@Frank Herrera I'm always fascinated with a lot of these things. Yet when the Beatles broke up Paul went on to write total rubbish after a short time and John would roll out greats. Around the time he was already going forward artistically by going retro rock n roll while Paul was all Mull of Kintyre
@@ggoldfingers Are you serious? Quit that antiquated thinking and and actually give his music an unbiased listen. Paul was on fire after he left the Beatles. His first album McCartney had some excellent songs on it like Maybe I'm Amazed, Every Night, and Junk. He did everything himself and it influenced a lot of DIY musicians and lo-fi styles. Then you've got RAM which was critically trashed at the time, but is now universally praised by critics. RAM is even thought of by many as an early indie pop album and that would explain one of the reasons why the critics didn't like it at the time. Whatever the critics thought, people loved it then and love it even more now. Then you've got Band on the Run which was so good that even the usual McCartney bashers couldn't bash it. Then if you fast forward in time, Paul did Flaming Pie and Chaos and Creation which are thought of as two of his best albums. With all this information, you can see that Paul has been making amazing music his whole life and hasn't stopped.
The level of genius in Lennon's and McCartney's compositions (and pieces like "Martha" are compositions, not just songs) still blows my mind to this day! The rhythmic, chord structure and melodic complexities of this and other great songs, and the shear beauty of all those elements working together as they do still leaves me speechless when I hear again, 50 years later! Props to George Harrison too. Good job by these two kids.
I feel the same way. I'm old enough to remember when they were just a news item on a Pittsburgh rock and roll station. A few months later they appeared on the Ed Sullivan Show and took the world by storm. Even my father, a former country musician, found them impressive. Fifty-six years later they're still my favorite band, not because of nostalgia -- I love modern R&R as well -- but because they were so damned good. Every time I listen to "Abbey Road" I'm stunned by the writing, the musicianship, the vocal harmonies and the sheer beauty of their work.
@Frank Herrera Yes, I am well aware that later in their career Lennon and McCartney wrote separately, and anyone familiar with their work can easily distinguish one from the other. I only refer to the Lennon-McCartney song writing partnership under which all of their material with the Beatles is published regardless of which ever one actually wrote a particular song.
@Frank Herrera Paul once said in an interview that, as a teen, he aspired to write stuff like Cole Porter's and Gershwin's tunes. Great American Songbook. I think he could have done it, and he almost did it with "Martha." Also, "Here, There, and Everywhere," and "Yesterday." Granny tunes? Gimme more granny tunes!
I totally agree, you guys did a nice job, I see a lot of requests here for Rocky Raccoon and you would sound great on that, I expect bur I want to request "In My Life"; the banjo would sound very good on that harpsichord lead.
@@SimonFrack YES!!! Growing up in the late 70s, early 80s, It was very UN-COOL to like any music more than 5 years old. If your parents liked it, then was verboten. I had a friend who also liked the Beatles, but we kept it a secret.
I have to say I think this is the best cover I have ever heard in my life.....and absolutely warms my heart that a younger generation is keeping these songs that I hold dear to my heart alive and well.... Thank you thank you guys !!
I'm 78 +++ and these two young guys amaze me ! They are so very fortunate they have this talent to bring an old song back to life and keep the unique Beatle sound alive . Carry on gentlemen ! I envy the fun you are having together !
I've been a Beatles fan since December of '63 and I've heard tons of Lennon-McCartney covers over all these years. This is truly one of the all-time most enjoyable. You guys play really well and I *love* your voices. Subscribed!
You guys don't realize what joy you bring to those of us in the grey work a day world marching steadily to our deaths...you bring Color and beauty makes life just a bit sweet...thank you
Josh: When those of us that grew up with this music heard it fresh out of the wrapper, we were amazed. I feel no less amazed by this great re-arrangement. We were also told, by our elders, that this music was just a fad that would wither & die quickly. Thanks to you both for helping to keep these treasures alive, and for helping to prove my elders wrong.
Josh I've been following your musical journey and progress for several years now and you always deliver something to make me smile and feel uplifted. While i enjoy all of your collaborations the chemistry you and Carson share is obvious to see, and invariably produces fantastic results. Carson has a great vocal sound and both of you clearly love the process of making great music. Thank you for many hours of enjoyment and long may you continue to shine . . .
I am absolutely charmed by this version, country twang suits this tune and I'm sure Macca would approve. A toe-tapper to be sure. Nice work Carson, and Josh -- superb!
i can't decide what's more impressive; the musical performance or the amount of facial expressions the dude on the right makes throughout the entire video. that is a performance in and of itself.
Whenever I hear a cover like this I celebrate both the players and the song. Such a simple ditty by McCartney, but ooooh so clever. Well done guys, loved it.
From a old man to wet behind the ears young kids. AWESOME JOB !! Seriously in a world where everything is faked its awesome to see authenticity people no longer connect to music because its not authentic keep it real AWESOME JOB
This seventy plus bohemian dude appreciates your musicianship and your choices of music to cover many thanks. I’m an old circus clown living in the beautiful Pacific Northwest
Also, "Hide Your Love" ... oh oh "Night Before" .... oh heck, any Beatles song you guys do would be a tremendous treat and a honor to the Beatles heritage.
Amazing - Piano line played on the Banjo...! As a Beatles nut, this really gets the spirit of the original and reminds you how great anybody who can play this, this well, is... so simple, so complex, so subtle...!
I just found out today that this song, written by Sir Paul, was written about his dog. So cool. And so well performed by the Other Favorites. Hats off fellas, you've done it again.
Just some info for the song since I've read that many people here haven't heard the song before. Maybe you already know that but this song was written by McCartny for his dog called Martha.
You guys are absolutely incredible, and your faces look so casual in the last few seconds after the song ends; as if you've been doing this your whole life. If I pulled off something that sounded anywhere near as good, I'd be cheesin ear to ear
Martha My Dear Martha my dear, Though I spend my days in conversation, please Remember me, Martha my love Don't forget me, Martha my dear. Hold your head up, you silly girl Look what you've done. When you find yourself in the thick of it, Help yourself to a bit of what is all around you, Silly girl. Take a good look around you Take a good look and you're bound to see That you and me were meant to be For each other, silly girl. Hold your hand out, you silly girl. See what you've done When you find yourself in the thick of it, Help yourself to bit of what is all around you, Silly girl. Martha my dear, You have always been my inspiration, please Be good to me, Martha my love Don't forget me, Martha my dear
Great rendition. Loved how you traded off on the vocals. Also, loved how the banjo covered the tube part. Very good! But the best part is that you guys just seemed to be having fun. Now that's music!
Great cover ... listening to it makes me think about how great The Beatles were ... this was just a short little album track... Exceeds most people's hits.
A beautiful rendition of the song that stopped the epic battle between Batman and Superman. Very touching! Truly you are the Clark and Bruce of your generation.
One of the best Martha covers I've heard from just two simple singers with their instruments, (no slight intended lads) and certainly one of Macca's more difficult songs! Great effort.....more please!
Never heard this song before, so had no clue, no biases. When Josh was singing, I thought, "is this a McCartney tune?" He sounded so much like Maca. Reading the comments, I learned that my impression was correct. So, congratulations to me for being aware enough to catch that one, and congratulations to Josh and Carson for doing an incredible job once again.... four years ago.
I am absolutely addicted to this song 🎶. The rhythm of it and I can’t sit still. I play it over again and again. A day or two later if I think 🤔 of this song 🎶 I have to quit what I’m doing and listen to it again. Fortunately I have it on utube channel on my phone. 😊😊😊😊😊
Boy! This guy is a genius. So good to hear a combination of a guitar and a banjo. Hope you guys have a chance to come to Japan and play your fantastic music. Hyper well done. Thanks from Hiroshima.
Incredible! However, by law, a cover version of "Martha My Dear" must immediately segue into a cover of "I'm So Tired".
It did, in my head...I can hear it now...
Jurgo's right you know... It's US code 17942.6.3.04a " Martha has to be followed by I'm so tired".
it's automatic ...can't help it
No no no
It's on the bible!
Here, we can see what would happen in an alternate universe where John and Paul grew up in Louisiana instead of Liverpool
@Frank Herrera I'm always fascinated with a lot of these things.
Yet when the Beatles broke up Paul went on to write total rubbish after a short time and John would roll out greats.
Around the time he was already going forward artistically by going retro rock n roll while Paul was all Mull of Kintyre
@@ggoldfingers McCartney wrote rubbish and Lennon greats?🤣🤣 good one mate
@@ggoldfingers I'm aware it's a matter of opinion, but I would argue that Paul was putting out strong material after the Beatles, just like John.
And in 50 years this video will surface in the anthology retrospective of their career.
@@ggoldfingers Are you serious? Quit that antiquated thinking and and actually give his music an unbiased listen. Paul was on fire after he left the Beatles. His first album McCartney had some excellent songs on it like Maybe I'm Amazed, Every Night, and Junk. He did everything himself and it influenced a lot of DIY musicians and lo-fi styles. Then you've got RAM which was critically trashed at the time, but is now universally praised by critics. RAM is even thought of by many as an early indie pop album and that would explain one of the reasons why the critics didn't like it at the time. Whatever the critics thought, people loved it then and love it even more now. Then you've got Band on the Run which was so good that even the usual McCartney bashers couldn't bash it. Then if you fast forward in time, Paul did Flaming Pie and Chaos and Creation which are thought of as two of his best albums. With all this information, you can see that Paul has been making amazing music his whole life and hasn't stopped.
The level of genius in Lennon's and McCartney's compositions (and pieces like "Martha" are compositions, not just songs) still blows my mind to this day! The rhythmic, chord structure and melodic complexities of this and other great songs, and the shear beauty of all those elements working together as they do still leaves me speechless when I hear again, 50 years later! Props to George Harrison too. Good job by these two kids.
I feel the same way. I'm old enough to remember when they were just a news item on a Pittsburgh rock and roll station. A few months later they appeared on the Ed Sullivan Show and took the world by storm. Even my father, a former country musician, found them impressive. Fifty-six years later they're still my favorite band, not because of nostalgia -- I love modern R&R as well -- but because they were so damned good. Every time I listen to "Abbey Road" I'm stunned by the writing, the musicianship, the vocal harmonies and the sheer beauty of their work.
Martha my dear was composed only by McCartney
@Frank Herrera Yes, I am well aware that later in their career Lennon and McCartney wrote separately, and anyone familiar with their work can easily distinguish one from the other. I only refer to the Lennon-McCartney song writing partnership under which all of their material with the Beatles is published regardless of which ever one actually wrote a particular song.
@Frank Herrera Paul once said in an interview that, as a teen, he aspired to write stuff like Cole Porter's and Gershwin's tunes. Great American Songbook. I think he could have done it, and he almost did it with "Martha." Also, "Here, There, and Everywhere," and "Yesterday." Granny tunes? Gimme more granny tunes!
I do a wicked McCarthy ..and I'm an older woman ( I meant McCartney... So dumb)
That’s the best argument I’ve ever heard for learning to play a musical instrument.
I keep coming back to rewatch this awesome rendition and it's a shame I can only hit the like button once.
I'm an old musician, not easily impressed. This was one of the more enjoyable performances I've experienced in some time.
I totally agree, you guys did a nice job, I see a lot of requests here for Rocky Raccoon and you would sound great on that, I expect bur I want to request "In My Life"; the banjo would sound very good on that harpsichord lead.
I also agree. It is very well done. Good work guys. Congratulations!
I agree! I'm also a not so young musician. You did a really nice job, boys!
me too :)
Alex Lynch Visit Foxes & Fossils to be further impressed...🎸
A great cover even without a battery cover :)
Nice one Peter,
they are enterprising young men: product placement.
+Peter Draws I laughed too hard at this :P
It is garanteed to put a smile on your face, when there is a comment by one of your favourite UA-camrs on a random video you stumbled across.
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
When you find Peter in the comment section of a Beatles cover video . And now you know Peter likes The Beatles . 😂 I can die happy now .
When I was 13 in 1980, I predicted that future generations would love the Beatles without ridicule from their peers.
Were people in the 80s mocked for liking the Beatles?
Considered a big old hat or something?
@@SimonFrack YES!!! Growing up in the late 70s, early 80s, It was very UN-COOL to like any music more than 5 years old. If your parents liked it, then was verboten. I had a friend who also liked the Beatles, but we kept it a secret.
@@KenPotter Makes sense I guess.
I guess the Beatles have always been liked, but ideas of “coolness” vary over time.
Josh does a great Paul McCartney. How about Rocky Racoon?
+fawcems I second this !
Yes. Rocky RaccooooOOOOOooooooooooooon. Raccoon. Do it. Please, gents.
that would be awesome!!
Or Honey Pieeeeeeee
Well I've got great news for you ;)
These youngsters know good music from before they were born and play it well
Tears come to your eyes when you hear these two guys, so young interpreting such a beautiful song from almost 50 years ago, very very good.
Almost? I'm afraid it's been 55 years now. Awesome cover, agreed.
I have to say I think this is the best cover I have ever heard in my life.....and absolutely warms my heart that a younger generation is keeping these songs that I hold dear to my heart alive and well.... Thank you thank you guys !!
I'm 78 +++ and these two young guys amaze me ! They are so very fortunate they have this talent to bring an old song back to life and keep the unique Beatle sound alive . Carry on gentlemen ! I envy the fun you are having together !
I've been a Beatles fan since December of '63 and I've heard tons of Lennon-McCartney covers over all these years. This is truly one of the all-time most enjoyable. You guys play really well and I *love* your voices. Subscribed!
I thought Slade did a very unusual cover of this but this is something else.
SMiLE!!!!!!
Oh what a night;)
The vocals caught my ear, also. I hate people who sing well. 'cause I cannot! LOL
Martha my dear don't forget me? More like... Murph my dear don't leave me
Dude more Beatles!! This is sick. You should do more of the White Album, it's so simple but so genius.
+IHaveACoolName Couldn't agree more.
+IHaveACoolName more Beatles
More beatles!!!!!!!
More Beatles!!
Cry Baby Cry!
THIS IS GORGEOUS! Seriously - I'm a person picky about Beatles covers and don't always like them. This is perfection. Thanks!
You guys don't realize what joy you bring to those of us in the grey work a day world marching steadily to our deaths...you bring Color and beauty makes life just a bit sweet...thank you
It makes my heart happy to know that McCartney and Lennon live on 50 years later.
Also my favorite cover of this McCartney gem.
I keep coming back to this song because I think it's one of the best collaborations of these guys. Love the banjo in there.
Everything you two do when you get together is amazing. Make an album together so I can pay for it.
Tyndan The Other Favorites do have an album. It's on iTunes.
EarToTheGroundMusi
Can’t stop grinning with delight
These two talented young men - I still have faith in the future. Respect and admiration.
永遠に受け継がれてく、本当にありがとう素晴らしいです
1:23 When she says she doesn't like bluegrass
Whaddya mean ?
1:19
Dumbass fucked his commebt
Brian Kelly I think they meant the face he makes at 1:23 but they could’ve meant him saying “silly girl” just before that
Maxwell Edison No he didn’t; look at Carsons face at 1:23. Looks like you’re dumbass
A classic Beatles tune beautifully interpreted and played. I keep coming back to this again and again.
lennon and McCartney would approve. as always great stuff
patrick jaroch Not sure if you knew but this was mostly paul with george on guitar that’s it no john
They should send Sir Paul a clip. I wouldn't be surprised if he replied with a thumbs up.
for sure bro ; )
@@wizardpig02 It was all Paul on this song. He played everything
Nah, John hated Paul’s weird granny songs or pretty songs. Ironic, because this is easily one of the best Beatles songs.
Josh: When those of us that grew up with this music heard it fresh out of the wrapper, we were amazed.
I feel no less amazed by this great re-arrangement.
We were also told, by our elders, that this music was just a fad that would wither & die quickly.
Thanks to you both for helping to keep these treasures alive, and for helping to prove my elders wrong.
Josh I've been following your musical journey and progress for several years now and you always deliver something to make me smile and feel uplifted. While i enjoy all of your collaborations the chemistry you and Carson share is obvious to see, and invariably produces fantastic results. Carson has a great vocal sound and both of you clearly love the process of making great music. Thank you for many hours of enjoyment and long may you continue to shine . . .
you have no idea of the JOY this little vid brought to me 👌
I am absolutely charmed by this version, country twang suits this tune and I'm sure Macca would approve. A toe-tapper to be sure. Nice work Carson, and Josh -- superb!
Love to see the younger generations digging The Beatles compositions! Well done!
The faces Carson makes are great
Weyoun VI ikr😂😂
Your recording helped me through a tough time, losing my mom Martha. Thank you. She enjoyed hearing your recording over dinner while in hospice.
i can't decide what's more impressive; the musical performance or the amount of facial expressions the dude on the right makes throughout the entire video. that is a performance in and of itself.
Whenever I hear a cover like this I celebrate both the players and the song. Such a simple ditty by McCartney, but ooooh so clever. Well done guys, loved it.
From a old man to wet behind the ears young kids.
AWESOME JOB !!
Seriously in a world where everything is faked its awesome to see authenticity
people no longer connect to music because its not authentic
keep it real
AWESOME JOB
This seventy plus bohemian dude appreciates your musicianship and your choices of music to cover many thanks. I’m an old circus clown living in the beautiful Pacific Northwest
please do a ive just seen a face josh
That would be awesome!
oh yeah, would love to hear that. they would kill it!
y m good idea
Also, "Hide Your Love" ... oh oh "Night Before" .... oh heck, any Beatles song you guys do would be a tremendous treat and a honor to the Beatles heritage.
I've been watching this video for some years now. This performance is amazing.
My day is made when I stumble across a video like this on UA-cam. Brilliantly done.
this is my favorite cover of anything ever
One of my favorites... I'm just blown away.
Bravo 👏 c'est une.de.mes.chansons.préférées des Beatles
j'ai 55 ans et j'adore vous écouter la chanter ❤
I don't have enough adjectives, but you guys are all the good ones. Re-opened my eyes to the genius of Paul again. Thanks!
Beautifull song, beautifully covered. Very well done young men !
Stunning audio matching as well! It FEELS like it was recorded in 1967.
From a 67 year old from Los Aneles in the 50's and 60's, EXCELLENT job, Boys !!
Amazing - Piano line played on the Banjo...! As a Beatles nut, this really gets the spirit of the original and reminds you how great anybody who can play this, this well, is... so simple, so complex, so subtle...!
Just simply beautiful.
Oh yes. Totally enjoying this performance! I love seeing young people playing this wonderful music, especially the talented people like you two..
My very favorite song! Thanks from México!!!!!!
I just found out today that this song, written by Sir Paul, was written about his dog. So cool. And so well performed by the Other Favorites. Hats off fellas, you've done it again.
Just some info for the song since I've read that many people here haven't heard the song before. Maybe you already know that but this song was written by McCartny for his dog called Martha.
You guys are absolutely incredible, and your faces look so casual in the last few seconds after the song ends; as if you've been doing this your whole life. If I pulled off something that sounded anywhere near as good, I'd be cheesin ear to ear
incredible...how Pauil's piano part just replaced by banyo n guitar...but still perfect..amazing...👍❤
Best cover of MARTHA MY DEAR to be sure!!!
One of the most difficult Beatles tunes to pull off, and you all did it well. Congratulations! :) :)
So amazing!!! One my favorite Beatles tunes !!!
Hey Josh, what's going on, you totally mastered every tiny bit of the guitar there is and now you are working on mastering the Banjo?
These two are absolutely adorkable!
Great covers like this only make me appreciate the Beatles even more. WELL done.
Thank you for letting me finally like that song, after 30 yrs!
What a great and unique rendition of this pretty little song written by Paul McCartney!
Thank you for this bright spot in these dark days.
Oh these guys and girls are just completely insanely ridiculously and mindbogglingly fantastic. The work they put into this stuff is crazy. Lovin it.
Truly Great! Really Amazing. So well done ... LOVED this.
Hats off please. My respects. Well done!!!
the perfection doesn't exis..... wow lovit guys
This is amazing! Such a great cover of one of my favorite Beatles song!!!!
I wasn’t expecting that! The perfect bounce that the song really requires. Salute to you guys!
well lads bloody fantastic , difficult song to cover , really well done .
Amazing lads. One of my favorite Beatles songs.
This is one of my favourite Beatles songs and, my goodness, did you ever do it justice! Love it!
I really liked this song. Thank you very much for posting. Have happy days forever!
Martha My Dear
Martha my dear,
Though I spend my days in conversation, please
Remember me,
Martha my love
Don't forget me,
Martha my dear.
Hold your head up, you silly girl Look what you've done.
When you find yourself in the thick of it,
Help yourself to a bit of what is all around you,
Silly girl.
Take a good look around you
Take a good look and you're bound to see
That you and me were meant to be
For each other, silly girl.
Hold your hand out, you silly girl.
See what you've done
When you find yourself in the thick of it,
Help yourself to bit of what is all around you,
Silly girl.
Martha my dear,
You have always been my inspiration, please
Be good to me,
Martha my love
Don't forget me,
Martha my dear
Martha was Paul McCartney's Old English Sheep Dog, memorialized forever by this little ditty. Great job guys!
Great rendition. Loved how you traded off on the vocals. Also, loved how the banjo covered the tube part. Very good! But the best part is that you guys just seemed to be having fun. Now that's music!
Isn’t that a great little song? So many quirks and subtleties! And wow, does it lend itself to the 5-string banjo. Stellar work, guys!
Great cover ... listening to it makes me think about how great The Beatles were ... this was just a short little album track... Exceeds most people's hits.
Perfect! If only I could write a love song like that to my dog
So sweet. Some say it was a combination of writing about his dog and a woman he was dating. Perhaps Paul will shed some light on that one day.
wow, never cease to amaze me. Masterful
And PLEASE cover more Beatles
How can I miss this one? Very enjoyable.
OMG! I love this!!
Yeah the Beatles are too good
@@bobthegreatreee3185 Jm
Yu
Well done a good and faithful version of this classic from my youth. Good on both of you.
Very very nice! That song is such a great example of the diverse genres the boys produced over their relatively short career as a band.
Wow!!! Just...wow!!! This was amazing!! 👏👏👏👏 Definitely wanna hear more Beatles covers in this fashion. Maxwells Silver Hammer would be perfect. 😁
Cover more Beatle classics guys you do a great job and it sounds good.
A beautiful rendition of the song that stopped the epic battle between Batman and Superman. Very touching!
Truly you are the Clark and Bruce of your generation.
One of the best Martha covers I've heard from just two simple singers with their instruments, (no slight intended lads) and certainly one of Macca's more difficult songs! Great effort.....more please!
Yes, this is a spectacular cover
The best covers on all of youtube and brilliant song. Always been a favourite
Never heard this song before, so had no clue, no biases. When Josh was singing, I thought, "is this a McCartney tune?" He sounded so much like Maca.
Reading the comments, I learned that my impression was correct. So, congratulations to me for being aware enough to catch that one, and congratulations to Josh and Carson for doing an incredible job once again.... four years ago.
Gentlemen, thanks for making this available to your viewers!
I can understand you being hesitant about covering a Beatles song.....but you nailed it!
I am absolutely addicted to this song 🎶. The rhythm of it and I can’t sit still. I play it over again and again. A day or two later if I think 🤔 of this song 🎶 I have to quit what I’m doing and listen to it again. Fortunately I have it on utube channel on my phone. 😊😊😊😊😊
Fantastic job!!! Very mature sound, man, you guys are on to something big!
Your Beatles covers are OUT OF THIS WORLD!!!!......
After 5 years, this is still so incredible. Im in awe. Fantastic work, absolutely fantastic
You two are amazing! Thanks for that ray of sunshine.
This is just a gorgeous interpretation of this fantastic song!
Boy! This guy is a genius. So good to hear a combination of a guitar and a banjo. Hope you guys have a chance to come to Japan and play your fantastic music. Hyper well done. Thanks from Hiroshima.