A new look at Ernest Hemingway

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 10 кві 2021
  • To many, writer Ernest Hemingway, author of such classics as "The Sun Also Rises," "A Farewell to Arms" and "The Old Man and the Sea," was the very definition of toxic masculinity. But a new PBS documentary finds the writer's literary image, personality and sexuality are not so cut-and-dried. Correspondent Mark Whitaker talks with filmmakers Ken Burns and Lynn Novick, and with Hemingway scholar Marc Dudley, about re-examining the larger-than-life writer in the age of #MeToo.
    "CBS Sunday Morning" features stories on the arts, music, nature, entertainment, sports, history, science and Americana, and highlights unique human accomplishments and achievements. Check local listings for CBS Sunday Morning broadcast times.
    Subscribe to the "CBS Sunday Morning" UA-cam channel: bit.ly/20gXwJT
    Get more of "CBS Sunday Morning": cbsn.ws/1PlMmAz
    Follow "CBS Sunday Morning" on Instagram: bit.ly/23XunIh
    Like "CBS Sunday Morning" on Facebook: bit.ly/3sRgLPG
    Follow "CBS Sunday Morning" on Twitter: bit.ly/1RquoQb
    Subscribe to our newsletter: cbsn.ws/1RqHw7T
    Download the CBS News app: cbsn.ws/1Xb1WC8
    Try Paramount+ free: bit.ly/2OiW1kZ
    For video licensing inquiries, contact: licensing@veritone.com

КОМЕНТАРІ • 314

  • @billycharles
    @billycharles 2 роки тому +57

    Men referring to other men as “toxic masculine” have great insecurities about their masculinity

    • @bittercreek9850
      @bittercreek9850 Рік тому +5

      This is spot on

    • @GregCoconut
      @GregCoconut Рік тому +4

      Yes agreed.

    • @marknewton6984
      @marknewton6984 Рік тому +5

      True-- what is wrong with being masculine)?!

    • @georget3953
      @georget3953 4 місяці тому +1

      no disrespect but i really don’t think you understand what toxic masculinity is

    • @melinda3413
      @melinda3413 4 місяці тому +1

      Cherry picking that out of this entire clip says quite a bit about you. 🤔

  • @shippenman5977
    @shippenman5977 2 роки тому +57

    A real man. Creative, flawed, lived on his own terms and made a contribution to human beings through his stories.

  • @drewhendley
    @drewhendley 3 роки тому +113

    Nothing is worse than judging the past by the ideals of the present

    • @rickriddle
      @rickriddle 3 роки тому +1

      Truth is Truth.

    • @moraeller5416
      @moraeller5416 3 роки тому +2

      You are correct!!!!!!!!

    • @jeffjones1056
      @jeffjones1056 3 роки тому

      Your so right

    • @partizankapartizanochka7034
      @partizankapartizanochka7034 Рік тому +1

      so we dont have to judge slavery, hitler, stalin, hiroshima ans so on??

    • @millznthrillz9882
      @millznthrillz9882 Рік тому +2

      @@partizankapartizanochka7034 That's not at all what he is saying. The ideals of the present have changed throughout time, slavery, hitler, stalin and hiroshima were always horrible things. People were always able to see that, whether they could control it was a different thing.

  • @jamesnetwall1193
    @jamesnetwall1193 3 роки тому +109

    I never thought that he was toxic I just thought he was a great writer. What in the world is wrong with being masculine

    • @tutubeas10
      @tutubeas10 Рік тому +12

      It's the latest fashion. If it weren't for masculine and macho men we wouldn't be enjoying the freedom we have today in most of the world.

    • @marknewton6984
      @marknewton6984 Рік тому +5

      Nothing wrong
      A great writer. Last real man in America.

  • @TheBibleisArt
    @TheBibleisArt 3 роки тому +72

    You spent no time on his actual literary art but minutes on his sexuality. Come on, guys.

    • @SilverHonda0767
      @SilverHonda0767 Рік тому +5

      I totally agree

    • @PaliAha
      @PaliAha Рік тому +1

      The new story is his sexuality among other things. We already know about his art. Come on, guy.

    • @champabay99
      @champabay99 Рік тому +4

      this is typical of literary academics, as an english major in college i can guarantee you that everything all the time is about sexuality to the literary community. it gets exhausting

    • @marknewton6984
      @marknewton6984 Рік тому +2

      A Great Writer!!

    • @roadrunner381
      @roadrunner381 2 місяці тому

      Well the title was called, A New look at Earnest Hemingway, not the work of Earnest Hemingway!

  • @rubychew6535
    @rubychew6535 3 роки тому +46

    You never needed to use a dictionary while reading his books. I think he did this because he wanted people (even the lay person) to enjoy his books. I think his mother may have had an impact on him since she seemed to be a dominate person. She would dress him in girls clothes sometimes.

    • @regisnyder
      @regisnyder 3 роки тому +7

      So true! I love Toni Morrison but a dictionary or laptop better be nearby when reading her works.

    • @awarenessvillage
      @awarenessvillage 3 роки тому +11

      Hemingway's books are uniquely accessible, yet so rich. He was a true artist.

    • @zelmoziggy
      @zelmoziggy 3 роки тому +1

      I never need to use a dictionary when I read books by most authors.

    • @orangewarm1
      @orangewarm1 2 роки тому

      Nor Orwell

    • @christopherreynolds4446
      @christopherreynolds4446 Рік тому

      His vocabulary simply was not rich

  • @billsmith6884
    @billsmith6884 Рік тому +19

    He was a man of his time. You can't judge him by today's standards.

    • @danielleharris300
      @danielleharris300 7 місяців тому +1

      Well said ,So many historical people are judged by today's standard

    • @timkdiamond
      @timkdiamond 6 місяців тому

      Also true.

  • @kevinm.8682
    @kevinm.8682 3 роки тому +44

    The problem with the current cancel culture is that you cannot easily apply the standards of today to people who lived and died even 30 years ago. Being critical of what was totally acceptable then but taboo now is an unfair standard. Of course they know this, but they have an agenda, and they can't let fairness and reason stand in the way.

    • @el_aleman
      @el_aleman 3 роки тому +6

      I do think this man born over a century ago was heavily influenced by the values and mores of his time. But this I can tell you this from my own experiences with Depression and PTSD from nearly 3 years in combat zones and several concussions and that is this: few people will ever look at you as a person with a history of mental illness and head injury, most will look at you as a person with severe character faults, i.e. a mal-adjusted person to stay away from....and they will judge you accordingly, regardless of how you may have recovered.... watch the video clip from his CBS interview .... this is not a man of weak character and poor moral judgment who drinks too much and is being forgetful, it shows a man who is seriously suffering the effects from head injury and cognitive deficit....I do not think this documentary would have been made or funded if it did not serve as an exposé to show Hemingway’s hidden behaviors.....Surely these behaviors are nothing to be emulated and cannot be completely attributed to his war experiences, mental illness, alcohol excess and head injury.... but let’s look at the whole picture before we start casting judgment and think twice before we cancel a person whose writing style sets the standard for American literature.

    • @angelboychanman
      @angelboychanman 3 роки тому

      This culture watches the movie Gone With The Wind and, most of all, they enjoy laughing at the women's clothing of the day.

    • @gmcmullins3251
      @gmcmullins3251 9 місяців тому

      I don't believe in cancel culture of the past. That's changing history. History, good or bad, is wise to be remembered

    • @matthewgallant3622
      @matthewgallant3622 7 місяців тому

      How was he misogynist and racist? They put this big charges on him with no evidence other than he likes to hunt and box.

  • @pabloalvez915
    @pabloalvez915 3 роки тому +140

    One of my favorite writers.
    His private life was his own business.
    Period.

    • @victorkong82
      @victorkong82 3 роки тому +3

      If you think that then you haven’t watched the documentary and you truly don’t understand Hemingway. Of all authors, his works are the most influenced by the attitudes of his private life. Period.

    • @pabloalvez915
      @pabloalvez915 3 роки тому +17

      @@victorkong82 You're wrong when you stated I dont understand Hemingway. Not at all , because Ive been reading and analyzing his literature for twenty years now, therefore you're making a very incorrect assessment of me . No you can't but that doesn't mean you still can't appreciate it. In my modest opinion, the documentary suffers from a PC type of bias, which makes it look like an immense biographical rewriting meant to appease. Look, I'm giving you an example : I really enjoy the Red Army Choir but I detest communism. However, they bring a patriotic "punch" to their music. You shouldn't pass off art because the artist is a controversial figure. Why? Because it makes you narrow minded - by focusing mostly on the person - and aligned with a particular agenda. You should examine and appreciate it for what it is. Try being fully impartial, stay away from judgements, and you'll be able to appreciate his work to the fullest. Period and enough said.

    • @alexusbratva878
      @alexusbratva878 3 роки тому +3

      Dostoevsky, Hemingway, Kerouac, Burroughs, Thompson, writers that writers, that young people in high school, should know! (in my opinion)

    • @christopherp.hitchens3902
      @christopherp.hitchens3902 3 роки тому

      His praise of Bullfighting during this documentary as an “art form” diminished his standing as an artist and certainly as an “intellectual”. It matters who a person is in his private life...otherwise, there would be no problem singing the praises of OJ Simpson. Or ...Derek Chauvin who also had a death struggle with someone he THOUGHT was only an animal.
      AND A GIANT MIDDLE FINGER TO KEN BURNS FOR INCLUDING THE GERIATRIC LLOSA AND HIS ABSURD ANTIQUATED THINKING!

    • @maggiewickwire2936
      @maggiewickwire2936 3 роки тому

      Public persons rarely have a private life. If you want your life to be private, don’t become famous.

  • @Johnonayacht
    @Johnonayacht 3 роки тому +28

    They love to say toxic masculinity

    • @ascii7085
      @ascii7085 3 роки тому +6

      I wonder if that's just how they say 'masculinity' or for some of these people there's a 'masculinity' which isn't toxic. It's strange he can't just be a 'bad person', they have to tie it in with this sex/gender.🤔

    • @julianmx13
      @julianmx13 3 роки тому +9

      Men are the only type of people that aren’t allowed to be themselves within a fair playing field, as today goes. Hemingway never did anything wrong beyond complicated matters that all people do and face everyday. His artistry and persona breaks through the current silly trends of social justice, easily.

  • @southerndandy4910
    @southerndandy4910 3 роки тому +9

    Judging a figure from the past by current standards is low IQ mental gymnastics.

  • @dougowen9873
    @dougowen9873 2 роки тому +9

    "Toxic Masculitiy"?? Hey buddy how far do you think his writing would have moved us as much as it did without that overarching "masculine" feel one gets from his great genius as reflected in the stories. Spare us the politically correct crapola when discussing one who was the greatest writer of the 20th century and possibly of all time. Masculine, in this sense was an integral and required part of his persona and genius. His genius eclipses lightweight reporting such as this piece of what passes for 'journalism' these days, Thank God his genius will still stick in the human mind long after tacky personality hit pieces like this are forgotten.

  • @BigPhilly15
    @BigPhilly15 Рік тому +15

    Hemingway was the greatest American writer of all time. Even if you cancel him, you can’t cancel the generations of authors profoundly influenced by his work (whether such authors realized his influence or not).

    • @anshuecon
      @anshuecon Рік тому

      Greater than Herman Melville?

    • @rusbread
      @rusbread 7 місяців тому

      Dreiser is much better, more ambitious in reflecting the era, morality and realities, deeper and more professional in word mastery and style. There are a lot of American authors many times more talented and interesting than Ham: Mark Twain, Jack London, O. Henry, John Steinbeck, Faulkner, Truman Capote, Jack Kerouac, William S. Burroughs, Ken Kesey and others

    • @timkdiamond
      @timkdiamond 6 місяців тому

      Name one.

    • @TylerD288
      @TylerD288 20 днів тому

      I'm just curious where you'd rank Faulkner? Personally I like Hemingway better, I am a fan I'll admit and I've only read a small amount of Faulkner. I did think Faulkner was a more complex writer and I want to read more.

    • @worldobserver3515
      @worldobserver3515 13 днів тому

      @@rusbread Rubbish.

  • @alejandrogs8254
    @alejandrogs8254 3 роки тому +10

    I am not very fond of the way in which Mark Whitaker conducted the note, I perceived it as quite judgemental, diservicing the audience; I feel that when Lynn Novick was talking about the quite interesting topic of the short hair of Hemingway's wives, opening the door to a deeper discussion about his sensibilities and a complementary light to appreciate his work, she was awfully drowned to square one to give a "yes, you see, some boys like boys and some girls like girls" explanation when Mr Whitaker so blatantly reduced the matter to "so he was a papa that wanted to be a mama"

  • @julianmx13
    @julianmx13 2 роки тому +9

    “wHeN iS hEmIngWay gOnNa bE cAnceLed??”
    *CBS for ya…*

    • @DetroitHomeInspector
      @DetroitHomeInspector 4 місяці тому

      They already are, aren't they? Saying that he wanted to be a girl and wanted his wives to be men. Did it occur to anyone that his ex-wife made it up to sell a book and get back at him? Nah...never happens.

    • @TylerD288
      @TylerD288 20 днів тому

      @@DetroitHomeInspector I'm a big fan of Hemingway, but even if that sexual stuff is true I don't care. It was the mans personal sex life for goodness sakes, why do these journalists care? Oh yeah, money. In any case none of that sexual stuff is even remotely illegal either. Personally, I'll focus on the writing.

  • @margo3367
    @margo3367 3 роки тому +21

    I'm not a depressive and so I was surprised how I got so depressed watching the first 2 or 3 episodes. Just being in his world was such a downer for me. I concluded it wasn't for me.

  • @jeffjones1056
    @jeffjones1056 3 роки тому +8

    It’s ridiculous to cancel history it is what it is the time was different back then. I think he was brilliant in his writings. Without him we wouldn’t have Hunter Thompson

  • @johnpresnell
    @johnpresnell 3 роки тому +19

    This CBS segment is embarrassing, and you can tell the people behind it aren’t very bright. On the other hand, the documentary, which I binge-watched, is excellent, and made by some very clever people indeed.

    • @mrs.herculepoirot7763
      @mrs.herculepoirot7763 3 роки тому +7

      They all sound like 12 year old girls.

    • @sto620
      @sto620 3 роки тому +6

      Agree, too much focus on the salacious and not enough on Hemingway’s literary genius. Sign of the times, I guess.

    • @TylerD288
      @TylerD288 20 днів тому

      Halfway through this piece, when the gears shifted into Hemingway's private sex life I asked myself, why do we care? If it wasn't illegal, why do we care and why aren't we talking about his writing?

  • @mmpw5775
    @mmpw5775 3 роки тому +18

    Saw this. Really liked it. It is tragic, and it is, above all, a story about a very talented man that was flawed, suffered greatly and yet it was amazing to see how the creative force was strong, if not urgent for expression. What was painful, was how his private life had such dissonance with the public life he portrayed. The human condition....

  • @user-iw4gz7vh4w
    @user-iw4gz7vh4w 3 роки тому +33

    1:39 Karen alert. "ChAllEnGiNg aT bEsT aNd prOblEmAtiC."
    How embarrassing to take this approach to one of the greatest geniuses America has ever seen. I hate living in this timeline. I hate the moral police who judge everything and everybody. I hate the corporate do-gooders who try to run our lives. I wish I could transport back to the early 1900s and be a boss like E.H.

    • @aranthos
      @aranthos 2 роки тому

      The world*
      He wasn’t American, he by his own admission, was a world citizen

    • @bittercreek9850
      @bittercreek9850 Рік тому

      He and Jack London

    • @XA-lm5oz
      @XA-lm5oz 11 місяців тому

      Okay, boomer.

  • @regisnyder
    @regisnyder 3 роки тому +25

    I enjoyed the 3-part series on him. I learned so much behind the alcoholism; plus the mental struggles he inherited. All his wives were strong in my opinion. Especially to deal with his somewhat narcissistic behavior. I don’t say he was a narcissist but a man that was allowed/encouraged to take on the persona. Hence his sexuality. He was able to expressed being vulnerable and shedding the whole macho cape with certain wives.

    • @nooopp
      @nooopp Рік тому

      Where is the 3 or series ?

  • @chrisfinch8637
    @chrisfinch8637 3 роки тому +22

    Ken Burns has such a fine narrative voice for these PBS documentaries, as well as Jeff Daniels (of Dumb & Dumber and 101 Dalmatians ‘96) who has a unique voice for Hemingway, himself.

    • @steveconn
      @steveconn 3 роки тому +1

      Daniel's also in Newsroom and more serious roles.

    • @BRLaue
      @BRLaue 3 роки тому +3

      It was narrated by Peter Coyote.

  • @mlecarre2057
    @mlecarre2057 3 роки тому +17

    Oh...my....Americans passing judgments on the dead

  • @alonzobishop3671
    @alonzobishop3671 3 роки тому +11

    It would be an interesting exercise to round up all the horrible people from the arts, politics, military etc..., and cancel all of them. I’m afraid what we would be left with is a lot of meh!

  • @mrs.herculepoirot7763
    @mrs.herculepoirot7763 3 роки тому +6

    What books have any of these people written? What wars have they won? I am quite sure when faced with war and death, all the people in this piece would have run the other way.

  • @JohnBrown-cz7ww
    @JohnBrown-cz7ww 3 роки тому +5

    I am so tired of the hormoneless castrated views of todays journalists. Many great known people of history had there flaws, it doesn't mean that you have to destroy them and take down the great things they did.

  • @AS-zn3zd
    @AS-zn3zd 3 роки тому +4

    This is an example of how small people downsize great person. ..by their own tiny measurements.

  • @larrysouthern5098
    @larrysouthern5098 3 роки тому +45

    Well I could imagine Mr Hemingway would be a "lightning rod" in todays "woke society"...but he probably wouldn't give a hoot about what people thought about him!!!

  • @georgittesingbiel219
    @georgittesingbiel219 3 роки тому +6

    Oddly enough, no mention of his six-toed cats he took care of in Key West. I think this reflects a softer, perhaps more feminine side of Hemingway ( in keeping with the whole androgeny thing )

  • @junesilvermanb2979
    @junesilvermanb2979 3 роки тому +7

    Ernest Miller Hemingway (July 21, 1899 - July 2, 1961) was an American novelist, short-story writer, journalist, and sportsman.
    His economical and understated style-which he termed the iceberg theory-had a strong influence on 20th-century fiction, while his adventurous lifestyle and his public image brought him admiration from later generations.
    Hemingway produced most of his work between the mid-1920s and the mid-1950s, and he was awarded the Nobel Prize in Literature in 1954.
    He published seven novels, six short-story collections, and two nonfiction works.
    Three of his novels, four short-story collections, and three nonfiction works were published posthumously.
    Many of his works are considered classics of American literature.

  • @alansmithee4895
    @alansmithee4895 3 роки тому +5

    Wow, what a ride those episodes were !!!
    😲🤹🤪⚡🎉🍷🧨🍸🍺🥃

  • @corailgris
    @corailgris 2 роки тому +6

    He was a literary giant, so of course he was too complex for the average to comprehend. And as a great writer, he was everyone of his characters, be it male or female. Because that's what artistic geniuses do.Duh.

  • @nrs6956
    @nrs6956 3 роки тому +4

    Thanks for the memories, Hemingway.

  • @bigbensarrowheadchannel2739
    @bigbensarrowheadchannel2739 3 роки тому +6

    The KB doc is one of his best yet. Even though I knew how he left this earth. The ending was very emotional to me. What an adventurous tortured life this man led.

  • @SilverHonda0767
    @SilverHonda0767 Рік тому +3

    Well, Hemingway’s has his own annual look-alike contest that’s been going on for over 40 years in Key West Florida. Name any famous actors, actresses, public figures will have their own look-alike contest ?

  • @ghenckel
    @ghenckel 2 роки тому +5

    Ernest Hemingway was The Man. PBS is filled with PC Correct abiding reporters. Great reporting, lol. Woke reporters changing the history of historic authors. Thanks so much.

  • @larvatusprodeo7745
    @larvatusprodeo7745 3 роки тому +14

    I would rather be around 1,000 Ernest Hemingways than one woke leftist soyboy.

  • @Storytime2023x
    @Storytime2023x 2 роки тому +2

    This is why it is called PRIiVATE life. You have no business knowing about it.

  • @heidithaw1072
    @heidithaw1072 3 роки тому +5

    Oh my. The man was an extraordinarily gifted writer. He was flawed as most of are.

  • @jamesbarbatano6016
    @jamesbarbatano6016 Рік тому +1

    My first step into the world of Hemingway was when I read The Old Man in the Sea back in middle school. At first difficult to understand, but, after watching the film adaptation with Spencer Tracy, I started to recognize how influential and interesting Hemmingway’s writing style was.

  • @mikeberry81
    @mikeberry81 2 роки тому +3

    For me, it is all about his writing, and that is what should define him and not gossip without his ability to respond. You can't cancel his impact on 20th century literature. Fitzgerald had a colourful life but don't hear much about him.

  • @rubberducky6411
    @rubberducky6411 3 роки тому +3

    There is a fine line between being famous and the dirty laundry that hangs on it ...

  • @aaroncrilly2005
    @aaroncrilly2005 3 роки тому +12

    Trust the art, but never the artist.

  • @codacreator6162
    @codacreator6162 3 роки тому +4

    Killing aspects of our history because they conflict with our current standards is ridiculous. I think the propensity to do so is largely driven by a general ignorance of history and attributing the attitudes of characters to those of their creators. We had to be there, to go through the horrible things we did, in order to get here. It's like trying to erase the legs of the ladder we're climbing behind us as we climb. Maybe Hemingway represents one of the most accessible examples of our history when our failure to learn the lessons of history will doom us to repeat it. Nowhere is the history we're supposed to learn from said to be limited to textbooks of historical events. The urge to "cancel" Hemingway is also driven by the ignorant notion that there is a risk in exposing people to examples of unacceptable behavior. If that were the case, we'd have to cancel art. Period. The whole point of art is to draw attention to and illustrate, sometimes celebrate and sometimes decry, the age within which it was created. Art is cultural history.
    If you are one of those that believes in correcting our past because you find it unpleasant or revolting, you might try learning how to place history and its art in context. Or isn't that something they teach in school, anymore? Cancel culture at its core is a cop out designed to end a debate before it even begins by calling out the cancelled as someone or some idea that doesn't merit discussion. But far from a demonstration of strength and solidarity, cancel culture is the bully, the 20-yard Tough Guy who punches the source of his disagreement. It is the refuge of little minds.

  • @angelboychanman
    @angelboychanman 3 роки тому +4

    Ken Burns and Lynn Novick are fair to Hemingway and are both likable, professional reporters. It appears that they came away from their project with a changed, deeper opinion of Mr. Hemingway. Anyone who has read about and researched the life of Ernest Hemingway are all too familiar with his flaws and his bedroom preferences and his contradictions. And they seem to understand that Hemingway's behavior is very unacceptable in today's world, but at the same time Hemingway did live in a different times. I admire their grasp of it all.
    A lot of artists/musicians/writers are more interesting than the art that they produce. Some art is more interesting than the artist. Infrequently, the artist and the art are worthy of our attention. Hemingway is one of the latter.
    It seems that the interviewer, Mark Whitaker, is only interested in amusing himself with the contradictory facts about Mr. Hemingway that run against the stereotype most associated with the writer. There is no appreciation or affection of Hemingway by Mr. Whitaker. He seems to be panting and almost salivating when he digs up what he considers to be paparazzi dirt and not the whole subject. His mindset is very much stuck in the too-current empty headed TV shows like "Extra" and the very half-witted Saturday Night Live of the past decades, and there is nothing universal or classy in his understanding of Ernest Hemingway.
    Whitaker didn't say anything or ask any questions to indicate that Whitaker had read Hemingway outside of required reading in high school English classes the night before a midterm. There is a lot of sophomoric, smug "nudge-nudge" that is beneath the richness that we usually see on the very fine CBS Sunday Morning show. His questions and comments are more designed to get something juicy on film rather than giving his audience something they didn't already know about Hemingway.
    Ernest Hemingway was a human being. A very good human being and a very bad human being. If one wishes to read about a perfect human being, then one is better off reading the New Testament, but alas there wouldn't be the interesting bits of cheese Mark Whitaker salivates over. And Whitaker might have to put some thought into his reporting in regards to the Bible. Thoughtful is the last word that comes to mind in Mr. Whitaker's interview. He seems to be only capable of aiming at the easy target. And missing.

    • @kevinreily2529
      @kevinreily2529 3 роки тому +1

      The "gaping wound" in this woke hit piece was not that he had so many demons but that they gloss over why. If this had been about a female writer, they would have spent hours going over all the damage his mother did to him in his youth!!

  • @fritzcat6198
    @fritzcat6198 3 роки тому +4

    Oh God, why would these people slime Earnest by dragging this legend into the 21st century social BS? How absolutely shameful. I stopped watching this channel years ago.

  • @seamuscannon4603
    @seamuscannon4603 Рік тому +1

    I find it hard to dismiss the fact that he lied about his age and eyesight to drive ambulances for another country, got wounded, carried another soldier, got shot, picked him up carried him further, got shot, and carried it further. Later on he went to France in WW2 as a correspondent only to gain command of a company of soldiers and charged the front lines firing. I wouldn’t call this “masculinity,” but bravery. I mean he survived two plane crashes in as many days. I don’t think it’s a façade that conceals his awfulness, but one part of a personality that includes true bravery, and truly inexcusable condcut.

  • @davidblegen5182
    @davidblegen5182 3 роки тому +17

    When I was in High School, I read everything he wrote... Books and Short Stories. I even crafted a painting of him in Senior Art Class! I worshiped him and his craft to draw in a reader from the very first sentence.... and then I learned he committed Suicide and my admiration faded for a few years.... Now, I believe he is the greatest writer of the the 20th Century! God Rest his Soul of Happy Memory!

    • @juanmonge8
      @juanmonge8 3 роки тому

      Drinking absinthe destroyed his mind. He tried to walk into the propellers of an airplane in Africa.

    • @bobthetroll
      @bobthetroll 3 роки тому +2

      My understanding is that he was in severe pain chronically after his plane crash in Africa. Maybe don't be so judgmental of suicide, not sure if that's a religious view but it's ignorant.

  • @alec187
    @alec187 Рік тому +1

    I think people are products of their time and it’s more valuable for us to have the ability to contextualize historical figures in that way instead of devaluing their accomplishments.

  • @zorakzoltan5816
    @zorakzoltan5816 2 роки тому +3

    Ernest Hemingway was a genius, cbs suday morning not so much

  • @shaynedurfee3341
    @shaynedurfee3341 Рік тому +2

    Look! EH lived in a different time that should not be judged by modern views. We are making a huge mistake in this world now a days by not recognizing this. Im sympathetic to those in this world who cannot see this. Hemingway was flawed? By whose standards? Are we not all flawed? I will not push my beliefs here or anywhere and only I can judge myself and decide if I was flawed or not!

  • @2godless
    @2godless 8 днів тому +1

    Sixty-one! The man looked 90. How is that living a good life?

  • @clairelowry9122
    @clairelowry9122 3 роки тому +1

    Mary was an award-winning war reporter.

  • @dalepointer9312
    @dalepointer9312 3 роки тому +5

    I want to tell a story
    That is all I want to do
    A good honest tale
    About this guy or you
    Simple but complex
    Easy to understand
    Characters that are alive
    Woman, child or man
    Simple clear stories
    One, two and three
    Universal stories
    About love and war and me

    • @vsrohit
      @vsrohit 2 роки тому

      Well done Mr. Dale :)

  • @TheOhMarty
    @TheOhMarty 3 роки тому +3

    I don't understand why his sexual preferences or were important to his story other then for commercial

  • @TylerD288
    @TylerD288 20 днів тому

    "Completely obedient and sexually loose" yeah, I like that.

  • @StriderZessei
    @StriderZessei 3 роки тому +2

    Watching this, I can only think about Randy Feltface's but about Hemingway's life.

  • @susanfabian1521
    @susanfabian1521 3 роки тому +7

    This documentary really hasn't changed my view of Hemingway.

  • @CooperBlumenthal
    @CooperBlumenthal Рік тому +1

    I beg PBS to look for another filmmaker than Ken Burns. He uses a template that is as interesting as one + one = ?

  • @seththomas9105
    @seththomas9105 3 роки тому +9

    Nobody should be "canceled". History shouldn't be "canceled". My God, what is happening to this country? The rest of the world laughs.....

    • @laurah6381
      @laurah6381 3 роки тому

      How is history being canceled? Go to a museum or a library and you will find history.

    • @soybasedjeremy3653
      @soybasedjeremy3653 8 місяців тому

      ​@@laurah6381I think he means attacking others and erasing history leads to history repeating itself. Reminds me of when radical Christians would book burn, we often called them pilgrims. The same is going on the Left side of the aisle, woke pilgrims. Such as some schools not teaching biology, or skipping over chromosomes. Even history. This is what I call woke pilgrims.

  • @billycharles
    @billycharles 2 роки тому +1

    Don’t worry sweetheart Papa wouldn’t take you as a wife. He didn’t like “Karens”

  • @dondoyle8474
    @dondoyle8474 22 дні тому

    Why do we want to cancel everything for the way things were at that time?

  • @keithjones7614
    @keithjones7614 3 роки тому +1

    Why did CBS end this segment on such a negative note? Hemingway was an amazing artist and an incredibly complicated person, and the documentary does a great job of exploring this. But to end with that quote after that question is disingenuous to Hemingway and the documentary. Not a great segment by CBS regarding the documentary or Hemingway.

  • @olivergrumitt8033
    @olivergrumitt8033 2 роки тому +2

    There has never been a person in history, famous or not, who was 100 percent perfect. And there should not be attempts to erase anyone from history because of failures in their personalities we all have. Even evil people like Hitler and Stalin, Pol Pot, Mao, Idi Amin and so on should not be eradicated from history. We must remind ourselves of them otherwise what they did could one day easily be repeated.

  • @danielmayorga4812
    @danielmayorga4812 9 днів тому

    Hemingway lived in action: bullfighting, hunting in Africa living overseas, smoking cuban cigars and loving several women. He lived as few men live now.

  • @MisfitsFiendClub138
    @MisfitsFiendClub138 3 роки тому +10

    For Whom the Bell Tolls is one of my favorite . . . .
    Metallica songs 😎🤘🔔

  • @lonestarsurvivalist447
    @lonestarsurvivalist447 6 місяців тому

    I'm really under the impression that the Dos Eques beer commercial man is based on Ernest Hemingway hence the slogan "The Most Interesting Man In The World."

  • @deadsouls72
    @deadsouls72 2 роки тому +2

    Ernest Hemingway - the pattern recogniser.

  • @2onefive
    @2onefive 9 місяців тому +1

    Posthumously going through someone's writing, lifting handpicked excerpts, then thinking you know enough about their sexuality to comment on it with a smirk on your face is pathetic. The man was tourtured by severe depression his whole life and still managed to create works that are unmatched. Maybe let him rest in peace without forcing a queer identity on a dead man because you find it salacious

  • @kaceybongarzone4977
    @kaceybongarzone4977 3 роки тому +3

    He was a creative man

  • @jamesnetwall1193
    @jamesnetwall1193 3 роки тому +4

    This whole thing where we go through and pick apart people who are no longer here let me just say this Hemingway was a flawed human being who managed to make it inspired me to actually love life and by my own hand at writing. And for those out there who are doing the picking, you're not perfect either not by any stretch of the imagination because you know what you're a human being and your birth certificate is proof of damage. Knock it off

    • @Pisnack
      @Pisnack Рік тому +1

      Exactly! You just know that the sanctimonious woman in the clip - that never produced anything close to the caliber of Hemingway - has all sorts af toxic traits that would be revealed if anyone did a hit job like this on her and her mediocre life.

  • @tylerbushong3452
    @tylerbushong3452 Рік тому

    Ken Burns: “He IS the seminal writer in the 20th century FOR Americans.”
    Fitzgerald: “Hold my drink.”

  • @philmolineaux7757
    @philmolineaux7757 3 роки тому +1

    ...lucky for us Erne believed in the printed word, (ie closed captions), like thousands of other TV stations ! CBS obviously can't be bothered.

  • @trevortodor5596
    @trevortodor5596 Рік тому

    I think context is important. A lot of people in American society in the 1920s and 1930s thought that was and spoke that way. You shouldn’t get a pass ; but the reader should know what the language was back then.

  • @dashd.b.c1891
    @dashd.b.c1891 3 роки тому +9

    He to much of a “man for 2021” so now u attack his manhood by saying the worse thing possible smh

    • @steveconn
      @steveconn 3 роки тому +7

      You didn't watch. It didn't, just explained his complexity.

    • @susanfabian1521
      @susanfabian1521 3 роки тому +4

      Perhaps you should watch the documentary before making a judgment.

    • @sunshine3914
      @sunshine3914 3 роки тому

      Such a pathetic comment... in so many ways....

  • @r1a1p1AllenPogue
    @r1a1p1AllenPogue Рік тому +3

    Attempted hatchet job fails. This agist cross-generational discrimination must stop. For his era, Hemingway was socially progressive. Trying to judge him by 21st century standards is evil. If you condemn Hemingway for being a man of his times, then you condemn all of your own ancestors. What is wrong with us that we can't understand people in their historical context without contemporary judgement?

  • @otoepony5813
    @otoepony5813 2 роки тому

    I was not a mature enough ready to really appreciate Hemingway when I was in high school. I've never picked up a Hemingway book since. I used to say I couldn't stand him. I think it's time I gave him another try. I think I'm ready now.

  • @welcometoskrabaczmanorvlog4418
    @welcometoskrabaczmanorvlog4418 3 місяці тому

    I guess I don’t understand why we never say toxic feminity.

  • @fighters5514
    @fighters5514 11 місяців тому

    Happy birthday 🎈🎂 ernest hemingway

  • @plumiish
    @plumiish Рік тому +2

    Cancel Hemingway???!!! What a preposterous idea!

  • @dondoyle8474
    @dondoyle8474 3 роки тому +1

    With genius come A curse madness examples Edgar Allan Poe, Vincent Van Gogh, and Tesla unfortunately I could go on🤔

  • @peter-johnb.newman6236
    @peter-johnb.newman6236 3 роки тому +3

    Saw the documentary and did not know how many concussions he had during his time alive. Ken Burns with another masterpiece. Peter Coyote’s voice is mesmerizing.

    • @kevinreily2529
      @kevinreily2529 Рік тому

      A woke hit piece on a man who was betrayed by women in his youth and early twenties… and never trusted them.
      Jesus, Lynn Novak, Ken Burns’ lapdog has no business putting Hemingway down for anything he did.
      It all came from what his parents and women did to him.
      Like to see their hit pieces on Famous Female writers who lied about their lives but were No Hemingway.
      Of course that will never happen.
      Hemingway risked his life in battle many times.
      What has she ever done other than complain she doesn’t get enough credit?
      Pathetic.

  • @FourEyedFrenchman
    @FourEyedFrenchman 10 місяців тому +1

    Oh yay, presentism! Imagine being so insecure you talk down to dead people who lived in another time and place we have absolutely zero firsthand experience with. Empathy is dead, condescension reigns supreme.

  • @MarkCartret
    @MarkCartret Рік тому +2

    These are mainly lies mixed with known truths. The fact is there is very little about Hemingway we do not know. His life was an open book. The truths here are mixed with fictional accounts of what today’s world wants to make a famous writer into. Hemingway had a Gay son whom he was openly ashamed of. That is a fact. Hemingway was not a racist, no more than George Washington was, but a product of the times…a cold hard reality of life back then. Yes he was an alcoholic and a womanizer who could only be monogamous when he was depressed or when he had diabetes and bouts of extremely high blood pressure. Gay he was not. I knew the Hemingway family for many years and read most if not all what is out there in the press, and the library, about papa. Those were the days when you could find some truth unlike now.

  • @danielmayorga4812
    @danielmayorga4812 9 днів тому

    she said: "afraid to pick up a buck" ???? or a book?

  • @marialongoria8774
    @marialongoria8774 3 роки тому +1

    His Mother dressed himself and his sister's in different sexes clothes. Him in dresses and his sister's in boys clothes.

    • @angelboychanman
      @angelboychanman 3 роки тому +2

      That's the answer to a question that will come up on the English test.

  • @dillonjohnson3106
    @dillonjohnson3106 11 місяців тому +1

    This new documentary should be “canceled” get a life and check yourself before speaking on a dead man from a different era’s personal life this world is turning into something we all will soon hate.

  • @AmericanDreamSeeker
    @AmericanDreamSeeker 3 роки тому +3

    This video comes too close to being a hit piece. MLK cheated on his wife....AND???? This is much ado about nothing.

  • @Dark-7070
    @Dark-7070 3 місяці тому

    A society that attacks the people of their time will be devoured by the people of the future.

  • @thomask9398
    @thomask9398 Рік тому +1

    The boomers in this comment section are getting out of hand

  • @AntonioAlves-wm8ie
    @AntonioAlves-wm8ie 3 роки тому +2

    for me !! Killing animals and controlling Women, Racist, and Putting people down !! He needs to be Humble !! as a person he needs to learn how to love himself!! Im not a fan of him at all

    • @macyprimm7201
      @macyprimm7201 3 роки тому +1

      His mother's observations about his character were spot on and he hated her.

    • @jeffjones1056
      @jeffjones1056 3 роки тому +1

      Oh killing animals is so bad you would rather
      Have animals die of starvation what does that say about your psyche

  • @thomasclark631
    @thomasclark631 Рік тому

    Hemingway, known to all, known to none. Among the few that death cannot remove.

  • @soybasedjeremy3653
    @soybasedjeremy3653 8 місяців тому

    I wonder if the people who did this interview ever read sbout him?

  • @charliehippler770
    @charliehippler770 3 роки тому

    I don’t know CBS, not feeling this one..

  • @DrinkYourNailPolish
    @DrinkYourNailPolish 3 роки тому +4

    Babylon Bee does it again with another humourous parody!

  • @swampfox8030
    @swampfox8030 2 роки тому +1

    I love how they skipped over his work for the KGB. Communist sympathizer.

  • @BGTuyau
    @BGTuyau 2 місяці тому

    Who knew? Artists and writers are complicated!

  • @kristofthibaud8491
    @kristofthibaud8491 Рік тому

    1:51--Hemingway is holding his hands too low, welcoming a hook or a right cross. I think I coulda clocked 'im.

  • @EagleTears
    @EagleTears Рік тому

    Pushing folks to higher freedoms

    • @EagleTears
      @EagleTears Рік тому

      Against blank insinuations in inadmissible passive voice

  • @nightengale7163
    @nightengale7163 3 роки тому +1

    Great documentary.👍