There are others who have written books on the RSS, like Kingshuk Nag. Why are only Warren Anderson and Nilanjan Mukhopadhyay invited? Because journalists only care about opinions that match their own. Both Mukhopadhyay and Anderson are liberals and critics of the RSS while Nag isn't.
Anderson has internal links. He wrote Saffron Brotherhood way back with Damle. So Anderson is not outsider per say. One more thing, Anderson is a US CIA, State department guy. So contact with him is good for RSS PR in US as HSS also runs in US.
#theprint when was RSS anti minority? Reporter is trying to impose her opinion on others. If she could provide proof and then give that statement would be better...
Madam is a graduate from a ivy league here in usa and have strong feelings of hand in glove with the USA DS keep watching the chronology of videos and also the people of choosing and the narrative being build you will understand what we talking about. D R R
The Print thinks that they are too intelligent to get people who ever they want to give opinion. All these can talk without substance. Who will be next will be decided by BJP. Looks like these people are in a hurry.
This is the type of 'fiasco' that happens when the interviewer is just out and out focussed on grabbing a headline for his / her show, than have a meaningful conversation.. What a waste and what a shame..😢
Yogi has a crazy following in Karnataka and Telugu states. And also note that the route AP is taking a saffron parh these days. Just two days ago VHP launched a massive rally in AP to campaign for freeing of temples.
You are living in fools paradise if you think people consider RSS and it's sarsangchalak as their pope . Without yogi BJP will surely get defeated and India will get coalition govt in long term !!
im interested in hearing why you think fadnavis stands a chance? modi was a very powerful cm so for his track record it was rather easy for him to pull it off, but fadnavis doesn't seem that out there
Well. Systematically doctoring the future of RSS. I am sorry. Certainly you people will get disappointed. RSS is not entire Bharat. It is a part of Bharat. The real intention behind the Dr Mohanji’s statement is to awaken sleeping Hindu forces to fight for their Vedic Civilisation. Always organisation maintains gap between their core swayamsevaks and leadership. It’s a strategy. Initially they opposed Shabarimal issue later they actively jumped into the movement. If you understand Chanakya well you will understand the attitude of RSS. Good luck to you for doctoring . theories😂 Bharatiya Muslim is distinct from external Islamic doctrine. We will Indianise (BHARATIKARAN) the entire Muslim and Christian Indians under the leadership of Yogi Adityanath.
Regarding Muslims, the only thing we need is Uniform Civil Code. That will solve a lot of problems. But honestly, BJP has put that on the backburner, after initially abolishing triple talaq. And I don't think it's a bad idea to give reservations to backward caste Muslims. It will weaken the hegemony of Muslim upper castes.
The comments here seem overly critical. It seems like people want to listen to one view and nothing else. I listened to this hour long interview with interest. The host did a good job of gently bringing the guest back to the topic, as he was sometimes drifting away from the question asked. Overall, I got some good insights into RSS functioning and opinions.
None of de people mentioned is Worthy nor aFit replacement for a PM position 🎉 Let Modi continue till some sound, suitable One is found. Age Experience matters most, & a liberal Patriot, a Visionary, a Selfless person is 2be found ❤ Hemant Sh. is shabbily dressed & clothed, his presentation is a drawback & his accent is poor. Jaishankar cud be given a short term PM . How about .... A new comer Other s need to be dug out😢
I was expecting an intelligent discussion with Walter Anderson on a topic like RSS but this lady is not upto the mark. She is immature and lacks depth.
Interviewing a foreigner about RSS is laughable. They might have insights, no doubt, but this kind of foreign validations for the Indian phenomenon is not warranted.
It is not as strong as it is made out to be..I have attended their shakha..these people keep mocking Gandhi ji and Muslim too...they look important because congress has become weak..once congress put its house in order,it will again be as like any other organisation not very important as it is made out to be..
Congress mentality ruled India in form of Muslim invaders and Christian invaders for 1000 years . The congress mentality has to be destroyed not just weakened
Congress will not become strong untill they smash their upper leadership because Rahul Gandhi seems like he don't give a fuck about politics and doesn't work thet hard . It's been few days when Singh saheb passed but that guy is in Vietnam.. Congress needs a new leadership otherwise the Gandhian ideology will vanish from India .
The Print should tell who the next successor is will be to take over Position of this UA-cam channel, then they can Spreads Narratives as usual against BJP or Modi Ji
Who will be the PM after Modi will be decided by BJP workers and NOT by RSS. Let us be clear that Gadkari stands no chance whatsoever, as he has no following in the BJP. Gadkari is one the best Ministers Modi Govt had but that does not make his automatic choice for the next PM. But who will be the next PM will be decided at the time when Modi decides to retire. As of now, Modi should and must continue till 2034. By the time he retires, we will have Yogi, Himanta and Devendra as strong contenders, apart from Amit Shah and even Jai Shankar. Rajnath and Gadkari would be much older by then. So this issue is NOT due for discussion as of now!!! Period.
Celibacy is not to be equated with bachelorhood. 😅. Prof got very many things wrong. BTW bring the opposite voices too Guptaji. I'm contributing not just for RSS buttering 😂.
Walter Andersen is ultimate authority on Indian politicis.I read his books in early 2000's and he is a giant in political studies field.Great to see him on your channel
if RSS does the poll of their karyakartas, it will definitely come out that they favour digging every mosque and find shivling underneath. Now it seems, Mr. Bhagwat is not just giving in to what masses are saying but leading them to a different direction that in his view better for the country.
In one of the interviews, Gadkari said he got suggestions from the PMO to reduce his visits to Nagpur which is not only his Constituency, but also his birthplace and the HQ of RSS. And he did not care what PMO said. He did what he wanted to. While Rajnath Singh looks to be playing 2nd fiddle for PMO, Gadkari kept building the roads and earned quiet a good name. While Yogi kept proving himself, he still has an image of Dabang CM. Shah doesn't have the saintly image of Gadkari. Himantha, Yogi, Fadnavis are definitely potential PMs. But, not until 2034. Again... this is what I believe. As long as RaGa, Kejri kind of crooks do not sit in the PMO, it doesn't matter which BJP leaders sits there.
I was in RSS in 1979. I say Nitin Gadkari Ji because of his Nagpur, Marathi background does not make sense to be a must to replace MODI Ji, but Gadkari Ji is qualified leader. Idea of RSS indeed formulated by the "Chitpavan Brahmin", where 'Brahmin' itself a formulated one by them for a good SECULAR purpose, after looking the sufferings of JEWS in AD 1800s-1900s. That does not mean Hi(Si)ndus and Jews are same. ARYANS & Jews are SAME. But Hindus made Peace with Aryans through the #Sanskrit. But Jews (Abrahamic) had neither made Peace nor made any conflicts in history with so called Hindus (so do not adopt EUROPEAN responsibilities as Hindu responsibility). But one of the Abrahamic made problems in Gujarat, Saurashtra (Chittorgarh, Jauhar, #Saka), .. So the qualified to replace, atleast to test, Modi Ji is Yogi Adityanath Ji.
If this is your opinion, I sanghi would be very happy. You guys cannot understand why RSS has been successful for 100 years, because you wear ideological lense and not objective. Please continue with your ways, as with this you will never understand RSS and hence can never fight RSS effectively
RSS believes in Muslim - Brahmin unity to perpetuate their rule over Backward, Dalit and Adivasi Hindus. RSS is a B team team of Jawahar Lal Nehru !!!!
There are others who have written books on the RSS, like Kingshuk Nag. Why are only Warren Anderson and Nilanjan Mukhopadhyay invited?
Because journalists only care about opinions that match their own. Both Mukhopadhyay and Anderson are liberals and critics of the RSS while Nag isn't.
I hope you have heard the term "urban naxal".
Urban naxal😂😂😂
It is more important to listen to our critics than to praise
@@elcapitaan1Tell that to liberal journalists. They boycott their critics and only give platform to those who share their views. See here.
Anderson has internal links. He wrote Saffron Brotherhood way back with Damle.
So Anderson is not outsider per say.
One more thing, Anderson is a US CIA, State department guy.
So contact with him is good for RSS PR in US as HSS also runs in US.
The interviewer is prejudiced and full of pre-conceived notions, she doesn't have an open mind. She is putting me off, I am changing channels.
Anytime he says something good about infrastructure etc, the host deviates from the topic and tries to make it about communal disharmony
Exactly. All she wants is to drive the host to criticize RSS/BJP.
#theprint when was RSS anti minority? Reporter is trying to impose her opinion on others. If she could provide proof and then give that statement would be better...
When they massacred thousands of Muslims in riots over the decades 😂
What are you smoking? 😂
Seriously..how delusional are u? Why do u think it's been banned sooo many Times...😂😂😂😂
@@yj9032ur 1000% right...this illiterate thinks no one knows anything 😂😂😂
To the ones who say RSS is anti minority- RSS has decades old Muslim wing called Muslim Rashtriya Manch and a Sikh wing Rashtriya Sikh Sangat!
Madam is a graduate from a ivy league here in usa and have strong feelings of hand in glove with the USA DS keep watching the chronology of videos and also the people of choosing and the narrative being build you will understand what we talking about.
D R R
Many children of sanghi leaders also study in ivy league universities
Interviewer should be sacked. Always inturupping.
Does the RSS have an answer on the project to islamise India by 2047.
RSS have said Islam is an integral part of India. Indians are not as gullible as you assume
We want guys like u to join RSS or affiliated Organisations to strengthen the nation.
Without society RSS alone cannot to do it alone.
Brahmanical lies
Project?? Where? When? Who? WORLD' KNOWS U LEARN HOW TO TELL AND SPREAD LIES FROM YOUR MOTHER'S WOMB..CHI CHI CHI..STOP UR FAKE PROPAGANDA
Useless analysis
The Print thinks that they are too intelligent to get people who ever they want to give opinion. All these can talk without substance. Who will be next will be decided by BJP. Looks like these people are in a hurry.
Far Too early 2think of future PM ship. None out there deserving as of today 🎉
Someone said why not Subr. Swamy & that at 80 !!
This is the type of 'fiasco' that happens when the interviewer is just out and out focussed on grabbing a headline for his / her show, than have a meaningful conversation.. What a waste and what a shame..😢
Gadkari is only 7 years younger than Modi. Also he isnt a mass leader.
Yogi is insignificant below the Hindi belt.
@@swashbuckler122 untrue. He has mass following in Telugu states too.
@@AWMminiand in Karnataka
Yogi has a crazy following in Karnataka and Telugu states. And also note that the route AP is taking a saffron parh these days. Just two days ago VHP launched a massive rally in AP to campaign for freeing of temples.
@@swashbuckler122 Gadkari and Fadnavis are not that we'll known outside Maharashtra.
Gadkari nahee ho sakte..
Yogi baba hee hona chahiye
It won’t be shah
It won’t be Gadkari
It won’t be yogi
Don’t rule out Rajnath singh
don’t rule out fadnavis
You are living in fools paradise if you think people consider RSS and it's sarsangchalak as their pope . Without yogi BJP will surely get defeated and India will get coalition govt in long term !!
im interested in hearing why you think fadnavis stands a chance? modi was a very powerful cm so for his track record it was rather easy for him to pull it off, but fadnavis doesn't seem that out there
Shame you don't insert subtitles for summary. Prehistoric Print media
Well. Systematically doctoring the future of RSS.
I am sorry. Certainly you people will get disappointed.
RSS is not entire Bharat.
It is a part of Bharat.
The real intention behind the Dr Mohanji’s statement is to awaken sleeping Hindu forces to fight for their Vedic Civilisation.
Always organisation maintains gap between their core swayamsevaks and leadership.
It’s a strategy.
Initially they opposed Shabarimal issue later they actively jumped into the movement.
If you understand Chanakya well you will understand the attitude of RSS.
Good luck to you for doctoring . theories😂
Bharatiya Muslim is distinct from external Islamic doctrine.
We will Indianise (BHARATIKARAN) the entire Muslim and Christian Indians under the leadership of Yogi Adityanath.
Even bjp picked gadkari,yogi will have enough time to become due to his young age
I can imagine why Shekhar Gupta was so much rattled post 2017 UP assembly elections when Yogi Adityanath's name cropped up for CMs position.
RSS has completed 100 years but how many more lives will the media "personalities" of India take to understand RSS
That means Yogi should be next joice for PM face.
Whole India knows yogi will be next PM besides he won form the biggest state of indja 2 times and now third time
Regarding Muslims, the only thing we need is Uniform Civil Code. That will solve a lot of problems. But honestly, BJP has put that on the backburner, after initially abolishing triple talaq.
And I don't think it's a bad idea to give reservations to backward caste Muslims. It will weaken the hegemony of Muslim upper castes.
Go slow and steady everything will align in it's place !!
Print journos taking up RSS as a topic .....painfully 😂😅
The comments here seem overly critical. It seems like people want to listen to one view and nothing else. I listened to this hour long interview with interest. The host did a good job of gently bringing the guest back to the topic, as he was sometimes drifting away from the question asked. Overall, I got some good insights into RSS functioning and opinions.
She wore a beautiful burqa.
Toudukutting interview.
None of de people mentioned is Worthy nor aFit replacement for a PM position 🎉 Let Modi continue till some sound, suitable One is found.
Age Experience matters most, & a liberal Patriot, a Visionary, a Selfless person is 2be found ❤
Hemant Sh. is shabbily dressed & clothed, his presentation is a drawback & his accent is poor.
Jaishankar cud be given a short term PM .
How about .... A new comer Other s need to be dug out😢
I was expecting an intelligent discussion with Walter Anderson on a topic like RSS but this lady is not upto the mark. She is immature and lacks depth.
Interviewing a foreigner about RSS is laughable. They might have insights, no doubt, but this kind of foreign validations for the Indian phenomenon is not warranted.
Divine dispensation & divine grace will decide next PM ❤🎉
It is not as strong as it is made out to be..I have attended their shakha..these people keep mocking Gandhi ji and Muslim too...they look important because congress has become weak..once congress put its house in order,it will again be as like any other organisation not very important as it is made out to be..
Please make the congress strong.
Congress mentality ruled India in form of Muslim invaders and Christian invaders for 1000 years . The congress mentality has to be destroyed not just weakened
Congress divides the country 😢
Congress will not become strong untill they smash their upper leadership because Rahul Gandhi seems like he don't give a fuck about politics and doesn't work thet hard .
It's been few days when Singh saheb passed but that guy is in Vietnam..
Congress needs a new leadership otherwise the Gandhian ideology will vanish from India .
Do they mock gandhi without a reason?
Gadkari is not a stong serious determined person for a pm post. ❤ Besides a big minus point is Gadkari He is too much of a great Foodie 😮😢
Whenever he speaks something good about the government she quickly interrupts him, not a good interviewer.
The Print should tell who the next successor is will be to take over Position of this UA-cam channel, then they can Spreads Narratives as usual against BJP or Modi Ji
Not everything is about Modi
@elcapitaan1 oh is it
Who the heck is this.Anderson chap to make these wild comments.
I think the comments were made by Mohan Bhagwat. Anderson is merely providing analysis.
A foreigner telling us who to elect and select for India's PM. No thank you.
I wish this woman would stop interrupting
She is trying really hard to get her biases about rss and bjp validated by her guest
Leftist DS Print tryting its best to create a rift and split in Hindus. Batenge tho Katenge
Who will be the PM after Modi will be decided by BJP workers and NOT by RSS. Let us be clear that Gadkari stands no chance whatsoever, as he has no following in the BJP. Gadkari is one the best Ministers Modi Govt had but that does not make his automatic choice for the next PM.
But who will be the next PM will be decided at the time when Modi decides to retire. As of now, Modi should and must continue till 2034. By the time he retires, we will have Yogi, Himanta and Devendra as strong contenders, apart from Amit Shah and even Jai Shankar. Rajnath and Gadkari would be much older by then.
So this issue is NOT due for discussion as of now!!! Period.
Who the hell are you???😂😂 Do you have a say in it?
@@mid5526 Does Walter Andersen has a say in it!!!!! he he!!! Only BJP workers have a say in it!!!
Seems to know very little about the Hindu Muslim issue...
the author obviouslyt ried to put words in the mouth of the speaker but miserably failed.
It should be only Yogi. No one else.
Celibacy is not to be equated with bachelorhood. 😅. Prof got very many things wrong. BTW bring the opposite voices too Guptaji. I'm contributing not just for RSS buttering 😂.
Walter Andersen is ultimate authority on Indian politicis.I read his books in early 2000's and he is a giant in political studies field.Great to see him on your channel
This is sad. Come with me I will show you real India
Zipping on express highway and claiming vishwaguru is the problem why India is where it is
if RSS does the poll of their karyakartas, it will definitely come out that they favour digging every mosque and find shivling underneath. Now it seems, Mr. Bhagwat is not just giving in to what masses are saying but leading them to a different direction that in his view better for the country.
In one of the interviews, Gadkari said he got suggestions from the PMO to reduce his visits to Nagpur which is not only his Constituency, but also his birthplace and the HQ of RSS. And he did not care what PMO said. He did what he wanted to. While Rajnath Singh looks to be playing 2nd fiddle for PMO, Gadkari kept building the roads and earned quiet a good name. While Yogi kept proving himself, he still has an image of Dabang CM. Shah doesn't have the saintly image of Gadkari. Himantha, Yogi, Fadnavis are definitely potential PMs. But, not until 2034. Again... this is what I believe. As long as RaGa, Kejri kind of crooks do not sit in the PMO, it doesn't matter which BJP leaders sits there.
I was in RSS in 1979.
I say Nitin Gadkari Ji because of his Nagpur, Marathi background does not make sense to be a must to replace MODI Ji, but Gadkari Ji is qualified leader.
Idea of RSS indeed formulated by the "Chitpavan Brahmin", where 'Brahmin' itself a formulated one by them for a good SECULAR purpose, after looking the sufferings of JEWS in AD 1800s-1900s. That does not mean Hi(Si)ndus and Jews are same.
ARYANS & Jews are SAME.
But Hindus made Peace with Aryans through the #Sanskrit.
But Jews (Abrahamic) had neither made Peace nor made any conflicts in history with so called Hindus (so do not adopt EUROPEAN responsibilities as Hindu responsibility).
But one of the Abrahamic made problems in Gujarat, Saurashtra (Chittorgarh, Jauhar, #Saka), ..
So the qualified to replace, atleast to test, Modi Ji is Yogi Adityanath Ji.
Hello Sanghis 😂
Ok Soros katha uvach
Lol....
Gadkari is the only able Minister in the entire BJP rank and file whose pragmatism is not marred by narrow, divisive ideology of RSS and BJP
Good pr work by gadkari ji
Why are sanghis so offended in the comments. It was a factual discussion based on actual statements made in public.
If this is your opinion, I sanghi would be very happy. You guys cannot understand why RSS has been successful for 100 years, because you wear ideological lense and not objective. Please continue with your ways, as with this you will never understand RSS and hence can never fight RSS effectively
RSS believes in Muslim - Brahmin unity to perpetuate their rule over Backward, Dalit and Adivasi Hindus. RSS is a B team team of Jawahar Lal Nehru !!!!
Bhai sasta nasha band karle
We don't need a Gora to tell us about rss or India, bewakoofi, stop seeking approval from the west, grow up
Shame on Print - self loathing desis, SHAME, dump this channel.
why not Fadnavis than Gadkarior Yogi?
Lol 🤣
Read surah tauba 5 and 29,
That is the hate speech against all other religion.
Islam and other religion cannot coexist
Read manusmriti to know ur own reality