'India Is Forgetting the Unity in Diversity That It Once Taught the World'
Вставка
- Опубліковано 21 бер 2019
- Delhi University's professor Apoorvanand in conversation with academic, psephologist and Swaraj India's national president, Yogendra Yadav on the need to seek a clear definition of a country as diverse as India and how can India integrate its different cultures, religions and languages.
Click here to support The Wire: thewire.in/support
"India" means even others communities should feel that unity
ऐसी डिवेट कई वर्षों बाद सुनने को मिली कितना विविध है मेरा भारत में आप की बातें सुनके चिंता भी है सुकून भी है जय भारत।
विविध आकार प्रकार के मोती, मणियाँ, को समता रूपी धागे में पिरोने से एक माला तैयार होती है। यही हमारे देश के सविंधान निर्माताओं की मुल भावना थी। 🌈🙏
Lekin TUSTIKARAN ki politics sb bekar kr deti hai..
Thanks to Prof. Apoorvanand and Yogendra Ji. Brilliant Discussion!
Hardeep bhai exactly
I'm a simple man.. I see Yogendra Yadav I hit like :))
Ni
Yogendra Yadav-the man having outstanding understanding about Indian society
@@MrSatyamGowtham dear, it means intellectualism is judged by seats only??? Then according to u sakshi maharaj & sadhvi pragya jyoti is much more educated than any one...height of pseudo intellectualism...
@@MrSatyamGowtham in that case I agreed that intellectualism is based on proper understanding of any topic but when u r making personal remarks to anyone then u should make difference between seats winning & one's personal qualification.. according to me.. intellectualism can not be judged by constituency win or loss.. coz. According to me Mr. Manmohan singh is a great personality but he never fought any loksabha election.. so u need to understand the difference.
@@MrSatyamGowtham because education doesn't win you elections here 😀
Great discussion between two legend. New Zealand ki PM Jecinda Andren ne duniya ki aman pasand logo ka dil jeet liya.Bhaiyo 2019 me PM chuno Chowkidar nahi
Yes, we do not need chowkidar. We need a effective PM. A PM who is empathetic
@S J J Andhbhakt aagae hahahahaha
@Mahender bhadana Andhbhakt aa gae hahahaha
@S J J kal Gurugram me kya hua dekhlo Andhbhakt aankhe kholo tab duniya dikhai degi nahi jumlo me uljhe rahoge
Unity will come when Muslims support Ram Mandir
बहुत अच्छी बातें सुनने को मिलती हैं सर । मैं आप दोनों विद्वानों की बहुत आभारी हूँ । ऐसी विचार-चर्चाएं प्रस्तुत करते रहिएगा, धन्यवाद ।
Shobhna Ma'am,
Pranaam🌹
Aap Kaisi Hain?
Shobhna Vijh jjji
Mainstream मीडिया में ( The wire ) की सख्त जरूरत है ....
Tv पत्रकारिता के दौर में .........
ua-cam.com/video/gyt6zx2PumU/v-deo.html
I quite agree with what Prof Yadav has said..... I think he has hit the nail on the head about we going away from our traditions and roots.....
Saurabh don't over intellectualise these two leftist sickullar minded old haggards , they are only fillibustering
@@goutamdas6302 at least they r not propagating fundamentalist & capitalist mindset..
@@prinsuyadav4218 Ae Yadav , Sun le religious fundamentalism is the need of the hour to spot Muslim feet lickers like you , sale Bihar me MY combination bana ke tum yadav log muslimo ke talwe chat te ho ... Besgaram
@@goutamdas6302 re bewkoof tu pakka shakha hi lagata hoga tbhi tere gyan chakshu nai khule... Pehle padhai kar ache se ...& Before making any comments read constitution , nai tu das hi ban ke rahega unka.... Anpad saale..or agar itni hi fat rhi hai to khul ke kaho na.. bole na bjp ki muslimo ko bhagao.. kyu ..fatati hai kya tumhari.. saalo koi contribution hai ni azadi me ab gyan chod rhe ho
@@prinsuyadav4218 Prinsu , you advise me to read constitution , let me correct you I am by cast Kayasth , which is far superior to your Yadav cast both in social standing and education wise ok , so I know pretty well how secularism (42nd amendment ) was inducted into Indian Constitution during the days of emergency 1976
Don't waste your life licking the feet of your illiterate leader like Lalu Yadav and Tej Pratap Yadav , why u buffoons fall in love with Muslims , is there something weong in your DNA ???
Just compare my leader Naveen Pattnaik CM odisaa who is a kayasth with your illiterate uneducated leaders like Ram Vilas paswan tej Pratap Yadav Lalu Yadav but Bihar has high quality leaders like Yashwant Sinha karpuri Thakur Bhagavad Jha Ajad
Sachai ye he ke tum sab chote jat ke log mil kar Bihar ko barbad Kar dia ... Tum jaise chote jat ke log anpadh , ganwar chote dimag ke hote ho OMG
You advise me
योगेंन्द्र यादव जी आप लेफ्टिस्टों को देश के रक्षक कह रहे हैं ये तो देश के टुकडे चाहने वाले लोग हैं ।लेफ्टिस्ट कब से देश के रक्षक हो गये हैं। आप जैसे लोगों ने ही 1947 में देश का विभाजन हो जाने दिया ।
बहुत ही प्रेरणादायी और मार्गदर्शन करने वाला कार्यक्रम है। आप दोनों बुदिजीवी शख्सियत को सलाम
बहुत सुंदर विचार हैं आपके । अफ़सोस है कि भारत उन लोगों के कब्जे में है जो भारतीयता की समझ नहीं है।
चुनाव का महीना है मच गया शोर
फिर आया है time to choose
Who will screw us more.
ऐसा गया है ये discourse नीचे,
गोत्र जनेऊ versus hate की स्पीचें,
कोई बोँलें पप्पू,कोई चौकीदार चोर,
ममता जी, माया पवार,सबका है सपना
Pm की कुर्सी पे नाम हो अपना,
सोनिया मुलायम का,भी है यह सपना
Pm की कुर्सी पे मुन्ना हो अपना,
और अडवाणी जी रोये,
in corner alone
AZAD 1 AZAD अति सुन्दर।
AZAD 1 AZAD.. Lage raho...
Adwani ji jarur koi bada Pap kiya hoga😬😬
@democracy Teri aise ki taise .... episode dekh liya😀😀
भारत ५००० साल से नहीं चला आ रहा है - आप का यह वाक्य आप की सोच का द्योतक है ।
I am mesmerised by knowing that in the midst of so much noise there are still people who can think with so much clarity.
Yogendra sir is extraordinary... The guy is full of knowlegde... the way he speaks... good listener...
🙏This is called "Dialogue",great programme,thanks Wire,this talk will go above the bigoted minds,sad,time to rise and fight these forces together."Sawal hi Parampara"👍
Sirr,,i salute you...🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Congratulations to The wire news , the true news channel. just an year ago had only a little over 2.5 lakh subscribers on UA-cam. Now 12 lakh ! Clearly indicates the changing directions of winds.
Unity will come when Muslims support Ram Mandir
@@satyamevjayate1601 let's accept there was a temple that was destroyed by some muslim ruler. You destroyed the mosque. Khatam karo na baat.
@@soumyadip1997 it's an issue between hindus and muslims. Atheists should stay away.
Aise program hi TV pe aana chahiye.. thanks to both of you sir's
Yeh chunav .berozgari .greebi ya vikas ka mudda nahi raha...modi ne desh ki jo halat kardi hai sabse bada mudda desh aur uske sambidhan ko bachane ka ho gaya hai..aur humlog bachaenge.🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
@Angry Aaryabhat wah beta aap phir aa gaye..aapka baap hijda nahi iska proof aap ho..pata nahi kyun paida kya tujhe...
great great great
overwhelmed.
gratitude to both.
Always eager to hear something from you Mr. Yadav.. I can feel the soul of india while listening to you..
Apoorvanand sahab behtareen kaam kar rahe hain
बहुत बहुत शुक्रिया अच्छा लगा बहुत ही बेहतरीन तरीके से समझाया है
भारतीय परिपेक्ष्य में राष्ट्रवाद विविधताओं में नेचुरल एकता ही हैं अर्थात् विविधताओं का सम्मान होना चाहिए।शानदार ज्ञानपरक संवाद।
Very nice video by Apporvanand ji. India really needs many such videos nowdays. These things enhance the thinking capacity, makes it broader. But unfortunately Indias intellectual capacity is becoming shallower and narrower day by day. May common sense peace brother hood prevails all over.
@S J J haha😄 my brother common sense and foolishness doesn't discriminate on basis of religion, color etc. Its with every one depends whether we want to use it or not and get nurtured by reading and listening to good things.
@S J J please stop using Hindu Muslim terms etcs, enough damage in past 5 years. It's time to become human first i guess.
@@EducationEasy4All Unity will come when Muslims support Ram Mandir
@@satyamevjayate1601 haha 😄 thought Lord Shiva was more prominent in that region. But suddenly after seeing first time telivised version of Ramayan, a certain political party started liking it. Everyone support Lord Ram temple built anywhere in Ayodhya but nobody will support when its built by destroying someone's else worship place that too an historical 600 years building Babri Mosque falsely. You can't justify wrogn. The people who are ready to kill and use political miliage in the name of Ram have forgotten the basic teaching of Lord Ram, he himself were to avoid clash in his home choosed 14 years exile. just so that peace and harmony maintain in his family 4 mothers and brothers. But i think the people doesn't understood the ramcharitmanas correctly. Even the tulsidas who wrote it was thrown out of town by his people. This shows how much superficial we human are.
@@satyamevjayate1601 perhaps I can support you if you comment from a real profile 😀
बहुत बहुत धन्यवाद सर् ।
The Wire Is On Fire !
Good Work !
🔥🔥👌 💖💙💛TheWIRE.🌹
They are killing it
गहन चींतन जो आप करकर अपने देश के अधोगती को और बदतर ना होने देनेकी प्रयास कररहे हो, उस देश भक्ति तडप के लीये आपको सहस्र धन्यवाद, साधुवाद .
I love to get enriched through the in-depth analysis of both the intellectual Yogendra Yadav and Prof Apoorvanand.
Bahut hi achha vishleshan kiya done ne...dhanyavaad yogendrajee aur apoorvajee.
Behtareen discussion , magar modi ko support karne wale log is tarah ki gyan ki baaten nahi samajh sakte.
Unhone aankhon pe patti bandh li hy
@S J J beta asli profile to banao itna garvit hindu ho to
@S J J sirf wahi log samajh sakte hain jinme insaniyat hai aur jinko Bharat se pyar hai , modi ji ke supporter jo ab insaan na hoke Nazi robot ho gaye hain wo nahi samajh sakte
@S J J asli profile se samjhao na bhaiya. Nek kam mein chhupna kaisa
You, the legendary duo. Excellento !!👍
Jio! Absolutely brilliant discussion. Ty both of you. Big fan
Enriching, enlightening, uplifting conversation.
आप दोनो के विचार हमें नई ऊर्जा प्रदान करते है। ऐसी गहन और ज्ञानवर्धक चर्चा के लिये आप और " The Wire " को साधुवाद ।
Yogendra Yadav is totally negative that is why he was removed from aam admi party.
You are Great sir
बहुत ही सुन्दर चर्चा एवं विचार ।
Great discussion sir , thanks
Porf. Apoorvanand Sahab ki baat or vision samzh aa gaya.
👍👍🙏🙏Jai Bheem Jai Bharat
YY's content always satisfies me.
Heart touching and Brilliant discussions
Bachpan se seekhte aa rahe hain ki India is 'unity in diversity'..aaj jo haal hai Desh ka jaankar bahut dukh hota hai..
महोदय इस देश में अच्छे शिक्षकों और अच्छी शिक्षा का आभाव है परिणामस्वरूप आज देश में मानवतावादी विचारधारा संकटग्रस्त है
Very essential video
Great great discussion by Apoorvanand ji and Yogender ji, nation need such personalities.
किसी भी बाहरी शरणार्थी का भारत में स्वागत है लेकिन इस कीमत पर नहीं कि वे शरणार्थी यहाँ के बहुसंख्यकों को अल्पसंख्यक बना दें और खुद बसुसंख्यक बन जायें।
किसी भी बाहरी शरणार्थी का भारत में स्वागत है लेकिन इस कीमत पर नहीं कि वही शरणार्थी आगे चलकर अपने लिए एक अलग देश माँगने लग जायें जैसा कि 1947 में हुआ था।
Both gentle man nice thinking
Wire Anchor & Mr. Yogendraji both are very polite mannerable excellent debate. 🌹
Very heart touching dissociation ... Ek the Wire Chantal ek beh Chantal jo...dhool ke beaver bhi nehi
Kya baat hai sir... Maan ko chhu gaya aaj ka varta se
Sir aap dono bady mahan hain.
Excellent discussion
In 2019 there is not election between BJP and Congress party but a election between Gandhi ji and Savarkar i,e between minority and secular
ua-cam.com/video/gyt6zx2PumU/v-deo.html
😂😂😂 Savarkar won
Good language and manners, knowledgeable discussion.
What a Great Program , Hats of to both of you !!!
Yogendra jii and apoorvanad jii you all are doing a great work pls keep us inspiring to establish secularism with diversity in our country. Unity of our country lies in diversity
And our constitution is also a bunch of units of diversity pls save country our from this bjp and rss India pls stop voting on the basis of caste or religious or hindutav
Let's together make a india in which any community will not dominatin but the feeling of Indianism is dominate
Lets establish biggest secularism in the world
Ap dono ke ander real bhartiyata dikhti h hats of sir
Kya shaandar charcha
very emotional talk - it is always good to listen yogandra jee
मै भी मानता हूं कि भारत को एक समतामूलक शांतिप्रिय और प्रोग्रेसिव देश बनाना होगा। मगर मेरी मुश्किल उन लोगों से है जो अनजाने में या जानबूझकर एक खास धर्म को खास treatment देने की बात करते जबकि उस धर्म की मूल बातें ही democracy, peace और equality के विचारों के खिलाफ है। ये ढोंग बंद करके हमें एक progressive aur scientific देश बनाना है।
these two are Great intellectuals great discussions
Dil ye hi kahta kee New Zealand ki pm jaisi koi pm hamre desh ki hoti
Great discussion. Superb.
We are still looking for what should our country stand for !! But fail to recognize that how rich was the culture of thousands of years on which it stands. It stood because it kept welcoming all the cultures, religions, languages and knowledge. But we failed after independence to keep up with what held our country together. Opportunists took advantage of this and brought religion to its center. Lately the discussions started on to whom this country really belonged, based on caste, culture and language spoken. This is where we failed. Very true Yogendraji.
भारत का स्वधर्म ख़तरे में है == (योगेंद्रपति जी के अनुसार) हमारी दुकान/नौकरी ख़तरे में है
Great job sir
yogendra yadav se puri tarah se mai sahmat ho.
Bjp के लिए सत्ता और पार्टी ही सबसेE बड़ी है।
When two wise man talk ,hearing them is always a pleasure.
Crucial discussion on current situation of our country, thank you sir
Modi jindabaad.......I Will vote modi for development
@@civi12132 kaun sa development, agr development kiya hota to development pe vote mangta, jo bhi step liya sab barbaad karne wala hi tha,
@@Chemistrybyhusainsir lol. Apply burnol. BJP will gain majority in 2019
Baat kuch is tara hi honi chahiye.
Good knowledge
Thank you
आप लोगो से बहुत कुछ सीखने को मिलता है बहुत जल्द लोग समझ जाए गे
अब ऐसी उमीद आप जैसे लोगो से ही है
u two r great sir.....after listing such debates and such thoughts we again start feeling that there is still some hope to save democracy......great ...and pls continue...
BHUT ACHE KHYAL HE
Very thoughtful discussion . We need such more discussions
👌
अपूर्वानंद जी अच्छा होता कि आप बताते कि आप कैसा भारत चाहते हैं
महोदय आपकी चर्चाओं का हमेशा एक ही विषय रहता है जो आसान शिकार भी है हिन्दू विचारधारा जिसे आप भारत और विश्व के लिए सबसे बड़ा ख़तरा समझते हैं। जब मैं आज के दिन हिन्दू धर्म और मुस्लिम धर्म में धार्मिक कट्टरता, महिला शोषण, अशिक्षा, अलगाववाद, अन्य धर्मों से घृणा भाव आदि की तुलनात्मक समीक्षा करता हूं तो पाता हूं कि धर्म के रूप में सबसे उदार हिन्दू धर्म है इस धर्म के मानने वाले हर तरह के सुधार के लिए तत्पर रहे हैं यहां आपको हिन्दू प्रतीकों, मान्यताओं की आलोचना का अधिकार है जो अन्य कही नहीं मिलेगा। आप भारत के 15% लोगों (तथाकथित स्वर्ण जातियां) में से आधे लोगों को ही इस देश की हर समस्या की जड़ कहते हैं अप्रत्यक्ष रूप में आप देश की 92% जनसंख्या जिसमें मुस्लिम, पीछड़े, दलित आदि सभी है को भड़काने की कोशिश करते हैं जिससे तथाकथित दोषी वर्ग के प्रति कभी भी हिंसा फैल सकती है शायद आपका लक्ष्य भी यही है? विश्व के अनेक भागों में यहूदियों के खिलाफ भी ऐसा ही माहौल बनाया गया था जिसके परिणामस्वरूप स्वरुप यहूदियों के खिलाफ हिंसा ने भयानक रूप ले लिया था।
Well done sir you are right great
23:46 Islamic Tariqa hai professor Saheb Jo hmme hamare nabi karim rasool sawa ne sikhaya hai Mehmano ka adaar krne ke liye teen din tk aap sewa kiye mehmanno ki.
Two legends in one frame
Every word should rip through connoisseur "s eye, ear and hearts ! Congrats !
Very informative and mature discussion ...
BHUT KHUB SER
brilliant exposition by prof.
On our independence from British regime, the freedom fighters envisaged an IDEA OF INDIA which they laid foundation to over seven decades ago when we set out to live, work and function as a NATION.
However, a section of socially-challenged people in our population had a fascist IDEA OF INDIA. They were opposed to the DEMOCRATIC, SOCIALIST SECULAR REPUBLIC IDEA of INDIA. They could not live with DIFFERENCES and DIVERSITY of this nation. They wanted to become the NEW COLONIAL FORCE a la the British Colonial force from whom we gained our independence. They were the ones that founded RSS. They wanted all different people groups in India to accept and subscribe to their personal worldviews and accept them as superior humans that had an unquestionable RIGHT to RULE over others and enjoy all the GOOD THINGS OF LIFE. They condemned, demonized and vilified other religions and people that followed other religious, political and worldviews.
They branded fellow Indians that did not subscribe to their sanghee fascist ideas as traitors and anti-nationals. The sanghees branded traitors and anti-nationals all Indians that rejected Hindu-ism as a religion and embraced Christianity, Islam and other religions as they found merit in them.
Interestingly, these supremacists have idea neither of religions, nor of scriptures, nor of history, nor of any subject of learning that matters. Most of them are, in fact, spiritual drop-outs. RSS-BJP remains a political organization of a handful of intellectually-challenged and socially-challenged Manuvadi Brahmnic Hindus in Nagpur that spread to a minority of their kind across India in the last 7 decades. They have neither contributed anything, neither to HINDUISM nor to INDIA. Name ONE SANGHEE who could contribute anything to mankind and anything at all to Hinduism, anything at all to INDIA as a nation. No Hindu gives such a bad name to Hindu religion and India as the BJP-RSS Sanghee parivar does.
It is high time the TRUE HINDUS of this nation recognize this fact and save Hindu-ism and India from the hands of sanghee perverts that on diagnosis, medically speaking, would prove PSYCHOPATHS, NARCISSISTS and SOCIOPATHS that are extremely dangerous to a society of peace-loving, law-abiding, normal fellow humans that love to peacefully co-exist and work with each other. Whose country is this? That of the former or latter? Whose country should India be? Of the former or the latter? Whose world should this be? Of the former or the latter?
It is high time normal humans of India take back this country from the hands of the mentally sick. Elections 19 is the opportunity the people of India can grab to show the door to the mentally sick fascists and bring back to power healthy minds that can continue working toward making this nation an ideal nation in the whole world where people of all races, people following all religions, people of different skills, opinions, worldviews, capacities LIVE and WORK as ONE MAN, without any discrimination, oppression and exploitation. An India where EQUALITY, LIBERTY, FRATERNITY, UNITY, HARMONY and PROGRESS thrives without any threat from within. That's what WE as a NATION should dream of becoming and work together to become.
نئےبھارت کی تعمیر و تشکیل ساری تہذیبی اور ثقافتی روایتوں کے ساتھ ہی ممکن ہے ہم نے ہمیشہ ہر طرح کے لوگوں 'تہذیبوں'مذہبوں اور زبانوں کو سینے سے لگایا ہے ۔یہی بھارت کی پہچان ہے اور اسی پہچان کے ساتھ ہی بھارت آگے بڑھ سکتا ہے
मान्यवर , जय हिन्द ।
I totally agree with Dr Yogendra Yadav that muslims can't bare any criticism regarding their religion. The Bhartiya Islam just like all other religions in our country should be mainstreamed bcz muslims around me and muslims away from me don't really know their religion. People think they know Islam by learning some quranic phrases and hearing some quranic phrases by their priest . The fact is u cannot know about anything without reading it in depth. People believe that the Saudis are the real followers of Islam this is not the truth. Saudi is a Monarchy and Monarchy is unislamic from the day Islam came and this is the real problem people are not really interested in knowing islam by core. They are just like andhbhakts they only believe what they are told.and that's why bhartiya islam should be main streamed so that people can know the real Islam so that people can question the ones who are misguiding us by showing us a different Islam.
Bharat ki jeet hui 2019 mein 2024 mein bharat ki ek aur bar jeet hogi.
प्रोफेसर अपूरवाननद जी बहुत अच्छी बातें कही हैं आपने - मगर जो व्यक्ति इन्सानियत से और इन्सानों से प्रेम नहीं करता है वह देश प्रेम का डोंग कर रहा है इस देश की बदकिस्मती और बर्बादी की बात है कि कुछ लोग बीजेपी विरोधियों को गालियां देना ही देश प्रेम समझने लगे हैं
The election of 2019 would be between Gandhiji's Ideology of Incluveness and Savarkar's Ideology of exclusion with religious extremism !!
We ca’t understand our culture because we are secular. :-) Apoorvanad ji shows his true feelings as he is so embarrassed about our own history.
High level & brilliant discussion
Great thinking, keen analysis and very very interesting discussion.