Equality of Opportunity vs equality of Outcome

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 30 вер 2024
  • Analyses and explain the political concept of Equality, its different dimensions, equality of opportunity and equality of outcome. It also explains equality of resources given by Ronald Dworkin. Also analyses past year’s university exam questions on this topic.
    Part of exam help guide videos for undergraduate course - BA Hons - in Political science.
    The author is masters from London School of Economics and Political Science and academic enthusiasts.

КОМЕНТАРІ • 79

  • @VladimirputinRuss
    @VladimirputinRuss 3 роки тому +24

    It's a gem channel ,I am from engineering background,I took psir as optional bought all books spent 12 hours a day to understand the sub finally I understood a bit ,later on found this channel will be using this channel to the maximum ❤❤❤❤🇮🇳🇮🇳

    • @POLSCHELP
      @POLSCHELP  3 роки тому +1

      welcome...all d best...

  • @deepsikha02
    @deepsikha02 2 роки тому +1

    Sir, Is formal equality is equality of opportunity?
    And , substantive equality is same as equality of outcome?

  • @sunnyhindustani4234
    @sunnyhindustani4234 7 місяців тому +1

    thanku sir

  • @sunnyhindustani4234
    @sunnyhindustani4234 Рік тому +1

    thanku sir

  • @colorfunwithbuddies
    @colorfunwithbuddies 2 роки тому +2

    Thank you so much sir for the easy explanation of these complex concepts.
    Really very helpful for all political science students ❤

  • @TanyaKumari-m5x
    @TanyaKumari-m5x 9 місяців тому +1

    Sir your explanation is hard to understand. You use really hard language and sometimes even it’s not clear
    Please improve 🥱🙏

  • @learnwithmyself8715
    @learnwithmyself8715 2 роки тому +2

    Sir thanks for you ,very interesting and fully understandable

  • @juhi4101
    @juhi4101 Рік тому +1

    thank you so much sir....your explanation is at par😃😇

  • @testmail783e
    @testmail783e 4 роки тому +3

    Sir, you are super. Country needs peoples like you.

    • @POLSCHELP
      @POLSCHELP  4 роки тому

      thanks for nice words...matters...

    • @nikita9346
      @nikita9346 Рік тому +1

      @@POLSCHELP sir please make video for DU M. A first sem students hmare exam April first week se start please do something it's humble request

  • @akashyadav6835
    @akashyadav6835 Рік тому

    Caste reservation falls under which equality, opportunity or outcome?

  • @abhishekanshuwali3808
    @abhishekanshuwali3808 4 роки тому +2

    Sir, How does equality of opportunity undermines social solidarity and fraternity?

    • @POLSCHELP
      @POLSCHELP  4 роки тому

      inequality creates class cleavages(gap), feeling of deprivation, having been treated unfairly...all this undermine social capital, solidarity and fraternity

    • @abhishekanshuwali3808
      @abhishekanshuwali3808 4 роки тому

      @@POLSCHELP Got it Sir Thank you very much for the video.

    • @POLSCHELP
      @POLSCHELP  4 роки тому

      well, u hv picked up right point. equality of opportunity is formal equality which merely allow every individual equal opportunity to compete fairly...it believes in individual autonomy...individualism (unlike equality of outcome which is communitarian )...hence it undermines social solidarity...only if u consider formal equality of opportunity...NOT substantive...which is almost same as equality of outcome...if u feel more confused...no fault of yours...

    • @abhishekanshuwali3808
      @abhishekanshuwali3808 4 роки тому +1

      @@POLSCHELP No Sir I got it.
      Thanks for replying.

  • @Kaushikfamily7809
    @Kaushikfamily7809 3 роки тому +2

    Sir u explain each topic in very clear and simply manner thnks a lot👍❤️

  • @pranabmahapatra8111
    @pranabmahapatra8111 4 роки тому +1

    Thank you sir I'm read TDC 2nd year so entarested

  • @ishajaiswal5016
    @ishajaiswal5016 4 роки тому +2

    Sir how does equality of opportunity allow economic inequality?

    • @POLSCHELP
      @POLSCHELP  4 роки тому

      Formal equality of opportunity is negative equality...means State/Govt provide equal chance to everyone to win race of life...to acquire property... it does not intervene to make the outcome equal...so who will hv more? those who r well off to begin with...so rich will become richer, poor poorer...

    • @ishajaiswal5016
      @ishajaiswal5016 4 роки тому

      @POL SC HELP thank you sir, got it.

  • @MissPriya-zp8ky
    @MissPriya-zp8ky 2 роки тому +1

    Done!👍
    Political entrance exam.

  • @Dancerpinki
    @Dancerpinki 2 роки тому +1

    Tq so much sir..just waiting for ur video sir..its help a lot ..

  • @NetranandaNaik-qm2px
    @NetranandaNaik-qm2px 5 місяців тому

    Love from odisha 🙏

  • @akashpandey7774
    @akashpandey7774 3 роки тому +2

    Mind-blowing voice sir

  • @magraj-jakharjnu
    @magraj-jakharjnu Рік тому +1

    Thank you

  • @raghavdeepika1720
    @raghavdeepika1720 2 роки тому +1

    Thank you so much sir for posting these videos. These are so well explained and helpful for me. Thank you 😇

  • @Pranita2000
    @Pranita2000 4 роки тому +1

    Sir starting me aap kahte h inequality in nature, men, society, and later Hobbs ki heading me likha h equally among men in nature ?
    I didn't get the point ...
    Kindly explain...

    • @POLSCHELP
      @POLSCHELP  4 роки тому

      In view of Hobbs, on natural ability all men/women are almost equal, some may have stronger physically, others stronger mentally, in totality they are almost equal. But what I said is socio-economic inequality...men have unequal resources/properties even in state of nature...Hobbs said insatiable desire of power and resources lead to war of all against all in the state of nature

    • @Pranita2000
      @Pranita2000 4 роки тому

      @polscihelp sir thank you ...

  • @yashasvi_8
    @yashasvi_8 6 місяців тому

    thank you 😊

  • @ishikatyagi9632
    @ishikatyagi9632 3 роки тому +1

    Sir the way you teach is just marvellous 👍 I really thank you for putting so much efforts I would be really grateful if you make videos for 2nd year political science honours

    • @POLSCHELP
      @POLSCHELP  3 роки тому

      thanks; all videos of 2nd year pol sc is already uploaded ... just search them across the channel..

  • @Aa-zg3fc
    @Aa-zg3fc 2 роки тому +1

    Thank you sit

  • @theman-hattan4243
    @theman-hattan4243 5 років тому +2

    Thank you for your great work Sir

    • @POLSCHELP
      @POLSCHELP  5 років тому

      thanks...keep watching...

  • @poojakashyap6598
    @poojakashyap6598 5 років тому +1

    Thank you sir for this video

  • @akriti_bangtan7245
    @akriti_bangtan7245 4 роки тому +1

    Sir I have a query as u said state have less involvement in equality of opportunity & it is meaningless for poor people. how it can be possible ? coz state is the one who helps those lower class or poor background people to overcome from their situation by giving them resources in order to equalize them along with rich ones so that they both can start their race from same point don't u think in this way state is having interfarence ? Also it is kinda different from the formal equality (who believes in only equality before law but it doesn't go in depth) unlike equality of opportunity.

    • @POLSCHELP
      @POLSCHELP  4 роки тому +1

      u hv raised good points...need elaboration...may come back to explain...

    • @akriti_bangtan7245
      @akriti_bangtan7245 4 роки тому

      @@POLSCHELP sure sir 💜🙏

    • @POLSCHELP
      @POLSCHELP  4 роки тому +2

      ok...there I was talking about formal equality of opportunity...in a sense negative equality...means No interference from the State ...opposite is equality of Outcome- positive equality, where State needs to intervene to provide free education, medical care, income transfers other social welfare. And yes, formal or negative equality (State not interfering or not discriminating on the basis on caste/creed/religion/sex, etc) is meaningless for poor for they are not capable to compete on equal footing with those who are privileged.
      However, this is not so simple. Equality of opportunity is a continuum...from formal to substantive...latter is much closer to equality of outcome. For having substantive equality of opportunity, State need to intervene and those are not meaningless to poor. Hope it makes sense...

    • @akriti_bangtan7245
      @akriti_bangtan7245 4 роки тому

      @@POLSCHELP ok sir tysm for clearing my doubts 💜🙏

  • @juhi4101
    @juhi4101 Рік тому

    even after paying hefty amount ....we aspirants dont get such clarity ......heartfelt gratitude sir !!

  • @VladimirputinRuss
    @VladimirputinRuss 3 роки тому +1

    Thank you sir useful for my optional

  • @Unna624
    @Unna624 4 роки тому

    Can you make a video on VALUE OF EQUALITY BY BERNARD WILLIAMS ( DU MA pol.sci 1 year topic)

  • @manisha_sayings
    @manisha_sayings 2 роки тому

    Thank you sir for the wonderful explanation.😇

  • @powerofmind777
    @powerofmind777 2 роки тому

    Sir I want to know your name pleas

  • @k.y8622
    @k.y8622 2 роки тому +1

    Sir kya aapka telegram pe bhi grouph

    • @POLSCHELP
      @POLSCHELP  2 роки тому

      yes...to join mail at dupolschelp2018@gmail.com

  • @abhinavchandra361
    @abhinavchandra361 5 років тому +1

    thanku sir

  • @आदित्य-फ4प
    @आदित्य-फ4प 3 роки тому +1

    Thankyou so much Sir.

  • @akashpandey7774
    @akashpandey7774 3 роки тому +1

    Wow sir please keep it up

  • @GarimaSingh-iu3ms
    @GarimaSingh-iu3ms 2 роки тому

    Each nd everything is fine but i request you to increase your content so that we have resources nd content to write in exam.

    • @POLSCHELP
      @POLSCHELP  2 роки тому

      this medium has its limitation...videos cannot be too long...

  • @ankitpandey7539
    @ankitpandey7539 Рік тому

    Thank You sir❤

  • @tarunsingh2756
    @tarunsingh2756 2 роки тому

    Bhai thodi sound thik krle

  • @kaptaan_97
    @kaptaan_97 4 роки тому

    Thank you, Sir!

  • @aasthasingh7450
    @aasthasingh7450 2 роки тому

    From where we can get notes

    • @POLSCHELP
      @POLSCHELP  2 роки тому

      polschelp.myinstamojo.com/

  • @kajalbaaniya9643
    @kajalbaaniya9643 5 років тому +1

    Good

  • @charliebrownau
    @charliebrownau 5 років тому +1

    Funny how we NEVER hear about 50/50 discriminating quotas for:-
    * Garbo
    * Sewage workers
    * Mowing lawns
    * Landscaping
    * Plumbers
    * Electricians
    * Snake catchers
    * Night Petrol station attendant
    * Construction
    * Mining
    * road crews
    * IT/PC repair
    * Power pole repair
    #equality

    • @POLSCHELP
      @POLSCHELP  5 років тому

      because quota (affirmative action) is demanded for the jobs or ''primary goods'' linked to social recognition, self-dignity, and political power such as government jobs(bureaucracy), Legislature, and higher education. thanks and good wishes;