This is so beautiful and I love that Billie has grown up in the spotlight but knows when to let others have their moment... Never does she overshadow Phoebe's vocals, just complements them, because even though it's Billie's show it's phoebe's song. I love it.
@@akrobeau i think the main issue people have isnt the actual age gap, it's the fact that they knew each other while Billie was 15 and Jesse was 25- dating someone you knew when they were a child is a bit odd
I saw Phoebe perform this song at Conor’s bar (he was also present) in Omaha in ‘16 for about 30 ppl. Here there’s probably 30,000 ppl. Incredible to watch her grow.
@@SoScarlettItWasMaroon like the topic of the song… “you were in a band when i was born”… the whole song is about phoebe’s trauma surrounding an age gap relationship with an older musician
i need. need. NEED. this version professionally recorded and uploaded on spotify. genuinely for so many reasons, this is a supreme version of this song. the contrast between an older and more jagged, slightly numb and tired post-traumatic-experience voice like phoebe singing it versus the younger and sweeter sounding vocals billie brings to the table..... insane... made me cry recounting some of my own experiences. not to mention their voices are breathtaking on their own, but together?? absolutely ethereal.
@@ididntknowtheyhadwifiinhell I feel like her coming out and being like "everybody didn't know?" is A Sign this should have already happened. I mean. If she'd been in boygenius they would definitely have.
I NEED THEM TO RELEASE THIS! i’ve been a huge billie eilish fan since i was little and for the past year i have really gotten into Phoebe Bridgers. I’m obsessed with both Billie and Phoebe’s voices and songwriting.
I performed 500 shows starting in '79 and performed US/UK until I stopped cold on March 11 2000. Discovered Phoebe in '17 with Stranger in the Alps (thanks WFUV!) and saw her at Asbury Lanes in '18. I was inspired. Now I'm back, writing, recording and performing... I don't think this happens without the awakening due to Phoebe, her band and all of her incarnations with other players. Ironically, my next show is March 11 2023, 23 years to the day from my last concert and just 30 miles from where I last saw Bridgers. Phoebe, I don't know if you'll see this, but thank you.
This is so cool, I love how excited the crowd is and how excited Phoebe is. Going from being overwhelmed by this to selling out Madison Square Garden with boygenius less than half a year later must have been a trip :D Billie's voice is perfect on this too -- they have really complementary ranges, and I agree with the people up (down?) thread that she does a really lovely job of just letting Phoebe have the moment and pitching in. She seems 100% just as excited for her to be there and it's super endearing.
(Also there's this little moment they both have looking at each other with "you were in a band when I was born" that's just. clearly. ....women in the music industry having Gone Through It with guys who want to take advantage of them Solidarity. Which, fuck yeah. If a good thing can come out of that BS good.)
I cannot express enough in words that these ladies are my everything my two favorite musicians of all time on earth and I've seen them live in the past two years post apocalypse in the front row every time theyve both came to NY weather at gov ball in 2021 or at their own concerts in 2022 this past year,went every night they were here and I've always been in the front row sections feeling connected to them Ive looked into their eyes I love them so much I wish was there crying right now if I wasn't on a cruise ship contract as a performer I would've been there and I would've actually combusted I love them so much this means so much to me I literally feel like they're a cosmic forces now they finally sang together I feel like this is going to bring some sort of insane energy into the world ugh WOW I love them so much
I don’t know phoebe’s music that well, but this video, the energy, the pure joy, (and now, reading the lyrics) the continuing utterly confessional style of the lyrics, THE BLENDING OF THESE TWO AND HOW MUCH THIS MAKES SENSE, the reaction… it’s just beyond gorgeous.
Crazy, I remember seeing Phoebe as an opener in small venues around LA and SD in 2017 and now she's headlining venues like this, crazy how fast that was
I was prepared to hate this but this is a really fucking beautiful version of Motion Sickness. There's an intensity to it in the performance. Maybe because I can actually hear the lyrics and not just random squeals and howling like alot of live performance videos.
my brother sent me this. he knows i love billie and he knows i'm starting to like phoebe bridgers. after this video, phoebe is now one of my fav artists. guaranteed
when the song started i was tearing up after only a few seconds. phoebe's mellow singing and guitar playing, the crowd cheering and singing along, billie watching her in admiration, all of that together created such a beautiful moment.
phoebe is my favorite .. just love her whole being , she's badass ..best artist bar none , so natural she is gorgeous without even trying n writes the most stunning lyrics out there , oh n did I say she is my favorite !! The real deal
when i first saw and know phoebe i was like "damn this girl has a style like 2018-2019 billie that i missed so much" and now i just saw them on the same stage FUCKKKKKK
Like. If there was a song I imagined Billie covering and it fitting her Matrix vocals perfectly, it was any of Phoebe's originals. Lulls you into a trance.
Phoebe Bridgers is otherworldly. They both have the ghost in their voices. That ineffable quality I can't quite describe. Totally gorgeous
Very well said
great comment
oxymoron
Compare that to the likes of Drake and Bad Bunny. Completely different and 100 times more beautiful and honest to my ears.
Ethereal
Okay WHAT. I am viscerally shocked at how PERFECT Billie's voice is for this song?? I need an emo-indie-acoustic album from Billie now.
SAAAAME SAME SAME
AND PHOEBE WILL PRODUCE IT!
@Eric Mercer underrated song!
Have You listened to "dont smile at me"?
Also check this one out..lots of covers and acoustic stuff from her early days. Her voice is angelic ♥️
ua-cam.com/video/hWnrn7mTeGU/v-deo.html
I love how peaceful the crowd is, letting them sing rather than screaming over them
just look at the far right side of the frame
Agreed. Which is so rare at a billie eilish concert.
How does Phoebe Bridgers so consistently make me cry when nearly nothing else in the world can?
I don’t know, maybe mental problems?
Billie’s volume control on the harmonies is perfect
This is so beautiful and I love that Billie has grown up in the spotlight but knows when to let others have their moment... Never does she overshadow Phoebe's vocals, just complements them, because even though it's Billie's show it's phoebe's song. I love it.
Billie is a beautiful soul ❤️ down to earth so kind and sweet! So empathetic, but also so brave and strong stubborn woman! I love her personality!
i need a studio version of this, too perfect
its quite similar to the motion sickness demo on the deluxe album!
I forget how indie Billie is they sound amaaazing together
They should do an EP together.
@@droughdough OMFG YES
What does that even mean
i love women and music and togetherness
This is the comment
amen
same omg
how billie gonna sing "you were in a band when i was born"
Hahaha
My parents have a 10 year age gap and it’s a perfectly healthy relationship. Billie is 20 or 21 she can make decisions on her own
@@akrobeau i think the main issue people have isnt the actual age gap, it's the fact that they knew each other while Billie was 15 and Jesse was 25- dating someone you knew when they were a child is a bit odd
blaming billie for this is insane do you have worms for brains
@@akrobeau we don’t care about ur creepy parents love life
I saw Phoebe perform this song at Conor’s bar (he was also present) in Omaha in ‘16 for about 30 ppl. Here there’s probably 30,000 ppl. Incredible to watch her grow.
How tall was she then?
and now just played at the eras tour with 70,000 people!
Billie sounded absolutely stunning singing that verse, she did it justice! I’m obsessed with this
I’M CRYING, LEGIT TWO OF MY FAVORITE ARTISTS SINGING TOGETHER😭😭😭🖤🖤
FR I LOVE THEM
Legit same!!!! ❤
does no one notice the irony of them singing this song…
Wdym
@@SoScarlettItWasMaroon like the topic of the song… “you were in a band when i was born”… the whole song is about phoebe’s trauma surrounding an age gap relationship with an older musician
@@SoScarlettItWasMaroon billie is dating the lead guy from the neighborhood who is 11 yrs older than her
was wondering if anyone would have commented this
i was searching for a comment like this
i need. need. NEED. this version professionally recorded and uploaded on spotify. genuinely for so many reasons, this is a supreme version of this song. the contrast between an older and more jagged, slightly numb and tired post-traumatic-experience voice like phoebe singing it versus the younger and sweeter sounding vocals billie brings to the table..... insane... made me cry recounting some of my own experiences. not to mention their voices are breathtaking on their own, but together?? absolutely ethereal.
billie’s voice is perfect for this song oh my
Please do an album together. That had insane Simon and Garfunkel dynamics
That was totally my reaction
billie eilish fourth member of boygenius when?
@@ididntknowtheyhadwifiinhell I feel like her coming out and being like "everybody didn't know?" is A Sign this should have already happened. I mean. If she'd been in boygenius they would definitely have.
I can't believe I'm seeing Phoebe live in February. I'm going to cry my damn eyes out.
so??? how amazing was it???
I NEED THEM TO RELEASE THIS! i’ve been a huge billie eilish fan since i was little and for the past year i have really gotten into Phoebe Bridgers. I’m obsessed with both Billie and Phoebe’s voices and songwriting.
This is such a special musical moment. It made me cry for how beautiful it is :')
This song sounds so good with that harmonizing!
I performed 500 shows starting in '79 and performed US/UK until I stopped cold on March 11 2000. Discovered Phoebe in '17 with Stranger in the Alps (thanks WFUV!) and saw her at Asbury Lanes in '18. I was inspired. Now I'm back, writing, recording and performing... I don't think this happens without the awakening due to Phoebe, her band and all of her incarnations with other players. Ironically, my next show is March 11 2023, 23 years to the day from my last concert and just 30 miles from where I last saw Bridgers. Phoebe, I don't know if you'll see this, but thank you.
My god that's a lot of shows! Was it with a band or solo?
How did it go?!
Wow, I got chills through the entire song, what a beautiful duo
crying watching this from my room this is so amazing
Both of their voices make me cry so hard. It must have been amazing to be here
so i need this in a spotify version ASAP
This is so cool, I love how excited the crowd is and how excited Phoebe is. Going from being overwhelmed by this to selling out Madison Square Garden with boygenius less than half a year later must have been a trip :D Billie's voice is perfect on this too -- they have really complementary ranges, and I agree with the people up (down?) thread that she does a really lovely job of just letting Phoebe have the moment and pitching in. She seems 100% just as excited for her to be there and it's super endearing.
(Also there's this little moment they both have looking at each other with "you were in a band when I was born" that's just. clearly. ....women in the music industry having Gone Through It with guys who want to take advantage of them Solidarity. Which, fuck yeah. If a good thing can come out of that BS good.)
will always come back to this video.
I got to see Phoebe Bridgers concert last month in Brazil but God only knows what I would do to be there to see this live. I love them both so much🤍
love them both but interesting choice of song.......
I cannot express enough in words that these ladies are my everything my two favorite musicians of all time on earth and I've seen them live in the past two years post apocalypse in the front row every time theyve both came to NY weather at gov ball in 2021 or at their own concerts in 2022 this past year,went every night they were here and I've always been in the front row sections feeling connected to them Ive looked into their eyes I love them so much I wish was there crying right now if I wasn't on a cruise ship contract as a performer I would've been there and I would've actually combusted I love them so much this means so much to me I literally feel like they're a cosmic forces now they finally sang together I feel like this is going to bring some sort of insane energy into the world ugh WOW I love them so much
the guy who was filming those two girls screaming at each other 🥲🥲 so sweet
That beginning where billie harmonizes with Phoebe was gorgeous singing by billie
Nah i got goosebumps-
No one does it like them
Phillie-Album please.
I love Phoebe sm I just recently started listening to her and I’m in love with her music. Billie does her songs justice for sure!
everyone's reactions to introducing her 😭so sweet
man it makes me so happy to see Phoebe Bridgers and Billie Eilish on the same stage together, it almost feels like I know them both
The audio tho!!!! Amazing
I don’t know phoebe’s music that well, but this video, the energy, the pure joy, (and now, reading the lyrics) the continuing utterly confessional style of the lyrics, THE BLENDING OF THESE TWO AND HOW MUCH THIS MAKES SENSE, the reaction… it’s just beyond gorgeous.
Crazy, I remember seeing Phoebe as an opener in small venues around LA and SD in 2017 and now she's headlining venues like this, crazy how fast that was
Not me crying at these ghostly haunting harmonies! WOW!!!
tears. my two favorites singing this song. its unreal.
bawling
I LOVE THISSS
This audio quality is really great
Angels
How have I not seen that masterpiece until today ???
i can’t stop crying, this is what heaven sounds of
holy fuck billie sounded incredible here, what a pairing!
i didn't espect this two. I loved so much
I'm so sorry I miss that ....out of town!!
Thanks for posting!!!
Wow! Awesome duo. Great sound for a concert phone video too
This gave me emotional motion sickness
Phoebe’s voice!!!!!! Gah I need a studio version of this!
Simply... Amamos 💖💓🤩🤩🤩⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️❤️🔥
This made me immediately start crying wow
They both sound beautiful wow
Priceless ❤ My eyes water happy tears when I hear Phoebe sing. Billie is love!
Phoebe's doing a festival in NZ next year but I'm just months off being 18 so I can't go...would do anything to experience this!
Fake ID😊
@@userales my friend is doing that but I cant :'(
Two artists who take some incredibly ugly things and create things of beauty.
We need these amazing performers to collab!
goooooosebumps
watching this on the 25th, my favorite christmas present
Awesome duet. Can't really say enough about Phoebe. Amazing talents here on one stage.
Mystical ❤
I was there!!!
witnessing this live would absolutely destroy me
I was prepared to hate this but this is a really fucking beautiful version of Motion Sickness. There's an intensity to it in the performance. Maybe because I can actually hear the lyrics and not just random squeals and howling like alot of live performance videos.
Nothing but 💜's all the way down!😍🥰😘
BIGGEST CROSSOVER EPISODE OF MY LIFE
I literally love her so much omg phoebe is my bae
I loved every second of this girlies
my brother sent me this. he knows i love billie and he knows i'm starting to like phoebe bridgers. after this video, phoebe is now one of my fav artists. guaranteed
i cant believe i got to be there😭 so special
when the song started i was tearing up after only a few seconds. phoebe's mellow singing and guitar playing, the crowd cheering and singing along, billie watching her in admiration, all of that together created such a beautiful moment.
Ethereal ethereal ethereal ethereal 🙌🏻
I AM SOBBING I CANT DO THIS
Phoebe is just amazing. Wow
never in the short time left of 2022 WOULD I HAVE IMAGINED THIS
the perfect combo, two big stars 🥺🌟🌟
AmZing❤
I NEED A RECORDING SONG FROM THEM like this 😭
Fangirling hard here 🎶
phoebe is my favorite .. just love her whole being , she's badass ..best artist bar none , so natural she is gorgeous without even trying n writes the most stunning lyrics out there , oh n did I say she is my favorite !! The real deal
I know it's passion, but the sound of girls collectively screaming hysterically just sends shivers down my spine.
when i first saw and know phoebe i was like "damn this girl has a style like 2018-2019 billie that i missed so much" and now i just saw them on the same stage FUCKKKKKK
you’re so right, me too
Like. If there was a song I imagined Billie covering and it fitting her Matrix vocals perfectly, it was any of Phoebe's originals. Lulls you into a trance.
the irony!!!
This was the best night!!!
this was on my birthday and in my city i wish i was there
Love how Finneas is just sitting there and enjoying the show
3:04 goosebumps
So ironic them singing together this and Billie's bf lmao
My granddaughter needs to see her please come to El Paso Billie
I clicked this video so fast.
I would love to see/hear this with much better clarity. Great pairing.
i feel so blessed rn
my fav people ever
This sounds incredible!!