Isn't the All Arounder One is Karina? She has everything. She is Leader, Main Dancer, Lead Rapper, good Vocalist that can easily become Lead Vocalist on other group, she has Unreal Visual, and amazing Stage Presence. Have you seen she on 4th Ranking in this video? Ok, for Vocal Karina and Giselle are changeabe, but she is such great Vocalist even though she is not part of Vocal-line. What she can't do?
@@yuqideep5270 where did they rap? They never actually rapped if you’re talking about the “I’m on the next level” part. That’s not a rap at all. That’s talking/singing.
@@darkbladesman7353 Karina is The Leader, Main Dancer, Lead Rapper, such a great Vocalist, have Unreal Visual, Amazing Stage Presence, and very populer. Have you ever seen she on 4th Rank on this video? What she can't do?
@@darkbladesman7353 both winter and Karina can be ace but Karina is really higher than winter when it comes to rap , stage presence, charisma facial expressions.
y'all underestimating giselle's vocal when literally girlie have that experience, and we aren't yet aware of her range but her technique are better than karina. anw it's still your opinions.
karina is better but that doesn't mean people are underestimating giselle's vocal. i mean, of course someone has to be last? if either of the members are last, it would still make some people offended. plus, ranking of skills such as vocals, dance and rap are not and should never be based on opinion. all of them have a background in singing and all of them are excellent vocalists. in other group, giselle would def excel. stop those type of comments, obviously someone will be last in every category. they can't be all in first.
You are the one that is underestimating Karina's vocals. Karina have more experience in vocal training from professional than Giselle. Only reason why you think Karina is lower than Giselle is because giselle was in choir. But you are forgetting the fact that before entering SM, Karina was a vocal student at vocal academy ( where Solar trained) + she has 4 years of professional vocal training from SM. Whereas Giselle trained in a Choir in her high school. Giselle is great but Karina is definitely better.
@@ayeon5609 I didn't underestimate karina's VOCAL, I'm talking about VOCAL TECHNIQUE and I stand by my comment that giselle have better VOCAL TECHNIQUE because karina is kinda shaky which is understandable because they are still rookie which can be improve by time comes. My comment is all about those comment that underestimating saying that giselle doesn't have a good vocal because she's the rapper when giselle haven't show her real potential yet. And I didn't even rank giselle and karina's vocal?? as I said i'm talking about vocal technique, and the main point of my comment is all about those comment that underestimate giselle's vocal here that's all it has nothing to do about their vocal and ranking
@@mystique1033 Karina have better techniques, she have better support, and she is definitely a better vocalist. Also tell the vocal technique criteria where you think Giselle is better. Also you are talking about how giselle haven't shown her potential, then how do you know Giselle is better than Karina ? Also no one is underestimating Giselle's vocal, because in forever/black mamba era every UA-cam was ranking Giselle higher than Karina except vocal channels.
I agree with your ranking but for now we should put both Ningning and Giselle 3rd for dancing and Winter and Ningning 3rd for rapping until they show more stuffs in the future. And for me Karina visual is no.1
Ningning is definitely 3rd at dancing. You should see Ningning fancams for next level. This one is probably her best stage - ua-cam.com/video/FYg5MnxagRY/v-deo.html
@@regularpotato No they're are visuals but Winter fits the Korean beauty standards more so she's the visual of the group. Just because u find Karina prettier doesn't mean she's the visual🤷♀️(no hate to her, she's also super pretty)
@@aura-bj4wr we haven't had a chance to see her really rapper yet, she was obviously just playing on the radio. I still think it's too early to draw conclusions
@Luiza Soares yeah prettiness can be subjective blah blah (just say you're tasteless) but karina IS the most talented member so cry about it i guess? i'd be sorry for you getting all worked over seeing karina get praised but showing empathy towards jealous closeminded haters? not my thing
Vocal 1. Ning ( support up to B4/C5, can compare with Jessica/BoA ) 2. Winter ( support up to A4/Bb4 ) 3. Giselle ( had some shallow support I guess at least she can compare with Joy ) 4. Karina ( she has style but still too nasal) Dance 1. Karina 2. Winter 3. Giselle 4. Ning Rap 1. Giselle 2. Karina 3. Ning 4. Winter Visual 1. Karina ( I just say the truth that she pretty & AI than her ae ^^ ) 2. Winter 3. Giselle 4. Ning
@@secrets5870 can you stop using her choir thingy to keep saying that makes her better than Karina? Karina was actually at vocal academy for years and she was training as main vocal too
@@godjihyo143 so whats about the technique when the only part that ningning have os the same of winter and giselle and its not diferent at all, and we are talking about korean rap, im pretty sure winter have a better pronunciation of words than ningning, after all winter is korean and its her first language
hello this is my ranking, and this is facts based on netizens/fans and also SM Entertainment Vocal 1. NingNing - ofc she's the main vocal and the queen of vocal in 4th gen 2. Winter - lead vocal to main vocal 3. Giselle - everyone agreed that giselle is better than karina when it comes to vocal, because giselle was a former member in choir, so what did u expect? she had a good vocal and she said that her hobby is hitting the high notes, and i really think if sm give her lines to show her skills in vocal, no doubt everyone thinks that she's the main vocal 4. Karina - i read that she's member in music academy so she had a good vocal too. (FYI. All members in aespa could be a main vocalist) and winter said in their previous vlog they have not specific position in vocal, so everyone could be a main vocalist position hahahaha. Dance 1. Karina - ofc she's a main dancer 2. Winter - lead dancer 3. NingNing - i prefer her over giselle, i thought that she's a lead dancer in black mamba era because of her energetic moves and also fans noticed that 4. Giselle - i love her dancing skills too, it's so clean and smooth Rap 1. Giselle - ofc no doubt, she's a main rapper, the best female rapper in sm, after Amber from f (x). Giselle's rap is very fast and i love her flow when she rapped. 2. Karina - same as giselle her rap flow too is very swag 3. NingNing - i prefer her over winter because she said that she want to be a rapper. Also she rapped to their new song Next Level and wow i amazed it she good at it 4. Winter - She good at rapping too Stage Presence 1. NingNing - everyone noticed about this, ningning has very strong stage presence watch her fancam in black mamba, her facial expression is very strong 2. Karina 3. Giselle 4. Winter Visual 1. Winter 2. Karina 3. NingNing/Karina All-Rounder can sing, can dance, can rap very well criteria as an KPOP idol 1. Karina/Winter 2. Giselle/NingNing Bias 1. All of them ACE OF THE GROUP: KARINA FACE OF THE GROUP COULD BE WINTER OR KARINA POPULARITY 1. KARINA 2. WINTER 3. GISELLE 4. NINGNING
@@arieltagnipez7309 No, she is not. All of people in youtube that have channels about vocal have said that Karina is better. Of course one person can be wrong, but every person who have knowledge about vocal have said Karina is better.
My ranking -Vocal 1.Ningning 2.Winter 3.Karina 4.Giselle -Rap 1.Giselle 2.Karina 3.Winter 4.Ningning -Dance 1.Karina 2.Winter 3.Ningning 4.Giselle -Visual 1.Winter/Karina 2.Giselle 3.Ningning -My bias ranking 1.Karina 2.Winter, Giselle, Ningning YA'LL DO YOU EVEN KNOW WHAT IS AN OPINION!?U WANT OTHERS TO RESPECT UR OPINION BUT CAN'T EVEN RESPECT MINE
@Keishi Kaneko opinion can't be a lie,for example some people say they prefer Lisa's rapping over Jennie's, but Jennie is a better rapper,the same goes for me, I prefer Winter's vocals than Ningning's but Ningning is technically a better vocalist
Tbh Winter is the best singer like her voice is so unique. It’s deep and high at the same time lol I was surprised hearing Black Mamba for the first time
@@shielomaedatinginoo4547 a SM director said that the most pretty idol in real life from SM is winter...but of course if you want to rank jiminjeong visual it will be more focused on preference..(sorry bad eng)
I agree with the rankings and i cant stop laughing from how the transitions cut off the other members Example In vocals Its ningning's ranking,Then the video should stop there when her line ends but instead the other member's line starts but then cuts off which makes me wheeze i cant- Im about to bust a lung whenever that happens🤣
Vocal: -Ning -Winter -Karina -Giselle(Ik she's good interms of vocal but she haven't really showed it yet so imma rank her last) Dance: -Karina -Winter -Ning -Giselle(she really is behind ning in dancing and its ok bcs her dancing is pretty good to someone who only trained for 10months while ning trained for years) Rap: -Giselle(no doubt) -Karina -Win/Ning(haven't heard them properly rap, there are vocalist that are good in rapping but dont get the chance to rap, for example, Jisoo from Bp) Visual: note* THERE IS NO VISUAL HOLE IN AESPA -Winter -Karina -Ning -Giselle overall: -Winter/Karina -Ning/Giselle PS: Giselle often get last bcs maybe its her training period she only trained for 10 months while others trained for years 3yrs is the second shortest training period and thats a huge gap to improve her skills
Mi ranking nov 2021 Vocal 1.Ningning-main vocal, su voz es muy poderosa, sus notas altas son impecables y estoy segura que aún nos puede mostrar más 2.Winter-lead vocal, su tono de voz es muy bonito, puede hacer notas altas y fácilmente podría ser main vocal. 3. Karina-sub vocal, karina podría ser como tal una lead vocal, su voz es muy estable. 4.Giselle-sub vocal, por ser 4 no significa que no sea buena cantando, también tiene una voz muy estable y como siempre Sm tiene los mejores vocalistas, hasta Giselle siendo sub vocal en aespa podría ser lead vocal. •El Fuerte de aespa al ser de SM obvio es el vocal y nos lo han demostrado, literalmente aespa tiene dos main vocals y dos lead vocals, todas pueden hacer notas altas y sus voces son preciosas y muy estables. Baile 1.Karina-main dancer, por lo que he visto de Karina baila muy bien, su técnica es diferente a la de otros grupos pero siento que es muy del estilo Sm. 2.winter-lead dancer, los pasos de winter son muy fluidos y se ve muy bien bailando. 3.ningselle-sub dancer, son buenas bailando, para mi las dos ocupan el 3er lugar. •Su baile es muy bueno y siento que no nos han demostrado todo su potencial, espero que Sm las dejé hacer dance cover. Y por lo que veo en los grupos de chicas de Sm son más de hacer movimientos con las manos. Rap 1.Giselle-main rapper, su rap es muy bueno, ya nos demostró que puede escribir su propio rap y espero que Sm le de la oportunidad de escribir su rap en canciones más adelante. 2.Karina-lead rapper, me gusta mucho su forma de rapear, y nos ha demostrado que es buena. 3.Winter-sub rapper, en savage nos mostró un poco de su rap y se escuchaba muy bien, espero que más adelante nos vaya mostrando más. 4.Ningning-rapper, aún no nos ha mostrado como tal su rap, pero dijo que estaba practicando así que espero que en el siguiente comeback le den al oportunidad de rapear. •Giselle y karina son un buen dúo de rap y winter y ningning se ven que tambein tiene muy buen potencial en el rap. Visual 1.Winter-Aunque muchos dicen que no es la oficial, creo que desde el debut se confirmó por cómo las presentaron en sus synk, cumple con los estándares de Corea. 1.Karina- es muy hermosa y también cumple con los estándares de Corea. 1.Giselle-Gigi tiene un toque elegante y extranjero, su visual es impresionante. 1.Ningning- Ning es extremadamente bonita, tiene unos ojos muy bonitos y tiene un aura sexy y tierna a la vez. •siento que en términos visuales aespa es como Exo, unos dicen que es Kai otros que están suho, otros que es Sehun, ya es más del gusto personal. En presencia escénica a mi me gustan todas, siento que no necesitan hacer tantas expresiones, para mi gusto está perfecto así, no está exagerado, y siento que su baile y la historia de la canción no es como para que hagan tantas expresiones, así les da unas vibras elegantes. Bias 1.Winter 2.kariningselle Para esos que se pelean por quien es más all rounder o quién es la visual, seguras que son mys? o son akgaes o antis tratando de tirar hate 🙄
Hello, this is my Opinion :) -` Vocal 1. NingNing Ofcourse She's Main Vocalist 2. Winter She's Good at singing too, She Lead Vocalist 3. Giselle 4. Karina -` Rap 1. Giselle Giselle is too good for me at Rapping, Btw she's Main Rapper 2. Karina Karina Rap is make me Addicted, She's Lead Rapper 3. NingNing 4. Winter -` Dance 1. Karina She's Main Dancer 2. Winter She Is Lead Dancer 3. NingNing 4. Giselle -` Visual 1. Winter Yeah Ofcourse She's Beautifull At Natural and At Makeup 2. Karina She Is So Beautifull too at Natural Or Makeup 3. NingNing 4. Giselle Thank You For Reading My Opinion :)
Hahaha giselle can do harmonation as well as high notes. Just look her video before debut , and sm confirmed that 1. Ningning 2. Winter 3. Giselle 4. Karina in terms in vocal.
@@ryu-qn6fw yes it is, idk the popular one beacuse each member are popular in different countries in my country Ningning is the most biased/popular member
I personally agree with practically all of them APART from the dance ranking. I'd place NingNing as 4th and Giselle as 3rd. Cause at least for me, Giselle ain't the weakest at two things.
![4th Gen GG Ranking In Different Categories 2021[IZ*ONE, ITZY, (G)I-DLE, EVERGLOW, AESPA, LOONA]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/wlT-4lrckbg/mqdefault.jpg)
![4th Gen GG Ranking In Different Categories 2021[IZ*ONE, ITZY, (G)I-DLE, EVERGLOW, AESPA, LOONA]](/img/tr.png)
![IVE VS AESPA [ VOCAL, DANCE, RAP, VISUAL & MORE'] 2021-2022 #IVE#aespa#kpop#ranking](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/nF5gskjhK_Y/mqdefault.jpg)
Vocal
Ningning
Winter
Karina
Giselle
Rap
Giselle
Karina
Winter/Ningning
Visual
All of them at the top
i think winter is the most all rounder member,cause shes a visual,a lead vocal,lead dancer, and sub rapper🤗
She is not an sub rapper
Isn't the All Arounder One is Karina? She has everything. She is Leader, Main Dancer, Lead Rapper, good Vocalist that can easily become Lead Vocalist on other group, she has Unreal Visual, and amazing Stage Presence. Have you seen she on 4th Ranking in this video? Ok, for Vocal Karina and Giselle are changeabe, but she is such great Vocalist even though she is not part of Vocal-line. What she can't do?
@@kimchaehyunletsdebut4244 periodt.
@lola dacutest but Giselle isn’t that good in dancing
@@somoyed_jeno3727 yeah but karina isn's as good as Giselle in rap
Ning Ning & Winter haven’t actually rapped but you could use that as an example I guess
Wrong, in the new song Next level they rapped
@@yuqideep5270 where did they rap? They never actually rapped if you’re talking about the “I’m on the next level” part. That’s not a rap at all. That’s talking/singing.
@@xoMultiiStanox Rap isn't about being fast lol... i agree that they didn't rap but that doesn't have to do with the pace of their line.
@@thelionkink I didn’t mean fast in that way, I mean as in it’s just not rapping, that’s why I said it was talking/singing
@@xoMultiiStanox thats rap
Karina is the Ace of Aespa
It's winter babe who is an ace😏😉
@@darkbladesman7353 Karina is The Leader, Main Dancer, Lead Rapper, such a great Vocalist, have Unreal Visual, Amazing Stage Presence, and very populer. Have you ever seen she on 4th Rank on this video? What she can't do?
Yes 🔥
@@darkbladesman7353 🥴
@@darkbladesman7353 both winter and Karina can be ace but Karina is really higher than winter when it comes to rap , stage presence, charisma facial expressions.
ningning is such an underrated visual tho
FR like pls I’m so drawn to her visuals every time I see her 😭😭
Updated :
Vocal :
#1. Ning ning
#2. Winter
#3. Karina
#4. Giselle
Dancer ;
#1. Karina
#2. Winter
#3. Ning ning
#4. Giselle
Rap :
#1. Giselle
#2. Karina.
#3. Winter
#4. Ning ning
Visual :
#1. Winter
#2. Karina
#3. Giselle
#4. Ning ning
Agreeeed
Agree
Agree
Ok but I think they’re all visuals. 😍😍
Me at First i Thought that Karina was the Visual,all the staff say that Karina IS very beautiful
y'all underestimating giselle's vocal when literally girlie have that experience, and we aren't yet aware of her range but her technique are better than karina. anw it's still your opinions.
karina is better but that doesn't mean people are underestimating giselle's vocal. i mean, of course someone has to be last? if either of the members are last, it would still make some people offended. plus, ranking of skills such as vocals, dance and rap are not and should never be based on opinion. all of them have a background in singing and all of them are excellent vocalists. in other group, giselle would def excel. stop those type of comments, obviously someone will be last in every category. they can't be all in first.
You are the one that is underestimating Karina's vocals. Karina have more experience in vocal training from professional than Giselle. Only reason why you think Karina is lower than Giselle is because giselle was in choir. But you are forgetting the fact that before entering SM, Karina was a vocal student at vocal academy ( where Solar trained) + she has 4 years of professional vocal training from SM. Whereas Giselle trained in a Choir in her high school. Giselle is great but Karina is definitely better.
@@ayeon5609 I didn't underestimate karina's VOCAL, I'm talking about VOCAL TECHNIQUE and I stand by my comment that giselle have better VOCAL TECHNIQUE because karina is kinda shaky which is understandable because they are still rookie which can be improve by time comes. My comment is all about those comment that underestimating saying that giselle doesn't have a good vocal because she's the rapper when giselle haven't show her real potential yet. And I didn't even rank giselle and karina's vocal?? as I said i'm talking about vocal technique, and the main point of my comment is all about those comment that underestimate giselle's vocal here that's all it has nothing to do about their vocal and ranking
@@mystique1033 Karina have better techniques, she have better support, and she is definitely a better vocalist. Also tell the vocal technique criteria where you think Giselle is better. Also you are talking about how giselle haven't shown her potential, then how do you know Giselle is better than Karina ? Also no one is underestimating Giselle's vocal, because in forever/black mamba era every UA-cam was ranking Giselle higher than Karina except vocal channels.
@@ayeon5609 not y'all giving too much attention to these rankings, all of them are different, stop defending each other lol.
For me:
Visual
1. Karina
2. Ningning/Winter
3. Giselle
Vocal
1. Ningning
2. Winter
3. Karina
4. Giselle
Rap
1. Giselle
2. Karina
3. Winter
4. Ningning
Bias: Winter
I agree with your ranking but for now we should put both Ningning and Giselle 3rd for dancing and Winter and Ningning 3rd for rapping until they show more stuffs in the future. And for me Karina visual is no.1
Thanks!!😙😙
Ningning is definitely 3rd at dancing. You should see Ningning fancams for next level. This one is probably her best stage - ua-cam.com/video/FYg5MnxagRY/v-deo.html
Karina is the main dancer, so she is in 2nd place in visual 😁
@@regularpotato 🤣🤣🤣🤣 you're out of it, practically all of them are visual, but in the group they are second
@@regularpotato No they're are visuals but Winter fits the Korean beauty standards more so she's the visual of the group. Just because u find Karina prettier doesn't mean she's the visual🤷♀️(no hate to her, she's also super pretty)
Karina the ace of aespa
I think for visual
Karina
NingNing
Winter
Giselle
Rap ranking: Winter 3√ all round Ace top 3 in everything
@grace we will have to agree to disagree
Winter is 4th in rapping not 3rd cause ningning actually practices rapping unlike winter
@@ilychu2203 in my opinion winter has a better voice for rap
@@anaxavier5867 just bc she has a better voice for rap doesn’t mean she’s better at rapping than NingNing...
@@aura-bj4wr we haven't had a chance to see her really rapper yet, she was obviously just playing on the radio. I still think it's too early to draw conclusions
Vocal
1. Ningning
2. Winter
3. Giselle
4. Karina
Rap
1. Giselle
2. Karina
3. Winter
4. Ningning
Dance
1. Karina
2. Winter
3. Ningning
4. Giselle
Visual
1. Winter
2. Karina
3. Giselle
4. Ningning
Rap ranking:winter 3✓
karina the most talented and prettiest member mwah 💅🏻
@Luiza Soares yeah prettiness can be subjective blah blah (just say you're tasteless) but karina IS the most talented member so cry about it i guess?
i'd be sorry for you getting all worked over seeing karina get praised but showing empathy towards jealous closeminded haters? not my thing
@Luiza Soares probably a solo stan
Vocal
1. Ning ( support up to B4/C5, can compare with Jessica/BoA )
2. Winter ( support up to A4/Bb4 )
3. Giselle ( had some shallow support I guess at least she can compare with Joy )
4. Karina ( she has style but still too nasal)
Dance
1. Karina
2. Winter
3. Giselle
4. Ning
Rap
1. Giselle
2. Karina
3. Ning
4. Winter
Visual
1. Karina ( I just say the truth that she pretty & AI than her ae ^^ )
2. Winter
3. Giselle
4. Ning
Ningning being 4th in dancing is such a joke😰
Ning Ning is a better dancer and Giselle and Giselle is way nasal and supports less than Karina
@@daisyr8490 giselle was in a choir for 4 years SM PLS GIVE HER MORE OPPORTUNITIES TO SHINE don’t sleep on her vocals
@@shuhuaaa4074 i think her and giselle are on the same level. ning ning’s stage presence is CRAZY
@@secrets5870 can you stop using her choir thingy to keep saying that makes her better than Karina? Karina was actually at vocal academy for years and she was training as main vocal too
Karina 🥰🥰
Winter had more rap than ningning in next level and the fact that winter is better than ningning in korean i would put winter in 3rd in rap
Winter is better in korean because she's korean and ningning is Chinese
But NingNing raps better than Winter
I dont think we should judge their rap yet bc both of them haven’t shown much until now. Maybe people put Ning2 third bc she is into rap more.
It's not who rapper most but technique is also important well ningning is best in rap than winter
@@godjihyo143 so whats about the technique when the only part that ningning have os the same of winter and giselle and its not diferent at all, and we are talking about korean rap, im pretty sure winter have a better pronunciation of words than ningning, after all winter is korean and its her first language
hello this is my ranking, and this is facts based on netizens/fans and also SM Entertainment
Vocal
1. NingNing - ofc she's the main vocal and the queen of vocal in 4th gen
2. Winter - lead vocal to main vocal
3. Giselle - everyone agreed that giselle is better than karina when it comes to vocal, because giselle was a former member in choir, so what did u expect? she had a good vocal and she said that her hobby is hitting the high notes, and i really think if sm give her lines to show her skills in vocal, no doubt everyone thinks that she's the main vocal
4. Karina - i read that she's member in music academy so she had a good vocal too.
(FYI. All members in aespa could be a main vocalist) and winter said in their previous vlog
they have not specific position in vocal, so everyone could be a main vocalist position hahahaha.
Dance
1. Karina - ofc she's a main dancer
2. Winter - lead dancer
3. NingNing - i prefer her over giselle, i thought that she's a lead dancer in black mamba era because of her energetic moves and also fans noticed that
4. Giselle - i love her dancing skills too, it's so clean and smooth
Rap
1. Giselle - ofc no doubt, she's a main rapper, the best female rapper in sm, after Amber from
f (x). Giselle's rap is very fast and i love her flow when she rapped.
2. Karina - same as giselle her rap flow too is very swag
3. NingNing - i prefer her over winter because she said that she want to be a rapper. Also she rapped to their new song Next Level and wow i amazed it she good at it
4. Winter - She good at rapping too
Stage Presence
1. NingNing - everyone noticed about this, ningning has very strong stage presence watch her fancam in black mamba, her facial expression is very strong
2. Karina
3. Giselle
4. Winter
Visual
1. Winter
2. Karina
3. NingNing/Karina
All-Rounder
can sing, can dance, can rap very well criteria as an KPOP idol
1. Karina/Winter
2. Giselle/NingNing
Bias
1. All of them
ACE OF THE GROUP: KARINA
FACE OF THE GROUP COULD BE WINTER OR KARINA
POPULARITY
1. KARINA
2. WINTER
3. GISELLE
4. NINGNING
you got the popularity wrong and the Visual part I am confused lol and face of group i would see Ning Ning bc of presents in the group
These girls are all rounder
We can't rank winter and ningning on rap yet we haven't heard them properly
Ningning rap on motto
Winter is a sub rapper and is more capable than NingNing. Now you can hear it on "Savage"
@@ongphim6757 she doesn't have a rap position. I would rank her higher than ning tho since she rapped more often
Winter rap in savage✨
Vocal
NN
Winter
Giselle
Karina
Rap
Giselle
Karina
NN
Winter
Dance
Karina
Winter
Giselle
NN
Visual
Winter
Karina
Giselle
NN
I thought Ning was the Visuals LMFAOOO she is so pretty!
My opinion
Visual
1.Winter
2.Karina
3.Giselle
4.Ningning
Vocal
1.NINGNING
2.WINTER
3.GISELLE
4.KARINA
RAP
1.GISELLE
2.KARINA
3.WINTER/NINGNING
DANCE
1.KARINA
2.WINTER
3.NINGNING
4.GISELLE
I like this ranking
Your ranking is teh best i love it
for me it’s
vocal: ningning, winter, giselle, karina
rap: giselle, karina, winter, ningning
dance: karina, winter, ningning, giselle
visuals: karina, giselle, winter, ningning
bias: karina, giselle, ningning, winter
Vocal:
Ning2
Winter
Karina
Giselle
Dance
Winter
Karina
Ning2
Giselle
Rap
Giselle
Karina
Winter
Ning2
Visual
Winter/Karina
Giselle/Ning2
Agree👌.
Thanks:33
@@user-gh9ju4jh3w giselle is must better to karina to vocal
@@arieltagnipez7309 No, she is not. All of people in youtube that have channels about vocal have said that Karina is better. Of course one person can be wrong, but every person who have knowledge about vocal have said Karina is better.
Vocal:
4) Giselle
3) Karina
2) Winter
1) Ningning
Dance:
4) Ningning
3) Giselle
2) Winter
1) Karina
Rap:
4) Ningning
3) Winter
2) Karina
1) Giselle
Visual:
4) Ningning
3) Karina
2) Giselle
1) Winter
Right
@@lynnkhant1176 Thank you
Giselle is bad in dance at ningning lol and ning at unique visuel at member who is qo beauty standart lol
@@BTSsexyvempirejin they are interchangable. Ningning has more power while giselle has better body control
@@ilychu2203 no lie
Imo karina visual is no joke!! An aceeee
Yes! This is the perfect list! I agree on everything.
I wish I could put all there ranking in here but I dont really like to type or think to much cause everything is in my brain.
Vocal :
1. Ningning
2. Winter
3. Karina
4. Giselle
Dance :
1. Karina
2. Winter
3. Giselle
4. Ningning
Rap :
1. Giselle
2. Karina
3. Winter
4. Ningning
Visual :
1. Winter
2. Karina
3. Ningning
4. Giselle
Karina best visual
My ranking
-Vocal
1.Ningning
2.Winter
3.Karina
4.Giselle
-Rap
1.Giselle
2.Karina
3.Winter
4.Ningning
-Dance
1.Karina
2.Winter
3.Ningning
4.Giselle
-Visual
1.Winter/Karina
2.Giselle
3.Ningning
-My bias ranking
1.Karina
2.Winter, Giselle, Ningning
YA'LL DO YOU EVEN KNOW WHAT IS AN OPINION!?U WANT OTHERS TO RESPECT UR OPINION BUT CAN'T EVEN RESPECT MINE
Liar, Winter don't sing better than Ningning
@@Ggky306 That is MY ranking, MY opinion, I prefer Winter vocals than Ningning, I am not a huge fan of Ningnings vocals
@@Ggky306 Do you even know what is the difference between a lie and an opinion?
Giselle is more of an ace than Ning Ning, Ning Ning can only sing, Giselle can sing and rap
@Keishi Kaneko opinion can't be a lie,for example some people say they prefer Lisa's rapping over Jennie's, but Jennie is a better rapper,the same goes for me, I prefer Winter's vocals than Ningning's but Ningning is technically a better vocalist
Tbh Winter is the best singer like her voice is so unique. It’s deep and high at the same time lol I was surprised hearing Black Mamba for the first time
My opinion:
Vocal:
1- Ningning
2- Winter
3- Giselle
4- Karina
Visual:
1- Karina
2- Winter
3- Giselle&Ningning
For me
Visual : 1.winter 2.ning
3.giselle 4.karina
you got it opposite lmaooo 🤣
@@aura-bj4wr diff opinions^^btw no rankings theyre all beautiful
My opinion on aespa ranking
Vocal
1.NingNing 10/10
2.Winter 9.8/10
3.Karina 7.8/10
4.Giselle 5.9/10
Dance
1.Karina 10/10
2.Winter 9.5/10
3.NingNing 4.3/10
4.Giselle 2.3/10
Rap
1.Giselle 10/10
2.Karina 9.8/10
3.Winter 6/10
4.NingNing 5.3/10
Visual
1.Winter 10/10
2.Karina 9.9/10
3.NingNing 9/10
4.Giselle 8.6/10
My bias
1.NingNing
2.Karina
3.Giselle
4.Winter
That was my opinion how agree with me how doesn’t it’s ok but yea
I agree
They saying that KARINA is more beautiful but why did SM pick WINTER as the Visual of the group
Maybe they find KARINA as the most attractive but For me WINTER IS THE MOST BEAUTIFUL
@@shielomaedatinginoo4547 yea but the beauty of the group is KARINA
@@shielomaedatinginoo4547 a SM director said that the most pretty idol in real life from SM is winter...but of course if you want to rank jiminjeong visual it will be more focused on preference..(sorry bad eng)
Agree!!
I agree with the rankings and i cant stop laughing from how the transitions cut off the other members
Example
In vocals Its ningning's ranking,Then the video should stop there when her line ends but instead the other member's line starts but then cuts off which makes me wheeze i cant-
Im about to bust a lung whenever that happens🤣
I think winter is the 3rd in rap and Ningning is 4th
No hate but the ranking for rap is
1- Giselle
2- Karina
3- Winter
4- Ningning
(no hate I respect ur opinion)
Vocal
1 Ningning
2 winter
3 karina
4 giselle
Dance
1 karina
2 winter
3 ningning
4 Giselle
Rap
1 giselle
2 karina
3 winter
4 ningning
Visual
1 ningning
2 karina
3 winter
4 giselle
Winter I think is a better rapper then Ning Ning u probably didn’t know this though because savage album wasn’t out at the time
In my opinion
vocal
1.ningning
2.winter
3.Karina/Giselle
dance
1.Karina
2.winter
3.ningning
4.Giselle
rap
1.Giselle
2.Karina
3.winter
4.ningning
visual
1.winter
2.ningning
3.Karina
4.Giselle
Vocal:
-Ning
-Winter
-Karina
-Giselle(Ik she's good interms of vocal but she haven't really showed it yet so imma rank her last)
Dance:
-Karina
-Winter
-Ning
-Giselle(she really is behind ning in dancing and its ok bcs her dancing is pretty good to someone who only trained for 10months while ning trained for years)
Rap:
-Giselle(no doubt)
-Karina
-Win/Ning(haven't heard them properly rap, there are vocalist that are good in rapping but dont get the chance to rap, for example, Jisoo from Bp)
Visual:
note* THERE IS NO VISUAL HOLE IN AESPA
-Winter
-Karina
-Ning
-Giselle
overall:
-Winter/Karina
-Ning/Giselle
PS: Giselle often get last bcs maybe its her training period she only trained for 10 months while others trained for years 3yrs is the second shortest training period and thats a huge gap to improve her skills
There is not any visual hole in kpop
AESPA
For me giselle vocal on 3rd place while giselle dancing skill on 4th
I would say Winter is better than NingNing at rapping but other than that I agree with this ranking
The fact that winter is all rounder and it has been confirmed by karina herself in an interview.
?🤔
Me parece muy acertado todo, buen video
Mi ranking nov 2021
Vocal
1.Ningning-main vocal, su voz es muy poderosa, sus notas altas son impecables y estoy segura que aún nos puede mostrar más
2.Winter-lead vocal, su tono de voz es muy bonito, puede hacer notas altas y fácilmente podría ser main vocal.
3. Karina-sub vocal, karina podría ser como tal una lead vocal, su voz es muy estable.
4.Giselle-sub vocal, por ser 4 no significa que no sea buena cantando, también tiene una voz muy estable y como siempre Sm tiene los mejores vocalistas, hasta Giselle siendo sub vocal en aespa podría ser lead vocal.
•El Fuerte de aespa al ser de SM obvio es el vocal y nos lo han demostrado, literalmente aespa tiene dos main vocals y dos lead vocals, todas pueden hacer notas altas y sus voces son preciosas y muy estables.
Baile
1.Karina-main dancer, por lo que he visto de Karina baila muy bien, su técnica es diferente a la de otros grupos pero siento que es muy del estilo Sm.
2.winter-lead dancer, los pasos de winter son muy fluidos y se ve muy bien bailando.
3.ningselle-sub dancer, son buenas bailando, para mi las dos ocupan el 3er lugar.
•Su baile es muy bueno y siento que no nos han demostrado todo su potencial, espero que Sm las dejé hacer dance cover. Y por lo que veo en los grupos de chicas de Sm son más de hacer movimientos con las manos.
Rap
1.Giselle-main rapper, su rap es muy bueno, ya nos demostró que puede escribir su propio rap y espero que Sm le de la oportunidad de escribir su rap en canciones más adelante.
2.Karina-lead rapper, me gusta mucho su forma de rapear, y nos ha demostrado que es buena.
3.Winter-sub rapper, en savage nos mostró un poco de su rap y se escuchaba muy bien, espero que más adelante nos vaya mostrando más.
4.Ningning-rapper, aún no nos ha mostrado como tal su rap, pero dijo que estaba practicando así que espero que en el siguiente comeback le den al oportunidad de rapear.
•Giselle y karina son un buen dúo de rap y winter y ningning se ven que tambein tiene muy buen potencial en el rap.
Visual
1.Winter-Aunque muchos dicen que no es la oficial, creo que desde el debut se confirmó por cómo las presentaron en sus synk, cumple con los estándares de Corea.
1.Karina- es muy hermosa y también cumple con los estándares de Corea.
1.Giselle-Gigi tiene un toque elegante y extranjero, su visual es impresionante.
1.Ningning- Ning es extremadamente bonita, tiene unos ojos muy bonitos y tiene un aura sexy y tierna a la vez.
•siento que en términos visuales aespa es como Exo, unos dicen que es Kai otros que están suho, otros que es Sehun, ya es más del gusto personal.
En presencia escénica a mi me gustan todas, siento que no necesitan hacer tantas expresiones, para mi gusto está perfecto así, no está exagerado, y siento que su baile y la historia de la canción no es como para que hagan tantas expresiones, así les da unas vibras elegantes.
Bias
1.Winter
2.kariningselle
Para esos que se pelean por quien es más all rounder o quién es la visual, seguras que son mys? o son akgaes o antis tratando de tirar hate 🙄
Giselle is better in vocal than Karina tbh, i mean her techniques and voice flexibility. But Karina is also good
agree!
Hello, this is my Opinion :)
-` Vocal
1. NingNing
Ofcourse She's Main Vocalist
2. Winter
She's Good at singing too, She Lead Vocalist
3. Giselle
4. Karina
-` Rap
1. Giselle
Giselle is too good for me at Rapping, Btw she's Main Rapper
2. Karina
Karina Rap is make me Addicted, She's Lead Rapper
3. NingNing
4. Winter
-` Dance
1. Karina
She's Main Dancer
2. Winter
She Is Lead Dancer
3. NingNing
4. Giselle
-` Visual
1. Winter
Yeah Ofcourse She's Beautifull At Natural and At Makeup
2. Karina
She Is So Beautifull too at Natural Or Makeup
3. NingNing
4. Giselle
Thank You For Reading My Opinion :)
Literally showed the least of 1st plac and most of 3 and 4
Hello? But giselle vocal is better than karina
No way 😂
I dont think so
No way
Hahaha giselle can do harmonation as well as high notes. Just look her video before debut , and sm confirmed that 1. Ningning 2. Winter 3. Giselle 4. Karina in terms in vocal.
legit
Rap winter 3
Who is the cute and funny 💜
Winter
Also Ningning
The intro is too long
I agreed ❤️
Can someone tell me who is the most biased/ popular member of aespa?
Probably Karina
@@kpoptroll4234 ty♡
1 . karina
2.winter
3.NingNing
4 . giselle
@@jenxning8743 is this the ranking of most biased member? Most to least?
@@ryu-qn6fw yes it is, idk the popular one beacuse each member are popular in different countries in my country Ningning is the most biased/popular member
AGREE
I personally agree with practically all of them APART from the dance ranking. I'd place NingNing as 4th and Giselle as 3rd. Cause at least for me, Giselle ain't the weakest at two things.
Hi
Hi
@@user-gh9ju4jh3w 💖
I love u so much!!!!
Hellooo
@@jupitteria 😊
Giselle has better vocals than Karina
Izone;(
Giselle is better than winter in vocals
Eh?
Sorry.......... Giselle is better than karina in vocals.......
Name...... Changed 😂😂
I think Giselle’s dance and visual is upper than Ningning
yes
And Giselle vocal is better than Karina I saw from forever
Giselle tends to underdance/skip some moves during performance stages.
lmao? Ningning is better than her
@@alanbalcarcel5850 I think so 😅 actually I’m gonna talking about Giselle’s vocal is better than Karina
it’s crazy. they are all top visuals. ningning is meh but still
Vocal
1. Ningning
2. Winter
3. Karina
4. Giselle
Rap
1. Giselle
2. Karina
3. Ningning/winter
Dance
1. Karina
2. Winter
3. Ningning
4. Giselle
Visual
1. Karina
2. Winter
3. Giselle/winter
Stage presence
1. Karina
2. Ningning
3. Giselle
4. Winter
Agree with this except stage presence.
Visual Giselle/Winter???