Aerospace Is Probably The Best MacOS Tiling Manager I've Ever Used

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 1 лют 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 233

  • @shinyuta
    @shinyuta 2 місяці тому +98

    I just switched from yabai and fully setup Aerospace with sketchybar yesterday. Very nice. The removal of the animation between MacOS spaces make the experience feel a lot faster.

    • @avramukk
      @avramukk 2 місяці тому +2

      same

    • @pedestrianlove
      @pedestrianlove 2 місяці тому +2

      Yeah a recent upgrade just breaks my yabai setup, so I went for aerospace and never look back.
      Plus, aerospace = yabai + skhd, this makes it even easier to configure the entire WM experience.

    • @hameldesai4756
      @hameldesai4756 2 місяці тому +2

      Hey, where in the system settings in mac os can I turn this off "The removal of the animation between MacOS spaces"
      Thank you!

    • @RegrinderAlert
      @RegrinderAlert 2 місяці тому +2

      @@hameldesai4756It’s not part of the system settings. It’s because Aerospace doesn’t use spaces.

    • @Wubwub772
      @Wubwub772 2 місяці тому +3

      if you use yabai, just turn on "reduce motion" in mac prefs. its the same thing

  • @srgsanky
    @srgsanky 2 місяці тому +13

    One of the best thing that I learned from this video is to switch to the terminal with a keybinding and use aerospace + fzf to switch between open windows. The other thing is the ability to have multiple modes where each can perform a different action for the same keybinding (for e.g. using the same keybinding to open WezTerm in one mode, while opening Alacritty in another mode). TIL.

  • @fixpoint
    @fixpoint 2 місяці тому +7

    I discovered Aerospace about two months ago and have been using it ever since. It took me a couple of weeks to get proficient, but now I couldn’t imagine life without. I like the fzf command you demonstrated, so I’ll be adding that into the mix. I opted to skip out on sketchy as the value it provided was not worth the effort. Great video as usual! Thanks!

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  2 місяці тому +1

      Thanks!
      I'd really like to remove sketchybar, but without workspace indication I feel lost...

    • @fixpoint
      @fixpoint 2 місяці тому

      @ Yes, I would be lost too if it weren’t for two things. One, aerospace does show which workspace you are currently in via the menu bar. And two, I’ve got myself in a routine where I place certain windows in specific workspaces. For example, email always goes into workspace 3 for me. I’ve found that I don’t need to see how many workspaces I currently have open very often. And in the when I do, I just click the menu bar, which lists all of them. Of course, every one has their own preferences. Nonetheless, thanks for sharing your setup! Great stuff!

  • @theherk
    @theherk 2 місяці тому +6

    Been using it for a few months and love it. I like to set the workspace names to relevant emoji so you get a nice helpful icon in the menu bar.

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  2 місяці тому

      Haha that's creative! I was thinking of actually renaming them using characters of they're meant for, i.e. 'b' for browsing, 'f' for finalcut, 'o' obsidian etc etc

    • @jakmazdev
      @jakmazdev 2 місяці тому

      ​@@devopstoolbox ​ I used the whole names for different spaces, like "web" and "code". Then upgraded it to sketchybar for even better indication!

  • @TheXtremerEditor
    @TheXtremerEditor 2 місяці тому +3

    i have been using aerospace for a long time now and i love it

  • @supernewuser
    @supernewuser Місяць тому +1

    first I've heard of aerospace but it looks pretty nice. I switched to a benq programming monitor a few months back and once you get it configured it is great. I haven't had eye strain since switching to it.

  • @ethanherrera1552
    @ethanherrera1552 Місяць тому +11

    my favorite navigation method is Command + Space type first two letters of app. idk why but it just feels better and faster to me than all this software. this one looks cool though

  • @GavinBogie
    @GavinBogie 2 місяці тому +2

    Been using it for months! Great Software!

  • @MihoNightwalker
    @MihoNightwalker 2 місяці тому

    Wau this is fantastic, thanks for the video. I'm trying this out first thing tomorrow.

  • @EttVenterPhoto
    @EttVenterPhoto 2 місяці тому +4

    I've been using Aerospace for about 2 months, and it's the only WM I've been able to stick with after trying them all. Love your videos man you and I are a similar flavour of nerd.

  •  2 місяці тому +6

    Even being a Linux user for more than 15 years this is great content. And now, there is a tilling manager for Windows, named Komorebi.
    Also, you should make a video about your coffee hardware and grains someday, they look top notch!

    • @onejdc
      @onejdc 2 місяці тому

      +1 for Komorebi, a Windows Tiling Manager written in the Rust programming language ( /grin )

  • @davidallred991
    @davidallred991 2 місяці тому

    surprised it took you so long. once of my favorite pieces of software in my setup, nothing comes close if using multiple monitors

  • @Slade_9000
    @Slade_9000 14 днів тому

    Chefs kiss, as a Linux user (hyprland) and moving to a Mac from a windows laptop at work, this is gonna help so much.

  • @christophersherman8036
    @christophersherman8036 Місяць тому

    Oh man thank you for showing me this. Ecosystem ties me to MacOs but I've always hated how I can't replicate i3 easily. The fix is finally here

  • @9636dev
    @9636dev 2 місяці тому

    Congrats on passing 2^15 subs!

  • @jakubkuchejda3864
    @jakubkuchejda3864 2 місяці тому +3

    I think a Raycast plugin would be a cool improvement to the "ff" command, having to go to the terminal first seems like an unnecessary extra step when you want to find an application. You can then create a custom keybinding to execute the command from anywhere.

  • @slaapliedje
    @slaapliedje 7 днів тому

    Nice, so you have a video showing how to make macOS usable for a Linux user! I always feel like Samantha Carter trying to explain something to Jack O'Neill when I try to tell people why I dislike macOS vs Linux.

  • @brian-wood
    @brian-wood 25 днів тому

    I really love Aerospace, it has been a game-changer for me. The main thing I need to figure out is why sometimes my windows start to flake out and all my screens (3) start flashing as it shuffles rapidly between layouts. Usually this happens at the same time I'm trying to demo how cool Aerospace is to someone, haha. I'm sure I have a pre-defined postion for an app that isn't playing nicely... That and sometimes it crashes since I moved to Sequoia. So, I have some work to do on it's config yet, but absolutely love it.

  • @Metruzanca
    @Metruzanca 2 місяці тому +34

    Happy user of Rectangle (window snapping shortcuts) and alt-tab (actually see a preview of, like windows/linux does and all windows as separate entries). Combined with cmd+space to open whatever app and I'm pretty productive. alt+space summons my iterm terminal which auto-collapses when not focussed. I pretty much only work with my apps in "full screen" (not macos full screen, that shit sucks) and sometimes a vertical split down the middle. I don't need anything else. I tried workspaces for a bit but thats just too much. I'll minimize things that aren't needed (and alt-tab is configured to will filter those entries out)

    • @JohnS-jc5mj
      @JohnS-jc5mj 2 місяці тому +8

      Same here keep it simple all this other shit looks complicated

    • @sergiosoares5045
      @sergiosoares5045 2 місяці тому +1

      Same here, Rectangle + Alt Tab (showing only apps for the opened desktop) is powerful already.
      Another trick is alt + cmd + h to minimize all apps, then I use spotlight to focus on what I really need.
      But I will give a try to Aerospace to have more opinions about tiling in MacOS.

    • @TadeasF
      @TadeasF Місяць тому

      spewing truth brother. tiling wms are nice when you actually manage to set it up so you have to remember LESS, not more than with rectangle setup.
      I had this pretty nutty setup for yabai, skhd and sketchybar but tbh it really did not make me more productive.
      i accidentally removed my os partition when I was installing asahi linux, haha. then I said fuck it, let's keep it simple. it's a treat when you give your computer to a collegue in office and don't have to explain how to use it. those guys who run these setups arent working, mostly, apart from the mythical 10xs out there ofc. but how does linus code anyway, huh? 24" screen and fucking walking desk, lol

    • @TadeasF
      @TadeasF Місяць тому

      i have a machine which is running manjaro with sway tiling wm. that's nice and saves time and I love to use it. cuz it literally turns everything into tmux. 100% recommend. tl;dr macos tiling wms are kinda shite but that's also due to the restrictive ecosystem anyway.

    • @leoruda
      @leoruda 3 дні тому

      Ran the same for a long time. But I included Amethyst. I just leave it on floating layout and cycle to tall, column or vertical layouts as needed. Got to the point I barely use rectangle anymore. Also, as i use a dual monitor setup, Amethyst letting me apply screen padding to only one monitor let's me to use on just part of the screen and letting me use the other part as normal. I bound the "float window" shortcut to a mouse button so even with tiling activated its pretty ease to handle the windows the way I was more used to. I dunno, sometimes I think I made it more complicated, but I've been using the mouse less.. so.. who knows. I think he said it all in the video, both in his intro, and through his show and tell of monitor setups, lol. The "power user" thing is a metaphor for life. You chase after more and more, only to find out it isn't really worth it and just go back to the basics. I'm just surfing the wave at this point.

  • @petaflop3606
    @petaflop3606 2 місяці тому +3

    Amazing, so timely, having just about had enough of Mac's lacking window management. They made such a token attempt in the last couple releases, I was almost about to full linux hyprland lol but I'm glad I can stick to my mac dev env. Thanks for the intro to Aerospace

  • @GOTHICforLIFE1
    @GOTHICforLIFE1 2 місяці тому +1

    Been using Aerospace for a while, and it's really nice. Only thing i don't really like compared to my normal keybound rectangle, is that i sometimes have to use multiple workspaces instead of having windows overlapping them like i did before.
    That can be a pro or a con, depending on how you prefer to work. that was a minor con for me, but in return aerospace allows me to super easily readjust the sizes of windows.
    Super nice once you get used to it. The biggest hurdle to get used to is how windows interact with each other. But overall great tool

    • @theherk
      @theherk 2 місяці тому

      Why can’t you have them overlap?

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  2 місяці тому

      To be fair, you can just set everything as a floating window by default using a catch all regex - see my config and just use '*'. then you'd be able to only using it for size adjustment. but then you lose most of the functionality of having tiling windows in the first place...

    • @gustavocampos1593
      @gustavocampos1593 Місяць тому

      In yabai my workspace 3 is on stacking mode, so every app on it becomes full screen, like what you said

    • @theherk
      @theherk Місяць тому +1

      @@gustavocampos1593 interestingly I do the exact same for my workspace 3 in aerospace due to how zed does window per project. On that workspace I only ever see one window even though many projects are open.

  • @Merlinvn82
    @Merlinvn82 2 місяці тому

    Aerospace is awesome. I use meh (ctr+shift+alt) as the main key instead of Alt key, so I don't have to mess with alt for my Neovim key, hyperkey for moving or modifing windows, workspace. And each frequencely use app will have its own namespace: Meh+b: browrser, meh+n: note, meh+t: terminal, and so on. Cmd+tab: now switch back and forth workspace instead of app.

  • @ronitgandhi7716
    @ronitgandhi7716 2 місяці тому +1

    Hey! Love your setup. No hate but can you make videos for devops also? Because i am seeing your videos since the start and I really enjoyed and learnt many new things from your old videos. I am not saying new are not good, they are top tier in all ways:editing, explaining. But i want to see more hacks or tips related to cloud and devops, as your channel name says. No hate just a friendly tip! Anyways I'll always watch all your videos. Great content❤

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  2 місяці тому +1

      Point taken! Thanks for the feedback.
      A word of honesty, cloud architecture is what I do for work, and while this channel was meant to cover these things, I found myself drawn to a very narrow niche of improving my setup so that I enjoy my work.
      You'd probably notice on my nushell vid, (another one coming soon) that most of my examples include working with kubectl and aws. I'll think about this comment and try out some more interesting bits with a devops angle in the future.
      thanks!

    • @ronitgandhi7716
      @ronitgandhi7716 2 місяці тому

      @devopstoolbox Yeah. But anyways I'm here to watch any kind of video you make. Because they are damn interesting and always learning new things!!

  • @Krmpfpks
    @Krmpfpks Місяць тому

    I agree that one monitor is better than moving your head around constantly. However the same goes for spaces! Flipping them is too big a change.
    However I dont like tiling window managers, I use Moves (before that easy move resize). Cmd+Shift + Mouse move (without button) moves the window, Alt+Shift resizes.
    Lightning fast, no thinking required. Working like this as a developer since over 20 years. You can take advantage of overlapping windows, no jumping between spaces required

  • @benarcher372
    @benarcher372 2 місяці тому +1

    Thank you so much!

  • @binh1298ify
    @binh1298ify 2 місяці тому

    Thanks, I've been using yabai for a while and this is much better

  • @jonathanrodriquez3775
    @jonathanrodriquez3775 2 місяці тому +3

    sketchyBar had been a game changer for me paired it with Amethyst

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  2 місяці тому

      Amethyst didn't work for me, but sketchybar is a thing of beauty and I'm so happy I found the experimental feature of running it vertically

  • @YannSchmidt
    @YannSchmidt 2 місяці тому +1

    I just moved my mac to use Nix Darwin a few days ago. I will try Aerospace. I didn't like Yabai so I stopped looking for a WM after that.
    I so want to try Ghostty but It's almost there !

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  2 місяці тому

      I think you're going to love aerospace. I had the same experience with yabai.
      Ghostty is coming out soon, and it's definitely great and it is my default emulator now, but to be honest, Wezterm is just as good and even better in some cases. Ghostty just makes an overall better package than the alternatives

  • @Michaeljamieson10
    @Michaeljamieson10 11 днів тому +1

    my goal to make mac os more like linux power user will be complete with this window tiling management system

  • @farzadmf
    @farzadmf 2 місяці тому +2

    AeroSpace is awesome. Just wish that it had a way to resize and move floating windows

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  2 місяці тому +2

      Havn't even thought of that option!

  • @substance90
    @substance90 16 днів тому

    The problem with a highly customized keyboard centric setup like that is that every time you go away for some time, muscle memory fades and you have to scratch your head when you get back. My Vim muscle memory is strong only because I use Vim mode in every IDE or editor that I use. Putting me in front of a tmux now would have me scratching my head, even though I spent every day whole day long in it until about 3-4 years ago.

  • @adjaydev
    @adjaydev 2 місяці тому +1

    Aerospace is the best! I switch from Amethyst earlier this year after the 'throw to screen x' stopped working after a macos update. I'm glad Amethyst stopped working! 🤣

  • @SxC97
    @SxC97 Місяць тому

    Not having to disable SIP is a huge plus to Aerospace, the only downside looks to be the lack of integration with the built in Mission Control, which allows an easy overview of all windows on the system. Have you found this to be a downside?
    Also, on the topic of switching between the mouse and keyboard, have you looked into the Svalboard keyboard? It seems to solve the issue of input switching and would integrate beautifully with a TWM.

  • @Michael-n7n2i
    @Michael-n7n2i Місяць тому

    I wish there was an in-between version of Rectangle Pro and this that was a bit more UI friendly

  • @carlt.8266
    @carlt.8266 Місяць тому +1

    I am also heavily invested in Apple‘s monoculture, but when you go that far, I am curious what makes you buy a Mac still? Is it the hardware (screen, case, speakers, touchpad, etc.)?
    Because, for me it is the interplay of all their devices. If Frame.Work, or some other open minded company, would start building HomePod-like speakers, offering protocols like Apple HomeKey, the whole continuity protocol for Linux, building smartphones, etc. I would never never spend a second look at Apple’s portfolio.
    As you don‘t mention anything else than macOS in your videos, why is it, that you don‘t run Linux and rice it the way you like? Docker is even running natively (without transparent VM) on Linux.

    • @andrer3764
      @andrer3764 Місяць тому +1

      Not the OP but i imagine some like some of the Linux feel but having more mainstream apps like Final Cut without having to emulate or run compatibility layers.
      Also you've mentioned some great reasons!

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  Місяць тому +1

      Honest answer - at this point I'm too much IN the ecosystem (iphone ipad, family devices, final cut for editing and MORE). So giving up is starting over and letting go some pretty useful syncs (copy pasting between devices, photos sharing, airdrop and so many functions I use daily).
      Also, I don't know about the stability of other systems, but MacOS, despite everyone's hate has just been nothing but stable for me. I rarely to never restart my computer. Either updating my system or the occasional refresh. I can go months between them no problem.
      You're right about the other pros - docker with no hypervisor, ricing options and more, maybe, some day :)

    • @carlt.8266
      @carlt.8266 Місяць тому

      @@devopstoolbox totally understandable. I live in the same technical prision and I like the interlinked authentication of all Apple devices and other Continuity Protocol features too much go main on Linux atm

  • @edwardferrari7342
    @edwardferrari7342 21 день тому +1

    Great video. I have been thinking of getting a ZSA voyager, do you think it would be worth it? I think it would tbh.

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  19 днів тому

      Definitely. If I'm honest, it's the one keyboard everybody's been recommending that I havn't been able to put my hands on (yet). I got the moonlander over the voyager because of the tenting option and not sure if I could live without it (led me to the dygma defy which I've been rocking over the past month)

    • @edwardferrari7342
      @edwardferrari7342 19 днів тому

      @devopstoolbox Nicee!! Thanks so much. Yeah I saw your post about that, looks sick. If I'm going to be honest, you deserve way more subs, keep up the great work.

  • @cunningham.s_law
    @cunningham.s_law 2 місяці тому

    amazing this video made me switch from amethyst
    only problem is I now have to change my bindings since I used alt hjkl to resize panes in tmux or wezterm

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  2 місяці тому

      what I love about it is the freedom to keep or change whatever you like...

  • @Judesmood118
    @Judesmood118 8 днів тому

    How is it with multitouch gestures? I recently switched to a touchpad for my desktop setup… and with windows gestures I’m very quick and productive with tiling windows…
    But I’m trying to convince myself to get a MacBook 😁

  • @howqso2885
    @howqso2885 Місяць тому +1

    The thing is : The aerospace keybindings are interfering with my tmux button some times and while I do want to change it, I don't want to lose the i3 configuration I can have for this tool.
    Really to be honest, I'm so green at mac that I feel like the macos keypad system is confusing me. I can deal with Windows tiling, Linux through Sway, Cosmic and i3 but I feel like I get lost in my keys with Mac.

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  Місяць тому

      Not sure why this would be special for mac, but I can say that all my tmux bindings are only triggered in tmux after it's prefix (ctrl a in my case). I don't map them to the root tree ever exactly for this reason.
      Aerospace has my apps pop with alt, and the rest of the actions start with opt(alt) + shift. easy for me to remember and handle

    • @howqso2885
      @howqso2885 Місяць тому

      @@devopstoolbox Yeah I'm still confused. I am struggling with the normal macos special keys, so even copying and paste grinds my gear.
      Like why would you use the cmd + c and cmd + v when you could use control, and use the cmd for tiling, launching apps and other desktop related actions, it's just weird for me.
      So cmd, alt, control are really a pain to handle, then adding aerospace and then even iterm with a tmux configuration gets too hard.
      I should either reduce the complexity until I get better at one, or take actual hours to recognize the bindings and sort everything to not get confused. First week with a mac either way, I might just get better by practice. I know that many dev, devops and average linux user find the experience pretty neat so I'll keep on trying.

  • @NickSkriabeen
    @NickSkriabeen 2 місяці тому

    been using aerospace for a few months now. it’s far better than yabai+skhd in pretty much every aspect. the only issue I have is that it starts lagging a lot when there’s a CPU hungry process. i know the author made some progress in recent release to improve the situation, but it is still there unfortunately. there are few more quirks like windows jitter if you put your mac to sleep, then disconnect an external monitor and then wake computer up, but that’s something I cal live with

  • @Keb_Le
    @Keb_Le 2 місяці тому +1

    virtual workspaces was game changing for me

    • @Keb_Le
      @Keb_Le 2 місяці тому

      appreciate the cofee analogy btw loll

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  2 місяці тому

      absolutely

  • @ZenityStudios
    @ZenityStudios Місяць тому

    commenting before watching. I tried aerospace a while ago, dont remember much didnt like something about it to replace Amethyst for me. lets see if this changes anything

  • @timhowlinson9353
    @timhowlinson9353 2 місяці тому +1

    Looks good, have added it to my future to do list. Any idea how it might function on a 2 monitor setup? Also have you considered the Apple studio display for your 1 monitor setup? Expensive but the 5k and glass screen is really nice.

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  2 місяці тому

      aerospace has an entire section dedicated for multi monitor setup but I naturally didn't try it out.
      I did consider the apple monitor but like you said - not a good value for money. got myself a 32" 4k and I'm happy

    • @NidrixGlandda
      @NidrixGlandda Місяць тому

      multimonitor is very nice as well... you can create shortcuts that move the node/window to the "next" monitor or another shortcut to move the whole space to the next monitor.

  • @karthikkaniyur
    @karthikkaniyur Місяць тому +1

    @devopstoolbox very intuitive video and walkthrough. What I noticed is that if Stage Manager is enabled on the Mac (it is very useful to me), Aerospace seems to have issues adjusting the windows. It simply fails to resize at all!. Also, if you are on Sequoia, they now provide some bare window manager features too (finally). Hence, I found Aerospace to be conflicting for the most, I ultimately decided to uninstall it. Do you have any thoughts on that?

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  Місяць тому

      1. totally agree. it has it's corners, and I found more
      2. I've recently found myself turning it 'on' and 'off' throughout the week
      While it's not as good a solution as aerospace, you can always use Raycast's awesome yet simple window managment. Not tiling by any means but can help with splitting things up on the screen

  • @ferferrara
    @ferferrara 2 місяці тому +1

    Hey, I love that level of customization, but at the same time, it leaves me wondering, what's stopping you from switching to a Linux distro? I think this is an interesting question, I do it frequently, and I would like your opinion.

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  2 місяці тому +3

      In all honesty, I love macs, I love the “safe garden” (with all its downsides). In my line of work I deal with Linux servers most of the time but never as a desktop.
      While I do want to try it out one day, it would require additional hardware (probably a ton of other settings) and yet another variable (or a bunch of them) to get used to. I have too many of these ATM

  • @enidoi
    @enidoi 2 місяці тому

    take everything you just did here and show how to use nix or ansible whatever to setup everything to make iterating setups and redeploy quickly on new setups/ resets.. bet that video would pop.
    anyways subscribed

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  2 місяці тому

      Already did :)
      Although, to be fair, I'm removing nix home manager from my dotfiles setup bc I think it creates unnecessary friction in 99% usecases

  • @martinlarsson6621
    @martinlarsson6621 2 місяці тому +1

    Been using Aerospace for a while and it’s as close to i3 I can come on Mac.
    Theres only one issue that totally bugs me. When I have a debugger attached to a program, when the program is paused, then Aerospace waits on response from it and completely hangs. When debugging I have to resort to cmd-tabbing to get the work done.

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  2 місяці тому

      Sounds like a nightmare. I also had one very rare issue, where it can't work properly with a teleprompter... try openning an issue there. they're quite responsive

  • @adudenamedruby
    @adudenamedruby Місяць тому

    Heya. Good stuff. I'm looking into sketchy bar but, I'm curious how you dealt with Aerospace working best with "Displays have separate Spaces" turned off and SketchyBar working best with "Displays have separate Spaces" turned on??

  • @muizzyranking
    @muizzyranking 2 місяці тому +1

    Watching this incase i get Mac soon.

  • @MetroKitten
    @MetroKitten 2 місяці тому +1

    I hope they will implement some more ultra wide support. Only thing that makes aerospace not workable for me. Having a 30 inch wide terminal isn’t ideal.

    • @theherk
      @theherk 2 місяці тому

      You don’t have to. You’ll can set different gap settings based on display name. So for my wide screen I just increase the side gaps.

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  2 місяці тому

      honestly, that's why I sold my ultrawide monitor. instead of contributing to my productivity it was killing it. adding a tiling manager made things worse. instead I got a nice, standard ratio 4K monitor that I love. aerospace does the rest

    • @AizazShahid-ck8cn
      @AizazShahid-ck8cn 2 місяці тому

      I have been using yabai + sketchybar with my ultra wide and it works great

  • @ZiRo815
    @ZiRo815 2 місяці тому +1

    Been using aerospace for almost a year now. I found it funny how many people were ignoring Aerospace because their favourite UA-camr was talking about the (inferior) yabai.

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  Місяць тому

      I honestly tried Yabai more than a few times. It's not as good, for many reasons.

  • @LeFlamel
    @LeFlamel 2 місяці тому +1

    I still don't see the need for any tiling more complex than a single vertical split. Otherwise I pretty much always want whatever GUI I'm looking at in full screen. Basically why tile when you can just pull up whatever GUI I want on command with Raycast?

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  2 місяці тому

      You're not wrong. but when you want stuff running side by side it's always a mess. I been doing that with yabai, then raycast, then just got a bigger screen thinking they'd be floating around. long story short, non of them worked.
      sure, when you need a single instance of anything ther's no point in tiling. but when you do want a little bit more freedom that's where I was losing.
      also, the workspace + app launcher capabilites totally got me

    • @LeFlamel
      @LeFlamel 2 місяці тому

      @devopstoolbox I run stuff side by side inside Zellij just fine (it has floating panes). But tiling for GUIs is overkill because the scaling around the core UI is usually pretty bad. And Raycast can pull up specific instances easily if the instance has dynamic naming.

  • @con_sci
    @con_sci 2 місяці тому +2

    Any idea why Yabai needs to disable SIP but Aerospace doesn't?

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  2 місяці тому

      Honestly, no. and I didn't bother asking. could be part of the reason why aerospace's dev doesn't care about getting his app approved by apple?

    • @ZiRo815
      @ZiRo815 2 місяці тому +1

      Yes, because Aerospace doesn’t use MacOS spaces. The “spaces” are virtualized through Aerospace itself, in contrast to Yabai which tries to use MacOS spaces natively.

    • @con_sci
      @con_sci Місяць тому

      @@ZiRo815 I also found out from the docs that it hides windows by moving them to the bottom corners of the monitor viewport, which sounds super hacky

    • @ZiRo815
      @ZiRo815 Місяць тому

      @@con_sci I prefer that over messing with SIP.

  • @dhrechanyi
    @dhrechanyi 2 місяці тому +1

    try Raycast for apps shortcuts management

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  2 місяці тому

      I love raycast! but alt+keystroke isn't compareable to raycast+typing the name... it's my next in line when I don't have a binding

  • @linkarzu
    @linkarzu 2 місяці тому +1

    Everyone seems to be migrating to Aerospace, but my heart is with Yabai and I specifically use it in stack mode and set my terminal transparent. Aerospace has stack mode too? Personally, I don't like tiles.

    • @quiquicuta5375
      @quiquicuta5375 2 місяці тому +1

      Yes it does. I personally use it this way too. In Aerospace the stack mode is known as "accordion", you can also modify the accordion padding to your preference, so there are no gaps between the apps of the stack. Btw, I really enjoy your content!

    • @linkarzu
      @linkarzu 2 місяці тому +1

      @@quiquicuta5375 appreciate the response!
      So it's the accordion mode shown in the video, just without paddings or gaps then, thank you!

  • @jovar7545
    @jovar7545 Місяць тому +1

    Disable stage manager to work.
    Otherwise command+n opens new stage.

  • @TheRealZitroX
    @TheRealZitroX 2 місяці тому +2

    there is no "alt" at macs
    This is a bit misleading but just a small comment from me.
    Otherwise i love your content and i will think about using it since the switching window feature from mac sucks for me and animations are slow.

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  Місяць тому

      yup you're right, I kind of pushed it with trying to be "global"

  • @traumzeit
    @traumzeit 2 місяці тому +1

    Would you mind sharing your aerospace config? Looks like it isn't on GitHub yet.

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  2 місяці тому +1

      Yes! pushed now. sorry for the delay

  • @dotintegral
    @dotintegral 2 місяці тому +1

    Huh... I don't have an idea how to bind keys. Can't use ALT + letters, as my native language requires those combos. Can't use CTRL + letters as this is what Vim/Tmux use. Can't use CMD + letters, because of all the handy shortcuts in other apps. Using Shift + Mod + letter feels like playing on a piano

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  2 місяці тому

      in this case, I'd create a mode for app launching. set the shortcut to enter the mode and send the relevant key.
      the only issue with this setup is the annoyance of having to hit the 'enter mode' shortcut everytime you need an app

  • @lowcust04
    @lowcust04 5 днів тому

    you use the MX3 mouse to, do you know any solution for the extra buttons without use the logi app? THX

  • @wthrajat
    @wthrajat 2 місяці тому

    Hey! How is your browser blurred too? Which compositor are you using for Mac?

  • @Strucs
    @Strucs 2 місяці тому +1

    Is it possible to switch between Aerospace and normal mode ? For example, I want to use Aerospace only when i need to focus

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  Місяць тому

      That's an interesting idea I've been thinking of too. Not sure but will definitely explore.

    • @brian-wood
      @brian-wood 25 днів тому +1

      I'm not sure if this is what you mean, but there is a default cmd+E option to disable it temporarily (or until you re-enable it again, basically). Then when you do re-enable it to focus, if you have predefined work areas for certain applications, it automatically shifts things back into place. Or you can straight up not have it set to auto-start and launch it when you want, then quit it when done.

  • @raykandersbreivik658
    @raykandersbreivik658 Місяць тому

    can you please make a video hwo to make sketchybar working on a nix darwin system. it seems that it's a common issue that sketchybar on nix darwin is empty wen installed and stored on the regular path

  • @lucasefe
    @lucasefe 2 місяці тому +1

    Hey. Thanks for the video. Your dotfiles are not updated, can you push your changes? Thanks!

  • @sebastianalfaro1887
    @sebastianalfaro1887 2 місяці тому

    Hey!! love this videos, i took a lot of ideas form them, wanted to ask you, which docking station are you using here 1:33 ?

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  2 місяці тому +1

      Thanks! This is the CalDigit TS3 Plus. I think they have a bigger brother now that's even better.
      Absolute beast and I love it! every single port is used and it's maxed out 😅

  • @MartinEngelke-q7l
    @MartinEngelke-q7l 2 місяці тому

    Sketchybar is the real game changer :)

  • @kubakakauko
    @kubakakauko 28 днів тому

    Is there a way to achieve a 2x2 layout with aerospace?

  • @1234minecraft5678
    @1234minecraft5678 2 місяці тому +1

    Alt + Ctrl + Shift + F, bro has a hand more than me, this is too much

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  2 місяці тому +1

      I know I'm cheating but that's what board configurations are for. I have both a superkey configured and a bunch of keys sending both alt and shift exactly for that.
      also, you can play around with it if it doesn't conflict with other shortcuts

  • @tamalchakraborty5346
    @tamalchakraborty5346 11 днів тому

    Can we just use macOS as it is?
    Never felt a day that it should have anything else other than what it comes with already?

  • @tsukinoko_kun
    @tsukinoko_kun 2 місяці тому

    The big problem with tiling window managers on Mac is that many windows have a minimum and/or maximum size. Even Discord isn't working when tiled.

  • @imbologna
    @imbologna Місяць тому

    Off-topic, but can I ask where you got your TRRS for your moonlander? I'll take an affiliate link if you have one.

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  Місяць тому +2

      there you go: Tez Cables Coiled Cable Aviator E-Series

  • @batyr1166
    @batyr1166 Місяць тому +1

    Why do you call opt key as alt?

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  Місяць тому

      Because that's how it's mapped in macos and sometimes referred to in the docs. Nothing intentional they're just the same

  • @_Altdragonson
    @_Altdragonson 2 місяці тому +1

    i was using this for a while but tell you what it becomes a hassle after a while

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  2 місяці тому

      I can definitely see why. Personal opinion - it has to some with 1. sensible (and lean) config 2. an actual motivation for running side by side apps and 3. bindings that you can get used to.

  • @mtin79
    @mtin79 2 місяці тому

    What about raycast window manager ? It comes with 100 of other tools too

    • @davidallred991
      @davidallred991 2 місяці тому +3

      aerospace is much better especially for multiple monitors, I use both together, aerospace for window management and raycast for shortcuts and tools etc.

  • @avramukk
    @avramukk 2 місяці тому

    Is it possible to configure default behaviour for new aerospace like in yabai?
    Like half of of window each times, not just vertical.
    I see that i need attach each time them, but can I do it automaticaly without alt+ hjkl?

  • @KenBanksPEng
    @KenBanksPEng 2 місяці тому +1

    Given Aerospace is not sensibly compatible with macOS Spaces, I thought it was a showstopper, since I have my yabai giving me windows management per Space (without disabling System Integrity Protection).
    I will now investigate the Aerospace / sketchybar version of spaces. Wonder if I can map the 3-finger trackpad swipes to this new space emulation.

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  2 місяці тому

      Pretty sure there’s a setting for that I’ve seen in the docs but never bothered as my Mac is in clamshell mode and I try to keep my hands on my keyboard

  • @jtrtsay
    @jtrtsay Місяць тому

    cmatrix is sooo pretty

  • @KietDev-xj2ss
    @KietDev-xj2ss 2 місяці тому

    How did you get that window border ? I can't find any line in your .config that enables it

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  2 місяці тому +1

      I cover that at the end of the video, this is jankyborders!

  • @jizhang2407
    @jizhang2407 2 місяці тому +1

    Thanks. I'm using Loop which is also quite handy.

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  2 місяці тому

      beautiful! I'm trying to avoid the mouse as much as I can but nevertheless a great option !

  • @AmeltonGsairus
    @AmeltonGsairus Місяць тому

    This is WHAT I WAS LOOKING for a years and was shocking that Apple dont provide this feature in default...as they dev on the Mars and ship they OS to Earth...

  • @sotonin
    @sotonin 2 місяці тому

    You realize you already have "spaces" individual desktops you can switch between with CTRL+LEFT and CTRL+RIGHT arrow right?
    Split screening is just silly imo. Full screen each app and switch between spaces easily with the hotkeys

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  2 місяці тому

      Of course, BUT - no indication of what's where without popping the top bar + the animation is extremely annoying.
      However, if it was only all fullscreens for me there would be no need for a tilling manager, I often need more than one app - code and docs, editing software and files, notes app and browser. Moving back and forth isn't a good way of going about things. for me at least

  • @arkix_yt4897
    @arkix_yt4897 2 місяці тому

    sorry how can you start tmux automatically every time you open new terminal window? do you attach it to last session or start it manually?

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  2 місяці тому

      I don’t have it setup although I’m assuming you could just tell the terminal to run Tmux attach on startup. I don’t find myself killing a terminal window. Almost ever

  • @vitalis
    @vitalis 2 місяці тому

    How about windows alternatives?

  • @yechielw
    @yechielw 2 місяці тому +1

    I switched from mac to nixOS and never looked back

  • @iron7956
    @iron7956 2 місяці тому +1

    How much buggy is it? I have heard that yabai was really buggy. It's one of the few things that would be keep me from switching to mac, I am to comfortable with hyprland

    • @subatomicmolecules
      @subatomicmolecules 2 місяці тому +2

      Aerospace is far less buggy because they would rather reimplement their own stuff than deal with private API's like YABAI

    • @Wubwub772
      @Wubwub772 2 місяці тому +1

      you should know aerospace hides windows in the same space instead of using multiple spaces. some apps have issue with that you'll need to test your own workflow

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  2 місяці тому

      So far, other than the odd crash here and there which I haven't really managed to debug yet, so unsure whether it's my config or something else, it's been great. everything works as expected

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  2 місяці тому

      true. photoshop is one such example

  • @owlmostdead9492
    @owlmostdead9492 2 місяці тому +2

    Auto-tiling is clearly the way to go

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  2 місяці тому

      for some for sure. it can be a nightmare if not done right and configured properly

  • @shyampadia
    @shyampadia 2 місяці тому +1

    Aerospace is so easy to use. Everyone should switch to it

  • @mirkoigumnovic6381
    @mirkoigumnovic6381 2 місяці тому +1

    Found any downsides?

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  2 місяці тому +1

      Good question! I did.
      Very rarely it would crash, not something I managed to catch or reproduce intentionally or something that bothers me enough (once a month and pretty sure it’s a setting that I managed to miss)
      Also, super specific, but I have a teleprompter that functions as a screen and they won’t play nicely together no matter the energy I invest. So I have to disable it for a few minutes every other week when making videos.
      The rest are all fixable with proper bindings.

    • @mirkoigumnovic6381
      @mirkoigumnovic6381 2 місяці тому

      @@devopstoolbox It receives pretty good reviews everywhere. And all downsides I found so far are minor and could be called nitpicking: its not as snappy as yabai (I guess this is due to rearranging window positions to simulate spaces) and those few pixels visible in the bottom right corner are triggering my OCD so much 😅 We can only dream apple would one day let us manage spaces the way linux does to get this solved in a proper way, but thats highly unlikely. Anyways a great piece of software and thumbs up for your review.

  • @HakAtIt
    @HakAtIt 2 місяці тому +1

    Ugh. This looks painful AF.
    I just moved away from Gnome, realizing it was why I was hating my linux system.
    The accordion configuration is what i think id have to do. Least this feels like im on my phone or a mobile, but if inwant to work on things in full screen, I'd just open the window full screen.

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  2 місяці тому

      it's not the full screen that appeals so much, it's the ability to have working tiles that you can set side by side, change orientation, size, and, when you need it - a workspace.

    • @HakAtIt
      @HakAtIt 2 місяці тому

      @devopstoolbox tiles are neat. I did look into it before. Windowa allows to automatically tile when you hit the edge of the screen, and most windowing DE's do now too.
      I just have realized this format isn't for me, though i appreciate that it exists.

  • @mihaiii6720
    @mihaiii6720 2 місяці тому +2

    PLEASE PUSH YOUR AEROPSACE CONFIG

  • @driden1987
    @driden1987 2 місяці тому

    NGL Omer, at this point should look into drinking mate

  • @joaopauloalbq
    @joaopauloalbq 2 місяці тому

    2:23 That looks bad, the window appears and then repositions .-.

  • @DanteMishima
    @DanteMishima 2 місяці тому +3

    How sweet.... The amount of things you have to go through for basic functionality

  • @useless274
    @useless274 2 місяці тому

    macos is fng terrible. it shocks me how people think the default mac experience is somehow good.. i like that it's closer-to-linux than windows, but the window management, file manager, big-brother enforcement.. it just sucks. i been using amethyst but i really wish aerospace had more automated layout options - especially for ultrawide monitors splitting manually is pain. i think aero also missed the idea - they should treat the 'workspaces' as tags, so they can be merged/un-merged like a real linux tiling wm..

  • @rrkumar78
    @rrkumar78 2 місяці тому

    After watching this video, I guess I’m the Starbucks coffee guy. I have no idea what any of this stuff means and wish there was just a simple GUI to make it work.

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  2 місяці тому

      There’s nothing wrong with that… on the contrary. Some of us have a tendency to make a rabbit hole out of everything 😜
      BTW, checkout github.com/MrKai77/Loop

  • @natanloterio
    @natanloterio 2 місяці тому +2

    saying that starbucks sells coffee is wild

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  2 місяці тому

      There's a limit to how offensive you can be here... don't wanna get cancelled 🤣

  • @kissu_io
    @kissu_io 2 місяці тому

    Very snobby and perfect. 💖

  • @natanloterio
    @natanloterio 2 місяці тому

    just use the apps windows maximized as a new desktop and navigate between them using Ctrl + Arrow Keys. Waaay more intuitive that this

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  2 місяці тому

      And when you need stuff side by side / floating on top like your finder / notes app? This is where things gets tricky for me. If I could do with only fullscreen and having one app at a time there would be no issue...

  • @darkkingmina4487
    @darkkingmina4487 Місяць тому

    why to do all of that when u can just use arch linux and hyde

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  Місяць тому

      So all mac users in the world should sell their macs of move to Linux :) ?

  • @brandonfoy9583
    @brandonfoy9583 Місяць тому

    What’s the real point for all this?

    • @devopstoolbox
      @devopstoolbox  Місяць тому +1

      Ahh... being able to run apps side by side, or top to bottom, and be able to pop any application with one hotkey. When I'm not using my mouse I find myself enjoying work = getting into flow + removing friction.