Why 5 Of The World's Priciest Salts And Spices Are So Expensive | So Expensive Food

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 16 тра 2022
  • From cinnamon to green cardamom, bamboo salt to river reed salt, join us as we revisit what makes these spices and salts so expensive.
    MORE BUSINESS INSIDER VIDEOS:
    How 4 Of The World’s Most Expensive Seafoods Are Harvested | So Expensive Food
    • Why 4 Of The World's P...
    Why Cloves Are So Expensive | So Expensive
    • Why Cloves Are So Expe...
    Why Sandalwood Is So Expensive | So Expensive
    • Why Sandalwood Is So E...
    ------------------------------------------------------
    #Spices #SoExpensive #BusinessInsider
    Business Insider tells you all you need to know about business, finance, tech, retail, and more.
    Visit us at: www.businessinsider.com
    Subscribe: / businessinsider
    BI on Facebook: read.bi/2xOcEcj
    BI on Instagram: read.bi/2Q2D29T
    BI on Twitter: read.bi/2xCnzGF
    BI on Snapchat: / 5319643143
    Boot Camp on Snapchat: / 3383377771
    Why 5 Of The World's Priciest Salts And Spices Are So Expensive | So Expensive Food

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1,8 тис.

  • @ejaaz7260
    @ejaaz7260 2 роки тому +2854

    Bamboo salt seems like a scam tbh.

    • @CuteSealYHM
      @CuteSealYHM 2 роки тому +92

      Ikr

    • @cardboard2night
      @cardboard2night 2 роки тому +559

      It was really sus when he said that heat removes microplastic 🙄🧐

    • @rob-8928
      @rob-8928 2 роки тому +403

      @@cardboard2night especially since they have been doing it well before microplastics lmfao

    • @portlandjosh
      @portlandjosh 2 роки тому +109

      @@rob-8928 The furnace during roasting number nine is at 900 degrees Centigrade. I know of no microplastic that could withstand that temperature!

    • @morgueinduarte1977
      @morgueinduarte1977 2 роки тому +80

      It actually taste closer to msg, waaayy different then pink salt

  • @0815firstuser0815
    @0815firstuser0815 2 роки тому +791

    0:00 Intro
    0:20 Bamboo salt
    6:24 Ceylon cinnamon
    13:09 Cardamom
    19:52 Cloves
    28:27 River reed salt

  •  Рік тому +617

    What amazes me and annoys me the most is that for this being some of the "most expensive" items in the world, workers almost always seem to be paid 8 dls a month...

    • @vnrbhat
      @vnrbhat Рік тому +71

      Because of middlemen.

    • @morho9422
      @morho9422 Рік тому +81

      capitalism supports the existence of the middle men and their liberty no matter how much it's abused.
      anyway, these people need to be kept poor. that makes the others rich.

    • @mastod0n1
      @mastod0n1 Рік тому +31

      Capitalism!

    • @RadenWA
      @RadenWA Рік тому

      Eventually more and more people from these countries won’t want to do these jobs anymore, and instead move to the capitalist first world countries. Then it would be their issue to give them proper salary while the commodity becomes even more expensive or just unavailable because nobody wanna do the work anymore. And then who would they blame? Not the capitalist overlords, that’s for sure.

    • @m74796
      @m74796 Рік тому +9

      @@morho9422 so socialism is good ???😆😆 😆

  • @Mr.Nobody_007
    @Mr.Nobody_007 Рік тому +682

    I have a exporting company specialised in spices from Kerala, the amount of time, care and dedication the farmers putting into their plants are commendable,but often they may not get fruits of their labour, mostly middle men exploits them.
    We try to work with the farmers directly but often they may not have capacity to store and process. Where as middle men buys the spices at low cost they store them for long time sell it higher price, even some time they create artificial shortage and increase the price.

    • @badxradxandy
      @badxradxandy Рік тому +34

      Sounds like you're a middleman

    • @Mr.Nobody_007
      @Mr.Nobody_007 Рік тому +57

      @@badxradxandy there is atleast 2-3 people in between me and the farmers, and they have the huge influence in setting price and demand.

    • @ioannadearc7901
      @ioannadearc7901 Рік тому +2

      Heart breaking.

    • @baddyforall2568
      @baddyforall2568 Рік тому +3

      Really sad sir. Government need to build proper warehouses. What are they doing?. Am from Tamilnadu. Just asking

    • @nikmat
      @nikmat Рік тому +6

      I won a cardamom estate in Puliyanmala, I can sell you directly, interested?

  • @Blitzkrieg1976
    @Blitzkrieg1976 2 роки тому +846

    I give so much respect to these hard workers..people, including myself, take certain spices for granted. This is definitely eye opening. I will keep this in mind the next time I cook. Without these wonderful people involved, I would never know the incredible spices produced.

    • @kirkcousins3789
      @kirkcousins3789 2 роки тому +16

      i looked super hard online, but i cant find the person who asked

    • @granitwinchester3037
      @granitwinchester3037 2 роки тому +18

      I dare to say, that this is the message we should get from these videos. In todays world we tend to forget (often forced because of economical circumstances) that time is a very important ingredient and the reason why some things are more expensive (and should be)

    • @heatherjohnson-raeburn4078
      @heatherjohnson-raeburn4078 Рік тому +5

      we take things for granted. look how hard it is to produce these spices and salts

    • @keepthefaith9805
      @keepthefaith9805 Рік тому +1

      Very good 😊

    • @masudalemzadeh5998
      @masudalemzadeh5998 Рік тому +1

      @@granitwinchester3037 -

  • @just2bears606
    @just2bears606 2 роки тому +420

    “First of all, being a salt, bamboo salt has salty flavor.” Does that mean I should worry about sweet salt?

    • @maskaw2905
      @maskaw2905 2 роки тому +20

      No, but salt that isn't sodium chloride has a weird taste or smell.

    • @maskaw2905
      @maskaw2905 2 роки тому +2

      Ammonium chloride has a strong smell

    • @maskaw2905
      @maskaw2905 2 роки тому +14

      to be more precise salt crystal other than sodium chloride is difficult to describe the taste without sodium chloride. The best example is MSG. If you taste MSG itself you cant really tell the taste but mixed with normal salt it makes the salt less tangy and more complex taste. So you don't need to worry about getting salt that is sweet. they need to make it salty to show the differences between salt products.

    • @estelleandjason
      @estelleandjason Рік тому +3

      Well I would not tell you to worry, but do be aware that salts from different sources do taste different! I did not realize this until I experienced the world of salt from various sources! It is very interesting!

    • @just2bears606
      @just2bears606 Рік тому +1

      @@estelleandjason I’m interested; how do they taste different? Is it just a higher level of saltiness, or is there truly different tastes, like the difference between a red and green apple?

  • @milkman2962
    @milkman2962 Рік тому +439

    The man peeling the bark has all my respect, I can't imagine the amount of splinters he has gotten his whole life.

    • @ToeCutter454
      @ToeCutter454 Рік тому +50

      you don't generally get splinters from fresh green wood, the fibers need to be dry and stiff.

    • @gayatria2272
      @gayatria2272 Рік тому

      not wrong

    • @In3rt_ia
      @In3rt_ia Рік тому +27

      Soft fibres. No splinters. Still hard work

    • @wolfmantroy6601
      @wolfmantroy6601 Рік тому +7

      Those hands are calloused to be like gloves.

    • @Thinminteater
      @Thinminteater Рік тому +14

      Imagine how good that job must smell tho

  • @grovermartin6874
    @grovermartin6874 Рік тому +62

    This has become one of my favourite channels. Wide ranging, well explained, organically laid out. Good job!

  • @RayMak
    @RayMak 2 роки тому +348

    Real cinnamon is really fragrant and delicious

  • @moshfiq
    @moshfiq 8 місяців тому +16

    I had lots of suspicions about the benefits of Bamboo salts the salt producers were claiming. And at the end of that part those questions were raised by the host and answered. I admire the honesty in making this documentary.

    • @marioxerxescastelancastro8019
      @marioxerxescastelancastro8019 7 місяців тому +1

      It was not honest. They say the benefits are yet to be fully uncovered. In truth, it was studied and they found there are no health benefits. It is just dirty salt.

    • @ZRWSCOLORSORTER
      @ZRWSCOLORSORTER 8 днів тому

      me too

  • @madnessintomagic
    @madnessintomagic Рік тому +46

    Franklin Roosevelt? I need to know the story behind his name. Has to be super interesting. I love this series and can’t wait to try so many of the things I’ve seen.

    • @SacredDaturana
      @SacredDaturana Рік тому +4

      The other guy interviewed for that segment was labeled Charles Simpson... I think these must be pseudonyms.

    • @dwaipayandebnath4232
      @dwaipayandebnath4232 Рік тому +8

      @@SacredDaturana It's south india, many people follow Catholicism, and it's quite common to find quirky names like that.

    • @SacredDaturana
      @SacredDaturana Рік тому +2

      @@dwaipayandebnath4232 Interesting! Would these Catholics usually adopt Anglo-style names? I got the impression that their names would be more Portuguese or Hispanic.

    • @dwaipayandebnath4232
      @dwaipayandebnath4232 Рік тому +4

      @@SacredDaturana The more southwards you go it's more Anglo-names. Also in the north east its Anglo-names (but its post independence spread of Catholicism). But close to bombay or goa you will find Portuguese names/or last names such as Silva (quite common across those regions)

    • @SacredDaturana
      @SacredDaturana Рік тому

      @@dwaipayandebnath4232 That makes sense, thanks for the elaboration! :)

  • @ryangmackeen
    @ryangmackeen 2 роки тому +73

    I wish the cinnamon workers got more of the payment since they do all the work...

    • @tcideh4929
      @tcideh4929 День тому

      They really don’t do all the work.
      Work in any agricultural industry and you’ll learn the vast majority of the work is post harvest. Up to 90% depending on the crop.
      Shipping, storing, shipping, grading, shipping, processing, shipping, selling.

  • @Nobe_Oddy
    @Nobe_Oddy Рік тому +109

    SUCH GOOD CONTENT!!! I REALLY like this series, A LOT!! The fact that it's expensive has that appeal that gets your attention, but then to show the people at the very beginning of the chain, and feature their hardships and work ethics makes me want to keep watching... there are SO MANY STEPS on most of the products we consume that we would NEVER guess they occur... this series shows us the TRUTH!
    THANK YOU!

  • @dhawthorne1634
    @dhawthorne1634 Рік тому +65

    One of the keys to the taste of that reed salt is it is lower in sodium than other salt sources. Filling a pot with plant ashes and water then straining and evaporated is how we get potash which is the earliest method of concentrating potassium salts.
    There is a product available at most grocery stores called NoSalt marketed towards people with high blood pressure. In truth, it is potassium chloride rather than sodium chloride. It is still salt, it just doesn't affect blood pressure because sodium and potassium can both fully saturate a water solution without affecting the solubility of the other. It can, however, cause a heart attacks and kidney failure in high quantities.

    • @conorhughes6018
      @conorhughes6018 Рік тому +6

      I was wondering about this. Your answer is insightful.

    • @KainYusanagi
      @KainYusanagi Рік тому +3

      Potassium chloride also tastes like ass, unfortunately, so most definitely is not a proper replacement of sodium chloride.

    • @angrycannibal6625
      @angrycannibal6625 Рік тому +1

      Good information

  • @saveworld1129
    @saveworld1129 Рік тому +66

    My respect to the Clove harvesters who risk their life still the spice is the cheapest among others. I will buy some cloves to support them

  • @YouAdii
    @YouAdii Рік тому +13

    This episode is making me crave a masala chai with the perfect blend of cinnamon, cardamom, and cloves. Hmm I wonder if I could add dash of salt on top? Respect to all the workers!

  • @conscious3714
    @conscious3714 Рік тому +15

    The hard work involved in producing these wonderful spices is highly commendable..

  • @onlysilv
    @onlysilv 2 роки тому +10

    Stay blessed; never stressed!

  • @eeemuse
    @eeemuse 2 роки тому +259

    What about Saffron? Real Saffron can cost you over $10,000 per/kg yet it's not even mentioned in the video!

    • @washaa
      @washaa 2 роки тому +31

      They uploaded a video last year focused on Saffron. Strange that it wasn't mentioned here

    • @eeemuse
      @eeemuse 2 роки тому +53

      @@washaa Even Vanilla beans are more expensive than what have been mentioned in this video.

    • @GeoPePeTto
      @GeoPePeTto 2 роки тому +114

      They had an Indian guy named Franklin Roosevelt. What more do you want? That’s priceless in itself.

    • @washaa
      @washaa 2 роки тому +17

      @@GeoPePeTto Extremely good point

    • @shivam_nagar69
      @shivam_nagar69 Рік тому +3

      @@GeoPePeTto 😂

  • @farooqkhan1149
    @farooqkhan1149 Рік тому +7

    My deep respect for all the workers who gave us wonderful spices without this imagine our food thank you very much.

  • @rizdalegend
    @rizdalegend 2 роки тому +126

    I'm going to start selling 10 times roasted salt

    • @13JimmA
      @13JimmA 2 роки тому +4

      My thoughts exactly

    • @fredsting9515
      @fredsting9515 2 роки тому +2

      Who's going to buy it?

    • @Lousy_Bastard
      @Lousy_Bastard 2 роки тому +15

      I'm sure there will be plenty of stupid people that will pay for it.

    • @MuscarV2
      @MuscarV2 2 роки тому +4

      The amount of times it's been "roasted" isn't a selling point though... It won't be better because it's roasted more times, it's done the right amount of times for the flavor they are looking for.
      How did you fail to understand any of that? The idiocy is immense.

    • @13JimmA
      @13JimmA 2 роки тому +19

      @@MuscarV2 clearly you don’t understand that it’s a joke lol

  • @Eva_Weesing
    @Eva_Weesing Рік тому +15

    I love how these people are so happy and passionate about what they do

    • @morho9422
      @morho9422 Рік тому +2

      look at what kind of environment they work in.

  • @Svartalf14
    @Svartalf14 Рік тому +5

    Thanks so much for the cloves segment. I've never seen cloves with their top bud still on, and I had no idea that quality even existed, not that such cloves are within my ability to get... maybe chefs at top notch restaurants can.. so learning about this was very interesting.

  • @ialrakis5173
    @ialrakis5173 Рік тому +16

    I like cardamom in a gin/tonic, soup and curries but man, I had no idea it was so labour intensive to get good pods.

    • @aditisk99
      @aditisk99 Рік тому +2

      Tastes god in tea too.

  • @SD-xh6ui
    @SD-xh6ui 2 роки тому +154

    That bamboo salt in India is similar to what we call as 'Kala Namak' or Black salt due to its outer coloring. It's expensive though but not as overpriced as that one.

    • @shreyasdeore8870
      @shreyasdeore8870 2 роки тому +1

      Dono alag hai! 🙂😂

    • @SD-xh6ui
      @SD-xh6ui 2 роки тому +14

      @@shreyasdeore8870 Process is almost similar. It's just that Black salt is prepared in a big pressurized pot.

    • @lakshmish666
      @lakshmish666 2 роки тому +12

      Also the taste is similar i guess...Black salt too has the egg yolk flavor

    • @asmityadav4216
      @asmityadav4216 Рік тому +4

      Kala Namak is a type of rock salt. That's why it's a bit expensive than sea salt. But black salt isn't only claimed to be healthy, it's recommended by physicians too.

    • @TWEAKLET
      @TWEAKLET Рік тому +2

      @@asmityadav4216 recommended why its still salt isn't it why would a doctor tell you to eat more salt?

  • @averageenjoyer9315
    @averageenjoyer9315 2 роки тому +9

    24:37, Lord have mercy

    • @caraday7768
      @caraday7768 3 місяці тому +1

      I scrolled very far to find you brother😂

  • @-2high2fly-
    @-2high2fly- 7 місяців тому +2

    I chuckled when I saw/heard Charles Simpson but when I saw/heard Franklin Roosevelt I was dead and buried 💀💀💀

  • @tweeterpie1
    @tweeterpie1 Рік тому +6

    Very interesting…I learned a lot of things that I’d never even heard of before, like the bamboo & reed salt.

  • @noramartin96
    @noramartin96 Рік тому +18

    These people are so unappreciated Now I realise how my Swedish grandmother valued her Cardamon pods so much to flavour her Easter buns. After 70 years I still have these pods ,they smell so sweet. Maybe I will try to grow them?

    • @ninjadog5800
      @ninjadog5800 Рік тому

      In Sweden? The thing about a lot of these spices is that they need tropical weather, that's what made India so rich for so long and why Europeans wanted it so badly

    • @noramartin96
      @noramartin96 Рік тому

      @@ninjadog5800 'In Sweden? Yes that's right

    • @red2theelectricboogaloo961
      @red2theelectricboogaloo961 Рік тому

      @@ninjadog5800 you could use a cold box or something. not gonna lie, growing my own spices is something i'm gonna try. this is me coming out of canada. growing your own stuff in general helps the bottom line, anyhow. but it'd be real nice to grow my own spices and herbs right in my backyard. i suppose it's not hard if you grow it in the summer or have a pot. then you just give it enough water and full sun and you should be away. same thing works with ginger, i heard.
      EDIT: i slipped up. it's a cold frame.
      EDIT 2: no, but really, i think growing smaller tropical plants wouldn't be a problem. larger ones need greenhouses which can get expensive. and they have to be well insulated. in any case, what makes most tropical plants tropical is that they can't tolerate frost, so i'd reckon it's a game of taking it inside when you need to.

    • @ninjadog5800
      @ninjadog5800 Рік тому

      @@red2theelectricboogaloo961 ohhh that makes sense

  • @krishna_2019
    @krishna_2019 Рік тому +119

    I hadn't realized how labour intensive the harvesting & production of Cardamom, Clove & Ceylon Cinnamon are. As for the salts, I hadn't heard about them before. It's a shame how much of a negative impact Climate Change has on these spices, especially because the regions that are affected most are the ones that contribute the least to Climate Change.

    • @_argurios8253
      @_argurios8253 Рік тому +5

      yeeeeah like... India? the least? come on

    • @krishna_2019
      @krishna_2019 Рік тому

      @@_argurios8253 "... the regions that ...", not country -- reading comprehension.

    • @realised_it_late
      @realised_it_late Рік тому +2

      @@_argurios8253considering the population yes

    • @lachlank.8270
      @lachlank.8270 Рік тому

      Australia and USA currently both getting extreme flooding, fires, and storms multiple times a year. Maybe 5 floods this year in Aus. Idk about China. We sell them all our coal though 🤣

    • @quemclouven4935
      @quemclouven4935 Рік тому +1

      @@lachlank.8270 That happens every year in the US though... we just have smartphones and social media now.

  • @tiredmummy7512
    @tiredmummy7512 2 роки тому +13

    I'm British. I only buy ceylon cinnamon not cassia... it a lot better. So pleased we label it correctly...

  • @bethanyephraim2761
    @bethanyephraim2761 Рік тому +25

    While we enjoy all these spices and salt in our foods and for other reasons, it's been very touching to note the difficult and risky jobs these poor people are doing to bring those wonderful products to us. May they be blessed for all their skills and hard work.🙏

  • @Reincarnation111
    @Reincarnation111 Рік тому +74

    My God.... I have used cinnamon, cardamom and cloves my whole life but had no idea how hard some people work so we can sit in our homes and enjoy their delectable taste. I have so much respect for these workers. This sure is an eye opener, educative and sobering. I feel immense gratitude for Mother Nature and for these people who toil so hard. Our earth is truly a magical place and we are failing to serve it. I am overwhelmed and in tears. I believe that nature worship is the right thing, which ancient civilizations understood. We are at Her mercy . 🙏🙏❗❗

    • @privatemale27
      @privatemale27 Рік тому +5

      I never realized that I have never purchased real cinnamon before...

    • @dinozaurpickupline4221
      @dinozaurpickupline4221 Рік тому +1

      I like your cat dear reincarnation

    • @Reincarnation111
      @Reincarnation111 Рік тому +1

      @@privatemale27 True and strange, and if we didn't see this clip we would never know.

    • @homo192
      @homo192 Рік тому +7

      Our whole lifestyle in so called western countries is based on the hard work of other people who don't get much for it. It started long ago with colonialism and never stopped.

    • @5DNRG
      @5DNRG Рік тому

      Love your beautiful viewpoint and comment...a breath of fresh air.💚

  • @mr.debiatagung5804
    @mr.debiatagung5804 Рік тому +38

    We have lots of cardamom farmers in my village which just started recently after they heard about it's profit but the thing is after 1 or 2 harvest they give up cardamom plantation because the ground workers (farmers) doesn't get the profit they expected which took so long and so much care that the profit just wasn't worth it. Also finding the right buyer is difficult to find as everyone wants to buy large quantities for the lowest price... For the top level workers (companies) it is very profitable.

    • @GeenaShaji
      @GeenaShaji Рік тому +4

      We have 11 acres of cardamom field and its price is very low after the covid issues .... we couldnt even get any profit from these cardamom.

  • @writingtotortureyou
    @writingtotortureyou Рік тому

    My cat is sick and this episode really helped me relax with them. Thankfully the vet was able to see us and she’s doing a lot better. This is for my new stress watch.

  • @moomoopuppy508
    @moomoopuppy508 2 роки тому +25

    I'd like to try the Kenyan river reed salt

    • @radarpinki
      @radarpinki 2 роки тому +4

      @Start Here agreed, chocolate is horrible

    • @Aveance94
      @Aveance94 Рік тому

      @@radarpinki You're right it's disgusting.

  • @rodica69
    @rodica69 Рік тому +6

    Wow, look at the size of those cardamom pods! They are so small and expensive in Europe! Also, opened pods are very frequent.

  • @jessitaran763
    @jessitaran763 Рік тому +85

    I used to work for a Greek olive oil company. It seems to me that the inherent value of cloves and the inherent value of olives stems from the same source - the oil. If clove farmers were to extract the oil from clove trees using the same extraction process used in olive oil production, it would substantially increase yields, as the fragrant oil that gives cloves value could be extracted from every part of the plant, instead of just the flower buds. It would also increase safety for workers as harvesting could be accomplished in a less precise fashion, without any reduction in the value of the product.

    • @Steelrat1994
      @Steelrat1994 Рік тому +25

      If you watch some of those 'why does this thing cost so much' you will see that the answer is always the same:
      - abysmally inefficient manual labor.
      - people that are willing or have no choice but to work for such low wages that any innovation and improvent is not worth it.
      - elevating the soulbreaking waste of their time and labor to a rank of art and tradition in spite of common sense.

    • @Visbalalam
      @Visbalalam Рік тому +11

      Cloves are used as is in Indian cooking for the taste. Not sure if adding in clove oil would achieve the same effect.

    • @MartinDevelopment
      @MartinDevelopment Рік тому +1

      I wonder about burning bamboo and pine to burn the same sea salt 9 times, what is the difference with say twice? Or # times

    • @RW-rt5nd
      @RW-rt5nd Рік тому +1

      Is this really feasible though? Clove oil is an essential oil rather than a vegetable/seed oil. They are not chemically very similar. Vegetable oils are composed mostly of flammable--but not extremely volatile--fatty acids with a mild odor whereas essential oils are composed of much more volatile, very fragrant, terpene chemicals. Essential oil extraction may be a more delicate process. Could the olive oil extraction process translate easily to cloves? I'm curious to know.

    • @sunithshyamlal
      @sunithshyamlal Рік тому

      am not sure whether whole cloves being used in Indian cooking and clove oil will have the same flavour profiles. whole spices add a very different dimension compared to powdered or oil versions. Most of our dishes, whether biryanis, curries or teas use mostly whole spices.

  • @rubyroseplantpalace1053
    @rubyroseplantpalace1053 Рік тому +1

    I am amazed. What treasures we have in these workers and products!

  • @michellemartin2330
    @michellemartin2330 Рік тому

    The best docu series. Very inspiring! ❤

  • @psychedelicmonkey55
    @psychedelicmonkey55 2 роки тому +159

    Imagine being dense enough to think bamboo salt was purifying anything

    • @planescaped
      @planescaped Рік тому +3

      It's a real grift alright.

    • @samuelrobson9933
      @samuelrobson9933 Рік тому +3

      ultimately it probably tastes pretty banging, ive tried a similar product. Kala Namak aka black salt

    • @TWEAKLET
      @TWEAKLET Рік тому +6

      its pseudo-science basically Chinese medicine stuff now I'm not saying bamboo that's been obliterated alongside some molten salt might not have some very minor health effects, but the trace minerals left over are near nothing worth noting and its definitely not going to make any real health difference or purify it but people like the taste and love the idea that it might be healthier than plain salt somehow

    • @Volodimar
      @Volodimar Рік тому +4

      Removing impurities by adding impurities.

    • @KainYusanagi
      @KainYusanagi Рік тому

      @@TWEAKLET Same with himalayan pink salt, which is really just iron impurities in salt.

  • @monah5532
    @monah5532 Рік тому +67

    Thank you for this video. I will never buy more than I need so I never waste any of the spices. I did not realize just how much work goes into production. I would be willing to pay more if I knew the workers and farmers would get more into their pockets and practices are sustainable. It only seems fair.

    • @shreythakur9079
      @shreythakur9079 Рік тому +2

      Lol the demand dictates supply but also profit … if the demand falls people lose their jobs

    • @monah5532
      @monah5532 Рік тому +7

      @@shreythakur9079 I was thinking of somewhere between "exploitation" and "so expensive no one will buy". If people can afford $6 for a cup of coffee, or even $3, they can pay a little more for work that is so labor intensive and that makes such a difference in the local farmers' lives.

    • @mmaxx6786
      @mmaxx6786 Рік тому

      Typical woke misdirected thinking.
      ...I respect their "fweelings" so much I will cut back on buying their products so they can keep more of it.
      Ever think they might want you to buy MORE so they can friggin survive?

  • @esther804
    @esther804 Рік тому

    These ppl work so hard. My respect for these hard working people. May God bless them ❤

  • @blacktara3936
    @blacktara3936 Рік тому +5

    Grateful to all of them for their hard work & glad these spices are available worldwide. As for the bamboo salt for medicinal purposes, why not take bamboo manna instead?

  • @CheddarCheeseBandit
    @CheddarCheeseBandit 2 роки тому +137

    I am a little suspect to his “science” on filtering out microplastics. If you heat them in a sealed kiln how are they filtered out? They can only be heated and consolidated with existing salt in the bamboo tube.

    • @alexiachimciuc3199
      @alexiachimciuc3199 2 роки тому +10

      Like Freddie Mercury used to sing; it's a kind of magic.. MAGIC !!

    • @radarpinki
      @radarpinki 2 роки тому +69

      Cause it's 150% bullshit lol

    • @faithnfire4769
      @faithnfire4769 Рік тому +50

      It's also completely irrelevant, because you are almost definitely going to put that salt on something that would bioaccumulate microplastics as well, likely in far greater levels?
      Frankly just buy rocksalt if you want salt without any plastic, or any salt that's decently reputable? Crystallization removes most all impurities...
      Anyway the whole thing is clearly pointless, there's no 'oil' in bamboo that wouldn't have vaporized if plastic is doing the same. "Good ingredients" my arse, the closest thing that could remain after that is a bit of ash. Might as well have thrown in a pack of mineral gummies, they probably would have contributed more.

    • @MrMiguelForster
      @MrMiguelForster Рік тому

      @@radarpinki Half the shit the culinary world says is grade a BS

    • @planescaped
      @planescaped Рік тому +23

      Yeah... the bamboo salt really came off as buying a "fashionable" salt and not anything truly special in any chemical or scientific way.
      Just like pink seasalt, it's just salt of a different shade and nothing about it is special beyond the color/process...

  • @rotax636nut5
    @rotax636nut5 Рік тому +33

    Makes me wonder how the 'bamboo salt' process was discovered, seems to me there must have been an awful lot of trial and error involved..

    • @wolfmantroy6601
      @wolfmantroy6601 Рік тому +10

      My guess.... they cooked their fish and rice in bamboo and added sea salt. They liked the way the sea salt tasted when cooked in the bamboo.

    • @mmaxx6786
      @mmaxx6786 Рік тому

      What about the river salt? LMAO
      Some kid stuck a stick in his campfire and licked it. Figured out ashes are basically Potassium Chloride and had a salty taste. Compare this to the Soy Sauce tradition and it's apparent why one society lives in mud huts

  • @jessicamasterson4394
    @jessicamasterson4394 9 місяців тому

    What a fantastic informative video. Beautifully filmed and engaging. Also your voice is so very pleasant to listen to and that is a big plus! Thank you

  • @wrenlittle8826
    @wrenlittle8826 Рік тому

    Amazing. Thank you for this.

  • @xandeexandee6513
    @xandeexandee6513 2 роки тому +15

    salt is salt

  • @whiskeykilmer1866
    @whiskeykilmer1866 Рік тому +12

    So regular table salt and a one-a-day multi-vitamin will be as good health-wise as bamboo salt.

    • @Despotic_Waffle
      @Despotic_Waffle Рік тому +3

      Not as good, actually better. Because all the studies show there's not much additional minerals added with bamboo salt anyway.

  • @GoodSongs4all
    @GoodSongs4all Рік тому

    Good information!
    Thank you! 👍

  • @gracecoburn9633
    @gracecoburn9633 6 місяців тому

    Thanks for documenting these amazing traditions

  • @yalungpura7437
    @yalungpura7437 Рік тому +5

    A small community in north east India also make something like river reef salt difference is that the Indian people collect weeds and other plants but the process is exactly the same

  • @mikec5400
    @mikec5400 2 роки тому +176

    they keep on emphasising "the salt absorbs the GOOD INDREDIANTS of the bamboo" lol this salt is just marketing bs

    • @qnpfr4954
      @qnpfr4954 2 роки тому +25

      As a Korean, I didn't know what bamboo salt was until I saw this video lol

    • @CheddarCheeseBandit
      @CheddarCheeseBandit 2 роки тому

      Bamboo salt cured my cancer and cured my blindness. You should honestly come to your own conclusion. Buy a small amount from a TRUSTED source. See if you like it. The first part of my comment was just an everyday joke my friend.

    • @kar_animates1092
      @kar_animates1092 Рік тому +10

      Not to be annoying but it just frustrates me that there’s no G in ingredients

    • @denserdeezsignz5498
      @denserdeezsignz5498 Рік тому

      @@kar_animates1092 I put my D in everyding.

    • @dantethunderstone2118
      @dantethunderstone2118 Рік тому +2

      They say that there’s nothing proven because it’s all scams, it’s just traditional mode of preparation that’s done to make money

  • @JustSearchNate
    @JustSearchNate Рік тому

    The level of respect you get for everyone in this video is incredible .

  • @wanebaaijurgen6699
    @wanebaaijurgen6699 Рік тому +1

    Learnt a lot. New respect for these spices.

  • @xadrach
    @xadrach 2 роки тому +13

    The bamboo salt is so stupid

  • @toddburgess5056
    @toddburgess5056 2 роки тому +8

    Clove oil is good to treat tooth aches.

    • @jethrot100
      @jethrot100 2 роки тому

      And mold / mildew. It is the most expensive oil I buy.

  • @aminaurten.6493
    @aminaurten.6493 5 місяців тому

    Thank you for this video.

  • @starcrib
    @starcrib Рік тому +1

    Fantastic Cultural Heritages- Bamboo Salt /Cinnamon Tree Bark / Green Cardamom / The Forests of South India for rare Clove / All these specifically acquired artisan food traditions and traditional skills. ! HUMANITY IS MARVELOUS .! 🌿🌏🌍🌎🌿

  • @sreelakshmib1223
    @sreelakshmib1223 2 роки тому +24

    Hats off to the clove harvesters

    • @nirmahl
      @nirmahl 2 роки тому

      Malayali 🤗

    • @dhruvakhera5011
      @dhruvakhera5011 2 роки тому +4

      @@nirmahl ചോദിച്ചില്ല 🗿

  • @IRosamelia
    @IRosamelia Рік тому +3

    Bamboo salt looks like the sort of stuff that might give you stomach cancer 🤔

  • @nurliyananajwabintiazlee1829
    @nurliyananajwabintiazlee1829 2 роки тому +100

    It annoys me to no end that highest quality products harvested in their country will be shipped out to the richer country while the locals settled with less than quality ingredients, similar to our country, the better quality raw materials were shipped out and we end up with some 2nd grade products :/

    • @un4893
      @un4893 Рік тому +16

      I agree but they ship that stuff out for a reason, they get more money. Ultimately expanding their well-being.

    • @JunkyardCactus
      @JunkyardCactus Рік тому +23

      So the concept of trade annoys you?
      Ignoring the ridiculous claim that “all” of it gets shipped abroad, would you rather the country stop exporting and importing goods? Items of luxury aside, that would mean no import of crucial goods, oil and medicine.
      People nowadays are sure quick to blame trade for all the perceived wrongs it causes while reaping and ignoring its rewards.

    • @jonathanasdell9310
      @jonathanasdell9310 Рік тому +8

      Means of refinement into product is super expensive to build and maintain. And unless all sources of a raw material stood up together and said "no, we want you to pay us more" and could outlast the stalemate, the lowest bidder is going to set the bar.

    • @biohazardlnfS
      @biohazardlnfS Рік тому +9

      Well, the richer countries have the money to pay for your over inflated quality products while your own countries don't have the market for it. If your people can't pay let's say 20 dollars for a kg of "real cinnamon" then no one will make it and your in a worse position. You can buy your own high quality products made in your countries. It's just your too poor to do so. In addition, if you get made the richer countries dont have to buy your ingredients but then now you've lost a market to make money

    • @anonymouslyopinionated656
      @anonymouslyopinionated656 Рік тому +1

      meh.

  • @Research0digo
    @Research0digo Рік тому

    Since this was filmed, how many Chinese companies have sprung up, up river from this nice person's operation?
    I have always admired Carlo's Slow Food movement, this was a spectacular video, thank you.

  • @wallacesouza2678
    @wallacesouza2678 Рік тому +15

    I'VE BEEN SEEING POST EVERYWHERE ABOUT FOREX TRADING AND CRYPTO CURRENCY, A LOT OF PEOPLE KEEP SAYING THINGS ABOUT THIS TRADING PLATFORMS PLEASE CAN SOMEONE LINK ME TO SOMEBODY WHO CAN PUT ME THROUGH..?

    • @montserratherrero782
      @montserratherrero782 Рік тому

      Mrs Olivera Jane okhumalo,God will
      continue to give you the strength to satisfy
      all your client.

    • @Simeonsaater
      @Simeonsaater Рік тому

      Wow l'm just shock someone mentioned
      expert Mrs Olivera Jane okhumalo, I thought
      I'm the only one trading with her, She helped
      me recover what i lost trying to trade my
      self.

    • @marinefernandez3166
      @marinefernandez3166 Рік тому

      who's this professional, everyone is talking
      about i always see her post on top comment
      on every UA-cam video I watched how can i
      reach her?

    • @carolineknudsen5306
      @carolineknudsen5306 Рік тому

      @@marinefernandez3166 Ohhh yeah I have her contact I have been trading with her also

    • @carolineknudsen5306
      @carolineknudsen5306 Рік тому

      @@marinefernandez3166 Give her a call, or sms direct

  • @brianloper6669
    @brianloper6669 Рік тому +9

    I like this series but especially for this one a little more descriptive narration would have been appreciated. I know it’s all about money but I’m also curious how cardomom pods smell being picked fresh. Like nothing at all? A different smell? Musky? Also, how much do these harvesters make…never mentioned.

  • @GamerDave1974
    @GamerDave1974 4 місяці тому

    I never knew how MUCH I should appreciate Clove

  • @andreaforde8399
    @andreaforde8399 Рік тому

    blessings to these people out there....🙏🙏🙏

  • @samuelmuldoon4839
    @samuelmuldoon4839 Рік тому +17

    It is possible to make black salt (bamboo salt) with a lot less work. It is essentially charcoal and salt mixed together. Simply roast the bamboo (with no salt) untill the bamboo turns black. Then grind the bamboo charcoal into dust. Mix charcoal, salt, and water together. Re-bake untill dry. Also, use grinding machines, not chefs knives and hammers. Eating small amounts of charcoal can have some health benefits. There is no need to bake it nine times or chop the salt by hand with hammers, or motor and pestle.

    • @user-mr4pm7jv5e
      @user-mr4pm7jv5e Рік тому +9

      She said “they bake it 9 times as it achieves the LOWEST level of toxicity and HIGHEST amount of minerals in the salt”…. THATS why they do it. By cheating out they would loose that. Sometimes there’s reasons behind why they do it.. pay attention

    • @SacredDaturana
      @SacredDaturana Рік тому +14

      @@user-mr4pm7jv5e Pay attention to what? They claim it but it's not clear why baking it nine times that way achieves what they say it achieves. It's just NaCl and activated carbon.

    • @user-lb8do4ew6k
      @user-lb8do4ew6k Рік тому +1

      The process also adds the trace akali & other minerals in the bamboo to the salt.

    • @nobodymcnobody215
      @nobodymcnobody215 Рік тому +10

      @@user-lb8do4ew6k By burning the bamboo to ash you aren’t removing the things in the bamboo, the minerals and alkali in the real bamboo salt will be at insignificant levels anyways

    • @goodlife6277
      @goodlife6277 Рік тому +2

      @@user-lb8do4ew6k and microplastics...

  • @alli6791
    @alli6791 Рік тому +4

    The woman at 21:05 just tossed the pods into a bag next to her, without looking first. Muscle memory is cool.

  • @tenshinty2231
    @tenshinty2231 Рік тому +2

    In our Village in North East India, we collected 10 kgs per head to pay for electricity bill. Each kg was sold for around rupees 20. That's roungly $.25 dollar. Idk what kind of cinamond it is. We have a natural forest where cinamond trees would grow 1 feet diameter or so everywhere. The leaves you see here were exactly the same but they tend to grow straight with small branches

  • @MoutonNoir105
    @MoutonNoir105 Рік тому +4

    I was surprised by the price of the Clove buds because in Mexico we can buy 1 kg bags (2.2 pounds) for 800 MXN which is about 40 USD.
    She said that less than half a pound can go for as much as 30 USD 🤯😳

  • @rowangreymantle
    @rowangreymantle Рік тому +5

    I absolutely love knowing about these wonderful salts, and spices. These people are artisans in their fields.

  • @m.ccheddarbox874
    @m.ccheddarbox874 Рік тому +4

    It's very clear with all these traditions the people that are in charge and highly sought after don't make enough money. They essentially have a masters degree in these areas and are probably paid an extremely small fraction. While they may be doing better then others in their areas, it's sad they aren't better off.

  • @kf_mq5303
    @kf_mq5303 Рік тому

    😲 omg.... need to treasure all species in our kitchen .. I have a high respect for these people

  • @BusinessIndex1
    @BusinessIndex1 Рік тому +5

    I loved the fragrance of real cardamom ❤

  • @fritzeph6550
    @fritzeph6550 2 роки тому +12

    Real cinnamon is very expensive why the workers are still poor😭.

    • @nazmulhasankhan3393
      @nazmulhasankhan3393 Рік тому

      Sarcasm statement right?

    • @red2theelectricboogaloo961
      @red2theelectricboogaloo961 Рік тому

      the processors want money, too. unfortunately, they're usually also the ones who have more leverage since it's up to them to evaluate the quality and find the market for whatever they're selling. so it's them who get to set the rules, and the farmer usually gets the short end of the stick.

  • @Yogi-vy7dk
    @Yogi-vy7dk 11 місяців тому

    i came to know today that the people behind them ared so hard working . i give huge respect to these workers .

  • @anonymouslyopinionated656
    @anonymouslyopinionated656 Рік тому +2

    28:08 For clarification, the person speaking does NOT say it's due to climate change Nor that the weather has changed off late.
    That's just Business Insider inserting it.
    All he says is that because the business is sensitive to the vagaries of weather, it's inherently risky.

  • @olive7831
    @olive7831 Рік тому +4

    green cardamom is my favourite flavour. you need the bright green ones - the old, dry tan colour ones are terrible

  • @fat_2396
    @fat_2396 Рік тому +5

    They aren’t joking because I own a produce company down in immokalee Florida and let me tell you for just 25lbs of cinnamon it cost me $550 keep in mind it’s just 25lbs

    • @Funnyclips-mp8xv
      @Funnyclips-mp8xv 11 місяців тому +1

      Ceylon cinnamon is very expensive in Singapore and Thailand

  • @sabihatanveer8494
    @sabihatanveer8494 Рік тому

    BI is a treasure trove of knowledge 💎

  • @rosaliabonayog0001
    @rosaliabonayog0001 Рік тому

    Thank you.God speed to our farmers.

  • @shampersaud2763
    @shampersaud2763 Рік тому +11

    Kudos to all the spices and salt harvesters. I can understand the prices being high.The spices are wonderful natures miracles of sweet aroma and flavours which boost health benefits too. When I had Covid, my wife boiled cloves, cinnamon, lemons, ginger, cardamom, turmeric, and drank with honey.This drink was a miraculous immune booster drink....Very good video content with facts and love ,patience from the people.....

  • @victoriaclarisse1779
    @victoriaclarisse1779 2 роки тому +32

    I really hope Penzey’s pays these people well because I buy most of all these. I do struggle with how to use cardamom to show its best potential. I won’t embarrass myself with sharing how I used it, but I am open to serious suggestions.

    • @aleenaprasannan2146
      @aleenaprasannan2146 2 роки тому +6

      Use the seeds inside....SPARINGLY... and discard the husk. Honestly biting into a whole cardamom feels like life hitting you like a wall of bricks

    • @didosauce6008
      @didosauce6008 2 роки тому +6

      Cardamom is very good in tea, simmer some black tea leaves in water, and add 1-4 cracked cardamom pods, you want to make sure the pods are cracked open to expose the seeds, then simmer for a bit and if you’d like, add equal parts milk to water to make a basic Indian chai

    • @unbounder
      @unbounder 2 роки тому +3

      Whatever you do, don't leave it in the food. It's great in teas and as a natural aromatic - especially great for incensing rices (throw them in through the boiling process), and certain soups and chutneys really benefit from cardamom being involved, so long as you find a step in the process to remove them from the final product. It's rather underrated imo, same as cloves - but that's because you can very easily mess up a dish with them.

    • @BARK910
      @BARK910 2 роки тому +1

      Ive bitten into so many pods in curry, it tastes unpleasant and it can damage teeth. Remove them from food if you are cooking with it, Remove any spices to avoid yourself and guests from biting into the spices.

    • @ShiroiTengu
      @ShiroiTengu 2 роки тому +2

      Make Turkish coffee

  • @striker44
    @striker44 Рік тому +2

    These are what attracted the western adventurers to colonists, from traders to establishment of military imperialism in South Asia. Today, these farmers are still exploited, which needs to change through fair trade policies.

  • @t19890204
    @t19890204 Рік тому +1

    even if its not proven to have a healthy effect, the placebo it gives people are priceless

  • @danielmilner6035
    @danielmilner6035 9 місяців тому +4

    It always fascinates me on how people discover new spices, especially things like the reed salt

  • @c00mgoblin
    @c00mgoblin Рік тому +8

    I thought Saffron was the most expensive spice…

  • @Constantinus213421
    @Constantinus213421 8 місяців тому

    Charles Simpson at 21:17, what a fitting name.
    "Dealers like Franklin Roosevelt" at 26:39.

  • @aravindh.aravindh.6488
    @aravindh.aravindh.6488 5 місяців тому

    Love you dedicate your work I am support my all 👌👍👏

  • @iulixMAXgames
    @iulixMAXgames Рік тому +23

    The sad part is people who work to make this kind of stuff they are not paid too much 😐

  • @mastod0n1
    @mastod0n1 Рік тому +4

    It's easy to forget that a lot of the products you buy pass through the hands of multiple people on the opposite side of the world (speaking as an American). And it's easy to take it for granted.

    • @Whisper0ak
      @Whisper0ak Рік тому

      Passes through their toes too!

  • @SC-md8wu
    @SC-md8wu Рік тому +1

    I appreciate the effort put into this video as well as commend the amount of effort put into the harvesting of these spices by these highly skilled workers! I hope they get to one day reap the benefits of their efforts.
    And ofc, climate change was a reoccurring theme throughout this video. :(

  • @syedabukhari2643
    @syedabukhari2643 Рік тому

    Very informative 👏 👌

  • @NoName-ll2mp
    @NoName-ll2mp Рік тому +4

    In germany we have homoöpathie, it´s basically the same as the salt thing but with sugar and we give it a fancy name "Globuli". It´s helps against everything. It´s hilarious! xD

    • @red2theelectricboogaloo961
      @red2theelectricboogaloo961 Рік тому

      oh, homeopathy. pretty sure that does nothing, no? it's just putting something into a vial and then diluting it 20 or 30 times. the theory went that water has a memory and that that was supposed to make whatever was in there stronger, but i'm pretty sure it's been tested and, yeah, it's basically just water at that point.

  • @ibnQAYIM
    @ibnQAYIM 2 роки тому +8

    when i catch this channel, everything seems expensive😂😂

  • @LoideNghidengwa
    @LoideNghidengwa 3 місяці тому

    Wow, I have respect for the people who produce these spices. Cloves are gaining popularity in Namibia because of its medicinal properties

  • @mrsnulch
    @mrsnulch Рік тому +1

    Surprised you didn't mention saffron, but this was super interesting!!

  • @qwertz12345654321
    @qwertz12345654321 Рік тому +5

    Bamboo salt sounds incredibly wasteful and pointless. The entire point of using sea salt instead of industrial salt is because of its impurities. impure salt tastes better to humans