It really made me sad to think that the moments that we make memories with someone would someday become a memory that will look back to once they're gone or it will remain with us when we bid our farewell.
i think, because that 'end' is something that making things good. when we just keep driving on a long, straight and never ending road, we'll never (or maybe barely) look behind, we just keep looking forward and barely look and appreciate what we left behind... nothing's last forever, but that's the beauty in life, because with that we can appreciate things...
"is" -> "was" But his finger can't click the mouse because he didn't want to admit it. Until her graduation concert end... He cried, then the sound of single click happened.
As Vision said "A thing isn't beautiful because it lasts" At the very least she was able to graduate officially, was able make tons of MVs and talked/collab with whoever she wanted before her graduation. So atleast we had time to let it sink in and say goodbye properly. (Im still sad tho)
Aqua's graduation is the perfect and satisfying ending. After seeing so many graduations that left me sad and with a bittersweet ending like Coco and Sana, I actually felt really sad that Aqua made the decision to graduate from Hololive. But realizing that she has been there for 6 years and many things she has done, at the end of her graduation, crying from sadness at first turned into crying from happiness, why? Because Aqua has already fulfilled her purpose in Hololive, she graduated to live her life, 6 years in Hololive is something admirable that she has remained for a long time and with that she has already earned my respect. It's the first vtuber graduation that really made me cry with happiness because Aqua has already fulfilled her purpose At this point, we should no longer cry with sadness because a member of Hololive is graduating, on the contrary, cry with happiness that each of them has and is fulfilling their purpose in Hololive, most of them have already fulfilled their dreams that have come true and are still pursuing it now, the only thing that makes us cry with sadness is when a member of Hololive has been terminated, because all her years of work and effort in Hololive were in vain and her channel are no longer available, that's because at Aqua's graduation I felt happy that her channel will remain as if it was a museum or a hall of fame, but in Mel's case, I really wish she didn't have that ending, I wanted Mel to have a perfect and satisfying ending like Aqua. So remember guys, if a Hololive member announces her graduation, at first you have to cry from sadness that they are leaving, but then cry from happiness that they have fulfilled their purpose in Hololive for many years. At this point, most of the remaining early HoloJP generations are already 5-6+ years into Hololive, and it's pretty safe to say they're going to make that decision, But if you take into account what I said, each member of Hololive has truly fulfilled their purpose and their dreams have come true. THANK YOU VERY MUCH MINATO AQUA, YOU WAS ONE OF THE MANY VTUBERS WHO MADE US DISCOVER THIS WONDERFUL PLACE THAT IS HOLOLIVE. AND THANKS TO YAGOO FOR CHOSEN HER AND SHOWING HIS SUPPORT. AND THANK YOU TO US, THE FANS, FOR SUPPORTING HER UNTIL THE END AFTER 6 YEARS ON HOLOLIVE. THIS IS WHAT I CALL A PERFECT AND SATISFACTORY ENDING FOR MINATO AQUA
it was such a sweet graduation compared to most out there. Most of the time we have a bitterness in the end cuz we think to ourselves, "why now?" but with aqua, I think its safe to say that she fulfilled what she wanted to do at Hololive and everybody agrees to that sentiment. I do hope whatever she decides to pursue whether its going indie or focusing on gaming, she's gonna be happy where she is and people will continue to show their support for her. I only ever discovered her about 3 months before her graduation announcement so I didn't quite get to point of calling her my oshi but that last month of her really made me appreciate her more and appreciate what she has been doing for these last couple years she's been a vtuber.
@@villahermosasebastian8794 If you know, you know what happened in September 2020, that moment marked her forever, That was one of the reasons she graduated, she only lasted 1 year and 6 months in Hololive, had too much potential in Hololive but graduated.
Although I may be sad because Aqua is about to graduate, 6 years is truly a very long journey for a Vtuber like her, which makes me respect her even more for the things she has done during that time She will always be the best onion 😭
I watch it from beginning to the last, it was hard but thank you for everything aqua even i didn't able to watch her streams a lot cuz i wasn't able to understand it, It was a pleasure knowing this whole 6 years 🥹😭 Arigato and Sayonara.... (Man I'm about to cry a bit actually)
@@nutmaster9541 same, like holy fck I can't believe it's been 4yrs since I got into hololive and that she was one of the reasons I went into the rabbit hole
@@nutmaster9541 I totally feel you! I just got into Vtube content as well. I'm really not a fan into this stuff but she was the reason I got hooked up :
It was heartbreaking when she was crying and singing I was crying along with her It's been my 4 years watching you and now from tomorrow i cant see any live notifications from you my oshi ❤ I will always Support your next Journey
I was already tearing up during the intro, but when Aquairo Pallete started I could'nt hold back my tears. That littke onion making me cry yo the very end 🥹
I was trying not to cry because there were people in the room while I was watching the graduation. It still kinda feels unreal to me 😭 I wish her good luck for the future, though! 🩷
I haven't cried for years. This stream makes me cry a little. And when I thought that would be it, her crying during the last song literally broke me 😢
My fav Vtuber when I heard about it I instantly bought some merch with Aqua and listening to her songs everyday and completed "Aquarium" I hope she'll come back to streaming out of hololive
I never watched her streams but I tuned into the Graduation Stream! I only understand five words in Japanese and I still cried. However, I don’t regret watching it!
At 1st it was a sad moment then i realize she can do many more stuff outside hololive due to game copyright infringement . She can still meet with her Holo friend in real life making me wanted to meet my old friend for some nostalgia talk. She's fine and so we are.
That’s life for you-everything has its end. Some things leave, and new things take their place. She’s just starting a fresh chapter. Let’s be glad we were part of her life, a part she’ll always remember 😢 As a Hololive fan, I’m happy right up until the last note of her final song. 'Aqua Iro Palette' will always be my favorite ❤
Anybody else just go to the live stream and gave it a like, typed a farewell message and then immediately went to watch something else with Thug Tears rolling down your face?.....I couldn't bring myself to watch anything related to it, before, and during it. Unless it was on some meme shit like this. I can't handle hololive graduations at all, I'll full on ugly cry for hours.
Man I wished people cared at all about mel when she got kicked. Instead she gets fan artist refusing to draw her in art anymore and everyone pretending she never existed.
It's still settling in, the fact that we're never gonna see her again, that smile at the end, it was so bright, it made me so happy and so unbelievably sad at the same time, man. Whatever happens, I hope and pray for nothing but happiness and good fortune to the talent behind Minato Aqua
It's not even a day have past but I start remembering all those goods times she live stream, I feel like my strength left me, my tears won't stop falling thinking that tomorrow I won't see Minato aqua live stream, and her notification on UA-cam, X won't pop out on my screen.
I literally had to stop whatever I was doing just to watch Aqua's graduation stream. I don't really watch her often but I really like her voice and her original aqua iro palette. I saw some clips here and there but really got familiar to her when Startend was formed. I can't believe that was 2 years ago... I finished the stream without breaking into tears, I just felt a bit sadness and loneliness but I dont know why... I will miss the gamer onion but I wish her all the best on her journey after hololive. See you again, Akutan o7
i am still crying i never cry this much in my life i was holding back my tears until i hear her cry in live . SHE REALLY LEAVE US I CAN'T BELIVE IT . SHE REALLY HAS BECOME A LEGEND I WILL NEVER FORGRT HER I STILL CAN'T STOP MY TEARS
I somehow kept my composure during the last song, but after the stream ended it hit me. Listening to the original Aqua Iro Palette once again, I broke into tears. It is so surreal, over the past 4 years I’ve been in this rabbit hole, Aqua is not my oshi, but AkuShio dual has always held a special place in my heart. I’m glad that she has a beautiful send off with every member in HoloJP, may happiness be with her wherever she goes.
I was smiling all the time watching her graduation live. But when she sang her last song and the livestream was finished, I felt it. I felt that this is it, you'll never truly know what you have, till it's gone. Minato Aqua is now but a memory. A memory that we should never forget.
I missed the live stream unfortunately, but I’ll watch the vod eventually. Goodbye Aqua. Even though I got into watching vtubers only recently, it’s still very sad to see a talent like her graduate. Cherish what memories you have of your oshis everyone. Everything will always come to an end.
This onion not only stimulates tears, but also stimulates the heart.... Especially when she sang aqua iro palette in the last part one... Although she graduated I can feel that too. Wish aqua all the best
Bug or not whether it's 750k or a 960k the fact of the matter is she became a legend of the vtubing world, and for that it make me happy that she decided this and stand by her words even if all the friends she made was trying to stop her until they finally accepted it even though I WANTED HER TO STAY BIT LONGER 😭😭😭😭😭😭
![Norio Cries & Reveals Regrets About Aqua's Graduation (Inuyama Tamaki) (Hololive) [Eng Subs]](/img/n.gif)
Onions do, in fact, make you cry.
Yeah.... Especially when they do leave after a long journey...
the legend was born... but what did it cost...
@@isanirucheverything....
Real
Boys... Im making french onion soup tonight... maybe... with a side of garlic bread
Her crying through the last song was tough...
DUDE THAT BROKE ME.
bro i thought i was ready but that shit broke me
The last song broke everyone, and i still can't get over it
I couldn't keep up bro 😢
Ikr she couldn't hold her own tears with us...
No more onions, but we're crying 😭😭
Yes, the onion is gone, my friend. But we have to be strong for her sake...
She was crying while singing dawg 😭i love her so much. It hurts too much
That was so emotinal, surpressing her tears as she sang the final song. 700k witness her final moments in Hololive.
I don't know JP but in the end i still feel my tears when she cry😢. I admire her so much
That part really hit me hard. You can tell she was holding tears.
Just changing "is" to "was" is saddest thing ever T^T
😢😭
WHY DO GOOD THINGS HAVE TO END
It really made me sad to think that the moments that we make memories with someone would someday become a memory that will look back to once they're gone or it will remain with us when we bid our farewell.
i think, because that 'end' is something that making things good. when we just keep driving on a long, straight and never ending road, we'll never (or maybe barely) look behind, we just keep looking forward and barely look and appreciate what we left behind... nothing's last forever, but that's the beauty in life, because with that we can appreciate things...
Don’t cry because It’s over; smile because it happened . Dr Seuss
this just makes me think of what we all have to come in terms with in the future :((((
@@orionji That's a good way to put it
Our onion had a Chad statement... I wish for the best of her, see you guys next year to reminisce the old times...
0:22 me too Keanu, me too
It was good while it lasted, at least she went off with a proper goodbye o7
I didn't want it to end, but the moment I heard her say Aqua Iro Palette, I knew it was the end. I bawled so hard.
In her sing ?
the editor has the hardest moment of pressing the "save the change" option
😭😭
"is" -> "was"
But his finger can't click the mouse because he didn't want to admit it.
Until her graduation concert end... He cried, then the sound of single click happened.
It was heartbreaking watching her fight her tears as she sang Aqua Iro Palette.
Aqua may have graduated, but her legend will still remain.
Im actually crying man.. Stumbled upon her and Miko during the pandemic and have been watching ever since.. shit hurts... wishing Aqutan the best..
same. it was hololive resistance minecraft clip..
All of us will miss her
As Vision said "A thing isn't beautiful because it lasts"
At the very least she was able to graduate officially, was able make tons of MVs and talked/collab with whoever she wanted before her graduation. So atleast we had time to let it sink in and say goodbye properly. (Im still sad tho)
Aqua's graduation is the perfect and satisfying ending. After seeing so many graduations that left me sad and with a bittersweet ending like Coco and Sana, I actually felt really sad that Aqua made the decision to graduate from Hololive. But realizing that she has been there for 6 years and many things she has done, at the end of her graduation, crying from sadness at first turned into crying from happiness, why? Because Aqua has already fulfilled her purpose in Hololive, she graduated to live her life, 6 years in Hololive is something admirable that she has remained for a long time and with that she has already earned my respect. It's the first vtuber graduation that really made me cry with happiness because Aqua has already fulfilled her purpose
At this point, we should no longer cry with sadness because a member of Hololive is graduating, on the contrary, cry with happiness that each of them has and is fulfilling their purpose in Hololive, most of them have already fulfilled their dreams that have come true and are still pursuing it now, the only thing that makes us cry with sadness is when a member of Hololive has been terminated, because all her years of work and effort in Hololive were in vain and her channel are no longer available, that's because at Aqua's graduation I felt happy that her channel will remain as if it was a museum or a hall of fame, but in Mel's case, I really wish she didn't have that ending, I wanted Mel to have a perfect and satisfying ending like Aqua.
So remember guys, if a Hololive member announces her graduation, at first you have to cry from sadness that they are leaving, but then cry from happiness that they have fulfilled their purpose in Hololive for many years. At this point, most of the remaining early HoloJP generations are already 5-6+ years into Hololive, and it's pretty safe to say they're going to make that decision, But if you take into account what I said, each member of Hololive has truly fulfilled their purpose and their dreams have come true.
THANK YOU VERY MUCH MINATO AQUA, YOU WAS ONE OF THE MANY VTUBERS WHO MADE US DISCOVER THIS WONDERFUL PLACE THAT IS HOLOLIVE. AND THANKS TO YAGOO FOR CHOSEN HER AND SHOWING HIS SUPPORT. AND THANK YOU TO US, THE FANS, FOR SUPPORTING HER UNTIL THE END AFTER 6 YEARS ON HOLOLIVE.
THIS IS WHAT I CALL A PERFECT AND SATISFACTORY ENDING FOR MINATO AQUA
it was such a sweet graduation compared to most out there. Most of the time we have a bitterness in the end cuz we think to ourselves, "why now?" but with aqua, I think its safe to say that she fulfilled what she wanted to do at Hololive and everybody agrees to that sentiment. I do hope whatever she decides to pursue whether its going indie or focusing on gaming, she's gonna be happy where she is and people will continue to show their support for her. I only ever discovered her about 3 months before her graduation announcement so I didn't quite get to point of calling her my oshi but that last month of her really made me appreciate her more and appreciate what she has been doing for these last couple years she's been a vtuber.
Why is Coco bittersweet? She left for the same reasons as Aqua. While Sana left because she didn't like being a vtuber
@@villahermosasebastian8794 If you know, you know what happened in September 2020, that moment marked her forever, That was one of the reasons she graduated, she only lasted 1 year and 6 months in Hololive, had too much potential in Hololive but graduated.
@@TheVtuberRevolutionary what? She said in her last streams that she left because she was being restricted on the type of content she wanted to make
@TheVtuberRevolutionary honestly I gonna watch her video clips tho
im not fucking ready for when her talent page will be changed to [Alum] Minato Aqua
IT ACTUALLY HAPPENED SHE GOT LISTED AS [ALUM]
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
Although I may be sad because Aqua is about to graduate, 6 years is truly a very long journey for a Vtuber like her, which makes me respect her even more for the things she has done during that time
She will always be the best onion 😭
I'm still crying now
im still wiping my snot slow down with the upload bro
The way she cried on the last part make me really cried.
Onion gone and we still crying 🥹😭
本当に永遠の思い出と伝説をありがとう
Just checked the vtuber wiki and they really changed it that quick
shes not gonna see this but sore high, you havetouched the hearts of us all! Even till the end!
I'm still crying now.
Watching her cry while singing her final song was heartbreaking.
I'm going to miss her so much.
Just finished the stream...
I watch it from beginning to the last, it was hard but thank you for everything aqua even i didn't able to watch her streams a lot cuz i wasn't able to understand it,
It was a pleasure knowing this whole 6 years 🥹😭
Arigato and Sayonara.... (Man I'm about to cry a bit actually)
正直な話、湊あくあは卒業しないでほしかった。けれども、彼女の卒業ライブは最高のものにしてくれた。湊あくあには感謝の気持ちしかない。
i just learned Aqua and Im 6 years late :
she's one of the holo members that got me into hololive and it's hard seeing her leaving man..
@@nutmaster9541 same, like holy fck I can't believe it's been 4yrs since I got into hololive and that she was one of the reasons I went into the rabbit hole
@@nutmaster9541 I totally feel you! I just got into Vtube content as well. I'm really not a fan into this stuff but she was the reason I got hooked up :
Same bro, I saw her valo stream and she's so amazing. I copied her play style and it definitely worked.
same....it's too late now...
It was heartbreaking when she was crying and singing
I was crying along with her
It's been my 4 years watching you and now from tomorrow i cant see any live notifications from you my oshi ❤
I will always Support your next Journey
Best Onion ever!!
I was already tearing up during the intro, but when Aquairo Pallete started I could'nt hold back my tears. That littke onion making me cry yo the very end 🥹
Each gen getting one of their members graduated 1 by 1. So far I know, first and sixth gen are still completed.
I was trying not to cry because there were people in the room while I was watching the graduation. It still kinda feels unreal to me 😭
I wish her good luck for the future, though! 🩷
She's back guys😊
where tho?
where broo?
Tell me where is she ????
SHEESS BACK!!!
I haven't cried for years. This stream makes me cry a little. And when I thought that would be it, her crying during the last song literally broke me 😢
My fav Vtuber when I heard about it I instantly bought some merch with Aqua and listening to her songs everyday and completed "Aquarium" I hope she'll come back to streaming out of hololive
Never watch her stream but i know how does it feel when your beloved one graduated. Feel left behind and won't be able to interact anymore.
I never watched her streams but I tuned into the Graduation Stream!
I only understand five words in Japanese and I still cried.
However, I don’t regret watching it!
We will miss you so much Aqua senpai 😢 I’m crying 😭
At 1st it was a sad moment then i realize she can do many more stuff outside hololive due to game copyright infringement . She can still meet with her Holo friend in real life making me wanted to meet my old friend for some nostalgia talk.
She's fine and so we are.
Damn it... Future people will never understand how much that little change in Wiki hurts
so sad that took only 2 month after A-chan's graduation😢
i cried the moment the stream ended. much love to aqua, and wherever she'll decide to go to next
That’s life for you-everything has its end. Some things leave, and new things take their place. She’s just starting a fresh chapter. Let’s be glad we were part of her life, a part she’ll always remember 😢
As a Hololive fan, I’m happy right up until the last note of her final song. 'Aqua Iro Palette' will always be my favorite ❤
Anybody else just go to the live stream and gave it a like, typed a farewell message and then immediately went to watch something else with Thug Tears rolling down your face?.....I couldn't bring myself to watch anything related to it, before, and during it. Unless it was on some meme shit like this. I can't handle hololive graduations at all, I'll full on ugly cry for hours.
"Stop cutting Onions damn Ninjas"
Now do everyone after her PL redebut 😅
Lemme cry 😭😭😭😭 bye aqua-tan
6 years too late, but I'm glad I was with her until the end!
Man I wished people cared at all about mel when she got kicked. Instead she gets fan artist refusing to draw her in art anymore and everyone pretending she never existed.
"was" first time a single word make my wanna sobs
This video is so unbelievably relatable I almost broke down when I heard her cry during Aquiro Pallete-
This is almost my exact same reaction😭
This actually really hit me hard…
I'm just drinking wine watching every fun memory. We're gonna miss her.
NO ONE WAS TRULY READY FOR AQUA IRO PALETTE CRYING VER. 😭 😭 😭
Bro I legit sobbed during that last song. I didn’t watch much more than her clips but she was one of my favorites in jp.
It's still settling in, the fact that we're never gonna see her again, that smile at the end, it was so bright, it made me so happy and so unbelievably sad at the same time, man. Whatever happens, I hope and pray for nothing but happiness and good fortune to the talent behind Minato Aqua
I'm hardened by all the graduations I attended
Im so sad that i cant even cry... This is about to keep me up from sleeping
Hearing her cry through the last song and pushing through to the end. 💜💜 Strongest Onyan.
To think it's been 4 years since I joined the void... time sure flies o7
おつあくあ〜⚓
It's not even a day have past but I start remembering all those goods times she live stream, I feel like my strength left me, my tears won't stop falling thinking that tomorrow I won't see Minato aqua live stream, and her notification on UA-cam, X won't pop out on my screen.
Theatchange from ‘is’ to ‘was’ was heartbreaking
The live has just started and I'm already crying, especially when she was crying in the last song, I cried even more🥹
最後まであくあは、伝説だ
So true the longer the stream went on, the more you felt broken 💔
Onions have a lore behind it, and it will make you broke
I literally had to stop whatever I was doing just to watch Aqua's graduation stream. I don't really watch her often but I really like her voice and her original aqua iro palette. I saw some clips here and there but really got familiar to her when Startend was formed. I can't believe that was 2 years ago...
I finished the stream without breaking into tears, I just felt a bit sadness and loneliness but I dont know why... I will miss the gamer onion but I wish her all the best on her journey after hololive. See you again, Akutan o7
I don't slice an onion, but still cry
I could barely see through the tears
i am still crying i never cry this much in my life i was holding back my tears until i hear her cry in live . SHE REALLY LEAVE US I CAN'T BELIVE IT .
SHE REALLY HAS BECOME A LEGEND I WILL NEVER FORGRT HER
I STILL CAN'T STOP MY TEARS
I enjoy that in tears 😭😭😭
“was” is such a magic word, only changed it from “is” can makes us this sad.
I was indeed not ready, nor will i be
this hurts me so much seeing another great vtuber leaving truly a sad day for hololive fans
I somehow kept my composure during the last song, but after the stream ended it hit me. Listening to the original Aqua Iro Palette once again, I broke into tears. It is so surreal, over the past 4 years I’ve been in this rabbit hole, Aqua is not my oshi, but AkuShio dual has always held a special place in my heart. I’m glad that she has a beautiful send off with every member in HoloJP, may happiness be with her wherever she goes.
Don't cry, soon we will get an apple.
I was smiling all the time watching her graduation live. But when she sang her last song and the livestream was finished, I felt it.
I felt that this is it, you'll never truly know what you have, till it's gone.
Minato Aqua is now but a memory. A memory that we should never forget.
I was cry laughing so hard at that neko at the end. Thank you Akutan for making us smile even when we’re that sad
Gentlemen, it’s been an honor.
I just realized she hasn't done a Shuffle Medley yet... Dang... 😢
I was watching Sonic 3 trailer while watching her graduation, the excitement and sadness blend together
Even I can't believe that our beloved Onion is gone
I missed the live stream unfortunately, but I’ll watch the vod eventually. Goodbye Aqua. Even though I got into watching vtubers only recently, it’s still very sad to see a talent like her graduate. Cherish what memories you have of your oshis everyone. Everything will always come to an end.
I regret not seeing her last live. I regret not being able to hear her withold tears as she sang one last time.
Damn it all. We miss you, Aqua-tan.
This Onion got me into Apex. Startend part already got me bawling.
But then she was crying while singing Aqua Iro Palette 🥲🥲🥲
I needed a huge canister of copium after she said thank you for the last time
this onion indeed make you cry a lot
I swear it's just the onion
Shit was already emotional but her crying during the last moments broke me...
This onion not only stimulates tears, but also stimulates the heart.... Especially when she sang aqua iro palette in the last part one... Although she graduated I can feel that too.
Wish aqua all the best
Bug or not whether it's 750k or a 960k the fact of the matter is she became a legend of the vtubing world, and for that it make me happy that she decided this and stand by her words even if all the friends she made was trying to stop her until they finally accepted it even though I WANTED HER TO STAY BIT LONGER 😭😭😭😭😭😭
I am going to cry until I sleep...
I-I’m not crying it’s just because of an onion
I’m not crying, my eyes are just water cooling