”As it shouldn’t. Most people here are missing the point. ”The doctor is saying we need to enjoy ourselves while we’re here” with a cigarette and a raspy voice. He’s obviously obliviously killing himself.” Doesn't seem like you agree.
@@viski2528 Really? We aren't really living any longer with all these health experts running things. In fact here in the US, life expectancy is dropping.
@@gw437 And the funniest part of all this is when he sincerely denies it, telling that his own character on the screen is pure fiction. (Ever seen the final scene of that unique Barbara Kopple documentary on his jazz band tour in Italy, WILD MAN'S BLUES - the moment he visits his father & mother in their '90s, once he's back in NY?)
I have never ever thought before that, a random video on youtube would help curing my crippling depression and nihilistic way of living. 'Brooklyn is not expanding', wow.
I can be so simple. The problem is, when depressed, you cannot really „grasp“ this thought. It's not like people don't know about the universe (not saying the end of time theories are correct, they probably aren't takes lots of hubris to claim certainty), people do know. BUT it doesn't stress them out. Thats the point: it is depression, anxiety and ocd, that creates nihilistic thoughts and despair. Psychology comes before philosophy! Most people don't get that
If I were ever lucky enough to meet Mr. Allen and ask for his autograph, this is what I'd like him to write: "Brooklyn is not expanding!" ... and then his name.
Had a phase like young Alvy Singer when I was about ten years old. Thanks alot, Prof. Hawking, thanks alot "Scientific American" for some childhood depression. But Dr. Flicker really gives the meaning of life in this scene. ;)
Why are you depressed, Alvie? What is that your business? What has the universe got to do with it? And we've gotta try to enjoy ourselves while we are here!
Love it- of course, this line of reasoning should always ALWAYS be encouraged- that kid is right- throw him in a college level philosophy course- get his head on straight 😀 Not everyone experiences education sequentially, but I love the adults superficial responses- - and those petty games are perhaps just as valuable as the philosophy class 😄
superficial response? I think he was right on the mark - "Brooklyn won't be expanding for billions of years and we've got to enjoy ourselves while we were here". IMO quite a meaningful answer.
As it shouldn’t. Most people here are missing the point. The doctor is saying “we need to enjoy ourselves while we’re here” with a cigarette and a raspy voice. He’s obviously obliviously killing himself.
@@duffharris9295 It actually should, at least according to the movie. What the doctor says is exactly what Woody realizes later in the scene where he goes to see a movie to run away from his existential crisis. It was actually a good advice.
idk if here is a nice place for searching the answer of life. but you may try the meaning of life by monty python. and there is a book series by douglas adams. they will help a lot *thumbs up*
Neil Degrasse Tyson, Brian Cox, Carl Sagan, Isaac Asimov, Albert Einstein. Literally people that put hard work on this, those who depresses on things like this are stupidly egocentric.
@@Viktor-ej9ss When I think of the word "egocentric", I think of those worthless bunch of celebrities who have no contribution to society not the intellectuals that you've mentioned.
Why would you get depressed. It is inspiring and challenging. Maby the ultimate challenge for humans to think about what could be out there and what infinity means. Therefore I would say it it is in fact beautiful.
"We gotta try to enjoy ourselves while we're here! Huh?... Huh?... A-ha-hah-ha... Bwa-haha-haha!"
Oh man.. 😝😝😝😝😝😝😝😝
I remember that from childhood. Authoritative older figures, dispensing loud, garrulous assurances with a laugh. Doctors, teachers, coaches, etc.
@@ChrisJones-ij3xp
While they smoked and drank themselves to an early grave!
Might just be my age, but I find it hard to disagree with Dr Flicker on this one
Easier said than done
i think about this scene a lot.
Me, too. Like just now.
What movie is this?!?!? I've spent the last 2 days trying to figure it out so I can watch it... FUCK
@@HorseCuhm The movie is Annie Hall
@@HorseCuhm you didn’t do a good job since it says the movie title in the description two times
@@HorseCuhm It's a Woody Allen movie. You're not allowed to watch it, otherwise you'd be supporting the artistic genius of a child molester.
The ultimate Jewish mother comeback, “ What is that your business?” Lol
We gotta try to enjoy ourselves while we're here!
Amalia MURCIA PARRA he's got a point
Imagine your bf .. he must be enjoying every moment of it
What is that your business?!
The older I get the more I agree with the cigarette wielding doctor.
”As it shouldn’t. Most people here are missing the point. ”The doctor is saying we need to enjoy ourselves while we’re here” with a cigarette and a raspy voice. He’s obviously obliviously killing himself.” Doesn't seem like you agree.
Cigarettes are incredibly enjoyable. Seems like he is following his own advice tbh.
@@viski2528 Really? We aren't really living any longer with all these health experts running things. In fact here in the US, life expectancy is dropping.
@@ThomasPurcell because of the shit they put in our meat to make it addictive.
he guy playing the doctor was president of Yale University
That has to be my favourite scene in the movie.. "What's the point?" !!! That just cracks me up everytime!
" Brooklyn is not expanding!"
@@alexandradanieleNot yet. Give it a few trillion years!
Brooklyn is not expanding!!
Nihilism rekt in four words
@@gw437 You're missing the point
you can see the kid trying not to smile when the mom talks.
@@gw437 And the funniest part of all this is when he sincerely denies it, telling that his own character on the screen is pure fiction. (Ever seen the final scene of that unique Barbara Kopple documentary on his jazz band tour in Italy, WILD MAN'S BLUES - the moment he visits his father & mother in their '90s, once he's back in NY?)
I have never ever thought before that, a random video on youtube would help curing my crippling depression and nihilistic way of living. 'Brooklyn is not expanding', wow.
I can be so simple. The problem is, when depressed, you cannot really „grasp“ this thought. It's not like people don't know about the universe (not saying the end of time theories are correct, they probably aren't takes lots of hubris to claim certainty), people do know. BUT it doesn't stress them out.
Thats the point: it is depression, anxiety and ocd, that creates nihilistic thoughts and despair. Psychology comes before philosophy! Most people don't get that
I watch this video everyday. Idk why.
The delivery of "what's the point?" Is some straight up timeless classic gold 😂
If I were ever lucky enough to meet Mr. Allen and ask for his autograph, this is what I'd like him to write: "Brooklyn is not expanding!" ... and then his name.
I'd ask him to write, if I may be so bold to reply after 14 years, "What's the point?"
_...you"re here in Brooklin, Brooklin is not expanding! 😂🤣😂 Genius 👏👏👏
This dialogue is the 2022 university philosophy exam question in Turkey, this is incredible.
Perfect.
i basically had this exact same thing with my mom a few years back
Tyt 2022 Felsefede vardı ve doğru yaptım sınav bu gündü teşekkürler Annie hall
neki cevap
@@zetonams9640 pragmatizm
and then he became the lead singer in radiohead.
"Brooklyn is not expanding . . . "
(LOL) I love it when Moms . . . tell it like it is.
Thank god. I'm moving to Brooklyn. Where I live now will be an empty void of collapsed molecules any day now!
Had a phase like young Alvy Singer when I was about ten years old. Thanks alot, Prof. Hawking, thanks alot "Scientific American" for some childhood depression. But Dr. Flicker really gives the meaning of life in this scene. ;)
herbert perebynis How did you got over that? I am feeling the same in this period.
@@zouhairelyaagoubi me too..i feel bad..thinking this...
How can I get out of this?
Where did they get this video of me?
To funny! I feel the same...
wish i could see the world the way woody does... :)
You think you do want to, but seeing the world with no goggles like that... trust me, you might not really want it.
Doctor knows the meaning of life. Everyone please listen to him:)
Why are you depressed, Alvie? What is that your business? What has the universe got to do with it? And we've gotta try to enjoy ourselves while we are here!
Best antidepressant ever🤘👍✌
This is how I feel.
story of my existence in 45 seconds.lol
Michael Sherman & Joe Rogan brought me here; ‘18. Wow, published in 2007? Props to the channel - internet longevity.
fuck!! I can't sleep, universe is expanding, I ain't fucking going to work tomorrow
that short video clip once was a philosophy question in Turkey's national exam
Great movie. Comments here not too shabby too.
The doctor is remarkably like Jack!
waar ben ik nu terechtgekomen?
Father George Lemaitre, Catholic University of Louvain is to blame for Alvy's depression.
The man of the Big Bang theory !
One of the most genius aspects of this movie is that it already gives you the meaning of life in the early scenes. 0:38
"What is that your business?"
The best line ever... "What's the point?"
i never knew thom yorke was from brooklyn
I think, all sensitive human beings went through a phase like this. What's the point?
Love it- of course, this line of reasoning should always ALWAYS be encouraged-
that kid is right- throw him in a college level philosophy course- get his head on straight 😀
Not everyone experiences education sequentially, but I love the adults superficial responses-
- and those petty games are perhaps just as valuable as the philosophy class 😄
superficial response? I think he was right on the mark - "Brooklyn won't be expanding for billions of years and we've got to enjoy ourselves while we were here". IMO quite a meaningful answer.
@@vicinvesta8349 sure, meaningful wi effectual results of shuttin tha kid down😄 I mean, u really think the kids all resolved now?
it will break apart!!! :O
It's not just expanding..... It's expanding TOO FAST!
READ A BOOK!
No it isn't. It's expanding exactly as fast as it should.
Dr. Flicker
The universe is expanding. Honey Badger don't care!
how do they know that its not expanding now because of the energy in the big bang and will start to slow down?
La traduzione in Italiano rende di più, nel senso che, è molto più comica!
ya know, kid's got a point
Hilarious.
The black hole at the center of it all
yeah but wouldnt that be expected early in an explosion? That it expands faster?
tyt 2022
Expanding... not expending.
0:16
yes, yes, yes, thank god, brooklyn is not expanding!!!!!
What's the point? 😁
my mom
The psychiatrist reminds me of Rudy Giuliani.
@peckaloomer greek doctors still do it mate. the 99% of them
#yks2022
**existence
"What's the point?"
Dr Flicker...the psychiatrist.
@peckaloomer my doctor smoked a pipe...he's dead now. Died of lung cancer
YKS 2022'de çıktı
What is that your business?!?
This was so dumb. Is still dumb but yes. Why not enjoy it?
Evrenin bununla ne alakası var ? brooklynde yaşıyorsun , brooklyn genişlemiyor!
Hahahaha this is nonsense
the universe doesnt exist
The doc looks so much like Bruce Campbell lol
why do we do anything?
the same as saying why DON'T we do anything? it's just as nihilistic
What is that your business?!
LOL - As though he is crossing personal boundaries with the universe
i love woody allen!
when i watch his movies i don't feel normal but at least not alone anymore
Tyt sosyalden gelenler
Woody can't be beat. Classic!
Hi :) are u ok? 😃
that woman had fantastic delivery! all three of the sell the scene so well
Alvy's posture is perfect too.
it's the way i feel today. Covid 19 lol
"Three out of four doctors smoke Camels!" (An advertising slogan in the past.)
I remember those ads well!
This scene became a university exam question in Turkey. İt was pretty funny
My dad quoted this scene at me when I was having a serious existential crisis and mental breakdown.
It didn't help.
As it shouldn’t. Most people here are missing the point. The doctor is saying “we need to enjoy ourselves while we’re here” with a cigarette and a raspy voice. He’s obviously obliviously killing himself.
@@duffharris9295 yes but he’s still enjoying himself while he’s here? Isn’t that the entire paradox which fuels the joke?
Give it a day or two.
@@duffharris9295 It actually should, at least according to the movie. What the doctor says is exactly what Woody realizes later in the scene where he goes to see a movie to run away from his existential crisis. It was actually a good advice.
@@duffharris9295 What's the point of living an extra twenty years if you're going to be miserable all the time?
Tell Dr. Flicker!
Allah bu sorunun belasını versin...
eh? huh? a hahah LOL
I envy the person who'll be the very last on the earth to watch this
Love you
Me, except with Global Warming.
The speech in this scene was asked in the 2022 university entrance exam in Turkey.
Sadly in terms of population, our "universe" is really indeed expanding, and at exponential levels..
🗣️WHAT IS THAT YOUR BUSINESS?!?!? 💁🏻
hey everyone,,,i think of these too..wonder whats the purpose of life....but never can give an answer,,,
there is no purpose to life. why does there have to be a purpose?
idk if here is a nice place for searching the answer of life. but you may try the meaning of life by monty python. and there is a book series by douglas adams. they will help a lot *thumbs up*
@@ruslanbabayan326 , you are wrong
BROOKLYN IS NOT EXPANDING!!1
I feel for the kid, who else wouldn't get depressed by the UNIVERSE and INFINITY...?
True I feel like the kid this period
Neil Degrasse Tyson, Brian Cox, Carl Sagan, Isaac Asimov, Albert Einstein. Literally people that put hard work on this, those who depresses on things like this are stupidly egocentric.
@@Viktor-ej9ss Funny, I think the same thing about people who worship celebrities and put down others for fun.
@@Viktor-ej9ss When I think of the word "egocentric", I think of those worthless bunch of celebrities who have no contribution to society not the intellectuals that you've mentioned.
Why would you get depressed. It is inspiring and challenging. Maby the ultimate challenge for humans to think about what could be out there and what infinity means. Therefore I would say it it is in fact beautiful.
yks2022 sınavında hayatımızı karartan soru bu kısmı paragraf olarak sordular🥺
"WHAT IS THAT YOUR BUSINESS?" Priceless.
@theporksicle If nothing we do in this world matters, then the only thing that matters is what we do. --- Angel, season five finale.
Tell Dr Flicker!
What is that your business? LOL!
00:35 Playing it over and over from this point, is the best medicine
Ahahaha
She's right, it's none of his business.
"What is that your business !" LOL