When Will Kolkata Doctor Get Justice? Why No Action On Incompetent Officials? Newshour Debate

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 10 вер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 132

  • @gopalghorai265
    @gopalghorai265 25 днів тому +10

    This is West Bengal. don't expect justice 😢😢

  • @hg6qc
    @hg6qc 25 днів тому +12

    Send mamta didi to Bangladesh because she loves peaceful bangali people

  • @solomonraj.17
    @solomonraj.17 25 днів тому +14

    Taufiq Ahmed said ' may be dozens or hundreds of people have gang raped' to tell about the rumour news....
    How dare you to talk so negligently on national Tv. I wish you shud have been in that place rather than that innocent doctor....she is watching you from above you will face the consequences.

    • @Msa-wv7xu
      @Msa-wv7xu 23 дні тому

      @@solomonraj.17 all of them are the same...they are a curse for the country, for the world

  • @ChinkuYajurva
    @ChinkuYajurva 25 днів тому +7

    All female doctors please don’t work during night shift..if the authorities cannot provide safety they cannot demand you work in such horrendous conditions. Let the male doctors take the burden as they are incapable of protecting female colleagues. Your life and safety is more important than working for an inhuman and cruel society and system. All female doctors kindly protest by working only during day shifts. Urge the IMA to implement this rule. You do not have to be service minded at the cost of your own safety for an ungrateful population. It’s my humble request to all female doctors.

    • @Blueballoonss
      @Blueballoonss 24 дні тому +1

      I once posted a comment as a reply to a statement by a minister,"women should avoid situations where they r alone,"i commented "hv the govt made rules women should not work at nyt?" N a user replied don't expect us man to work more hrs when we enjoy the same salary 😊.i Mean i was not even saying we dnt want work at nyt.i was just commenting.thats the mindset of man in india

    • @ChinkuYajurva
      @ChinkuYajurva 24 дні тому

      @@Blueballoonss Women can compromise on the salary if that’s what is bothering the men. No amount of money can replace trauma induced by harassment or loss of life.

  • @ashishchatterjee7354
    @ashishchatterjee7354 24 дні тому +1

    We are demanding justice from the Government. Now from whom is the Government demanding justice? I am really baffled.

  • @Sameera-g2q
    @Sameera-g2q 25 днів тому +7

    I think she knows about hospital scam illegal activities so she was murdered .

  • @CorpusCallosum1939
    @CorpusCallosum1939 25 днів тому +8

    Suspects…. Principal of the college, Some Drs in the same department, and definitely the Culprit… Mr. ModarC Roy

  • @nothingnesstonothingness
    @nothingnesstonothingness 25 днів тому +5

    It's more than gangrape and murder. Investigate those 4 interns who were seen on CCTV alomg with her and also that principal. This collega has a history of s3x scandals, necrophilia, and drug trafficking. So many students have been keeled for the same reason. Abhaya knew something about this racket. Even the police commissiner who is handling this case has the history of distortion in such cases. Plus, that was not mob who attacked the doctors protest but majority of them.were students, some faces are so visible on videos, why police have not caught them?

    • @supritiphani1282
      @supritiphani1282 25 днів тому +1

      Principal knows everything. He maybe involved

  • @jvince3971
    @jvince3971 25 днів тому +5

    No CCTV what hospital is this

  • @MegaVarun27
    @MegaVarun27 25 днів тому +5

    More than 5people are involved.... This ia not done by 1 man..... Mamata KMKC

  • @tribhuvanraj1180
    @tribhuvanraj1180 25 днів тому +7

    If this case doesn't find justice I don't know on which case we will get justice

  • @auraa1958
    @auraa1958 25 днів тому +9

    Bengal wants resignation of CM. What is central government doing thus far? If you know Mamata is doing wrong then why not invoking President rule?

    • @Venkatasubramanian-z7s
      @Venkatasubramanian-z7s 25 днів тому

      🤺🤺

    • @RahulRaj-gd4lm
      @RahulRaj-gd4lm 24 дні тому +2

      @@auraa1958 it's not that easy for President rules, entire anti Modi ecosystem will get activated by crying Dictator Modi Dictator Modi and create Bangladesh like situations.only option is all Bengalis shouldn't vote Mamata in upcoming elections

    • @parthachem83
      @parthachem83 24 дні тому +1

      He can't. When will u ppl learn the basic rules and law? It requires Governor to recommend it and President to approve it with support of PM. If u don't have basic knowledge, don't show up in comments shouting nonsense
      If he tries it otherwise, anyways courts can overturn it any time. We already know how SC acts against Central Govt and for such INDI parties already. Presidential rule is not a joke. It requires full proof case for it.

    • @parthachem83
      @parthachem83 24 дні тому

      These ppl have no idea about the difference between an autocracy and democracy. Every state is an autonomous body with centre monitoring them. Or what's the point of state elections and state govt? They can't force everything since courts will always overturn it. If u are doing something this drastic, u should have solid evidences that will be undeniable. WB natives facing it but everyone else still thinks it is political. It is not that simple. Somehow they still think living in "Indira is India" age where PM gets do anything without accountability

  • @auraa1958
    @auraa1958 25 днів тому +4

    Sagarika ghosh knows everything it looks.

  • @AR-yv3dj
    @AR-yv3dj 25 днів тому +14

    I'm sure that the doctor was a Non Peaceful, else Bengal would be burning by now....

    • @AGGRESSION3666
      @AGGRESSION3666 25 днів тому +3

      If it was a Muslim community , Bengal toh kya……!!!!

    • @Mah_noor99
      @Mah_noor99 25 днів тому +2

      muslim ho ya Hindu ya koi christian ye matter nhi krta Yar , wo Dr ye b matter nhi krta wo ek insaan thi ek ladki thi Kisi ki Beti thi us masoom ladki k sath wohi hua Jo bichari nirbahaya k sath hua tha as a girl merii rooh kanp Rahi hy soch kr k the amount of pain and trauma that poor girl went through I pray upar wala us k maa baap ko sukoon de or insaaf de they lost a piece of their heart kia guzar rhi hogi un logo pr ....I'm a Muslim girl from Pakistan 🇵🇰 but that does not matter I have so many hindu friends from India mere liyee insaniyat se bada koi dharm nhi ..... When I was a kid I used to ask my mom k log kiu Beti ki birth pr sad hoty sometimes she says Beti k paida hone se dar nhi lgta uski kismat se lgta hy ....girls are not safe it's a fact

    • @nothingnesstonothingness
      @nothingnesstonothingness 25 днів тому +1

      Don't drag religion so soon... there are culprits from peaceful community also. So have some shame. This crime is beyond what you are seeing. Just wait and watch.

    • @ZK4mBD
      @ZK4mBD 25 днів тому +2

      ​@@nothingnesstonothingnesswe in Bangladesh empethize with you and stand in protest for Moumita also. We realize the value of life lost and how it feels to fight with a govt that doesn't listen. Wish you saw our situation above religeous bias and stood for the human rights and justice too. Anyways, i wish and pray you guys see light through this protest and get justice. RIP Moumita. May the criminals are arrested soon.

    • @soumyadeepsengupta827
      @soumyadeepsengupta827 25 днів тому +1

      ​@@nothingnesstonothingnessyour peaceful community is islam only

  • @Msa-wv7xu
    @Msa-wv7xu 25 днів тому +6

    God knows why our president and supreme court is quiet...what will it take for them to act, if such incidents cant affect them

  • @ganendraroy867
    @ganendraroy867 25 днів тому +4

    Who should be sacked Ms mamata Benerjee’s, home minister or health minister or chief minister Hglqclqcb ha ha

  • @madhuryadutta3462
    @madhuryadutta3462 25 днів тому +16

    Law and order, government mechanism has collapsed in West Bengal. I urge the president to kindly impose president rule in West Bengal immediately. Step back Mamta

  • @behappy-vp9cl
    @behappy-vp9cl 25 днів тому +11

    Don't expect justice....

    • @silentwatch7643
      @silentwatch7643 24 дні тому +1

      😮 why is this man out of breath?? Has he got something to hide??

    • @vaishbhonsle2558
      @vaishbhonsle2558 24 дні тому

      Yes same thought ​@@silentwatch7643

  • @rajvirdee1317
    @rajvirdee1317 25 днів тому +3

    Get these officials first and sack them.Other wise they will continue ad slways.Make example and wake rest of their lot to perform.

  • @ZK4mBD
    @ZK4mBD 25 днів тому +1

    People in India must stand together and not bend for any compromise till justice is done. We in Bangladesh know the feeling and we are with you in spirit and protest. Please keep close eye on every progress or lack of and raise your voice immediately. Dont give up and you shall win.

  • @DeepaDeepana-d3u
    @DeepaDeepana-d3u 25 днів тому +4

    What methods can forensic scientists use to identify individual perpetrators in a sexual assault case where multiple attackers are involved and their DNA is present in the victim's body?

  • @vineetsehgal8135
    @vineetsehgal8135 24 дні тому +1

    Against whom Mamta is protesting??

  • @raghuveersanatan5759
    @raghuveersanatan5759 25 днів тому +1

    If evidence is wiped out what cbi or courts will do ???

  • @todaygeneration3887
    @todaygeneration3887 25 днів тому +3

    Why can't they do narco test and get truth from sanjay roy

  • @riffmasterification
    @riffmasterification 24 дні тому +1

    We want President/Governor's rule in WB.

  • @madhuryadutta3462
    @madhuryadutta3462 25 днів тому +15

    Mamta hatao Bengal bachao

  • @sanjayraz78gurung13
    @sanjayraz78gurung13 24 дні тому

    Still they are not saying that they are helping CBI,,, definitely the nation should rise for justice

  • @tvraotammireddy831
    @tvraotammireddy831 24 дні тому +1

    People should have an eye on those who are supporting Mamata.

  • @krishnamurthychillara6552
    @krishnamurthychillara6552 24 дні тому

    The home minister n health minister of West Bengal should resign immediately and the focus of every single demonstration across nation

  • @RahulRaj-gd4lm
    @RahulRaj-gd4lm 25 днів тому +5

    Sanjoy Roy is not alone the perpetrator of the rape and murder. It’s unlikely that a single person could commit killing like this?. Why is the TMC government so swift to destroy evidence? Are you aware of the actual suspects in this case? WB Labor Minister Nirmal Maji's son and Irrigation Minister Soumen Mohapatra's son.

  • @MrPattnaikb
    @MrPattnaikb 25 днів тому

    At the end no justice will be given . All the criminal will be set free in few days . Just matter of time .

    • @silentwatch7643
      @silentwatch7643 24 дні тому

      😮 True!! Nirbhaya took 10 years. There was plenty of evidence.
      I wonder how long this will take.

  • @ganesanganesan4707
    @ganesanganesan4707 24 дні тому

    Godi media culprit aressted . Mamta already prepared for CBI ENQUIRE. CBI ALSO INVESTIGATING. MAKING POLITICS.

  • @Stardust-xl8nn
    @Stardust-xl8nn 24 дні тому

    Why are the female MPs from TMC silent?
    Why is the INDI alliance silent?
    Is rape of a woman in INDI alliance ruled state not a crime?
    India remembers the kind of agitation & aggressiveness INDI alliance took for rape cases that happened in BJP ruled states

    • @parthachem83
      @parthachem83 24 дні тому

      Didn't get lipstick or bags for talking about it

  • @himabindudunna8491
    @himabindudunna8491 24 дні тому

    The incident took place in the hospital, so hospital authorities is the complainant, but didn't file any complaint i.e., FIR
    But Police took suo moto
    Lack of hospital authorities, to hide illegal activities happening in the hospital, the hospital authorities didn't lodge the complaint
    That's why the Principal was transferred to nearby hospital

  • @user-lc7ym4fc7u
    @user-lc7ym4fc7u 24 дні тому

    Kamru chaudhary sounds very reasonable

  • @srihari772
    @srihari772 24 дні тому

    Irrespective of everything else, and above all, the "Most Elementary, Apparently Glaring, and Screaming Issue" in this case is "Appointing a Person" with a "Notorious Track Record and Complaints" and "Allowing him to Continue as a Police Volunteer with a "Free Access" even in a "Drunken State" to "All the Departments in a Reportedly Reputed Hospital in a City Centre" "Without any Security Checks" on Him??!! which "any layman" "could easily judge" is by itself a matter of "Gross Oversight and Criminal Negligence!!"

  • @asmisaxena
    @asmisaxena 24 дні тому

    I don't think the man arrested is the only culprit

  • @asmisaxena
    @asmisaxena 24 дні тому

    RESIGN RESIN RESIGN WITH IMMEDIATE EFFECT

  • @khadarsk649
    @khadarsk649 24 дні тому

    Justice😢

  • @shivanid5904
    @shivanid5904 24 дні тому

    Yeh mamta kyu protest kar rahi hai , woh khud cm , home minister hai Kolkata ki . Shame on her

  • @somannair3280
    @somannair3280 24 дні тому

    Mamtha is a shame for the whole Indian womenfolk. Is she one of them or in between?

  • @neeharghosh7105
    @neeharghosh7105 24 дні тому

    Madam, why you called TMC goon Tauusif

  • @ashishchatterjee7354
    @ashishchatterjee7354 24 дні тому

    This is what the TMC representatives they always shirk the main issue and goes to other irrelevant topics.

  • @Fluency-nk7qz
    @Fluency-nk7qz 24 дні тому

    All the public must wake up for justice why in india citizens r never gt justice public move hojaooo

  • @sandeep_sandy07
    @sandeep_sandy07 24 дні тому

    Just see ...no congress members just lifting this story ...wrost this are wrost to our India ...

  • @UrsVJ9
    @UrsVJ9 24 дні тому

    The worst cm in india till now

  • @asmisaxena
    @asmisaxena 24 дні тому

    Madam, where is the presidents rule

  • @VasuBs
    @VasuBs 24 дні тому

    Mamtha to tughlak ka mummy nikali. Ruling west bengal like a cruel dictator.

  • @SathyaSathya-o8t
    @SathyaSathya-o8t 24 дні тому

    Mamtha government should dismiss.then only all state CM ,police DGP will work properly.girls will safe

  • @asa9402
    @asa9402 25 днів тому +2

    Bjp central leadership is with TMC for political reason ,they also don't want justice।

  • @sandeep_sandy07
    @sandeep_sandy07 24 дні тому

    Cm doesnot doing justice to that sister then why your are being as a cm ..just resing

  • @khadarsk649
    @khadarsk649 24 дні тому +1

    Apkebaar congress paar😮

  • @asmisaxena
    @asmisaxena 24 дні тому

    A mockery of politics

  • @kurtsnuggs2194
    @kurtsnuggs2194 24 дні тому

    Shame on West Bengal.
    Shame on the government...Shame on police..Shame on hospital authorities.
    Sanjay roy is just a pawn in this crime. DOCTORS AND PEOPLE DONT GIVE UP THE FIGHT EVEN IF IT MEANS BRINGING DOWN EVERYBODY IN THIS SYSTEM

  • @ShayengShiu
    @ShayengShiu 25 днів тому

    Capital punishment assured

  • @StevenKilner
    @StevenKilner 24 дні тому

    Hahaha 🍇Banerjee the best

  • @prabharao6880
    @prabharao6880 24 дні тому

    Throw out didi begum

  • @asmisaxena
    @asmisaxena 24 дні тому

    Why mamta is still there

  • @BabluChakarabaty
    @BabluChakarabaty 24 дні тому

    Police mantri Shastra mantri kaun hai Mamata Banerjee aur vah khud police ke bare mein aandolan kar raha hai natak agar karna hai to Mamta banarji se sikhiye

  • @pamartyhimaja6315
    @pamartyhimaja6315 25 днів тому

    Mamatha should resign.

  • @joachimmarappa9136
    @joachimmarappa9136 24 дні тому

    Incompetent fellows shame on you
    And you guys wanted equal with other nations.When you are incapable of saving a person who is working for . Nonsense

  • @shadiqueali7760
    @shadiqueali7760 24 дні тому

    This is not time for politics,
    A person has been raped and murdered.
    According to NCRB 2021 statistics, Rajasthan reported the highest number of rapes among Indian states, followed by Madhya Pradesh and Uttar Pradesh. Among metropolitan cities, the national capital of Delhi continued to have the highest incidence of rape at 1,226 cases in 2021, while Jaipur had the highest rape rate (34 per 100,000 population). Kolkata had the least number of registered rape cases among metropolitan cities, with the lowest rape rate.[4]
    if you still think this is a government failure, then tell us the which government is correct
    I hope the government may work harder and catch all the criminals involved.

  • @SanthoshKumar-be7bn
    @SanthoshKumar-be7bn 24 дні тому

    Annpad cm

  • @srivatsabakthisaran3710
    @srivatsabakthisaran3710 25 днів тому +2

    Why modi shah not taken any action on cm of westbengal why afraid modi no use as pm

    • @todaygeneration3887
      @todaygeneration3887 25 днів тому

      😂He his no comparative to IG she is right or wrong but took bold decision, he his more of self image oriented thts why loosing trust of Hindus.

  • @Venkatasubramanian-z7s
    @Venkatasubramanian-z7s 25 днів тому

    MamKong
    🦍

  • @naiwangkonyak7522
    @naiwangkonyak7522 24 дні тому +1

    😊😅😮😢😅😅😅😅

  • @tee-u3u9o
    @tee-u3u9o 25 днів тому +1

    Digital india😅😅😅😅😅😅😅

    • @Msa-wv7xu
      @Msa-wv7xu 25 днів тому +1

      What's there to laugh in this ...shame on you

    • @dineshbabu4921
      @dineshbabu4921 25 днів тому

      Why laughing, if didn't take seriously it will happen to your Mother, sister and daughter.

    • @Msa-wv7xu
      @Msa-wv7xu 25 днів тому

      @@dineshbabu4921 such shameless hijdas we have in our country

  • @milindkamat280
    @milindkamat280 25 днів тому +1

    Napusank BJP

  • @orthodel
    @orthodel 25 днів тому

    Why people in panel not raising question about what happened in Sandeshkhali.

  • @g_balakrishna52074
    @g_balakrishna52074 24 дні тому

    Better resign as a CM Mamatha

  • @mshakthivelu9049
    @mshakthivelu9049 24 дні тому

    Joker 😂 Mamatha bajji

  • @user-oq5iy8di6k
    @user-oq5iy8di6k 24 дні тому

    MODI MEDIA STUDENTS NO SUPPORT ONLY IS ADANI AMBANI SUPPORT FOR MODI MEDIA 😭😭😭😭👠⛸️👠👡🥜🥜

  • @krishnamurthychillara6552
    @krishnamurthychillara6552 24 дні тому

    The home minister n health minister of West Bengal should resign immediately and the focus of every single demonstration across nation