He's such a smart and eloquent man with all the right logical skills to dissect this myth but still stops short of the simplest and most plausible explanation which is, as you said, that this is a myth.
cessna caravan Damned if you do damned if you don’t, that’s a predicament one often finds him/herself in Islam. according to Wikipedia, Daesh called him a murtaad back in 2016.
Please read this book written by a prolific Islamic Scholar Imran N Hossein on Yajuj And Majuj 👇👇👇 www.geopolitica.ru/sites/default/files/hosein_gog_magog.pdf
The only myth is what man have managed to convince himself of. And That is what he learned so far and sees, gives him the ability to to know the 99.99% what he has no knowledge of. Go back 100 years and tell them about making a device that connect u to China in seconds “an iPhone” you will certainly be told that what you are speaking of is a myth. And the next generation will also call what they haven’t seen a myth, and so on. Ignorance beyond imagination!
@@nabilelshukri There is much in the Quran that Muslims centuries ago did not yet have the concepts or language to understand nor explain. The passage of time and acquisition of knowledge proved the Quran true. I believe the story of guj and majuj to be one of those occurrences where time and growth of knowledge will once again prove Quran true. The time will come were this won't be a mystery to our descendants. All I can say is may God help them then.
I'm a Muslim but glad you linked to the original lecture Mr. Radwan, so people can watch it for themselves in context. That's proper documentation practice and evidence of honesty.
Even a highly educated and intelligent person like Yasir having tremendously hard time to interpret his scripture and ironically enough, Quran claims, "And indeed, We have made the Qur'an easy to understand"
It is easy to understand actually. This is a story. That is basically it. All the interpretations etc. people came up with in 1400 years are a different things and very vast in volume.
Please read this book written by a prolific Islamic Scholar Imran N Hossein on Yajuj And Majuj 👇👇👇 www.geopolitica.ru/sites/default/files/hosein_gog_magog.pdf
Pot Head have you heard Imam Hussein's explanation on Gog and Magog? Watch both part 1 and 2, ua-cam.com/video/QG-F3O584-0/v-deo.html From my Playlist you can also find a huge amount of evidence re the takeover by the Khazarian jews of global banking, political, media and judiciary and being the prime funders and initiators of wars between nations, diving and conquering over centuries. They converted from being phallic worshippers very shortly after Islam started expanding, infiltrating first the Christian nobility in the west through usury. Hence the Rothschilds and the 13 families are clearly the Dajaal/Anti christ at the top of their pyramid. And Gog and Magog are their many millions of zombie like materialistic minions in their Masonic and many other secret societies, corrupt religion, most media, government and civic institutions through which they control the billions in society.
Thanks for pointing this out. Really feels vindicating to see them openly admit what we were saying all along.
5 років тому+6
Qadir still cannot admit , openly , how ludicrous ,not only this but also other craap in the Quran is , from Solomon tales to conception, happening from the backbone to evolution . I wonder , does he already know Quran is false but is unable to admit , as it could lead to violence for him ,loss of livelihood, family and even death . We know so many who are secretly apostates , who don't want to be open about their views for fear of the repercussions.
Please read this book written by a prolific Islamic Scholar Imran N Hossein on Yajuj And Majuj 👇👇👇 www.geopolitica.ru/sites/default/files/hosein_gog_magog.pdf
I commented this with my other account too. I am an ex-Muslim young man . I am a Christian now. I live in Iraq. I am a Kurd. I used to be a very devout Muslim and studied Islam and Arabic language for a long time to become a Sheikh (Islamic Scholar). early in my life I began to have some doubt about Islam. For example how would the Quran deny Jesus's crucifixion when we have overwhelming evidence to support it, even outside the Bible. Why the Quran denies Jesus is the Son of God in every sense, when we have many verses that says so in the new testament. Why is God not Called Jehova or Yahwei in the Quran, especially when the Quran claim that it is from the same God who inspired the Bible. Why the Quran claims Muhammed is mentioned by name in the Bible and Jesus said he would come after him, when in fact Mohammed is not mentioned at all in the bible. Why the Quran claims it will be preserved and not change, when in fact there are so many versions of Quran (these are not different readings of the Quran, but different versions of the Quran). Watch or read Jay smith about that. You see the Kaaba in Mekka is the holiest place in Islam and the Quran says Abraham built it as a place of worship. When in fact Mekka is never mentioned in the bible and Abraham did not even go to Mekka. Why so much laws in favour of man and against women. Why is it lawful in Islam to marry a six year old girl. That is exactly what Mohammed did, married her when she (Aysha) was 6 and had sex with her when she was 9 years old. Why so many apocrypha in the Quran. Like the seven sleepers. see the Quran 18: 9-26. Jesus making bird out of clay, Solomon's bird and queen of sheeba. Why so much violence in The Quran and especially in the hadith (saying and action of Mohammed) like ordering to kill anyone who leaves Islam and killing every adult (in Islam about 14 years and above) on earth who does not believe in Mohammed and Allah and does not pray like what Mohammed taught, Quran 9 :29. Taking captured girls and women after killing or capturing the men and makimg them slaves, the girls and women also become slaves and are distributed among the Muslim fighters (Mujahideen). Muhammad in a hadith picked the most beautiful for himself. They become their sex slaves for having sex with willingly or unwillingly whether their husband or family still alive or not. The Mujahiduns can sell them in the Market. These made me doubt about Islam. I listened to many smart and intelligent Islamic scholars about the answers to my doubts and questions, but they were not convincing. I started to watch some channels on youtube that criticize Islam. Channels like (Act 17 apologetics, Islam critiqued, apostate prophet, Jay smiths videos). Their criticism matched what I studied about Islam. I knew it must not be from God. I thought about Christianity. I downloaded a Bible. I read it. I was impressed by Jesus's peaceful sayings, commands and actions. I found Christianity convincing. I watched so many videos about Christianity on UA-cam. I knew Jesus was the truth. I knew he was the Son of God. One day on February 2019, I raised my hand, closed my eyes and pleaded to God with all my heart. I asked Allah, if he was the true God, let him do something and save me from becoming a Christian. I stress, I asked him with all my heart. No response from Allah. Then I asked Jesus Christ to be my Lord, saviour, and my God. I said you are the way, the truth and the life. Come to my life show me something. In the midst of my prayer, I sensed an energy entering me. It made me feel happy. It made me sweat and fell heat (warmth) and love. At that time I did not know what it was, but I knew it was a sign from. Jesus. Later on I knew it was the fruit of the holy spirit. Now I like my life more, because I know I am a child of God, and not only a mere slave of Allah, as it is the case in the Quran. My life now in a way is more difficult. I haven't told my family yet. If I tell them they are going to disown me in the best case scenario if not kill me. At the end this is what Mohammed orderd Muslims to do.That's why I need to move to the West. If not I have to live among them and pray and fast like them and speak like them and praise Mohammed and Allah, and hide my thought and biblical views about Jesus, the Son of God. I ask you my brothers and sisters to pray for my family and every Muslim on earth to know Jesus Christ and accept him as their God, Lord and saviour. I hate Islam (because of so many of its teachings, including violence) more than anything that I hate on earth but we should not hate Muslims, they need love and caring. They need Jesus Christ. I want to become a peacher and someone who shares the Gospel to the world and especially to my fellow Kurds. You too can share the gospel and become a soldier of Jesus Christ. God bless you, every Muslim and every non-Christian.
@@lovepeople951 have you heard Imam Hussein's explanation on Gog and Magog? Watch both part 1 and 2, ua-cam.com/video/QG-F3O584-0/v-deo.html From my Playlist you can also find a huge amount of evidence re the takeover by the Khazarian jews of global banking, political, media and judiciary and being the prime funders and initiators of wars between nations, diving and conquering over centuries. They converted from being phallic worshippers very shortly after Islam started expanding, infiltrating first the Christian nobility in the west through usury. Hence the Rothschilds and the 13 families are clearly the Dajaal/Anti christ at the top of their pyramid. And Gog and Magog are their many millions of zombie like materialistic minions in their Masonic and many other secret societies, corrupt religion, most media, government and civic institutions through which they control the billions in society.
It's so amazing and miserable at the same time the capacity of our human minds to do whatever it takes to save our beliefs while pretending to be critical about them
Please read this book written by a prolific Islamic Scholar Imran N Hossein on Yajuj And Majuj 👇👇👇 www.geopolitica.ru/sites/default/files/hosein_gog_magog.pdf
If Islam is such a perfect and clear religion why are these people doing so many gymnastics trying to understand it, interpret it and reinterpret it, reinterpret is essentially changing the meaning as they go along?
Chetan Naik Chetan Naik Well brother, we always learn more so that we can reinterpret - this applies to science, art, etc. If you read the same book when you were 15 then 25 then 45 -> your understanding would change. The miracle of the Quran include: 1) no contradictions 2) science that was unknown 1400 years ago that we’re learning just now 3) grammar & style And so much more. I invite you to read it for yourself with an objective mind. Otherwise, it’s mental laziness or an existing bias against Islam.
Zatchooze Naut In that case, your reading skills are less than my preschool child lol. Truth is that you’ve never read the Quran because you’re too lazy or have hatred in your heart.
@@kevinsander8286 Probably you are Islamically indoctrinated not scientifically educated. Islam is wrong in stating supernatural creationism, borrowing prevailing myths in and around Arabia. Overwhelming scientific evidence points to natural evolution of humans from their ape like ancestors, not the result of incest in Adam-Eve's family. Just one of the examples where Islam is wrong, there are plenty.
@@kevinsander8286 Obviously, you don't see any contradictions because if there was one scholars like Yasir Qadhi will twist the meaning at convenience and make it suitable to current scientific understanding.
Chetan Naik You & your countrymen workshop cows & monkeys so don’t even try to bring science or logic into this discussion lol. As I stated above, folks like yourself are too mentally lazy or taught to hate Islam. Otherwise, you would read with an objective mind the science that Islam mentioned 1400 years ago that were just now learning. Also, the reason you think Islam “borrowed” things from other religions isn’t because it copied those things...it’s because God perfected his final religion for mankind. For example, He promised that no more religions will come after Islam - and he was correct. The only ones are localized religions like Sikhism. I will make it even easier for you. I challenge you too view videos from EF Dawn here on UA-cam. I reverted to Islam and it was the best decision of my life. Open your mind & your heart, brother.
Thanks to Dr. Quadhi for admitting that there are huge problems in the interpretation of some Quranic verses. It's true thousands of people (includes not only young but adults too) are questioning these verses and leaving Islam in droves findings unsatisfactory, silly and sometimes mind-boggling stupid answers or no answers.
There are muslim preachers who have built a career over this yajooj majooj fairy tale like Imran Hussein. Spreading fairy tales and conspiracy theories.
Please read this book written by a prolific Islamic Scholar Imran N Hossein on Yajuj And Majuj 👇👇👇 www.geopolitica.ru/sites/default/files/hosein_gog_magog.pdf
@Ornando Dijks Yes, his explanations make as much sense as those *illuminati confirmed* memes. Btw you may have been impressed by the word "eschatology" but it is basically mythology.
@@saifaljaaidi9280 brother , there was no need for that , you are confused in terms of turth , wallahi , if you open your heart and be sincere , and ask allah for guidance , wallahi you will get it , and i m not judging you , cause this could happene to any of us , just know there wwere shahbas who left islam , and came back after being honest and sincere withemselves , you may do , and may allah bring you back .
YQ said there is only ONE hadith that gives the impression that Yajuj and Majuj are still currently alive, and previous scholars have said that that hadith is weak, and therefore it is not Islamically obligatory to believe they are currently still alive.
It’s amazing he openly admits he doesn’t believe stuff. Poor guy. I feel like he knows deep down it’s all false, but his livelihood depends on preaching this stuff.
His livelihood and his life frankly. Even if he wanted to, he would never be really able to come out with disbelief openly. He'd be hounded non-stop given his relative fame..
Being an Islamic preacher isn't a good economic move, with the exception of very poor countries where the alternative is joblessness. He has multiple degrees and can earn much plenty of money doing other things. In the west, it's a choice you have to take seriously because you will have to accept that the rewards will be in the Hereafter, not in this life. It is not like Christian evangelicism. In brief, YQ said there is only ONE hadith that gives the impression that Yajuj and Majuj are still currently alive, and previous scholars have said that that hadith is weak, and therefore it is not Islamically obligatory to believe they are currently still alive. It's a quite simple issue when looked at it this way. They were alive in the past, and we believe their "children" will be alive/active in the future.
1400 Years since the Death of the prophet The companions of the prophet The 3 best early generations of Muslims The best interpretators and Scholars of the Holy Quran and Hadith The most authentic Tafsirs of the Quran The view of the overwhelming majority of scholars of the past and contemprorary scholars of Today. And finally 1400 Years after the revelation of the Quran , Yasir Qadhi , Or Yasir Qadhi's friend to be accurate has got the right interpretation of the Gog and Magog Story. Thank God for Yale University graduate , Yasir Qadhi for enlightening us. Shouldn'tThe Quran and Hadith be clear and not be revealed in a manner that it will be misunderstood for 1400 years ? is it truly possible for God to mislead his followers and the best and most pious scholars for 1400 Years and even the most respected scholars of the 21st century. Shouldn't the holy Quran be perfecty rational and logical. Your argument that things understood by consensus and established by majority of scholars may be irrational or illogical but we should accept them on faith as being beyond our understanding is weak and is the same argument used by Hindus , and christians when we question their beliefs as well. Yasir Qadhi is questioning the traditional authentic authorities of Islam.
"To struggle with the truth and then admit the struggle is a safer position than to invent something that is far fetched and then pretend that it is answering the problems." If better directed, it could have been as eloquent a refutation of religion in general as I have heard.
Why would Allah protect evil humans (Gog & Magog) that do nothing than spreading corruption and even preserve their lifes even when they don't have water to drink, food to eat and no sunlight... But then lets majority of his believers die a horrible death and doesn't protect them from the "Enemys of Allah"... What a merciful god! Protecting the evil people but not his believers ❤
Who really are the true Gog and Magog? The original and true prophecy of Gog and Magog is the 3000 year old prophecy from the book of Ezekiel chapters 38 and 39. READ THE TWO CHAPTERS FOR YOURSELF; It will be the difference between eternity in heaven and eternity in hell! This original account is 1500 years before Qur'an 18:94 and the hadiths and it makes far better sense than the tale of the two corrupting subhuman tribes found in the hadiths. Already, part of the prophecy of Ezekiel has been fulfilled! Manuscripts of Ezekiel were also found among the Dead Sea scrolls which are dated 300 years before Jesus and confirm the current contents of Ezekiel as genuine. I understand that it will be surprising for Muslims to learn that the hadiths misrepresent A LOT of end time prophecies especially from the New Testament book of Revelations (written almost 750 years before the collection of the hadiths) and in so doing placed Muslims on the wrong side of the future! The manuscripts of the book of Revelations from BEFORE Muhammad are still available today. Who are the original and true Gog and Magog? Gog is a RULER and Magog is his KINGDOM (Ezekiel 38:2)-like a Khalifa and Caliphate. Gog is the prophesied ruler of Magog. Gog is the real Antichrist (not the mythical one-eyed Al-Maseeh al-Dajjaal of the hadiths!). Gog/the Antichrist will be used by Satan in the last 7 years of the world to oppose the HOLY COVENANT (Daniel 11:28) God has with the nation of Israel (Deuteronomy 29:13). In modern terms, Magog will be the Antichrist's alliance of 10 nations (Ezekiel 38:5 or Revelations 17:12-13) supporting his satanic cause of committing a mass genocide against the nation of Israel because of Satan's hatred of the holy covenant God has with Israel (Ezekiel 38:8). The God who has a long standing covenant with Israel is the God whose name is the God of Abraham, Isaac and and Jacob, NOT Allah, (the two are not the same God!) because Allah seeks to commit a mass genocide against Jews in the end times (Saheeh hadith 2922) to the point even hiding behind a rock won't protect the Jews from being killed by Allah's forces. In Saheeh Muslim (2922), the Messenger of Allah said: “The Hour will not begin until the Muslims fight the Jews and the Muslims will kill them, until a Jew hides behind a rock or a tree, and the rock or tree will say: O Muslim, O slave of Allah, there is a Jew behind me, come and kill him". According to the hadiths, the imposter of Jesus Christ (the Islamic Prophet Isa) who is a Jew, will be leading Allah's armies AGAINST the Jews, God's chosen nation! Does this make sense to you? WHO ARE THE FOLLOWERS OF GOG AND MAGOG (THE ANTICHRIST)? COULD YOU BE AMONG THEM? The true definition of Antichrist is first ever used in the Gospels (which, if you believe the Qur'an, are confirmed as the eternal and unalterable (incorruptible) word of Allah and which Christians "have with them" (in the 7th century) and should judge themselves by: (QS 18:27, 5:43, 5:47, 3:3-4, 6:115 and 7:157). It's the Qur'ans dilemma! According to the Gospels, the Antichrist and his followers are those who deny that Jesus is the Son of God and is ONE with the father: "Who is a liar but he who denies that Jesus is the Christ? He is ANTICHRIST who denies the Father and the Son. Whoever denies the Son does not have the Father either; he who acknowledges the Son has the Father also." [1John 2:22-23] It is therefore a fact of life that the theology of the Qur'an and Islam is openly antichrist as it DENIES-6 CENTURIES AFTER THE EVENT and against the testimony of his Mother, Mary and the disciple John who were with him on the cross-that Jesus Christ was crucified (QS 19:91-92) and that Jesus Christ is the Son of God (QS 4:157). IF Islamic endtimes is FULFILLED, a future Islamic leader will be Antichrist because he will deny that Jesus Christ is the Son of God. IF Islamic end times is FULFILLED, Gog and Magog (the Antichrist and his alliance of nations) will certainly be Islamic in nature: an Islamic Antichrist, likely the Mahdi, and his KINGDOM (Caliphate)-a confederation of Middle East nations (but not limited to the Islamic Middle East). China and Russia? Maybe! The alliance of nations led by Gog will be set on destroying the nation of Israel because the false god of this world, who is disguised as the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob and as the god of righteousness and light (2 Corinthians 11:13-14), is set against the HOLY COVENANT God has with Israel. Why does Allah want to commit a mass genocide against God's chosen nation?
Please read this book written by a prolific Islamic Scholar Imran N Hossein on Yajuj And Majuj 👇👇👇 www.geopolitica.ru/sites/default/files/hosein_gog_magog.pdf
cessna caravan look, many Muslims don’t even go into the details... they live their life without over thinking, whatever they got in their Islamic school back home is enough for many, as an immigrants they put their kids into Islamic Sunday school here in the states and that’s it. I did it to my kids, they got scared and intimidated and confused but public school made them doubt and they just Americanized without practicing Islam line their parents want them to . I asked my brother in law how do u know that Allah is real? He looked at me and said: but it’s written in Quran... I don’t ask any more questions and hide my disbelief in Islam.
5 років тому+1
@@roxolanathor48 ha ha , Its clear to everyone now, that "allah " was just mohds alter ego. Allah spoke to mohd and declared him, the last prophet . Mohd spoke to allah and accepted being the last prophet . Zero witness , except Mohd telling others, allah spoke to him . its ironical, Allah spent so much time , talking in the quran, nonsensical stuff, that has zero value . If alalh even said, boil your water before you drink it. That very simple and basic advice alone, would have saved tens and tens of millions of lives ! yet allah was more concerned about mohds sex life !, then humanity as a whole
Why ask around? God is a conclusion each soul has to reach on their own. Look around do you believe all this happened randomly and that our existence has no purpose? Look around, can you see the details? Is this all in vain and our life should be spend only in us feeding nothing else but our ego? And if we were to live a fully materialistic life, who would profit from that and would that make us happy?
I’ve watched several of Yasir Qadhi’s videos especially the one regarding the Qur’an’s preservation. I can certainly tell you this man deep down is at the very least a strong Agnostic about Islam. If he listens to the many arguments presented by Ex-Muslims such as the Morality (Sex-Slavery), scientific inaccuracies (Sky held up by pillars that you can’t see) etc. He will become an Apostate. However I doubt he will ever publicly denounce Islam as he will receive too much hate, loss of his statues, maybe death threats, lose his career etc. It’s not worth it for him. But we all deep down know this man is an Agnostic maybe Apostate eventually. I’m an Ex-Muslim. I have finally left Islam, I just Truly can’t believe this religion is coming from God.
@@PeaceOnEarthandMercyMild Birth rates and leaving means being killed in a muslim country lol. Im in the UK and it means none of my family talk to me and my nephews/nieces aren't allowed to speak to me/their uncle. Because it fucking dehumanises you and people prefer to stay in the closet
not a muslim, but i have profound respect for anyone who shows such dedication to taking their text seriously. i can listen to qadhi all day lol, dude is sharp!
The fact that this man who is clearly very educated and intelligent, goes at lengths to make sense of this myth is sad, but this is what fear of falling into kuffar can do to a Muslim. The fact that he also goes at lengths to distance himself from the conclusion that it's a myth and that no one ascribe the quote to him for fear of reprisal is even sadder.
YQ said there is only ONE hadith that gives the impression that Yajuj and Majuj are still currently alive, and previous scholars have said that that hadith is weak, and therefore it is not Islamically obligatory to believe they are currently still alive.
Salam. YQ said there is only ONE hadith that gives the impression that Yajuj and Majuj are still currently alive, and previous scholars have said that that hadith is weak, and therefore it is not Islamically obligatory to believe they are currently still alive. They were alive in the past, and we believe their "children" will be alive/active in the future. If this was one of the reasons you left Islam, then at least cross this off that list. I hope one day you look at Islam again afresh.
Good morning Mr. Hassan. I am Youssef, an Egyptian teenager who is your biggest fan. I just had one question regarding your debunking of Islamic Miracles. How do you know that history is correct and accurate. How do you that the books of the Greeks really came from them. I would love to talk to you via email or Facebook. I love you more than anything and thank you for being amazing and lovely.
Yes it's important to always remain critical and ask questions about all such matters. It's then up to us to weigh the evidence and come to the best conclusion we can, while bearing in mind we could be wrong. For me personally I didn't lose my faith in Islam because of Gog & Magog or any individual verse or narrative. It was the cumulative effect of the various issues. If there is a God he would surely appreciate that people could have perfectly valid reasons to doubt Islam without it having anything to do with them being evil or bad people. My question is always, if God wanted us to believe everything in the Qur'an, why allow even the slightest reason to doubt them? Particularly when eternal torture is at stake.
cessna caravan What do you mean by highest incidence of mental illness? All Muslim countries are mental institutions from the time of Mohamed the epileptic, and schizoid father of Islam.
@ vice roy we know about the Greeks The same way we know about the pharaohs of an Ancient Egypt: history that was supported by the archeological artifacts!
@ Vice Roy You can read more about the historical method, I'd like to emphasize that the process is never about knowing with absolute certainty what happened in the past, but about trying to come up with the best possible explanation, and the most rational thing to believe in, given the evidence
Appreciate your question. What we read in History books may not be correct always..It can be adulterated. To assign to truth .. we cannot rely on history books.
I am learning a lot about Islamic Mythology by watching your videos. My teachers at the madrassa didn't touch such subjects probably because it was too fanciful even for children and as Yasir Qadhi puts it "problematic". I think Yasir Qadhi forgets that Islam is a "package". You cannot pick and choose from it in accordance with modern sensibilities.
@Hᴜꜱᴛʟᴇ Lᴏʏ ..I think you are the only fool sorry following the devil and he us laughing at you You think youbwre here on earth with no purpose how foolish is that Is that why people come to islam every single day educated people .doctors, scientists people whom know and study science
I had the same feeling when I watched his video about evolution - he accepts it because of the overwhelming amount of evidence, but denies human evolution because it contradicts the quran
So I just remembered one video of him too. Here's saying it quite straightforward, there's a line where you have to stop thinking. ua-cam.com/video/LhtCEUw5MKQ/v-deo.html
Thanks Yasir Qahdi, might aswell say whole notion of religion is 1 big myth. Once you entertain ideas by worldy academics, religion goes right out of the window.
But they could be behind a wall,in a icy region ,think logically they break the wall go to sleep,at night the temperature drops more freezing the wall again
Salam. YQ said there is only ONE hadith that gives the impression that Yajuj and Majuj are still currently alive, and previous scholars have said that that hadith is weak, and therefore it is not Islamically obligatory to believe they are currently still alive. They were alive in the past, and we believe their "children" will be alive/active in the future. Shaikh Hossein may be right, but every human can be right or wrong. YQ understands it how he does, there isn't anything wrong Islamically with either viewpoint. Check his latest video with Muhammad Hijab.
this reminds me of one particular story about the dajjal in which he is described to be (currently) living chained on an island waiting till the end times. I think it was narrated somewhere in Abu Dawud. - I looked it up and to my suprise its actually in Sahih Muslim.
That's crazy that the zombie theory makes more logical sense than classical interpretations. Also I find in interesting that Qadhi is the only one who seem to point out only one hadith, of all the ones they have on this topic, actively mention these tribes being alive and that one classical scholar pointed out the issues with this hadith. Like how has this not been discussed before that the tribes being alive somewhere until now became the mainstream view?
the hadiths like to make impossible mathematics at the end of time. both ya'juj & ma'juj and the difference of numbers between men and women both (according to the hadith) will have the same ratio which is 1:99. for every one man, there's 99 women. for every 1 human, there's 99 of ya'juj and ma'juj. after i discovered these hadith i started having doubts
Surat Al-Araf And recite to them, (O Muhammad), the story of the man to whom We gave Our Signs and who turned away from them; then ultimately Satan caught up with him and he was led astray. Now, had We so willed We could indeed have exalted him through those Signs, but he clung to earthly life and followed his carnal desires. Thus his parable is that of the dog who lolls out his tongue whether you attack him or leave him alone. Such is the parable of those who reject Our Signs as false. Narrate to them these parables that they may reflect. 7:174-175
I like his sincerity but his conclusion is just irrationnel. "I believe in them because the coran says so" even if you find it complety irrationnel and incoherent ?
Thanks for sharing. As someone who knows very little of Islam (I've focused more on Christianity and faith in general) it is surprising to me exactly which goofy myths are defended in this religion.
boulderdennis Please read this book written by a prolific Islamic Scholar Imran N Hossein on Yajuj And Majuj 👇👇👇 www.geopolitica.ru/sites/default/files/hosein_gog_magog.pdf
I find it astonishing that he finds THIS piece of islamic tradition as the most problematic when there are countless examples of more ridiculous stories and pieces of information that stand no logical ground at all. But to be fair, it's very rare to see any muslim leader to apply logic to his religion and criticize it in any way, so kudos to Yasir.
Please read this book written by a prolific Islamic Scholar Imran N Hossein on Yajuj And Majuj 👇👇👇 www.geopolitica.ru/sites/default/files/hosein_gog_magog.pdf
YQ said there is only ONE hadith that gives the impression that Yajuj and Majuj are still currently alive, and previous scholars have said that that hadith is weak, and therefore it is not Islamically obligatory to believe they are currently still alive. Salam.
The problem with todays scholars is they want to explain everything literally.. And forget one thing we have limitations.. our vision, frequency limit in our hearing etc...
@@HassanRadwan133 Fair enough! I very randomly come across your videos that I'd seen several years ago and always enjoyed them. Hope you're doing well whatever you're up to these days anyway :)
@@HassanRadwan133 Dear Hassan Radwan, are your children and wife still Muslim? And sorry for what happened with you, I have just read your biography on Medium website.
Hi Hassan Radwan Any updates on meeting mufti Abu layth ? It would be nice to discuss the quran with mufti abu layth. Alot of the other ex muslims seemed very hesitant to discuss the mistakes in the quran with mufti Abu layth but started off with prove God exist and how do you know Islam is the truth. It would be nice to see you discussing with mufti abu layth the CLEAR CUT mistakes and the verses that goes against the voice of reason with mufti abu layth. Love and peace to you all!
Sheikh Imran hossein has ably explained the phenomenon of Yajuj wa Majuj and made it clear that classical scholarship cannot penetrate the verses of the Quran and hadith and deliver the interpretation.
I'm subscribed to and have watched Sheikh Imran Hosein's videos on this topic But who really are the true Gog and Magog? The original and true prophecy of Gog and Magog is the 3000 year old prophecy from the book of Ezekiel chapters 38 and 39. READ THE TWO CHAPTERS FOR YOURSELF; It will be the difference between eternity in heaven and eternity in hell! This original account is 1500 years before Qur'an 18:94 and the hadiths and it makes far better sense than the tale of the two corrupting subhuman tribes found in the hadiths. Already, part of the prophecy of Ezekiel has been fulfilled! Manuscripts of Ezekiel were also found among the Dead Sea scrolls which are dated 300 years before Jesus and confirm the current contents of Ezekiel as genuine. I understand that it will be surprising for Muslims to learn that the hadiths misrepresent A LOT of end time prophecies especially from the New Testament book of Revelations (written almost 750 years before the collection of the hadiths) and in so doing placed Muslims on the wrong side of the future! The manuscripts of the book of Revelations from BEFORE Muhammad are still available today. Who are the original and true Gog and Magog? Gog is a RULER and Magog is his KINGDOM (Ezekiel 38:2)-like a Khalifa and Caliphate. Gog is the prophesied ruler of Magog. Gog is the real Antichrist (not the mythical one-eyed Al-Maseeh al-Dajjaal of the hadiths!). Gog/the Antichrist will be used by Satan in the last 7 years of the world to oppose the HOLY COVENANT (Daniel 11:28) God has with the nation of Israel (Deuteronomy 29:13). In modern terms, Magog will be the Antichrist's alliance of 10 nations (Ezekiel 38:5 or Revelations 17:12-13) supporting his satanic cause of committing a mass genocide against the nation of Israel because of Satan's hatred of the holy covenant God has with Israel (Ezekiel 38:8). The God who has a long standing covenant with Israel is the God whose name is the God of Abraham, Isaac and and Jacob, NOT Allah, (the two are not the same God!) because Allah seeks to commit a mass genocide against Jews in the end times (Saheeh hadith 2922) to the point even hiding behind a rock won't protect the Jews from being killed by Allah's forces. In Saheeh Muslim (2922), the Messenger of Allah said: “The Hour will not begin until the Muslims fight the Jews and the Muslims will kill them, until a Jew hides behind a rock or a tree, and the rock or tree will say: O Muslim, O slave of Allah, there is a Jew behind me, come and kill him". According to the hadiths, the imposter of Jesus Christ (the Islamic Prophet Isa) who is a Jew, will be leading Allah's armies AGAINST the Jews, God's chosen nation! Does this make sense to you? WHO ARE THE FOLLOWERS OF GOG AND MAGOG (THE ANTICHRIST)? COULD YOU BE AMONG THEM? The true definition of Antichrist is first ever used in the Gospels (which, if you believe the Qur'an, are confirmed as the eternal and unalterable (incorruptible) word of Allah and which Christians "have with them" (in the 7th century) and should judge themselves by: (QS 18:27, 5:43, 5:47, 3:3-4, 6:115 and 7:157). It's the Qur'ans dilemma! According to the Gospels, the Antichrist and his followers are those who deny that Jesus is the Son of God and is ONE with the father: "Who is a liar but he who denies that Jesus is the Christ? He is ANTICHRIST who denies the Father and the Son. Whoever denies the Son does not have the Father either; he who acknowledges the Son has the Father also." [1John 2:22-23] It is therefore a fact of life that the theology of the Qur'an and Islam is openly antichrist as it DENIES-6 CENTURIES AFTER THE EVENT and against the testimony of his Mother, Mary and the disciple John who were with him on the cross-that Jesus Christ was crucified (QS 19:91-92) and that Jesus Christ is the Son of God (QS 4:157). IF Islamic endtimes is FULFILLED, a future Islamic leader will be Antichrist because he will deny that Jesus Christ is the Son of God. IF Islamic end times is FULFILLED, Gog and Magog (the Antichrist and his alliance of nations) will certainly be Islamic in nature: an Islamic Antichrist, likely the Mahdi, and his KINGDOM (Caliphate)-a confederation of Middle East nations (but not limited to the Islamic Middle East). China and Russia? Maybe! The alliance of nations led by Gog will be set on destroying the nation of Israel because the false god of this world, who is disguised as the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob and as the god of righteousness and light (2 Corinthians 11:13-14), is set against the HOLY COVENANT God has with Israel. Why does Allah want to commit a mass genocide against God's chosen nation?
While he watched the zombie movie, Can some one please tell him to watch a movie called “the wonder women” then he will know if they existed some where or not.
As a former Christian it pains me to see him doing this. I copped pleas for Adam, Noah and his impossible flood, Abraham Isaac, Jacob, Joshua and Water walking Jesus. It’s best to just let legends be legends. Why defend the indefensible??
Quranic story is simple. Some people asked Dhul Qarnain to build a wall to protect them from yajuj majuj. Someday they will be back ..... I dont think a muslim is required to believe anything more than that.
omer ali exactly, I really don’t see a problem, anything after that is up to interpretation, its not like this is a pillar of out faith, only something concerning the end days
I am muslim and yet I will say your response is very weak. As Yasir Qadhi rightly points, where are they on earth? they were not two people, they were a nation, a nation that is supposedly alive and will come back, from where? the whole earth has been mapped.
tbh I think the only reason he allows his cognitive dissonance to overflow his logical reasoning is simply because he's invested too much into Islam to leave it now. Also its not as simple as leaving any other religion. if you leave Islam, you lose everything, your family, friends and most likely if youre a scholar, your job.
Friend, Qhadi has a point! Who really are the true Gog and Magog? The original and true prophecy of Gog and Magog is the 3000 year old prophecy from the book of Ezekiel chapters 38 and 39. READ THE TWO CHAPTERS FOR YOURSELF; It will be the difference between eternity in heaven and eternity in hell! This original account is 1500 years before Qur'an 18:94 and the hadiths and it makes far better sense than the tale of the two corrupting subhuman tribes found in the hadiths. Already, part of the prophecy of Ezekiel has been fulfilled! Manuscripts of Ezekiel were also found among the Dead Sea scrolls which are dated 300 years before Jesus and confirm the current contents of Ezekiel as genuine. I understand that it will be surprising for Muslims to learn that the hadiths misrepresent A LOT of end time prophecies especially from the New Testament book of Revelations (written almost 750 years before the collection of the hadiths) and in so doing placed Muslims on the wrong side of the future! The manuscripts of the book of Revelations from BEFORE Muhammad are still available today. Who are the original and true Gog and Magog? Gog is a RULER and Magog is his KINGDOM (Ezekiel 38:2)-like a Khalifa and Caliphate. Gog is the prophesied ruler of Magog. Gog is the real Antichrist (not the mythical one-eyed Al-Maseeh al-Dajjaal of the hadiths!). Gog/the Antichrist will be used by Satan in the last 7 years of the world to oppose the HOLY COVENANT (Daniel 11:28) God has with the nation of Israel (Deuteronomy 29:13). In modern terms, Magog will be the Antichrist's alliance of 10 nations (Ezekiel 38:5 or Revelations 17:12-13) supporting his satanic cause of committing a mass genocide against the nation of Israel because of Satan's hatred of the holy covenant God has with Israel (Ezekiel 38:8). The God who has a long standing covenant with Israel is the God whose name is the God of Abraham, Isaac and and Jacob, NOT Allah, (the two are not the same God!) because Allah seeks to commit a mass genocide against Jews in the end times (Saheeh hadith 2922) to the point even hiding behind a rock won't protect the Jews from being killed by Allah's forces. In Saheeh Muslim (2922), the Messenger of Allah said: “The Hour will not begin until the Muslims fight the Jews and the Muslims will kill them, until a Jew hides behind a rock or a tree, and the rock or tree will say: O Muslim, O slave of Allah, there is a Jew behind me, come and kill him". According to the hadiths, the imposter of Jesus Christ (the Islamic Prophet Isa) who is a Jew, will be leading Allah's armies AGAINST the Jews, God's chosen nation! Does this make sense to you? WHO ARE THE FOLLOWERS OF GOG AND MAGOG (THE ANTICHRIST)? COULD YOU BE AMONG THEM? The true definition of Antichrist is first ever used in the Gospels (which, if you believe the Qur'an, are confirmed as the eternal and unalterable (incorruptible) word of Allah and which Christians "have with them" (in the 7th century) and should judge themselves by: (QS 18:27, 5:43, 5:47, 3:3-4, 6:115 and 7:157). It's the Qur'ans dilemma! According to the Gospels, the Antichrist and his followers are those who deny that Jesus is the Son of God and is ONE with the father: "Who is a liar but he who denies that Jesus is the Christ? He is ANTICHRIST who denies the Father and the Son. Whoever denies the Son does not have the Father either; he who acknowledges the Son has the Father also." [1John 2:22-23] It is therefore a fact of life that the theology of the Qur'an and Islam is openly antichrist as it DENIES-6 CENTURIES AFTER THE EVENT and against the testimony of his Mother, Mary and the disciple John who were with him on the cross-that Jesus Christ was crucified (QS 19:91-92) and that Jesus Christ is the Son of God (QS 4:157). IF Islamic endtimes is FULFILLED, a future Islamic leader will be Antichrist because he will deny that Jesus Christ is the Son of God. IF Islamic end times is FULFILLED, Gog and Magog (the Antichrist and his alliance of nations) will certainly be Islamic in nature: an Islamic Antichrist, likely the Mahdi, and his KINGDOM (Caliphate)-a confederation of Middle East nations (but not limited to the Islamic Middle East). China and Russia? Maybe! The alliance of nations led by Gog will be set on destroying the nation of Israel because the false god of this world, who is disguised as the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob and as the god of righteousness and light (2 Corinthians 11:13-14), is set against the HOLY COVENANT God has with Israel. Why does Allah want to commit a mass genocide against God's chosen nation?
It does have definitive correct answer even though, as always when religion is mixed in, the arguments will never cease and even the correct definitive answer will usually be ignored or rejected because it is only accepted by the few who are intellectually free. Ya'juj and Ma'juj have long since "escaped" ... the barrier has long since served its purpose ... they have long since spread out, living their lives. They are normal people, historically known, and their descendants are living among us as Muslims, Christians, Buddists, atheists, etc. They have countries that still bear their names because of historical association (Ya'juj = Of Juj = Of Gorg = Georgia, and Mongolia = the land of Ma'juj/Magog), they have had great leaders, like Genghis Khan, and have invaded, conquered and had their days of Empire like many others before and after them. But those who are easily bedazzled and swayed by fairytales and myths and ridiculous made-up prophecies will continue to be confused and continue to argue. Set religion aside, think like a historian, and it's clear as daylight.
"intellectually free"?? If you are genuinely open to *all* possibilities, - including the possibility the Qur'an is man-made and contains myths - I would agree with you. But tell me honestly, are you genuinely open to that possibility? Or is your starting point a firm conviction that it is the word of God? If the latter then that's not "intellectually free".
@@HassanRadwan133 Yes I believe I am open to that possibility; I have considered it, still consider it, will continue to consider it. Just like other things. Who wants to believe or be tricked into a falsehood? Do you think it isn't impossible that someone who is intellectually free (relatively speaking of course, because we all ultimately rely on others' works) can be firmly convinced of the Qur'an or of the existence of God? But really I was just talking about this story which the Qur'an relates (according to its internal narrative) upon request rather than spontaneously. So it was known, it was a part of history up to that point (whether factual or not). Stories and HIStories are transmitted from earlier times. You don't need to believe in God or that the Qur'an is from God to see clearly who Ya'juj and Ma'juj were/are. You just need to follow the his-tory and be free of the surrounding myths that developed post-Qur'an. That's all I was really getting at. If these later post-Qur'anic myths and end-of-times tales are added to something that its core is factual or itself a myth is something else. Is the story of Alexander the Great's building of the Caspian Gates true or man-made? I have no reason to doubt it is true.
Dr Yasir said that Gog and Magog can't survive in cave. Fact : A cave in Romania about 5 millions year old have its own ecosystem. What if Allah is sustaining them ?
Salam. YQ said there is only ONE hadith that gives the impression that Yajuj and Majuj are still currently alive, and previous scholars have said that that hadith is weak, and therefore it is not Islamically obligatory to believe they are currently still alive. They were alive in the past, and we believe their "children" will be alive/active in the future. Shaikh Hossein may be right, but every human can be right or wrong. YQ understands it how he does, there isn't anything wrong Islamically with either viewpoint. Check his latest video with Muhammad Hijab.
Thank you Hassan, Another great video to pointed out that the words of Allah in the Qur'an are more confusing and doesn't make sense to me gradually.. It is really hurts me in a way that i am a devoted muslim for 40 plus year..
I have a long comment for this video. I hope you will read it until the end. I agree with you that their explanation sounds sometimes like a fairy-tale and myth, and unfortunately, not well researched. But I have to say that the story of Dhul-Qarnayn in Quran is one of my favourite. I will explain you why. Dhul-Qarnayn was a very just and powerful ruler who was not an oppressor. (He might be Cyrus the Great or Darius the Great or another character from the history. I read their biographies. There are some parallels.) No matter who he was, the point is that he didn't oppress people he ruled and treated them very well (see surah Al-Kahf). And even helped people to escape the oppression of a very cruel tribe (who were mostly thieves, rapists, cannibals). According to my research, the oppressed people were ancestors of nowadays Georgians, the so called Colchian or/and Iberians living near the Caucasus mountains and speaking Kartvellian language, very different from other languages of the surrounding areas (it is also referenced in the surah Al-Kahf). If you look at the Caucasus mountains there is one narrow pass in the middle called Darial Gorge (there is also another pass called Derbent pass but it is located near Caspian sea far from Georgians). According to my research the massive Iron wall was built on the Darial Gorge between two mountains (This place has a lot of iron ores). It made ancestors of Georgians feel safe for centuries (this is not an uncommon practice in the history - Great Wall of China against various nomadic groups from the Eurasian Steppe, Trump wanted to build a wall to "save" US from Mexican immigrants). The oppressors were according to my research Skythians or their descendents Khazars. In one of Georgian mythologies, ancestors of Georgians who were suffering from the attacks of Khazars were describing them as Gog and Magog and saying that they were thieves, cruel like beasts and ate human flesh. I checked all kind of sources from the history to get this information together (I can give you sources if you are interested to read). When the Iron wall was removed (I couldn't find exactly when it might happen. Maybe some time between 8th or 12th century.) In one of the Hadith, it is mentioned that they said "inshaAllah" short before the Wall was destroyed. It can refer to the event when they started practicing one of the monotheistic religions (Judaism). According to the historical sources, rulers of this tribe accepted this religion for political reasons (you can read more details in the book of "Thirteenth Tribe" by Arthur Koestler, the author is Jewish himself). The commoners as it normally happens in the history took the religion very seriously and started practicing it in their life (similar to Romans, when Constantin embraced Christianity because of the politics, after a while the commoners became very religious Christians). One of the belief of Judaism is that Jews are not allowed to have their own state. That is why, sticking strictly to the laws of Torah, they stopped being a state and spread around the globe. Most of the Jews nowadays are white and originating from Caucasus mountains (see the Book 13th Tribe by Koestler, as I mentioned above the author himself is Jewish and did a very good research on the history of Khazars, I recommend you to read it). The Elites of this tribe has always played a big role in the history of mankind, probably starting to be very relevant during the European colonisation of the world (or earlier). The colonialists were taking away resources, damaging the environment, causing poverty and bringing their own system in these regions which didn't always benefit the indigenous people (do you see parallels with the description of Gog and Magog? They were oppressing common people which is the opposite of how Dhul-Qarnayn was ruling). Last few centuries, the elites of this tribe were behind the most of the big wars (Napoleon's battle of Waterloo, World Wars etc.). The main function of wars was/is to destroy the existing system and establish a new system which profits the elites. You can read this from different historical sources. In fact, the west ruled by the elites of this tribe is still taking away valuable resources from the third world countries. Banking system with currency inflation and interest rates is making people poor every day. Most of the people are not informed or ignorant of what is going on in the World because the system is so complex and there are so many distractions like social media, games, movies etc. We don't have time to do the real research. Media also influences our view of the world. We cannot deny this anymore. What was not normal before, is normalised with the influence of the media, be it habits, our desires etc. For example, COVID became number one star within few days because of the media and is still popular for about 1.5 years. This is just one example. And there are many. I did this research for a long time using different sources to verify my findings. Of course, I am not 100% sure if this is true. But based on everything I read until now, it makes the most sense. I am not done with my readings yet and my views might change with time. Since you also like diving deep into the scientific and historical books, I thought maybe my views and conclusions will also be food for thought for you. Happy weekend :)
@@HassanRadwan133unbelievable what he is talking in this video whereas there are so many tafsirs and history books which give a better, reasonable and historical explanation on Yajuj and Majuj. Sounds like he watched too many Hollywood/marvel movies :( I also watched other videos on this topic, and I am more than disappointed. The quality of information regarding the important topics in Quran on UA-cam is so low (be it miracles, historical events). Since youtube/internet is mostly an only source that youth is using to learn about Islam, so disappointing that these scholars neglect their responsibility and don't do a proper research. I hope that they will watch your videos and reflect on themselves..
Thank you very much for your kind words and unparalleled wisdom. What you said is what I have come across exactly with little differences. The problem of many of us Muslims is that we don't do research and read the Quran and hadith as it is supposed to be. In the end we look intellectually deficient and challenged. Yajuj wa Majuj are already out and in full control of the entire political, economic, financial institutions across the globe. I quote Samuel P Huntington's clash of civilizations and Remaking of World Order on pages 81and 82 and he says about the Western civilization in general : They 1. Own and operate the international banking system 2. Control all hard currencies 3. Are the world's principal customers 4. Provide the majority of the world's finished goods 5. Dominate international capital markets 6. Exert control over many societies 7. Are capable of massive military intervention 8. Control the sea lanes 9.conduct most advanced research 10. Control leading education 11. Dominate access to space 12. Dominate aerospace industry 13. Dominate international communications 14. Dominate the high tech industry. That's Yajuj wa Majuj if you read the requisite ayat and ahadith on Yajuj wa Majuj. Hasn't the prophet prophet Muhammad(saw) said in a hadithul qudsi that Yajuj wa Majuj will NOT be destroyed by any people except by Allah. No one people Russians or Chinese will defeat them except by divine intervention. They can only checkmate them. The Quran is very fundamental but its other pieces require another faculty to deduce what's going on. The faculty of interpretation, taaweel here now is important and not tafseer.
I think this maybe it where I completely draw the line in my disbelief now. It was one hell of a ride but farewell. I was an ex-muslim but gave a tad chance to Islam. But this is the conclusion.
Please read this book written by a prolific Islamic Scholar Imran N Hossein on Yajuj And Majuj 👇👇👇 www.geopolitica.ru/sites/default/files/hosein_gog_magog.pdf
Dali Atheism has lots of problems with the whole humanity that’s why they kicked the religion out of politics in the early 20th century and caused WW1 and WW2 resulting in the killing of millions all because the so-called atheists wanted to achieve world peace. These atheists, seculars and liberals are still searching for peace, i wonder when they’ll achieve that peace may be you know the answer🤔 There is a book by the name of Encyclopaedia of war which says that from 8000BC to 2000AD humanity fought 1763 wars and only 121 war were fought by religion and guess what...the remaining 93% wars were fought by atheists secularists and Liberals 😱😱
@@anonymousincognitoo Brother there just needs to be a straightforward answer with this. The Qur'an and Hadiths have been interpreted in so many ways there should not be a variety of mental gymnastics as seen from the highly intellectual scholars like Hijab. I need 100% truth in this
Nazmul Islam Please read this book written by a prolific Islamic Scholar Imran N Hossein on Yajuj And Majuj 👇👇👇 www.geopolitica.ru/sites/default/files/hosein_gog_magog.pdf Brother the release of Yajuj and Majuj is linked to the return of the Israelite Jews to the Holy Land (Jerusalem) as mentioned in Chapter 21, Verses 95-96 of the Glorious Quran. Jews returned to Jerusalem, after more than 2000 years, right after Balfour Declaration in 1917 and after that mankind witnessed League of Nations in 1920 which gave way to the creation of Passport in 1920 after that in 1924 Visa Regulations came and than in 1926 border security forces were installed on each countries’ border and than the world was imprisoned in cages on the basis of race, colour, creed, tongue and territory. Around 1920 the concept of Nation States engulfed the whole world Around 1920, mankind for the first time witnessed the global usage of the paper money as a medium of exchange which became very prevalent after Bretton woods accord in 1944. Around 1920, the world’s very first miss world competition was inaugurated which brought the women into the market so that their bodies could be used as means to expand the frontiers of capitalism. Around 1920 very first nude beach came into existence in Germany. In other words, when you see Israeliste Jews being brought back to the holy land than that means that their return could only have become possible because of the assistance from Yajuj and Majuj who are the Modern wester Judeo-Christian goddless Civilisation because they have been trying for a thousand years to liberate Jerusalem. The first crusade was launched around 1096 by the Western Europe (Western Christianity) while Easter European Byzantine Empire (Eastern Orthodox Christianity) did not participated in the crusades. The crusaders failed to permanently hold the control of Jerusalem. Meanwhile, in 1897 only the European Jews established the Zionist movement to launch a struggle calling all the jews to return to their promised land. And than finally in 1917 the Secular Europe under the leadership of Great Britain issued the Balfour Declaration resulting in the liberation of Jerusalem and from 1918 up until 1947 Britain allowed the return of the jews to the Holy land, some from the front door and a lot from the back door secretly. In short, the original Yajuj and Majuj are located in the Western European Christians as well as Jews and also the former USSR which was the product of Jews like Trotsky who, along with many other zionist Jews, cause the Russian Revolution. But the world as whole will follow the original thus Yajuj and Majuj will make their carbon copies by making people follow their life style either by hook or by crook. Brother there can be a lot that I can write but it’s not possible right now, therefore I urge you to please read the aforementioned book by clicking the link. Hope this will develop an interest in you to read the book. Thank you!
Without going into any kind of debate i am firm believer that there are so many things that Human race is still not been able to understand yet revealed in Quran as so many things we understood not at the time of revelation but during the course of 14 centuries gradually when human intellect, science, knowledge base expanded and started understanding those issues. Gog & Magog is also among those issues that still we humans can't fully understand but this has already started getting revealed and myths being created around this revelation of Quran have already fading out. Some scholars have also done good work in understanding this issue and in my opinion they have already solved some of the puzzles around this issue. If brother Yasir is interested i can share some material that could form basis of new research. Quan never told us not to dig out issues like these but it always encourages us (both believers and non believers) to do efforts, research and think deep to understand these issues even if it takes a very long time is understand. Allah has no problem we understand few things after 2 or 3 of may be 10 thousand years later. He is not in hurry at all. For example the notion of Quran that on the day of judgement whole life of a human being good and bad both deeds would be given to him in his or her hand and he would not need any help to believe that but he or she would be accepting and admitting that yes I did all this. Rather he or she would admit that no smallest sin or smallest good deed was missed. Now only in the end of 20th century Human being are able to clearly understood this after nearly 14 centuries. Issue of Gog Magog may take few more centuries of millennia to fully understood or may be few can soon reach the depth of the mystery with the divine help.
don't take his opinion as a muslim majority opinion. Same as we don't understand how Adam was created from dust / mud and we don't understand how the false Messiah Al-Dajjal is already alive, we cannot fathom the existance of Gog and Magog, but we still believe it, because we have divine text to prove it.
Who really are the true Gog and Magog? The original and true prophecy of Gog and Magog is the 3000 year old prophecy from the book of Ezekiel chapters 38 and 39. READ THE TWO CHAPTERS FOR YOURSELF; It will be the difference between eternity in heaven and eternity in hell! This original account is 1500 years before Qur'an 18:94 and the hadiths and it makes far better sense than the tale of the two corrupting subhuman tribes found in the hadiths. Already, part of the prophecy of Ezekiel has been fulfilled! Manuscripts of Ezekiel were also found among the Dead Sea scrolls which are dated 300 years before Jesus and confirm the current contents of Ezekiel as genuine. I understand that it will be surprising for Muslims to learn that the hadiths misrepresent A LOT of end time prophecies especially from the New Testament book of Revelations (written almost 750 years before the collection of the hadiths) and in so doing placed Muslims on the wrong side of the future! The manuscripts of the book of Revelations from BEFORE Muhammad are still available today. Who are the original and true Gog and Magog? Gog is a RULER and Magog is his KINGDOM (Ezekiel 38:2)-like a Khalifa and Caliphate. Gog is the prophesied ruler of Magog. Gog is the real Antichrist (not the mythical one-eyed Al-Maseeh al-Dajjaal of the hadiths!). Gog/the Antichrist will be used by Satan in the last 7 years of the world to oppose the HOLY COVENANT (Daniel 11:28) God has with the nation of Israel (Deuteronomy 29:13). In modern terms, Magog will be the Antichrist's alliance of 10 nations (Ezekiel 38:5 or Revelations 17:12-13) supporting his satanic cause of committing a mass genocide against the nation of Israel because of Satan's hatred of the holy covenant God has with Israel (Ezekiel 38:8). The God who has a long standing covenant with Israel is the God whose name is the God of Abraham, Isaac and and Jacob, NOT Allah, (the two are not the same God!) because Allah seeks to commit a mass genocide against Jews in the end times (Saheeh hadith 2922) to the point even hiding behind a rock won't protect the Jews from being killed by Allah's forces. In Saheeh Muslim (2922), the Messenger of Allah said: “The Hour will not begin until the Muslims fight the Jews and the Muslims will kill them, until a Jew hides behind a rock or a tree, and the rock or tree will say: O Muslim, O slave of Allah, there is a Jew behind me, come and kill him". According to the hadiths, the imposter of Jesus Christ (the Islamic Prophet Isa) who is a Jew, will be leading Allah's armies AGAINST the Jews, God's chosen nation! Does this make sense to you? WHO ARE THE FOLLOWERS OF GOG AND MAGOG (THE ANTICHRIST)? COULD YOU BE AMONG THEM? The true definition of Antichrist is first ever used in the Gospels (which, if you believe the Qur'an, are confirmed as the eternal and unalterable (incorruptible) word of Allah and which Christians "have with them" (in the 7th century) and should judge themselves by: (QS 18:27, 5:43, 5:47, 3:3-4, 6:115 and 7:157). It's the Qur'ans dilemma! According to the Gospels, the Antichrist and his followers are those who deny that Jesus is the Son of God and is ONE with the father: "Who is a liar but he who denies that Jesus is the Christ? He is ANTICHRIST who denies the Father and the Son. Whoever denies the Son does not have the Father either; he who acknowledges the Son has the Father also." [1John 2:22-23] It is therefore a fact of life that the theology of the Qur'an and Islam is openly antichrist as it DENIES-6 CENTURIES AFTER THE EVENT and against the testimony of his Mother, Mary and the disciple John who were with him on the cross-that Jesus Christ was crucified (QS 19:91-92) and that Jesus Christ is the Son of God (QS 4:157). IF Islamic endtimes is FULFILLED, a future Islamic leader will be Antichrist because he will deny that Jesus Christ is the Son of God. IF Islamic end times is FULFILLED, Gog and Magog (the Antichrist and his alliance of nations) will certainly be Islamic in nature: an Islamic Antichrist, likely the Mahdi, and his KINGDOM (Caliphate)-a confederation of Middle East nations (but not limited to the Islamic Middle East). China and Russia? Maybe! The alliance of nations led by Gog will be set on destroying the nation of Israel because the false god of this world, who is disguised as the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob and as the god of righteousness and light (2 Corinthians 11:13-14), is set against the HOLY COVENANT God has with Israel. Why does Allah want to commit a mass genocide against God's chosen nation?
the main problem for me in metaphorical interpretation is the slipery slope of applying it to any verse or story sounding too illogical or irrational or severe in the quran. "dont beat your wife literally no! only in a metaphorical sense!"
٩٥ وَحَرَامٌ عَلَىٰ قَرْيَةٍ أَهْلَكْنَاهَا أَنَّهُمْ لَا يَرْجِعُونَ 95:21 And there is a ban upon a community which We have destroyed: that they shall not return. ٩٦ حَتَّىٰ إِذَا فُتِحَتْ يَأْجُوجُ وَمَأْجُوجُ وَهُمْ مِنْ كُلِّ حَدَبٍ يَنْسِلُونَ 96:21 Until, when Gog and Magog are let loose, and they hasten out of every mound,
The more one increases in knowledge, the more one increases in tolerance. And the less read one is, the easier it becomes to ascribe deviancy to a view that one has not come across before. The teacher of our teacher, Sh. Abd al-Raḥmān al-Sa'dī (d. 1956), claimed that Ya'jūj and Ma'jūj were not tribes trapped behind an existing wall, because that was something that was not proven by the Quran or Sunnah, and something that he said modern science (in his day!) didn't back up. He claimed that they must therefore be something else - his view was that although originally they might have been Mongolian tribes, in our times, they are the biological and intellectual descendants of those tribes, and hence he included Russians and Americans and other peoples. Before him, Shaykh Anwar Shah al-Kashmīrī (d. 1933) also posited that the wall of Dhul-Qarnayn no longer existed and that Ya'juj and Ma'juj were some type of current populations. Now, while I personally don't agree with the details of either of their opinions, the fact of the matter is that these great scholars (and others) within mainstream Sunnī Islam challenged the classical view, based on their understanding of the Quran and Sunnah, and their understanding of the knowledge that the modern world conveys. All too often, a beginning student of knowledge mistakes 𝑡ℎ𝑒𝑖𝑟 𝑖𝑛𝑡𝑒𝑟𝑝𝑟𝑒𝑡𝑎𝑡𝑖𝑜𝑛 of the Quran and Sunnah as 𝑡ℎ𝑒 Quran and Sunnah. In the 1950s, scholars who didn't understand Sh. al-Sa'dī's paradigm accused him of being a deviant who rejects the Sunnah, and even filed a Royal complaint against him with King Ibn Sa'ūd. The King called him to a conference convened for his sake, with a group of scholars, and the Shaykh defended his paradigm with such a profundity that none of the scholars who accused him had anything left to say. Even if they didn't agree with his view, they couldn't fault him for having an alternative view, because his uṣūl (or paradigm) were valid. My views on Ya'jūj and Ma'jūj are just that: my views. I could be wrong, and every scholar or student of knowledge has the right to accept or reject or academically critique them. No problem. What *is* a problem, of the highest magnitude, and one that, if it persists after this post, I will sue for in the Court of Allah on Judgment Day, is the outright and blatant lie that I reject the Quran or authentic Sunnah based on the claim that they are illogical or irrational. What is a lie, based on jumping on an ambiguous word or two and reading in a meaning that is clearly not intended as the context shows, is the claim that I mock the classical scholars of Islam. Both of these are outright slanders against me. I reiterate: from my perspective, I agree with Sh. al-Sa'dī and many of his students (and perhaps at a later time I will also explain some interesting side notes about my teacher Ibn `Uthaymīn and his views Ya'juj and Ma'juj - but that is another post): the Quran and authentic Hadith do not require us to believe that there are hundreds of millions of people still hiding somewhere on this earth. If you feel that the Quran or Sunnah asks us to believe that, fair enough, that is your view, based on what Hadith you consider valid and how you choose to interpret them. Final point, to really illustrate my paradigm: the rising of the Sun from the West is far more 'problematic' view to hold from a purely physical and scientific perspective. The mechanisms of how that would occur are simply beyond the domain of scientific possibility given our current understanding of physics. Yet, because the authentic Sunnah is so explicit on this point, and because I feel that there is no room for re-interpretation, I have no choice but to accept it because that is what īman dictates, and Allah is indeed capable of all things. We do not decide the validity of a Hadith based on whether it is rational or not, but the question is: what exactly is the Quran or authentic Hadith asking us to believe? This is the argument that I am making in my lectures on Ya'jūj and Ma'jūj. May Allah protect us from solving this problem in this world by ever having to see the reality of Ya'jūj and Ma'jūj!! Yasir Qadhi's response
Please read this book written by a prolific Islamic Scholar Imran N Hossein on Yajuj And Majuj 👇👇👇 www.geopolitica.ru/sites/default/files/hosein_gog_magog.pdf
Why is abrahamic god in release 1.0,1.1,1.2 so angry, so bloodthirsty, so narcissictic, so full of human psychological problems?,,,, Is he lonely or did we sick bastards projected our fears into a fairytale being? Why 3 unclear books about the same god? Is our almighty god not able to write one clear book for all humanity, so he has to try 3 times and fails miserbly every time? Will he burn in hell for causing separation, hate and bloodbaths in his name for millenia?
My friend Hassan, with all due respect just because your or my intellect or Yassir Qadhis for that matter cannot reconcile something, that does not mean that it is not true, if one believes in the One True God that created everyone and everything and is completely powerful over all things, and one believes that the Quran is from the Creator, then one would not question something like how theses tribes yajuj and majuj could remain somewhere for thousands of years. It is quite simple. I am not attacking you my friend but rather pointing out this is not that strange. I myself am British and became Muslim 9 years ago and Al Hamdulilah (all praise is due to the One True God) for this favour.
Do you believe God is rational? If you do, then he must act rationally. That is the only way that we can know him. An irrational God is no better than a crazy person with a shotgun. We don't know what will trigger them. How is Islam any truer than Buddhism (or any other 4,000+ religion out there) if you cannot use reason to compare it?
Salam. YQ in his latest video with Muhammad Hijab said there is only ONE hadith that gives the impression that Yajuj and Majuj are still currently alive, and previous scholars have said that that hadith is weak, and therefore it is not Islamically obligatory to believe they are currently still alive.
My view is simply we do not have full info or background regarding this hadith, especially from the Sahabah or the Prophet himself, it is therefore up for speculation regarding the deeper meanings or realities of it. I don't see the need to go that deeply into it as it does not have a impact on our daily lives. Yasir Qadhi states from ibn Kathir that it may be borrowed from banu Israel.
Hi Hassan Radwan Other EX muslims are interviewing and discussing with mufti abu layth. It would be nice to see a discussion with MUFTI ABU LAYTH about the 100% clear cut mistakes and how the verses of the Quran go against the voice of REASON with yourself. I am aware you actually believe in the God but do not believe in religion. So it would be nice discussing with mufti Abu layth and showing him clear cut verses that goes against the voice of reason. The reason I am saying this is because MUFTI ABU LAYTH has replied to alot of the doubts EX muslims bring about the Quran and proves that they are not mistakes and uses the voice of REASON TOO. Mufti abu layth's defence of the QURAN AND SUNNAH is VERY VERY POWERFUL. So it would be nice to see yourself discussing and proving to mufti that the quran is clearly against the voice of REASON. Love and peace to you all!
Theres one more the sura also describes people that sleep for such time without food and water , so somthing might be there that is hidden from us and living in some ways 😂
He's such a smart and eloquent man with all the right logical skills to dissect this myth but still stops short of the simplest and most plausible explanation which is, as you said, that this is a myth.
cessna caravan Damned if you do damned if you don’t, that’s a predicament one often finds him/herself in Islam. according to Wikipedia, Daesh called him a murtaad back in 2016.
Please read this book written by a prolific Islamic Scholar Imran N Hossein on Yajuj And Majuj 👇👇👇
www.geopolitica.ru/sites/default/files/hosein_gog_magog.pdf
Thank you for your efforts.
The only myth is what man have managed to convince himself of. And That is what he learned so far and sees, gives him the ability to to know the 99.99% what he has no knowledge of.
Go back 100 years and tell them about making a device that connect u to China in seconds “an iPhone” you will certainly be told that what you are speaking of is a myth. And the next generation will also call what they haven’t seen a myth, and so on. Ignorance beyond imagination!
@@nabilelshukri There is much in the Quran that Muslims centuries ago did not yet have the concepts or language to understand nor explain. The passage of time and acquisition of knowledge proved the Quran true. I believe the story of guj and majuj to be one of those occurrences where time and growth of knowledge will once again prove Quran true. The time will come were this won't be a mystery to our descendants. All I can say is may God help them then.
I'm a Muslim but glad you linked to the original lecture Mr. Radwan, so people can watch it for themselves in context. That's proper documentation practice and evidence of honesty.
Even a highly educated and intelligent person like Yasir having tremendously hard time to interpret his scripture and ironically enough, Quran claims, "And indeed, We have made the Qur'an easy to understand"
It is easy to understand actually. This is a story. That is basically it. All the interpretations etc. people came up with in 1400 years are a different things and very vast in volume.
You didn't get the point yasir qadhi doesn't have problems with quran he talking about a hadiths explaining it,
Easy to remember **
@@adams8968 actually the Quran speaks in detail about Dhul Qarnaan and Yajuj wa Majuj in surah Kaf.
There are other things like dipping the fly!
Yessir qadhi is a strong case of cognitive dissonance, we've all been there but the difference is we had to move on.
Pot Head yes but on our own terms and at our own pace...
Please read this book written by a prolific Islamic Scholar Imran N Hossein on Yajuj And Majuj 👇👇👇
www.geopolitica.ru/sites/default/files/hosein_gog_magog.pdf
Pot Head have you heard Imam Hussein's explanation on Gog and Magog? Watch both part 1 and 2,
ua-cam.com/video/QG-F3O584-0/v-deo.html
From my Playlist you can also find a huge amount of evidence re the takeover by the Khazarian jews of global banking, political, media and judiciary and being the prime funders and initiators of wars between nations, diving and conquering over centuries. They converted from being phallic worshippers very shortly after Islam started expanding, infiltrating first the Christian nobility in the west through usury. Hence the Rothschilds and the 13 families are clearly the Dajaal/Anti christ at the top of their pyramid. And Gog and Magog are their many millions of zombie like materialistic minions in their Masonic and many other secret societies, corrupt religion, most media, government and civic institutions through which they control the billions in society.
Only because he came to a different conclusion ? What gives you the right to act so high and mighty? Not everyone has to go the same path you took.
@@dreamingclouds2891 how am I acting "high" or "mighty"
Thanks for pointing this out. Really feels vindicating to see them openly admit what we were saying all along.
Qadir still cannot admit , openly , how ludicrous ,not only this but also other craap in the Quran is , from Solomon tales to conception, happening from the backbone to evolution . I wonder , does he already know Quran is false but is unable to admit , as it could lead to violence for him ,loss of livelihood, family and even death .
We know so many who are secretly apostates , who don't want to be open about their views for fear of the repercussions.
Please read this book written by a prolific Islamic Scholar Imran N Hossein on Yajuj And Majuj 👇👇👇
www.geopolitica.ru/sites/default/files/hosein_gog_magog.pdf
I commented this with my other account too.
I am an ex-Muslim young man . I am a Christian now. I live in Iraq. I am a Kurd. I used to be a very devout Muslim and studied Islam and Arabic language for a long time to become a Sheikh (Islamic Scholar). early in my life I began to have some doubt about Islam. For example how would the Quran deny Jesus's crucifixion when we have overwhelming evidence to support it, even outside the Bible. Why the Quran denies Jesus is the Son of God in every sense, when we have many verses that says so in the new testament. Why is God not Called Jehova or Yahwei in the Quran, especially when the Quran claim that it is from the same God who inspired the Bible. Why the Quran claims Muhammed is mentioned by name in the Bible and Jesus said he would come after him, when in fact Mohammed is not mentioned at all in the bible. Why the Quran claims it will be preserved and not change, when in fact there are so many versions of Quran (these are not different readings of the Quran, but different versions of the Quran). Watch or read Jay smith about that. You see the Kaaba in Mekka is the holiest place in Islam and the Quran says Abraham built it as a place of worship. When in fact Mekka is never mentioned in the bible and Abraham did not even go to Mekka. Why so much laws in favour of man and against women. Why is it lawful in Islam to marry a six year old girl. That is exactly what Mohammed did, married her when she (Aysha) was 6 and had sex with her when she was 9 years old. Why so many apocrypha in the Quran. Like the seven sleepers. see the Quran 18: 9-26. Jesus making bird out of clay, Solomon's bird and queen of sheeba. Why so much violence in The Quran and especially in the hadith (saying and action of Mohammed) like ordering to kill anyone who leaves Islam and killing every adult (in Islam about 14 years and above) on earth who does not believe in Mohammed and Allah and does not pray like what Mohammed taught, Quran 9 :29. Taking captured girls and women after killing or capturing the men and makimg them slaves, the girls and women also become slaves and are distributed among the Muslim fighters (Mujahideen). Muhammad in a hadith picked the most beautiful for himself. They become their sex slaves for having sex with willingly or unwillingly whether their husband or family still alive or not. The Mujahiduns can sell them in the Market. These made me doubt about Islam. I listened to many smart and intelligent Islamic scholars about the answers to my doubts and questions, but they were not convincing. I started to watch some channels on youtube that criticize Islam. Channels like (Act 17 apologetics, Islam critiqued, apostate prophet, Jay smiths videos). Their criticism matched what I studied about Islam. I knew it must not be from God. I thought about Christianity. I downloaded a Bible. I read it. I was impressed by Jesus's peaceful sayings, commands and actions. I found Christianity convincing. I watched so many videos about Christianity on UA-cam. I knew Jesus was the truth. I knew he was the Son of God. One day on February 2019, I raised my hand, closed my eyes and pleaded to God with all my heart. I asked Allah, if he was the true God, let him do something and save me from becoming a Christian. I stress, I asked him with all my heart. No response from Allah. Then I asked Jesus Christ to be my Lord, saviour, and my God. I said you are the way, the truth and the life. Come to my life show me something. In the midst of my prayer, I sensed an energy entering me. It made me feel happy. It made me sweat and fell heat (warmth) and love. At that time I did not know what it was, but I knew it was a sign from. Jesus. Later on I knew it was the fruit of the holy spirit. Now I like my life more, because I know I am a child of God, and not only a mere slave of Allah, as it is the case in the Quran. My life now in a way is more difficult. I haven't told my family yet. If I tell them they are going to disown me in the best case scenario if not kill me. At the end this is what Mohammed orderd Muslims to do.That's why I need to move to the West. If not I have to live among them and pray and fast like them and speak like them and praise Mohammed and Allah, and hide my thought and biblical views about Jesus, the Son of God.
I ask you my brothers and sisters to pray for my family and every Muslim on earth to know Jesus Christ and accept him as their God, Lord and saviour. I hate Islam (because of so many of its teachings, including violence) more than anything that I hate on earth but we should not hate Muslims, they need love and caring. They need Jesus Christ. I want to become a peacher and someone who shares the Gospel to the world and especially to my fellow Kurds. You too can share the gospel and become a soldier of Jesus Christ. God bless you, every Muslim and every non-Christian.
O sameer hello
@@lovepeople951 have you heard Imam Hussein's explanation on Gog and Magog? Watch both part 1 and 2,
ua-cam.com/video/QG-F3O584-0/v-deo.html
From my Playlist you can also find a huge amount of evidence re the takeover by the Khazarian jews of global banking, political, media and judiciary and being the prime funders and initiators of wars between nations, diving and conquering over centuries. They converted from being phallic worshippers very shortly after Islam started expanding, infiltrating first the Christian nobility in the west through usury. Hence the Rothschilds and the 13 families are clearly the Dajaal/Anti christ at the top of their pyramid. And Gog and Magog are their many millions of zombie like materialistic minions in their Masonic and many other secret societies, corrupt religion, most media, government and civic institutions through which they control the billions in society.
Oh my Love for this man, Hassan Radwan. I'm forever grateful of you
It's so amazing and miserable at the same time the capacity of our human minds to do whatever it takes to save our beliefs while pretending to be critical about them
Please read this book written by a prolific Islamic Scholar Imran N Hossein on Yajuj And Majuj 👇👇👇
www.geopolitica.ru/sites/default/files/hosein_gog_magog.pdf
comment of the month :)
If Islam is such a perfect and clear religion why are these people doing so many gymnastics trying to understand it, interpret it and reinterpret it, reinterpret is essentially changing the meaning as they go along?
Chetan Naik
Chetan Naik
Well brother, we always learn more so that we can reinterpret - this applies to science, art, etc.
If you read the same book when you were 15 then 25 then 45 -> your understanding would change.
The miracle of the Quran include:
1) no contradictions
2) science that was unknown 1400 years ago that we’re learning just now
3) grammar & style
And so much more. I invite you to read it for yourself with an objective mind. Otherwise, it’s mental laziness or an existing bias against Islam.
Zatchooze Naut
In that case, your reading skills are less than my preschool child lol.
Truth is that you’ve never read the Quran because you’re too lazy or have hatred in your heart.
@@kevinsander8286 Probably you are Islamically indoctrinated not scientifically educated. Islam is wrong in stating supernatural creationism, borrowing prevailing myths in and around Arabia.
Overwhelming scientific evidence points to natural evolution of humans from their ape like ancestors, not the result of incest in Adam-Eve's family. Just one of the examples where Islam is wrong, there are plenty.
@@kevinsander8286 Obviously, you don't see any contradictions because if there was one scholars like Yasir Qadhi will twist the meaning at convenience and make it suitable to current scientific understanding.
Chetan Naik
You & your countrymen workshop cows & monkeys so don’t even try to bring science or logic into this discussion lol.
As I stated above, folks like yourself are too mentally lazy or taught to hate Islam. Otherwise, you would read with an objective mind the science that Islam mentioned 1400 years ago that were just now learning.
Also, the reason you think Islam “borrowed” things from other religions isn’t because it copied those things...it’s because God perfected his final religion for mankind. For example, He promised that no more religions will come after Islam - and he was correct. The only ones are localized religions like Sikhism.
I will make it even easier for you. I challenge you too view videos from EF Dawn here on UA-cam.
I reverted to Islam and it was the best decision of my life. Open your mind & your heart, brother.
Thanks to Dr. Quadhi for admitting that there are huge problems in the interpretation of some Quranic verses. It's true thousands of people (includes not only young but adults too) are questioning these verses and leaving Islam in droves findings unsatisfactory, silly and sometimes mind-boggling stupid answers or no answers.
There are muslim preachers who have built a career over this yajooj majooj fairy tale like Imran Hussein. Spreading fairy tales and conspiracy theories.
It's a good step forward but it's still not right
Please read this book written by a prolific Islamic Scholar Imran N Hossein on Yajuj And Majuj 👇👇👇
www.geopolitica.ru/sites/default/files/hosein_gog_magog.pdf
@Ornando Dijks
Yes, his explanations make as much sense as those *illuminati confirmed* memes. Btw you may have been impressed by the word "eschatology" but it is basically mythology.
@@zverh no need to debate with this "one eyed king" fella. Let him believe what he wants to believe in his land of blinds
As a Muslim, I always adored this man. Now, as an apostate, I still respect and love this man.
I heard this about Shabbir Ally too haha
I have a lot of respect for both Yasir Qadhi & Shabbir Ally
You all are confused
@@أبوأنسالدارقتنيالشنقنطي Yep, we are confused. Do you suggest some interventionist stoning ceremony for induction of clarity?
@@saifaljaaidi9280 brother , there was no need for that , you are confused in terms of turth , wallahi , if you open your heart and be sincere , and ask allah for guidance , wallahi you will get it , and i m not judging you , cause this could happene to any of us , just know there wwere shahbas who left islam , and came back after being honest and sincere withemselves , you may do , and may allah bring you back .
I never heard such honest statement from a preacher. I pray for you to ALMIGHTY. Thank u.
YQ said there is only ONE hadith that gives the impression that Yajuj and Majuj are still currently alive, and previous scholars have said that that hadith is weak, and therefore it is not Islamically obligatory to believe they are currently still alive.
It’s amazing he openly admits he doesn’t believe stuff. Poor guy. I feel like he knows deep down it’s all false, but his livelihood depends on preaching this stuff.
His livelihood and his life frankly. Even if he wanted to, he would never be really able to come out with disbelief openly. He'd be hounded non-stop given his relative fame..
Meghan Jane I know, it really sucks. He’s kind of stuck in the same Islamic life forever.
Being an Islamic preacher isn't a good economic move, with the exception of very poor countries where the alternative is joblessness. He has multiple degrees and can earn much plenty of money doing other things. In the west, it's a choice you have to take seriously because you will have to accept that the rewards will be in the Hereafter, not in this life. It is not like Christian evangelicism.
In brief, YQ said there is only ONE hadith that gives the impression that Yajuj and Majuj are still currently alive, and previous scholars have said that that hadith is weak, and therefore it is not Islamically obligatory to believe they are currently still alive. It's a quite simple issue when looked at it this way. They were alive in the past, and we believe their "children" will be alive/active in the future.
Wow I love our Muslim brothers and sisters in humanity, I respect this so much Mr Yasir Qadhi.
That’s what happens when you watch to many zombie films like world war z
1400 Years since the Death of the prophet
The companions of the prophet
The 3 best early generations of Muslims
The best interpretators and Scholars of the Holy Quran and Hadith
The most authentic Tafsirs of the Quran
The view of the overwhelming majority of scholars of the past and contemprorary scholars of Today.
And finally 1400 Years after the revelation of the Quran , Yasir Qadhi , Or Yasir Qadhi's friend to be accurate has got the right interpretation of the Gog and Magog Story.
Thank God for Yale University graduate , Yasir Qadhi for enlightening us.
Shouldn'tThe Quran and Hadith be clear and not be revealed in a manner that it will be misunderstood for 1400 years ? is it truly possible for God to mislead his followers and the best and most pious scholars for 1400 Years and even the most respected scholars of the 21st century.
Shouldn't the holy Quran be perfecty rational and logical.
Your argument that things understood by consensus and established by majority of scholars may be irrational or illogical but we should accept them on faith as being beyond our understanding is weak and is the same argument used by Hindus , and christians when we question their beliefs as well.
Yasir Qadhi is questioning the traditional authentic authorities of Islam.
Please tell me this is sarcasm
@@asadnawaz4092 why? It is a perfectly logical argument. If you disagree you should provide an adequate and reasonable counter argument.
Leaving a comment here so I can see any future counter arguments.
@@cmf1402 @asad Nawaz isn't ready🤣🤣
"To struggle with the truth and then admit the struggle is a safer position than to invent something that is far fetched and then pretend that it is answering the problems." If better directed, it could have been as eloquent a refutation of religion in general as I have heard.
Why would Allah protect evil humans (Gog & Magog) that do nothing than spreading corruption and even preserve their lifes even when they don't have water to drink, food to eat and no sunlight...
But then lets majority of his believers die a horrible death and doesn't protect them from the "Enemys of Allah"...
What a merciful god! Protecting the evil people but not his believers ❤
Well said Shayk Yasir. Makes you think deeply. We love you.
Who really are the true Gog and Magog?
The original and true prophecy of Gog and Magog is the 3000 year old prophecy from the book of Ezekiel chapters 38 and 39. READ THE TWO CHAPTERS FOR YOURSELF; It will be the difference between eternity in heaven and eternity in hell!
This original account is 1500 years before Qur'an 18:94 and the hadiths and it makes far better sense than the tale of the two corrupting subhuman tribes found in the hadiths. Already, part of the prophecy of Ezekiel has been fulfilled!
Manuscripts of Ezekiel were also found among the Dead Sea scrolls which are dated 300 years before Jesus and confirm the current contents of Ezekiel as genuine.
I understand that it will be surprising for Muslims to learn that the hadiths misrepresent A LOT of end time prophecies especially from the New Testament book of Revelations (written almost 750 years before the collection of the hadiths) and in so doing placed Muslims on the wrong side of the future! The manuscripts of the book of Revelations from BEFORE Muhammad are still available today.
Who are the original and true Gog and Magog?
Gog is a RULER and Magog is his KINGDOM (Ezekiel 38:2)-like a Khalifa and Caliphate. Gog is the prophesied ruler of Magog. Gog is the real Antichrist (not the mythical one-eyed Al-Maseeh al-Dajjaal of the hadiths!). Gog/the Antichrist will be used by Satan in the last 7 years of the world to oppose the HOLY COVENANT (Daniel 11:28) God has with the nation of Israel (Deuteronomy 29:13).
In modern terms, Magog will be the Antichrist's alliance of 10 nations (Ezekiel 38:5 or Revelations 17:12-13) supporting his satanic cause of committing a mass genocide against the nation of Israel because of Satan's hatred of the holy covenant God has with Israel (Ezekiel 38:8).
The God who has a long standing covenant with Israel is the God whose name is the God of Abraham, Isaac and and Jacob, NOT Allah, (the two are not the same God!) because Allah seeks to commit a mass genocide against Jews in the end times (Saheeh hadith 2922) to the point even hiding behind a rock won't protect the Jews from being killed by Allah's forces.
In Saheeh Muslim (2922), the Messenger of Allah said: “The Hour will not begin until the Muslims fight the Jews and the Muslims will kill them, until a Jew hides behind a rock or a tree, and the rock or tree will say: O Muslim, O slave of Allah, there is a Jew behind me, come and kill him".
According to the hadiths, the imposter of Jesus Christ (the Islamic Prophet Isa) who is a Jew, will be leading Allah's armies AGAINST the Jews, God's chosen nation! Does this make sense to you?
WHO ARE THE FOLLOWERS OF GOG AND MAGOG (THE ANTICHRIST)? COULD YOU BE AMONG THEM?
The true definition of Antichrist is first ever used in the Gospels (which, if you believe the Qur'an, are confirmed as the eternal and unalterable (incorruptible) word of Allah and which Christians "have with them" (in the 7th century) and should judge themselves by: (QS 18:27, 5:43, 5:47, 3:3-4, 6:115 and 7:157). It's the Qur'ans dilemma!
According to the Gospels, the Antichrist and his followers are those who deny that Jesus is the Son of God and is ONE with the father:
"Who is a liar but he who denies that Jesus is the Christ? He is ANTICHRIST who denies the Father and the Son. Whoever denies the Son does not have the Father either; he who acknowledges the Son has the Father also." [1John 2:22-23]
It is therefore a fact of life that the theology of the Qur'an and Islam is openly antichrist as it DENIES-6 CENTURIES AFTER THE EVENT and against the testimony of his Mother, Mary and the disciple John who were with him on the cross-that Jesus Christ was crucified (QS 19:91-92) and that Jesus Christ is the Son of God (QS 4:157).
IF Islamic endtimes is FULFILLED, a future Islamic leader will be Antichrist because he will deny that Jesus Christ is the Son of God.
IF Islamic end times is FULFILLED, Gog and Magog (the Antichrist and his alliance of nations) will certainly be Islamic in nature: an Islamic Antichrist, likely the Mahdi, and his KINGDOM (Caliphate)-a confederation of Middle East nations (but not limited to the Islamic Middle East). China and Russia? Maybe!
The alliance of nations led by Gog will be set on destroying the nation of Israel because the false god of this world, who is disguised as the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob and as the god of righteousness and light (2 Corinthians 11:13-14), is set against the HOLY COVENANT God has with Israel. Why does Allah want to commit a mass genocide against God's chosen nation?
The True set people free, it liberates, thank you Dr Yashir Qadhi
I don't wish Yasir will become an ex-muslim. He is a much more effective voice in speaking about the absurdities this way.
Mohammed J if he continue this wAy there will be a fatwa on his head soon...
Please read this book written by a prolific Islamic Scholar Imran N Hossein on Yajuj And Majuj 👇👇👇
www.geopolitica.ru/sites/default/files/hosein_gog_magog.pdf
cessna caravan look, many Muslims don’t even go into the details... they live their life without over thinking, whatever they got in their Islamic school back home is enough for many, as an immigrants they put their kids into Islamic Sunday school here in the states and that’s it. I did it to my kids, they got scared and intimidated and confused but public school made them doubt and they just Americanized without practicing Islam line their parents want them to . I asked my brother in law how do u know that Allah is real? He looked at me and said: but it’s written in Quran... I don’t ask any more questions and hide my disbelief in Islam.
@@roxolanathor48 ha ha , Its clear to everyone now, that "allah " was just mohds alter ego. Allah spoke to mohd and declared him, the last prophet . Mohd spoke to allah and accepted being the last prophet . Zero witness , except Mohd telling others, allah spoke to him .
its ironical, Allah spent so much time , talking in the quran, nonsensical stuff, that has zero value . If alalh even said, boil your water before you drink it. That very simple and basic advice alone, would have saved tens and tens of millions of lives ! yet allah was more concerned about mohds sex life !, then humanity as a whole
Why ask around? God is a conclusion each soul has to reach on their own. Look around do you believe all this happened randomly and that our existence has no purpose? Look around, can you see the details? Is this all in vain and our life should be spend only in us feeding nothing else but our ego? And if we were to live a fully materialistic life, who would profit from that and would that make us happy?
I’ve watched several of Yasir Qadhi’s videos especially the one regarding the Qur’an’s preservation. I can certainly tell you this man deep down is at the very least a strong Agnostic about Islam. If he listens to the many arguments presented by Ex-Muslims such as the Morality (Sex-Slavery), scientific inaccuracies (Sky held up by pillars that you can’t see) etc. He will become an Apostate. However I doubt he will ever publicly denounce Islam as he will receive too much hate, loss of his statues, maybe death threats, lose his career etc. It’s not worth it for him. But we all deep down know this man is an Agnostic maybe Apostate eventually. I’m an Ex-Muslim. I have finally left Islam, I just Truly can’t believe this religion is coming from God.
But the religion seems to be attracting a tremendous number of new 'reverts'- why do you think that is?
@@PeaceOnEarthandMercyMildyou can also say the same thing towards other major religions.
@@PeaceOnEarthandMercyMild Most people are either forced into it or they join primarily for social benefits.
@@PeaceOnEarthandMercyMild Birth rates and leaving means being killed in a muslim country lol. Im in the UK and it means none of my family talk to me and my nephews/nieces aren't allowed to speak to me/their uncle. Because it fucking dehumanises you and people prefer to stay in the closet
People need to be informed about the Truth cause people eternal destiny is at stake, thank you Dr Yasir Qadhi for speaking the truth in love
not a muslim, but i have profound respect for anyone who shows such dedication to taking their text seriously. i can listen to qadhi all day lol, dude is sharp!
The fact that this man who is clearly very educated and intelligent, goes at lengths to make sense of this myth is sad, but this is what fear of falling into kuffar can do to a Muslim. The fact that he also goes at lengths to distance himself from the conclusion that it's a myth and that no one ascribe the quote to him for fear of reprisal is even sadder.
This is a good Marvel story for Disney!
Yajuj and Majuj are mentioned in the Quran by name : Surah Al Anbiya verse 96.
It sounds like a fairy tale, I agree with Dr Yasir Qadhi, it's unbelievable
He simply cannot bring himself to admit it's nothing but a myth.
Thank you for posting this
YQ said there is only ONE hadith that gives the impression that Yajuj and Majuj are still currently alive, and previous scholars have said that that hadith is weak, and therefore it is not Islamically obligatory to believe they are currently still alive.
Yasir in an incredibly smart guy. He was an imam before I become an exmuslim.
Salam. YQ said there is only ONE hadith that gives the impression that Yajuj and Majuj are still currently alive, and previous scholars have said that that hadith is weak, and therefore it is not Islamically obligatory to believe they are currently still alive. They were alive in the past, and we believe their "children" will be alive/active in the future. If this was one of the reasons you left Islam, then at least cross this off that list. I hope one day you look at Islam again afresh.
Good morning Mr. Hassan. I am Youssef, an Egyptian teenager who is your biggest fan. I just had one question regarding your debunking of Islamic Miracles. How do you know that history is correct and accurate. How do you that the books of the Greeks really came from them. I would love to talk to you via email or Facebook. I love you more than anything and thank you for being amazing and lovely.
Yes it's important to always remain critical and ask questions about all such matters. It's then up to us to weigh the evidence and come to the best conclusion we can, while bearing in mind we could be wrong. For me personally I didn't lose my faith in Islam because of Gog & Magog or any individual verse or narrative. It was the cumulative effect of the various issues. If there is a God he would surely appreciate that people could have perfectly valid reasons to doubt Islam without it having anything to do with them being evil or bad people. My question is always, if God wanted us to believe everything in the Qur'an, why allow even the slightest reason to doubt them? Particularly when eternal torture is at stake.
cessna caravan
What do you mean by highest incidence of mental illness? All Muslim countries are mental institutions from the time of Mohamed the epileptic, and schizoid father of Islam.
@ vice roy we know about the Greeks The same way we know about the pharaohs of an Ancient Egypt: history that was supported by the archeological artifacts!
@ Vice Roy You can read more about the historical method, I'd like to emphasize that the process is never about knowing with absolute certainty what happened in the past, but about trying to come up with the best possible explanation, and the most rational thing to believe in, given the evidence
Appreciate your question. What we read in History books may not be correct always..It can be adulterated.
To assign to truth .. we cannot rely on history books.
I have never seen honest person, like yaser qadhi 💝💝♥️❤️
I am learning a lot about Islamic Mythology by watching your videos. My teachers at the madrassa didn't touch such subjects probably because it was too fanciful even for children and as Yasir Qadhi puts it "problematic". I think Yasir Qadhi forgets that Islam is a "package". You cannot pick and choose from it in accordance with modern sensibilities.
It could be came to doubts. Dont think just taqlid
Please don't litsen to misguided so called scholars like yasir qhadi
May Allah guide us all to the true knowledge
@@stepstojannah8173 shut up and make taqlid by salafi scholars. Dont think let it do by others.
@@Ccccccgggggggjj .. you shut up and follow your best mate satan until you burn with him in fire 😂
@Hᴜꜱᴛʟᴇ Lᴏʏ ..I think you are the only fool sorry following the devil and he us laughing at you
You think youbwre here on earth with no purpose how foolish is that
Is that why people come to islam every single day educated people .doctors, scientists people whom know and study science
I had the same feeling when I watched his video about evolution - he accepts it because of the overwhelming amount of evidence, but denies human evolution because it contradicts the quran
So I just remembered one video of him too. Here's saying it quite straightforward, there's a line where you have to stop thinking. ua-cam.com/video/LhtCEUw5MKQ/v-deo.html
If I am not mistaken, there is a video where he claims to be a Muslim and denies his apostasy after having doubts at some point in his life.
He even explained that he had doubts about Islam but he pushed them away unfortunately
Pot Head exactly! Also, did you notice how often he touched his nose? It’s a sign of anxiety or a lie... I think he is a closeted atheist!
@@roxolanathor48 no, I don't think so, it's called cognitive dissonance
Thanks Yasir Qahdi, might aswell say whole notion of religion is 1 big myth. Once you entertain ideas by worldy academics, religion goes right out of the window.
For the first time I have seen such an honest gentleman. I myself do believe ve in Allah but not ready to swallow everything.
But they could be behind a wall,in a icy region ,think logically they break the wall go to sleep,at night the temperature drops more freezing the wall again
@@mohammedyaseenchopdat1210 where do they get water, fire, food, sun, medicine?
@@mohammedyaseenchopdat1210 the wall is described as being made of iron tho
In case if you're wondering, the person he's referring to 6:06 is Imran Hussein.I used to listen to his ''theories'' and the rest is history.
I guessed it was Imran Hosein, but why did Yasir Qadhi say Bermuda? I thought Imran Hosein was from Trinidad?
Salam. YQ said there is only ONE hadith that gives the impression that Yajuj and Majuj are still currently alive, and previous scholars have said that that hadith is weak, and therefore it is not Islamically obligatory to believe they are currently still alive. They were alive in the past, and we believe their "children" will be alive/active in the future. Shaikh Hossein may be right, but every human can be right or wrong. YQ understands it how he does, there isn't anything wrong Islamically with either viewpoint. Check his latest video with Muhammad Hijab.
this reminds me of one particular story about the dajjal in which he is described to be (currently) living chained on an island waiting till the end times.
I think it was narrated somewhere in Abu Dawud.
- I looked it up and to my suprise its actually in Sahih Muslim.
It’s true, I’ve seen it game of thrones
yes, Game of Thrones copied it from the Quran. It had sex, violence, sex slaves, sex with siblings, and full of myths.
Yassir, have you watched “The walking dead” series on AMC? Asking for a friend. 😉😂
That's crazy that the zombie theory makes more logical sense than classical interpretations.
Also I find in interesting that Qadhi is the only one who seem to point out only one hadith, of all the ones they have on this topic, actively mention these tribes being alive and that one classical scholar pointed out the issues with this hadith. Like how has this not been discussed before that the tribes being alive somewhere until now became the mainstream view?
the hadiths like to make impossible mathematics at the end of time. both ya'juj & ma'juj and the difference of numbers between men and women both (according to the hadith) will have the same ratio which is 1:99. for every one man, there's 99 women. for every 1 human, there's 99 of ya'juj and ma'juj. after i discovered these hadith i started having doubts
Even me
Surat Al-Araf
And recite to them, (O Muhammad), the story of the man to whom We gave Our Signs and who turned away from them; then ultimately Satan caught up with him and he was led astray.
Now, had We so willed We could indeed have exalted him through those Signs, but he clung to earthly life and followed his carnal desires. Thus his parable is that of the dog who lolls out his tongue whether you attack him or leave him alone. Such is the parable of those who reject Our Signs as false. Narrate to them these parables that they may reflect. 7:174-175
Aa’uzdu,billahi minishytan nirajeem.
Ok?
I like his sincerity but his conclusion is just irrationnel. "I believe in them because the coran says so" even if you find it complety irrationnel and incoherent ?
Irrational*
That’s how his belief limits his thinking - he’s not allowed to accept facts that contradict the quran
If he didn't say that, then he wouldn't be a muslim. Simple !!
I tried to think like that at one point too but I realized I was only lying to myself
Pot Head same here but i realized that when I started explaining it to my kids... it was making sense only in my head ...
Thanks for sharing. As someone who knows very little of Islam (I've focused more on Christianity and faith in general) it is surprising to me exactly which goofy myths are defended in this religion.
Dr. Quadhi should just give it up and change his name, shave and ask for witness protection.
boulderdennis Please read this book written by a prolific Islamic Scholar Imran N Hossein on Yajuj And Majuj 👇👇👇
www.geopolitica.ru/sites/default/files/hosein_gog_magog.pdf
Exactly. We dont need people who reject the truth. Dr Yasir can go and live his life.
@@anonymousincognitoo No thank you.
@Ornando Dijks I don't believe in Islamic scholars since I don't believe in that religion. I'm Jewish and I don't care!!!!!!!!!!!!!
@@boulderdennis who cares what you care 🤔🤔 hmmm then hell is waiting for you!!!
I find it astonishing that he finds THIS piece of islamic tradition as the most problematic when there are countless examples of more ridiculous stories and pieces of information that stand no logical ground at all. But to be fair, it's very rare to see any muslim leader to apply logic to his religion and criticize it in any way, so kudos to Yasir.
Yajuj & Majuj is an issue where apologetics just don't cut it - even for devout Muslims it is a real problem.
Anybody: "This makes no sense"
Religious person pulling out ol' reliable: "It's beyond our limited comprehension, Allah knows best"
Another great upload my friend.
Love to the family
Please read this book written by a prolific Islamic Scholar Imran N Hossein on Yajuj And Majuj 👇👇👇
www.geopolitica.ru/sites/default/files/hosein_gog_magog.pdf
It is interesting for me to see that Yasser Qadhi himself and other people laughing at this issue!
We.. The mainstream Muslims do not agree with YQ in this yajooj & majooj. He is lost in this issue .... Sadly. May ALLAAH عز Guide him
YQ said there is only ONE hadith that gives the impression that Yajuj and Majuj are still currently alive, and previous scholars have said that that hadith is weak, and therefore it is not Islamically obligatory to believe they are currently still alive. Salam.
إن هذا إلا أساطير الأولين
The problem with todays scholars is they want to explain everything literally.. And forget one thing we have limitations.. our vision, frequency limit in our hearing etc...
Very very true yet painful.
The guy who made up these stories would be laughing if he was alive today. So much energy being spent on discussion of a made up story.
I would too lmao
Good video man, are you still posting at all?
Thank you. No, I don't make videos anymore.
@@HassanRadwan133 Fair enough! I very randomly come across your videos that I'd seen several years ago and always enjoyed them.
Hope you're doing well whatever you're up to these days anyway :)
@@HassanRadwan133 Dear Hassan Radwan, are your children and wife still Muslim? And sorry for what happened with you, I have just read your biography on Medium website.
Hi Hassan Radwan
Any updates on meeting mufti Abu layth ? It would be nice to discuss the quran with mufti abu layth. Alot of the other ex muslims seemed very hesitant to discuss the mistakes in the quran with mufti Abu layth but started off with prove God exist and how do you know Islam is the truth.
It would be nice to see you discussing with mufti abu layth the CLEAR CUT mistakes and the verses that goes against the voice of reason with mufti abu layth.
Love and peace to you all!
I wonder how yasir qadhi is still a muslim after his explanation 😅
Obviously money is a main motive. Salut to you Hassan.
Blocked behind the wall ??
This is Attack on Titan ?😅
great work mr Hassan - i wish u success -
In the name of Allaah, the most Gracious, the most Merciful
Ahhhhh Yasir said my mind doesn't believe it, but then perhaps his heart does believe it 😂
Sheikh Imran hossein has ably explained the phenomenon of Yajuj wa Majuj and made it clear that classical scholarship cannot penetrate the verses of the Quran and hadith and deliver the interpretation.
I'm subscribed to and have watched Sheikh Imran Hosein's videos on this topic
But who really are the true Gog and Magog?
The original and true prophecy of Gog and Magog is the 3000 year old prophecy from the book of Ezekiel chapters 38 and 39. READ THE TWO CHAPTERS FOR YOURSELF; It will be the difference between eternity in heaven and eternity in hell!
This original account is 1500 years before Qur'an 18:94 and the hadiths and it makes far better sense than the tale of the two corrupting subhuman tribes found in the hadiths. Already, part of the prophecy of Ezekiel has been fulfilled!
Manuscripts of Ezekiel were also found among the Dead Sea scrolls which are dated 300 years before Jesus and confirm the current contents of Ezekiel as genuine.
I understand that it will be surprising for Muslims to learn that the hadiths misrepresent A LOT of end time prophecies especially from the New Testament book of Revelations (written almost 750 years before the collection of the hadiths) and in so doing placed Muslims on the wrong side of the future! The manuscripts of the book of Revelations from BEFORE Muhammad are still available today.
Who are the original and true Gog and Magog?
Gog is a RULER and Magog is his KINGDOM (Ezekiel 38:2)-like a Khalifa and Caliphate. Gog is the prophesied ruler of Magog. Gog is the real Antichrist (not the mythical one-eyed Al-Maseeh al-Dajjaal of the hadiths!). Gog/the Antichrist will be used by Satan in the last 7 years of the world to oppose the HOLY COVENANT (Daniel 11:28) God has with the nation of Israel (Deuteronomy 29:13).
In modern terms, Magog will be the Antichrist's alliance of 10 nations (Ezekiel 38:5 or Revelations 17:12-13) supporting his satanic cause of committing a mass genocide against the nation of Israel because of Satan's hatred of the holy covenant God has with Israel (Ezekiel 38:8).
The God who has a long standing covenant with Israel is the God whose name is the God of Abraham, Isaac and and Jacob, NOT Allah, (the two are not the same God!) because Allah seeks to commit a mass genocide against Jews in the end times (Saheeh hadith 2922) to the point even hiding behind a rock won't protect the Jews from being killed by Allah's forces.
In Saheeh Muslim (2922), the Messenger of Allah said: “The Hour will not begin until the Muslims fight the Jews and the Muslims will kill them, until a Jew hides behind a rock or a tree, and the rock or tree will say: O Muslim, O slave of Allah, there is a Jew behind me, come and kill him".
According to the hadiths, the imposter of Jesus Christ (the Islamic Prophet Isa) who is a Jew, will be leading Allah's armies AGAINST the Jews, God's chosen nation! Does this make sense to you?
WHO ARE THE FOLLOWERS OF GOG AND MAGOG (THE ANTICHRIST)? COULD YOU BE AMONG THEM?
The true definition of Antichrist is first ever used in the Gospels (which, if you believe the Qur'an, are confirmed as the eternal and unalterable (incorruptible) word of Allah and which Christians "have with them" (in the 7th century) and should judge themselves by: (QS 18:27, 5:43, 5:47, 3:3-4, 6:115 and 7:157). It's the Qur'ans dilemma!
According to the Gospels, the Antichrist and his followers are those who deny that Jesus is the Son of God and is ONE with the father:
"Who is a liar but he who denies that Jesus is the Christ? He is ANTICHRIST who denies the Father and the Son. Whoever denies the Son does not have the Father either; he who acknowledges the Son has the Father also." [1John 2:22-23]
It is therefore a fact of life that the theology of the Qur'an and Islam is openly antichrist as it DENIES-6 CENTURIES AFTER THE EVENT and against the testimony of his Mother, Mary and the disciple John who were with him on the cross-that Jesus Christ was crucified (QS 19:91-92) and that Jesus Christ is the Son of God (QS 4:157).
IF Islamic endtimes is FULFILLED, a future Islamic leader will be Antichrist because he will deny that Jesus Christ is the Son of God.
IF Islamic end times is FULFILLED, Gog and Magog (the Antichrist and his alliance of nations) will certainly be Islamic in nature: an Islamic Antichrist, likely the Mahdi, and his KINGDOM (Caliphate)-a confederation of Middle East nations (but not limited to the Islamic Middle East). China and Russia? Maybe!
The alliance of nations led by Gog will be set on destroying the nation of Israel because the false god of this world, who is disguised as the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob and as the god of righteousness and light (2 Corinthians 11:13-14), is set against the HOLY COVENANT God has with Israel. Why does Allah want to commit a mass genocide against God's chosen nation?
While he watched the zombie movie, Can some one please tell him to watch a movie called “the wonder women” then he will know if they existed some where or not.
As a former Christian it pains me to see him doing this. I copped pleas for Adam, Noah and his impossible flood, Abraham Isaac, Jacob, Joshua and Water walking Jesus. It’s best to just let legends be legends. Why defend the indefensible??
Quranic story is simple.
Some people asked Dhul Qarnain to build a wall to protect them from yajuj majuj.
Someday they will be back .....
I dont think a muslim is required to believe anything more than that.
omer ali exactly, I really don’t see a problem, anything after that is up to interpretation, its not like this is a pillar of out faith, only something concerning the end days
I am muslim and yet I will say your response is very weak. As Yasir Qadhi rightly points, where are they on earth? they were not two people, they were a nation, a nation that is supposedly alive and will come back, from where? the whole earth has been mapped.
Sheikh imran hosein, interpretation is very easyer to understand yajuj and majuj
tbh I think the only reason he allows his cognitive dissonance to overflow his logical reasoning is simply because he's invested too much into Islam to leave it now. Also its not as simple as leaving any other religion. if you leave Islam, you lose everything, your family, friends and most likely if youre a scholar, your job.
Friend, Qhadi has a point! Who really are the true Gog and Magog?
The original and true prophecy of Gog and Magog is the 3000 year old prophecy from the book of Ezekiel chapters 38 and 39. READ THE TWO CHAPTERS FOR YOURSELF; It will be the difference between eternity in heaven and eternity in hell!
This original account is 1500 years before Qur'an 18:94 and the hadiths and it makes far better sense than the tale of the two corrupting subhuman tribes found in the hadiths. Already, part of the prophecy of Ezekiel has been fulfilled!
Manuscripts of Ezekiel were also found among the Dead Sea scrolls which are dated 300 years before Jesus and confirm the current contents of Ezekiel as genuine.
I understand that it will be surprising for Muslims to learn that the hadiths misrepresent A LOT of end time prophecies especially from the New Testament book of Revelations (written almost 750 years before the collection of the hadiths) and in so doing placed Muslims on the wrong side of the future! The manuscripts of the book of Revelations from BEFORE Muhammad are still available today.
Who are the original and true Gog and Magog?
Gog is a RULER and Magog is his KINGDOM (Ezekiel 38:2)-like a Khalifa and Caliphate. Gog is the prophesied ruler of Magog. Gog is the real Antichrist (not the mythical one-eyed Al-Maseeh al-Dajjaal of the hadiths!). Gog/the Antichrist will be used by Satan in the last 7 years of the world to oppose the HOLY COVENANT (Daniel 11:28) God has with the nation of Israel (Deuteronomy 29:13).
In modern terms, Magog will be the Antichrist's alliance of 10 nations (Ezekiel 38:5 or Revelations 17:12-13) supporting his satanic cause of committing a mass genocide against the nation of Israel because of Satan's hatred of the holy covenant God has with Israel (Ezekiel 38:8).
The God who has a long standing covenant with Israel is the God whose name is the God of Abraham, Isaac and and Jacob, NOT Allah, (the two are not the same God!) because Allah seeks to commit a mass genocide against Jews in the end times (Saheeh hadith 2922) to the point even hiding behind a rock won't protect the Jews from being killed by Allah's forces.
In Saheeh Muslim (2922), the Messenger of Allah said: “The Hour will not begin until the Muslims fight the Jews and the Muslims will kill them, until a Jew hides behind a rock or a tree, and the rock or tree will say: O Muslim, O slave of Allah, there is a Jew behind me, come and kill him".
According to the hadiths, the imposter of Jesus Christ (the Islamic Prophet Isa) who is a Jew, will be leading Allah's armies AGAINST the Jews, God's chosen nation! Does this make sense to you?
WHO ARE THE FOLLOWERS OF GOG AND MAGOG (THE ANTICHRIST)? COULD YOU BE AMONG THEM?
The true definition of Antichrist is first ever used in the Gospels (which, if you believe the Qur'an, are confirmed as the eternal and unalterable (incorruptible) word of Allah and which Christians "have with them" (in the 7th century) and should judge themselves by: (QS 18:27, 5:43, 5:47, 3:3-4, 6:115 and 7:157). It's the Qur'ans dilemma!
According to the Gospels, the Antichrist and his followers are those who deny that Jesus is the Son of God and is ONE with the father:
"Who is a liar but he who denies that Jesus is the Christ? He is ANTICHRIST who denies the Father and the Son. Whoever denies the Son does not have the Father either; he who acknowledges the Son has the Father also." [1John 2:22-23]
It is therefore a fact of life that the theology of the Qur'an and Islam is openly antichrist as it DENIES-6 CENTURIES AFTER THE EVENT and against the testimony of his Mother, Mary and the disciple John who were with him on the cross-that Jesus Christ was crucified (QS 19:91-92) and that Jesus Christ is the Son of God (QS 4:157).
IF Islamic endtimes is FULFILLED, a future Islamic leader will be Antichrist because he will deny that Jesus Christ is the Son of God.
IF Islamic end times is FULFILLED, Gog and Magog (the Antichrist and his alliance of nations) will certainly be Islamic in nature: an Islamic Antichrist, likely the Mahdi, and his KINGDOM (Caliphate)-a confederation of Middle East nations (but not limited to the Islamic Middle East). China and Russia? Maybe!
The alliance of nations led by Gog will be set on destroying the nation of Israel because the false god of this world, who is disguised as the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob and as the god of righteousness and light (2 Corinthians 11:13-14), is set against the HOLY COVENANT God has with Israel. Why does Allah want to commit a mass genocide against God's chosen nation?
It does have definitive correct answer even though, as always when religion is mixed in, the arguments will never cease and even the correct definitive answer will usually be ignored or rejected because it is only accepted by the few who are intellectually free.
Ya'juj and Ma'juj have long since "escaped" ... the barrier has long since served its purpose ... they have long since spread out, living their lives. They are normal people, historically known, and their descendants are living among us as Muslims, Christians, Buddists, atheists, etc. They have countries that still bear their names because of historical association (Ya'juj = Of Juj = Of Gorg = Georgia, and Mongolia = the land of Ma'juj/Magog), they have had great leaders, like Genghis Khan, and have invaded, conquered and had their days of Empire like many others before and after them.
But those who are easily bedazzled and swayed by fairytales and myths and ridiculous made-up prophecies will continue to be confused and continue to argue.
Set religion aside, think like a historian, and it's clear as daylight.
"intellectually free"?? If you are genuinely open to *all* possibilities, - including the possibility the Qur'an is man-made and contains myths - I would agree with you. But tell me honestly, are you genuinely open to that possibility? Or is your starting point a firm conviction that it is the word of God? If the latter then that's not "intellectually free".
@@HassanRadwan133
Yes I believe I am open to that possibility; I have considered it, still consider it, will continue to consider it. Just like other things. Who wants to believe or be tricked into a falsehood? Do you think it isn't impossible that someone who is intellectually free (relatively speaking of course, because we all ultimately rely on others' works) can be firmly convinced of the Qur'an or of the existence of God?
But really I was just talking about this story which the Qur'an relates (according to its internal narrative) upon request rather than spontaneously. So it was known, it was a part of history up to that point (whether factual or not). Stories and HIStories are transmitted from earlier times. You don't need to believe in God or that the Qur'an is from God to see clearly who Ya'juj and Ma'juj were/are. You just need to follow the his-tory and be free of the surrounding myths that developed post-Qur'an. That's all I was really getting at.
If these later post-Qur'anic myths and end-of-times tales are added to something that its core is factual or itself a myth is something else. Is the story of Alexander the Great's building of the Caspian Gates true or man-made? I have no reason to doubt it is true.
Dr Yasir said that Gog and Magog can't survive in cave.
Fact : A cave in Romania about 5 millions year old have its own ecosystem.
What if Allah is sustaining them ?
Uhhh? So where is the big wall?
Salam. YQ said there is only ONE hadith that gives the impression that Yajuj and Majuj are still currently alive, and previous scholars have said that that hadith is weak, and therefore it is not Islamically obligatory to believe they are currently still alive. They were alive in the past, and we believe their "children" will be alive/active in the future. Shaikh Hossein may be right, but every human can be right or wrong. YQ understands it how he does, there isn't anything wrong Islamically with either viewpoint. Check his latest video with Muhammad Hijab.
@@OriginalAndroidPhone please think for yourself we don't need to follow these preachers
You can not accept the fact that you have been lied that your book is perfect and it has no lies.
Mr. Yasir Khadi is the rarest honest Muslim.
Yasir Qadhi is very brave to take on this issue head on but not so brave as to admit the obvious that the story is a myth. the power of faith!
I wonder why many musim apologist fear people that left Islam. If their religion is true they should not worry about it.
That's real struggle 😬
@Islam Safari he really seems like he's just one step away from it and he knows it.
L. J. Agreed! Is he now an Ahlus sunna wa Jamaa or salafi?
10:30 How much more explicit can the texts be?
Thank you Hassan, Another great video to pointed out that the words of Allah in the Qur'an are more confusing and doesn't make sense to me gradually..
It is really hurts me in a way that i am a devoted muslim for 40 plus year..
I know how you feel, my friend.
Video is cut in so many places ,it cant be used as valid source to learn about this topic.
I have a long comment for this video. I hope you will read it until the end.
I agree with you that their explanation sounds sometimes like a fairy-tale and myth, and unfortunately, not well researched.
But I have to say that the story of Dhul-Qarnayn in Quran is one of my favourite. I will explain you why.
Dhul-Qarnayn was a very just and powerful ruler who was not an oppressor. (He might be Cyrus the Great or Darius the Great or another character from the history. I read their biographies. There are some parallels.) No matter who he was, the point is that he didn't oppress people he ruled and treated them very well (see surah Al-Kahf). And even helped people to escape the oppression of a very cruel tribe (who were mostly thieves, rapists, cannibals). According to my research, the oppressed people were ancestors of nowadays Georgians, the so called Colchian or/and Iberians living near the Caucasus mountains and speaking Kartvellian language, very different from other languages of the surrounding areas (it is also referenced in the surah Al-Kahf). If you look at the Caucasus mountains there is one narrow pass in the middle called Darial Gorge (there is also another pass called Derbent pass but it is located near Caspian sea far from Georgians). According to my research the massive Iron wall was built on the Darial Gorge between two mountains (This place has a lot of iron ores). It made ancestors of Georgians feel safe for centuries (this is not an uncommon practice in the history - Great Wall of China against various nomadic groups from the Eurasian Steppe, Trump wanted to build a wall to "save" US from Mexican immigrants).
The oppressors were according to my research Skythians or their descendents Khazars. In one of Georgian mythologies, ancestors of Georgians who were suffering from the attacks of Khazars were describing them as Gog and Magog and saying that they were thieves, cruel like beasts and ate human flesh. I checked all kind of sources from the history to get this information together (I can give you sources if you are interested to read).
When the Iron wall was removed (I couldn't find exactly when it might happen. Maybe some time between 8th or 12th century.) In one of the Hadith, it is mentioned that they said "inshaAllah" short before the Wall was destroyed. It can refer to the event when they started practicing one of the monotheistic religions (Judaism). According to the historical sources, rulers of this tribe accepted this religion for political reasons (you can read more details in the book of "Thirteenth Tribe" by Arthur Koestler, the author is Jewish himself). The commoners as it normally happens in the history took the religion very seriously and started practicing it in their life (similar to Romans, when Constantin embraced Christianity because of the politics, after a while the commoners became very religious Christians). One of the belief of Judaism is that Jews are not allowed to have their own state. That is why, sticking strictly to the laws of Torah, they stopped being a state and spread around the globe. Most of the Jews nowadays are white and originating from Caucasus mountains (see the Book 13th Tribe by Koestler, as I mentioned above the author himself is Jewish and did a very good research on the history of Khazars, I recommend you to read it).
The Elites of this tribe has always played a big role in the history of mankind, probably starting to be very relevant during the European colonisation of the world (or earlier). The colonialists were taking away resources, damaging the environment, causing poverty and bringing their own system in these regions which didn't always benefit the indigenous people (do you see parallels with the description of Gog and Magog? They were oppressing common people which is the opposite of how Dhul-Qarnayn was ruling). Last few centuries, the elites of this tribe were behind the most of the big wars (Napoleon's battle of Waterloo, World Wars etc.). The main function of wars was/is to destroy the existing system and establish a new system which profits the elites. You can read this from different historical sources. In fact, the west ruled by the elites of this tribe is still taking away valuable resources from the third world countries. Banking system with currency inflation and interest rates is making people poor every day. Most of the people are not informed or ignorant of what is going on in the World because the system is so complex and there are so many distractions like social media, games, movies etc. We don't have time to do the real research. Media also influences our view of the world. We cannot deny this anymore. What was not normal before, is normalised with the influence of the media, be it habits, our desires etc. For example, COVID became number one star within few days because of the media and is still popular for about 1.5 years. This is just one example. And there are many.
I did this research for a long time using different sources to verify my findings. Of course, I am not 100% sure if this is true. But based on everything I read until now, it makes the most sense. I am not done with my readings yet and my views might change with time.
Since you also like diving deep into the scientific and historical books, I thought maybe my views and conclusions will also be food for thought for you.
Happy weekend :)
Thank you for sharing your thoughts
@@HassanRadwan133unbelievable what he is talking in this video whereas there are so many tafsirs and history books which give a better, reasonable and historical explanation on Yajuj and Majuj. Sounds like he watched too many Hollywood/marvel movies :( I also watched other videos on this topic, and I am more than disappointed. The quality of information regarding the important topics in Quran on UA-cam is so low (be it miracles, historical events). Since youtube/internet is mostly an only source that youth is using to learn about Islam, so disappointing that these scholars neglect their responsibility and don't do a proper research. I hope that they will watch your videos and reflect on themselves..
Thank you very much for your kind words and unparalleled wisdom. What you said is what I have come across exactly with little differences. The problem of many of us Muslims is that we don't do research and read the Quran and hadith as it is supposed to be. In the end we look intellectually deficient and challenged. Yajuj wa Majuj are already out and in full control of the entire political, economic, financial institutions across the globe. I quote Samuel P Huntington's clash of civilizations and Remaking of World Order on pages 81and 82 and he says about the Western civilization in general : They
1. Own and operate the international banking system
2. Control all hard currencies
3. Are the world's principal customers
4. Provide the majority of the world's finished goods
5. Dominate international capital markets
6. Exert control over many societies
7. Are capable of massive military intervention
8. Control the sea lanes
9.conduct most advanced research
10. Control leading education
11. Dominate access to space
12. Dominate aerospace industry
13. Dominate international communications
14. Dominate the high tech industry.
That's Yajuj wa Majuj if you read the requisite ayat and ahadith on Yajuj wa Majuj. Hasn't the prophet prophet Muhammad(saw) said in a hadithul qudsi that Yajuj wa Majuj will NOT be destroyed by any people except by Allah. No one people Russians or Chinese will defeat them except by divine intervention. They can only checkmate them.
The Quran is very fundamental but its other pieces require another faculty to deduce what's going on. The faculty of interpretation, taaweel here now is important and not tafseer.
His "friend" is the voice in his head lmao
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
I agree with U
I think this maybe it where I completely draw the line in my disbelief now. It was one hell of a ride but farewell. I was an ex-muslim but gave a tad chance to Islam. But this is the conclusion.
Please read this book written by a prolific Islamic Scholar Imran N Hossein on Yajuj And Majuj 👇👇👇
www.geopolitica.ru/sites/default/files/hosein_gog_magog.pdf
Dali Atheism has lots of problems with the whole humanity that’s why they kicked the religion out of politics in the early 20th century and caused WW1 and WW2 resulting in the killing of millions all because the so-called atheists wanted to achieve world peace. These atheists, seculars and liberals are still searching for peace, i wonder when they’ll achieve that peace may be you know the answer🤔
There is a book by the name of Encyclopaedia of war which says that from 8000BC to 2000AD humanity fought 1763 wars and only 121 war were fought by religion and guess what...the remaining 93% wars were fought by atheists secularists and Liberals 😱😱
@@anonymousincognitoo Brother there just needs to be a straightforward answer with this. The Qur'an and Hadiths have been interpreted in so many ways there should not be a variety of mental gymnastics as seen from the highly intellectual scholars like Hijab. I need 100% truth in this
Nazmul Islam Please read this book written by a prolific Islamic Scholar Imran N Hossein on Yajuj And Majuj 👇👇👇
www.geopolitica.ru/sites/default/files/hosein_gog_magog.pdf
Brother the release of Yajuj and Majuj is linked to the return of the Israelite Jews to the Holy Land (Jerusalem) as mentioned in Chapter 21, Verses 95-96 of the Glorious Quran. Jews returned to Jerusalem, after more than 2000 years, right after Balfour Declaration in 1917 and after that mankind witnessed League of Nations in 1920 which gave way to the creation of Passport in 1920 after that in 1924 Visa Regulations came and than in 1926 border security forces were installed on each countries’ border and than the world was imprisoned in cages on the basis of race, colour, creed, tongue and territory. Around 1920 the concept of Nation States engulfed the whole world Around 1920, mankind for the first time witnessed the global usage of the paper money as a medium of exchange which became very prevalent after Bretton woods accord in 1944. Around 1920, the world’s very first miss world competition was inaugurated which brought the women into the market so that their bodies could be used as means to expand the frontiers of capitalism. Around 1920 very first nude beach came into existence in Germany.
In other words, when you see Israeliste Jews being brought back to the holy land than that means that their return could only have become possible because of the assistance from Yajuj and Majuj who are the Modern wester Judeo-Christian goddless Civilisation because they have been trying for a thousand years to liberate Jerusalem. The first crusade was launched around 1096 by the Western Europe (Western Christianity) while Easter European Byzantine Empire (Eastern Orthodox Christianity) did not participated in the crusades. The crusaders failed to permanently hold the control of Jerusalem. Meanwhile, in 1897 only the European Jews established the Zionist movement to launch a struggle calling all the jews to return to their promised land. And than finally in 1917 the Secular Europe under the leadership of Great Britain issued the Balfour Declaration resulting in the liberation of Jerusalem and from 1918 up until 1947 Britain allowed the return of the jews to the Holy land, some from the front door and a lot from the back door secretly.
In short, the original Yajuj and Majuj are located in the Western European Christians as well as Jews and also the former USSR which was the product of Jews like Trotsky who, along with many other zionist Jews, cause the Russian Revolution. But the world as whole will follow the original thus Yajuj and Majuj will make their carbon copies by making people follow their life style either by hook or by crook.
Brother there can be a lot that I can write but it’s not possible right now, therefore I urge you to please read the aforementioned book by clicking the link. Hope this will develop an interest in you to read the book. Thank you!
Without going into any kind of debate i am firm believer that there are so many things that Human race is still not been able to understand yet revealed in Quran as so many things we understood not at the time of revelation but during the course of 14 centuries gradually when human intellect, science, knowledge base expanded and started understanding those issues. Gog & Magog is also among those issues that still we humans can't fully understand but this has already started getting revealed and myths being created around this revelation of Quran have already fading out. Some scholars have also done good work in understanding this issue and in my opinion they have already solved some of the puzzles around this issue. If brother Yasir is interested i can share some material that could form basis of new research. Quan never told us not to dig out issues like these but it always encourages us (both believers and non believers) to do efforts, research and think deep to understand these issues even if it takes a very long time is understand. Allah has no problem we understand few things after 2 or 3 of may be 10 thousand years later. He is not in hurry at all. For example the notion of Quran that on the day of judgement whole life of a human being good and bad both deeds would be given to him in his or her hand and he would not need any help to believe that but he or she would be accepting and admitting that yes I did all this. Rather he or she would admit that no smallest sin or smallest good deed was missed. Now only in the end of 20th century Human being are able to clearly understood this after nearly 14 centuries. Issue of Gog Magog may take few more centuries of millennia to fully understood or may be few can soon reach the depth of the mystery with the divine help.
You are in denial my friend.
@@innocentmushi3036 no dear I am not in denial I am in a process of learning. Ready to change my own opinion if find some logic.
don't take his opinion as a muslim majority opinion. Same as we don't understand how Adam was created from dust / mud and we don't understand how the false Messiah Al-Dajjal is already alive, we cannot fathom the existance of Gog and Magog, but we still believe it, because we have divine text to prove it.
Who really are the true Gog and Magog?
The original and true prophecy of Gog and Magog is the 3000 year old prophecy from the book of Ezekiel chapters 38 and 39. READ THE TWO CHAPTERS FOR YOURSELF; It will be the difference between eternity in heaven and eternity in hell!
This original account is 1500 years before Qur'an 18:94 and the hadiths and it makes far better sense than the tale of the two corrupting subhuman tribes found in the hadiths. Already, part of the prophecy of Ezekiel has been fulfilled!
Manuscripts of Ezekiel were also found among the Dead Sea scrolls which are dated 300 years before Jesus and confirm the current contents of Ezekiel as genuine.
I understand that it will be surprising for Muslims to learn that the hadiths misrepresent A LOT of end time prophecies especially from the New Testament book of Revelations (written almost 750 years before the collection of the hadiths) and in so doing placed Muslims on the wrong side of the future! The manuscripts of the book of Revelations from BEFORE Muhammad are still available today.
Who are the original and true Gog and Magog?
Gog is a RULER and Magog is his KINGDOM (Ezekiel 38:2)-like a Khalifa and Caliphate. Gog is the prophesied ruler of Magog. Gog is the real Antichrist (not the mythical one-eyed Al-Maseeh al-Dajjaal of the hadiths!). Gog/the Antichrist will be used by Satan in the last 7 years of the world to oppose the HOLY COVENANT (Daniel 11:28) God has with the nation of Israel (Deuteronomy 29:13).
In modern terms, Magog will be the Antichrist's alliance of 10 nations (Ezekiel 38:5 or Revelations 17:12-13) supporting his satanic cause of committing a mass genocide against the nation of Israel because of Satan's hatred of the holy covenant God has with Israel (Ezekiel 38:8).
The God who has a long standing covenant with Israel is the God whose name is the God of Abraham, Isaac and and Jacob, NOT Allah, (the two are not the same God!) because Allah seeks to commit a mass genocide against Jews in the end times (Saheeh hadith 2922) to the point even hiding behind a rock won't protect the Jews from being killed by Allah's forces.
In Saheeh Muslim (2922), the Messenger of Allah said: “The Hour will not begin until the Muslims fight the Jews and the Muslims will kill them, until a Jew hides behind a rock or a tree, and the rock or tree will say: O Muslim, O slave of Allah, there is a Jew behind me, come and kill him".
According to the hadiths, the imposter of Jesus Christ (the Islamic Prophet Isa) who is a Jew, will be leading Allah's armies AGAINST the Jews, God's chosen nation! Does this make sense to you?
WHO ARE THE FOLLOWERS OF GOG AND MAGOG (THE ANTICHRIST)? COULD YOU BE AMONG THEM?
The true definition of Antichrist is first ever used in the Gospels (which, if you believe the Qur'an, are confirmed as the eternal and unalterable (incorruptible) word of Allah and which Christians "have with them" (in the 7th century) and should judge themselves by: (QS 18:27, 5:43, 5:47, 3:3-4, 6:115 and 7:157). It's the Qur'ans dilemma!
According to the Gospels, the Antichrist and his followers are those who deny that Jesus is the Son of God and is ONE with the father:
"Who is a liar but he who denies that Jesus is the Christ? He is ANTICHRIST who denies the Father and the Son. Whoever denies the Son does not have the Father either; he who acknowledges the Son has the Father also." [1John 2:22-23]
It is therefore a fact of life that the theology of the Qur'an and Islam is openly antichrist as it DENIES-6 CENTURIES AFTER THE EVENT and against the testimony of his Mother, Mary and the disciple John who were with him on the cross-that Jesus Christ was crucified (QS 19:91-92) and that Jesus Christ is the Son of God (QS 4:157).
IF Islamic endtimes is FULFILLED, a future Islamic leader will be Antichrist because he will deny that Jesus Christ is the Son of God.
IF Islamic end times is FULFILLED, Gog and Magog (the Antichrist and his alliance of nations) will certainly be Islamic in nature: an Islamic Antichrist, likely the Mahdi, and his KINGDOM (Caliphate)-a confederation of Middle East nations (but not limited to the Islamic Middle East). China and Russia? Maybe!
The alliance of nations led by Gog will be set on destroying the nation of Israel because the false god of this world, who is disguised as the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob and as the god of righteousness and light (2 Corinthians 11:13-14), is set against the HOLY COVENANT God has with Israel. Why does Allah want to commit a mass genocide against God's chosen nation?
the main problem for me in metaphorical interpretation is the slipery slope of applying it to any verse or story sounding too illogical or irrational or severe in the quran. "dont beat your wife literally no! only in a metaphorical sense!"
like... beat her in a game of chess?
٩٥ وَحَرَامٌ عَلَىٰ قَرْيَةٍ أَهْلَكْنَاهَا أَنَّهُمْ لَا يَرْجِعُونَ
95:21 And there is a ban upon a community which We have destroyed: that they shall not return.
٩٦ حَتَّىٰ إِذَا فُتِحَتْ يَأْجُوجُ وَمَأْجُوجُ وَهُمْ مِنْ كُلِّ حَدَبٍ يَنْسِلُونَ
96:21 Until, when Gog and Magog are let loose, and they hasten out of every mound,
May Allah Guide him and US
The more one increases in knowledge, the more one increases in tolerance. And the less read one is, the easier it becomes to ascribe deviancy to a view that one has not come across before.
The teacher of our teacher, Sh. Abd al-Raḥmān al-Sa'dī (d. 1956), claimed that Ya'jūj and Ma'jūj were not tribes trapped behind an existing wall, because that was something that was not proven by the Quran or Sunnah, and something that he said modern science (in his day!) didn't back up. He claimed that they must therefore be something else - his view was that although originally they might have been Mongolian tribes, in our times, they are the biological and intellectual descendants of those tribes, and hence he included Russians and Americans and other peoples.
Before him, Shaykh Anwar Shah al-Kashmīrī (d. 1933) also posited that the wall of Dhul-Qarnayn no longer existed and that Ya'juj and Ma'juj were some type of current populations. Now, while I personally don't agree with the details of either of their opinions, the fact of the matter is that these great scholars (and others) within mainstream Sunnī Islam challenged the classical view, based on their understanding of the Quran and Sunnah, and their understanding of the knowledge that the modern world conveys.
All too often, a beginning student of knowledge mistakes 𝑡ℎ𝑒𝑖𝑟 𝑖𝑛𝑡𝑒𝑟𝑝𝑟𝑒𝑡𝑎𝑡𝑖𝑜𝑛 of the Quran and Sunnah as 𝑡ℎ𝑒 Quran and Sunnah. In the 1950s, scholars who didn't understand Sh. al-Sa'dī's paradigm accused him of being a deviant who rejects the Sunnah, and even filed a Royal complaint against him with King Ibn Sa'ūd. The King called him to a conference convened for his sake, with a group of scholars, and the Shaykh defended his paradigm with such a profundity that none of the scholars who accused him had anything left to say. Even if they didn't agree with his view, they couldn't fault him for having an alternative view, because his uṣūl (or paradigm) were valid.
My views on Ya'jūj and Ma'jūj are just that: my views. I could be wrong, and every scholar or student of knowledge has the right to accept or reject or academically critique them. No problem.
What *is* a problem, of the highest magnitude, and one that, if it persists after this post, I will sue for in the Court of Allah on Judgment Day, is the outright and blatant lie that I reject the Quran or authentic Sunnah based on the claim that they are illogical or irrational.
What is a lie, based on jumping on an ambiguous word or two and reading in a meaning that is clearly not intended as the context shows, is the claim that I mock the classical scholars of Islam.
Both of these are outright slanders against me.
I reiterate: from my perspective, I agree with Sh. al-Sa'dī and many of his students (and perhaps at a later time I will also explain some interesting side notes about my teacher Ibn `Uthaymīn and his views Ya'juj and Ma'juj - but that is another post): the Quran and authentic Hadith do not require us to believe that there are hundreds of millions of people still hiding somewhere on this earth. If you feel that the Quran or Sunnah asks us to believe that, fair enough, that is your view, based on what Hadith you consider valid and how you choose to interpret them.
Final point, to really illustrate my paradigm: the rising of the Sun from the West is far more 'problematic' view to hold from a purely physical and scientific perspective. The mechanisms of how that would occur are simply beyond the domain of scientific possibility given our current understanding of physics. Yet, because the authentic Sunnah is so explicit on this point, and because I feel that there is no room for re-interpretation, I have no choice but to accept it because that is what īman dictates, and Allah is indeed capable of all things. We do not decide the validity of a Hadith based on whether it is rational or not, but the question is: what exactly is the Quran or authentic Hadith asking us to believe? This is the argument that I am making in my lectures on Ya'jūj and Ma'jūj.
May Allah protect us from solving this problem in this world by ever having to see the reality of Ya'jūj and Ma'jūj!!
Yasir Qadhi's response
You should really read the comments on the original video guys. cognitive dissonance and confirmation bias in full effect.
Please read this book written by a prolific Islamic Scholar Imran N Hossein on Yajuj And Majuj 👇👇👇
www.geopolitica.ru/sites/default/files/hosein_gog_magog.pdf
@@anonymousincognitoo never heard of Imran N. Hosein
Why is abrahamic god in release 1.0,1.1,1.2 so angry, so bloodthirsty, so narcissictic, so full of human psychological problems?,,,,
Is he lonely or did we sick bastards projected our fears into a fairytale being?
Why 3 unclear books about the same god? Is our almighty god not able to write one clear book for all humanity, so he has to try 3 times and fails miserbly every time?
Will he burn in hell for causing separation, hate and bloodbaths in his name for millenia?
My friend Hassan, with all due respect just because your or my intellect or Yassir Qadhis for that matter cannot reconcile something, that does not mean that it is not true, if one believes in the One True God that created everyone and everything and is completely powerful over all things, and one believes that the Quran is from the Creator, then one would not question something like how theses tribes yajuj and majuj could remain somewhere for thousands of years. It is quite simple.
I am not attacking you my friend but rather pointing out this is not that strange. I myself am British and became Muslim 9 years ago and Al Hamdulilah (all praise is due to the One True God) for this favour.
Do you believe God is rational? If you do, then he must act rationally. That is the only way that we can know him. An irrational God is no better than a crazy person with a shotgun. We don't know what will trigger them. How is Islam any truer than Buddhism (or any other 4,000+ religion out there) if you cannot use reason to compare it?
Salam. YQ in his latest video with Muhammad Hijab said there is only ONE hadith that gives the impression that Yajuj and Majuj are still currently alive, and previous scholars have said that that hadith is weak, and therefore it is not Islamically obligatory to believe they are currently still alive.
@@OriginalAndroidPhone OK. And how many Islamic scholars agree with him? Is he even an Islamic scholar?
Don't listen to these psychos. Listen to salafi scholars
Liam Gallgher
Isn’t yasir qadhi a salafi?
So the coronavirus is gog and magog?
Its a creature that looks like a dog monkey werewolf.
Skip to min 30
ua-cam.com/video/NAb5WpRkuB8/v-deo.html
@@Conekiller29 It was a sarcastic comment, mate.
My view is simply we do not have full info or background regarding this hadith, especially from the Sahabah or the Prophet himself, it is therefore up for speculation regarding the deeper meanings or realities of it. I don't see the need to go that deeply into it as it does not have a impact on our daily lives. Yasir Qadhi states from ibn Kathir that it may be borrowed from banu Israel.
classic sweeping under the rug cope
Hi Hassan Radwan
Other EX muslims are interviewing and discussing with mufti abu layth. It would be nice to see a discussion with MUFTI ABU LAYTH about the 100% clear cut mistakes and how the verses of the Quran go against the voice of REASON with yourself.
I am aware you actually believe in the God but do not believe in religion. So it would be nice discussing with mufti Abu layth and showing him clear cut verses that goes against the voice of reason.
The reason I am saying this is because MUFTI ABU LAYTH has replied to alot of the doubts EX muslims bring about the Quran and proves that they are not mistakes and uses the voice of REASON TOO.
Mufti abu layth's defence of the QURAN AND SUNNAH is VERY VERY POWERFUL.
So it would be nice to see yourself discussing and proving to mufti that the quran is clearly against the voice of REASON.
Love and peace to you all!
I feel old asking this :(
He says the young can tell the elders what the genre of these movies is
Some1 tell me please
Zombie movies
Very Brave Sir. thanks
Theres one more the sura also describes people that sleep for such time without food and water , so somthing might be there that is hidden from us and living in some ways 😂
Did you leave Islam?
Is this the same who was talking about the evolution theory?
Yasir want to reinvent this interpretation? But in other things “what’s written is written and can’t be interpreted”? 🤔
About yajuj and maijuj
Funny people think Alexander aka dhul Qar'nain who build as Muslim
when he was a known homosexual
Allah knows best
Maybe Yasir Quadi would look into Artificial Intelligence. Because AI sounds pretty like Yajuj Majuj!
not remotely close