Spies of War - The D-Day Spies | Full Documentary

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 7 чер 2024
  • June 6th, 1944: nearly 130,000 Allied soldiers storm Normandy's beaches, initiating the liberation of France from the Nazis. Behind the scenes of this major event of WWII, British MI-5’s double agents contributed to the largest deception campaign of the war. Their mission: to trick the Germans into thinking that the Allies would land elsewhere to keep German troops out of Normandy. In this episode of “Spies of War”, relive this extraordinary mission contributing immensely to the success of D-Day.
    The Soldier who Never Was: • Spies of War - The Sol...
    --
    Welcome to the official Get.factual youtube channel! 🌍
    We are a documentary streaming channel covering history, science, technology, and nature. Explore worlds distant, forgotten, and unknown; from the depths of ocean trenches to the far reaches of the cosmos.
    New uploads of full-length documentaries and docu-series every week!
    Subscribe here: bit.ly/GetfactualSUB
  • Розваги

КОМЕНТАРІ • 222

  • @Peirithous
    @Peirithous 9 місяців тому +8

    I will forever be in awe of the GREATEST GENERATION for as long as I live …so much gratitude ❤❤❤🌹🕊

    • @Davidfooterman
      @Davidfooterman 7 місяців тому

      What nationalities and ethnicities are you allowing into that fabled group??

    • @Peirithous
      @Peirithous 7 місяців тому +2

      @@Davidfooterman not the nazzzzis that’s for sure👿👿

    • @Davidfooterman
      @Davidfooterman 7 місяців тому

      @@Peirithous I gotta ask you: who is this GG? Is it the enduring of hardship during the Depression and WW2, or the witnessing of and participation in those events that defines this group? Either way, Americans are the least accurately described this way because, it could be argued, we suffered and participated less than our European cousins and, dare we admit it, could also have been the nation possibly more responsible for the whole debacle than any other single participant, (setting aside the Nazis who were not and are not a sovereign nation).

  • @micheley2140
    @micheley2140 Рік тому +7

    There is so much suspense why isn’t this a movie?

  • @Anglo_Saxon1
    @Anglo_Saxon1 9 місяців тому +8

    To think of 8,000 warships all together and part of the same operation is absolutely mind blowing!

    • @colindebourg9012
      @colindebourg9012 8 місяців тому +1

      My late Father was a merchant seaman, and on D Day he was on a troopship called the Empire Farmer, so great was the naval bombardment that Mum said when he came back he was deaf and shook for a week.

    • @Anglo_Saxon1
      @Anglo_Saxon1 8 місяців тому

      @@colindebourg9012 Yeah,my Grandad was a R.N gunner in a D.E.M.S team(defensively equipped merchant ship).I was a bit too young to have been able to speak to him about the war though.👍

    • @colindebourg9012
      @colindebourg9012 8 місяців тому

      @@Anglo_Saxon1 I think we don't realise just how young these heroes were, my Dad went to sea in 1940 aged 18, endured the Arctic convoys to Russia, North Atlantic convoys to America and many other trips including being torpedoed in the Indian Ocean aboard the Dorrington Court, he must have been terrified.

  • @moobaz8675
    @moobaz8675 Рік тому +28

    Brilliant. The amazing thing is that by today's standards they did it for the right reasons and not money. We could learn a lot from their actions and behaviour.

  • @r.menzel8020
    @r.menzel8020 Рік тому +14

    Fascinating documentary.

    • @voraciousreader3341
      @voraciousreader3341 Рік тому

      There are errors, the most egregious of which is totally omitting *OPERATION MINCEMEAT,* a British plant of disinformation (using a dead body) which is probably the most convincing ruse which resulted in Hitler’s absolute refusal to send help to Normandy….one of a handful of fatal misjudgments. Look it up in Wikipedia where there’s an excellent article. There’s also an excellent documentary just about this operation on the Timeline channel.

  • @doonewatts7155
    @doonewatts7155 Рік тому +4

    Fascinating to learn about the unbelievably incredible of the stories behind the stories behind the story. Superb thank you

  • @thisisreallife5086
    @thisisreallife5086 Рік тому +5

    Amazing. Incredible story, well told.

  • @sonaterese799
    @sonaterese799 Рік тому +3

    Brilliant and amazing - thank you

  • @waceyseufer7083
    @waceyseufer7083 Рік тому +6

    That was absolutely amazing 👏 one of the best docs I've seen in a long time!!!!! 👏

    • @nancywages7029
      @nancywages7029 Рік тому

      You might enjoy operation Fortitude. Feeding misinformation to the Germans. Many put their lives on the line and others died. We owe them everything

  • @mehdidjeebet4614
    @mehdidjeebet4614 6 місяців тому +1

    Absolutely fantastic documentary!!!

  • @etiennenobel5028
    @etiennenobel5028 Рік тому +7

    Great stuff!

  • @padraiggluck2980
    @padraiggluck2980 Рік тому +3

    A great documentary. ⭐️

  • @robertdelacruz2951
    @robertdelacruz2951 9 місяців тому +1

    Epic! Great documentary!

  • @trampertravels
    @trampertravels 9 місяців тому +4

    'Brutus' is buried in the Polish Cemetery in Newark-on-Trent, Nottinghamshire, England.

  • @doreekaplan2589
    @doreekaplan2589 9 місяців тому +1

    Excellent! Thanksalot

  • @henryjohnfacey8213
    @henryjohnfacey8213 Рік тому +15

    I have great respect for Nigel West and Max Hastings. My Father, Mother, Uncles, and Aunts, millions unknown and known, tacking part in what has been described here. A nice sampler to a fascinating subject and brave individuals.

  • @sonaterese799
    @sonaterese799 Рік тому +6

    The use of micro dots and invisible ink put digital technology into the shade (where it belongs) - absolutely love this type of video, thank you

  • @elenivargis126
    @elenivargis126 Рік тому +5

    Just awesome!

  • @kmac4124
    @kmac4124 Рік тому +3

    truly fascinating !!!! i love a happy ending .

  • @treatpage
    @treatpage Рік тому +14

    They are the heroes forever without them we wouldn’t have been enjoying freedom that we take for granted. Thank you for all those known all unknown individuals who played significant roles on winning the war and made the world a better place for humanity. Imagine what if the German and Japan have won the ww2. I’m sure many of us would have been gone instinct and there were dictators all over the world.

    • @brycecolwell4304
      @brycecolwell4304 9 місяців тому +3

      Indeed.ask any true war hero and without fail their answer is uniform:the true heroes never came home ...

  • @hongchang9370
    @hongchang9370 Рік тому +3

    Spies, outright fascinated. I admire the men and women, right up to this very day. A agent is awesome, but a double agent WOW. Thanks Bearhunter5

    • @michael-4k4000
      @michael-4k4000 Рік тому

      Lol there are NO women spies u silly goose..... now go eat a cucumber 🥒 sandwich 🥪

  • @briansanderson480
    @briansanderson480 6 місяців тому +2

    As far as I know their were no Australian New zeland people involved in DDay except some in the RAF. Australia was committed to fighting the Japanese .

  • @fionathomson4436
    @fionathomson4436 Рік тому

    Very interesting 👌

  • @golfhound
    @golfhound Рік тому +6

    There is a wonderful mini-series called "Reilly Ace of Spies" which is a true story about the greatest British spy in UK's history spanning from the 1890's during the Russian-Japanese War until Stalin took office in Russia. It is starring Sam Neill as Reilly plus a whole large group of British actors everyone will recognize from Masterpiece Theater. It's in ten episode and to this day probably the most intense exiting spy thriller made. This was long before the fantasy James Bond etc. and well worth everyone's time to watch. Sam Neill was brilliant incredible. Reilly was so successful that he turned the tides of history time and again to UK's favor.

  • @jkhan4969
    @jkhan4969 Рік тому +6

    Love it. Please upload more documentaries based on Egyptian Empire

    • @jorgecruzseda7551
      @jorgecruzseda7551 Рік тому

      From Ramsses, Tut or Ptolemys time???

    • @jkhan4969
      @jkhan4969 Рік тому

      @@jorgecruzseda7551 Yes absolutely ❤️

  • @andypandy9013
    @andypandy9013 Рік тому +7

    I think that a line from the TV series Secrets Of War, narrated by Charlton Heston, really summed it up:
    "In World War Two no one, but no one, did espionage better than the British".

    • @jackietreehorn5561
      @jackietreehorn5561 11 місяців тому +4

      True....the one they done with the doppelganger Nazi floating off the coast was genius

    • @richardcaves3601
      @richardcaves3601 9 місяців тому +4

      There's a fairly accurate statement made after the war that goes: This war was won by Russian blood, American brawn and British brains

    • @andypandy9013
      @andypandy9013 9 місяців тому

      @@jackietreehorn5561
      I think you mean the fake Royal Marines Major in Operation Mincemeat.
      ua-cam.com/video/bh2e6sE6YXA/v-deo.html

    • @andypandy9013
      @andypandy9013 9 місяців тому

      @@richardcaves3601
      I like that phrase very much indeed. Thank you. 🙂

    • @jackietreehorn5561
      @jackietreehorn5561 9 місяців тому

      @@richardcaves3601 and all three kidnapped German scientists when it ended just to start the cold war...German physicists obviously had more brains than all three lol....true though

  • @tombergins8215
    @tombergins8215 Рік тому +4

    Jebsen & Pujol were partners, they planned their entry into Abver & MI6 in order to destroy the Nazis on their own.
    These 2 guys were true SUPER HEROES as were the rest.

  • @johnkidd1226
    @johnkidd1226 9 місяців тому +3

    Canadians after Italy were seen as shock troops so reporting on their embarkation for Pas de Calais while Americans were staying in England was an important part of the deception that the first attack was a diversion at Normandy.

  • @johnpolhamus9041
    @johnpolhamus9041 6 місяців тому +1

    There is a lost reel of film that was taken by a Marine color-movie photographer dropped behind the German lines the night of the 4th, and concealed in a spot overlooking Omaha beach from the south. He asked what he was to photograph and was told, "You'll know when you see it." His reels have disappeared into the archives and have not surfaced.

  • @edward6902
    @edward6902 8 місяців тому +1

    2:10 there was a Polish Division on Juno Beach with the Canadian 1st Army

  • @michaelcampin1464
    @michaelcampin1464 Рік тому +43

    What about not only the Canadians but also.the Australians and New Zealanders and all the Commonwealth troops too. You forgot the South Africans etc etc.

    • @robertyou9030
      @robertyou9030 Рік тому +10

      There is many Nations what taken part in D-day and as a British citizen I can I say thank you very much we hold great depth to these Nations

    • @gordonspicer
      @gordonspicer Рік тому +12

      Whilst not disagreeing with you I have never read any Australian or NZ formations arriving on D Day beaches on June 6 or even in the months thereafter. However, the was a 100 French Commando unit which did and the Polish armoured division (which finally opened the Failaise gap !) arrived shortly thereafter. The Free French division arrived in Normandy from Algeria in July 1944 I believe and were "allowed" to help in the liberation of Paris.

    • @philodonoghue3062
      @philodonoghue3062 Рік тому +3

      American lacuna - the “rest of the world” ( or actually the world except America - which is the real “American exceptionalism” not its flawed “democracy”.

    • @chrissmit6439
      @chrissmit6439 Рік тому

      South Africa fought with Brittain for Brittain against the Nazis less than 50 years after Brittain went full throttle to wipe us out completely by burning farms, killing each and every farm animal and killing defenseless women and children in concentration camps throughout South Africa. However when Germany started kicking their behinds they were quick to come begging for the lives of those very same people to help them defending their island. No hard feelings. Just an eyeopener to see the bully hiding behind the bullied when the chips are down for them. It does not mean they were defenseless, just scared when they faced the devil. No one was allowed by them to came to our aid whilst they were rampaging through our country. They callled that strategy, Scorched Earth. What it was, was the slaughtering of unarmed women and children by starvation for one. They would execute children in front of the mothers and siblings to force them to inform on Boer positions.

    • @nancywages7029
      @nancywages7029 Рік тому +4

      Yes they were there too and we can thank them as well.

  • @ianprince1698
    @ianprince1698 6 місяців тому +1

    during the war, my dad in the Royal Navy was issued H M S cap tallies instead of the ship's name as normal

  • @goodwood-rc4nx
    @goodwood-rc4nx Рік тому +4

    the author Ben MacIntyre has written a wonderful book about this subject, well worth a read/listen

  • @cjones3702
    @cjones3702 Рік тому +12

    The music is TOO much.

  • @e-curb
    @e-curb Рік тому +2

    Next you can do a video about Agent Zig-Zag. The UK's triple agent!

    • @gavinlepoer9424
      @gavinlepoer9424 Рік тому

      You mean zig-zag-zug

    • @e-curb
      @e-curb Рік тому

      @@gavinlepoer9424 No, his code name was Agent Zigzag. Eddie Chapman.

  • @gordonspicer
    @gordonspicer Рік тому +8

    frankly, although a super documentary, it must be said there are lot's of books on this subject published for some years now and all the key subjects are pretty well known

    • @brettcurtis5710
      @brettcurtis5710 Рік тому +7

      Juan Pujol - Garbo - has been known about since at least the 1980s! As was Dusko Popov - Tricycle - but many especially not WW2 fans, will never have heard of them.

    • @kixigvak
      @kixigvak Рік тому +3

      New information on the war surfaces all the time.

    • @Grimenoughtomaketherobotcry
      @Grimenoughtomaketherobotcry Рік тому +3

      The British government still has many WWII files that remain classified.

    • @whatiswrongwithwhatihadwankers
      @whatiswrongwithwhatihadwankers Рік тому +2

      Whilst I agree with you I don't know anyone under 25 who even knows what ww2 was. A video game possibly

    • @nancywages7029
      @nancywages7029 Рік тому +1

      ​@@whatiswrongwithwhatihadwankers lol. Do they even know who George Washington was?

  • @hongchang9370
    @hongchang9370 Рік тому +3

    I like the guy says treasure is a difficult women. (Aren’t they all). Lol😊. I will admit,as Marco and tough I was back in the day. I would so terrified of getting caught.being beaten,mentally and physically. Thanks Bearhunter5

    • @michael-4k4000
      @michael-4k4000 Рік тому

      "Aren't they all"? So all women are difficult? What a piece of work u are..... #respectallwomen

    • @denissolomon855
      @denissolomon855 Рік тому

      Red October

    • @denissolomon855
      @denissolomon855 Рік тому

      The Hunt For Red October

    • @FigaroHey
      @FigaroHey Рік тому

      Your comment actually makes no sense whatsoever. Write in your native language, maybe.

  • @AbdulRahim40881
    @AbdulRahim40881 Рік тому +3

    1st view 1st Like and 1st comment

    • @mjc11a
      @mjc11a Рік тому +4

      BFD.

    • @desertodavid
      @desertodavid Рік тому

      @AbdulRaman, so what's your comment? Eediot

  • @nickdanger3802
    @nickdanger3802 Рік тому +3

    JAPAN'S UNWITTING D-DAY SPY By Charles Fenyvesi May 26, 1998 Washingtom Post
    Japan's wartime ambassador to Berlin, a great admirer of Hitler, unwittingly supplied the United States with a methodical accounting of German defenses along the Atlantic coast in the critical months leading to the Allied invasion at Normandy, newly released documents show.
    For instance, after a four-day tour of the Third Reich's Atlantic fortifications in November 1943, he accounted for every German division's location, manpower and weaponry. He accurately described tank ditches as "built in a triangular cross section with a span across the top of 5 meters and a depth of 3.5 meters." He wrote about turrets "built in a continuous line, close to the shore," each equipped with two or three machine guns as well as grenade launchers.

    • @richardcaves3601
      @richardcaves3601 9 місяців тому

      Which of course was read by ultra

    • @nickdanger3802
      @nickdanger3802 9 місяців тому +1

      @@richardcaves3601 The SIS built its first machine that could decrypt Purple messages in late 1940. A second Purple analog was built by the SIS for the US Navy. A third was sent to England in January 1941 on HMS King George V, which had brought Ambassador Halifax to the U.S. That Purple analog was accompanied by a team of four American cryptologists, two Army, two Navy, who received information on British successes against German ciphers in exchange. This machine was subsequently sent to Singapore, and after Japanese moves south through Malaya, on to India. A fourth Purple analog was sent to the Philippines and a fifth was kept by the SIS. A sixth, originally intended for Hawaii, was sent to England for use there.[3]: p.23

  • @Davidfooterman
    @Davidfooterman 8 місяців тому +2

    I knew the son of a personally powerful woman spy of WWII. He was, himself, quite a formidable fellow: extremely intelligent and charismatic, but his mother was a powerful person in his mind, so much so, in fact, that I don’t recall much about his father even though he was a handsome and imposing figure in his own right. This was a superwoman with a very unusually powerful persona. Oh, and she was gorgeous as well; the ‘housemaster’ who lived at and oversaw the house I boarded at (there were about 10 or so houses, averaging perhaps 70 boarders per house, that made up the school of approximately 750 students aged between 13 and 18. Oh, by the way, my school was named ‘Rugby’ and it doesn’t take a rocket scientist to figure out what we invented!

    • @DURRHURR
      @DURRHURR 7 місяців тому

      You invented methamphetamine?

    • @malcolmscrivener8750
      @malcolmscrivener8750 6 місяців тому

      No of course not . Everyone knows Hitlers chemists invented it .
      The rugger boys just perfected it !

  • @fernandocortes1187
    @fernandocortes1187 8 місяців тому +1

    45:40 month and a half after Normandy invasion

  • @noneyobiz1988
    @noneyobiz1988 Рік тому

    Double Agent Tricycle looks like Reinhard Heydrich

  • @Davidfooterman
    @Davidfooterman 8 місяців тому +2

    Oops, I lost my direction there …. Our housemaster openly showed his infatuation with her, which would have been an embarrassment, had he not been surrounded by similarly motivated men, and women, on the staff. I don’t know if she had a professional career; she might, I think, have been a writer and political commentator.

  • @davidcook5858
    @davidcook5858 Рік тому

    Read the book, "Double Cross" by Ben MacIntyre.

  • @rammlady6225
    @rammlady6225 Рік тому

    Interesting programme indeed, but the music is to high and irritatating!!!😖

  • @tronghungdao251
    @tronghungdao251 Рік тому

    ❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉

  • @akunokaori
    @akunokaori Рік тому +1

    Films are a flashy activity, but in reality it is a steady activity to collect and organize information. Leading figures who do not appear on the stage.

    • @voraciousreader3341
      @voraciousreader3341 Рік тому +1

      Such as *Operation Mincemeat,* an incredibly subtle British ruse which was just as important as Patton’s “army” and the double agents which isn’t even _mentioned!!_ I won’t be watching anymore videos produced by this company!

  • @chrisvickers7928
    @chrisvickers7928 Рік тому +1

    Pujol Garcia was so successful he was awarded an MBE and an Iron Cross 2nd class. I think that's a one of.

    • @Grimenoughtomaketherobotcry
      @Grimenoughtomaketherobotcry Рік тому +2

      Read up on Eddie Chapman, then.

    • @chrisvickers7928
      @chrisvickers7928 Рік тому +1

      @@Grimenoughtomaketherobotcry Interesting character. The Germans gave him an Iron Cross but the British seem to have given him money and a pardon for his criminal record but, alas, no MBE.

    • @gordonspicer
      @gordonspicer Рік тому +2

      @@chrisvickers7928 question his class & background in those days. Now they are "two a penny" and let's notvraise the question of knighthoods !

    • @FigaroHey
      @FigaroHey Рік тому +1

      A one of WHAT?

    • @chaletlouladou5418
      @chaletlouladou5418 6 місяців тому

      Dusko was similarly awarded an OBE and Iron Cross.

  • @denislalande7407
    @denislalande7407 Рік тому

    Comment avoir les commentaires en français

  • @michaelcampin1464
    @michaelcampin1464 Рік тому +2

    WWII is not over Andorra is stillat war with Germany as they were not included in the surrender documents.

    • @richardcaves3601
      @richardcaves3601 9 місяців тому

      Not so, they signed after the reunification of Germany in 1991

  • @carolecarr5210
    @carolecarr5210 9 місяців тому +1

    Considering English, Great Britain's history, wicked, this was their finest hour. The English showed their core true selves by voting their greatest leader out of office before the end of the war. Churchill did not deserve their ingratitude.

    • @Davidfooterman
      @Davidfooterman 7 місяців тому

      Insulin is a miracle for many diabetics, BUT they don’t take a stat dose if their blood sugar is down to normal.

    • @sandydennylives1392
      @sandydennylives1392 16 днів тому

      He was going to keep the country back in the 30's; no NHS, no council houses, and robber Baron's still in charge of transport and industry. When the safeguards were in place by Atlee, he was voted back in.

  • @CharlieJoe42
    @CharlieJoe42 10 місяців тому +1

    My comment would be why did it take so long for us (i.e., The US) to realize that the agents of the GPU whom were posing as American Citizens entered into the USA after outfitting themselves at Macy's in Toronto & Ontario. Then just walking through both Canadian and U.S. Customs as if they were returning home from a vacation.
    Oops!

  • @southernsmoke8391
    @southernsmoke8391 Рік тому +4

    Do one on the unreported contributions of the Red Tails & frontline melanated soldiers.

  • @Bigwave2003
    @Bigwave2003 Рік тому +3

    The repetitive background music is so ANNOYING!

  • @jimmycrosby
    @jimmycrosby Рік тому +1

    Not sure about Max Hastings assertion about German Panther and Tiger Tanks being superior to anything the allies had. I would counter with The Pershing and The Sherman Firefly, both of which could more than hold their own against the Germans.
    Also, what defines superiority; is it the ability to produce small numbers of arguably technically superior vehicles, or is it the ability to produce thousands of standard models of an allegedly lesser technical specification. I don't believe some of the mythology that has been spun around the German army and its equipment of WW2. The allies of that period consisted of men of the highest quality across all areas.

    • @richardcaves3601
      @richardcaves3601 9 місяців тому

      You are quite right. The much touted superiority of German tanks was neutralised by overwhelming numbers, of both Sherman's and T35s. Nazi obsession with bigger and better tanks actually caused their defeat, because effort was diffused, parts weren't interchangeable, and just like the jet fighters, there was too little fuel

  • @Brian1Graves
    @Brian1Graves Рік тому +7

    That is incorrect. They did not "change" the course of history. That WAS the course of history, To change that...one would need a time machine. Using the phrase is so silly.

    • @FigaroHey
      @FigaroHey Рік тому +1

      'Shaped the course of history' is the phrase the editor probably should have given them. Oh, right: we don't seem to have editors anymore, do we?

    • @Brian1Graves
      @Brian1Graves Рік тому

      @@FigaroHey 👍 Got that right. That would have been a better phrase.

    • @ruthstiefler2792
      @ruthstiefler2792 9 місяців тому

  • @Davidfooterman
    @Davidfooterman 8 місяців тому

    Hitler had a sour-looking, troubled-soul of a face. His quiet spoken voice, however, sounds very powerful. This was probably a major factor in his influence of senior military and political figures, without whose unreserved cooperation, to the point of complete and utter self-subordination, he could not possibly have harnessed the power of Germany to wage war for his specific purposes. This sole, unassisted power of an individual is no longer enough, although unfortunately the versatility and efficiency of modern communications technology provide much of that necessary assistance before the cooperation of close political associates is even tapped. So, the power of an individual is technologically magnified; and that is also, therefore, the soft point of weakness at which the attack on a bad actor must be concentrated. We know and are equipped with the know-how to neutralize bad actors; we only need the will to do so!

  • @JamesPowell-jc4mo
    @JamesPowell-jc4mo 10 місяців тому

    We paid for lend lease, did the French pay reparations, it was their country we fraught for. Again.

  • @chrisdorrington9209
    @chrisdorrington9209 Рік тому +6

    What about Operation Mincemeat

    • @williamyalen6167
      @williamyalen6167 Рік тому

      Chris Dorrington, Yes, totally agree that Operation Mincemeat was a brilliant and effective Allied pre-invasion deception - but for the 1943 invasion of Sicily, not 1944 D-Day at Normandy.

    • @e-curb
      @e-curb Рік тому +6

      Unrelated to the D-Day invasion.

    • @jasonwiley798
      @jasonwiley798 Рік тому +4

      Operation mincemeat was bout to he invsion of Sicily

    • @keriallen2711
      @keriallen2711 Рік тому

      Different event honey

    • @michael-4k4000
      @michael-4k4000 Рік тому

      Mincemeat was just a movie lol

  • @Padoinky
    @Padoinky Рік тому +1

    The MI5 should have just let the dog into the country

    • @michael-4k4000
      @michael-4k4000 Рік тому +1

      Aren't there enough dogs in the country?

  • @JamesPowell-jc4mo
    @JamesPowell-jc4mo 10 місяців тому

    Don't tell me we were mugged with the whole bill. We finally paid the yanks back but it took 50 years.

  • @henryj.8528
    @henryj.8528 6 місяців тому

    The films I've seen never show more than one "rubber" tank or plane. Even if it was a dozen as this video claims, that pales in comparison to the vehicle parks and airfields in southern England with thousands of trucks, tanks and planes. That, plus the difficulty the Germans would have had sending over photo reconnaissance missions, I find it hard to believe this aspect had any impact on their thinking. Yet every documentary touts it.
    Also, way too much music.

  • @martin777xyz
    @martin777xyz 11 місяців тому

    Annoying unnecessary background music

  • @tonyfrench2574
    @tonyfrench2574 6 місяців тому

    Max Hastings is woefully ignorant

  • @JYRIVIRMA
    @JYRIVIRMA Рік тому +2

    Bad music,disturbing

    • @zmalevo2126
      @zmalevo2126 Рік тому +1

      Yes, i had difficulty making out what was being said.

  • @johnmasterman
    @johnmasterman Рік тому

    My name is John masterman, no relation unfortunately. I read everything publication on xx

  • @voraciousreader3341
    @voraciousreader3341 Рік тому +13

    Wait a minute…. *WHERE IS “OPERATION MINCEMEAT”?!?!?* How can anybody trust a channel that misses something _THAT IMPORTANT?!?_ This ruse was just as important as the double agents, bc it was so subtle!! What a terrible thing to convince people they know about an extremely critical event in history, but they’ve not seen the critical element!!

    • @scottgeorge4268
      @scottgeorge4268 Рік тому

      Absolutely agree, it was a masterpiece of deception and played a huge role in the successful invasion of France.

    • @williamyalen6167
      @williamyalen6167 Рік тому

      voracious reader, Yes, totally agree that Operation Mincemeat was a brilliant and effective Allied pre-invasion deception - but for the 1943 invasion of Sicily, not 1944 D-Day at Normandy.

    • @tonydoherty2190
      @tonydoherty2190 Рік тому

      Operation mincemeat had nothing to do with Normandy landings it was Operation husky to invade sicily in 1943

    • @e-curb
      @e-curb Рік тому

      This video is about the spies relating to the D-Day invasion. Mincemeat was the year before to deceive against the landing on Sicily.

    • @jppalm3944
      @jppalm3944 Рік тому +3

      I agree but the operation didn't involve spies per se

  • @johanmeischke9189
    @johanmeischke9189 Рік тому

    Ah human hermaphrodites are infertile they're also extreamly rare

  • @Shmarti
    @Shmarti Рік тому

    You ruined it at the end by snapping us back to reality with modern video...And yet you were doing so great. Shame!

  • @frederickanderson1860
    @frederickanderson1860 Рік тому +5

    This is nonsense. The fog of war is never predicted , its the ordinary soldier whose deeds make the final outcome.

    • @georgemijatovic4060
      @georgemijatovic4060 Рік тому

      You comment like an amateur

    • @voraciousreader3341
      @voraciousreader3341 Рік тому +1

      I could not disagree more, or more loudly! Without *Operation Mincemeat” (which wasn’t even mentioned here, making this video highly suspect), Patton’s “ghost army, and the double agents, the Allied soldiers would have been *SLAUGHTERED* by the huge forces Hitler instead kept encamped in the Pas de Calais had the ruses been unsuccessful, or worse, never implemented. As it was, the allied soldiers were gunned down in droves on the beaches by the German tower emplacements which Hitler had built on France’s western coast all the way to Norway. All of the naval bombardment hadn’t destroyed even ONE of them. You can scoff at this evidence if you like, but I would ask you to try to find a historian who disagrees, military OR civilian! *Hitler so strongly believed the misinformation for TWO MONTHS,, refusing to send even one tank division to Normandy, as he was so convinced that Patton was landing with his huge fake army across the Channel* and every Allied general fully understood how critical this was to the success of the invasion, with comparatively minimal loss of life for the men who risked their lives during the initial landings.

    • @frederickanderson1860
      @frederickanderson1860 Рік тому +1

      @@voraciousreader3341 again the fog of war can turn any well planned operation to failure. The enigma code was broken and to hat was just as vital for the success of the landings. The best regiment's we're on the Eastern front, and the supply lines harassed by superior air power. Yet the battles had to be won by ordinary soldiers who fought in the difficult terrain of France. Like Wellington remark at Waterloo it was a close run thing.

    • @southernsmoke8391
      @southernsmoke8391 Рік тому +1

      Two answers can be the right one. Mission planning & empowering soldiers to make decisions.

    • @frederickanderson1860
      @frederickanderson1860 Рік тому

      @@southernsmoke8391 again how do you attain victory in war by claiming more territory you can't manage or defeating the army . Blitzkrieg failed in Russia because of its vastness and the rapid advance of the tanks and mechanised artillery. Yet the Germans had more horses than vehicles. So how could the infantry catch up with the rapid advancing tanks to secure the ground they won.