Farm Bills & Farmer Agitation | Myths vs Realities by Vibhas Jha Sir
Вставка
- Опубліковано 9 вер 2024
- Dear UPSC aspirants
NEXT IAS presents a new series named "Beyond Big Picture''. In this series, we will cover burning issues of national and international importance. The topics will be chosen selectively as per their importance for the upcoming CSE Mains from RSTV’s Big Picture Programme and others. The idea is to give more comprehensive and systematic yet, to the point information as per UPSC’s demand. This series will be a weekly affair.
One member of the best GS Faculty Panel of NEXT IAS will be the speaker as per his/her expertise in particular subjects like History, Geography, Society, Polity, Governance, International Relations, Economy, Internal Security, Environment, Disaster Management and Ethics. This series will help you to boost your GS and Current Affair preparations for upcoming UPSC exam.
The Big Picture programme is a pioneer debate and discussion platform in which many eminent personalities present their opinion on a particular topic or issue. We will be providing the summary of discussion so that you can utilise your time in the best way possible .
In this video(Episode 2) , Mr Vibhas Jha will be analysing the myths and realities of the Farm Bills and the Farmers Agitation. Recently, the Supreme court has announced a committee to look into these bills.
Three acts are :
1. The Farmers’ Produce Trade and Commerce (Promotion and Facilitation)
Bills, 2020
2. The Farmers (Empowerment and Protection) Agreement of Price
assurance and Farm Services Bill, 2020
3. The Essential Commodities (Amendment) Bill, 2020
Coverage will follow like :
-Factual Analysis of 3 bills
-Historical Perspective
-Pros (Potential Benefits )and Cons
-Recommendations of Committees like Shanta Kumar and its analysis
-Future Challenges
-What can be done ?
-Conclusion
Dr Vibhas Jha is a senior faculty of Economics (Optional) and Indian Economy (GS) at NEXT IAS. He is well known for his excellent conceptual clarity and presentation skills with an enormous teaching experience of over 21 years. He has guided a lot of successful candidates including top rankers. The topic was covered in RSTV Big Picture debate under the title of ‘’ARE FARMER DEMANDS JUSTIFIED?”
Why should you follow the Big Picture Summary provided by NEXT IAS?
1. Coverage is comprehensive and crisp.
2. Presentation is done in answer writing style.
3. Prelims related information is also covered in the summary.
4. Previous Years and Practice Questions are also included after the summary
You can download the summary of Big Picture through this link www.nextias.co...
NEXT IAS offers GS PRE CUM MAINS FOUNDATION COURSE for General Studies to give students an edge in IAS examination. India’s best GS team will guide you to understand this examination. Course has started from 7th January 2021 in LIVE ONLINE MODE. Offline Course will be started from 25th February 2021. Admission is open.
For more details, click this link www.nextias.co...
For GS+CSAT Course info click this link www.nextias.co....
To know more, visit: www.nextias.co...
Follow us on Instagram: / nextias
Facebook: / nextiasmadeeasy
Twitter: / nextiasmadeeasy
Quora : www.quora.com/...
Blog: blog.nextias.com
Telegram: t.me/nextiasof...
#Farmer_Protest #IAS #Big_Picture
Dear All
The summary of Farm bills and related issue can be downloaded from our website
Please click this link
www.nextias.com/news/are-farmer-demands-justified
There is no option to download the file we can only see the summary
Dear Prince
We will call back asap.
why the Batch column of registration page is not working , i am unable to register for this course. why no-one responds to call?
@@pammi99 plz choose session 2020-21 Live online ...If you are still facing any issue please let us know .
I want to know if Sir is Providing Indian Economic Service Course. Let Me Know Sir
One of the best teachers of economics.. still remember what he taught us in Vajiram. 🙏
Have you written upsc mains
Same here!!
So true mann!
Best economics facility
Sir please keep supporting
Ye vajiram me the kya phle ?
If teaching economics is an art then vibhas sir is Picasso...... 👍👍
Mrunal sir
90 minutes full of knowledge , unbiased calculations, teaching us how to make a good policy in future. Thank you sir.
Rightly said.
Keep watching and Keep sharing.
Not just a great teacher but a noble person. Wish you good health always🙏🙏
So true
He's so pure with heart ❤️
1:15:41 telling facts
Thank you sir for this unbiased explanation🙏
Dear Sahil, Glad you like it!
Keep Learning and Keep Sharing.
The legend! One who breathes and lives in Economics.
Vibhas Sir is a gem.A living legend of economics
I was dying to hear from you on this issue Sir. Today when this video was recommended to me I was elated.
I have never seen or met any teacher or human like you. You are one perfect being on the planet earth I try to be like you. You taught me in Vajiram.
Huge respect to you Sir.🙏
Glad you like it !
Keep watching And keep sharing .
I vouch for him. I was a student of him two years back. Every Indian should hear his words regarding the farm laws and make an enlightened view, irrespective of politics.
I am mesmerized by the way you explained the subject matter in a very holistic manner.Wish i could be in touch with you physically but at the same time i am proud that we share the same origin and may be same culture.I m also from Mithila region of Bihar .Thank you sir for enlightening us very pragmatically.Wishing for you a long life and fame .And one more thing I want to request is that you should believe that there is always an Eklavya considering Drona in you ❤️❤️❤️.
I am blessed that I have studied from Vajiram and Ravi teacher’s I will always be indebted to them Vibhas sir , Ojha sir, Parmar sir, Shyam sunder sir, Jayant sir, kapuria sir, Gautam sir, abbey sir, Atish sir , Pathak sir, brijendra sir and all of them. Thank you for teaching us.
We need more videos like this from vibhas sir.
Great initiative. 👍👍👍👍
Best explanation by our Bihari Babu Economist.....Proud to you sir
Vibhas sir has been the best economics teacher I have ever got to learn from.... Thank you next ias for bringing him on UA-cam...
Dear Devanshu, Glad you like it.
Keep Learning and Keep Sharing!
He deserves lot of respect how well he explained all things, veracity in his voice.
True! Thank you for the wonderful feedback.
Keep Learning and Keep Sharing.
One of the best economics teacher from Vajiram and Ravi. Sir still remember your lectures and discussions. 💯💯💯💯
Can't be more explanatory and factful then this. You are still an excellent communicator and teacher. Made me go back to my graduation classes.
Best teacher of NextIAS, GEM of economics... 🙏🙏🙏
I still remember he taught us in vajiram after the sad demise of Sanjeev Verma sir
Great teacher !!
Lots of respect.
Did you qualify upsc
That is how intellectual minds look...
Vibhas sir is just amazing. No one can teach economy better than him.
Yes! Keep Learning and Keep Sharing!
Very well explained sir!
Overall these reforms are game changers but amendments needed.
I hope now people can understand the reality of so called"farmers" opposing reforms under political influence, blocking roads and depriving citizens of their fundamental right to travel and liberty.
Good analysis sir👍👍
Thankyou sir..We need more such videos of vibhas sir
NAMASTE sir I wanted to say that you also don't know what a wonderful teacher and a person you are. Sir I am requesting you please upload more such videos at least current issues pertaining to economics like- Sri Lankan crisis is going on , Russia -Ukraine war is going on etc so I think we all wanted to know from you what are the impacts of these crisis on indian economy and global economy and recently you have uploaded lectures related to economics optional and in one of those lecture you have discuss little bit about - why turkey refuse to take Indian wheat. So sir I want that you should upload lectures on such topics. Thank you sir it is an request only
Dear Aspirant, We have noted your feedback. The Russia-Ukraine crisis has been covered in Beyond Big Picture ua-cam.com/video/a4CyyAeUlX4/v-deo.html. Stay connected!
Amazing Amazing video. Hope farmers protesting could see this once
I was a student of Vibhas Sir in 2018-19. He's the one who asked us to connect with him via e-mail and to my surprise he always reply very spontaneously everytime a query is asked via e-mail. He had the best vision on how to increase employment in India and similar analysis of topics of national importance.
You are coming from bihar. I am very happy sir . 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Love to see you on this platform sir !! Finally getting to learn from you even after Vajiram Days 😊😊 Hope you keep us enlightened by your knowledge and wisdom sir 😊😊
Thanku so much vibhas sir... 😊
Master of economics... 🙏
Most welcome 😊
Keep Watching and Keep sharing .
This type of understanding should be put in front of farmers, instead of scratching each others back.
Great teacher ❤️❤️👍👍👍👍..He is expert what he says comes in exam which is not a joke....
A big loss(Vajiram & Ravi) and a boon for NEXT IAS.....fortunate to have his guidance.
Thanks NEXT IAS for such a good initiative.
Very comprehensive and holistic coverage of the Bills. This discussion educates the people on the Bills.
Best analysis of farm bill n obviously best teacher of economic even in person .. thank u sir
For launching new education policy lot of debate and discussions were held in the open and everybody knew that new education policy is coming but for farmers act, nothing like that happened.
We can organise training camp for farmers , and who ever attends training camps will get a certificate , and when big companies come they can contact to farmers who r trained so , every farmers will have to attend camp and farmers itself become more aware
I really liked the video and the way information was delivered. Sir is so innocent in saying he is not political. Reason being there will be positive and negative sides of all policies but you have to choose your politics and that's what make a democracy strong. Anyway as a instructor he can be neutral but as a person it's hard for one to be apolitical especially for someone whom this act is directly affecting.
Anyway, analysis was very sound and thanks for your initiative and hard work ❤️.
Nothing like hearing your detailed explanations Sir. Miss attending your live classes during Vajiram days. Very comfortably, the best teacher who not only is knowledgeable but also knows how to convey things in most lucid way.
Dear Aditi, Glad you liked it! Thank you for your kind words. More videos of Vibhas Sir will be available soon.
Keep Learning and Keep Sharing!
And specially those jokes and sarcasms full of humour and knowledge as well. 😀
@next ias you have got a gem......vibhas jha
Thank you Sir for giving a clear picture of the bills. A Great Explanation as always. :)
My pleasure!
It was an honour to be ur student in vajiram.. Most intellectual and sophisticated teacher
Thank you for this helpful discussion ☺️
Your identity is beyond Vajiram and Next Ias..I had the privilege to interact with you in Vajiram..Love from Bihar..!!
As always bang on. Sir if you remember" isms are very dangerous". Couldn't be better than this.
Sir, the mandi fee that you defined is not paid by farmers but the the traders/Arhatiyas. This has been many times vaguely referred in newspaper editorials also, but as per farmers themselves they do not pay it, mandi fee is levied on the traders.
True that. At least in state of Punjab And Haryana Farmers donot pay Mandi taxes. They are paid by Commission Agents.
@@AbhishekLour @Jaspinder Bhullar yes the APMC framework is riddled with many issues as rightly pointed out by sir in the video, but the amended laws do make them more vulnerable to the private monopoly and further monopsony as visible in Telecom sector. Though the country benefitted in terms of expanded telecom infra but ultimately consumers will have to bear the brunt of fallacies of monopolised markets. Similarly in case of farm laws, farmers becoming more vulnerable and specifically S&M farmers do not have resources to fight against private players considering the redressal mechanism is via SDM court which is famously riddled with rampant corruption.
@@abhayvin1 brother first study telecom sector and then debate.
Ultimately who is benefiting from liberalisation of telecom sector- 1st is govt as taxes collection, infrastructure development and reaching grassroot level,jobs creation etc
2nd- consumers (you can compare service in terms of net speed ,call quality etc of bsnl and jio,which brought revolution in india)
I hope you can analyse
@@AbhishekLour absolutely bro.
But there are some andhliberals or modi haters opposing whichever scheme he comes with.
You can't wake a person up who is pretending to be asleep.
☝️This line suits so called "farmers" protesting or rather I would say blocking roads etc.
@@vaibhaavwaaliia buddy i am not engaging here for repealing of laws, reforms are must, i drew parallel between the sectors to guage impact of unregulated private entry. You can compare the impact of monopoly with rise of tariffs within a short frame of 5 6 years when jio entered. And taking the case of BSNL, govt didnt allow it to participate in 4g spectrum auction thus you can't compare the speeds since jio or for that matter airtel now majorly operate in 4g spectrum domqin. Anyway BSNL remains a strategically important company for us because aur defence communication(army airforce and navy) infra is by BSNL and thus it has its specific role.
Taking your points, govt in case of farm laws has brought welcome reforms only thing is framework has to be so strong that it doesn't become too costly for S&M farmers' livelihoods.
And i do have fair amount of knowledge about telecom sector + defence due to some field experience.
Thanks
One of the best teacher I have ever seen...@ vajiraam & ravi Delhi...🙏🙏🙏
sir loved the way you teach, cleared all the doubts
please make videos like this on the contemporary issues
keep inspiring us.
One of the best analysis and to the point discussion. Video gave a very holistic approach towards better outcomes both for the farmers and the nation as a whole.
Thank you sir.
Dear Akash
Glad it was helpful!
Keep Watching and Keep Sharing .
My favourite teacher 😊🙏
Wizard of Economics
One of the best explanation on farm bill ive heard so far... Kudos to the speaker for being neutral and putting the facts as they are !!! Wish ur suggestions are heard across by the govt and farmers and bring out necessary changes... N finally implement the bill to act 👍
Dear Janki, Glad you liked it!
Keep Learning and Keep Sharing.
Great initiative....thanx next ias...sir kindly, if possible , provide lecture on export related issues/ facts / data with different sectors w.r.t. global economy, GDP and 5 trillion vision.
Dear Gaurish
Thank you for your valuable comment
we will upload soon
It was best lecture i have listened to clarify doubts on recent farm bills👍👍
The best ...proud student of vibhas sir
Subscribed for Vibhash Sir ♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️
Please sir make a video on this year's theme of PBD ' Role of NRIs in Self Reliant India ' .
Vibhas sir is awesome.. He is very knowledgeable person..
Be it Vajiram or Next Ias it is always a pleasure to attend your lectures.. Thank you for such a simplified explanation. 🙏🙏
You are most welcome
Thanku sir...nice series...pls continue this type of series we benefited a lot of from your knowledge and enhance our understanding...
amazing sir ...brilliant way of teaching ..i really miss vajiram and ravi days .
Great insights about these farm bills
It is really a beyond the picture show.
However at 1:13:50 sir has interchanged the facts about perishable and non perishable items .
According to original bill govt will interfere when there is 100% rise in price of perishable goods like onion tomato potato etc. and 50% price rise in non perishable goods like pulses.
You always add value sir!
We missed the opportunity to learn from him. He should come to NEXT IAS before. Sir please write article to Indian Express. Anyway this still helped a lot. Hope sir will come regularly with these issues. Expecting some sessions on budget 2021 from him.
Dear Sharanya, Glad you like it. More videos of Vibhas Sir will be uploaded in future. Till then keep watching and keep sharing!
Please subscribe and press the bell icon for the latest update.
It was so nice to heed u sir after so long.. really it is so soothing.
Best economics faculty..!
He give all the insights plus approach to deal with subject and explains each and every term so that a non economics student can also.
easily understand.
Great teacher and equally good as a person..
Miss your classes..
Sir plz provide this kind of illustration on such complicated policies.Thank you
Sir... Why govt can't give a minimum price... And make every buyer responsible to pay atleast that price... Buyer could be anyone be it goverment Or any private player. Like MRP...
Search about the price of wheat international market you will get the answer
Such nuanced explanation. I wish I had found sir earlier😀
Thanks a lot sir, please bring more such videos.
Fantastic discuss 🔥, but sir I think MSP data was not fully correct,
Government only procure only 6-7% of total produce, So clearly government is not procuring more than 90%, but in there reports they are mentioning entire amount that is around , now it's very obvious that government can support farmers in term of MSP,
We are farmers , and this year conditions are very bad , paddy prices are at record low price last year it was around 1960-2000/quintal, but now it's around 1400-1500
Very nice series . Pls come up with more issues like FPI , 5 trillion, Make in India.
Very informative and wholesome video on the issue. Thank you sir for the video.
Wonderfully curated putting all the doubts regarding the bills at rest. Thank you so much Sir!
A genuinely good human being🙏
Amazing articulation sirji🙏
Dear Simmi, Glad you liked it.
Keep Learning and Keep Sharing!
Yes best economics teacher. Best analysis always
Farmers aur farm bills ka to pta nhi lekin next ias n badhiya nuksaan pahuchya h Vajiram ko
Thank you sir for enlightening us🙂🙏🙌
It's my pleasure
THANK YOU SO MUCH SIR FOR THIS VIDEO ....AND YOUR EFFORTS .THIS IS REALLY HELPFULL WILL LOOK FORWARD FOR MORE VIDEOS .
👍
Thankuu Sir ....we always need ur words on every topics...for better analysis
Great Explanation sir, best insights on this topic sir. Also sir the act says 100% increase in perishables and 50% increase in non perishables. Please check on this and guide us. Thank you sir.....
Sir this act was launched in Bihar as model act 2016 and it failed. Because the objective(more benefit reaches to farmers) with which it was launched did not reach farmers.
No doubt production increased but that was not the sole purpose of the act.
It means govt should bring a stronger act.
Thank you so much sir! This gave us an exhaustive and a balanced view about this issue. It was really nice to listen to you after such a long time. I hope we can expect more such videos in future! :)
Glad it was helpful!
With due respect 1. apmc and msp are different things. The apmc doesn't guarantee msp.
2. Govt procurement with msp is extended to 23 crops.
3. There is already provision in the act that land can not be grabbed under any circumstances.
Thanks Next ias ..
Glad you like it
Keep watching and Keep sharing .
Never had a teacher like him☺
Thanku so much sir
I still remember your classes in vajiram
Wonderful sir.....u are my inspiration.....thanks alot and belated happy birthday sir....my god shower all the love on you
Well teached in a simple manner , good initiative by next ias.
U are amazing sir
if crop subsidy= issue price-msp-cost of storage &transport then sir it would not be negative because issue price would be less than msp
Thank you sir... nicely explained.
Dear Aspirant, Glad you like it!
Keep Learning and Keep Sharing.
Very efficiently explained... Thank you for helping us to take a holistic view on this hot topic... Thank you a lot sir .. 🙏
Glad you like it.
Keep Learning and Keep Sharing!
Please upload these type of lecture
best teacher
Thank sir for this important lecture. I always admire your dedication to your students and the topics you discuss.
Dear Rishabh, Glad you like it!
Keep Learning and Keep Sharing.
Sir please make a video course on economy for first attempters who are going to appear for 2022 and how to get started with it.
Dear Aoishe, thank you for your valuable feedback.
We will look into it.
Keep Learning and Keep Sharing.
Really great.... Got no words to appreciate. What a clear n exhaustive explanation. I salute. Thanks a lot.
Sir do u have any such vedio on CAA and on Kashmir.
Also do u have any suggestion for those who can't afford huge charges for joining Current Affairs course 🙏🙏
Vibhash sir is the best.
Thank you so much for this great insight on the much heated topic...