It’s quite interesting that everyone knows what they like about Libre but nobody can say what is so special about the crystal noir that they like it. That’s the mystery I love to create around myself ha ha.. You will love me but you won’t know why…
I think another way to analyse the answers (if the reactions were stitched together in order) is that the Versace one probably smells better on the dry down compared to Libre? I noticed that the YSL one got a lead pretty early on but as we got more reactions (and as the perfumes had more time to dry down and mix with the person's skin chemistry) Crystal Noir started picking up more positive reactions from people. great video btws! just found your channel and I've been really liking your content so far :))
Crystal Noir is unique. It has a coco nut note done absolutely beautifully in a price range that it is affordable, compared to niche. It performs well in every aspect, and is truly sophisticated, meaning it is not supposed to be a banger, but a frag with real personality, not for everyone.
I own the YSL Libre.. the lavender and the vanilla mix is just GORGEOUS!! , my room spray is also vanilla and lavender combined 💜 😊 it's justttt I cannot!! ❤❤❤
I think it would be better if tested on woman's skin instead of a man, because I think it's different chemistry. But in a paper it's more neutral than on a body.. I would like you to test Mon Guerlain edp and MFK Oud satin mood edp or maybe Armani Si edp... It was very nice idea!! Thank you Monica!! Love it!! 😍
Libre was my passion for the first time. But I’ve found it being quite boring soon. Now Crystal Noir is my love. It’s more deep, more niche. The perfume of a witch🙊
Just found your channel and subscribed! I’ve always thought Crystal Noir reminded me of men’s (expensive) shaving cream so when I saw the first guy’s reaction that said that I was like yes! I’m not the only one! I own and enjoy both of these fragrances. Great video!❤
The expressions on the faces of the men when they liked something were priceless. You could see their imaginations...working. And you know what I mean :)
Hello, lovely! I LOOOOVE Crystal Noir & don't own the YSL... but I'm rethinking the YSL - only the INTENSE! I gather from your vid, men seem to prefer something a bit more fresh & zesty as opposed to "vampy." Idk. I love that your husband did this & would love to see more of these. How about a comparison between LIGHT BLUE INTENSE & HYPNOSE or PRADA D'IRIS? Those are my 2023 spring & summer scents. Love from Palestine.
i'm really satisfied with this video as i'm getting this for my girlfriend as a valentines gift. she likes lavender. so i'm getting this for her (i personally prefer something more sophisticated as well but she doesn't like it on herself)
I was rooting for Crystal Noir cause i’m not a fan of the Libre dna, i don’t get the hype at all it has a chemical cleaning supplies smell, even the intense doesn’t do it for me (although the drydown of libre intense is not bad!)
That was so interesting!! I find libre gets a lot of hate from women UA-camrs but I love it. They are both good to me. I’d like to see gris charnel reactions because it’s so good to me but my spouse says it’s just ok. I’m not sure what it would go against. I also would like reactions to starlight.
I absolutely would never wear Crystal noir as I find it way too mature for me and doesn't maatch me as a person at all. But I have to say out of the two it's deffinately the more sophisticated complex smell that is just way more original . Libre is more in my realm but it smells like something I have smelled a hundred times before.
Can not be compared I think. Totally different scents and quality. Gris Charnel is a masterpiece. Libre is mainstream, simple and nothing special to me.
@@CS-bi3hh maybe, if you’re asking people that are into fragrances but that’s not really the case here :) so I think it would be interesting to hear people’s opinion on the street of the two compared side by side
@@Anonimna85 Do you have old formula? or new one? I'm looking for old formula... but nowdays all new in gold box and it's really disappointing.. no plume, so weak, just 3-5 mins and its gone... though all is original :(
I do not like the libre. The lavender is done terrible in my opinion. It's like looking in the fun mirrors in the carnival back to back lavender in your face with a weird rounded scent that smells gross to me. Like peppery. Black pepper the kind you put on food. Lavender and black pepper. Yuck.
It’s quite interesting that everyone knows what they like about Libre but nobody can say what is so special about the crystal noir that they like it. That’s the mystery I love to create around myself ha ha.. You will love me but you won’t know why…
I think these perfumes should be tested on Monika rather than her husband, it would give a different vibe,
Totally agree! Body chemistry gives different scent results - Monika should do another video on the same perfumes
I was thinking the same thing while watching it…
Definitely, this was odd
I don't think her husband would appreciate that. She's too pretty the men would say they like everything
@@user-jk8ur7sj3t Then ask an other women who is single. Not unsolvable.
I love libre intense over the original. It’s interesting to see the male perspective on women’s perfumes. Great video.
Oh yes definitely. I use the Parfum version and its just gorgeous.
Ja finde ich auch, aber man darf nicht zuviel von dem Intense sprühen, sonst riecht der ganze Raum danach.
I think another way to analyse the answers (if the reactions were stitched together in order) is that the Versace one probably smells better on the dry down compared to Libre? I noticed that the YSL one got a lead pretty early on but as we got more reactions (and as the perfumes had more time to dry down and mix with the person's skin chemistry) Crystal Noir started picking up more positive reactions from people.
great video btws! just found your channel and I've been really liking your content so far :))
Crystal Noir is unique. It has a coco nut note done absolutely beautifully in a price range that it is affordable, compared to niche. It performs well in every aspect, and is truly sophisticated, meaning it is not supposed to be a banger, but a frag with real personality, not for everyone.
They say the new formulated it doesn’t have coconut 🥺 no wonder it smelled different
I own the YSL Libre.. the lavender and the vanilla mix is just GORGEOUS!! , my room spray is also vanilla and lavender combined 💜 😊 it's justttt I cannot!! ❤❤❤
I think it would be better if tested on woman's skin instead of a man, because I think it's different chemistry. But in a paper it's more neutral than on a body.. I would like you to test Mon Guerlain edp and MFK Oud satin mood edp or maybe Armani Si edp... It was very nice idea!! Thank you Monica!! Love it!! 😍
I really don’t like the ysl libre, but I do like the crystal noir
Libre was my passion for the first time. But I’ve found it being quite boring soon. Now Crystal Noir is my love. It’s more deep, more niche. The perfume of a witch🙊
So you want smell like a withcer XD
Just found your channel and subscribed! I’ve always thought Crystal Noir reminded me of men’s (expensive) shaving cream so when I saw the first guy’s reaction that said that I was like yes! I’m not the only one! I own and enjoy both of these fragrances. Great video!❤
Libre woman here. I loooove this fragrance soooooo much! 💜🧡 Versace's Bright Crystal has been my go to summer fragrance though for years!
The expressions on the faces of the men when they liked something were priceless. You could see their imaginations...working. And you know what I mean :)
Hello, lovely! I LOOOOVE Crystal Noir & don't own the YSL... but I'm rethinking the YSL - only the INTENSE! I gather from your vid, men seem to prefer something a bit more fresh & zesty as opposed to "vampy." Idk. I love that your husband did this & would love to see more of these. How about a comparison between LIGHT BLUE INTENSE & HYPNOSE or PRADA D'IRIS? Those are my 2023 spring & summer scents. Love from Palestine.
So interesting! make more of these🥰
i'm really satisfied with this video as i'm getting this for my girlfriend as a valentines gift. she likes lavender. so i'm getting this for her
(i personally prefer something more sophisticated as well but she doesn't like it on herself)
I was rooting for Crystal Noir cause i’m not a fan of the Libre dna, i don’t get the hype at all it has a chemical cleaning supplies smell, even the intense doesn’t do it for me (although the drydown of libre intense is not bad!)
I don’t understand the hype ether, Libre reminds me of Poem by Lancôme and I cannot stand it.
That was so interesting!! I find libre gets a lot of hate from women UA-camrs but I love it. They are both good to me.
I’d like to see gris charnel reactions because it’s so good to me but my spouse says it’s just ok. I’m not sure what it would go against.
I also would like reactions to starlight.
Love these types of videos!
I love YSL Libre and all their flankers and Versace Crystal Noir is ok for me
Nice idea and good job! Very professionally, loved it😊
I absolutely would never wear Crystal noir as I find it way too mature for me and doesn't maatch me as a person at all. But I have to say out of the two it's deffinately the more sophisticated complex smell that is just way more original . Libre is more in my realm but it smells like something I have smelled a hundred times before.
I’m surprised actually😮
But smelling it on his wrist, they could smell a lot different if it was sprayed on a woman’s wrist!!!
Libre is libre. Its a banger
I’d love to see gris charnel vs libre intense!
Can not be compared I think. Totally different scents and quality. Gris Charnel is a masterpiece. Libre is mainstream, simple and nothing special to me.
@@CS-bi3hh maybe, if you’re asking people that are into fragrances but that’s not really the case here :) so I think it would be interesting to hear people’s opinion on the street of the two compared side by side
Hypnotic Poison Vs Coco mademoiselle or la Nuit tresor
I love this video!!!! Your husband did a Exceptional job!!!!
Thank you much… I am desperately seeking a new fragrance… looking at libre Parfum
Love these! ❤️
I never want to go for both of them. All these mainstream fragrances are worn by too many people. I want to smell unique.
then go for niche brands
They should have used the Crystal Noir eau de parfum instead of the eau de toilette.
love love both of them
This is not accurate cause the paper doesn’t does any justice to Versace one. It’s one of the sexiest if a woman wears it. I prefer the parfum as well
Great video!
I use both perfumes! ❤❤
I prefer Libre intense
I got YSL Libre EDP, the projection is very poor, I am heart broken.
Could you do a comparison video on the crystal perfumes🙏🏼
I love Libre!
Dos de mis favoritas!!! Pero Crysta Noir es mucho mas adictiva y Libre tiene mayor presencia.
Love YSL Libre
I don’t know if I will buy Versace crystal noir edt or edp 😩
Edp 😊 I have both, but EDP has more depth, and last longer.
@@Anonimna85 Do you have old formula? or new one? I'm looking for old formula... but nowdays all new in gold box and it's really disappointing.. no plume, so weak, just 3-5 mins and its gone... though all is original :(
To me, libre smells like a men’s fragrance with a play dough scent to it 😭
Is that the old (black box) or the new (gold and black box) version of Crystal Noir?
It’s the new box edt
The new one doesn’t compare to the old one. The one smells very masculine to me but still great
Very helpful
I think it should be tested in the scent strip because the skin chemestry of man i very diferent from women 🤪
Good job you did🙂
Have none of them though 🤪
Tf black orchid, kayali vanilla, olympea
Love ysl libre, esp intense
I do not like the libre. The lavender is done terrible in my opinion. It's like looking in the fun mirrors in the carnival back to back lavender in your face with a weird rounded scent that smells gross to me. Like peppery. Black pepper the kind you put on food. Lavender and black pepper. Yuck.
is that the edT or edP of versace bright crystal??
it's the edt
And it's not bright crystal it's crystal noir
Hey! Which libre is that? Libre edp or intense?
libre edp. The intense has darker color
Your ph will change the smell... Women vs men skin is very different.
I love female fragrances. I'm actually gonna buy them just to spray on my pillow and remind me of some of my exes/ flings
Then the new girlfriend goes over and wonders why your pillow smells like a girl
Which versace is this the edt or edp
Edt new one
libre!!
Crystal noir isn’t as amazing as everyone makes it. It doesn’t have sillage. Very overated
I really hate Libre intense don’t get me wrong it’s just smell like grandma
Really?
Never heard that before.
I like Libre edp and edt. It’s better