Sherlock | Vivisection (Sherlock & Molly)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 25 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 55

  • @reignreigngoawayy
    @reignreigngoawayy 4 роки тому +75

    love the part when sherlock said “people always give up after 3” then you inserted the scene where sherlock told molly that moriarty made a mistake: that moriarty thought there were only 3 important people to sherlock’s life. he forgot about molly and that was his biggest mistake since molly helped sherlock faked his death. this video is so new and perfect! i hope more people find it.

  • @katrinafeldmane9515
    @katrinafeldmane9515 5 місяців тому +6

    The 2nd "I love you" was admission for himself. Such emotion.

  • @user-pg5cn7uf6n
    @user-pg5cn7uf6n 4 роки тому +104

    can we talk about the connections that the whole shows seemingly has with how Sherlock feels about Molly??? I love how your videos connects them. I would've never made them. Thank you for the lovely video.

    • @ohifonlyx33
      @ohifonlyx33 Рік тому +10

      Seriously. Everywhere I look I see another little connection that makes me believe Sherlock meant it when he said ILY. Even the reoccurring lines about eating chips or dinner is interesting... Sherlock is known not to eat while he's on a case as it slows him down... and of course, he's married to the work. So at the beginning of the series Molly starts by asking Sherlock out for Coffee meant to be a romantic invitation, now follow that metaphor throughout the series and we see Molly state SHE is getting chips and when she starts to ask if Sherlock wants "anything" she changes her mind and answers for him that she knows he doesn't. But Sherlock actually looks like he was about to ask for something. We also see Sherlock cancel Molly's lunch date to work/eat with him. And then most notably, while he's working on a case with her, he asks her if she wants chips. So much for not eating while working... so much for not being intrested...
      He also pays special care to ask for her forgiveness when he is wrong and feels bad about disappointing her (her slap is embedded in his memories and used to save his life).
      Obviously John is his bestie and most important friendship in the show... but John doesn't always see Sherlock as human... Molly saw him looking sad and asked if he needed help in such a real way and when Sherlock went to her with a request, he openly showed emotion... and when John is angry at him, the next person he turns to is Molly.
      The interesting thing is that while he blatently pretends to have feelings for Janine, he clearly is not acting like himself, but donning a persona. With Irene, there's a game to be won (she clearly wants to dominate his will and he clearly doesn't want to lose to her). But with Molly... she sees the sad person underneath, and even if he's not everything they say he is,, she would still want to help him. Which over time seems to make him less guarded around her, less dismissive of her feelings. As if he's no longer acting.

  • @mstrikeout
    @mstrikeout 4 роки тому +96

    ohh this was truly beautiful! Especially the parts when Molly says "fall now" and he goes "I love you" and when Mrs Hudson says that whenever he can't answer something, he stabs it AND THEN HE DESTROYS THE COFFIN GHROGRHO really beautiful and emotional video! Also thanks for bringing some sherlock back into my youtube feed! :D

  • @rainestoehr431
    @rainestoehr431 4 роки тому +51

    Just when I think I’m passed Sherlock and Molly, something new pops up and drags me right back into my favorite ship. This was wonderful, great work yet again.

  • @evelyncristinamejiacarrasc3049
    @evelyncristinamejiacarrasc3049 4 роки тому +39

    I have no words to express my feelings right now. Found this on tumblr and ran here to save it. I love these two so much, reminded me of when I started shipping 6 years ago, and it feels amazing after all this time

  • @ayanieb.1226
    @ayanieb.1226 4 роки тому +38

    This is brilliantly made! Sherlock have burried his emotions this vivisection opened it. I love it! I still do believe that he loves Molly passively, though. Throughout the season she's the only one he let to see his vulnerable side. If John is his weak point, Molly is his strength. Thank you for this wonderful work!

  • @anastasiyapresnjakova3060
    @anastasiyapresnjakova3060 4 роки тому +27

    «I have this terrible feeling from time to time that we all might humans»
    First of all I want to thank you. Your works are something special, something that makes me think and analyze what was been show and told. Even though they haven’t got these cool colourings and video effects, but they have got The Stories. And I appreciate them much. I’ve already watched your work about 10 times, and of course I will more, but the first impression is something you want to share with.
    Vivisection is the practice of performing operations for the purpose of experimentation or scientific research (used only by opponents of such work). It’s ruthlessly sharp and detailed criticism or analysis. You’ve made your vivisection again with this video (I adore three parts of your detailed analysis), I’ve got a feeling that you wanted to point that Euros and Molly have much in common. They see “true” Sherlock hidden deep even from himself. And the true aim of the Final Problem was to open his «little emotions» about his friendship, family and friends. What he really feels. And I like that you added Missis Hudson words about Sherlock. She could see quite well «through his bullshit» too.
    My favourite part of this is The Fall and how you’ve literally played with the falling. To fall in love with someone is like a jump in uncertainty. And maybe the true meaning of the “Reichbach fall” was a Sherlock’s sacrifice to the people he appreciated. «You do count». The sacrifice was for Molly too. And maybe this test was his “final falling” into the emotions.
    Thank you one more time. And I’m really sorry for the long comment.

    • @mathilde-with-an-e
      @mathilde-with-an-e  4 роки тому +5

      Never be sorry for a long comment. I am enchanted. I don't think there is a higher praise than encouraging people to analyse the medium and go deeper. And what a wonderful analysis indeed! It means a great deal to me. I am very grateful that you took the time to tell me such lovely things :) Thank you so so very much.

  • @Munchlette_Belle
    @Munchlette_Belle Рік тому +5

    Every few months for the past couple of years, I come back to this video to watch it again because I love it so much. I enjoy rewatching all of your Sherlock/Molly videos but this one is my favorite. I love the music in this and the ways you link up dialogue from different parts of the show to create the narrative. I just wanted you to know that I don't just watch your videos and move on, they absolutely live in my head and I come back to them over and over again.

    • @mathilde-with-an-e
      @mathilde-with-an-e  Рік тому +1

      🥹🥲😭😭 I can only DREAM of doing to others what movies and shows do to me. And to read this, well…. I am floored. I cannot possibly express in writing how precious this is to me but it really, really is. This is what I secretly want to achieve without ever daring to think it’ll actually happen. Yet I cannot deny that there is definitely an intention on my part to move people and leave an impression on them. This is what editing is designed for. And to get there is the most rewarding thing of all. Thank you for taking some time out of your day to tell me this. I’m so so so glad you liked this particular one. I have a soft spot for it too. It made me teary working on it because at the time, it felt that I had captured what that relationship is to me as a viewer. And how rather beautiful it is. So I’m really pleased if you love it too. Working so hard on something and have it appreciated by others is something truly special. 🥰

  • @piesRevil
    @piesRevil 5 місяців тому +2

    You notice so many little nuances that, perhaps, subconsciously I'm aware of, but have never truly noticed or thought about before - and then illustrate these points so eloquently. I've watched a few of your videos today, and each one has shown me more reasons to love the thought the writers put into creating the show and the rich layers of Sherlock x Molly. Thank you for the thought, time and craftsmanship that you put into these videos.

    • @mathilde-with-an-e
      @mathilde-with-an-e  5 місяців тому +1

      I have birds flying out of my head after reading such a wonderful, thoughtful message. There is a depth to their relationship that I find endlessly fascinating to explore. You have made my week. Thank you very much for this. What a pleasure! 💛

  • @heymikey4025
    @heymikey4025 Рік тому +6

    I’m just throwing this out there, but the words on the coffin/headstone is supposed to be DIRECTED TO THE DECEASED (like beloved Mother, sister, daughter etc), so baring that in mind who would actually say “I Love You” to Molly Hooper if she was dead?
    Since this was Sherlock’s test and Eurus is cleverer than both her brothers she seemingly knows that SHERLOCK loves Molly…hence the words on the coffin being directed towards Molly.
    Just my 2 cents…

  • @naomidoesnotsharefoodhehe8745
    @naomidoesnotsharefoodhehe8745 4 місяці тому +1

    His eyes dilated when he said "you" when came to molly to plan for his fake death. He loved her

  • @eleaklea3180
    @eleaklea3180 4 роки тому +20

    I loved your editing, this was like a meta-analysis and a poem at the same time! There are some moments which I did not link before seeing your video. I loved how you played with the shooting and the fall.

  • @StillJustDreaming
    @StillJustDreaming 4 роки тому +20

    This was brilliant and so heart-wrenchingly painful (but in the best possible way)

  • @martys8247
    @martys8247 Рік тому +2

    So amazing, I have no words!

  • @user-jl7ym4en5b
    @user-jl7ym4en5b 4 роки тому +7

    Thank you for the work, the passion that you put into this. You made the odd storyline of the sister so much more enjoyable. I am so grateful to you and all of those who adore "Sherlock" & have the talent to edit these so intricately, & then share your joy with everyone. It's such intelligent work, and so kind of you.

    • @mathilde-with-an-e
      @mathilde-with-an-e  3 роки тому +2

      You are ever so kind, thank you so so much. It means a lot to me, truly. :)

  • @mantra4ia
    @mantra4ia 14 днів тому

    The way the voiceovers are cut together with the falling and the stabbing is superb. John and Mrs Hudson talking about Sherlock's emotional outbursts is quite a closer. This is really great.

  • @goodshipsherlollipopfanfic42
    @goodshipsherlollipopfanfic42 4 роки тому +19

    Brilliant! Once again, you out in an extraordinary effort unearth little view comments by Sherlock that highlight his true feelings. There are little snippets here I've barely paid attention to that now seem more significant - the way Sherlock tries to divorce himself from his feelings, how Eurus says she wants to see him interact with people he's close to. 0How did I never notice that line before?) the way "there must be something comforting about the number three" and the way you link it back to Sherlock saying three names, but not Molly's, highlighting the big blunder Moriarty made in discounting what she meant to him. Extraordinary research you've made to put this together. I've never seem so much thought put into all the hidden details of various scenes that are overlooked. I can't even imagine the amount of hours you must have spent in going through the series to draw on so many of these little gems, we always see the usual scenes that everyone can quote by heart, but the addition of the extra scenes highlights your attention to detail. I think I can safely say am am the number one fan of your Sherlolly videos! Even watching them gives me ideas on incorporating some of these lesser known ideas into stories myself, with Sherlock’s innermost thoughts revealed. This wonderful video just highlights even further that Eurus absolutely knew Sherlock’s feelings for Molly truly went beyond the platonic. In fact, I'd venture to say (as I am showing in a story I am currently writing), that his love is of the Agape (unconditional) type, as well as the Eros love of the romantic type, No Philia love here, and I am sure he realizes that with the second "I love you " which I will never get enough if watching!). Brava! You should be doing this for a living with a talent for detail like this!

    • @anastasiyapresnjakova3060
      @anastasiyapresnjakova3060 4 роки тому +1

      That's the reason I love and appreciate her videos. She always finds somethings that we see, but don't observe.

  • @sidradawood4380
    @sidradawood4380 4 роки тому +10

    This is pure genius!!!! I... don't.... have words!!! Sherlolly is Canon!!!!!🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤 Brilliant job (especially "people usually stop after three"........cut to... you do count")
    Love from Pakistan 🇵🇰 ♥

  • @luminara1unduli
    @luminara1unduli 4 роки тому +6

    Bless you and your cow! This was absolutely amazing! Your Sherlolly videos are the best. Hope you'll stick around in the fandom forever! Great, great job!

  • @hanna50000
    @hanna50000 3 роки тому +3

    Absolutely incredible. You summarised in under four minutes what would have taken most people an entire essay!

  • @mizmariott4175
    @mizmariott4175 Місяць тому

    I keep coming back to this masterpeace

  • @xThreeWishesX
    @xThreeWishesX 4 роки тому +6

    DEAR LORD! I can't breathe. This is so intense. You are a brilliant editor.

  • @dxctorsapphic
    @dxctorsapphic 4 роки тому +6

    I am in floods of tears. This is so utterly beautiful. I've missed these two. The ending of this video is just perfection. ❤❤

  • @felicityqueen
    @felicityqueen 4 роки тому +4

    I'm completely speechless by this masterpiece!

  • @sydneygrom2757
    @sydneygrom2757 4 роки тому +2

    This is my favorite Sherolly edit ever!! So good! The connections have me crying!!

  • @mizmariott4175
    @mizmariott4175 2 роки тому

    I'm always coming back to these videos, for years now! They are simply amazing

  • @iffatrizvi9531
    @iffatrizvi9531 4 роки тому +2

    Oh my God, I love all your sherolly videos but this one was so long after the seasons ended and you still find new ways to connect scenes and dialogues and surprise us all

  • @BackwardBlossom
    @BackwardBlossom 4 роки тому +3

    I’m speechless! This is so stunning 💕

  • @alinecristina7745
    @alinecristina7745 4 роки тому +2

    “I don't count” 😭🤧 amazing video edit, I love the song 💙

  • @iela353
    @iela353 2 роки тому

    this is so MASTERFULLY done! I rarely see edits of them that are this good, everything is in place 🙌 thank you for making this 💜

  • @titiksham9778
    @titiksham9778 2 роки тому

    What a stunning piece of art this was. My god the way you related the scenes and the dialogues just *chef's kiss*. I'm in awe of how talented you are.
    #sherlollyforever

  • @04nbod
    @04nbod 3 роки тому +2

    Amazing. I love this. This is it. This is their relationship. This is why I love it

  • @stacylou5809
    @stacylou5809 4 роки тому +1

    great video.. i always love the dynamic between Molly and Sherlock that built up over the seasons.. the progression was well paced and was running in the background so to speak. I also think this is a prime example of how sometimes men are viewed as being rather emotionless creatures..well compared to women, that they dont feel things in the same way. Maybe the writers are also trying to convey that whilst Sherlock is highly intelligent and remains seemingly above emotions, he has the capacity to feel ..including his love for Molly, John, Mycroft. Due to his experiences with Euros and his friend, i think it made him focus on science and facts as these are predictable and easer to manage rather than difficult emotions ie: loss, love, guilt, etc. You captured these elements well in this video so thank you. Sorry for the long rant lol

  • @annv8360
    @annv8360 4 роки тому +1

    Absolutely spectacular visual meta its a truly brilliant masterpiece!! I do wonder however if the fall in TAB belongs with his other falls? TAB is about his conflicted feelings re: Molly and at the end he seems to jump almost lightheartedly into them, just after flinging away his 'clever detective' persona as symbolized by the deer stalker. Perhaps he surrendered his heart consciously to molly atm??

  • @heatherwalker5883
    @heatherwalker5883 4 роки тому

    So well cut together. Beautiful in every way!

  • @ladyjenkins9560
    @ladyjenkins9560 4 роки тому +1

    Wow, it's just perfect ! Your video is so well-made ! It makes me want to watch more videos of these two ;)

  • @jennycai8094
    @jennycai8094 3 роки тому

    this is truly a masterpiece I am speechless

  • @Shivani-dh7xh
    @Shivani-dh7xh 3 роки тому

    It's a privilege to be watching this masterpiece. Thank you 🙏

  • @smallfoxstudios
    @smallfoxstudios 3 роки тому

    An amazing edit! So good!✨👍💕

  • @kailynhuang
    @kailynhuang 4 роки тому

    I loved this 😭 beautiful!

  • @katelinauwu3804
    @katelinauwu3804 4 роки тому +2

    Wow! Nice job! :D

  • @heathercontois4501
    @heathercontois4501 3 роки тому

    I can't believe I missed all that!!!!

  • @Sweebilli
    @Sweebilli 4 роки тому +2

    Wow.. Wow wow wow.. I cld re-watch it again and again 👏👏👏

  • @felicialindsey5924
    @felicialindsey5924 4 роки тому

    Wow! Just wow!

  • @Romance_dream_
    @Romance_dream_ 2 роки тому

    Waw.. please Make more..

  • @Tbnasib3
    @Tbnasib3 4 роки тому +2

    That. Was. Amazing.