And another clue I found was when they were in the dollhouse, and A (Charlotte) locked them outside. Spencer said to the rest of the liars that when she was face to face with Charles she felt as though she met him when she was really little...
Random Person another big clue in my opinion was when spencer offered Mary herbal tea etc and Mary said she was never one to turn down caffeine... caffeine is literally Spencer's everything
Lili Flora some people think cece paralysed her and some other stuff but I don't think it really explains what happened in the show or mona just played along
Note in the scene that is the "two twins horror story", they are playing with two brunette dolls and one blonde - this could represent Spencer and her twin (brunettes) and CeCe (blonde)
its not about who the doll represented at that time i think she means its more like foreshadowing. A took the baby from mary and gave her another 'child' (the mona doll) like a cuckoos egg. You know what i mean? And since she and Jessica are twins you could see (its so twisted) the holy mary (or however you call her idk) as jessica getting a child which is not hers. I knoooow its complicated and i probably explained it badly, but maybe you get what i mean.
I think it Spencer also changed because of Mona screwed up her life so bad‼‼‼‼ Mona has a personality disorder😈😈Like Spencer said to Aria BITCH CRAZY‼‼‼‼‼‼‼‼‼‼
actually we do know who the dad is. Peter was tricked by Mary that he was hooking up with Jessica, which got her pregnant, and peter said to veronica he wanted another child. because veronica couldn't get pregnant, he adopted his own child, spencer, which, even veronica, doesn't know about the mary and peter affair :)
Sorry but this barely showed any clues. How about the fact that Jessica HATED Spencer... always blaming Spencer because she knew she was Mary's daughter... explains why she was creeping up on her in the middle of the night, maybe to get rid of her?
That makes no sense because if she hated spencer why would she not hate cece to bc their both mary drakes daughter yet she was pointing the finger at spencer but cece is marys daughter too?
Hiedi Martinez jessica never considered cece as mary’s daughter, as you would see when she was talking to jason and ali and aria about the flashback at aunt carols house, jessica said “you may have given birth, but he was my son.” she may have not felt that same way for spencer.
Wouldn't it be crazy if Mons was the twin? The two are always trying to out do the other. They both are super intelligent. I wouldn't be surprised if it happened thus way. They could be fraternal twins. 😮😒🤔
The point where I had a really strong feeling that Mary was her mother was towards the end of one episode where each girl has a moment in camera time and spencer was looking in her family album
You should have mentioned in the doll house, when spencer said being next to 'Charles' made her feel like being around a cousin or someone you knew when you were little, an example of this would be a sister/brother you had never met.
Maybe Aria and Spencer are the twins. Mary and Aria's uncle may really be Aria's father. They both are mentally unstable and they may have met in Radley. Didn't the drunk guy say that he delivered 2 of her babies?
did you notice that the dolls the twins were playing with were one blond and two brunettes? maybe cece, spencer and her twin? and the other one was only holding a blond one, maybe alison?
I believe that the twins resemble Jessica and Mary. Now Spoiler Alert:!! Mary had Alex and Spencer, the two brunette dolls and Jessica had alison. The blonde one. The doll they are fighting over is CeCe. CeCe is Mary’s daughter but Jessica gets her in the end. You then see the other twin, Mary, stab her sister. That was foreshadowing that Mary is Jessica’s killer.
I knew that Spencer was Mary's daughter when she looked in her family's photo album at the end of an épisode. At this point I was 100% sure that she was her daughter
potato_master ಠ_ಠ yeah that's crazy how many ppl are adopted ! Don't get me wrong, I love PLL, but I feel like it's getting a little bit repetitive 😩 And when season 7B is gonna air, I won't remember anything from the last episodes because the break is soooo long ! ⏰ Sorry if I made mistakes, I don't speak English very well cuz I'm French 😇
I thought it was weird that Spencer was looking at the photo album in s7 but then rewatching i realised that it was Alex (spencers twin) looking through the album - trying to figure out the life she didnt get.
So the rest of the three girls(Aria, Hanna and Emily) had nothing to do with the A and AD drama. They all had to suffer only because they were friends with the Hastings/DiLaurentis kids. Thats sad!!
Cierra Nisbet I think that girl with Ashely was the girl from Allison's story because she said my sister are always fighting and the girl was cold so I think she was the twin that was killed by the other one and when she called her mum themum dried because she was dead.
there’s also a scene where spencer offers mary coffee, and she’s something along the lines of “i can never deny caffeine” or “i can’t live without it” or something that implies that she, like spencer, is a coffee addict, because if you think about it her parents never seemed to like it as much as spencer, so she got that from mary
Kayla Lacaille the Halloween twin scene was a memory of Charlotte? Or are you talking about a different scene? Because the Halloween one wouldn't make sense I don't think, since she was in radley at the time, and still being called Charles, and dressing as a boy. (Going by the age of the twins)
I think it was Mary and Jessica and the dolls represent their children. There's Alex and Spencer, the brunettes, with Mary, and then there's Alison, the blonde, with Jessica. They then fight over Charlotte, but Jessica wins and Mary stabs Jessica.
The biggest and only clue imo that Spencer was Mary's daughter was this throwaway line Mary said about "never turning down caffiene/coffee" and Spencer is always on about her coffee like every other episode. I knew as soon as she said, besides the fact their hair/clothing style are similar, that Mary would be Spencer's biological mother.
If Spencer does indeed have a twin, I would love for it to be Sydney. Simply for the fact that Charlie Chaplin's birth name was Charles Spencer Chaplin and he had a brother named Sydney. Maybe Mary has an obsession with Chaplin and named all her kids after him ^^ Still, I can't shake the feeling that Lucas is A.D. I quickly guessed that Mona was the original A, simply because she was the only character that didn't actually contribute to the story's development. The writers had no reason to create her in the first place, other than her being the secret villain. It's the same with Lucas in season 7 now. He has no business being in the story. Hannah clearly doesn't need another love interest and he's never really been good for anything else (storywise).
I think given the series finale, it is obvious that Jessica was the evil/crazy one. I mean she lied about Mary killing a child, sent her to a mental facility, then authorized horrible practices to be done to her while she was there. On top of all of this, she tried to team up with Peter to murder her in cold blood. Mary has obviously been through some really terrible things. All of her children were taken away from her, then her twin sister treated her like an animal. Although Mary has done some questionable things in the past, I don't think she's a danger to anyone. When she murdered Jessica, I really think she thought of it as self defense. She's just so misunderstood. The way she was willing to go to jail for Spencer proves that she has a big heart and soul for those she cares about.
Vincent Van No I don't think it did but didn't Caleb have a spin off show in Ravenswood?They hinted that in pll universe spirits and the supernatural existed after all they included ms grundelwald and her bs
I think it was just meant to be a little callback to the horror story Ali told to Hanna while she was babysitting, so just some urban legend that ties into the story in some way.
i had the feeling that mary was spencer’s mom since episode one of season 7 when she went to her house, she was talking about spencer and melissas picture when they were younger also when she said “i know enough about your family that they are great secret keepers” as in Mary was Spencer’s bio mom. and she just gave a vibe like she wanted to see Spencer and like she wanted to talk to Spencer. and then they found out Mary had a second child i knew for sure it was Spencer.
"She tried to poison them against me" Sounds like we heard something like this before? Thats because in the Ghost Train episode the twin girl-from the story Ali told the boy when Han was babysitting- told Ashley Marin that her sister likes to tell lies about her. And if you have heard rumors about Courtney DiLaurentis or have read Ali's Pretty Little Lies that would also sound familiar because Courtney pretended to be Ali and turned everyone against Ali who everyone thought was Courtney
My biggest problem with this theory is the fact that the doctor told them about Mary's second child, he never said anything about a Twin. Why not? Also, what does Ashley talking to that little ghost girl, have to do with Spencer potentially having a twin? Are you saying the Black Hoodie in the Nativity Set scene was leaving that clue or the writers?
Hannah Chambers I think that girl with Ashely was the girl from Allison's story because she said my sister are always fighting and the girl was cold so I think she was the twin that was killed by the other one and when she called her mum themum dried because she was dead.
Now you also have me thinking that those two yellow dresses that were in the Dilaurentis' piano may have been for the twins. Maybe Mary bought those dresses for Jessica to send to the "twins" and Jessica hid them but Ali found them? Is that too much of a stretch?
I don't know if you even payed attention to the season 6 finale because Cece literally explained that the reason jessica bought the two dresses and in general always two sets of girl clothing was because one was for allison and the second for charlotte...
Seriously. If Spencer IS actually Mary Drake's daughter (we don't even know if that is true yet) and Charlotte's sister then it makes no sense for her to have had a twin. Male or Female. Why would the doctor who delivered her, not remember that he also delivered her twin at the same time? If he did remember, why would he lie? If he didn't deliver her twin, who the heck did? Why didn't he? Why wouldn't Jessica have taken in at least one of the twins, she took Charlotte in? If Spencer does have a twin, it seems more likely that they would be biological children of Peter and Veronica but even that seems far fetched because it brings up the question; why wouldn't they keep both twins? It just doesn't make any sense to me. It also doesn't make sense why people seem to be completely overlooking these things. The popular theories for who her twin is, are confusing too; Mona - their father would have to be of asian decent. There are only two people that I can think of that we know, who are of asian decent. Mona's father, who we never see & Emily's. I don't think it makes sense for it to be either. So that would leave an unknown character, that doesn't seem very PLL to me. That leaves two options; they are of the same mother but have different fathers or Mona is not Spencer's twin. Jason - he is older than Spencer and also the son of Peter Hastings and Jessica DiLaurentis. I think it's pretty safe to say he isn't her twin. Wren - again, he is older than Spencer. Also for the people who say her parents were against their thing, the fact that he was engaged to Spencer's older sister at the time, may have had something to do with that. Just saying. Also it seems odd, that had Mary had 3 children and Spencer and Wren were two of them, why Spencer and Charlotte would not only be adopted by couples from the same town that they were born but who also lived next to each other but Wren would seemingly wind up in England. Toby - Firstly, EW. Secondly if Mr & Mrs Hastings were verbal in their dislike of Spencer and Wren, then I'm pretty sure they would have been down right inconsolable and angry about her dating her twin brother. Either way, I stand by my first statement Ew. I don't think PLL would do something that perverted. Also I'm pretty sure he's older than her. Side note ~ I love Keegan Allen. I am on the 'Spencer doesn't have a twin' bandwagon. I am also confused about why people think the big bad is one of the Liars. It would be interesting to see that play out but it doesn't make sense. Each of their families have been targeted and at various times each of the girls have been targeted and each have said they should go to the police but also back tracked on that on other occasions and encouraged the others not to go for fear of retribution to themselves or the people they care about. Who would have motives? What would the motives be? who has access to apparently unlimited funds and information? Anyway that's my 2c :)
Hannah Chambers I agree that it would be gross if Spencer and Toby were twins, and would hope PLL writers wouldn't write that, but didn't Charlotte hook up with Jason? Are they not cousins?
Yes thank you for pointing out the obvious Tara. I still see plot holes and feel it was a bad and somewhat rushed storyline that made the finale one of the worst I've ever seen. Other factors were involved too.
The baby part of the scenery I fell like it’s for moana and spencer because Spencer’s mother is Mary and Mona is not really dead and the way A is holding the baby and Big A is CeCe Drake her half sister
These are amazing, but please in the future try to have the video on the text a bit longer. I'm not native english speaker and therefore I can't read it that fast :3
Was I the only one who didn't miss the biggest clue: that scene in season 2 when Spencer and Veronica talked about Jason at school and Veronica more or less TOLD Spencer that she isn't her biological daughter?!
Also, the two twins were playing with 3 dolls, 2 with black\brown hair (Spencer and her twin Alex) and 1 with blonde hair (Charlotte, their older sister).
when the episode aired with the twins was Ali's mom already dead? She said me and my sister fight over everthing even our dolls. Hasn't the girls been referred to as dolls on more than one occasion? What if Ms. Dilerentes is Uber A?
To answer your question, Jessica (Ali's mom) wasn't killed until the end of season 4 & the Halloween episode with the little girl (This Is A dArk Ride) was the 13th episode of season 3
LaKeah Smith I think that girl with Ashely was the girl from Allison's story because she said my sister are always fighting and the girl was cold so I think she was the twin that was killed by the other one and when she called her mum themum dried because she was dead.
Okay but a lot of these references don't have any justification. Firstly you point out scene from 6x10 and before, in which CECE herself has no knowledge about Alex at all, so using the scenes before that as clues to SPENCER having a twin and the -A scenes of CeCe as she was -A at that time, does not make sense at all as again, she doesn't know anything about a twin. Secondly, Spencer picking up a rock to throw at Ali on the tv and connecting it to the scene where CeCe accidentally mistaken ali for Bethany, doesn't make sense either. In my opinion, that's not a clue at all more just a coincidence. Thirdly, point out the twins Halloween episode (which was season 2 actually, 2x13) was a theory to bring a twin into the story. Everyone knew eventually a twin in the DiLaurentis family will occur, but in regards to Spencer and Alex, no one knew, not CeCe, not Wren, not Spencer. Lastly, making a reference to all the Mary's was a plot they planned early in the story, some Mary was going to appear but Marlene only thought of bringing Jessica and Mary together as twins came in the later seasons after Jessica's death. The actress even revealed how thrilled she was to come back, and then the story of Mary came into full throttle and Spencer having a twin was decided during season 6 from episode 1 - 10. Therefore, these "clues" are not clues at all.
I do feel like the spencers twin storyline was thought up for the last season, I don't think they actually had it in mind at first I mean Spencer, Melissa and their patents were cast because they all look alike, and Spencer had her mothers traits, I think they always teased a twin theory but didn't specifically reference who the twin was
Okay wait there's a few problems with this (not the theory) if Mary is Spencer's mother what the ***hell*** was the point of telling Spencer that Jason was her brother? Is that still true? Confused.
the part I don't like about this ending is its so clear that they didn't have an ending they just kinda kept writing every season on its own trying to tie it back to the pervious seasons it's stupid now to keep going back and searching for clues we missed cause in reality there is nothing we missed that was on purpose for us it's wasn't well planned in the first place
Remember the scene where Spencer tells her mother that she has two daughters but is only protecting one, it is in season 2 I think. After that I went like: 'Ok, spencer is adopted'. And now that is actually true :p
ok 2 things: The doll that replaces the jesus is supposed to be mona, that's mona in the car boot. when you're led to believe Alison killed her but its charlotte before the dollhouse. The written parts disappears too quickly. Im a fast reader and i can't get to the end before it disappears.
When Spencer was in the same room with Charles (Charlotte), she said it felt like it was someone she knew when she was little and of course Charlotte is her sister.
I remember when Mona "disappeared"/"died", Ali had "nightmares" with Mona in them, dressed wierdly and all.. And one of the nightmares showed Ali (supposedly) when she was little, seeing 2 yellow dresses as gifts. Jessica told her not to tell her dad about it and even made her rehearse "I saw ONE dress"... What about this now??
The sisters of the story are playing, one of them with two brunette dolls and the other with a blonde doll. Could that be a hint that Mary has the 3 daughters? Brunette twins (Spencer and AD) and Charlotte?
Dr. Cochran said that the baby was put for adoption , and Spencer was taken away by the Hastings since she's Peter's daughter and Veronica is her step mom.
I Marlene King has stated the show was supposed to end with the revelation of Cece as A. Therefore everything after that (seasons 6-7) were set up for A.D. Spencers twin. So any entry trying to draw a line between Mary and Spencer in an early season is far fetched and practically impossible.
back in the season 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 marlene didn't even know that spencer is going to be mary's kid, so u are basically looking for smth that doesn't exist
I think there was another clue, i guess it was in season 7. When Mary arrived in Rosewood and Spencer and one of the other girls or caleb Look thought her bags they find a lot of books to learn languages which Mary has read. Spencer has always been talented when it came to languages and even says that she loves to learn new languages so I think Mary and Spencer share an obsession with languages
Bethany could still be alive and could be Spencer's twin because we know Bethany went to the ranch slot to ride horses. Mrs. D took her there slot and always gave her whatever Alison was wearing. and she often threw fits there to, that's why the women at the ranch remembered her.
I think the dolls the twins were playing with is a clue, one twin is holding two brown haired dolls (Spencer and twin) and the other has a blonde one (CeCe) then they both reach for the fourth one also blonde (Alison)
Look at the little twin sister's scene! I think there's proof that Spencer may have a twin. One of them (Mary) is holding two brunette dolls (Spencer and her twin) and Mrs. D is playing with a blond doll (Alison). Then they start fighting over another doll, which seems like an OLD one (Charles, Charlotte, Cece). That pretty much represents their relationship with their daughters. Then the little ghost girl says that she and her sisters are always fighting over everything, even their dolls, which represents their daughetrs. Mrs. D always wanted Alison to be better than Spencer, furthermore, Mary and Mrs. D fought over Charlotte in one episode, Mrs. D claming that Mary gave birth to him but she -Mrs. D- was her mother. So that may be a clue that Spencer has a twin sister!
Not to mention that if you read the books and actually watched the show you would know that spencer was the product of the Hastings not Mary bc spencer used to think she was adopted and they cleared that up that SHE WASNT
this has nothing to do with the video but you know when jason and aria go looking for answers about marys second baby? all the important details are blacked out. this could have been mary/jessica who broke in and blacked it out because they didnt want the liars finding out that it was spencer. idk just something that came into my mind, thought it was a possible link to spencer/mary.
later on Hanna's dad says that Charlotte was his son so u know how everyone was saying Charlotte is Mary's daughter, since Ted claimed Charlotte maybe the other baby was Spencer's twin since we know Mary had another baby not including spencer
the two blonde little girl twins in season 1 always made me think of Courtney and Alison from the books and how Alison literally lied about Courtney and got her locked up in Radley out of jealousy
but can we also talk about how spencers dad told spencer jason and ali are all cousins so it would only make sense if mary was spencers mom since her and jessica are sisters
about your "twin" theory, there was ONE set of twins mentioned throughout the whole show and that set was Mary and Jessica. that's it. the little girls were Jessica and Mary.
whoa i just had a thought, that the scene that alison was telling about the twins, they are Mary and Jessica, one of them, Mary, has two dolls both with brown hair, Alex & Spencer, the other twin, Jessica, has a doll with blonde hair, Alison. They then put all the dolls down and start fighting over a blonde doll, CeCe and the one with the doll with blonde hair who represents Alison, got it, like she got CeCe. what if that is a clue!!
In the scene where Mary says that spencer and Melissa look like twins did nobody else notice that when spencer sat down she looked A LOT like Mary with all the shadowing?
How does nobody talk about the scene where Spencer was dealing with her addiction and Veronica said to her that the last time you went through this we didn't know who was coming down to breakfast, you or your evil twin. Big clue.
I never understood that little girl (twin) horror story,is she supposed to represent the dead twin (Jessica) ? but Mary said that Jessica was the one getting her in trouble and the little girl was more like Mary.
I'm so confused. I just wanna know who A.D. is and people are saying Aria or Spencer, then Spencer's twin. And If Wren was Spencer's brother that would be gross. And then they're saying Alison or Alison's twin. Or Bethany is Ali's twin or Sara is Hanna's sister and then people are saying Lucas. I just don't know. THIS IS SO CONFUSING!!
And another clue I found was when they were in the dollhouse, and A (Charlotte) locked them outside. Spencer said to the rest of the liars that when she was face to face with Charles she felt as though she met him when she was really little...
Random Person omg good point
Random Person another big clue in my opinion was when spencer offered Mary herbal tea etc and Mary said she was never one to turn down caffeine... caffeine is literally Spencer's everything
Alliyah Khan Omg yeah. i never thought about that
Random Person something else I find strange Is that Mary said that she and Peter had a history
Random Person I REMEMBER THAT I THOUGHT THE SAME THING. it's prob just because charles was cece and cece is her sister
That doll that replaced Jesus was meant to be loser mona wasn't it
Scarlet Dymock yeah it was
Scarlet Dymock yea it wasn't meant for Spencer it was meant for mona
Lili Flora some people think cece paralysed her and some other stuff but I don't think it really explains what happened in the show or mona just played along
It explains it in the season 6b finale - she was paralysedorput under drug inflluence or something
Scarlet Dymock yeah
Note in the scene that is the "two twins horror story", they are playing with two brunette dolls and one blonde - this could represent Spencer and her twin (brunettes) and CeCe (blonde)
And if the twins were Jessica and Mary it could have been that they were fighting over who took care of Cece
OMG thats sounds so true
Eve Casey mindblown 😂😂
lol... I commented the same... I should have read your comment before.
Taryn Booth
That doll was mona not spencer
That's what I thought too. Especially since A/Charlotte had the "body" of Mona in her trunk.
its not about who the doll represented at that time i think she means its more like foreshadowing. A took the baby from mary and gave her another 'child' (the mona doll) like a cuckoos egg. You know what i mean? And since she and Jessica are twins you could see (its so twisted) the holy mary (or however you call her idk) as jessica getting a child which is not hers. I knoooow its complicated and i probably explained it badly, but maybe you get what i mean.
I understand thankyou
Peri Postaci now i understand thank you
Peri Postaci lightbulb
Spencer changed because she thought she saw toby dead it had nothing to do with the fact that mona asked her to join the A team
nour al-muswie gggggggggsghwn
I think it Spencer also changed because of Mona screwed up her life so bad‼‼‼‼ Mona has a personality disorder😈😈Like Spencer said to Aria BITCH CRAZY‼‼‼‼‼‼‼‼‼‼
When Mary said "i was born first she was born jealous" that's exactly what happened with Spencer and her twin
except alex didn’t know she had a twin and neither did spencer lol
Also, when Mary Drake went to visit spencer she said "I've never been one to turn down caffeine". Remind you of anyone?
Yeah it was too obvious for me when Mary Drake was introduced
Just watched the finale and I'm here looking at past theories 😂
For reaaaal 😂
May I just say she's still a Hastings lmao. Her dad is a Hastings so she is still one to
BasicallyLes well we're not actually sure who the dad is. and yeah she is a Hastings, you're right. but it's because she was adopted
actually we do know who the dad is. Peter was tricked by Mary that he was hooking up with Jessica, which got her pregnant, and peter said to veronica he wanted another child. because veronica couldn't get pregnant, he adopted his own child, spencer, which, even veronica, doesn't know about the mary and peter affair :)
Maryam Rauf That's not confirmed. That's a theory.
Legally, she's a Hastings. Biologically, that's up in the air.
Maryam Rauf if veronica couldn't get pregnant then how did she have Melissa?
Sorry but this barely showed any clues. How about the fact that Jessica HATED Spencer... always blaming Spencer because she knew she was Mary's daughter... explains why she was creeping up on her in the middle of the night, maybe to get rid of her?
That was Mary in Spencer's room when she was facing the window, not Jessica
DegrassiTV Official that was mary creeping to see her daughter (spencer)
Mary hated spencer because she was the family's secret
That makes no sense because if she hated spencer why would she not hate cece to bc their both mary drakes daughter yet she was pointing the finger at spencer but cece is marys daughter too?
Hiedi Martinez jessica never considered cece as mary’s daughter, as you would see when she was talking to jason and ali and aria about the flashback at aunt carols house, jessica said “you may have given birth, but he was my son.” she may have not felt that same way for spencer.
Wouldn't it be crazy if Mons was the twin? The two are always trying to out do the other. They both are super intelligent. I wouldn't be surprised if it happened thus way. They could be fraternal twins. 😮😒🤔
Garrett Reset remember when Mona said she was half Filipino
I don't remember that. I think irl she is half Japanese, which is very different from half Filipino.
Cry Baby it was shay who was half filopino
Cry Baby oh okay. I didn't recall that one. 😟 I hope we get some more backstory to their deep rivalry.
Carmen Cabello I love Mona's character also.
The point where I had a really strong feeling that Mary was her mother was towards the end of one episode where each girl has a moment in camera time and spencer was looking in her family album
Im not sure which episode but it was right at the end of an episode for a very short moment, a sort of recent one, If i remember ill let you know
drcool2 well that was Alex
You should have mentioned in the doll house, when spencer said being next to 'Charles' made her feel like being around a cousin or someone you knew when you were little, an example of this would be a sister/brother you had never met.
Saffron Peacock OH YOU'RE RIGHT
But i'm still confused about the Aria's file being taken in A's lair
I guess we have to wait until the final season to find out.
Maybe Aria and Spencer are the twins. Mary and Aria's uncle may really be Aria's father. They both are mentally unstable and they may have met in Radley. Didn't the drunk guy say that he delivered 2 of her babies?
charles/charlotte/cece and spencer x
maybe the file has information about who the dad is in it.
Yeah! And didn't a worker from Radley went up to Aria and Spencer separately and he recognises them and asked if they've been there before???
did you notice that the dolls the twins were playing with were one blond and two brunettes? maybe cece, spencer and her twin? and the other one was only holding a blond one, maybe alison?
Evelyn Ruiz omg wow
I believe that the twins resemble Jessica and Mary. Now Spoiler Alert:!!
Mary had Alex and Spencer, the two brunette dolls and Jessica had alison. The blonde one. The doll they are fighting over is CeCe. CeCe is Mary’s daughter but Jessica gets her in the end. You then see the other twin, Mary, stab her sister. That was foreshadowing that Mary is Jessica’s killer.
I knew that Spencer was Mary's daughter when she looked in her family's photo album at the end of an épisode. At this point I was 100% sure that she was her daughter
Tara Hassler I wasn't sure about Mary and Spencer, but was 100% sure about Spencer being adopted, like damn is everyone in rose wood adopted
potato_master ಠ_ಠ yeah that's crazy how many ppl are adopted ! Don't get me wrong, I love PLL, but I feel like it's getting a little bit repetitive 😩
And when season 7B is gonna air, I won't remember anything from the last episodes because the break is soooo long ! ⏰
Sorry if I made mistakes, I don't speak English very well cuz I'm French 😇
Tara Hassler totally agree with you and you're English was perfect 💕
Tara Hassler It was Alex Drake in that episode
I thought it was weird that Spencer was looking at the photo album in s7 but then rewatching i realised that it was Alex (spencers twin) looking through the album - trying to figure out the life she didnt get.
So the rest of the three girls(Aria, Hanna and Emily) had nothing to do with the A and AD drama. They all had to suffer only because they were friends with the Hastings/DiLaurentis kids. Thats sad!!
"What Child is this, who, laid to rest On Mary's lap is sleeping?" and then there is Spencer laying in Mary's lap when she was shot
Pretty Little Liars wrapped last night.
Annelise Fritchie I saw the snaps too! It made me tear up 😭
+Cristina Leon I know I was just like OMG no! And the one where Keegan was holding Troian and crying 😭
No it didn't the shows still playing now
Ed And lana the filming ended
Annelise Fritchie Pretty Little Liars wrapped last night. Forever.
This video makes A LOT of sense. this is AWESOME. That little girl with Ashley seems to be like Sarah Harvey.
Cierra Nisbet I think that girl with Ashely was the girl from Allison's story because she said my sister are always fighting and the girl was cold so I think she was the twin that was killed by the other one and when she called her mum themum dried because she was dead.
there’s also a scene where spencer offers mary coffee, and she’s something along the lines of “i can never deny caffeine” or “i can’t live without it” or something that implies that she, like spencer, is a coffee addict, because if you think about it her parents never seemed to like it as much as spencer, so she got that from mary
Anyone notice the dolls in the twin story look exactly like the liars and the doll the twins were fighting over looks like Alison👯
the two girls fighting are images of charlotte when she was younger lol thats why they look like her alot not alison!
Kayla Lacaille the Halloween twin scene was a memory of Charlotte? Or are you talking about a different scene? Because the Halloween one wouldn't make sense I don't think, since she was in radley at the time, and still being called Charles, and dressing as a boy. (Going by the age of the twins)
I think it was Mary and Jessica and the dolls represent their children. There's Alex and Spencer, the brunettes, with Mary, and then there's Alison, the blonde, with Jessica. They then fight over Charlotte, but Jessica wins and Mary stabs Jessica.
Exactly i thought that
The biggest and only clue imo that Spencer was Mary's daughter was this throwaway line Mary said about "never turning down caffiene/coffee" and Spencer is always on about her coffee like every other episode. I knew as soon as she said, besides the fact their hair/clothing style are similar, that Mary would be Spencer's biological mother.
If Spencer does indeed have a twin, I would love for it to be Sydney. Simply for the fact that Charlie Chaplin's birth name was Charles Spencer Chaplin and he had a brother named Sydney. Maybe Mary has an obsession with Chaplin and named all her kids after him ^^
Still, I can't shake the feeling that Lucas is A.D.
I quickly guessed that Mona was the original A, simply because she was the only character that didn't actually contribute to the story's development. The writers had no reason to create her in the first place, other than her being the secret villain. It's the same with Lucas in season 7 now. He has no business being in the story. Hannah clearly doesn't need another love interest and he's never really been good for anything else (storywise).
Chaplin's mother's name was Hannah btw. Which makes no sense. Just wanted to add that.
i don’t think mary was the one who named Spencer
omg this is soo good..IF SINCE SEASON 2 THAT WASN'T SPENCER BUT HER TWIN OR SOMETHING LIKE THAT
The person in their intro looks like spencer but with blonde hair... That would make sense for it to be spencers twin.
I know all along that Spencer was Mary's daughter though !
KaringtonDancer Um Wren didn't come back for 3 seasons because the actor was busy and also he's older than Spencer. He has Melissa's age
Love2 oh right nvm, I wasn't thinking straight :)
KaringtonDancer Spencer is Mary's daughter.
Jzabehl89 ik Spencer is Mary's daughter, I said it in my comment
KaringtonDancer "I know all along Spencer was Jessica's daughter though !" That's what your last sentence says.
I think given the series finale, it is obvious that Jessica was the evil/crazy one. I mean she lied about Mary killing a child, sent her to a mental facility, then authorized horrible practices to be done to her while she was there. On top of all of this, she tried to team up with Peter to murder her in cold blood. Mary has obviously been through some really terrible things. All of her children were taken away from her, then her twin sister treated her like an animal. Although Mary has done some questionable things in the past, I don't think she's a danger to anyone. When she murdered Jessica, I really think she thought of it as self defense. She's just so misunderstood. The way she was willing to go to jail for Spencer proves that she has a big heart and soul for those she cares about.
for your first clue that doll was mona not spencer because everyone thought that mona was dead
Why didn't Ashley ask for the little girls name??
RhondaKelly her name probably would of been mary
whatever happened to that little ghost in Hannah's house? did that storyline ever go anywhere?
ikr
Vincent Van No I don't think it did but didn't Caleb have a spin off show in Ravenswood?They hinted that in pll universe spirits and the supernatural existed after all they included ms grundelwald and her bs
I think it was just meant to be a little callback to the horror story Ali told to Hanna while she was babysitting, so just some urban legend that ties into the story in some way.
this is a great video. really makes me give props to the writers of the show its so clever it's crazy, never would have realized all of this stuff.
I agree with you when you said, spencer changed after the season 2 finale. She used to be my favourite character till this episode
i had the feeling that mary was spencer’s mom since episode one of season 7 when she went to her house, she was talking about spencer and melissas picture when they were younger also when she said “i know enough about your family that they are great secret keepers” as in Mary was Spencer’s bio mom. and she just gave a vibe like she wanted to see Spencer and like she wanted to talk to Spencer. and then they found out Mary had a second child i knew for sure it was Spencer.
THIS THEORY WAS ACTUALLY TRUE OMG
"She tried to poison them against me" Sounds like we heard something like this before? Thats because in the Ghost Train episode the twin girl-from the story Ali told the boy when Han was babysitting- told Ashley Marin that her sister likes to tell lies about her. And if you have heard rumors about Courtney DiLaurentis or have read Ali's Pretty Little Lies that would also sound familiar because Courtney pretended to be Ali and turned everyone against Ali who everyone thought was Courtney
what episode is 1:27 from wtf i don't remember that??
My biggest problem with this theory is the fact that the doctor told them about Mary's second child, he never said anything about a Twin. Why not?
Also, what does Ashley talking to that little ghost girl, have to do with Spencer potentially having a twin?
Are you saying the Black Hoodie in the Nativity Set scene was leaving that clue or the writers?
Hannah Chambers I think that girl with Ashely was the girl from Allison's story because she said my sister are always fighting and the girl was cold so I think she was the twin that was killed by the other one and when she called her mum themum dried because she was dead.
What's the song in the episode at the beginning. not the INTRO. But the one where A took Jesus doll.
we gotta get out of this place by the animals
THANK YOU. :):):):):)
its actually by denmark + winter
Now you also have me thinking that those two yellow dresses that were in the Dilaurentis' piano may have been for the twins. Maybe Mary bought those dresses for Jessica to send to the "twins" and Jessica hid them but Ali found them? Is that too much of a stretch?
I don't know if you even payed attention to the season 6 finale because Cece literally explained that the reason jessica bought the two dresses and in general always two sets of girl clothing was because one was for allison and the second for charlotte...
Omg you were right all along yesterday was the finale and A.D is Spencer twin sister.
You are a genius
Wtf why am I just realizing that Spencer and Alison were cousins, and didn't know the whole time!
Seriously. If Spencer IS actually Mary Drake's daughter (we don't even know if that is true yet) and Charlotte's sister then it makes no sense for her to have had a twin. Male or Female.
Why would the doctor who delivered her, not remember that he also delivered her twin at the same time?
If he did remember, why would he lie?
If he didn't deliver her twin, who the heck did?
Why didn't he?
Why wouldn't Jessica have taken in at least one of the twins, she took Charlotte in?
If Spencer does have a twin, it seems more likely that they would be biological children of Peter and Veronica but even that seems far fetched because it brings up the question; why wouldn't they keep both twins?
It just doesn't make any sense to me. It also doesn't make sense why people seem to be completely overlooking these things.
The popular theories for who her twin is, are confusing too;
Mona - their father would have to be of asian decent. There are only two people that I can think of that we know, who are of asian decent. Mona's father, who we never see & Emily's. I don't think it makes sense for it to be either. So that would leave an unknown character, that doesn't seem very PLL to me. That leaves two options; they are of the same mother but have different fathers or Mona is not Spencer's twin.
Jason - he is older than Spencer and also the son of Peter Hastings and Jessica DiLaurentis. I think it's pretty safe to say he isn't her twin.
Wren - again, he is older than Spencer. Also for the people who say her parents were against their thing, the fact that he was engaged to Spencer's older sister at the time, may have had something to do with that. Just saying. Also it seems odd, that had Mary had 3 children and Spencer and Wren were two of them, why Spencer and Charlotte would not only be adopted by couples from the same town that they were born but who also lived next to each other but Wren would seemingly wind up in England.
Toby - Firstly, EW. Secondly if Mr & Mrs Hastings were verbal in their dislike of Spencer and Wren, then I'm pretty sure they would have been down right inconsolable and angry about her dating her twin brother. Either way, I stand by my first statement Ew. I don't think PLL would do something that perverted. Also I'm pretty sure he's older than her. Side note ~ I love Keegan Allen.
I am on the 'Spencer doesn't have a twin' bandwagon.
I am also confused about why people think the big bad is one of the Liars. It would be interesting to see that play out but it doesn't make sense. Each of their families have been targeted and at various times each of the girls have been targeted and each have said they should go to the police but also back tracked on that on other occasions and encouraged the others not to go for fear of retribution to themselves or the people they care about.
Who would have motives? What would the motives be? who has access to apparently unlimited funds and information?
Anyway that's my 2c :)
Hannah Chambers I agree that it would be gross if Spencer and Toby were twins, and would hope PLL writers wouldn't write that, but didn't Charlotte hook up with Jason? Are they not cousins?
I don't remember that happening. However, yes they are cousins.
Hannah Chambers well you were wrong lol
Yes thank you for pointing out the obvious Tara. I still see plot holes and feel it was a bad and somewhat rushed storyline that made the finale one of the worst I've ever seen. Other factors were involved too.
Hannah Chambers I agree I hated it lol
1:32 song name?
The baby part of the scenery I fell like it’s for moana and spencer because Spencer’s mother is Mary and Mona is not really dead and the way A is holding the baby and Big A is CeCe Drake her half sister
When you're watching this after PLL has ended, and know the answers to all the theories XD
What season/ episode is 2:37???
XCAITLANGAMINGX Season 5 Episode 11
These are amazing, but please in the future try to have the video on the text a bit longer. I'm not native english speaker and therefore I can't read it that fast :3
Was I the only one who didn't miss the biggest clue: that scene in season 2 when Spencer and Veronica talked about Jason at school and Veronica more or less TOLD Spencer that she isn't her biological daughter?!
I've always thought that a has something to do with the Hastings and that it's one of them
Also, the two twins were playing with 3 dolls, 2 with black\brown hair (Spencer and her twin Alex) and 1 with blonde hair (Charlotte, their older sister).
when the episode aired with the twins was Ali's mom already dead? She said me and my sister fight over everthing even our dolls. Hasn't the girls been referred to as dolls on more than one occasion? What if Ms. Dilerentes is Uber A?
To answer your question, Jessica (Ali's mom) wasn't killed until the end of season 4 & the Halloween episode with the little girl (This Is A dArk Ride) was the 13th episode of season 3
LaKeah Smith I think that girl with Ashely was the girl from Allison's story because she said my sister are always fighting and the girl was cold so I think she was the twin that was killed by the other one and when she called her mum themum dried because she was dead.
Thanks for spoiling me in my recommended
Okay but a lot of these references don't have any justification.
Firstly you point out scene from 6x10 and before, in which CECE herself has no knowledge about Alex at all, so using the scenes before that as clues to SPENCER having a twin and the -A scenes of CeCe as she was -A at that time, does not make sense at all as again, she doesn't know anything about a twin.
Secondly, Spencer picking up a rock to throw at Ali on the tv and connecting it to the scene where CeCe accidentally mistaken ali for Bethany, doesn't make sense either. In my opinion, that's not a clue at all more just a coincidence.
Thirdly, point out the twins Halloween episode (which was season 2 actually, 2x13) was a theory to bring a twin into the story. Everyone knew eventually a twin in the DiLaurentis family will occur, but in regards to Spencer and Alex, no one knew, not CeCe, not Wren, not Spencer.
Lastly, making a reference to all the Mary's was a plot they planned early in the story, some Mary was going to appear but Marlene only thought of bringing Jessica and Mary together as twins came in the later seasons after Jessica's death. The actress even revealed how thrilled she was to come back, and then the story of Mary came into full throttle and Spencer having a twin was decided during season 6 from episode 1 - 10.
Therefore, these "clues" are not clues at all.
what song did you use?
2:15
It's Daydream by Ruelle:)
Benzo love x.
Benzo love the first one is a cover of we gotta get outta this place :)
Another thing that hinted at Spencer being Mary's daughter is that she mentioned how much she loved coffee, just like Spencer
I do feel like the spencers twin storyline was thought up for the last season, I don't think they actually had it in mind at first I mean Spencer, Melissa and their patents were cast because they all look alike, and Spencer had her mothers traits, I think they always teased a twin theory but didn't specifically reference who the twin was
2:08 what is the song?
Okay wait there's a few problems with this (not the theory) if Mary is Spencer's mother what the ***hell*** was the point of telling Spencer that Jason was her brother? Is that still true? Confused.
Kaya Sawyer The father it's The same: Peter
Kaya Sawyer because spencers dad didn't want anyone to know spencer was marys daughter.
Kaya Sawyer spencer n jason have the same father.
If I was Spencer I would be mad....Melissa isn't her sister, Mr. Hastings and Mrs. Hastings isn't her parents.
Ruhsaan Jones they still are her parents she was just adopted
Ruhsaan Jones only thing we know for sure is Mrs.hasting isn't her mother
Ruhsaan Jones I would be mad too and it makes a lot of sense as to why Spencer's family shuts her out and doesn't trust her.
Ruhsaan Jones It's called being bad parents
Loraine Lopez so true
the part I don't like about this ending is its so clear that they didn't have an ending they just kinda kept writing every season on its own trying to tie it back to the pervious seasons it's stupid now to keep going back and searching for clues we missed cause in reality there is nothing we missed that was on purpose for us it's wasn't well planned in the first place
That is actually a really good theory! Although it would upset me to think that the friendship between the girls isn't real. Kinda crazy
didnt Jessica take Bethany to the horses and gave her her own horse while she was in Radley??...............
yeah how did everyone know thus. i didnt even expect it
Well she obviously isn’t the daughter of her supposed to be mother but instead her mother is Mary Drake . Her father is still Mr.Hastings guys .
Remember the scene where Spencer tells her mother that she has two daughters but is only protecting one, it is in season 2 I think. After that I went like: 'Ok, spencer is adopted'. And now that is actually true :p
The first one is wrong he replaced baby Jesus with the Mona doll not the spencer doll
ok 2 things:
The doll that replaces the jesus is supposed to be mona, that's mona in the car boot. when you're led to believe Alison killed her but its charlotte before the dollhouse.
The written parts disappears too quickly. Im a fast reader and i can't get to the end before it disappears.
When Spencer was in the same room with Charles (Charlotte), she said it felt like it was someone she knew when she was little and of course Charlotte is her sister.
I remember when Mona "disappeared"/"died", Ali had "nightmares" with Mona in them, dressed wierdly and all.. And one of the nightmares showed Ali (supposedly) when she was little, seeing 2 yellow dresses as gifts. Jessica told her not to tell her dad about it and even made her rehearse "I saw ONE dress"...
What about this now??
One for ali and Charlotte
The sisters of the story are playing, one of them with two brunette dolls and the other with a blonde doll. Could that be a hint that Mary has the 3 daughters? Brunette twins (Spencer and AD) and Charlotte?
what's the song when -A was exchanging Jesus by Mona
Dr. Cochran said that the baby was put for adoption , and Spencer was taken away by the Hastings since she's Peter's daughter and Veronica is her step mom.
I Marlene King has stated the show was supposed to end with the revelation of Cece as A. Therefore everything after that (seasons 6-7) were set up for A.D. Spencers twin. So any entry trying to draw a line between Mary and Spencer in an early season is far fetched and practically impossible.
back in the season 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 marlene didn't even know that spencer is going to be mary's kid, so u are basically looking for smth that doesn't exist
I think there was another clue, i guess it was in season 7. When Mary arrived in Rosewood and Spencer and one of the other girls or caleb Look thought her bags they find a lot of books to learn languages which Mary has read. Spencer has always been talented when it came to languages and even says that she loves to learn new languages so I think Mary and Spencer share an obsession with languages
Bethany could still be alive and could be Spencer's twin because we know Bethany went to the ranch slot to ride horses. Mrs. D took her there slot and always gave her whatever Alison was wearing. and she often threw fits there to, that's why the women at the ranch remembered her.
what is the song in the end?
Well done!👌
What episode was 1:47 from?
I think the dolls the twins were playing with is a clue, one twin is holding two brown haired dolls (Spencer and twin) and the other has a blonde one (CeCe) then they both reach for the fourth one also blonde (Alison)
CrazyGaijin Wouldn't they both be reaching for the Cece doll since they were both her "mother"??
Look at the little twin sister's scene! I think there's proof that Spencer may have a twin. One of them (Mary) is holding two brunette dolls (Spencer and her twin) and Mrs. D is playing with a blond doll (Alison). Then they start fighting over another doll, which seems like an OLD one (Charles, Charlotte, Cece). That pretty much represents their relationship with their daughters. Then the little ghost girl says that she and her sisters are always fighting over everything, even their dolls, which represents their daughetrs. Mrs. D always wanted Alison to be better than Spencer, furthermore, Mary and Mrs. D fought over Charlotte in one episode, Mrs. D claming that Mary gave birth to him but she -Mrs. D- was her mother. So that may be a clue that Spencer has a twin sister!
Not to mention that if you read the books and actually watched the show you would know that spencer was the product of the Hastings not Mary bc spencer used to think she was adopted and they cleared that up that SHE WASNT
remember when there was a theory that Spencer was adopted bc Veronica always praised more Melissa than Spencer
yeah, they were right...
this has nothing to do with the video but you know when jason and aria go looking for answers about marys second baby? all the important details are blacked out. this could have been mary/jessica who broke in and blacked it out because they didnt want the liars finding out that it was spencer. idk just something that came into my mind, thought it was a possible link to spencer/mary.
On the last clue, the person who broke into Spencer's room was Melissa. She admitted it but I forget which episode.
later on Hanna's dad says that Charlotte was his son so u know how everyone was saying Charlotte is Mary's daughter, since Ted claimed Charlotte maybe the other baby was Spencer's twin since we know Mary had another baby not including spencer
the two blonde little girl twins in season 1 always made me think of Courtney and Alison from the books and how Alison literally lied about Courtney and got her locked up in Radley out of jealousy
but can we also talk about how spencers dad told spencer jason and ali are all cousins so it would only make sense if mary was spencers mom since her and jessica are sisters
Song 0:35-1:34
about your "twin" theory, there was ONE set of twins mentioned throughout the whole show and that set was Mary and Jessica. that's it. the little girls were Jessica and Mary.
I clicked on this thinking there were no spoilers....
Seriously ? lol
whoa i just had a thought, that the scene that alison was telling about the twins, they are Mary and Jessica, one of them, Mary, has two dolls both with brown hair, Alex & Spencer, the other twin, Jessica, has a doll with blonde hair, Alison. They then put all the dolls down and start fighting over a blonde doll, CeCe and the one with the doll with blonde hair who represents Alison, got it, like she got CeCe. what if that is a clue!!
what episode is 2:35
I think that Harold Crane is her dad. Look at the way he looks at her. And Mary owns The Lost Woods Resort now.
In the scene where Mary says that spencer and Melissa look like twins did nobody else notice that when spencer sat down she looked A LOT like Mary with all the shadowing?
How does nobody talk about the scene where Spencer was dealing with her addiction and Veronica said to her that the last time you went through this we didn't know who was coming down to breakfast, you or your evil twin. Big clue.
She was referring to her mood, I figured
I never understood that little girl (twin) horror story,is she supposed to represent the dead twin (Jessica) ? but Mary said that Jessica was the one getting her in trouble and the little girl was more like Mary.
I'm so confused. I just wanna know who A.D. is and people are saying Aria or Spencer, then Spencer's twin. And If Wren was Spencer's brother that would be gross. And then they're saying Alison or Alison's twin. Or Bethany is Ali's twin or Sara is Hanna's sister and then people are saying Lucas. I just don't know. THIS IS SO CONFUSING!!
last episode off pll or did miss something . Spencer got shot. did freeform air anymore eps.
LaToya Banks no they start airing in april