Climate Change Will Make MILLIONS Homeless. Where Will They Go? | Hot Mess 🌎
Вставка
- Опубліковано 25 сер 2024
- PBS Member Stations rely on viewers like you. To support your local station, go to: to.pbs.org/Dona...
↓ More info and sources below ↓
Peril & Promise is a public media initiative from WNET telling human stories of climate change and its solutions. Learn more at: www.pbs.org/wne...
In 2017, storms, floods, and droughts displaced 18 million people from their homes worldwide. And by some estimates, over the next three decades, 200 million people may need to leave their homes to escape the same kind of disasters, made worse by climate change. Where in the world will all these people go?
Please SUBSCRIBE! ►► bit.ly/hotmess_sub
And support us on Patreon: / hotmesspbs
Twitter: / hotmesspbs
Instagram: / hotmesspbs
Facebook: / hotmesspbs
References: bit.ly/2AWAojj
-----------
Host/Writer: Talia Buford, ProPublica
Creative Director: David Schulte
Editors/Animators: Karl Boettcher
Producers: Stephanie Noone & Amanda Fox
Story Editor: Alex Reich
Editor-In-Chief: Joe Hanson, Ph.D.
-----------
Produced by PBS Digital Studios
Theme Music: Eric Friend/Optical Audio
Music: APM
Stock images from www.shutterstoc...
This is actually the very issue I am doing my Master research on.
@@lukecooper9174 No. I am looking at it from an International Relations angle, focusing on ways to defuse and prepare for the humanitarian crisis this video describes.
Hessan´s County: Check Giles Slade, 2013. American Exodus; Climate Change and the Coming Flight for Survival (Gabriola Island, BC, Canada, New Society Publishers, 272pp.) Available through Amazon online. Also, check my website www.ciclicoahuila.com to see what we are doing here in Mexico to cope with climate change-induced drought. :-)
Will you publish it when its done? Would love to read it
Utter fools who believe this junk science . The Earth has ALWAYS had extreme weather !!! and CO2 is at it's lowest it has ever been in the worlds history in the universe. It is a way to spread communism. Green on the outside , red in the middle . A way for the greens to extract huge amounts of money from the poor to transfer to the rich . It looks like a paradise there , economic migrants, and the grand replacement of the West , driven by China. People look into Tony Heller. Patrick Moore The founder of Green Peace . China burn mote coal that the rest of The WHOLE world put together . Where is the Green lobby over there. The decline of the West, The rise of the East . Use you Vote
I gotta say, I did not read that correctly the first time. 😬
Oh yes! New Hot Mess episode!
Aspect Science u should collaborate with life noggin or hot mess
Captain Jeffrey that would be an absolute dream! Maybe need a few more subscribers first though to play in the big leagues!!! :)
How do I not worry about my 13 & 11 year old nieces future - feeling so overwhelmed tbh.
From Scratch Aunty Bindy
We need more people worrying about this. Although it's certainly incredibly worrying what the future will be like for our descendants, this is exactly what will drive the people, government, and business to take this threat seriously and start addressing it with all the attention it warrants.
That overwhelmed feeling can be paralyzing, I know 😔
There is a lot to worry about little girls future, college, marriages and such, but climate is not amount them.
Despite what the socialist/communist have told you, the climate is not being controlled by co2.
More smoke and mirrors. I never equated science with communism, I said the communist were using the fake science to push their agenda.
You are right facts are facts and the fact in this case is that mmcc is a scam. They refuse to use standard scientific methods created by centuries of scientist and their predecessors to prevent scientific fraud and the only possible reason is they are pushing fraud.
In a world where migration and immigrants are demonized as criminal, impending climate crises will be exacerbated by untold amounts as we berate and scream at refugees drowning in seas that were raised by our own economic growth.
This is why we need the border wall. Mexico is one of the most violent places on Earth, we don't want to move it into the US.
A border wall most likely wouldn't stop a determined deer from crossing the border, and it certainly won't stop a determined human. Humans are a lot more capable and intelligent than deer, or so I used to believe. It's a waste of money, and you're a fool for thinking such a stupid symbolic thing that will never be built would solve your imagined problems. For that, you'll have to search your own broken soul.
A border wall would certainly make it more difficult for people to come here from Mexico. It should be guarded as well, we could have drones patrolling it 24/7.
I didn't say anything about it solving problems, I said it would PREVENT a problem. The violence in Mexico needs to stay in Mexico.
Frank Rosser
no, that wall will be to keep the cold air out of the US
Stop showing off...
Well it's 2 years later, and indeed, there's an effect. Areas around Phoenix are anticipated to be uninhabitable in the near future.
the last time i was this early, nobody had to be concerned about climate change yet
climate change is a real threat
Climate change is not lineair, it's exponential. The situation is way worse.
@peiters no. only the models that have failed say it s linear.
I know who will not want to take them. The people who had the biggest impact... 😒
China?
Robert: Current contamination China. Cumulative, USA. Ongoing China, USA, India, Russia, Brazil, EU, etc.
@@NihilioFit No, every single one of end users of products and services with the highest environmental footprint. In general likely to be people with bigger wallets.
In a utopian world, every single individual older than 18 would get "environmental footprint credit" which is 11% short of last years. Every product like milk would have a score of CO2 consumption, PM pollution, etc. Once someone sells a product - credits would be sent from the buyer to seller. Children under 18 would be included in parents budget. If one has too many credits he or she can decide either to sell them or hoard them. In case someone wants to earn more credits - it could be done by planting trees (credits would need to be deposited in the rate of tree growth). In case someone burns down a church than it would be mandatory for them to either buy credits from someone else or do mandatory work to earn credits.
Since it is a reality it would be difficult to get collective governance globally in order to make that happen and even if it would be implemented than someone could game the system.
@@ArthursHD "In case someone burns down a church than it would be mandatory for them to either buy credits from someone else or do mandatory work to earn credits."
What does this have to do with environmental impact? Should one also have to buy credits if one criticises this system of yours or votes for a political party that aims to abolish it? Are those kinds of political parties even legal? Amazing how dystopian some utopias can seem to be, once you analyze them.
Also: different people have different needs (mostly depending on where in the world they live) so the idea that everyone gets the same amount of credit regardless of their needs seems quite unfair. But if different people are given different amounts of credit, who gets to decide on that? A question that anyone attempting to construct a societal system must ask themselves: who holds the power in this system?
Fortunately, there is no people that caused the biggest impact. That was an asteroid millions of years ago.
extreme temperatures is not a sudden disaster. Scientists and researchers have been yelling about it for many years, but the developed, powerful and privileged humans fell into a dangerous trap if not the most dangerous; we were content and stopped worrying about changing or improving. Nothing would be done before it was too late, and that's the truth about climate change.
This channel deserves more subs
we were able to migrate out of africa millions of years ago so we can do it now, apart from the fact that millions of years ago the population wasn't numbered at 7 billion. We can do our best, but realistically it's not gonna be easy and that's why we need to sort out climate change
Mars or bust !
--_-- When your Social Studies teacher gives you this during quarantine --_--
If only America could be a part of the countries that are helping to stop climate change🙁
IF only people would realize the climate change is nothing but an attempt to create a one world government. THAT is the community that you want to create, one where someone in a distant continent can decide if you can build a home.
@@roberthicks1612 Climate is real either way
@@princeslewis Of course climate is real. It has existed as long as we had air.
Also, man has altered the climate, with buildings cities and roads, farming and more.
That does not mean we are controlling it or that co2 has caused any change.
This video seems way too light hearted for the subject matter. This is a huge problem that will likely cause wars. The fact that we mass migrated thousands of years ago says nothing about how it will go in the near future. Like fr, she just casually says that mass migration as a result of climate change "may even challenge our ideas of nationhood itself!". Take one look at history and what's going on right now in different places in the world, challenges to nationhood like that will cause HUGE problems besides the mass migration itself.
There's a huge difference, it seems to me, between the migration 200,000 years ago to one today. They left in search of a better place and found many of them. Today this climate catastrophe is worldwide and the number of people on the planet is orders of magnitude larger. If large numbers of people are moving somewhere somewhat better, that somewhere will soon be overwhelmed. Not a pretty prospect.
1:16 "borders, a recent invention"
Stop, I can only love this channel so much.
lol soyboy
To elaborate: While you morons are circle-jerking about the collapse of the civilized world, you're not even aware that you're ruining any chance of getting reasonable people to accept your solutions to global warming. If you focused on the actual problem (which is CO2 emissions), rather than your moronic "social justice" agenda, people might actually be willing to accept the changes which are necessary to eliminate CO2 emissions.
Borders are imaginary, people are real
JJRyzer soy products typically have less estrogen than cows products so "soyboys" refer to men who are more masculine
As arbitrary as borders might be to some people, they are crucially important to humanity and they've been around as long as mankind has, whether it was fighting over hunting ground to hunter-gatherers, or grazing and pasture land for early farmers. Borders are as old as humanity is.
1:21 that is Breezehome from Whiterun lmao
In Arizona we have to worry about extreme heat and drought. Our cities like Phoenix and Tucson have to be smart in curbing water consumption if we don't want to be ghost towns. It's not like we have an ocean we can just desalinate.
And even desalination has its problems. Namely, the sheer cost in money and resources. And energy.
1:21 breezehome
No one has legitimately caught all the pokémon, zeraora hasn't been released yet.
Aidan Or *back befor gen 7.
But it can't have taken *that* long to make this video.
"No Gringo" by Vienna Teng. The relevance is real.
1:20 I'm sorry, is that Breezehome in Whiterun?
i like ths channel
Great vid as usual!
2:51 "That's the number of Alaskan villages and cities at risk of flooding or falling into the ocean due to erosion of their coastlines." And then the map shown has about 11 cities that are not on the coast. If they're not on the coast, how can they have coastlines?
although they're far inland, their elevation is very low, akiak is only 4m high despite being very inland
rivers have shorelines...
Yes! New video.
1:20 is.... is that Breezehome in Whiterun?
I've been fortunate to have been born in America. And although a lot of people in these United States have been devestated by hurricanes and displacement I have not. I have been subjected to more and more for more tornadoes and powerful storms I still haven't been displaced by them. I can't possibly understand those who have. Yeah I know it's horrible and heartbreaking to see on the news . But you really have to be there to know what it's really like. These people are humans like me. From all walks of life. My heart feels sorrow for every one of them.💔😘
@janie Straub. The truth is, the intensity of tornados has decreased since the 1930's by about 1/3rd. There has been a slight increase in level 1 tornados but a larger decrease in 4 and 5's. There has been a slight decrease in 3 and a slight increase in 2's.
hurricanes and typhoons have a slight, albeit statistically insignificant decrease in intensity and number.
Wild fires are 10th what they had in 1930's. If California state government would get out of the way, it could be decreased even more.
Wait... so THAT'S the take-away from all this? Not "let's figure out how to slow/stop climate change" but "let's all get ready and excited to move"???
01:19 music from skyrim, nice :D not sure if it's the breezehome from whiterun though ^^
04:15 i wouldn't want to miss catching them :o
04:22 probably you're right ^^'
i appreciate your view on that we can pull it by working together :D thank you for your work
Is that a drawing of one of the houses in whiterun
Thanks! Please make an episode talking about the likelihood of nuclear war or a third world war due to climate change. I can't imagine the people will just starve quietly while we stuff our faces with steak.
Sea rise is a smaller issue than starvation. Crop failures will kill billions.
sea level is Falling in Alaska according to noaa tide gauges . 93% of pacific atoll islands are either stable or growing in size . real science
U guyz r awesome
There will be a time, when some of us would be dead and some still alive, old and regretting why we did nothing, we would have done something, or something more than we did, which for most of us is already nothing
Check the english subtitles for the _Director´s cut_ version of the original script! xD
Explore Minnesota, Land of 10,000 lakes, great standard of living in breezy point Grand rapids Duluth. St cloud. brainerd. We have plenty of trees and room
Minnesota nice 😊
Teaming up with ProPublica = awesome!
Wait, what?
I mean, what?
Are you trying to tell me that our ancient ancestors *didn't* squabble over territory? Really? The thing that basically *all* predators and many prey animals do? Uh-huh. Right.
in the US they move to Florida , Arizona , Texas because people like to live where its warm . fastest growing US city : phoenix , also americas hottest city .
Nz. We already have a bunch of silicone valley people here, once it catches on that this place is in a good spot im thinking a lot more peopke are gonna want to come here
With cities like Amsterdam and New Orleans being built and lived in below sea level, even after getting demolished by storms and hurricanes, humanity will either rebuild and move right back in, move away, or adapt it's cities to compensate. None of which are world-threatening options, as all of history has shown.
From nationhood to humanhood.
The pie charts at 3:53 make no sense to me... what is that supposed to be showing?
Came down to comment on the same thing. They aren't showing anything, they are totally meaningless charts. Either Hot Mess left off the labels, or they simply made up some meaningless graphs. Either way is super unprofessional for science communicators. I really expect more scientific rigor than that from PBS!
That Whiterun Screenshot :3
Interesting, depends also in which time frame and who is going to pay for that. I am sure that when our ancestors moved they had to fund it themselves. And if they need to do it fast, there is no extra housing for 200 million people. Ourr ancestors built their own homes, but today people wait in camps built by the U.N.
Eventually we'll all be migrating to Atlantis.
Bus then to Texas and Florida -- the parts of Florida that are still above water.
Something you didn't mention was how climate change makes previously arid land more fertile and how the move inland and northward might promote deforestation.
What?? San Franciscans as climate refugees to Las Vegas? Cities shown as red dots in the middle of Alaska falling into the ocean?
I'm from India. And yeah it's true, climate change does affect us. Our cities have gotten not just more hotter but more extreme in general (summers are hotter, winters cooler, and monsoons are pretty much storms in the first few weeks). But the thing is, this is a result of the massive industrialization in our country and lack of proper enforcement of environmental ideals. People may migrate to other locations, but first world countries SHOULD NOT take immigrants and refugees. Do not let your countries deteriorate into a mere reflection of ours. There is a reason things are not changing here and are not getting better as fast as we want, and that is because, unfortunately, it has become a part of our mind-set, our culture even. If countries keep taking in refugees, then we will simply be running away from the problem, rather than being forced to solve it. I don't care how hot it gets in the coming decades, I'm not leaving my country, because I can tatleast be an asset to my country, but by moving, I'll simply become a liability for some other country.
Jason Grace i can understand wanting to stay in your country to try and help sort out the problems caused by climate change, but what if it's too dangerous to stay in your country, like in an island nation. For some island nations they might not even use that much electricity, but the rising sea levels caused by the rest of the world could completely flood their islands. Luckily for you india is a very big country, so if the place in india that you live becomes inhabitable because of climate change you could move to a different part of the country, but that's not always going to be possible for everyone
Are you really from India, Jason?
FYI In America, the immigrants we get from India tend to be very well educated and are disproportionately likely to be doctors and scientists and software developers, and quite successful. It's true that perhaps India would be better off if they stayed in India, but America is very literally enriched by its Indian immigrants.
jdawg My real name isn't Jason. Jason is just a fictional chara ter and this is a fandom account.
We're all stuck on this rock together.
If we can't manage to make room for each other and help each other survive, as a species, do we really even deserve to go on?
shingshongshamalama When you put it that simply, it's obvious. But you see, it isn't that simple. The most developed parts of human civilization will be put into danger of over population and scarcity of resources if too many refugees are taken.
So, send all climate migrants to Africa? Works for me. Or are you saying countries shouldn't be able to limit who comes there to live?
So we came to a point where climate change videos are not even trying to ask us to do something, but tell us to deal with it..
Are we all going to move into Antarctica and Greenland these places are going to turn into tropics
I don’t know why, but almost every problem we are facing as human beings begin with intolerance from those who have a better life, a life style they didn’t achieve, a life style that was given by those who really fought for a better world. Hunger, poverty, climate change, criminality... all these problems can be solve if we work together despite our diferencies.
What are the graphs at 3:53 supposed to be showing? Did you just make them up, or how about some labels up in there? Please try to be a bit more honest and professional with your science communication. Maybe you're trying to simplify it for a broad audience, but a little more scientific rigor reallllly wouldn't hurt here.
All that space in Antarctica will open up!
🌐👀👂
☝👅🖑
Zom Bee Nature (Antarctica is actually very small under the ice, and smaller when the ocean levels rise after the ice goes, but it IS land so I guess it works.)
😢 There you go bringing reality into things! 😉
@SDD525 a thriving business growing cactus pads to eat? Domesticated pet penguin farms? And of course all the UA-camrs churning out videos making slime out of Antarctic sand and seal droppings. Life hacks involving puddles and lichens. Conspiracy theories about auroras. Prank videos involving gravel.
Yep, a thriving business 🙄
Rapa nui is an excellent microcosm of how humanity's environmental negligence will lead to a literal downfall of an entire civilization.
Hi who is watching for schl
Hmmmm
Climate related deaths have gone down in the past 100 years
I don't think that migration of ancient people was close to what we'll gonna face soon. Probably they migrated very slowly and might not even notice it. But modern people will have to move much futher in one life time. This is not the same, not at all.
Hi, how do you make your animation?
We need to protect the environment if lots of people work on doing eco friendly things the world would be better
SDD525 true we all need to do our job and protect and care for the earth and each other no matter our age,gender, race, religion spread the word 🙂
something easy to do is being mindful of how much meat you eat; Don't misunderstand me, but eating meat for dinner every night puts unnecesary strain on the enviroment by giving the animal slaughterhouses the money they need to keep their industry going.
I just got word that gretta thunberg said all of the climate migrants can come and live with her.... HOW DARE ME!!!!!!🤪
idk to me this sounds like a severe underestimation. i mean i'm german far inland and i'm worrying about how it'll be in 50 years. thinking there will be many places in the usa that will be bearable sounds a bit optimistic when you already get temperatures of idk a lot, tornados that destroy cities and stuff slowly sinking. when do you reach the point where it's just too much? i'd rather think about going to places like russia or finland. that sounds more viable. but videos always make it sounds like you would just need to relocate within your own country or you'd just have to worry about coastal cities lmao.
Der to higher ground
Unfortunately the world of Soylent Green becomes reality by 2070
The rich are only not helping cause they don’t feel it.
I think they'll go to California.
TL;DR: Siberia, Scandinavia and Canada would actually become much nicer place, as they are dysproporcjonalny affected by warming.
im may UNDERWEAR!
I think I shouldnt get kids, it would be egotistical to bring more humans into this hell world of impending suffering. At the same time, i can't help but assume that the vast majority of people will continue to proliferate, making this mess even worse. So I might as well. But what if this course of thinking is why everyone will continue to have kids ? I guess that means we're going down together, and I guess that is the best case scenario - We won't suffer alone, and our kids probably won't know better.
Good video so true in 2021
We need to take a lesson from our ancestors and move underground.
The Syrians went to the neighbor countries, the rich ones went to Europe.
6th
54th
We colonized much of the planet's land, yes, but it took as several thousand years.
01:56 Bangladesh :')
As long as their is oil, money and kardashians. We ain’t progressing any further.
all we know is that it will be bad
well sometimes i feel like were either migrating to mars or just die. and yes i know that Mars wont work so yeah were fcked
25 million to 1 billion is a reeeeally wide range. So wide that my hot take is that this is not credible. But if you stick with it, it’s good info.
Expose prejudice, how about earned response.
No they won’t.
Are you guys also gonna tackle the miscalculations done by earlier and recent climate change graphs (like climate gate) which causes confusion on many unaware people in the future?
0:30 to Mars
What climate immigrants?
10,000 years changes a lot
I like your pitch I just thing you ignored all of written human history
Yeah, facts are not nice, sorry
My taxes at work propagandizing...
Hot Mess It's Okay to be smart Dr Joe let's *ALL* move to Mars when it's ready. 🤣 🏚👣 🔥🌪⛄ 🌐=🏡
yeah , look. Human kind wont disappear but millions will die, how awesome right?
Fire whoever wrote that Pokémon line.
They are headed to JoeBama's America - lol
Getting ready to invade the global north wooo yayyyyy
hogwash
Children of Men
Totally weird dudes
Total BS
as a geophysicist with 40 years experience working on paleo-climates, I think that this is scientific nonsense. the global temps may reach 1.5C by 2050 but it also could start a cooling trend like what precipitated the Maunder Minimum in the mid-1500's through the mid-1800's another reason why I don't financially support PBS