Tier1 + Tier2 / RWA * 100 = 900% 18:18 Email Draft R/sir, It is to bring to your kind notice that the Question Paper of Paper No. 3 - Advanced Auditing & Professional Ethics of CA-Final Exams November, 2024 contains 1(One) ambiguous Multiple choice questions and answers. The detail of the same is as follows; Question Paper Booklet Code - FBA1 Question Paper Booklet No. XXXXXXX Under the Part-I (MCQ) of Paper No. 3 - Advanced Auditing & Professional Ethics Integrated Case Scenario-II - related to 'XYZ & Associate LLP' MCQ Q.No. 5 - 'Arrive at Correct % of CRAR' Any of the Answers to question No. 5 asked on the basis of case study given in the question paper are not correct. Please verify and do the needful. The relevant screen shot of the question is attached for your reference. -- Thanks & Regards
Sir, the comments by the students reflect the amount of faith lost on ICAI. I just came across this video and was devastated during attempting these questions. Its peculiar how mistake in question papers cost student his efforts and disheartens him by deferring him by 6 months. I sometimes believe that CA Exams are more luck based and less on merit.
Respected sir, You are 100 percent right and i am with you sir And i had appeared for nov 2024 and In AFM PAPER Q2B IS ABSOLUTELY WRONG CAPITAL BUDGETING AT LEAST THEY HAVE TO PROVIDE 8MARKS grace for and for 5A ALSO 6 MARKS
I dont think any marks will be given. Or maximum 4 marks. This questions were purposely made unsolvable to control results. Last time g1 ka result around 27% tha. Usko control krne k liye is attempt mei jyada tough and purposefully wrong questions daale the in afm. Aabhi agle attempt mei afm ka easy aayega paper
@AceYourCA I shall hope so sir. But it is unlikely. It is past trend of institute to frame ambiguous or incomplete questions in following attempt to control results after giving more results in previous attempts.
Bhaiyo sbhi mail kro icai ko mene b krdiya h jb ye log may 23 ca inter ko 13 marks ka grace diya h to hme b milnega plss jyada se jyada mail kro jinhone nov 24 exam diye hai
As per ajay Agarwal you should not hope from icai to give Grace marks in nov 23 also in fr paper icai made mistake of around 12 marks but give only grace marks of 2 mrks
sir, i have exemptions in FR and SFM , iam hardly getting 10 marks in audit mcq, and written descriptive well, but dont know how icai evaluates descriptive, icai grace marks deke 40 kar sakta h kya if i score around 35
In case of general grace marks will be provided to all students. In other case, marks will be provided to those students who try to attempt the wrong questions
Do we need to mail this to ICAI ? We won't get grace marks if we don't mail them ? If the question is incorrect, shouldnt all of us who attempted that question get grace marks irrespective of whether we mail them or not ?
Icai on Nov 5 announced to give feedback on exam papers if there is any mistakes , we should mail them , based on the our responses, icai estimate the severity of the errors and allote general bonus to everyone if there is any mistake ...
As forex wala question galat thha aisa bola jaa raha hai...soo if forex wala question na solve karte hue...baki subparts kiye ho toh grace milege? E.g.Q4(a) Forex - not solved Q4(b) and Q4(c) solved
Sir what if I attempted all 6 questions but my whole one question is wrong which is done in 5th or 4th place but question done in 6th place is correct! How will they consider my 5 attempted questions??? Kindly reply🔴🔴
16mrk ke qs mai question wrong This is absolutely shambolic Already challenging papers mai questions galat matlab kaidho na. Baat 16 mrks ki nhi hai ,baat hai woh 16mrks impacting your entire paper CAs hate CA aspirants
Sir, if i have attended the question 2b of afm but i haven't completed it, irrespective of whether I know the remaining or not, would they provide Grace marks. 1more doubt sir, would they note down my sro and will it further affect the valuation of my paper adversely
@AceYourCA I just watched P S beniwal sir's MCQ discussion. One lease MCQ was not right The one you are thinking which was there in mtp 2 may 24 was drafted differently
Sir FR mei 2 mcq wrong hai Ek Current liability jismein picha hai wo Aur ek joint operation wala jismein provision mtp mei bolte 100 cr bnao but wo prov 40 cr contingent 60 cr hona chahie toh institute ko bolna hai ki sahi ans likh kr check krein wo
Sir, maine Q.2(a) attempt Kiya tha solve karne ke liye, but incomplete info ki wajah se half hi solve kar paaya. Toh kya muje full grace marks milega yeh question ke liye??
Tier1 + Tier2 / RWA * 100 = 900% 18:18
Email Draft
R/sir,
It is to bring to your kind notice that the Question Paper of Paper No. 3 - Advanced Auditing & Professional Ethics of CA-Final Exams November, 2024 contains 1(One) ambiguous Multiple choice questions and answers. The detail of the same is as follows;
Question Paper Booklet Code - FBA1
Question Paper Booklet No. XXXXXXX
Under the Part-I (MCQ) of Paper No. 3 - Advanced Auditing & Professional Ethics
Integrated Case Scenario-II - related to 'XYZ & Associate LLP'
MCQ Q.No. 5 - 'Arrive at Correct % of CRAR'
Any of the Answers to question No. 5 asked on the basis of case study given in the question paper are not correct.
Please verify and do the needful.
The relevant screen shot of the question is attached for your reference.
--
Thanks & Regards
kindly share the format of mail
Shared in the telegram grouo and in pinned comment also
Please give format for AFM exam also
Sir, the comments by the students reflect the amount of faith lost on ICAI. I just came across this video and was devastated during attempting these questions. Its peculiar how mistake in question papers cost student his efforts and disheartens him by deferring him by 6 months. I sometimes believe that CA Exams are more luck based and less on merit.
You r right..but we have to survive in these conditions..
Respected sir,
You are 100 percent right and i am with you sir
And i had appeared for nov 2024 and
In AFM PAPER Q2B IS ABSOLUTELY WRONG CAPITAL BUDGETING AT LEAST THEY HAVE TO PROVIDE 8MARKS grace for and for 5A ALSO 6 MARKS
Mail to icai
Individually mail karna hoga?@@AceYourCA
But mail write up format, would you like to provide?
I dont think any marks will be given. Or maximum 4 marks.
This questions were purposely made unsolvable to control results.
Last time g1 ka result around 27% tha. Usko control krne k liye is attempt mei jyada tough and purposefully wrong questions daale the in afm.
Aabhi agle attempt mei afm ka easy aayega paper
Kam se kam 10 marks in afm and 2 marks in audit...
Audit mai each mark is crucial, I have fkd the descriptive.
Muskil seh 15-20 expect karrha
@@kaibaing4288Same bro! Even I fd up in description even for easy question
@AceYourCA I shall hope so sir. But it is unlikely.
It is past trend of institute to frame ambiguous or incomplete questions in following attempt to control results after giving more results in previous attempts.
Bhaiyo sbhi mail kro icai ko mene b krdiya h jb ye log may 23 ca inter ko 13 marks ka grace diya h to hme b milnega plss jyada se jyada mail kro jinhone nov 24 exam diye hai
As per my opinion
Fr 2 marks
Afm 4 to 6 marks
Audit 2 marks
Jiska bhi self evaluation me 142 and above aa rha hai wo mostly pass ho jna chahiye
@@saurabhkumarshukla9677 let's see on 26th dec
As per ajay Agarwal you should not hope from icai to give Grace marks in nov 23 also in fr paper icai made mistake of around 12 marks but give only grace marks of 2 mrks
We can hope..baki decision to icai ko hi lena hai
Aby aisa kbi ni hoga institute grace de
sir, i have exemptions in FR and SFM , iam hardly getting 10 marks in audit mcq, and written descriptive well, but dont know how icai evaluates descriptive, icai grace marks deke 40 kar sakta h kya if i score around 35
Yes..specific grace of around 3 marks may be given
@@pallavidoddi4637 bhai hadd hai yar aise golden opportunity kaun miss krta hai
Tier1 + Tier2 / RWA * 100 = 900%
Whether in fr we get grace marks for fr ambiguity
Sir.. Question no nai likha.. Only page choda blank after 2a question.. Will they give grace marks?
In case of general grace marks will be provided to all students. In other case, marks will be provided to those students who try to attempt the wrong questions
Sabko milega attempt wala kuch rule nhi@@AceYourCA
Afm ma 40 grace marks to alll 🎉🎉🎉🎉
Nice joke
Sirf Que no 2(b) likha he and paper blank chor diya he matlab attempt nahi kiya tab bhi grace milenge kya? Same done for 5(a) also
2b likhna is sufficient
@@AceYourCA Thank you sir. I hope ICAI grace marks de
Do we need to mail this to ICAI ? We won't get grace marks if we don't mail them ? If the question is incorrect, shouldnt all of us who attempted that question get grace marks irrespective of whether we mail them or not ?
Icai on Nov 5 announced to give feedback on exam papers if there is any mistakes , we should mail them , based on the our responses, icai estimate the severity of the errors and allote general bonus to everyone if there is any mistake ...
Mail is important
Any chance for idt grace marks 2 to 3 to 4
Sir any chance of getting grace marks in FR as well??kya lagta hai aapko personally🔴🔴
Less chances..
With all due respect, in MCQ 11 of Z. Ltd - I think its common sense and asking them about "PV of what" sounds silly.
You may be right. But we should send email. Let ICAI decide
Sir Maine solve Krne k koshish kri but bad main cross Krdiya to grace marks mileage ??
Depends
As forex wala question galat thha aisa bola jaa raha hai...soo if forex wala question na solve karte hue...baki subparts kiye ho toh grace milege?
E.g.Q4(a) Forex - not solved
Q4(b) and Q4(c) solved
Forex vala question galat nhi tha mere question bank same question tha
Last forex nahi.... International Cap Budge..
Might be..but i think institute will not admit this question as wrong..
Sir what if I attempted all 6 questions but my whole one question is wrong which is done in 5th or 4th place but question done in 6th place is correct! How will they consider my 5 attempted questions??? Kindly reply🔴🔴
Maximum marks wala question will be considered
Maximum 5-8 marks milege dont expect more than that
Ha wahi 6-7 in AFM and 3-4 in audit utna to ICAI deta hai paper tough aata hai
Y u r so negative bro..at least 10 marks will be given as grace in afm..
16mrk ke qs mai question wrong
This is absolutely shambolic
Already challenging papers mai questions galat matlab kaidho na.
Baat 16 mrks ki nhi hai ,baat hai woh 16mrks impacting your entire paper
CAs hate CA aspirants
I also think so..but we need to fight.
So mail to icai.
Sir, if i have attended the question 2b of afm but i haven't completed it, irrespective of whether I know the remaining or not, would they provide Grace marks.
1more doubt sir, would they note down my sro and will it further affect the valuation of my paper adversely
Grace marks will be provided.
Noting down of SRO is a myth..
@@AceYourCAThank you for the reply sir
Sir i not attempted qn 2b
Will i get 8 marks in Afm???
Less chances
Icai bass fail karega
Assumption bolega lene ko
Nhi aisa nhi hai bro
Sir i attempted 2a ,5b but didn't attempted wrong questions 2b,5a , will i get grace marks ?
In case of general grace. Everyone will get marks.
Otherwise less chances in your case
quetion no.nhi dala to marks nahi milenge kya
In case of specific grace..nhi milenge
Is mail to icai is compulsory to get grace marks??. Or generally they give grace marks?
Not compulsory but recommended
DT IDT me kitne question wrong the
DT, IDT, IBS, FR paper. Will analyse and upload a video on sunday
Fr me ek MCQ wrong hai
Uske bhi 2 mark
I don't think so..
@AceYourCA I just watched P S beniwal sir's MCQ discussion.
One lease MCQ was not right
The one you are thinking which was there in mtp 2 may 24 was drafted differently
Sir suppose maine AFM ka vo question attempt karne ke liye blank page chora & end me strike kar diya , to kya milega marks uska ??
If you had tried to solve that question half, and then left blank space for remaining part, then you might get grace.
Every student gets the grace marks if there's any error in question
Yes
Bhai ye mail kyu karna padega, ye funda clear nahi ho rha
Read icai notification, i have shared in my telegram channel
Praveen Jindal voice lagrhi!
But i am not praveen sir
Last may 24 m bhi afm m 2 msqs galat thy koi grace marks mile thy kisi ko.
Haan..4 marks grace mila sabhi ko..isiliye students ke 30 out of 30. Marks aayae
Sabko nhi mile thy even audit m bhi nhi
I hope is baar mile
@@aayushikajain5389 should i leave ca i m in found if yes then wht i should do
No. Pls don't leave ca.
I will make a seperate video for all who are stuck in ca since a long time
Please give me format for AFM exam to email
Find out pinned comment or in my telegram channel. Make changes accodingly.
Thankqq so much, Sir audit k liye to aap bhi kr lo
Already send email..screenshot shared in my telegram channel.
@AceYourCA thankqq so much
1 1 subject ka alag alag mail karu ya sabka saath?
Sabka ek sath bhi kar sakte ho
Sir ese to mene 2 question chod diya pura or dusra attempt kiya
Fir to sir ese to injustice ho jaega na
Disc rate nhi de rakhi thi isikaran mene choda vo pura question
To fir milege kya marks ?
Less chances in case of specific grace
@@AceYourCAspecific grace kuch nhi
Sir FR mei 2 mcq wrong hai
Ek Current liability jismein picha hai wo
Aur ek joint operation wala jismein provision mtp mei bolte 100 cr bnao but wo prov 40 cr contingent 60 cr hona chahie toh institute ko bolna hai ki sahi ans likh kr check krein wo
Ye 2no mcq correct hain
@ teachers air 1 tk wrong bolre plz confirm it once before saying
Sir man lo 2a kia hai but 2b kia he nahi to grace milega???
General grace mein sabko marks milenge, but specific grace mein..sirf attempt karne wale ko hi marks milenge
@AceYourCA attempt means ek question ka dusra part kia hai to pahla part attempt me aaega ya nahi aega
Ye puch ra hu sir
Fr me bhi ek mcq wrong hai
Which one?
@AceYourCA lease payment calculate krne wala option tha 140000, 840000 ...
i did not attempt any of the wrong question..will i get grace?
If general grace will be provided than you will get 10 marks. O/w less chances
sir please reply for this sir...
Already replied above.
No
No
Sir I have mailed but after 20th due to some issues, I have attempted to 2 and 5 will I get the grace marks
After 20 mail not considered..but high chances of getting grace marks..because thousands of emails has been sent to icai..so..hope for the best.
Sir mail sabke liye compulsory hai kya krna
Bonus toh sabko milega na
Jo mail kre yaa ni kre??
Jitne jyada emails..utne jyada chances of grace..
Sir, maine Q.2(a) attempt Kiya tha solve karne ke liye, but incomplete info ki wajah se half hi solve kar paaya. Toh kya muje full grace marks milega yeh question ke liye??
Full marks will be awarded to u
AFM Me 16 Marks to Nhi milege
4-5 hi dega Kmsekm
Kam se kam 10 marks.
@AceYourCA 2b Me kahega Assume kar lo Discount rate , To kaphi km chance hai Ki 10+ dega Grace . 4-5 bs dega
Agar phley question attempt kiya or baad mein kaat diya ?? To grace marks milenge ....?
Depends..
Can u share message to email
Bro..thoda mehnat to kro..mene telegram group me screen shot send kiya hai..pls. check
Whether in fr we get grace marks for fr ambiguity
Depend upon icai. But gr8 chances of grace..atleast 2 marks