@@בועזקשת-פ1ד The truth is that Jewish history has to be read in the context of the time. Do you think he would have preferred to live under crusader rule, where Jews where burnt as children of the devil?
@@moislam3804 Sure not, the muslims at the midle ages were the lesser of 2 evils for the jews. When the economy prosperd the islamic dhimi rules were not enforced but it could change really fast every time things went badly
@@בועזקשת-פ1ד Of course, no Muslim denies, that. So it would make sense to mention that one of the greatest Jewish philosophers was the chief physician of another giant figure of not only Muslim but Western history.
No mention of reversing Apostacy ideas and that he went to fix the Kariate problem, which was devolving Judaism. A Jew is a Jew is a Jew is a Jew, no matter FORCED CONVERSION at the sword by The CALIPHATE or CHRISTIANITY. Thanks for saving Marranos and essentialy putting the Kol Nidre into full effect. I'm a descendant of Rashi, but you are my "Grandpa", too, Rambam.
okay you explaiend the histroy but you barely touched upon his theolgoy and conception of judaism, and briefly explained why he was controversial. 10/10 for history, 3/10 for philopshy of rambam
Sam actually wrote an episode for us that is coming out in a few weeks! There's definitely no reason that you can't have two videos that compliment each other.
WAllah Jewish people are decent people (both secular and non secular) . I live in the west and I have recently moved to an area where there are many Jewish people and have found them to be great people. I prefer living among Jewish people than my original town which is majority Muslim. Allah is witness, this is the truth in my personal experience. Allah/G-D loves truth.
Thank you thank you so much for this short but great video regarding Rambam, although personally I am a bigger fan of Rashi... Nevertheless I might end up being a Sephardic convert to Judaism depending on my parent's ancestry.
"Is Moses Maimonides an unacknowledged ancestor of the psychoanalytic movement? In this book, David Bakan, Dan Merkur, and David S. Weiss look at the great medieval Jewish philosopher's prescription for the cure of souls and its psychological significance. In the Guide of the Perplexed, Maimonides, who was also a physician, describes the soul's illness: when sinners rationalize evil as good, they limit their capacities to reason, imagine, and behave well, which also produces physical symptoms. The cure depends on repentance in love and fear of God that is attained through philosophical knowledge, the interpretation of dreams and visions, and mystical contemplation. The authors look at the Aristotelian background of Maimonides' psychology, Maimonidean mysticism, his beliefs about prophecy and sexuality, and what is known of Maimonides' client population. A final chapter discusses Maimonides and Freud, noting that many distinctive features of the cure of souls are shared by Freud's original formulation of psychoanalysis. Indeed, the many points of convergence suggest Freud's direct or indirect contact with Maimonides' legacy."
Famous Rabinic Books : 1. Kitab al-Amanat wa’l-I’tiqadat (Emunot V’deiot-“The Book of Beliefs and Opinions”), by Rabbi Saadiah Gaon 2. Kitab Al Hidayah ila Faraid al-Qulub (Chovot HaLevavot-“Duties of the Heart”), by Rabbeinu Bachya 3.Kitab al-Ḥujjah wal-Dalil fi Nuṣr al-Din al-Dhalil (The Kuzari-“A Defense of the Despised Faith”), by Rabbi Yehudah HaLevi 4.Maqala Fi-Sinat Al-Mantiq (Millot HaHiggayon-“Treatise on Logical Terminology”), by Maimonides 5. Kitab al-Siraj (Peirush HaMishnayot-“Commentary on the Mishnah”), by Maimonides 6. Kitab al-Farai'd (Sefer HaMitzvot-“Book of Commandments”), by Maimonides 7. Dalalat al-Ha'rin (Moreh Nevuchim-“Guide for the Perplexed”), by Maimonides
The lord commands us to do bless those who curse u and love your enemies, do good to those who hate u. So you actually made a point to prove MAIMONIDES was holy
Do you know this series is based on the book Letters to Auntie Fori by Martin Gilbert. Here Auntie Fori is none other than Shobha Nehru (aunt of Jawaharlal Nehru)
It is well to remember that this Rabbi is a racist. He states in his book "A Guide for the Perplexed" that people of the steppe (Turks) and blacks are neither fully human nor fully animal but in-between the two.
In the Jewish law, a "non- fully human " means that not all of the mitsvot (laws of the Torah) apply to. And- this book is written in codes, which is because he didn't want uneducated people to read it and misunderstand it, and then go about and speaking bad about it. Educate yourself.
I am descended from Rambam.Much of what he taught comes from the teachings of Muhammad. eat until your stomach is one-third full, drink a third and leave a third air.
Golden age, if i am not forgotten thomas aquinas's summa theologia or his other books being used to brainswahed muslim and jews in andalusia during the spanish inquisition. That book debating muslim ashari-maturidi school on the basis of aristotelian philosophy and debating jewish base on the old testament , i wonder who these book from Musa bin Maimun can stand thomas aquinas's books, aquino attacking maimonides and averroes
I understand that Moshe Maimonides, Mosa Ben Maimoun or RamBam was a great doctor who healed many people. However, I was very traumatized when I saw he encourages uncle and niece marriage as a mitzvah and the best marriage possible when it is horrible incest and abuse and brings very ill kids. How come most Jews don't marry their nieces nor direct nor close cousins and are therefore avoiding being extremely ill, sexually abusive, incestuous and traumatizing generation to generation. Just a question, why does Maimonides tell Jewish people to marry their nieces ? Isn't that incest and sexual abuse ? Why does Maimonides not tell them to venture out into the world, leave their nieces alone in peace and stop lusting after their relatives ?
Niece is not one of those that are not allowed to marry. Why is that incest? Is cousin incest? I mean don't get me wrong, it's not acceptable to do that today but that's bec our culture has changed not the objective idea of incest. Incest is what the Torah determines as incest otherwise not.
Dhimmi meaning a person living in a region overrun by Muslim conquest who was accorded a protected status and allowed to retain his or her original faith. Not second class citizens. The muslims were obligated to pay compulsory zakat to state to help the poor (old welfare system) but non muslims were free from that obligation, they were required to pay some 2% on some form of income to get protected status and to have a stake in the society, simple.
You forgot the part that they are not allowed to carry weapons, that they have to bring the jizzah tax (which sometimes reached 50% of their income) on their knees, that they are not allowed to build new synagogues, that they are not allowed to testify against Muslims in court or hold public office and of course permission to take their daughters For marriage or even mistresses. Arab pesado historians really make me laugh
@@בועזקשת-פ1ד Jizyah is less then muslims mandatory zakat (charity). Zakat is 2.5% of savings, so imagine jizyah. In Islam you cannot force non muslims to pay zakat as they do not believe in islam to have that obligation. So to pay for their defence and security like all over the world they paid a tax. Simple, its away of stake in the society. Its not like they were forced to join the miltary. In uk we have 40% tax. No one feels degraded. The rich get tax lawyers and avoid paying tax, no one cares. As a general rule in islam, whether your muslim or non muslim if your poor then you do not have to pay zakat or jizyah, its means dependant. Allah swt made islam easy for us.
@@salampakistan3691 no it was 2nd class thats just a writing of history poor jews who couldnt pay were forced to convert of die and maimo called islam a curse
Harmony under Muslim rule; that is insane. That would be golden calf go back to Egypt mind set. Isaac was the sacrifice not Ishmael and many other fraudulent things Muslim claim. 🤔
Isaac and Ishmael are brothers and both are proponents of their Fathers Monotheistic Faith. Pre-Islam Ishmaelites are monotheist very much similar to Isaacites-Israelites. The Arabic Caliphate were the ones who introduced Islam (for political and ethnical reasons) a monotheistic concept very similar to Judaic Monotheism but with additional concepts of the Philosophies of JC (PBUH) and Mhmd (PBUH) accepted as prophecies, for those of the Ishmaelite descendants that has little interaction and communication with their Isaacite cousins, Islam was the closest form of the Monotheism they knew . Though it could be also a possibility that was the option made available to them by ruling Caliphates. It would but be fair to assume that a Jew and a Muslim can share a room in prayer and a Christian will be the odd one out in a different room.
isaac and ishmael are not exiset the are just in your miand .Jehovah is the Canaanite Lord of storms. You madmen, God does not exist. You must worship His Majesty as God
Just a question, why does Maimonides tell Jewish people to marry their nieces ? Isn't that incest and sexual abuse ? Why does Maimonides not tell them to venture out into the world, leave their nieces alone in peace and stop lusting after their relatives ?
Rambam/Maimonides is guilty over issuing the _heter iska,_ which is arguably not as bad as the traitor Hillel the Elder has done with his _prosbul,_ but of a similar vein and similar destruction of the Torah. There are no Orthodox Jews in the world. They are _all_ reformers, who thought they knew better. If only they at least understood as much as the Torah of Moshe Rabbeinu, perhaps they would have done some good. But sadly, they do not. I don't need to explain why the prosbul or heter iska are bad. Read them, read the Torah, and it is self explanatory. Rambam is Jewish corruption. They replaced God as the lawmaker, with lawmakers of their own choosing, who serve the rich and greedy, not justice and peace. The result is their never ending exile. I think the exile will not end, until Hillel and Rambam fall, although even that will probably not be enough (the Jubilee on land, or something other of similar severity, needs to be enacted and dutifully followed). It is interesting that on his tomb stone, they make this Rambam close to equal to Moshe Rabbeinu, and they also devalue everyone who came after Moshe Rabbeinu, which includes all the prophets and true loyalists like King David who wrote the Psalms (in which it is said, the righteous do not take interest, iirc). Rambam wasn't even an authenticated prophet, and his innovation over the Torah is fraud (which also means, he can not even become a prophet, under the law of prophets, FWIK). Why do they put this man over all these good people ? Because they serve the rich and greedy, who want to scheme around to increase their money at all cost, and Rambam helps them do it, as did Hillel the Elder, the traitor. The world is lost. The consequences will become extreme. Per curses section in the Torah, the next round will be 7 times worse. The last punishment was the Nazis. Time is up also, the humans have gone insane with their nukes and war lust, their shallowness and their inability to create stability. GAME OVER. How awful, a world of fools with nukes. It cannot be, and it will not be for long. It is extremely unstable and self destructive.
How is it possible that you don't mention the fact that he was Saladin's personal physician?!!
Yeah he's taught as a hero in our schools, weird how they missed that out.
@@moislam3804
He didn't had any big love for arabs or muslims at all. Read the letter he sent to the jews of yemen
@@בועזקשת-פ1ד The truth is that Jewish history has to be read in the context of the time. Do you think he would have preferred to live under crusader rule, where Jews where burnt as children of the devil?
@@moislam3804
Sure not, the muslims at the midle ages were the lesser of 2 evils for the jews. When the economy prosperd the islamic dhimi rules were not enforced but it could change really fast every time things went badly
@@בועזקשת-פ1ד Of course, no Muslim denies, that. So it would make sense to mention that one of the greatest Jewish philosophers was the chief physician of another giant figure of not only Muslim but Western history.
No mention of reversing Apostacy ideas and that he went to fix the Kariate problem, which was devolving Judaism. A Jew is a Jew is a Jew is a Jew, no matter FORCED CONVERSION at the sword by The CALIPHATE or CHRISTIANITY. Thanks for saving Marranos and essentialy putting the Kol Nidre into full effect. I'm a descendant of Rashi, but you are my "Grandpa", too, Rambam.
Rambam had extraordinary clarity and vision.
Thank you
okay you explaiend the histroy but you barely touched upon his theolgoy and conception of judaism, and briefly explained why he was controversial. 10/10 for history, 3/10 for philopshy of rambam
Sam Aronows Maimonides history was much more complete.
Sam actually wrote an episode for us that is coming out in a few weeks! There's definitely no reason that you can't have two videos that compliment each other.
It is called "Treatise on Logic", not "Treaties".
He was also Doctor Islam ruler
Dhimmi is a non-muslim under protection of muslim law/ peotected persons
WAllah Jewish people are decent people (both secular and non secular) . I live in the west and I have recently moved to an area where there are many Jewish people and have found them to be great people. I prefer living among Jewish people than my original town which is majority Muslim. Allah is witness, this is the truth in my personal experience. Allah/G-D loves truth.
This is reality David all this israel
Too short a video to cover the life and work of Maimonides....
proud to be a spanish sephardi jew🇪🇸✡️
Me too 😊
Rambam to Jewish spiritual and theology probably could be considered co-equal with Al-Ghazali to Islamic spiritual and theology.
Yes, & probably also considered co-equal to St. Thomas Aquinans in regards to Christian spiritual & theology.
As an Egyptian I am so proud that outstanding Andalusian man lived much of life in my country and was one of Saladin's consultants
I'm proud to be a jew ✡️ 💙 ❤️
🕎🕎 this is the symbol
Why did him being a doctor lead to video game music 😂
Thank you thank you so much for this short but great video regarding Rambam, although personally I am a bigger fan of Rashi... Nevertheless I might end up being a Sephardic convert to Judaism depending on my parent's ancestry.
The next episode is about Rashi!
@@UNPACKED yeah and I can't Waite for it...so so excited and waiting because unpacked's research is far deeper and spiritually uplifting.
Sephard ‘
"Is Moses Maimonides an unacknowledged ancestor of the psychoanalytic movement? In this book, David Bakan, Dan Merkur, and David S. Weiss look at the great medieval Jewish philosopher's prescription for the cure of souls and its psychological significance. In the Guide of the Perplexed, Maimonides, who was also a physician, describes the soul's illness: when sinners rationalize evil as good, they limit their capacities to reason, imagine, and behave well, which also produces physical symptoms. The cure depends on repentance in love and fear of God that is attained through philosophical knowledge, the interpretation of dreams and visions, and mystical contemplation. The authors look at the Aristotelian background of Maimonides' psychology, Maimonidean mysticism, his beliefs about prophecy and sexuality, and what is known of Maimonides' client population. A final chapter discusses Maimonides and Freud, noting that many distinctive features of the cure of souls are shared by Freud's original formulation of psychoanalysis. Indeed, the many points of convergence suggest Freud's direct or indirect contact with Maimonides' legacy."
he became a doctor xD hahaha got me good
Famous Rabinic Books :
1. Kitab al-Amanat wa’l-I’tiqadat (Emunot V’deiot-“The Book of Beliefs and Opinions”), by Rabbi Saadiah Gaon
2. Kitab Al Hidayah ila Faraid al-Qulub (Chovot HaLevavot-“Duties of the Heart”), by Rabbeinu Bachya
3.Kitab al-Ḥujjah wal-Dalil fi Nuṣr al-Din al-Dhalil (The Kuzari-“A Defense of the Despised Faith”), by Rabbi Yehudah HaLevi
4.Maqala Fi-Sinat Al-Mantiq (Millot HaHiggayon-“Treatise on Logical Terminology”), by Maimonides
5. Kitab al-Siraj (Peirush HaMishnayot-“Commentary on the Mishnah”), by Maimonides
6. Kitab al-Farai'd (Sefer HaMitzvot-“Book of Commandments”), by Maimonides
7. Dalalat al-Ha'rin (Moreh Nevuchim-“Guide for the Perplexed”), by Maimonides
Rambam lived with muslims and studies ibnu sina and ibnu ghazi books.when christian persucuted jews muslim ruler hired them in high ranking.
he hated islam... he though it was a curse from god
The lord commands us to do bless those who curse u and love your enemies, do good to those who hate u. So you actually made a point to prove MAIMONIDES was holy
Do you know this series is based on the book Letters to Auntie Fori by Martin Gilbert.
Here Auntie Fori is none other than Shobha Nehru (aunt of Jawaharlal Nehru)
תודה רבה
Jehovah is the Canaanite Lord of storms. You madmen, God does not exist. You must worship His Majesty as God
What is the music used here?
Maimonides was influenced by al Farabi
Muslim arab read histories jewish isrsel
💯💯💯
4:23 Rambam's legacy
Moses David this name christian
A good summary considering the length!
Hhhh seriously ? So, they fled the "persecution" by going to the " oppressors " home turf. 🤥🤥
Different Caliphates with different policies
It is well to remember that this Rabbi is a racist.
He states in his book "A Guide for the Perplexed" that people of the
steppe (Turks) and blacks are neither fully human nor fully animal
but in-between the two.
In the Jewish law, a "non- fully human " means that not all of the mitsvot (laws of the Torah) apply to.
And- this book is written in codes, which is because he didn't want uneducated people to read it and misunderstand it, and then go about and speaking bad about it. Educate yourself.
ממושה עד מושה אין מושה😊
I am descended from Rambam.Much of what he taught comes from the teachings of Muhammad. eat until your stomach is one-third full, drink a third and leave a third air.
Golden age, if i am not forgotten thomas aquinas's summa theologia or his other books being used to brainswahed muslim and jews in andalusia during the spanish inquisition. That book debating muslim ashari-maturidi school on the basis of aristotelian philosophy and debating jewish base on the old testament , i wonder who these book from Musa bin Maimun can stand thomas aquinas's books, aquino attacking maimonides and averroes
Tell me more, about this issue!
@@adenioilham2407 forced conversion because the fall of Granada. Search "mouriscos"
I understand that Moshe Maimonides, Mosa Ben Maimoun or RamBam was a great doctor who healed many people. However, I was very traumatized when I saw he encourages uncle and niece marriage as a mitzvah and the best marriage possible when it is horrible incest and abuse and brings very ill kids. How come most Jews don't marry their nieces nor direct nor close cousins and are therefore avoiding being extremely ill, sexually abusive, incestuous and traumatizing generation to generation. Just a question, why does Maimonides tell Jewish people to marry their nieces ? Isn't that incest and sexual abuse ? Why does Maimonides not tell them to venture out into the world, leave their nieces alone in peace and stop lusting after their relatives ?
Science: Man is not a sinner
Niece is not one of those that are not allowed to marry. Why is that incest? Is cousin incest? I mean don't get me wrong, it's not acceptable to do that today but that's bec our culture has changed not the objective idea of incest. Incest is what the Torah determines as incest otherwise not.
Dhimmi meaning
a person living in a region overrun by Muslim conquest who was accorded a protected status and allowed to retain his or her original faith.
Not second class citizens. The muslims were obligated to pay compulsory zakat to state to help the poor (old welfare system) but non muslims were free from that obligation, they were required to pay some 2% on some form of income to get protected status and to have a stake in the society, simple.
You forgot the part that they are not allowed to carry weapons, that they have to bring the jizzah tax (which sometimes reached 50% of their income) on their knees, that they are not allowed to build new synagogues, that they are not allowed to testify against Muslims in court or hold public office and of course permission to take their daughters For marriage or even mistresses. Arab pesado historians really make me laugh
@@בועזקשת-פ1ד
Jizyah is less then muslims mandatory zakat (charity). Zakat is 2.5% of savings, so imagine jizyah.
In Islam you cannot force non muslims to pay zakat as they do not believe in islam to have that obligation. So to pay for their defence and security like all over the world they paid a tax. Simple, its away of stake in the society. Its not like they were forced to join the miltary.
In uk we have 40% tax. No one feels degraded. The rich get tax lawyers and avoid paying tax, no one cares.
As a general rule in islam, whether your muslim or non muslim if your poor then you do not have to pay zakat or jizyah, its means dependant. Allah swt made islam easy for us.
"Protected status" sounds very mafia ish
@@MSHOOD123 like Israel
@@salampakistan3691 no it was 2nd class thats just a writing of history poor jews who couldnt pay were forced to convert of die and maimo called islam a curse
Harmony under Muslim rule; that is insane. That would be golden calf go back to Egypt mind set. Isaac was the sacrifice not Ishmael and many other fraudulent things Muslim claim. 🤔
Isaac and Ishmael are brothers and both are proponents of their Fathers Monotheistic Faith.
Pre-Islam Ishmaelites are monotheist very much similar to Isaacites-Israelites.
The Arabic Caliphate were the ones who introduced Islam (for political and ethnical reasons) a monotheistic concept very similar to Judaic Monotheism but with additional concepts of the Philosophies of JC (PBUH) and Mhmd (PBUH) accepted as prophecies, for those of the Ishmaelite descendants that has little interaction and communication with their Isaacite cousins, Islam was the closest form of the Monotheism they knew .
Though it could be also a possibility that was the option made available to them by ruling Caliphates.
It would but be fair to assume that a Jew and a Muslim can share a room in prayer and a Christian will be the odd one out in a different room.
The Jewish golden occurred under Muslim rule.
isaac and ishmael are not exiset the are just in your miand .Jehovah is the Canaanite Lord of storms. You madmen, God does not exist. You must worship His Majesty as God
Just a question, why does Maimonides tell Jewish people to marry their nieces ? Isn't that incest and sexual abuse ? Why does Maimonides not tell them to venture out into the world, leave their nieces alone in peace and stop lusting after their relatives ?
You wouldn't understand it unless you walk with God. Rambam seems to have replaced God in the orthodox eyes?
No, he hasn't.
stop projecting
Rambam/Maimonides is guilty over issuing the _heter iska,_ which is arguably not as bad as the traitor Hillel the Elder has done with his _prosbul,_ but of a similar vein and similar destruction of the Torah. There are no Orthodox Jews in the world. They are _all_ reformers, who thought they knew better. If only they at least understood as much as the Torah of Moshe Rabbeinu, perhaps they would have done some good. But sadly, they do not. I don't need to explain why the prosbul or heter iska are bad. Read them, read the Torah, and it is self explanatory. Rambam is Jewish corruption. They replaced God as the lawmaker, with lawmakers of their own choosing, who serve the rich and greedy, not justice and peace. The result is their never ending exile. I think the exile will not end, until Hillel and Rambam fall, although even that will probably not be enough (the Jubilee on land, or something other of similar severity, needs to be enacted and dutifully followed).
It is interesting that on his tomb stone, they make this Rambam close to equal to Moshe Rabbeinu, and they also devalue everyone who came after Moshe Rabbeinu, which includes all the prophets and true loyalists like King David who wrote the Psalms (in which it is said, the righteous do not take interest, iirc). Rambam wasn't even an authenticated prophet, and his innovation over the Torah is fraud (which also means, he can not even become a prophet, under the law of prophets, FWIK). Why do they put this man over all these good people ? Because they serve the rich and greedy, who want to scheme around to increase their money at all cost, and Rambam helps them do it, as did Hillel the Elder, the traitor. The world is lost. The consequences will become extreme. Per curses section in the Torah, the next round will be 7 times worse. The last punishment was the Nazis. Time is up also, the humans have gone insane with their nukes and war lust, their shallowness and their inability to create stability. GAME OVER. How awful, a world of fools with nukes. It cannot be, and it will not be for long. It is extremely unstable and self destructive.