Today it's exactly 79 years ago that the Battle of the Bulge began. Please like and share this video in honor of Hugh F. McHugh Join us on Patreon: www.patreon.com/SNAFUDOCS
Did they kinda pick the spot where a sniper would have been ? I know nearly impossible. You have done a great thing to pay respects to his family and our country by your outstanding work. Thank you
My grandpa was an M-18 gunner with the 704th tank destroyer battalion in this battle, those tanks had open tops, he said the only thing that saved his life, was because he took a leather jacket from a German prisoner. In Band of Brothers you see the trees exploding, he was defending a flank at Bastogne, a tree splinter nearly pierced the jacket right at the heart. They didn't have winter clothes though, so that tree splinter would have pierced his body. Either way, this investigative history, I am subbed!
I love that the manwho renovated the castle not only kept the names written on the walls, but researed them and put up a short history and photographs of the men where he could. What a lovely gesture.
Its common in many towns for people STILL to this day, go to tend the cemeteries of American and British soldiers. The Netherlands had this song composed for the 20th anniversary of their liberation. ua-cam.com/video/DRrTujHaHis/v-deo.htmlsi=QL-q1lPfz6bH3ASu
Great video. Taking my Dad back to the exact locations and photographing him where he was in combat during WWII was a 30 year goal for me. Finally in 1994-1998, we made 4 trips to retrace his footsteps from Omaha Beach to SW of Leipzig, Germany. It was incredible, very successful, and one of the greatest times of our lives together.
Thank you. "Convince" is probably the wrong word. It was more like "force". He did not want to go; then only said he would go at the last minute so I wouldn't have to go alone. There were tough times over there, the worst were Omaha Beach and Nordhausen Concentration Camp. But after the first trip, he wanted to go back again. We went every year until the end. @@carlv8168
That sounds amazing. It was hard to get my grandfathers to talk specifics about the war. Very late in his life, my paternal grandfather started to describe what he saw landing on Omaha beach on D-Day. I wish I had recorded it. Unfortunately, my motormouth brother came over and interrupted us, and that was it. I meant to visit him to try to talk about it more, but he suffered a fall, and passed away in the hospital.
Yes, getting those heroes to talk was difficult. Initially, I had minimal success in the 1960s through 1980s, but once I got my Dad back on location, and later reuniting him with many of his combat Battalion, I finally got the details. Once he started talking, I think it helped him accept all that he had seen and been a part of. At that point, he would answer all questions and didn't mind talking about it. Best thing I ever did. @@texaswunderkind
It's one thing to remember our dead, but It's so much more when others do. This brings tears to my eyes, and I'm eternally grateful for you to recognize those boys.
Deeply deeply respectful tribute from a highly talented and humble young man. You are sir a credit to your generation for the way you have honoured a fellow young man who lost his life on foreign shores. Respect to you fully deserved.
My grandfather was in the 7th Armored and was shot during the Bulge. He never talked about it except to say it was “rough.” He visited a French hospital and because of that experience he refused to go out on a stretcher when he was dying. He still had that conviction and trauma nearly 80 years later.
my grandfather was an raf spy pilot. the germans sabotaged his plane and he had to crash near a pyramid,..was found weeks later. he NEVER spoke about the war, my mother was named after his co-pilot
Excellent tribute! I really appreciate your respect for our heroes! While you sit in your peaceful, warm home tonight, think what it must have been like 79 years ago today, for those young American Soldiers out in the freezing cold on the front lines, with no combat experience when all hell broke out? Battle of the Bulge was the largest battle in American history!! Over 16,000 American Soldiers were killed!! We must NEVER forget their sacrifice! These types of tributes will keep their memory alive!!🪖🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
You are a tremendous historian. Many thanks for all your hard work. The end of this video brought tears to my eyes. Mighty emotional. A great memorial tribute to cameraman Hugh F. McHugh.
It is a presentation like this that makes me forever grateful for the many sacrifices given for America by individuals like Hugh Mc Hugh. Rest in peace my friend. You are never forgotten.
It's too bad that most young Americans today in that age group haven't a care in the world and don't have the least amount of interest in those young American soldiers who sacrificed their lives so that today's young people can absorb themselves in their selfish material world and being indoctrinated to hate everything that America stands for.
Interesting to follow in McHugh's footsteps on his last day. Very powerful and beautiful sequence at the end, brought me to tears and it was the first time I've ever heard of the guy. Thinking about what he could have become had he survived the war. Very good job.
I found this to be a wonderful piece. It was a sacred moment seeing where photographer McHugh took his last breath. Thank you so much for sharing this with us. Thank you to all the WWII vets who have given all to keep America free.
The honor, the respect and the passion that your entire crew puts forth in these videos is outstanding. As an American, I can only wish that our younger generations today would learn and appreciate what your group has done to remind us all of what WWII was like and bring us the incredible stories of the individuals that lived and died during that time period. Thank you SO much for what you do.
Photographers do have to stop, frame the shot and snap the picture. He was most likely a preferred target for a sniper. All of his photos were well composed and he had a great eye in a dangerous environment. RIP Hugh. Great work.
@@WarPhotographer1974 I'm curious as to why? I would think you'd be considered more of a non combatant like a medic. When I first started watching this I was wondering why the sniper chose to take out the photographer when there were guys with rifles right next to him.
Joey, that was outstanding! You, Flo, Myra, Bob and the team never cease to amaze me in telling the story of and honoring our soldiers. The story of McHugh will live on thanks to this video! -Bronson
This is an amazing tribute to this man. One of my absolute favorite WWII related activities is seeking out the exact spot where photographs were taken and finding the same scene in the modern world. It’s something I did many times when I was living in and traveling around Europe. Combining that activity with this tribute to his life is such a moving way to honor his service and his bravery and sacrifice. Thank you so much for preserving the memories of these Americans on our behalf. These people, from this part of our history, mean a lot to us, and it means a lot to see that you all treat them with this kind of respect.
My son who is in the United States Navy stationed in Sicily just recently visited bastogne and went to the Easy Company foxholes. He took over a hundred pictures for me. Thank you for these wonderful videos
Thank you. That was extremely moving. “They shall grow not old, as we that are left grow old. Age shall not weary them , nor the years condemn. We will remember them.”
Joey, Florent and Thulai. You guys do some of the best, if not the best videos honoring those who served and made the ultimate sacrifice in the name of freedom. Your work makes me reflect and appreciate all those brave soldiers for what they did. You guys are the best.
I had the honor of knowing a Battle of the Bulge survivor. His name was Gene Renoff (not sure of the spelling). Gene was shot by a German sniper and he laid in the snow for hours. Everyone who saw him fall thought he was dead. He said the snow helped keep him from bleeding to death. The 1970's was the last time I saw Gene. I'm sure he's passed by now. He was one of the kindest and nicest people I ever knew.
I was a British Army photographer and often when you tell people that was your job in the army they always tend to say ‘why does the army need photographers?’… they never seem to realise all these photos that they’ve seen from various wars since WW1, (in fact Rodger Fenton was one of the first war photographers as he photographed the Crimean war, but he was a civilian) were taken by military photographers. It’s obviously vital to keep folks back home, and the world at large, up to date with what is happening on operations. I’ve been lucky enough to get access to parts of the Imperial War Museum others never see due to being a service photographer, getting to see artefacts such as notes made by cameramen and photographers as they jumped into France with airborne forces or land on the beaches in Normandy. A truly vital part of the war effort and such an important historical contribution towards how we see and remember all conflicts. Thanks for highlighting a very under recognise aspect of service life, great watch.
Thank you for this very touching piece. My father was in St.Vith at the time and captured one month later in February and sent to Stalag IX B in Bad Orb. Your dedication and hard work deserves a reward.
Like others have mentioned here about their relatives, my Grandad was in the Battle of the Bulge and never spoke about it, talked about other parts of the war he was involved in, but bot this, my dad said it really changed him for a while.
My uncle fought in the Bulge, 1st Infantry division. My dad was in the pacific at Guam and Okinawa. But my cousin was a Combat Camerman in Vietnam, 221st Signal Company.
My uncle too, was in the Battle of the Bulge and was killed there on Jan. 9, 1945. His brother, my father, was in the 5th Rangers and climbed the cliffs at Point du Hoc during D-Day. He survived and lived until the age 92. Two heroes.
Your Content is excellent. What a honor you do the men who walked these footsteps. As someone who loves history, I find it amazing that we can see the exact spots these photos were taken and can compare how they have changed.,Awesome stuff! 🇺🇸
Thank you for honoring these soldiers. The content is amazing, but these gestures mean so much to me, and I’m guessing I’m not the only person who feels this way. You guys are amazing.
this photographer was so young and what could you do against a sniper! And especially with the 4x5 inch plate camera that required all your attention with taking cassettes in and out and turning them, and cocking the shutter to take 2 photos. Thanks for this impressive video!👌🏻
I think, sometimes we get lost in the casualty numbers of the second word war and forget the person/individual. This is a truly remarkable piece of history and makes it become more human and real. These guys weren’t just a black and white photo. Respect for the work you do.
Full of respect to the owner of the castle who saved a part of history for others to see. Thank you for not destroying a touching memorial to a very young man who only shot his camera. This was a very well presented and informative video, full marks to all concerned. We should never forget what these young men went through! Thank you.
Thank you for sharing. My grandfather fought in the US 3rd Army under Patton during the Battle of the Bulge. I always love learning about these stories and how the memories of the men who fought are still kept alive today. great work.
Wow, this is just incredible work !! The cameraman, Hugh F. McHugh gave his life to capture history and you are bringing us that history, thank you for honoring his work and sacrifice and bringing the horrors of war to light because for some reason we want to ignore it !!! Blessings
Many people of your generation are preoccupied with figuring out which bathroom to use. You are one of a kind. Thank you, sir, for doing this, and thank you for remembering our heroes!
Thank you for bringing our attention to this story, and for telling it so beautifully. I’m proud to say that two of my first cousins (also from New York) served in France, Belgium and Germany under Patton. Both survived the war, but one (a forward artillery observer) was hit and severely wounded by three German machine gun rounds, one of them lodged so close to his spine that the doctors were afraid to remove it. He died two years ago at the age of 97 - with that round still inside him.
Your work got a subscription from me immediately. This is some true dedication and passion to WW2 history, down to the finest details. And to honor Hugh F. McHugh this way, I only wish and hope anyone who knew him got an opportunity to see this video. If not, they surely will know some way, some how that you've done something to honor his life and work. The pictures are wonderful, he surely was a talented photographer. Seeing the modern day locations in their peace and serenity, it's hard to imagine the same places torn apart by bombs and full of smoldering wrecks and dead bodies. Great work, truly a wonderful little video.
This is the best channel on the internet! Thank you for keeping our soldiers memories alive and for caring for them in their final resting places in Europe
What amazing man, if it wasn't for men like this photographer. We would never knew what these men went through. Thank you hugh McHugh for taking these amazing photos. Rest in peace....
Thank you for the flags, the flower, and especially the video. It is gratifying that citizens of other nations make the time and effort to bring these stories to the world. Very much appreciated!!! Thank you so much!
Today is my birthday. Thank you for taking me with you on your journey. Ernest Woodrow Neeld is my grandfather and fought with Patton’s Armored Fist, the Texas Oklahoma regiment. He was born December 5,1916 and died in 1996. He was fluent in German which he learned while serving in the army. Thank you again for bringing us these then and now stories. Greetings from the high plains of Texas.
I am genuinely moved by the respect shown by both you and the gentleman who owns the castle. To have not painted over the names on the wall of troops in your country that were not your own, to track down the ancestor of one, to take such great trouble finding the locations and the reverence with which you treated it all was very touching. So many fine young men wasted on both sides.
Excellent job. I almost cried. Imagine spending weeks and months wearing the same clothes in that freezing cold and wet environment. On top of that, you are constantly on edge, never knowing where the next sniper may be. Again, great work done with great respect. Thank You! 👍👍👍 Many thanks to the owner of the castle and the crew who helped put this video together.
Mate this was chilling and done so respectfully as a veteran and a photographer this really hit home I wish I had my pro camera when I served in Rwanda and the Middle East... Thank you Hugh McHugh you have been remembered... Lest we forget..
Thank you for taking the time and energy to recognize who a TRUE HEROE is. You produced a dignified and honorable tribute for this fine young man and all the other men who gave all. God Bless.
The original photos and the present day photos were great. The ability to pause and really compare the two photos is greatly appreciated. This should be done more often. Excellent tribute, very well done sir.
Hi Joey, the ending brought tears 😢to my eyes the way you showed extreme respect and tenderness to one of the heroes that helped to liberate your country of birth. Thank you❤❤❤ for what you do.
As a boy some six decades ago I came across a book about the battle of St.Vith. it was a first hand account by a soldier, an officer, who fought there. I don't quite remember the title now. When Americans hear about the Battle of the Bulge, it is always about the heroic stand of US troops at Bastogne and somehow St.Vith is overlooked. That is unfortunate because St.Vith was just as bloody, just as heroic and just as desperate as Bastogne. If anything, the units in St.Vith were even more isolated but held up superior numbers of crack German soldiers attacking relentlessly for days. Yet the G.I.'s and St. Vith are rarely mentioned even today. It's as though history of the Bulge reserved the glory for only one location. Thanks for the wonderful video and the outstanding research you made.
You are correct. I have read some after action reports from the 7th armored division, and the fighting there was extreme. The 7th held the town longer than they were asked to. My grandfather was there and would barely talk about it. I can remember when I was a kid and was talking about how cold it was when he and I were deer hunting. He told me that I didn't know what cold was. He said the coldest he had ever been was in the bulge that winter.
I really appreciate all the hard work you put into creating this film and telling an extraordinary story. Thank you for this and other documents. A very good and useful channel for 2WW history enthusiasts. Greetings from Poland
A great video which really touched me, especially as McHugh was a non combatant and carried a camera instead of a rifle, but an enemy sniper still thought it was ok to pick him as a legitimate target. Keep up the great work you are doing. If we speak their names they will not be forgotten. 📷🙏🏻
This is incredible. It’s important to keep their history and stories alive. Amazing video! My neighbor Everett Cummings was Military Police and was stationed in France during WWII and he’s show me pictures and tell me stories of his service and time in Europe. These men were hero’s and a different breed. Before he passed away he gave me some of his medals and ribbons which I still have to this day. It’s incredible these structures are still standing today
Thank you and all those who collaborated in the making of this wonderful film. Your work serves as a reminder of the sacrifice so many young men made in this world conflict. I sincerely know your work will inspire future generations to never forget them.
As an American, who’s great grandfather stormed Omaha Beach with the 29th, thank you for placing our flag next to his grave. You gave him the same respect any proud American as myself would. Thank you. Merry Christmas
Thank you for a great look back to the battle of the bulge and the brave photojournalism work and the sad end of Hugh F. McHugh. This video was well done and very interesting. You've done a great honor to Hugh F. McHugh and his brave work behind the lens.
I went to enlist as a Combat Photographer after being on an AA flight on 9-11. When I got to MEPS it was a year long wait to get into the school. I asked what unit and job would get me on the front lines the quickest. Growing up witnessing Desert Storm I was afraid I would miss my chance to go to war... I became a Combat Engineer in a Sapper Squad as part of TF-1-64 3RD ID. I picked up the best digital camera at the time that would fit in a grenade pouch, the Cannon Digital Elph at a wopping 2MP. It made it through Ah Najaf, Thunder Run 1&2, as well as Fallujah. I'm sure it still takes a good picture. Maybe I'll do something with the few hundred pictures that I took during that deployment. So far they sit in a suitcase in the closet net to my bed. This video kind of hit me. Maybe I'll start taking photos again... Who knows. Keep up the great content. Essayons.
Amazing story and presentation! I family friend was in the Battle of the Bulge, he shared with me his story of how he and his unit were captured as POWs. He passed away about 10 years ago
Amazing Video,,,,Thank you for sharing my Family's History during WW2,,,,,My Name is John Paul Lepley,,,,And I'm Very Proud of My Family's History....Lepley went from France to Southern Germany in Early 1700s.....this Video made me cry upon learning about my Realitive was there, And Showing Proof......Thank You For Adding Another Name To Our Family's Tree.....❤
I was very touched by the respect you have for Hugh. I always love these then and now photo comparisons. Thank you so much for taking us back in time and sharing the work of a brave cameraman!
I stumbled upon your page and I was immediately impressed. My grandfather fought in The Battle of the Bulge and survived but would never talk about it Thank you for your videos
It’s a beautiful thing that you are doing so that these unsung heroes may be remembered. And how sad and disgusting that the sniper targeted non-combatants.
Wonderful video. Thank you so much for honoring this man and what a tribute to go to his grave! We shall not forget the sacrifices of this great generation.
It’s so easy to view our landscape only in a present-day context and not recognise that the same landscape has borne witness to thousands of years of history, significant events and the people involved in them. Photographs can remind us of some of them and this young soldier’s last journey is forever immortalised in the video tribute. His family will have grieved his loss, his final moments so far from home. May he and his fallen comrades rest in peace. Their sacrifice should never be forgotten.
Today it's exactly 79 years ago that the Battle of the Bulge began. Please like and share this video in honor of Hugh F. McHugh
Join us on Patreon: www.patreon.com/SNAFUDOCS
Austrian weatherman needed five days of snow and got three
Did they kinda pick the spot where a sniper would have been ? I know nearly impossible. You have done a great thing to pay respects to his family and our country by your outstanding work. Thank you
Thank you for keeping the memories alive Joey! Peter F.
My grandpa was an M-18 gunner with the 704th tank destroyer battalion in this battle, those tanks had open tops, he said the only thing that saved his life, was because he took a leather jacket from a German prisoner. In Band of Brothers you see the trees exploding, he was defending a flank at Bastogne, a tree splinter nearly pierced the jacket right at the heart. They didn't have winter clothes though, so that tree splinter would have pierced his body. Either way, this investigative history, I am subbed!
Beautiful tribute.
I love that the manwho renovated the castle not only kept the names written on the walls, but researed them and put up a short history and photographs of the men where he could. What a lovely gesture.
the guy is a member of the German minority. Interesting blend of English, Flams and German.😁
Well said mate this video really touched me..
@@floriangeyer3454 Yeah, I was wondering why I suddenly could understand Flemmish. Now I know why! Thanks for that!
Its common in many towns for people STILL to this day, go to tend the cemeteries of American and British soldiers. The Netherlands had this song composed for the 20th anniversary of their liberation. ua-cam.com/video/DRrTujHaHis/v-deo.htmlsi=QL-q1lPfz6bH3ASu
Yes very incredible. Glad that he has interest in history and really preserve it.
Thank you for how you honored that young man that lost his life way to early and so tragically.
It was very emotional to watch. Thank you for your hard work in researching, editing and presenting this outstanding video.
Thank you for your service.
Bless all of those who served.
Great video. Taking my Dad back to the exact locations and photographing him where he was in combat during WWII was a 30 year goal for me. Finally in 1994-1998, we made 4 trips to retrace his footsteps from Omaha Beach to SW of Leipzig, Germany. It was incredible, very successful, and one of the greatest times of our lives together.
My uncle Spencer was in Leipzig at the same time
So glad that you were able to convince your dad to take those trips. You're a good son for doing that.
Thank you. "Convince" is probably the wrong word. It was more like "force". He did not want to go; then only said he would go at the last minute so I wouldn't have to go alone. There were tough times over there, the worst were Omaha Beach and Nordhausen Concentration Camp. But after the first trip, he wanted to go back again. We went every year until the end. @@carlv8168
That sounds amazing. It was hard to get my grandfathers to talk specifics about the war. Very late in his life, my paternal grandfather started to describe what he saw landing on Omaha beach on D-Day. I wish I had recorded it. Unfortunately, my motormouth brother came over and interrupted us, and that was it. I meant to visit him to try to talk about it more, but he suffered a fall, and passed away in the hospital.
Yes, getting those heroes to talk was difficult. Initially, I had minimal success in the 1960s through 1980s, but once I got my Dad back on location, and later reuniting him with many of his combat Battalion, I finally got the details. Once he started talking, I think it helped him accept all that he had seen and been a part of. At that point, he would answer all questions and didn't mind talking about it. Best thing I ever did. @@texaswunderkind
It's one thing to remember our dead, but It's so much more when others do. This brings tears to my eyes, and I'm eternally grateful for you to recognize those boys.
So great to be remembered.
What you do is incredible. You did a great job in honoring him, I think he would be very proud. The end is very emotional, well done.
Thank you so much!
Deeply deeply respectful tribute from a highly talented and humble young man. You are sir a credit to your generation for the way you have honoured a fellow young man who lost his life on foreign shores. Respect to you fully deserved.
My grandfather was in the 7th Armored and was shot during the Bulge. He never talked about it except to say it was “rough.” He visited a French hospital and because of that experience he refused to go out on a stretcher when he was dying. He still had that conviction and trauma nearly 80 years later.
God bless your grandfather and the many courageous young men just like him. So sorry for your loss.
Your Grandfather ✝️ God Bless Him, 🙏🏻Was With Pattons Third Army, The Proudest And Toughest, At The Battle Of The Bulge..🇺🇲
America fought for communism in WW2 through deception look at America and Europe and tell me the "good guys won"
They were incredible men. My grandfather was in Company A 77th medical battalion 7th armored division.
my grandfather was an raf spy pilot. the germans sabotaged his plane and he had to crash near a pyramid,..was found weeks later. he NEVER spoke about the war, my mother was named after his co-pilot
These men deserve so much more credit. They captured and preserved some of the only visual proof and references we have of these events in history.
Brilliant tribute. Hope someone in his family is fortunate enough to see this video. I salute you.
Excellent tribute! I really appreciate your respect for our heroes! While you sit in your peaceful, warm home tonight, think what it must have been like 79 years ago today, for those young American Soldiers out in the freezing cold on the front lines, with no combat experience when all hell broke out? Battle of the Bulge was the largest battle in American history!! Over 16,000 American Soldiers were killed!! We must NEVER forget their sacrifice! These types of tributes will keep their memory alive!!🪖🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
Hey dummy it was all for nothing look at America and Europe the "good guys" didnt win communism won!
👍🇺🇲
I think about them all the time. And every time my heart breaks.
Should have stayed at home
And allowed the Nazis to occupy Western Europe? Surely you jest.
These men deserve to be forever honored for their sacrifices for our country and the world. Thank you for bringing us their stories!
The "good guys" didnt win WW2 look at America and Europe and tell me the good guys won wake up
Lol
We weren’t under threat.
You just come from a government programmed, bootlicking generation.
A very respectful ending. Thank you for honoring these great men.
You are a tremendous historian. Many thanks for all your hard work. The end of this video brought tears to my eyes. Mighty emotional. A great memorial tribute to cameraman Hugh F. McHugh.
It is a presentation like this that makes me forever grateful for the many sacrifices given for America by individuals like Hugh Mc Hugh. Rest in peace my friend. You are never forgotten.
It's too bad that most young Americans today in that age group haven't a care in the world and don't have the least amount of interest in those young American soldiers who sacrificed their lives so that today's young people can absorb themselves in their selfish material world and being indoctrinated to hate everything that America stands for.
Amen.
The world is so much better isn’t it? Europe and America aren’t destroyed by immigrants now are they? We are now Babylon
Interesting to follow in McHugh's footsteps on his last day. Very powerful and beautiful sequence at the end, brought me to tears and it was the first time I've ever heard of the guy. Thinking about what he could have become had he survived the war. Very good job.
The real sad thing is that he almost did survive. Just a few more months
As a retired combat photographer, thanks for this video! It’s amazing to honor the people that came before us.
Thank You!
i agree and thank you also @mattsmith8265
I found this to be a wonderful piece. It was a sacred moment seeing where photographer McHugh took his last breath. Thank you so much for sharing this with us. Thank you to all the WWII vets who have given all to keep America free.
The honor, the respect and the passion that your entire crew puts forth in these videos is outstanding. As an American, I can only wish that our younger generations today would learn and appreciate what your group has done to remind us all of what WWII was like and bring us the incredible stories of the individuals that lived and died during that time period. Thank you SO much for what you do.
Couldn’t agree more. We need to do what we can to keep this history alive for generations to come. We need it for our great nation
What a great tribute and honor you have given to US Army Signal Corps Cameraman, Hugh F. McHugh. Thank you for doing this for him. Salute!
Photographers do have to stop, frame the shot and snap the picture. He was most likely a preferred target for a sniper. All of his photos were well composed and he had a great eye in a dangerous environment. RIP Hugh. Great work.
@@darrel7589actually, yes. We had a price for our heads in Iraq and Afghanistan.
@@darrel7589 it shows what you know
Combat medics and photographers are the ballsiest IMO, one runs to compromised spots, the other stands out to pause and get the best angle.
@@WarPhotographer1974 TY for your service.
@@WarPhotographer1974 I'm curious as to why? I would think you'd be considered more of a non combatant like a medic. When I first started watching this I was wondering why the sniper chose to take out the photographer when there were guys with rifles right next to him.
Joey, that was outstanding! You, Flo, Myra, Bob and the team never cease to amaze me in telling the story of and honoring our soldiers. The story of McHugh will live on thanks to this video! -Bronson
This is an amazing tribute to this man. One of my absolute favorite WWII related activities is seeking out the exact spot where photographs were taken and finding the same scene in the modern world. It’s something I did many times when I was living in and traveling around Europe.
Combining that activity with this tribute to his life is such a moving way to honor his service and his bravery and sacrifice.
Thank you so much for preserving the memories of these Americans on our behalf. These people, from this part of our history, mean a lot to us, and it means a lot to see that you all treat them with this kind of respect.
I hate wars. I think of my own son at age 20. Just kids. Heartbreaking. Thank you for taking the time to honor these men and time. I love history.
My son who is in the United States Navy stationed in Sicily just recently visited bastogne and went to the Easy Company foxholes. He took over a hundred pictures for me. Thank you for these wonderful videos
A lot of those foxholes are still in great shape!
Many re-dug, but still...
Thank you. That was extremely moving. “They shall grow not old, as we that are left grow old. Age shall not weary them , nor the years condemn. We will remember them.”
Wow. I actually wept. So many brave men caught up in world circumstances beyond their control. Thank you for this production.
Thank you for telling us the story of Hugh McHugh. Thank you for taking the time & effort. Thank you.
Joey, Florent and Thulai. You guys do some of the best, if not the best videos honoring those who served and made the ultimate sacrifice in the name of freedom. Your work makes me reflect and appreciate all those brave soldiers for what they did. You guys are the best.
This comment needs more thumbs up!
Outstanding job retracing McHugh's last day through his photography, moving and very touching throughout!
I had the honor of knowing a Battle of the Bulge survivor. His name was Gene Renoff (not sure of the spelling). Gene was shot by a German sniper and he laid in the snow for hours. Everyone who saw him fall thought he was dead. He said the snow helped keep him from bleeding to death. The 1970's was the last time I saw Gene. I'm sure he's passed by now. He was one of the kindest and nicest people I ever knew.
This videos of travelling back in time always give me chills.
Thank you for your work documenting so well the story of one American soldier, who would have otherwise been lost to Time. So many stories...
Wow! Thank you so much ❤
I was a British Army photographer and often when you tell people that was your job in the army they always tend to say ‘why does the army need photographers?’… they never seem to realise all these photos that they’ve seen from various wars since WW1, (in fact Rodger Fenton was one of the first war photographers as he photographed the Crimean war, but he was a civilian) were taken by military photographers. It’s obviously vital to keep folks back home, and the world at large, up to date with what is happening on operations. I’ve been lucky enough to get access to parts of the Imperial War Museum others never see due to being a service photographer, getting to see artefacts such as notes made by cameramen and photographers as they jumped into France with airborne forces or land on the beaches in Normandy. A truly vital part of the war effort and such an important historical contribution towards how we see and remember all conflicts. Thanks for highlighting a very under recognise aspect of service life, great watch.
Thank you for this very touching piece. My father was in St.Vith at the time and captured one month later in February and sent to Stalag IX B in Bad Orb. Your dedication and hard work deserves a reward.
Thank you for putting this togeather, May we never forget.
Like others have mentioned here about their relatives, my Grandad was in the Battle of the Bulge and never spoke about it, talked about other parts of the war he was involved in, but bot this, my dad said it really changed him for a while.
My uncle fought in the Bulge, 1st Infantry division. My dad was in the pacific at Guam and Okinawa. But my cousin was a Combat Camerman in Vietnam, 221st Signal Company.
My uncle too, was in the Battle of the Bulge and was killed there on Jan. 9, 1945. His brother, my father, was in the 5th Rangers and climbed the cliffs at Point du Hoc during D-Day. He survived and lived until the age 92. Two heroes.
@@kevinburke7932 God bless your father and uncle.
God bless your father, uncle and cousin!
Bless all the men who paid the ultimate sacrifice. It’s almost too hard to fathom what they went thru… for is.
So your cousin filmed war crimes with 3 million killed Vietnamese people?
Nice work. I appreciate the respect this video shows for the fallen army photographer. He is not forgotten.
Your Content is excellent. What a honor you do the men who walked these footsteps. As someone who loves history, I find it amazing that we can see the exact spots these photos were taken and can compare how they have changed.,Awesome stuff! 🇺🇸
Another awesome episode; I am humbled by the stories of these men… thank you for bringing them to life…
Thank you for honoring these soldiers. The content is amazing, but these gestures mean so much to me, and I’m guessing I’m not the only person who feels this way. You guys are amazing.
Love how I can sit down and watch a whole documentary in 15 minutes. Your gonna go far man, love the channel.
this photographer was so young and what could you do against a sniper! And especially with the 4x5 inch plate camera that required all your attention with taking cassettes in and out and turning them, and cocking the shutter to take 2 photos.
Thanks for this impressive video!👌🏻
I think, sometimes we get lost in the casualty numbers of the second word war and forget the person/individual. This is a truly remarkable piece of history and makes it become more human and real. These guys weren’t just a black and white photo. Respect for the work you do.
Full of respect to the owner of the castle who saved a part of history for others to see. Thank you for not destroying a touching memorial to a very young man who only shot his camera. This was a very well presented and informative video, full marks to all concerned. We should never forget what these young men went through! Thank you.
A moving tribute. Thank you.
Thank you for sharing. My grandfather fought in the US 3rd Army under Patton during the Battle of the Bulge. I always love learning about these stories and how the memories of the men who fought are still kept alive today. great work.
Bless you for remembering and honoring a tragic loss ...war truly is hell on earth
Wow, this is just incredible work !!
The cameraman, Hugh F. McHugh gave his life to capture history and you are bringing us that history, thank you for honoring his work and sacrifice and bringing the horrors of war to light because for some reason we want to ignore it !!!
Blessings
Many people of your generation are preoccupied with figuring out which bathroom to use. You are one of a kind. Thank you, sir, for doing this, and thank you for remembering our heroes!
Thank you for bringing our attention to this story, and for telling it so beautifully. I’m proud to say that two of my first cousins (also from New York) served in France, Belgium and Germany under Patton. Both survived the war, but one (a forward artillery observer) was hit and severely wounded by three German machine gun rounds, one of them lodged so close to his spine that the doctors were afraid to remove it. He died two years ago at the age of 97 - with that round still inside him.
Your work got a subscription from me immediately. This is some true dedication and passion to WW2 history, down to the finest details. And to honor Hugh F. McHugh this way, I only wish and hope anyone who knew him got an opportunity to see this video. If not, they surely will know some way, some how that you've done something to honor his life and work. The pictures are wonderful, he surely was a talented photographer. Seeing the modern day locations in their peace and serenity, it's hard to imagine the same places torn apart by bombs and full of smoldering wrecks and dead bodies. Great work, truly a wonderful little video.
This is the best channel on the internet! Thank you for keeping our soldiers memories alive and for caring for them in their final resting places in Europe
Thank you for finding his story and telling it. Thank you for honoring him.
Amazing work to preserve this history. To honor those that were there. Thank you.
What amazing man, if it wasn't for men like this photographer. We would never knew what these men went through. Thank you hugh McHugh for taking these amazing photos. Rest in peace....
Thank you for the flags, the flower, and especially the video. It is gratifying that citizens of other nations make the time and effort to bring these stories to the world. Very much appreciated!!! Thank you so much!
Thank you for such an honoring video of all these men that fought and died during WWII. These were of the greatest generation. We salute them.
It truly is an early Christmas present when my favourite WW2 then and now channel posts a video. Thanks guys!
Today is my birthday.
Thank you for taking me with you on your journey.
Ernest Woodrow Neeld is my grandfather and fought with Patton’s Armored Fist, the Texas Oklahoma regiment. He was born December 5,1916 and died in 1996.
He was fluent in German which he learned while serving in the army.
Thank you again for bringing us these then and now stories.
Greetings from the high plains of Texas.
Happy birthday and respect for your grandfather
@@megandarling2215
I miss him terribly.
Thank you.
@@ryandavis7593 your welcome friend he was a brave man
Appreciate so much that you are preserving their memory. Yours is important work.
I am genuinely moved by the respect shown by both you and the gentleman who owns the castle. To have not painted over the names on the wall of troops in your country that were not your own, to track down the ancestor of one, to take such great trouble finding the locations and the reverence with which you treated it all was very touching. So many fine young men wasted on both sides.
Very Fitting Credits to Hugh. A Very Brave Young Man ! Thank You and Your Friends for Your Sacrifice !
Let Us Never Forget their Sacrifice for Freedom !
Also Great Respect to the Owner of the Castle who has Preserved their Names !
Thank You Sir ! You are Very Honourable !
Excellent job. I almost cried.
Imagine spending weeks and months wearing the same clothes in that freezing cold and wet environment. On top of that, you are constantly on edge, never knowing where the next sniper may be.
Again, great work done with great respect. Thank You! 👍👍👍
Many thanks to the owner of the castle and the crew who helped put this video together.
Mate this was chilling and done so respectfully as a veteran and a photographer this really hit home I wish I had my pro camera when I served in Rwanda and the Middle East... Thank you Hugh McHugh you have been remembered...
Lest we forget..
Thank you for taking the time and energy to recognize who a TRUE HEROE is. You produced a dignified and honorable tribute for this fine young man and all the other men who gave all. God Bless.
The original photos and the present day photos were great. The ability to pause and really compare the two photos is greatly appreciated. This should be done more often. Excellent tribute, very well done sir.
Thank you for honoring Hugh F. McHugh by making this video nothing but respect for you and him!
Wonderful content. Yet another sad & heartbreaking story, but you have done well to honour his memory. Thank you. ❤
Respect Joey voor u en uw team, voor deze mooie filmpjes. Knap werk! 👍👌😉
Hi Joey, the ending brought tears 😢to my eyes the way you showed extreme respect and tenderness to one of the heroes that helped to liberate your country of birth. Thank you❤❤❤ for what you do.
This was gripping. Big respect to him for preserving the names/history of the soldiers.
Brought me to tears. Thank you. These guys will never be forgotten.
As a boy some six decades ago I came across a book about the battle of St.Vith. it was a first hand account by a soldier, an officer, who fought there. I don't quite remember the title now.
When Americans hear about the Battle of the Bulge, it is always about the heroic stand of US troops at Bastogne and somehow St.Vith is overlooked. That is unfortunate because St.Vith was just as bloody, just as heroic and just as desperate as Bastogne. If anything, the units in St.Vith were even more isolated but held up superior numbers of crack German soldiers attacking relentlessly for days. Yet the G.I.'s and St. Vith are rarely mentioned even today. It's as though history of the Bulge reserved the glory for only one location.
Thanks for the wonderful video and the outstanding research you made.
You are correct. I have read some after action reports from the 7th armored division, and the fighting there was extreme. The 7th held the town longer than they were asked to. My grandfather was there and would barely talk about it. I can remember when I was a kid and was talking about how cold it was when he and I were deer hunting. He told me that I didn't know what cold was. He said the coldest he had ever been was in the bulge that winter.
I really appreciate all the hard work you put into creating this film and telling an extraordinary story. Thank you for this and other documents. A very good and useful channel for 2WW history enthusiasts. Greetings from Poland
Thank you for doing this. It warms my heart that this young man will not be forgotten
A great video which really touched me, especially as McHugh was a non combatant and carried a camera instead of a rifle, but an enemy sniper still thought it was ok to pick him as a legitimate target.
Keep up the great work you are doing.
If we speak their names they will not be forgotten. 📷🙏🏻
This is incredible. It’s important to keep their history and stories alive. Amazing video! My neighbor Everett Cummings was Military Police and was stationed in France during WWII and he’s show me pictures and tell me stories of his service and time in Europe. These men were hero’s and a different breed. Before he passed away he gave me some of his medals and ribbons which I still have to this day. It’s incredible these structures are still standing today
Thanks! Your work is incredible!
Thank you and all those who collaborated in the making of this wonderful film. Your work serves as a reminder of the sacrifice so many young men made in this world conflict. I sincerely know your work will inspire future generations to never forget them.
Your series takes so much of this region back to horrific times... a beautiful area that at that time was an active and terrible field of conflict.
Thank you so much for the donation!
Great video and thanks for showing us where that brave man died. May he Rest In Peace.
There are no words other than thank you. RIP Hugh.
Amazingly brave to retrieve the camera! What a lovely tribute to the brave that risked everything. RIP Hugh
As an American, who’s great grandfather stormed Omaha Beach with the 29th, thank you for placing our flag next to his grave. You gave him the same respect any proud American as myself would. Thank you. Merry Christmas
Thank you for a great look back to the battle of the bulge and the brave photojournalism work and the sad end of Hugh F. McHugh. This video was well done and very interesting. You've done a great honor to Hugh F. McHugh and his brave work behind the lens.
I went to enlist as a Combat Photographer after being on an AA flight on 9-11. When I got to MEPS it was a year long wait to get into the school. I asked what unit and job would get me on the front lines the quickest. Growing up witnessing Desert Storm I was afraid I would miss my chance to go to war... I became a Combat Engineer in a Sapper Squad as part of TF-1-64 3RD ID. I picked up the best digital camera at the time that would fit in a grenade pouch, the Cannon Digital Elph at a wopping 2MP. It made it through Ah Najaf, Thunder Run 1&2, as well as Fallujah. I'm sure it still takes a good picture. Maybe I'll do something with the few hundred pictures that I took during that deployment. So far they sit in a suitcase in the closet net to my bed. This video kind of hit me. Maybe I'll start taking photos again... Who knows. Keep up the great content. Essayons.
Essayons ? ; p
@@MarcDufresneosorusrex "Let us try"
Amazing story and presentation! I family friend was in the Battle of the Bulge, he shared with me his story of how he and his unit were captured as POWs. He passed away about 10 years ago
Incredible location and looks mostly the same as in 1945, thank you for taking us there.
Amazing Video,,,,Thank you for sharing my Family's History during WW2,,,,,My Name is John Paul Lepley,,,,And I'm Very Proud of My Family's History....Lepley went from France to Southern Germany in Early 1700s.....this Video made me cry upon learning about my Realitive was there, And Showing Proof......Thank You For Adding Another Name To Our Family's Tree.....❤
Wonderful work!! God Bless Hugh's Soul and God Bless his family!
I was very touched by the respect you have for Hugh. I always love these then and now photo comparisons. Thank you so much for taking us back in time and sharing the work of a brave cameraman!
Great video, so respectful, thank you😔
I stumbled upon your page and I was immediately impressed.
My grandfather fought in The Battle of the Bulge and survived but would never talk about it
Thank you for your videos
It’s a beautiful thing that you are doing so that these unsung heroes may be remembered. And how sad and disgusting that the sniper targeted non-combatants.
Wonderful video. Thank you so much for honoring this man and what a tribute to go to his grave! We shall not forget the sacrifices of this great generation.
Thank you guys, I'm really impressed.... and deeply touched....
It’s so easy to view our landscape only in a present-day context and not recognise that the same landscape has borne witness to thousands of years of history, significant events and the people involved in them. Photographs can remind us of some of them and this young soldier’s last journey is forever immortalised in the video tribute. His family will have grieved his loss, his final moments so far from home. May he and his fallen comrades rest in peace. Their sacrifice should never be forgotten.
Well done folks - excellent research and investigation. As a former professional road cyclist , I often trained around these areas and know them well.
This was incredibly well done. Thank you!!!