The lawsuits over this song were interesting. I don't know the details, but Funk, like Folk and some other genres, borrows a LOT from other songs. This was the first funk song to make enough money for anyone to bother suing for copyright violations. But then all the funk artists started competing over who actually originated which aspects, as they were all copying from each other for decades.
@@Snugglypatchvids Zubats in Pokémon (Gen. 1, at least) are far and away the most common Pokémon in the game and you run into them all the time. Any time 12tone mentions "this was everywhere" in relation to a song's/motif's/style's prevalence, he always draws a Zubat :)
When I turned 40, I was like "hey man, all this pop music is just recycled stuff from the past." When I turned 50, I was like "Oh... the music I grew up with was also recycled stuff from the past." This is a great example of taking cool stuff from the past, combining it with some new paint, and making a great new song that's catchy as hell. When the old farts in my life say "They can't make good music these days," I share this song with them. Killer, killer track - thanks for this awesome video, 12tone!
Some additional thoughts/corrections: 1) Another explanation for the G7 (as opposed to Gmi7) is that we're not in minor, we're in Dorian, and that's just the diatonic IV chord in that scale. That's perfectly valid and doesn't really conflict with the blues-based analysis I presented, but the reason I leaned more toward the blues interpretation is that, in my experience, while the IV chord in Dorian is a dominant 7, most songs will sort of shy away from that, using either a major triad or a major 6 instead. The dissonance isn't really the point of a dorian IV chord, whereas it is in the blues. Given that the melody is pretty strictly minor pentatonic, neither tonality is clearly established, so if Dorian makes more sense to you, I think it's a perfectly reasonable answer. It's just not my preferred one. More importantly, though, I just don't think the chords are that big a deal in this song, so I wanted to get through them as quickly as possible and move on. 2) In retrospect I wish I'd spent a bit more time on the different percussion layers for different sections. The claps in the intro, to a full drumbeat as the only support in the verse, to those metronome kicks in the back half of the prechorus, and especially the use of a full groove in the breakdown (and the missing hi-hats for the first part) all tell a great story. Oh well, something for the "What I Got Wrong" video I guess. 3) Another reason the high Fs in the verse feel high is that the melodic structure treats them as if they are: they're positioned on accented notes, and the rest of the time he sits on C and D. that relative restraint makes the moments where he jumps up memorable, even if he's not jumping very high. 4) I'm not confident in my transcription of the breakdown vocals, but hey, it's spoken, the pitches are intentionally imprecise so who cares. But I think it might've been better to put those Fs as Ds. 5) I actually think I screwed up the the transcription on the bass vocal part too. I was hearing that pick-up at the end as a repeated D, but after some prompting from my discord I went back and double-checked and I think it's actually a C#. Doesn't change any of the stuff I said, but it would've been nice to note that half-step resolution. Although apparently most transcriptions out there call it a C, which I'm pretty sure is also wrong, so who knows. 6) Speaking of the bass vocals, someone else in my discord pointed out that it's actually a tresillo as well: It's a bit of a weird one 'cause the staccato on the F makes it feel like the accented note, whereas tresillos usually accent the beat (You can hear that in the verse, where the accents fall on "this", "ice", and so on.) but it's on all the same parts of the beat, which ties it in with the rest of the rhythm in ways I wish I'd noticed in time to include.
I don't know it seems to me like a pretty standard dorian vamp, it's in a whole lot of funk music. I never noticed the "shying away" from the seventh, in what music can I find it ?
I can't not hear the second to last note of the intro as a C. (The "90% of [its] musical identity" line right at the beginning.) Looking at Google Image Search results for sheet music for this, it seems every transcriber out there agrees with me. We hear it go up from C to end on D, and it feels really jarring to have them both transcribed here as Ds. Totally forgivable mistake, but I'd love to have the correction listed here so it can feel less jarring! Thanks!
One of your best videos. Well-paced and clearly explained. I never noticed that the verse's vocal range was so small. Looking forward to hearing your thoughts on the drums. Great job :D
When you mentioned the lyrics dropping out in the chorus because its a dance track and they wanted to focus on the fun feeling of the song, I was reminded of that saying in musical theatre about how when there's too much emotion to speak, you sing, and when there's too much emotion to sing, you dance. It seems like the same thing applies here.
"Like a handoff in a musical relay race" I think is the single most accurate and concise musical metaphor ever, I'm not surprised but this is some damn good scripting
I remember being taught by my music teacher that the human brain loves music because it loves trying to guess what's next. My guess is having the 1/16th and 1/8th off beats helps trick the mind essentially making it more addicted to the song if that makes sense.
The other exciting and interesting part of this song is the outro. The band jams out on the DM7 G and the horn and bass arranging is so tight as they play those different variations and riffs. No matter how bored you get of playing this our band still loves that part.
"Ronson and Mars had discovered a long forgotten gem from an earlier musical era" Yes it was called the Minneapolis sound. Listen to The Time ( Jungle Love etc ) Prince wrote those songs and shaped the sound, so you can say Uptown Funk is a blatant homage to that era. Even the latter part of the video gives a nod to the First Avenue music venue in Purple Rain.
Agreed. The Time and Zapp and Roger were ALL over this song. They basically condensed all the technical features of that time period in funk into a well-written song. That’s quite an accomplishment, but to fully appreciate it, you need to know the history behind it.
@@GDIEternal Agreed William. My comment was a brief generic UA-cam observation befitting for a forum like this. Having studied and played music particularly funk for near 30 years you can rest assured I can appreciate any musical accomplishment and the history behind it.
Glad I'm not the only one who saw it. The lick is so powerful you can hear it by just seeing the notes getting written down. Felt like I was getting visually Lick-Rolled there. (Is that a thing? Lick-Rolling? If not, can we make it a thing pls?)
Toward the end of the video, I realized my foot was tapping along to the song, but there wasn't any song playing, it was all talking by our dear friend 12Tone. Says a lot about the power of this song.
It would really help the video's exposition if you repeated the musical snippets you're discussing and comparing. I find myself constantly jumping back to remind myself of the fragment you're describing. A good example is the snippet from 4:07, which you keep discussing for almost two minutes. At 5:10 you start talking about its apparent range, a full minute after you play the sample. Man, I can't remember subtle illusory effects for more than a minute like that!
I wish you had touched on the awesome bassline at the end of the song (D, d, C, B| A, G, F G, AF). It’s the cherry on top of the funktastic cake, a climax of everything that preceded it.
Cool analysis. Great point about the importance of arrangement. Sometimes the best songs are the simplest songs, or the ones that seem simple but actually have a lot going on that most people don't consciously notice. Thanks!
Having the real stems to illustrate all what all the different parts actually sound like adds SO much to your videos! So glad that's been able to happen recently.
Because I don't have a TV and don't actively seek this stuff out, I can honestly say I have never heard this song. Though now I hear the bits and pieces of it here, I have heard people singing it to themselves.
I remember being in primary school when this came out, everyone was singing it. My parents both loved it despite their usually differing music tastes and its still one of those bangers I always have to turn up
this channel inspires me to learn music because I get a new perspective to see at the same song that I listened to but now they sound much better (does it make any sense?) my mind is blown!
I love your breakdowns, and I especially love your doodles. The memes and the little elephant(?) dudes make your videos fun to watch even when the music theory stuff is flying over my head.
I think the second half of the prechorus is absolutely well interpreted as a Riser-Drop. It sounds to me like a brilliant borrowing of an element of EDM, and like the other elements of the song, doing so with full understanding of the purpose and heart of the technique. Rather than the drop being some dubstep effect or hard hitting dance synth thing, it's funk horn fanfare, fitting the electronic music trope of a drop perfectly into the whole pop-funk vibe of the song.
One of the things that trips me up as a writer is getting an idea and thinking it's "just" something. These analyses remind me that every song breaks down into "just" a few things, put together in clever ways.
There are other videos about this song where they do the archaeology has to wear these particular sounds come from. Mostly 1970s and 1980s African-American Pop music. Well trained black musicians might have had experience in classical or jazz but we’re playing gospel or whatever popular at the time. Soul, funk, disco, R&B and Rap. All of these genres influence and change each other overtime.
I played Mark Ronson on an episode of Sing Your Face Off in Thailand with a star impersonating Bruno Mars and a group of dancers paying his backup. We did this song straight into "That's What I Like". It was a season finale episode and we were on as a guest-star act, not competing. The judges enjoyed it anyway, and the audience was screaming. It was a lot of fun. I actually didn't know anything about Bruno Mars, but it was interesting learning the song. To this day when I hear either song come on I think, "Hey, that's our song." It was interesting hearing you break it down and analyse it.
Ngl, my favorite thing about Bruno Mars is how much he's improved as an artist. This early stuff like Grenade and Lazy Song were garbage, but as time has gone on he's drastically improved. Hats off to him
Liked the song, now I know WHY! :-) You can tell the musicians/writers really have a handle on music theory implemented with the intent of evoking specific emotions and feelings when it is explained this well. I found myself a couple of times saying, yeah that makes sense, or THAT'S why that does that. Nice.
That's why the Gap Band sued and got partial credit. The bridge ("Uptown funk you up") - start saying "oops upside your head, said oops upside your head" there instead.
I also hear the kick drum(?) beats in the verse as having a similar tone to the root notes in the background on the intro (which might be an illusion), and while it’s not in the same rhythm, it meant I assumed the sung “do do do” bit continues through the verses. Despite hearing the song casually a lot, I had never noticed they didn’t until you pointed it out.
many of the things the guitar does (Only 3rd and 7th voicings, c# to d) are very very common things a guitarist plays in funk :D Its something you learn quite early when introduced to the style. Just wanted to share for anyone interested. The song really just takes all the parts a classic funk song has, and puts a more modern twist around it :)
I would like you to explain why Blurred Lines and Got to Give It Up are actually completely different songs and only people who don't understand music would even entertain the idea that there was a copyright violation there.
Could you do something on the concept of call and response? You did a video covering questions and answers (the concept) a few years ago, but this concept seems subtly different? is it rhythmic rather than based on resolutions?
This is a really weird request, but I think you could do a great video about the Futurama birthday song, it's so fascinating how they balance being close to and not quite on Happy Birthday to You, and it feels like it has a really clever combo of lyrics and melody going on.
You'd think F's would be easy, especially for tenors, but I know a lot of them who can't brighten their tone enough to make them sound good and anything north of F-sharp just sounds more and more strained. Bruno definitely has a great instrument.
Yes, the human voice can fuck with the octaves. I play with that sometimes and the highest note I ever made a software think I am singing in a C#7 and the lowest a G0. Really weird and fun.
Great video, but I've got a minor issue with the transcription of the bass line (same with the intro vocal part). The second to last note should be a minor seventh, it's not repeating the root, i.e, C D not D D.
“If you think of one thing when you think of Uptown Funk, you think of the vocal bassline.” That’s not my experience at all. I’ve never noticed that the bassline is vocal; for me the most salient part of the song is the upper vocals, and the first thing I think of is the buildup in the prechorus. I’d like to know more about the tricks composers and performers in [insert genre here] use to call attention to specific voices or moments-what they are, how they work, and what happens when they don’t work.
It never occurred to me that someone wouldn't recognize that bass line as vocal, but then, I sing bass so I am trained to pay attention to the bass parts and I definitely recognize voices in that range. Anyway, I also don't think I could honestly say that I ever think of just one thing when I think of Uptown Funk. As noted, there's a lot of great technique going on here.
I also noticed that in the bass part from the beginning there is also a kind of tresillo in the syncopated g-f-d. Also, why is the VI dominant while the I is minor? Is that also standard is Blues?
It's the linear reusing of ideas that makes this feel like a funky pop song instead of a funk song. Not saying it's bad, cuz it's not, it's awesome, but I always felt like it was set apart from the funk of the past with how pattern based it is.
The general musical idea behind this song (and why it became so popular) IMHO is that it combines a modern, up-to-date EDM pattern (beat, rise, drop) with the sound, groove and arrangement style of the 70s funk tunes. It works as an EDM song, as it has all stuff a modern dance tune needs, but sounds like a classic funk song, which everyone knows and everyone likes (even people who hate EDM).
Great walkthrough of the song! So surprised that it is just the same idea in all these parts! However, I don't get the "stop time" part fully 9:58 "starting 8th note before the beat and ending on the.... " part, how does it fit perfectly?
The keyboard line the horns play over in the chorus is very Minneapolis Sound, which this video briefly mentions early on: ua-cam.com/video/TBr6H75DBsU/v-deo.html
The lawsuits over this song were interesting. I don't know the details, but Funk, like Folk and some other genres, borrows a LOT from other songs. This was the first funk song to make enough money for anyone to bother suing for copyright violations. But then all the funk artists started competing over who actually originated which aspects, as they were all copying from each other for decades.
Wow lmao
345 likes now even tho I had liked it before and idk when since the comment is 2y old
This video is entirely about arrangement technique and I love it.
Arranging/production. Yes indeed :)
Welcome to 12 tone
First time? *james Franco meme*
"The song was everywhere" with a zubat actually killed me
His inside jokes kill me every time.
Explain?
@@Snugglypatchvids Zubats in Pokémon (Gen. 1, at least) are far and away the most common Pokémon in the game and you run into them all the time. Any time 12tone mentions "this was everywhere" in relation to a song's/motif's/style's prevalence, he always draws a Zubat :)
“I won’t get too far into vocal technique, because we’d be here forever”
Hey can you like do that?
I second that
@@malcolmrose-zadow5517 I third that
@@mihailmilev9909 I fourth that 👍
@@malcolmrose-zadow5517 I secon't that.
jk
I've got a lifetime to waste and spare, go off bruh
When I turned 40, I was like "hey man, all this pop music is just recycled stuff from the past." When I turned 50, I was like "Oh... the music I grew up with was also recycled stuff from the past." This is a great example of taking cool stuff from the past, combining it with some new paint, and making a great new song that's catchy as hell. When the old farts in my life say "They can't make good music these days," I share this song with them. Killer, killer track - thanks for this awesome video, 12tone!
But can they make good music that isn’t retro?
@@matiaspereyra9375 Yes.
126th like
Couldn't agree more. Then you find out that Mozart and Bach were all "drawing inspiration" too....... And we all know the story about jazz right......
Some additional thoughts/corrections:
1) Another explanation for the G7 (as opposed to Gmi7) is that we're not in minor, we're in Dorian, and that's just the diatonic IV chord in that scale. That's perfectly valid and doesn't really conflict with the blues-based analysis I presented, but the reason I leaned more toward the blues interpretation is that, in my experience, while the IV chord in Dorian is a dominant 7, most songs will sort of shy away from that, using either a major triad or a major 6 instead. The dissonance isn't really the point of a dorian IV chord, whereas it is in the blues. Given that the melody is pretty strictly minor pentatonic, neither tonality is clearly established, so if Dorian makes more sense to you, I think it's a perfectly reasonable answer. It's just not my preferred one. More importantly, though, I just don't think the chords are that big a deal in this song, so I wanted to get through them as quickly as possible and move on.
2) In retrospect I wish I'd spent a bit more time on the different percussion layers for different sections. The claps in the intro, to a full drumbeat as the only support in the verse, to those metronome kicks in the back half of the prechorus, and especially the use of a full groove in the breakdown (and the missing hi-hats for the first part) all tell a great story. Oh well, something for the "What I Got Wrong" video I guess.
3) Another reason the high Fs in the verse feel high is that the melodic structure treats them as if they are: they're positioned on accented notes, and the rest of the time he sits on C and D. that relative restraint makes the moments where he jumps up memorable, even if he's not jumping very high.
4) I'm not confident in my transcription of the breakdown vocals, but hey, it's spoken, the pitches are intentionally imprecise so who cares. But I think it might've been better to put those Fs as Ds.
5) I actually think I screwed up the the transcription on the bass vocal part too. I was hearing that pick-up at the end as a repeated D, but after some prompting from my discord I went back and double-checked and I think it's actually a C#. Doesn't change any of the stuff I said, but it would've been nice to note that half-step resolution. Although apparently most transcriptions out there call it a C, which I'm pretty sure is also wrong, so who knows.
6) Speaking of the bass vocals, someone else in my discord pointed out that it's actually a tresillo as well: It's a bit of a weird one 'cause the staccato on the F makes it feel like the accented note, whereas tresillos usually accent the beat (You can hear that in the verse, where the accents fall on "this", "ice", and so on.) but it's on all the same parts of the beat, which ties it in with the rest of the rhythm in ways I wish I'd noticed in time to include.
I don't know it seems to me like a pretty standard dorian vamp, it's in a whole lot of funk music. I never noticed the "shying away" from the seventh, in what music can I find it ?
I can't not hear the second to last note of the intro as a C. (The "90% of [its] musical identity" line right at the beginning.) Looking at Google Image Search results for sheet music for this, it seems every transcriber out there agrees with me. We hear it go up from C to end on D, and it feels really jarring to have them both transcribed here as Ds. Totally forgivable mistake, but I'd love to have the correction listed here so it can feel less jarring! Thanks!
10:32 😍😍
I was here to say the same as Darshan, so yeah
One of your best videos. Well-paced and clearly explained. I never noticed that the verse's vocal range was so small. Looking forward to hearing your thoughts on the drums. Great job :D
I just finally gotten that song out of my head after six years, and now you brought it back. Damn you Ronson and your infernally catchy grooves!
We all know Uptown Funk, but when will there be Downtown Funk?
Pretty sure Midtown funk comes first 🤣
When Billy Joel gets around to it 😂
the holy trinity:
Uptown Funk, Midtown Punk, Downtown Crunk
"Everybody's goin' uptown..."
I'm still here waiting
When you mentioned the lyrics dropping out in the chorus because its a dance track and they wanted to focus on the fun feeling of the song, I was reminded of that saying in musical theatre about how when there's too much emotion to speak, you sing, and when there's too much emotion to sing, you dance. It seems like the same thing applies here.
"until everything changes" - Fire Nation emblem. Haha love your visual jokes every time
Best part of his videos. XD
"Like a handoff in a musical relay race" I think is the single most accurate and concise musical metaphor ever, I'm not surprised but this is some damn good scripting
You say, “but I’m old school” so mournfully
I remember being taught by my music teacher that the human brain loves music because it loves trying to guess what's next. My guess is having the 1/16th and 1/8th off beats helps trick the mind essentially making it more addicted to the song if that makes sense.
The other exciting and interesting part of this song is the outro. The band jams out on the DM7 G and the horn and bass arranging is so tight as they play those different variations and riffs. No matter how bored you get of playing this our band still loves that part.
"Ronson and Mars had discovered a long forgotten gem from an earlier musical era" Yes it was called the Minneapolis sound. Listen to The Time ( Jungle Love etc ) Prince wrote those songs and shaped the sound, so you can say Uptown Funk is a blatant homage to that era. Even the latter part of the video gives a nod to the First Avenue music venue in Purple Rain.
Yeah, I mean it’s so blatantly The Time, it’s blindingly obvious
Not to mention that they add "Funk You Up" by The Sequence (1979)
Agreed. The Time and Zapp and Roger were ALL over this song. They basically condensed all the technical features of that time period in funk into a well-written song. That’s quite an accomplishment, but to fully appreciate it, you need to know the history behind it.
@@GDIEternal Agreed William. My comment was a brief generic UA-cam observation befitting for a forum like this. Having studied and played music particularly funk for near 30 years you can rest assured I can appreciate any musical accomplishment and the history behind it.
They got those horns from a 1983 Tim maia track
“Homage.” I see what you did there. #thelick
Glad I'm not the only one who saw it. The lick is so powerful you can hear it by just seeing the notes getting written down. Felt like I was getting visually Lick-Rolled there. (Is that a thing? Lick-Rolling? If not, can we make it a thing pls?)
I missed that apparently
@@ashtarbalynestjar8000 Thanks, I needed that!
Is it just me or does anyone else hear the second to last note of the bass line as a C and not a D?
Its not just you
Same
Yeah it's definitely C
Pretty sure that's a typo
maybe a c# but definately lower than a d
Toward the end of the video, I realized my foot was tapping along to the song, but there wasn't any song playing, it was all talking by our dear friend 12Tone. Says a lot about the power of this song.
Nile Rodgers usually plays guitar like this, not really hitting the root note, listen to any of his productions. He is a fucking legend.
9:07 Nice homage… Your move, Adam Neely
The day will come when this guy will analyze Bohemian Rhapsody and our heads will explode.
ua-cam.com/video/Ez8Ljhv9dyw/v-deo.html
Told ya
he has!
It would really help the video's exposition if you repeated the musical snippets you're discussing and comparing. I find myself constantly jumping back to remind myself of the fragment you're describing.
A good example is the snippet from 4:07, which you keep discussing for almost two minutes. At 5:10 you start talking about its apparent range, a full minute after you play the sample. Man, I can't remember subtle illusory effects for more than a minute like that!
Yeah, I think it’s a copy-strike thing.
Smoother than a fresh jar of skippy.
I wish you had touched on the awesome bassline at the end of the song (D, d, C, B| A, G, F G, AF). It’s the cherry on top of the funktastic cake, a climax of everything that preceded it.
Cool analysis. Great point about the importance of arrangement. Sometimes the best songs are the simplest songs, or the ones that seem simple but actually have a lot going on that most people don't consciously notice. Thanks!
I seriously love the style of these videos. One of the most unique and effective UA-camrs.
3:58 did he really just draw the fire nation insignia when he said everything changes??
Having the real stems to illustrate all what all the different parts actually sound like adds SO much to your videos! So glad that's been able to happen recently.
What sells the song for me is the sawtooth synth during the chorus.
Because I don't have a TV and don't actively seek this stuff out, I can honestly say I have never heard this song. Though now I hear the bits and pieces of it here, I have heard people singing it to themselves.
3:59 I know he has done this before but it still gets me every time.
I didn't think it would be possible for me to like this song any more than I already did
“Blues history” - draws a crossroads...
He went down to the crossroads, trying to catch a ride.
"I'd call it a chorus cuz i'm old school" hit me right in the feels, man. Bring back choruses! Choruses still matter!!!
Everything changes
* Draws fire nation symbol *
I remember being in primary school when this came out, everyone was singing it. My parents both loved it despite their usually differing music tastes and its still one of those bangers I always have to turn up
this channel inspires me to learn music because I get a new perspective to see at the same song that I listened to but now they sound much better (does it make any sense?) my mind is blown!
I love your breakdowns, and I especially love your doodles. The memes and the little elephant(?) dudes make your videos fun to watch even when the music theory stuff is flying over my head.
I think the second half of the prechorus is absolutely well interpreted as a Riser-Drop. It sounds to me like a brilliant borrowing of an element of EDM, and like the other elements of the song, doing so with full understanding of the purpose and heart of the technique. Rather than the drop being some dubstep effect or hard hitting dance synth thing, it's funk horn fanfare, fitting the electronic music trope of a drop perfectly into the whole pop-funk vibe of the song.
12:01 - In the tradition of 18th century Europe. Your turn, Adam Neely.
I love 12tone - and I love this song. Thanks for explaining why I love both!
The last note in the riff is C. If you listened to it so much, how did you miss that?
Anyone else notice when he says “jolt of energy” he draws a fork and a power outlet?
One of the things that trips me up as a writer is getting an idea and thinking it's "just" something. These analyses remind me that every song breaks down into "just" a few things, put together in clever ways.
There are other videos about this song where they do the archaeology has to wear these particular sounds come from. Mostly 1970s and 1980s African-American Pop music. Well trained black musicians might have had experience in classical or jazz but we’re playing gospel or whatever popular at the time. Soul, funk, disco, R&B and Rap. All of these genres influence and change each other overtime.
THIS SONG ALWAYS MAKES ME WANNA GET UP, AND DANCE WHEN ITS WAYYYYY TOO LATE
7 words - *Oops Upside Your Head - The Gap Band*
Wow ua-cam.com/video/yVjFwcdQlN0/v-deo.html
It's actually called "I Don't Believe You Want to Get Up and Dance (Oops!)"
Pay attention, sucker.
HOLY CRAP! This took forever! We’ll done 👏
I played Mark Ronson on an episode of Sing Your Face Off in Thailand with a star impersonating Bruno Mars and a group of dancers paying his backup. We did this song straight into "That's What I Like". It was a season finale episode and we were on as a guest-star act, not competing. The judges enjoyed it anyway, and the audience was screaming. It was a lot of fun. I actually didn't know anything about Bruno Mars, but it was interesting learning the song. To this day when I hear either song come on I think, "Hey, that's our song." It was interesting hearing you break it down and analyse it.
Ngl, my favorite thing about Bruno Mars is how much he's improved as an artist. This early stuff like Grenade and Lazy Song were garbage, but as time has gone on he's drastically improved. Hats off to him
I watched this video to get a bit of insight into the song, but when you wrote your 'homage' I found myself going for the subscribe button!
Are you sure that the intro vocal riff doesn’t end with a C then a D, instead of a D then D?
The lyrics of the chorus are actually "open the door, get on the floor, everybody walk the dinosaur"
I wish I understood this, but the degree of analysis is amazing.
I liked the little comparison of European to blues harmony ala 3:25 area. Very good implementation of Neely Theory
Liked the song, now I know WHY! :-) You can tell the musicians/writers really have a handle on music theory implemented with the intent of evoking specific emotions and feelings when it is explained this well. I found myself a couple of times saying, yeah that makes sense, or THAT'S why that does that. Nice.
hey, loved the analysis. wish you had spent some time on what the bass is doing at the last section of the song (is it an outro?). keep it up, man!
The beat is from All Gold Errything by Trinidad James. He's credited.
That low note on 4+ is certainly C. It's idiomatic, it sounds like it, and there's no reason it would be anything else.
This video gave me ptsd of the radio stations playing it non-stop
Eh, there were infinitely worse songs that year we had to deal with, so it wasn't that bad.
Don't forget to listen to what 12tone analyses before hearing his brilliant analysis, helps it sink in!
Sounds so like Oops Upside Your Head at points.
That's why the Gap Band sued and got partial credit.
The bridge ("Uptown funk you up") - start saying "oops upside your head, said oops upside your head" there instead.
I also hear the kick drum(?) beats in the verse as having a similar tone to the root notes in the background on the intro (which might be an illusion), and while it’s not in the same rhythm, it meant I assumed the sung “do do do” bit continues through the verses. Despite hearing the song casually a lot, I had never noticed they didn’t until you pointed it out.
I thought from the title that it was a genre.
many of the things the guitar does (Only 3rd and 7th voicings, c# to d) are very very common things a guitarist plays in funk :D
Its something you learn quite early when introduced to the style. Just wanted to share for anyone interested. The song really just takes all the parts a classic funk song has, and puts a more modern twist around it :)
not to mention the excellent bass work giving the song much of its life, in comparison to a programmed bass
"Doesn't really come across in words"
*draws a rose*
You! I see what you did there! Best not say it out lout and enjoy the silence.
I would like you to explain why Blurred Lines and Got to Give It Up are actually completely different songs and only people who don't understand music would even entertain the idea that there was a copyright violation there.
Up town funk you up, uptown funk you up,SAY!
My brother made this song his alarm, which utterly ruined it for me.
he understands what the sound if for.
that 1 sentence encapsulates what it means to be a good cover.
Could you do something on the concept of call and response? You did a video covering questions and answers (the concept) a few years ago, but this concept seems subtly different? is it rhythmic rather than based on resolutions?
this was amazing!
This is a really weird request, but I think you could do a great video about the Futurama birthday song, it's so fascinating how they balance being close to and not quite on Happy Birthday to You, and it feels like it has a really clever combo of lyrics and melody going on.
Very cool. Thanks! I learn so much from you.
9:20 the message is "Yeah, Uptown Funk.".
You'd think F's would be easy, especially for tenors, but I know a lot of them who can't brighten their tone enough to make them sound good and anything north of F-sharp just sounds more and more strained. Bruno definitely has a great instrument.
The first thing I think of when someone mentions Uptown Funk is the brass. The intro is a close second, though.
It's hard to believe that future generations will not remember how this song was fucking everywhere in 2014.
I dont care if you like pop music or nah, this song is objectively one of the best of the decade
You notate the penultimate note of the bass riff as a D but I always hear it as a C
*I usually speedup videoes to 1.25x but here i always slow down videos to .75x.*
I barely know any of these chords and other stuff because I’ve only played piano for a year but this is still interesting.
Yes, the human voice can fuck with the octaves. I play with that sometimes and the highest note I ever made a software think I am singing in a C#7 and the lowest a G0. Really weird and fun.
Me not knowing any music theory..
*Yes i agree.*
Funky Fresh! No matter your age!
The bassline ends with C moving to D, not D twice.
You even do an "understanding Kokomo?" It's considered one of the WORST summer songs of all time which blows my mind because i personally love it lmao
I never took music theory, so hearing what I've always called a "drag triplet" being called a "tresillo" was pretty funny
Great video, but I've got a minor issue with the transcription of the bass line (same with the intro vocal part). The second to last note should be a minor seventh, it's not repeating the root, i.e, C D not D D.
“If you think of one thing when you think of Uptown Funk, you think of the vocal bassline.”
That’s not my experience at all. I’ve never noticed that the bassline is vocal; for me the most salient part of the song is the upper vocals, and the first thing I think of is the buildup in the prechorus.
I’d like to know more about the tricks composers and performers in [insert genre here] use to call attention to specific voices or moments-what they are, how they work, and what happens when they don’t work.
It never occurred to me that someone wouldn't recognize that bass line as vocal, but then, I sing bass so I am trained to pay attention to the bass parts and I definitely recognize voices in that range. Anyway, I also don't think I could honestly say that I ever think of just one thing when I think of Uptown Funk. As noted, there's a lot of great technique going on here.
Bout damn time!
I also noticed that in the bass part from the beginning there is also a kind of tresillo in the syncopated g-f-d.
Also, why is the VI dominant while the I is minor? Is that also standard is Blues?
Do you sell your sheets when you are done writing on them?
Great! What is a musical relay race?
It's the linear reusing of ideas that makes this feel like a funky pop song instead of a funk song. Not saying it's bad, cuz it's not, it's awesome, but I always felt like it was set apart from the funk of the past with how pattern based it is.
The general musical idea behind this song (and why it became so popular) IMHO is that it combines a modern, up-to-date EDM pattern (beat, rise, drop) with the sound, groove and arrangement style of the 70s funk tunes. It works as an EDM song, as it has all stuff a modern dance tune needs, but sounds like a classic funk song, which everyone knows and everyone likes (even people who hate EDM).
Great walkthrough of the song! So surprised that it is just the same idea in all these parts!
However, I don't get the "stop time" part fully 9:58 "starting 8th note before the beat and ending on the.... " part, how does it fit perfectly?
I'm curious: do you extract the note patterns from the track, or are you working from sheet music, generally?
The keyboard line the horns play over in the chorus is very Minneapolis Sound, which this video briefly mentions early on: ua-cam.com/video/TBr6H75DBsU/v-deo.html
This song may be the single catchiest thing I've ever run across. Yorktown from Hamilton rivals it, but damn this song is great.