can't divide India based on castes.
Reservation for Economically Weaker Sections will be a feasible option only when our society is not fragmented into several groups.
For that we need complete annihilation of caste. Why were reservations required in the first place? Because backward castes were economically backward. My mother is teacher in a semi-rural high school. The correlation between caste and economic state is painfully obvious there.
@@anweshaguha7366 Not sure I agree with the annihilation of caste concept - that is the idealistic approach. Discrimination finds a way - if not caste then it will be the region or the skin color or the education.
The result of the current caste system is economic backwardness which can be answered using reservation for them which will also help them to grow.
The social deformation hampers the poor most so that should be the priority.
I do understand the rich Dalit also faces discrimination but that should be dealt with laws of the land - not reservation.
@@abhineshbachchan3212 That will be a dream to have an unfragmented society - what we need to strive are less hatred and more bonding. Probably education is the only answer - added with the law to handle discrimination.
Lovely episode !!!
It's not about merit! With the total reserved seats now - 79% in TN, Maharashtra- 78%, MP- 73% and so on and Moreover unreserved seats are also available for reserved groups.
And most SC students in my colleage came in BMWs, Audi etc.
What a social justice!
India will be a superpower with substandard bureaucracy, doctors and engineers.
I'll never treat my children with substandard doctors no matter their caste.
Funny though MH and TN are two of the most developed states in India....
Especially in case of TN...reservations helped lot of people and decreased the socioeconomic disparities.
@@srikk9 is the growth anything compared to South Korea, China etc which were behind India at the time of independence.
Reservation did not cause growth they grew inspite of reservation.
To improve socioeconomic condition focus should be on health and education investment of the needy and not giving benefit of reservation to only a few families generation after generation.
@@cutekitten4351 My friend reservations were best implemented in Tamil Nadu that's why it has best budding middle class...the principal of reservations is to include as many people as possible in higher strata of societies....look at all the politicians and top business personnel in India they are mostly from upper castes...this is because they enjoy the privilege of being part of high class societies for centuries at least.
90 % villages in India still practice cast discrimination....the houses of dalits are on outskirts....manual scavenging of sewage is still done by chamars....(is there any upper caste person who does this...I don't want any person to do this ..but till we get the equipment and resources to do it mechanically is it not good to share the burden)
..this hegemony cannot be corrected in few decades...it will take take a century or two create a level playing field with democracy....
China has an authoritarian government...we can't compare ourselves with China...we didn't give away our freedom of choice for development
Sri K Tamil Nadu is in no way any different than an average Indian state, even states like Himachal outperform it in most indicators.
As far as domination of upper caste is concerned it is not due to privileges but the persuit of excellence that is embedded in their mindset. That is why they are successful all over the world. I got scholarship due to my caste? While my reserved category classmates even from better schools struggled.
Did Ramanujam succeed due to his caste even after being poor?
While there are people like Ambedkar who succeeded even after facing 19th century discrimination.
What reservation has actually done is to make general category students more hard working and unreserved ones less competent thereby increasing inequality, this is also encouraging brain drain from India- from Indira Noyi to Sunder Pichai all are high caste.
Instead of promoting excellence India is becoming a bastion of mediocrity while the world is marching ahead.
Instead of reservation the depressed castes should be exposed to intense competition that is prevalent in the world and make them help themselves.
What they need is support in form of best education and health and not substandard teachers and doctors which are going to service them again creating another generation of mediocres.
@@cutekitten4351 Weak sections of community cannot be thrown in competition without strengthening them first....
The pursuit excellence came in because of lower caste people had been subjugated to worst form of "Manuwadi"...im guessing you don't know how dalits were treated....
Please read Manu Smrithi....
Anyhow I will give personally account of my grandfather......he had to tie a broom to his waist which is used to erase his foot steps....his had carry his own container to spit into...he was not supposed to speak to upper cast people with his head up...mind you this was just 80 years ago...if a group of people were this kind of subjugation for thousands of years.....fear and risk aversion will be instilled in their genes....
Taking about privilege....why is that marwardies control most of the dealerships in consumer goods.....this is because they had social capital for lot of years...they rarely alllow people of other communities to enter the market (again there are exceptions everywhere) they have stronghold on.local markets and goods ...that's why you see big ecommerce entrepreneurs coming from these communities.....
It takes people from subjugated castes lot of years to develop this level of confidence and hold on businesses....
All people did not start at zero from independence but most of dalits stated from negative at the time of independence...
It's very good analysis. Where can I find more on this topic??
you can study 'annihilation of caste' written by B.R.Ambedkar. in it’s penguin edition,you'll find a foreword written by arundhati roy,which will give a vivid picture of atrocities of castism in india. For more,you can read the writings of journalist p.sainath.
Devyani khobergade is case in point.. her father got into bureaucracy due to reservation and even she got into due to that... Result- numerous corruption cases against father and daughter almost broke down India-US relations because of her stupidity and playing dalit card.
They don't need reservation as they can use the numerous constitutional and legal remedies available to them, who actually need are rural dalits who never get chance to break away from the I'll society. Truth remains that the elite dalits use the rural ones for gains.
Nope. Mistakes attract punishment if proved. Not revocation of affirmative actions.
What about reservation in educational institutes?
Please shed some light on that too.
Except reservation ...there is also EXPLOITATION ....example...
In Bank exams fee structure
For ST / SC : 00.00 INR
For OBC/GENERAL : 750.00 INR
...also in other exams fee structure is like this ... NONSENSE ACT ...
Who bstrd made these
Why is there a difference between fees of sc/st and generals. What benefit will sc/st get if generals have more fees
Beautiful...👌
Thank you very much for this very informative video. Greetings from Prague, Czech republic.
Good job NL. Much needed video.
Really great work guys
newslaundary . team please release your video in hindi and other language too. At least in hindi I want to share it too my circle but most of them are not comfortable with english .
Excellent bro. Good work
You Are Great Brother 😯
Aap Hindi mein karo taaki hum unko dikha paaye jinko English samajh nahi aati. Good job guys!
L E A R N
Its just an opinion, but i believe Reservation should be treated only as a counter measure, and not the solution to the problem of psudo-superiority, We have to try and stand above the concept or the need for reservation, should gradually take positive steps to curb cast descrimination...and not only that, we should provide better free, scientific and productive Education without discrimination... So that one day... Hopefully we will be known in our society by things we did, and not by our mere surnames. Untill then Reservation is a necessary evil, and its nothing to be Proud Of, because remember.. Merit to hona hi chahiye...😊😅
Salute to Lord Commander.
kudos to the writer
man!!
true journalism .......
Very important perspective
Just make an undercover series where you go to a village of Brahmin and upper caste dominance , with Dalit surname... show to the World where we are standing.
In next part, go to a residential society ...live for few days with Dalit surname ..
Slightly disappointed as I was expecting some probable solutions to this hotly debated topic. While in theory, it does look good, in practice, the ones who deserve the reservation cannot utilize it because the "privileged" among the reserved are using it repeatedly. As a result only one small section among the weaker section keeps getting stronger, while it's status quo for the remaining lot. This pivotal point was missed. Secondly, only reservation in jobs was focused. Quality of the job opportunity depends on which college you've studied in. Rest is self explanatory.
A. Savarnas should stop boasting their caste status and marry their progeny into bahujan families in their economic (income)group. Such exogamous family can completely give up their caste instead of giving father's caste to the child.
B. Or else wait till all Bahujan women end up marrying into Savarna families while Bahujan don't raise male child. But even then Brahmins discriminate among themselves too.
So B option is not really an option.
if that section grows, it will help other same discriminated. so it helps
Then watch video of vikas divyakirti on reservation it's in detail
Superb...no words..👍
This video series is about constitution, so the people who have reached here watching the entire series are either well educated or atleast well informed. And thus no need for scrolling through comments, I am damn sure that they are gonna be positive about reservation.
@Meghnad Subtitle may be added downside throughout.. good job done again
nice explanation ...
No u still haven't explained privilege vs reservation right. Also i think u should try to embrace in this video strongly that reservations is for representation so that my casteist uncle can understand it better. Some examples of how affermative action work should have been better.
@Arindam Das bt brahmins r not poor bcz of their caste. Bt a dalit is poor bcz of their caste, even though they work more. Thats how privilege work i think.
@Arindam Das vivek missed the point in that argument. Caste based violence is completely different. It should not come in accordance with reservations at present.
Why haven't they explained it? It's because there's no valid stand that they can take. Reservation was initially introduced to do away with the separation of people of the basis of economic benefit. It has now become the banner mark for creating the same alienation that it was meant to eradicate.
Again i would still adress it as an issue, but those would be on communal grounds. And the people who endorse it for such reasons, let me be clear, i do not defend them. But as in my own case, when the 40 percentiles hold higher positions than the 90 percentiles, that it when you see problems such as inefficiency at typing, not being able to handle numbers, inability to interpret and analyse data. Need i elaborate further?
@@palashmukherjee9006 ohh i see 👍🏻
@Rohan D but one thing if an ST IAS officer has a child will u consider it from backward society. Does he deserve reservation to come forward. Instead he gets both Privelage + Reservation for which the STs who really deserve it suffer..
I am also backward.
I also need reservation.
Reservation is the better future hope for SC and ST.
The point on marks cut off and college admissions has been ignored. That's the primary pain point. Should shed some light on it.
shhhj dont say facts
I request a part 2 on this please
Nice .
Very Deep Study.
Good Work
Talk about data of reservation in education. All skilled labour jobs are earned by educational degrees where there is reservation
Man, where were you......
NEET now has 62.5% Reservations that means only 37.5% seats are based on merit ....The worst Happened to Middle class family From Unreserved category who are indirectly being sidelined from achieving their dreams.
Still u can't make in that 37.5% .
@@jrtesla6504 That is open for all , not specifically for general people . Write the exam then you'll get the struggle ( Unless you've reservation ) .
Great episode. No homework?
100% Fact
Those who say reservations kill merit, ask them, if that's the case then why the state like TN is ahead on all socioeconomic indicators which has the largest representation and affirmative action (not reservation) compared to states like UP, Bihar, Rajasthan, MP or Uttarakhand.
Very informative , ....good one .
..where you get those data of employment percentage....???
Back than when I entered in medical college i get discriminated by teacher and students of general category (in a casual manner, indirectly/sometimes directly) that i m only here because of reservations and if reservations was not there I couldn’t be here and always see i am inferior intellectually . Before starting viva they used to ask name when i answer Priya they say tell full name so indirectly know the cast and then they start viva wd all the judgements……these are the professors who are well educated still illiterate.
Amazing dude. 💜🤘
बहुत बढ़िया लार्ड कमांडर ☺️☺️☺️
So is it right to say that once a person come out of his/her socially backward class. He/ She should be removed from reservation?
No as it's bad for governing party, so they won't scrap it.
Yes for sake of country
No for sake of politicians
How will you decide that
I think SC/ST should also have creamy layer.
Yeah I think the same ....so that the people in them only who are really poor can get the benefit...
Otherwise it is like the same people are getting benefitted again and again.
@@sssp1998 yes even I'm SC but have given up my reservation for poor people of. my caste.
No brother its based on DNA
we have the best DNA thats why even poor people from our caste are intelligent but dalits even if they are rich have no talent because of DNA
thats why SC/ST does not have creamy layer
Great episode and what is your problem with GD bakshi!!
Very informative. 🙏🌹👍
What about those who possess reservation as well as privileges?🤔
Very nice keeping it on
Will Reservation go away ? Yes, if it is taxed !
Corruption is cancer and tolerance level has gone down and iam afraid to criticize current rulling party if i do so what if tomorrow people come lynch me
Very astutely put! Kudos! But do pls do a Hindi subtitle
Dude, do you really have a very strong accent or just making out of itttttttttt lol
Meghnad bhai why don't you hire a hindi translator who can translate whatever is there in your pitch and another episode in hindi be shot so that our Hindi listeners could also have this precious knowledge of our Constitution??? Please think about it!!!