Music Critic Reacts to J-HOPE - CHICKEN NOODLE SOUP ft. BECKY G
Вставка
- Опубліковано 2 жов 2024
- jhope is back baby with a new song featuring Becky G whch is apparently a remake of an older song that i've never heard of!
Please subscribe so I can eat: bit.ly/2KocGff
HEY DO YOU LIKE CLOTHES? BUY MY MERCH: teespring.com/...
I make KPOP content for AMINO follow me @ Dylan Ginno
aminoapps.onel....
Twitter: @dylanginno bit.ly/2oDUAen
Instagram: @dyl.ginno bit.ly/2VlkuYR
Ask me Questions here: curiouscat.me/...
Hey guys, I've seen a couple people commenting that I 'should've' known this song was a remake. I have never heard of the original nor did I see this press release that has been mentioned. I review music as stand alone pieces of art so I personally don't see how it is relevant to this review. I understand that you may not have liked my critique but I stand by them now knowing that this song is a remake of an older song.
-Ginno
Then your review is invalid, kinda. No offence.
You can't just throw away the meaning and history behind ANY song. Artistic thought and technical aspects flow together in music. Making a "review" without both important parts is invalid. You can have an initial reaction without any prior knowledge but it's not a review. Moreover, when you later get to know the story of the song, don't just make up excuses and still call it a review. You can have a first opinion on a standalone song. But it's just a reaction based on your preferences, not in any way "critical review".
Just because it has an original doesn't make the remake song better. You can hate the original and like the remake or like the original and hate the remake. They are both two independent songs that don't rely on each other. Just because the original was popular doesn't makes this song equally good or boast it up.
That's the thing, it's not a stand alone piece of art. It doesn't make sense to review it as one when it pays homage to an original. I also feel like you don't really understand the conventions behind the hip hop genre very well to make a fair judgement.
nobody has an issue with your critique in itself, youre completely entitled to not find this song all that great. lots of people dont like it. and even if you knew the context, you still probably wouldn't have liked it, which is fine. but the way you dismissed the broader context of the song, genre, and culture this remake is paying homage to does a disservice to the original artist and her culture and, in my opinion, prevents you from being able to fairly judge the song, even if you choose to treat it as a standalone piece. i really do respect your opinion and expertise but you cant deny that context shifts perception and in this case cultural context is the foundation this track was built upon. i dont believe you can form a fair opinion without understanding that foundation.
@@lightefilit it's a reaction not a review of the song? that title says "reacting" not "reviewing"
Check out Webstar's original Chicken Noodle Soup to get a better understanding. He said this song was what got him interested in dancing in the firat place.
This song and video is filled with nostalgia for sooo many people from their childhood and for JHope and BeckyG too
. They payed homage to the 2000's song of the same title by Webstar, it was huge back then. So its like remake
This is sample of another older song though
I see what you mean by the uncessary pop, but I feel like these days we just get the same beat through the whole song and this song the way they changed it has transitions is kind of fresh in my opinion, has a lil bit of everything and not just jam out with the same rythym
Totally agree about the first transition. But after listening to it a couple of times it kind of make sense and blend well? But I still isn't my coup of team.
Disagree with the Becky part bc that is the kind of flow Latin artist have so I think she was on point.
palabrasenllamas , they do well together as a duo.
It’s based on a song from the early 2000’s
Idk, for me everything works so well it’s really one if the best songs I heard lately 🤷🏼♀️
Phew..I thought that I was the weird odd person who liked the song 😶
i personally like that transition as it broke up the song really well and becky’s delivery, however i respect your opinion. i don’t think people realize that you’re not telling them they have to agree with you lmao
I think those of us who knew the older song will like this more. It's an unapologetic bop, and we have the emotions and memories wrapped up in it, and then you throw in JHope and BeckyG… It's gonna be HUGE here in the US. I'm not disagreeing with you about some of the transitions, but most people will just overlook that, and enjoy the beat and the memories.
kinda awkward to react to a song and give an opinion on its composition without doing any research into the source material and having no knowledge of the significance of the original. other than that, i respect your opinion on things you're knowledgeable on.
kinda ridiculous to react to a song and call yourself a "music critic" when you haven't educated yourself on the song or artists you're reacting to
GraceFace yes I agree with you , this guy don’t know nothing about music and he call himself music critic 😂
lol u should really listen to original 😭 this was huge in america back in the day and we all know this song
dude what the hell are you talking about? this song is a total bob. all the transitions work great, the unexpectedness makes it awesome.. not like just another hiphop music video. Give it another listen.
I don't know how you can criticize something without reserching facts first but to each his own I guess
I hear nothing wrong with the transition. But I respect your opinion.
The only reaction channel I see and subscribe to because of your honesty. Keep it up!
Bruh, just thanks for being honest. This people who reacted to BTS are so dramatic and fake just for the views. Even tho I liked the song, I aprecciated you’re work and respect you’re opinion. Keep true to yourself and don’t be affected to these yourger fans.
PS: sorry for my english, is not my first language, so...yeah 💕
Since when was this guy a music critic??..I remember seeing him some years ago as a non kpop fan or something...is he an expert now??
(No insult..just confused 🤨)
Bro what u sayimg this song is good
How could you call yourself a music critic if you have not done your research but still you dare to judge the title of the song and the chorus. Young cat let me tell you, the title and most of the lyrics you heard and "critized" were from the original song and there is a message behind "Chicken noodle soup" done by Webstar and Young B, and now by J Hope and Becky G. This remake is trilingual, you should even translate the lyrics before you judge.
I find the singing part so unsatisfying to hear omg!! And I really wish we could have heard more of Becky G's spanish rapping 😬
▶I actually love the transitions, the
singing melody for a 90's/2000 feel
#2 TRENDING-J-HOOOPE!!🔥🔥🔥🔥
J-Hope/dancer insisted on dancers'
names credits at the end!!❤ him!!
You realize that this was a song based back in 2000. You really need to more research before you criticize a song.
The song had 11 million views in 14 years and peaked at 45. Most people have never heard of it.
He's also reacting to the mix/production which no doubt is obviously new work so the critique is still valid.
@@eternalptgmx but bighit put out a press release talking about the song and where the song originated from. Criticism is fine but this is basic research that should have been looked.
Don’t really see how that’s relevant to the criticisms I made?
@@GinnoTV because if you had looked at bighit entertainment press release you could have compared the two and showed the diffrences between the remake and the orginal. And ask the question what makes these two different?? Was it the production? Was it camera work?
I love the song because of the meaning of it and it represents how far Hobi has come, and its very meaningful to me as an OG BTS fan who has been Hobi biased since the beginning (partially because of his dancing abilities). Its also a fun and unique song thats different from what they've released before. But if I weren't a BTS fan I probably wouldn't listen to it again I have to admit, could have done a much better more seamless job with the song if it were produced better (the original song is a bit of a difficult song to work with though). Other Army, he's not just a reactor he's a music critic and is judging their music seriously, he's allowed to not like it. I also often have criticisms of their music, I love BTS to bits but doesn't mean I think they're perfect. I prefer to watch someone like this who knows music than a generic reactioner who just likes everything they hear. Whether he knows the original song or not doesn't change the criticisms.
React to monsta x new song *love u* so good 😊
I really respect you not liking the pop transitions. I'm not crazy over them too
💜💜💜💜💜J-HOPE💜💜💜💜🔥🔥🔥😭😭😭💜💜
I don't suppose you know about the backstory to him making this enough for you to comment on the lyrics
Lmao u should do ur research first
I personally loved the transition that Becky G added to the song. It broke up the song and gave it a different vibe. I love the pop aspect that it gave. I, however, can respect your opinion that you don’t like it. What works for some don’t work for others. I found the remix of this song to be remarkable. Jhope did an excellent job in my opinion working with his experts.
what kinda music music critic doesn't do their research?
The beginning music sounds like Seinfeld.
React to super junior the crown 👑.
Another Tacky UA-cam self proclaimed music critic 🤣😂
Respect their opinion, nobody is forcing you to watch it.
I see wher e you come from with your takes.
I I really enjoy the energy and the fun of the song& mv tho.
I agree that the transition feels kinda odd, doesn’t fit well. It would’ve been great if the vocal melody (Becky) creat for other pop song tho, I like the hook. I’m not feeling the chorus as well. It just feels......meh cause it’s repeatable. I am a fan of BTS and JHope tho but this song kinda disappoints me (might change my mind, if I listen to it often?). Just being honest. Also, this song is a remake. I was hoping for originality and something new :/
You know what it worked for Jhope since he did everything on this song and it's obvious you know jack about this song since it's a homage to the original chicken noodle soap. By the way it's an east coast jam get your act together and that's my opinion
SONAMOO - WE ARE LEGENDARY was released yesterday and it's a banger!! I would love to see your reaction! Have a nice day!! ^_^
Just a throwback to a youtube oldie, nothing too serious. A fun ode to the original. But thanks for being honest. C:
You are correct, this is a remake of an old song from around 2006. J-Hope and his team changed it a little bit music wise as well as lyrics.
It is a inspirational work, this is the song that made J-Hope interested on dancing, same with Becky G.
You can listen to the original song and compare it.
I always appreciate your reactions man, I loved the remake tho 😂
maybe research first ig
Hello super junior just released two new songs called somebody new and the crown. Can you please react to them ❤️ thank you
just listen to og track :/
Can i request to react Keyakizaka46 song??
They 1st single really good. The title is "Silent Majority" by Keyakizaka46
this is a sample of a song from 2009 with the same name
It's such an odd song lol. I respect your opinion which seems to be about how there could be better percussion choices at transition. There is definitely a deliberate choice to be weird here, even by choosing to pay homage to the chicken noodle soup song from 2006 to begin with, I think. Lol
React Gfriend Rough !!!!! ♡♡♡♡
Honestly I just can't bring myself to like any of Becky G's parts, just my personal tastes :/ i like her input in the "I let it rain, I clear it out" part tho, her voice sounds very nice, but I wish her parts would have been less awkward & random tbh. However I think overall they vibe well together, it was a great collab, just a little underwhelming at some point.