Who would have thought that the emotional support itself, is the one who needed support the most:< We all hope that you're now happy whenever you are. Condolence for the fans, friends and families of moonbin. Engenes are wishing you to find the strength to make it through such a tragic event. Spreading love and giving hugs.
As a girl with deep depression, I can say that it’s exactly like you said. Of course every single person is different and their pain can’t be compared but thinking about my experience and my friend’s that passed away. We put a mask to the outside world we don’t want anyone to be involved and worried. Well me and my friend we had several breakdowns at the point of wanting beg for help (at least it happened for me, he talked with me about his problems) but it’s never enough you know? There are these thoughts of “you are worthless” “people just talk to you because of pity” “you don’t do anything right” “no one cares”. And thinking about this just make me start crying. It’s almost 5am and I couldn’t sleep. >My< personal experience with this illness is putting others above yourself, like they are more important, their feelings are more important. Soooo yeah Sorry I become really emotive when I see those situations… It’s sad to see someone lose their battle agains depression. It’s even worse knowing how awful it is because you feel it everyday. Bin was the first member I noticed in Astro and became my bias since then. It reminded me the hypnosis episode with monsta x, where jooheon said he was a lion. Anyway sorry for wasting your time
@@annonymus1770dear... I am also a teenager suffering from a lot of problems. I also have the same feeling just as yours. When a situation that makes you really heartbroken suddenly pops up to you then you will automatically starts thinking of the other things that ate you from inside. A lot of dangerous emotions will come to your mind. But you should always remind yourself about 2 words "✨️love yourself✨️".dear i am damn sure that it will bring you some relief because those words are really magical. Start caring for yourselves and start listening to a lot of good songs. Give yourself the time to heal and focus on yourself. I am sure Working out and yogas will really you as they also helped me. Engage yourself dear. We can't shut anyone's mouth or we can't suddenly drag ourselves from the problems because we have to live in this atmosphere until we become independent and realise that problems are a part of our life and it is this overcoming mentality of us by caring and loving ourselves which makes our life even more worthier. So luv yourself and care yourself more coz we can't change others but we can change ours weak attitudes towards our problems. So chill!!!!😃 and if you are reading thus then i am not gonna ask a sorry for wasting your time 😜
Lots of love from moa's as well 😭😭😭😭i m not able to get over this even cha eun woo said that he can't endure the pain as he was not able to protect hislil brother 😭😭😭😭😭😭
@@annonymus1770 You're right. Depression shows itself in people in many different ways. I find it exhausting to mask and hardly can force myself to smile so it's a wonder how those that can mask find the energy to do so. I don't get thoughts that people dislike me but I get thoughts of how I'll fail in life or not seeing anything worth living for anymore. Just wanting to sleep for days. It's an illness and shouldn't be brushed off just because it's invisible, it's just as real as visible illnesses (like heart disease). We're not lazy !! The worst part is that it's a life-long battle and we still don't have the proper tools and info to fight against our brains and people think it's not a big deal ...but it is.
Binnie is the kind of friend everybody wants to have. He appreciates his friends so much. He is not shy about expressing his admiration and love for his friends. He is really one of a kind.
And this video got recommended to me on such a devastating day. It is disheartening how idols mask their sadness and pain with the smiles on their faces. Rest in peace MoonBin. Our angel. You'll always be with us.
I don't know what Eun Woo might be feeling right now, looking back on this video about how close he is with Moonbin.. it breaks my heart truly imagining how he is feeling right now not realizing that his one true friend, the one who is always there to tell him that "it's okay Eunwoo-yah" is the one who is going through something. Moonbin shows a strong facade and smiling face everytime.. we didn't even know that his in a lot of pain. Rest in peace Moonbin-ah.. Condolence Astro family, Moonbin's family and to all arohas out there.
I feel so sad for eunwoo and sanha , specially for eunwoo how he feels right now that his very very closest friends was gone , I cried a lot watching this video.😢❤
I know ChaEunWoo cried so much of the sudden death of his bff , you can see it in his eyes and he cannot sleep well of thingking why this happens to his one true friend , a brother and buddy all the memories they shared together , be strong EunWoo !❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
I just lost my husband of 43yrs n the sorrow is so deep. He just went to heaven in June. So I know how the guys must feel even a yr after. Moonbin though I didn't know him. But through these videos I've learn to grieve for him too! Every life is important n should be valued. My deepest condolences to his family,ASTRO n friends n fans. Sending hugs to anyone that might need one. God loves you n you matter.❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
I never expected so many people to come to my videos looking for comfort. Dear Roha, I did this with a lot of love while Bin lived to show what a beautiful person he is (was), I hope it heals your heart a little knowing that you followed and loved the right person. A hug and strength. 💜
@Zoandeiry, ja es ist wirklich sehr tröstlich & aufbauend zugleich 🥰🎭😓❣ Sein Sprechen, sein Singen, sein Lachen, sein Tanzen, seine Wärme zu allem im Leben, sein Spaß mit seinen tollen Jungs - einfach alles bezaubernd❣ Ich höre Moonbin sehr gerne koreanisch sprechen auch wenn ich überhaupt gar nichts verstehe. Ich liebe die ganzen Videos der ASTROs, aber mein Lieblingsvideo ist momentan als Moonbin ein kleiner Junge war und "butterfly" singt. 🥰🎭😓❣❣❣❣❣ Dankeschön Zoandeiry 👌🏼😘👍🏼❣
Lindo video me hizo llorar ellos juntos se veían muy felices están juntos desde niños de amaban de verdad con todas las fuerzas de su corazón los amo a ellos y a todos los integrantes del grupo se ven lindos todos Unidos me gustaría que se volvieran a unir en memoria del grupo a Moonbin le gustaba verlos brillar en el escenario es tan triste saber que su vida de apagó su dulce sonrisa su amor hacia todos era un gran ser humano que se a ganado el amor de muchas personas alrededor del mundo por su simpatía su talento su carisma el nació para brillar y va a seguir brillando en nuestros corazones esa alegría que contagiaba me encanta ver su sonrisa era un hombre completo con todas las cualidades buena que puede tener un ser humano su partida todavía yo no lo puedo creer que ya no esté 😢 tenía el mundo a sus pies y es triste que se haya ido así de repente sin nadie esperarlo 😢 gracias por este video tan lindo de todos esos momentos lindos que vivieron juntos Cha Eunwoo y Moonbin con el grupo. 😢siempre lo recordaré con mucho cariño. Que descanse en paz y que Cha Eunwoo encuentre Consuelo y que este bien de salud al igual que todo el grupo y familiares.
@@Fan-qk6yyнет, потому что из-за него продлил контракт. Мало того, что он оказался плохим другом, так ещё и за то, чтобы его продвигала компания(продался), уговорил на этот не нужный Мунбину, контакт. И из-за него Бина убрали из всех развлечений и совместного отдыха.. Когда он с другими отдыхал в штатах и веселился, у МБ был график и тренировки, которые ему менее всех нужны были, так как он был самым лучшим из их группы, да и многих других. Это ыну и санхе надо было тренировок больше, они в этом нуждаются. И да, ыну даже на похороны не соизволил явиться, только успел сказать, что"я так и знал".... Развлечения ему дороже человека, который столько лет ему подтирал сопли и защищал. А как ыну приобрёл славу(по моему мнению не заслуженную), то сразу стал такой занятой и часто подводил группу, не принимая участие во многих концертах и съёмках. И много чего ещё... Мне не понятно почему столько людей его вообще смотрят, да тем более слушают? Он же не умеет петь.. Что с людьми стало? Я немного посмотрела его концерт в прошлом году... Ужас, фонограмма даже голос МБ.. Им лень было дуже перезаписать песни.. И поведение Ыну отвратительно, распахивал свой халат"или что там на нём было... И выглядит как извращенец. В нём нет ни капли от артиста... В общем, извините за долгое объяснение, но....
Moonbin was such a precious soul, now that he's gone, I hope his soul can rest in peace. We really lost a caring and understanding person. I can't imagine the pain the members and his family must have been going through. Deep and sincere condolences 🤍
9:02 made me cry hard. Haters might say “Eunwoo should just leave since he’s better as an actor and he can’t dance as good as the other members” but here’s a main dancer appreciating Eunwoo’s effort in catching up in terms of dance practice. And it also shows that despite his fame and influence, Eunwoo still makes sure to come back to where he started. Really love Astro’s friendship and personality. 😍🥰
@@ValerieGnow Hello, I was looking for the link but I couldn't find it anymore; If I remember correctly the clip I used in this video I found it on Instagram but it's hard to know because I download a lot of content from everywhere, sorry. 😔
Hold it, there are people saying he can't dance??? But he does it so fluently, his dancing flows so beautifully, and perfectly in sync with the other members... (I might be new to the astro fandom, but like... What?)
It's nonsense from haters who often underestimate Eunwoo for his good looks, forget that he's also extremely talented and didn't get where he is just because of his looks. But Aroha knows, so it doesn't matter 💜
Bin was genuinely a great person and im sure ppl who knew him personally are probably missing him deeply, bin i hope you're doing fine wherever you are, im praying for you, your family and friends ❤️
one thing that i have realised over the years while growing up.. if there is a warm and kind person in your life, protect him/her with all your heart..Moon seems to be that person with his brightest smile...Sadly he will be shining bright among the stars..RIP...
I really can't accept or even understand Moonbin's early passing. I am not an astro fan but I support all the fandoms and admire kpop idols as well. Apart from being talented, Moonbin seems like a very good person, brother, son, and friend. It is really sad knowing that he is already gone and will no longer be seen/watched by his fans. Thank you for showing the world how talented you are, moonbin! Keep shining!
There is ONLY ONE Moonbin, no one can compare and there will never be a second. I love this man and will be heartbroken for the rest of my life. If there is a love of my life it would be Moonbin. I hope we meet in another life. 🌸🌸💔💔😪😪🕊🕊😭😭💔💔💔💔💔💔
And now moonbin left us to join the angels ....he gaved everyone he knew support and love and now we're gonna have to endure this on our own .....rest in peace moonbin ....we all love you
as a fellow introvert I really love their relationship🥹 they don't need to speak to each other hence they understand each other's mind and habit. no matter how far they goes in the end they'll always be each other's safest place. let's be happy forever binwoo 😢💖
He was the biggest support system, yet he lost his battle. So heartbreaking and in yotak disbelief that he is no more. It is reminder to always check on our friends even though they look happier or look fine.
He didn't look happy at all! He was very sick and overworked. He had high blood pressure suffering from nose bleedings even at vlive, he was crunching in pain at dance practices but noone cared. How come everyone behaved like nothing happened? What did Eunwoo do? His emotional support was dying in front of his eyes..... Ohh, right, he was too busy mingling with Sanha
Moon bin was always there for anyone who needed him. He was so supportive and always helped everybody at their worst, but he got no emotional support that he needed the most himself. He always wanted his loved ones around him to be happy so he never expressed his pain. He was always a ray of sunshine brightening up everybody’s day. He was way too precious for this world. I miss our Binnie so much 🥺😭. I hope you, Moonbin, continue shining bright in the sky as the most beautiful star. Rest in peace, angel. 1998-2023. Child: Mom, why do the best people die? Mom: When you are in a garden, which flowers of you pick? Child: The most beautiful ones...
Yo siempre veo BINWOO porque extraño mucho a MOON BIN, y la mayoría de las veces veo q el mas sentimental y no se si serán penas tristes o emociones buenas pero es Nunu, y siempre mi LUNITA AMADA ESTUVO AHI PARA APOYARLO ABRAZARLO ,Y TAMBIEN SE PONIA TRISTE, entonces yo me pregunto quien era entonces el q mas tenia depresión ??? 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢 MOON BIN CUANTO TE EXTRAÑÓ😢😢😢😢😢😢😢 JAMAS OLVIDAREMOS A ESTA HERMOSA ESTRELLA ,PRECIOSA Y AMADA ESTRELLA😢😢😢😢😢😢
Seeing this now, after Moon's death hurts really bad but seeing his smile makes me feel at ease at the same time, but i still can't stop crying. I know he's in a better place and he doesn't have to feel stressed and sad anymore. He was a kind person that always seemed happy, now i hope he truly feels at peace. Deepest condolences to his family, the members of Astro, fans and everyone who's grieving. We love you Binnie, rip my dear. ❤🕊
Who knew that the moral support needed the support most , i still don't want to believe this happened rest in peace my bias 🙏 i hope in next life i meet you again and you would be more happy and get everything you want
은우는 몇 영상만 봐도 아스트로에 대한 자부심도 크고 아스트로를 더욱 알리고자 함도 커 보인다. 그만큼 개인 활동도 열심히 하고.. 혼자 많은 스케줄 소화하기가 힘들텐데, 힘든 걸 티내지도 않고 묵묵하게 열심히 해서 빈이는 항상 고마워하고 미안해했구나 눈빛이 말해주네..
It's now so sad to see this video as moonbin just left us he was such a bright person it is hard to believe this may his family and members find strength although it's hard 😢😢😢😢😭
오늘도 눈물로 시작이네... 첨엔 산하가 젤 걱정되었어. 그 아이 행여 무너질까봐 조심스럽게 인스타도 체크하고.. 사진이라도 뭐 올라오면 글케 반갑고 살아있구나 잘 있구나. 문산하며 더욱 빈이에게 많이의지했고 춤.노래.무대.운동.다정함.인성 빠지지않는 잘난형에게 늘 배워나가며 사랑과 챙김받기만 한줄알았는데 깊이있게보니 늘 형을 조심스레 챙겨주고 웃게해주고 편안하게 해주려는거 그 맘 잘알겠더라. 산하가 젤 많이 느끼고있었을테지 형의 다운되는 신체컨디션에 불안정한 무드를 지켜보며 해줄수있는게 많지않았을테고... 근데 이제보니 점점 걱정되는사람이 늘어. 은우가 생각보다 빈이 영향을 많이 받게 될것같아. 상남자 빈이가 은우에게 사랑표현도 많이 대놓고 자주했는데 그 다정한 사랑주던 내 베스트가 이세상에 없다는게 너무 잔인하게 느껴진다... 은우 표현많이 못하고 꾹꾹 누르는거 하지말고 좀 쉬어가며 자신을 잘 챙겼으면 좋겠어. 아마 하늘에서 빈이가 젤 걱정하는사람 은우 산하 둘이 아닐까싶어. 서로 안아주고 일으켜주며 잘 살아나가길 응원해. 문차산 영원해라❤
Такая глупость, Бин не любил Санху, он ему просто не нравился даже как человек, он сам открыто говорил, что ему трудно работать, а Ыну просто развлекается и дальше... Никогда он не был искренен... Он просто самовлюблённый нарцисс... Слишком его избаловали комплименты, причём не заслуженно....как человек может называть себя артистом, не умея танцевать, да и вокал так себе... Актёр из него так же отвратительный..
This madee cry to be honest... Now that Moonbin has left... Who is Eun Woo gonna rely on? I already miss him.... Is that possible? May he rest in peace... May Moonbin find peace and luck in the afterlife...... It's so sad... This really made me cry so much! Please support Astro!
Here after moonbin's death... aroha and binie's family I am so so so sorry for your loss. Astro members as well, I can only express my condolences. I'm really so sorry.
I cried at the moment when the song "Don't cry, my love" came out with the video of them crying and comforting each other... My whole heart melted when watching this, it totally warmed my heart. This is exactly the feeling whenever I think of binwoo. The word "friends" seemed to impair their bond, they're not just only friends, but more like a family. Although I've seen a lot of different binwoo edits, this one is surely the one that stands out. This video must be made of love towards ASTRO, couldn't thank you more for editing this.
아스트로멤버 모두가 바르고 착한 사람들. 이젠 힘들면 서로에게 기대 함께 헤쳐나가고 빈이의 빈자리 잘 채워주시길 바랍니다. 너무나 고생 많았던 아스트로.. 영상을 보는 내내 가슴이 아프고.. 이제 힘든날 지나고 좋은날 올껀데 별이된 빈.. 너무 가슴이 아프고 안타깝습니다..
Me rompió el corazón este video ,Dios mio 😢 ,Se querían tanto mis niños MOONBIN y Cha eunwoo y Cómo ,No extrañar a mis chicos de ASTRO.🥹 Si eran unos truinfandores , los mejores ,los únicos , Ojalá algún día no muy lejano vuelvan a subir al escenario,y brillen como solo ellos saben hacerlo ,Mis 5 Hermosos. , bendiciones.,,Y un abrazo hasta el cielo para mi Ángel Moonbin 🥹🥹
Thank you very much for thinking that, I am also a Binwoo veteran but I just dared to make a video about them, I am grateful for how well they are being received 🤧💜
Moon Bin is very affectionate, faithful and attentive to those he loves. It was very nice to see that he was always paying attention to Eun Woo's face, trying to identify how he was feeling. A very beautiful love! Moon Bin has won a piece of my heart! We are similar in many ways, we like well-prepared and refined food. We Both knew Just by looking at him for the first time that Eun Woo's parents earned the three Michelin stars without much effort. ❤😂❤🌜🤦🏻♂️🌹🌹❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Its been more than a week now my Moon...... Am still in a phased believing that you'll be back...... I wish I knew ur struggling alone....... Wish u all the rest up there..... You'll be always in my heart
Who would have thought that the most jolly person, the comedienne, the funny, the brother, the shoulder to cry on, and so on in the group would suffer such emotional pain. Watching this video was a heartbreaking. My tears won’t stop falling watching Moonbin with a smile on his face that already a star in the sky. His one of the idol that I really fond watching too because of his charisma and funny personality. Who would have thought that his already gone? This tragic death of Moonbin still can’t sink in. That his gone. 😔💔 May his family and friends find the inner peace about the demise of their loving Moonbin. Rest in Peace 🕊️🙏🏻 our loving Moonbin. You will be forever in our hearts ❤️❤️❤️
Moonbin era um ser iluminado pelos céus,com um coração gigante de amor ,carinho,dedicação,apoio,amigo,consolador,companheiro,meigo,carinhoso,amava o que fazia e o fazia com perfeição,e amava seus fãs,Dói saber que ele se foi,💔😔Era um artista completo e iluminado,e um ser humano incrível e maravilhoso,a nossa linda estrela agora esta brilhando no céu ⭐perdemos uma jóia rara,o céu ganhou um anjo iluminado precioso,minhas condolências aos familiares,grupo,amigos e equipe de trabalho,te amaremos eternamente Bin nossa eterna estrela brilhante⭐⭐UM ASTRO PERFEITO⭐💓💓💓💓💓💓
Who would have thought that the emotional support itself, is the one who needed support the most:< We all hope that you're now happy whenever you are. Condolence for the fans, friends and families of moonbin. Engenes are wishing you to find the strength to make it through such a tragic event. Spreading love and giving hugs.
As a girl with deep depression, I can say that it’s exactly like you said. Of course every single person is different and their pain can’t be compared but thinking about my experience and my friend’s that passed away. We put a mask to the outside world we don’t want anyone to be involved and worried.
Well me and my friend we had several breakdowns at the point of wanting beg for help (at least it happened for me, he talked with me about his problems) but it’s never enough you know? There are these thoughts of “you are worthless” “people just talk to you because of pity” “you don’t do anything right” “no one cares”.
And thinking about this just make me start crying. It’s almost 5am and I couldn’t sleep.
>My< personal experience with this illness is putting others above yourself, like they are more important, their feelings are more important.
Soooo yeah
Sorry I become really emotive when I see those situations…
It’s sad to see someone lose their battle agains depression. It’s even worse knowing how awful it is because you feel it everyday.
Bin was the first member I noticed in Astro and became my bias since then.
It reminded me the hypnosis episode with monsta x, where jooheon said he was a lion.
Anyway sorry for wasting your time
@@annonymus1770dear... I am also a teenager suffering from a lot of problems. I also have the same feeling just as yours. When a situation that makes you really heartbroken suddenly pops up to you then you will automatically starts thinking of the other things that ate you from inside. A lot of dangerous emotions will come to your mind. But you should always remind yourself about 2 words "✨️love yourself✨️".dear i am damn sure that it will bring you some relief because those words are really magical. Start caring for yourselves and start listening to a lot of good songs. Give yourself the time to heal and focus on yourself. I am sure Working out and yogas will really you as they also helped me. Engage yourself dear. We can't shut anyone's mouth or we can't suddenly drag ourselves from the problems because we have to live in this atmosphere until we become independent and realise that problems are a part of our life and it is this overcoming mentality of us by caring and loving ourselves which makes our life even more worthier. So luv yourself and care yourself more coz we can't change others but we can change ours weak attitudes towards our problems. So chill!!!!😃 and if you are reading thus then i am not gonna ask a sorry for wasting your time 😜
Lots of love from moa's as well 😭😭😭😭i m not able to get over this even cha eun woo said that he can't endure the pain as he was not able to protect hislil brother 😭😭😭😭😭😭
@@annonymus1770 You're right. Depression shows itself in people in many different ways. I find it exhausting to mask and hardly can force myself to smile so it's a wonder how those that can mask find the energy to do so. I don't get thoughts that people dislike me but I get thoughts of how I'll fail in life or not seeing anything worth living for anymore. Just wanting to sleep for days.
It's an illness and shouldn't be brushed off just because it's invisible, it's just as real as visible illnesses (like heart disease). We're not lazy !! The worst part is that it's a life-long battle and we still don't have the proper tools and info to fight against our brains and people think it's not a big deal ...but it is.
@@loveyourself1766 shut up we dont know the cause
Binnie is the kind of friend everybody wants to have. He appreciates his friends so much. He is not shy about expressing his admiration and love for his friends. He is really one of a kind.
Naprosto s Vámi souhlasím a je smutno všem nejvic rodičům a sestře 😢❤
And this video got recommended to me on such a devastating day.
It is disheartening how idols mask their sadness and pain with the smiles on their faces.
Rest in peace MoonBin. Our angel. You'll always be with us.
ikr it got recommended now am crying
He cried out for help so many times. His agency is pathetic. Schedules mean nothing if someone's in pain and anguish
Yes, it is so heartbreaking truly, but a lot of times we just don't know what lies beneath.😢
I don't know what Eun Woo might be feeling right now, looking back on this video about how close he is with Moonbin.. it breaks my heart truly imagining how he is feeling right now not realizing that his one true friend, the one who is always there to tell him that "it's okay Eunwoo-yah" is the one who is going through something. Moonbin shows a strong facade and smiling face everytime.. we didn't even know that his in a lot of pain. Rest in peace Moonbin-ah.. Condolence Astro family, Moonbin's family and to all arohas out there.
eunwoo and sanha might be breaking down. I feel so bad for them all though :(
I feel so sad for eunwoo and sanha , specially for eunwoo how he feels right now that his very very closest friends was gone , I cried a lot watching this video.😢❤
I know ChaEunWoo cried so much of the sudden death of his bff , you can see it in his eyes and he cannot sleep well of thingking why this happens to his one true friend , a brother and buddy all the memories they shared together , be strong EunWoo !❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Widać było jak cierpiał. Gasł z miesiąca na miesiąc. Nie chcieli tego widzieć
I just lost my husband of 43yrs n the sorrow is so deep. He just went to heaven in June. So I know how the guys must feel even a yr after. Moonbin though I didn't know him. But through these videos I've learn to grieve for him too! Every life is important n should be valued. My deepest condolences to his family,ASTRO n friends n fans. Sending hugs to anyone that might need one. God loves you n you matter.❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Watching this video after Moonbin passed away. I still cannot believe that he is no more in this world. He was special to everyone 😔
I never expected so many people to come to my videos looking for comfort.
Dear Roha, I did this with a lot of love while Bin lived to show what a beautiful person he is (was), I hope it heals your heart a little knowing that you followed and loved the right person.
A hug and strength. 💜
@Zoandeiry, ja es ist wirklich sehr tröstlich & aufbauend zugleich 🥰🎭😓❣
Sein Sprechen, sein Singen, sein Lachen, sein Tanzen, seine Wärme zu allem im Leben, sein Spaß mit seinen tollen Jungs - einfach alles bezaubernd❣
Ich höre Moonbin sehr gerne koreanisch sprechen auch wenn ich überhaupt gar nichts verstehe.
Ich liebe die ganzen Videos der ASTROs, aber mein Lieblingsvideo ist momentan als Moonbin ein kleiner Junge war und "butterfly" singt. 🥰🎭😓❣❣❣❣❣
Dankeschön Zoandeiry 👌🏼😘👍🏼❣
moonbin we all miss you. I'm still crying rest in peace my angel
Lindo video me hizo llorar ellos juntos se veían muy felices están juntos desde niños de amaban de verdad con todas las fuerzas de su corazón los amo a ellos y a todos los integrantes del grupo se ven lindos todos Unidos me gustaría que se volvieran a unir en memoria del grupo a Moonbin le gustaba verlos brillar en el escenario es tan triste saber que su vida de apagó su dulce sonrisa su amor hacia todos era un gran ser humano que se a ganado el amor de muchas personas alrededor del mundo por su simpatía su talento su carisma el nació para brillar y va a seguir brillando en nuestros corazones esa alegría que contagiaba me encanta ver su sonrisa era un hombre completo con todas las cualidades buena que puede tener un ser humano su partida todavía yo no lo puedo creer que ya no esté 😢 tenía el mundo a sus pies y es triste que se haya ido así de repente sin nadie esperarlo 😢 gracias por este video tan lindo de todos esos momentos lindos que vivieron juntos Cha Eunwoo y Moonbin con el grupo. 😢siempre lo recordaré con mucho cariño. Que descanse en paz y que Cha Eunwoo encuentre Consuelo y que este bien de salud al igual que todo el grupo y familiares.
Watching this makes me cry so hard. My heart hurts. Bennie expressed his gratitude well. Well done. I hope Eun Woo doesn’t blame himself too much.
True.
Он не винит себя... Такие, как он видят только себя. А лучше бы винил... Ему это зачтётся.
Whh would Eunwoo feel so guilty? Because he never saw the feels Bin was suffering 😢😢
@@Fan-qk6yyнет, потому что из-за него продлил контракт. Мало того, что он оказался плохим другом, так ещё и за то, чтобы его продвигала компания(продался), уговорил на этот не нужный Мунбину, контакт. И из-за него Бина убрали из всех развлечений и совместного отдыха.. Когда он с другими отдыхал в штатах и веселился, у МБ был график и тренировки, которые ему менее всех нужны были, так как он был самым лучшим из их группы, да и многих других. Это ыну и санхе надо было тренировок больше, они в этом нуждаются. И да, ыну даже на похороны не соизволил явиться, только успел сказать, что"я так и знал".... Развлечения ему дороже человека, который столько лет ему подтирал сопли и защищал. А как ыну приобрёл славу(по моему мнению не заслуженную), то сразу стал такой занятой и часто подводил группу, не принимая участие во многих концертах и съёмках. И много чего ещё... Мне не понятно почему столько людей его вообще смотрят, да тем более слушают? Он же не умеет петь.. Что с людьми стало? Я немного посмотрела его концерт в прошлом году... Ужас, фонограмма даже голос МБ.. Им лень было дуже перезаписать песни.. И поведение Ыну отвратительно, распахивал свой халат"или что там на нём было... И выглядит как извращенец. В нём нет ни капли от артиста... В общем, извините за долгое объяснение, но....
Moonbin was such a precious soul, now that he's gone, I hope his soul can rest in peace. We really lost a caring and understanding person. I can't imagine the pain the members and his family must have been going through. Deep and sincere condolences 🤍
Moonbin is younger but he’s always ready to take care of others.
Imagine in the future Eun woo going through a hard time and telling himself " it's okey eunwooya ", will that even console him anymore
🤧😭😭
9:02 made me cry hard. Haters might say “Eunwoo should just leave since he’s better as an actor and he can’t dance as good as the other members” but here’s a main dancer appreciating Eunwoo’s effort in catching up in terms of dance practice. And it also shows that despite his fame and influence, Eunwoo still makes sure to come back to where he started. Really love Astro’s friendship and personality. 😍🥰
I agree, this goes beyond how successful they can be individually, the friendship of the six is much more valuable than everything else. 💜✨
@@zoandeiry7888 hi, may I know where is this part from? Was is a fan meeting? Thank you!
@@ValerieGnow Hello, I was looking for the link but I couldn't find it anymore; If I remember correctly the clip I used in this video I found it on Instagram but it's hard to know because I download a lot of content from everywhere, sorry. 😔
Hold it, there are people saying he can't dance??? But he does it so fluently, his dancing flows so beautifully, and perfectly in sync with the other members... (I might be new to the astro fandom, but like... What?)
It's nonsense from haters who often underestimate Eunwoo for his good looks, forget that he's also extremely talented and didn't get where he is just because of his looks. But Aroha knows, so it doesn't matter 💜
I can't even imagine how Eunwoo is feeling at the moment. The world lost a beautiful gem and the heaven gained a beautiful angel 😔🕊️
❤
Can't imagine how hard it must be for Eun Woo, since they were practically each other's mental support....Rest in peace angel... 😞♥️✨
You will always be missed moon bin🥀. Hope the members find the stength to pass through this tough time💔
RIP OUR DEAREST MOON.....🌹
binwoo I hope your friendship will last forever
They just not a friends they are family
we still hope❤❤❤ may moonbin rest in peace ❤️🕊️
😭😭😭😭😭😭
They will…
Even if they need to meet again in another life, they will.
Everyone is here because of moonbin's death😭😭
Bin was genuinely a great person and im sure ppl who knew him personally are probably missing him deeply, bin i hope you're doing fine wherever you are, im praying for you, your family and friends ❤️
one thing that i have realised over the years while growing up.. if there is a warm and kind person in your life, protect him/her with all your heart..Moon seems to be that person with his brightest smile...Sadly he will be shining bright among the stars..RIP...
I really can't accept or even understand Moonbin's early passing. I am not an astro fan but I support all the fandoms and admire kpop idols as well. Apart from being talented, Moonbin seems like a very good person, brother, son, and friend. It is really sad knowing that he is already gone and will no longer be seen/watched by his fans. Thank you for showing the world how talented you are, moonbin! Keep shining!
he always shine even though he perished . from. earth.dearly departed. but always remembered
There is ONLY ONE Moonbin, no one can compare and there will never be a second. I love this man and will be heartbroken for the rest of my life. If there is a love of my life it would be Moonbin. I hope we meet in another life. 🌸🌸💔💔😪😪🕊🕊😭😭💔💔💔💔💔💔
This hits more than ever now!😭
NOW MOONBIN IS NOT HERE ANYMORE💔 REST IN PEACE 🕊 SUCH AN ANGEL😔
Our beloved Moonbin is now an angel. May you rest in peace 🕊
Watch this again after what happened to our beloved Binnie, it never be the same anymore😭😭
And now moonbin left us to join the angels ....he gaved everyone he knew support and love and now we're gonna have to endure this on our own .....rest in peace moonbin ....we all love you
watching this video after monnbin has gone is really hard for me , i really cried hard watching it
I come back to this on this heartbreaking day and it just breaks my heart even more....i can't stop the tears
Rest in peace Moonbin🕊
as a fellow introvert I really love their relationship🥹 they don't need to speak to each other hence they understand each other's mind and habit. no matter how far they goes in the end they'll always be each other's safest place. let's be happy forever binwoo 😢💖
Moonbin predivno djete❤❤❤😢
I can't stop crying eyes filled with tears 🥺😭😭 we will miss you RIP moonbin 😢
😢💔😭
Binwoo will always be loved ❤
From today when I see the brightest star in the sky while tears drop down my eyes, I know its Moonbin
He was the biggest support system, yet he lost his battle. So heartbreaking and in yotak disbelief that he is no more. It is reminder to always check on our friends even though they look happier or look fine.
He didn't look happy at all! He was very sick and overworked. He had high blood pressure suffering from nose bleedings even at vlive, he was crunching in pain at dance practices but noone cared. How come everyone behaved like nothing happened? What did Eunwoo do? His emotional support was dying in front of his eyes..... Ohh, right, he was too busy mingling with Sanha
Our moonbin left us today 😭😭😭
This made me cry....it's so sad that Moonbin is gone. He was so young, beautiful heart....RIP Moonbin and condolences to the family.
True 😢😢 Hope he is happy up there... He truly is an angel 😭😭
Moon bin was always there for anyone who needed him. He was so supportive and always helped everybody at their worst, but he got no emotional support that he needed the most himself. He always wanted his loved ones around him to be happy so he never expressed his pain. He was always a ray of sunshine brightening up everybody’s day. He was way too precious for this world. I miss our Binnie so much 🥺😭. I hope you, Moonbin, continue shining bright in the sky as the most beautiful star. Rest in peace, angel. 1998-2023.
Child: Mom, why do the best people die?
Mom: When you are in a garden, which flowers of you pick?
Child: The most beautiful ones...
😢😢😢😢
tha's true. Noone got his back. They just were takings whatever he could offer without thinking of him at all....
Yo siempre veo BINWOO porque extraño mucho a MOON BIN, y la mayoría de las veces veo q el mas sentimental y no se si serán penas tristes o emociones buenas pero es Nunu, y siempre mi LUNITA AMADA ESTUVO AHI PARA APOYARLO ABRAZARLO ,Y TAMBIEN SE PONIA TRISTE, entonces yo me pregunto quien era entonces el q mas tenia depresión ??? 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢 MOON BIN CUANTO TE EXTRAÑÓ😢😢😢😢😢😢😢 JAMAS OLVIDAREMOS A ESTA HERMOSA ESTRELLA ,PRECIOSA Y AMADA ESTRELLA😢😢😢😢😢😢
Moonbin, you will be loved and missed till the end of time. Rest in peace my angel 💜🖤💜🖤
Seeing this now, after Moon's death hurts really bad but seeing his smile makes me feel at ease at the same time, but i still can't stop crying. I know he's in a better place and he doesn't have to feel stressed and sad anymore. He was a kind person that always seemed happy, now i hope he truly feels at peace. Deepest condolences to his family, the members of Astro, fans and everyone who's grieving. We love you Binnie, rip my dear. ❤🕊
Rip moonbin 🤧💜
Coming back to this video after everything went South
He was our protector but we failed to protect him
Binnie , i will miss you. Nunu will always need you
But now his emotional support is gone forever💔😭 were here for you eunwoo rest well binnie
Who knew that the moral support needed the support most , i still don't want to believe this happened rest in peace my bias 🙏 i hope in next life i meet you again and you would be more happy and get everything you want
빈아 빈아 너 왜 어른인척했어🥺
맘이 넘 아파 미안해.. 늘 이쁜말해주고 위로해줘서 고마워
❤Moonbin je bio poseban .💔💔💔💔😢
This video hit different because Moon Bin suddenly left 😢
Rest In Peace angel 🙏
Im just watching all of those videos back and it Im so happy I was able to know him
Who will comfort our Eunwoo now that you're gone Binnie.😢😢😢
Gone too soon🕊 Rest In Peace dear angel
은우는 몇 영상만 봐도 아스트로에 대한 자부심도 크고 아스트로를 더욱 알리고자 함도 커 보인다. 그만큼 개인 활동도 열심히 하고.. 혼자 많은 스케줄 소화하기가 힘들텐데, 힘든 걸 티내지도 않고 묵묵하게 열심히 해서 빈이는 항상 고마워하고 미안해했구나 눈빛이 말해주네..
It's now so sad to see this video as moonbin just left us he was such a bright person it is hard to believe this may his family and members find strength although it's hard 😢😢😢😢😭
I hope you NEVER delete this video!!
R.I.P Moonbin 🕊️💔
오늘도 눈물로 시작이네... 첨엔 산하가 젤 걱정되었어. 그 아이 행여 무너질까봐 조심스럽게 인스타도 체크하고.. 사진이라도 뭐 올라오면 글케 반갑고 살아있구나 잘 있구나. 문산하며 더욱 빈이에게 많이의지했고 춤.노래.무대.운동.다정함.인성 빠지지않는 잘난형에게 늘 배워나가며 사랑과 챙김받기만 한줄알았는데 깊이있게보니 늘 형을 조심스레 챙겨주고 웃게해주고 편안하게 해주려는거 그 맘 잘알겠더라. 산하가 젤 많이 느끼고있었을테지 형의 다운되는 신체컨디션에 불안정한 무드를 지켜보며 해줄수있는게 많지않았을테고... 근데 이제보니 점점 걱정되는사람이 늘어. 은우가 생각보다 빈이 영향을 많이 받게 될것같아. 상남자 빈이가 은우에게 사랑표현도 많이 대놓고 자주했는데 그 다정한 사랑주던 내 베스트가 이세상에 없다는게 너무 잔인하게 느껴진다... 은우 표현많이 못하고 꾹꾹 누르는거 하지말고 좀 쉬어가며 자신을 잘 챙겼으면 좋겠어. 아마 하늘에서 빈이가 젤 걱정하는사람 은우 산하 둘이 아닐까싶어. 서로 안아주고 일으켜주며 잘 살아나가길 응원해. 문차산 영원해라❤
Такая глупость, Бин не любил Санху, он ему просто не нравился даже как человек, он сам открыто говорил, что ему трудно работать, а Ыну просто развлекается и дальше... Никогда он не был искренен... Он просто самовлюблённый нарцисс... Слишком его избаловали комплименты, причём не заслуженно....как человек может называть себя артистом, не умея танцевать, да и вокал так себе... Актёр из него так же отвратительный..
Guys moonbin is no more
It's so heartbreaking I feel bad for all the other members and the grief they will go through
May his soul rest in peace🙏💐💐
Who’s here after his death news?
R.I.P my angel 🕊️😔
😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 i can't believe
This madee cry to be honest... Now that Moonbin has left... Who is Eun Woo gonna rely on? I already miss him.... Is that possible? May he rest in peace... May Moonbin find peace and luck in the afterlife...... It's so sad... This really made me cry so much!
Please support Astro!
I would miss this interaction😞
i almost cry cuz of the thumbnail😭
Here after moonbin's death... aroha and binie's family I am so so so sorry for your loss. Astro members as well, I can only express my condolences. I'm really so sorry.
He is living in my heart ❤
I cried at the moment when the song "Don't cry, my love" came out with the video of them crying and comforting each other...
My whole heart melted when watching this, it totally warmed my heart. This is exactly the feeling whenever I think of binwoo. The word "friends" seemed to impair their bond, they're not just only friends, but more like a family.
Although I've seen a lot of different binwoo edits, this one is surely the one that stands out. This video must be made of love towards ASTRO, couldn't thank you more for editing this.
Thank you very much, I did it with a lot of love because I really love this friendship. 🥺💜
This is so heartbreaking 😞 Rest in peace puppycat
Watching this video makes me cry & cry again. Still indenial with what happen to Bin. Bin is an ace, talented, kind & all rounder. My Binwoo forever.
아스트로멤버 모두가 바르고 착한 사람들.
이젠 힘들면 서로에게 기대 함께
헤쳐나가고 빈이의 빈자리
잘 채워주시길 바랍니다.
너무나 고생 많았던 아스트로..
영상을 보는 내내 가슴이 아프고..
이제 힘든날 지나고 좋은날 올껀데
별이된 빈..
너무 가슴이 아프고 안타깝습니다..
wow, this is literally the best binwoo editing for sure. thank you! Telling a real, sincere, touching story between two human beings.
This got recommended to me and I’m losing my mind all over again, RIP Moonbin😭🕊️❤️
I love how kind and loving moonbin is to eunwoo and all astro members 💖💖💖
i hope moonbin will be at peace wherever he is....🤍
rest in paradise our moon😭❤️
I found this video by accident after reading pass-away news of Moon Bin. I think it’s hurt a thousand times for Moon Bin and others…
Sometimes we don't know behind their smile they have hard time 😭😭😭 may your soul rest in peace and Eun Woo please stay strong 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
I love their friendship. You can clearly see they have a special bond. I'm glad they have eachother when things are hard
Moonbin je uvjek njemu prilazio i tjesio ga ..predivni su obojica ❤❤❤😢😢😢
Rest in peace moon........... The moon went to the stars forever...... 🥺 love uhh moonbin........i can't stop my tears........🥺🤍
I'm in tears now. RIP Moonbin ❤✨
May moonbin rest in peace❤🕊️
The song is "Don't Cry, My Love" but I'm actually crying more. My Binwoo 😭😭😭
I'm devastated
11:09 11:35 even though Moonbin tries holding he’s own tears at the same time he comforts Cha Eunwoo..😢😔❤️💔…So sad u will be miss
so sad Eunwoo not even tries to comport him at such moments
Wow. This was a great video. Moonbin is his safety net. The bond they have is strong. ❤❤ Love it!
I am grateful for your words, I am glad you liked it. ♥️
Me rompió el corazón este video ,Dios mio 😢
,Se querían tanto mis niños MOONBIN y Cha eunwoo y Cómo ,No extrañar a mis chicos de ASTRO.🥹
Si eran unos truinfandores , los mejores ,los únicos , Ojalá algún día no muy lejano vuelvan a subir al escenario,y brillen como solo ellos saben hacerlo ,Mis 5 Hermosos. , bendiciones.,,Y un abrazo hasta el cielo para mi Ángel Moonbin 🥹🥹
He is gone now . I don't know how to live with this
Rest in peace Moonbin😭I really can't believe he is no more with us.We will miss you Moon🕊️
RIP binnnnn aaaaaahhh, such a beautiful heart ❤😢😭😭😭😭
Woow
....binie loves eunwoo oppa too much...
Rest in peace our moon 💔🥀
How can I not stop crying after watching this 😭😭😭😭 Moonbin 😭😭😭
This video both warmed me up and broke my heart in a thousand pieces...
😭😭i cant... Moonbin crying cause he can emphasized w/ Eunwoo its so touching😭😭. they're like siblings
Que hermoso video, estos chicos de verdad se amaban
Ahhh life is such a fragile thing...one minute your alive and kicking the next you're 6feet deep
Hits different after he passed away
As a veteran binwoo-shipper I have to say this is one of the best edit video about Binwoo.
Thank you for your hard work in make this video.
Thank you very much for thinking that, I am also a Binwoo veteran but I just dared to make a video about them, I am grateful for how well they are being received 🤧💜
Moon Bin is very affectionate, faithful and attentive to those he loves. It was very nice to see that he was always paying attention to Eun Woo's face, trying to identify how he was feeling. A very beautiful love! Moon Bin has won a piece of my heart! We are similar in many ways, we like well-prepared and refined food. We Both knew Just by looking at him for the first time that Eun Woo's parents earned the three Michelin stars without much effort. ❤😂❤🌜🤦🏻♂️🌹🌹❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Estoy viendo este video literalmente llorando, mi Moonbin nos dejó para convertirse en un ángel,
Now his emotional support is no more.. rip angel
Currently, watching this is so hard...
The tears fall and our hearts break. Rest well sweetheart ❤
Its been more than a week now my Moon...... Am still in a phased believing that you'll be back...... I wish I knew ur struggling alone....... Wish u all the rest up there..... You'll be always in my heart
Who would have thought that the most jolly person, the comedienne, the funny, the brother, the shoulder to cry on, and so on in the group would suffer such emotional pain. Watching this video was a heartbreaking. My tears won’t stop falling watching Moonbin with a smile on his face that already a star in the sky. His one of the idol that I really fond watching too because of his charisma and funny personality. Who would have thought that his already gone? This tragic death of Moonbin still can’t sink in. That his gone. 😔💔 May his family and friends find the inner peace about the demise of their loving Moonbin. Rest in Peace 🕊️🙏🏻 our loving Moonbin. You will be forever in our hearts ❤️❤️❤️
It makes me sad that I am seeing this after he passed away 😭
Im missing moonbin .. rest in peace binnie you'll forever be loved and remember.. moon meet stars..
Moonbin era um ser iluminado pelos céus,com um coração gigante de amor ,carinho,dedicação,apoio,amigo,consolador,companheiro,meigo,carinhoso,amava o que fazia e o fazia com perfeição,e amava seus fãs,Dói saber que ele se foi,💔😔Era um artista completo e iluminado,e um ser humano incrível e maravilhoso,a nossa linda estrela agora esta brilhando no céu ⭐perdemos uma jóia rara,o céu ganhou um anjo iluminado precioso,minhas condolências aos familiares,grupo,amigos e equipe de trabalho,te amaremos eternamente Bin nossa eterna estrela brilhante⭐⭐UM ASTRO PERFEITO⭐💓💓💓💓💓💓
Looks like Eunwoo is the baby of the group 😊