What is the future for women in Islam?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 17 чер 2024
- Women raised as Muslim debate whether there’s a place for them in Islam during a panel at the 2016 Women in the World Summit in New York City.
The panel features:
Ayaan Hirsi Ali, Founder, AHA Foundation and Fellow, Harvard Kennedy School
Farah Pandith, Adjunct Senior Fellow, Council on Foreign Relations
Zahra' Langhi, Co-Founder & Director, Libyan Women’s Platform for Peace
Hibaaq Osman, Founder and CEO, Karama
Moderated by Barkha Dutt Director, Barkha Dutt Live Media
Ms Barkha, yes child marriage exists in Hindu society but is illegal in the modern Hindu code law, whereas it is legal in Sharia and nobody has the guts to change it. That is the difference!
Exactly....
True
Yes 🙏
Muslim invasion was reason for child marriage in India. Do some research Barkha.
To challenge growing muslim population. Hindus started child marriages. In ancient times of Indian civilization there was no child marriages. Siddharth (Gautam Buddha) & Vardhaman (Mahavir) were married at age of 24 & 25 respectively.
In ayurveda & other indian religious scriptures, it is clearly mentioned that marriage age of man should be equal to or greater than 24 & for women it should be greater than 18.
Yes in hindu society also had child marriages, sati pratha but we made law against it. Now it's illegal. We had the guts to accept the fault.
Barkha must wear burqa
People made Sati Pratha on their own. Sati Pratha isn't a practice in any of Hinduism Holy Scriptures.
@@simpleguy38 lol
No religious book have supported Sati .Learn first .There is difference between Religious short coming and Cultural Short comins
Ae had child marriage not child intercourses okkk. Also marriage was done between child not with uncles. Get your data correct before ur brainwashed.
For all the non-Indians watching this, I would like to give the good news that Barkha Dutt, one of the most 'prominent' journalists of India in 2016 has been kicked out of TV channels and is now surviving as a UA-camr.
Not surprised
Good! She appears to be a muslim sympathizer...maybe because she was married to two Muslim men?
Haha LOL
Thank you
How can barkha shamelessly bring Hinduism in every defamatory argument? The show had nothing to do with Hindus and Hinduism, but she was like victim of every kind of assault, oppression, exploitation trying to express her anger on it. The practices of child marriage has been rejected in Hinduism long back ago, but see how confidently she has been quoting it like a brain-dead. And what amazes us is, Still she is anchoring shows like this.
Exactly....
She doesn't have guts to do the same with other religion. Reason?? Everyone knows.
She is not doing her interview professionally by projecting her own experiences of being a women in India and relationship with hinduism when clearly the show is suppose to be focused on Islam and womens perspective on it.
Such a shameless lady..barkhaaa
@@shamanth979 What's the reason?
Would like to know. Seriously.
I don't what's wrong with her wiring in her brain and her malfunctioning logic.
Equally ugly from inside to outside.
What a waste of Ayaan's time ! These women have no right to share the stage with her.
Alex, you said it
You are right Alex
Why she wear blue panties on head? 😂😂😂😂
As specially , The anchor , Barkha Dutt , she is one of the anti indian leftist journalist..
@Alex Stuck- totally true!
A kind request to Ayaan Hirsi Ali. Please arrange a permanent residential status for barkha dutt in somalia. Let her continue the freedom of speech with al-shabaab or pirates. We are ready sponsor her tickets or expenses.
lol true
If Ayaan Ali is right, then what is the reason of millions of Muslim women residing in the western civilization are adopting Islamic Way of Life? The other question is why then more women are converting to Islam than men? Finally, why at least 700 million Muslim ladies would not forsake Islam?
that is such bullshit...you are reading the wrong statistics.....muslim women are leaving islam by the droves. It is under your stupid nose but you are ignoring the facts.
+Syn Hope many women travelled to Islamic state to be jihadi brides? just because it's a big number, doesn't make it right. and sharia makes it very hard for people to leave the religion of Islam.
hahahahaha
Nobody:
Literally nobody:
Barkha Dutt: Hinduism
😂😂.
She is so obsessed with Hindu hate that she doesn't miss an opportunity to defame it.
yeah clowns like you are praising ayan for speaking against islam but bashing barkha for speaking against Hindus 😂😂
@@vikings_9408 so ayan speaking against islam is ok
but barkha speaking against Hindusm is not 😂
@@karlhans4116 the topic is future of women in islam not Hinduism
@@meghnaverma9364 Yeah she definitely can use example from hindu countries or christian countries to show that It's not about Religion but about region and Cultural norm
I support Ayaan for stating what is right.
This debate is 4 against 1. They thought all 4 together will suppress Ayan, but salute to Ayan she nailed all...
One of the speakers was not inconsistent with the 1, SWD. She didn't make it as 'politically incorrect" of a statement. I heard some valid points from the other women, but you are right that Ayaan made the most compelling argument. There was too much talking at once, though.
Ayan is tough love
Ayan shows what she is; educated and articulate. She’s streets ahead. She should sit back & let the other 4 fall into the hole they’ve dug for themselves.
Every educated person understand position of islam and muslim towards other people and world. Few idiots think they can fool world by dressing well and talking good about islam and muslim. But world is not going to eat shit if you put it beautifully in a decorated plate.
That is how evil Barkha Dutt conducts her shows. She packs her panel in such a way that supports her agenda. Ayan gives tight slap to this evil.
Other than Ayaan they seem to want to protect Islam more than they want to protect women and girls. No wonder the Muslim women suffer so much.
+Daisy Jane Pink exactly.
+Daisy Jane Pink So to the point. This is what religious dogma has gained throughout the years; protection of it's bogus doctrine while people, mostly women, suffer agonizing physical and psychological abuse. Great comment!
Islam will in turn protect women🥰
the response of ayaan hirsi is so timeless that I remembered her response 6 years after she gave this response to burkha dutt. ayaan is a superstar.
Barkha Dutt is one of the most insensitive human and she isn't Indian by mentality only guided by hatred philosophies
She doesn't need an opportunity to defame India and Hinduism.
@Wmd Tman though being married to anyone doesn't defines anything for me but yeah individual thoughts and decorum do on platforms like these!! India is my mother land and I would rather solve my issues or work for it rather then blabbering about my issues outside to be mocked upon by others...
@@Researchscholar_IGNOU I am an ex muslim...is hinduism is bad or not.? ...I believe in jesus christ but I trust hindu gods
@@livecreative531 well ,it doesn't force you to do anything definitely 😁
@@livecreative531 Hinduism is the equivalent of liberal democracy of religions. There are diverse practices and traditions, but the underlying core belief is the same. There isn't one book, instead there is a library. There are several schools of thought that ponder upon this life, each with their own philosophy. It's up to you to seek the knowledge that you want.
"It tells more about life after death than life before death"
~Ayan
These were literally the words of wisdom!
hats off to ayaan n to you too for this comment!👍👍👍
Because this life is temporary not eternal. This life is kept as test for another life.if you believe in logic and rational thinking then think why there is no equality amoung all human beings on this planet in terms of misery, domination of evil over good etc ,etc.if world is an eternal place then there world be no so many world wars and conflicts. So this world is temporary so God tells us about things in life also and in case more about life after death then that is to tell that there is far better world/And life than this world to achieve that and to make humans understand that what kind of creations he already have with him and what is this world /This creation is.if you y believe in tru religion you will understand this or other wise if you are driven by devil you will not understand it like ayaan who is not at all educated about Islam. She forms her opinions based on some individuals in Islam or she is already atheist and motivated by devil to fallow her patha. If she is really educated and believes in logic tell her to debate in front of whole world with zaker naik. Inshallah he will try to remove dust from her soul if at all she is true and honest person.
Whatever is there ,it is in this life only ,there is no afterlife . Whatever bad you do you have to pay it in this life only .
yeah they think about the life after death
@@azmathkhanofficial413 bro today is truth understand it nobody knows what happen after life love the nature
Barkha Dutt when you don't wanted to listen why you were taking interview? Ayaan.. You go girl... More power to you..
*Why Allah's allowed Muhammed married 6 year old baby girl Aishah and let him to f... her when she is 9?*
*Why Muslims considered Muhammed to be their prophet thats also without any prophesy?*
One lion against four duplicates? Ayaan live long !
Zahra Langhi says there's nothing in Islam that needs to be Reformed!!! And that's the most orthodox, conservative mindset. Ayaan Hirsi Ali more power to you.... Keep shining.
Islam is a foolish religion, I support ayaan
Look how burkha became angry when mahmood is criticized
So the rumours are true
I guess it's not my department because I'm neither a woman nor a Muslim but as a free thinker I feel like telling something. Ms/ Mrs Dutt asks Ms Ali that why is she picking on Islam and I'm like isn't that the reason for her to be on this panel, bruh! And then Ms Ali says 'thank you' gently, on her reply and I'm like.... now that's a hero I'm looking at.
No rumour..she is a Muslim..Barkha bano
🤣🤣🤣
@@daredevil5267 🤣🤣🤣🤣 barkha baano
@@sejalsonkar848 😜
Ayaan looks the only one who can actually think there.
Islam is hopeless religion
@@zahidmushtaq2891 christianity is the most following religion in the world.
@@zahidmushtaq2891 making pigs of womens to just eat sleep produce babies and repeat
Why do you think it wont be most followed
@@zahidmushtaq2891 yes because they sre forced by terriorist to follow..they aren't following willingly
@@zahidmushtaq2891 hahaha...i think u need to look at some facts.
I was watching this interview to see how many times Barkha was insulted😂😂.
Lol😂😂
I was Also looking for same 👍👍👍
Funny fellow🤣
Same here
She is used to 😄😄
Remembering what Alfred said
"Some people just want to watch the world burn".
Barkha dutt and her club are those people.
*Why Allah's allowed Muhammed married 6 year old baby girl Aishah and let him to f... her when she is 9?*
*Why Muslims considered Muhammed to be their prophet thats also without any prophesy?*
ayaan is the only woman with a brain
true
indeed
VERY BAD! DO NOT RENAME YOUR OWM MOM
BEGAIRAT MAA KA BETA BEGAIRAT HOGA,
Nathan...I agree,all the others are too indoctrinated...
Bakhra Dutt doesn't misses an opportunity to defame hinduism and India. Hats off to Ayan Ali for being so bold and reasonable.
#barkhadutt is Anti Hindu
BCZ ITS GOES AGAINST HINDU RELIGION...BARKHA IS NT RYT..IF AYAN SAYS ANYTHING AGAINST ISLAM THEN SHE IS BOLD...WELL STUPIDITY AT ITS BEST...
@storm raider whr is the proof pleas share
@storm raider correct and i tottaly agree with you even though i have same thought as you have. Nice to hear that
@Mangifera indica sita mata was not married at the age of six. Her age was more than 18 years at the time of marriage. Read the books if you want to get some knowledge. 2nd think we don't have any problem with burka but as you know suicide bomber wearing so its difficult to identify whether man or women inside burka. 3rd is you talking about ghoonghat we can see that only her face is covered so we can identify she is caring bomb with her or not. But in burka can u identify is she caring bomb or not.
This discussion is worthy of watching only because of Aiyan Ali. She is the jewel among them.
Ayan, Kudos to you! You nailed it by saying not to be silenced by labeling as Islamophobic when one tries to address the problems within Islam.
Should have been titled "when 4 unintelligent hens tried to argue with Ayaan."
That blue hijab woman is so much in denial
🤣🤣😂😂👏👏🙏🙏🙏
Who told you ayaan is intelligent .he is islamophobic and hater of islam.he interprets islam wrongly
@@muhammadishaqmuhammadishaq764 oooye gadhe pehle padh to le... She
@@muhammadishaqmuhammadishaq764 lol every intellectual follower of Islam is always Islamophobic becoz Ur religion is a shit
Apart from Ayan I understood no one in this discussion.
They were all speaking at same time.
Let me assure you women are the same everywhere. I had a laugh because they made me remember women around me! So funny.
And, yes... I am a woman too.
How true it is.same here.
Agree
*Why Allah's allowed Muhammed married 6 year old baby girl Aishah and let him to f... her when she is 9?*
*Why Muslims considered Muhammed to be their prophet thats also without any prophesy?*
Ayan : "Shut up all, I am the SME, you all are paid part timers"😂
4 islamic ladies on international forum to talk about sharia and ladies in islam but barkha keeps bringing up unrelated false alegations of other religion.
God save journalism
every awkward and weird fact about islam and prophet Muhammad got barkha so embarrassed that she starts comparing it with Hinduism and Christians, that it happens in India too..this happens among Christians too. barkha such an islamist.
In Hinduism And Others Religions More Then Dear Faces The Truth....And Do Research About Islam If You Belief On These Ladies Who’s Nothings Knows About Islam
Why is Govinda moderating the debate?
+Motorwala Xoom ahahaha
+Motorwala Xoom bwahahaha
+Motorwala Xoom too good :D :D
I hope I could post my laughter here. A mere bwahahahaha is not enough!!
+Motorwala Xoom ROFL
I have read Ayaan's life story and other books penned by her. I have the deepest respect for this bold lady.
I love ayaan, she is a great woman
We Muslims ar not looking for from people like u but from the almighty Allah if all she's saying about Islam true why can't she debate a real Muslim Scholars she will not do that because she knows she will be exposed for all the lies she's been brainwashing you with...
Barkah did her best to equate fringe practices of Hinduism with prominent practices or Sharia... The same fringe practices which are totally rejected by vast majority of the Hindus.. Hinduism has been evolving and that's the beauty of it..
True. In India not even a single mosque allows women. She is equating that with one Hindu temple not allowing women.
What a shame.
@@gmediagroupss A single mosque does not Allow women? What are you on about?
@@silentsword1161 I dont know which country u r from? But in India women are not allowed into mosques for prayer.
@@gmediagroupss Really... well I don't live in India so in truth I can't say anything.
But... I want to point out that in Islam women are allowed to pray in mosques.
@@silentsword1161 Thats ok. You can know it if u want to know. Just goole it
Ayaan Hirsi Ali hits the nail on its head while others just try to be as diplomatic as possible at times even attacking Ayaan for being blunt and to the point. Bow to this lady with brains!
😂😂😂
Agree
Other women are trying to suppress the reality she is speaking about their religion
They have let down women who have no voice only aynna is the best for women who are being oppressive to women
New Hampshire and MASSACHUSETTS Age of consent to marry with parental consent for males is 14; for females is 13 exactly as in Iran.
Barka dutt is Shamelessness personified 🔥🔥🤣🤣🤣
Barkha's strike rate - now landing on her cheeks!!
Thank you, Ayan. You shine! Love from Bharat 🇮🇳 ❤️
”Can we please for just these 30 minutes focus on the topic” damn Ayaan you got me.
That line was so satisfying
It's so true, because every time anyone talks about anything bad that has to do with Islam, you'll ALWAYS get these "but what about" responses, as if that somehow nullifies or justifies the bad things in Islam. You'll hear, "but but but, what about the Bible and Christianity? Mary was age 12 when she gave birth to Jesus", or "But but what about King Henry who had a wife who was age 13? Why don't you talk about that? Yeah, talk about them instead!" As opposed to "that's a good point about x, y, or z. I'll explain the reason for this...". You rarely hear someone talking about, for example, baseball, and have someone chime in and say, "But what about basketball?! In basketball they also...". It almost ALWAYS happens when discussion Islam and religion and it's an elementary way of "arguing".
Got me too. She got the guts. No show off
Mackline Viegas Huh?
Ayan is a SuPeR WoMaN
Rest r KaLaNK on WoMeN
Burkha Dutt, Hindu Child marriages in India is punishable by Indian law and even Hindu religion do not advocate such marriages.Its a practice in illiterate, some rural part of India, while Islam is fine with such kind of marriages.
Also may I add a child marrying a child. Not old men marrying six year olds and waiting for them to turn 9.
llwiishll no miss illiterate that's incorrect
..she, stupid fellow, even doesnt know that if she ll say child marriage as crime in Islam, she wld be beheaded by Islamic extremist who she is supporting for!
I dont understand wht level of stupidity she carries and how irrational thought she has against Hindu!
llwiishll Excellent Point
@@toptechviral where did u get this nonscence frm....
A God who says hell for those who don't believe in him cannot be a God.
It's like my father telling me if you don't trust me,you'll rot in hell.
Such is you God.
Unbelievable,isn't it?
Quran Says
No compulsion in religion
@@inaaranur1611 then why are apostates given a death sentence in Islam
@@inaaranur1611 What is the penalty for apostasy in Islam?
I am quoting Richard Dawkins. You answer that.
Hell is not your father's property. The more logical analogy would be: "if you don't obey your father, you can sleep in the barn and don't enter the house!" Or when a father tells his son: "Your siblings trust me, why don't you? Are you even my son?"
@@hudandardiriasfaq9828 the barn doesn't keep roasting you though doesn't it
Hypocrisy of Burkha Dutt is unparallel in the whole solar system...
It is very unfair to bring a brilliant woman like Ayan Hirsi Ali to debate with such shallow minds such as Zahra and Hibaaq.
+Thalamus Syri
Hibaaq was the worst.
Step 1- 'Human rights do not supercede religious rights!'
Step 2 - Stonings, beheadings, amputations
+Thalamus Syri YOU SAID IT! NONIE DARWESH,WAFA SULTAN AND ANN BARNHARDT SHOULD HAVE BEEN INVITED,THAT WOULD HAVE MADE HE DEBATE MEANING FULL. PERHAPS PAMELLA GELER ALSO!
+Thalamus Syri what about burkha ?? she is also a shallow minded person..
+Thalamus Syri >>>Ayan Hirsi Ali is an active run away malfeasance in her home land. you can cuddle and kiss such a superlative Muslim dissembler!
Farah Pandit is too much fluff.. she is just connecting random buzzwords with little meaning..
+Akshay Gee Yeah - the word that sprang to mind for me was 'deepity'. It all sounded very profound and insightful, but she really said absolutely nothing of value.
i agree.
Rt..nationalviews.com/barkha-dutt-muslim-husband-personal-life
+Akshay Gee Pandith is hindu kashmiri convert,aurangzeb muhdicked her ancestors
+Akshay Gee That was absolutely useless discourse.. pure PC crap with no real meaning
These women were uninformed about Islam except Ayan
Who here hates barkha dutt ? I'm expecting 1.4 billion likes 👍
Hats off Ayan for standing up to 4 Muslim apologists, the most vocal of whom is Burqa Dutt, comparing India to ISIS held Iraq and Syria.
Can Naxals be compared to ISIS?
@@shoaibmemon9557 nah naxals are xommists morons bit they aren't religiously driven. Religiously driven ones control. Communists can be de raducalised . U can't derasicalised if u consider liter interpretating of Quran to justify anti nonmuslim hatred man
😆😆😆nailed the burqa so badli
Well Ayan is a liar so yeah go ahead mad admire a lier that's what fools always do
@@shoaibmemon9557 Naxals are Maoist and athiest?? What's your logic ?
I like how the moderator talks about how there's misogyny in other religions, but then scolds Aayan for talking about Sharia. How can you talk about women's rights in Islam without talking about Sharia? That has more relevance than Donald Trump.
This debate wasn't even fair. Even though the 3 apologists and the moderator were against Aayan, she blew them all out of the water.
+Curtis Fowler She is an Indian media lady who is known to be biased and always hijack the conversation and an attention seeker. What your observations are here , are being that of Indian media viewers for number of years.
The topic was about women in islam and I don't know how Donald Trump came into the convo plus trashing him is a popular choice to win the crowd. Who knows he can be potential POTUS and wouldn't be surprised if Barkha dutt has to interview him and what Trump would say then. Barkha will then realize she should not take anything for showmanship
+Curtis Fowler she is the most hated journalist in india she was involved in multi million dollars scams and also hates the hindu majority to its core, by the orders of her masters who are hardcore pro leftist /centrist pseudo secular
+Curtis Fowler LOL, you're right.No body gives a damn to her debates, programs. We came over to watch this video bcoz ayaan gave her a tight slap not to stray offtopic as she does always. She is pro-muslim, biased, involved in lots of scams. Other 3 ladies are also islamists only Ayaan was giving unbiased views. Last thing, but more imp, we understand HER Husband is a hardline muslim
+Curtis Fowler burka dutt and her news channel is famous in India for supporting jihadis view
Yes you're right NDTV, India Today, Indian Express and The Print are Pro-Jihadi media
Barkha Dutt tried to indulge in whataboutery and tried to drag in Hinduism to digress from criticism of Islam and Ayan Hirsi Ali shot her down immediately
Body posture matters - Check them out.
Ayan, the confident, level headed warrior!
"Islam gives women all the rights they need" she doesn't know Islam at all. And she goes on to say "Human rights do not supersede religious rights". Can only imagine what kind of reform she can bring.
And as usual Ayan was bold in pointing out the evils of Quran and the self proclaimed prophet. Hats off to her.
"all the rights they need" do not mean all the rights they want. Women only need to be able to eat and breathe to live. As always, they are more slippery than lubricant.
This was absolutely shocking according to her all countries should practice Islam then as opposed to human rights. Where's freedom of religion? 😮
Poorly moderated. Failed to steer the panel into a meaningful and sensible discourse. Lack of clarity and direction is perhaps the outcome of Moderator's fuzzy mindset. Only Ayaan comes through with some credibility and conviction. Rest of them, including Barkha, were just dishing out meaningless innuendos and un-synchronized pieces.
Exactly..
This debate was 1 against 4 and Ayaan won single handedly.
For a second,imagine a world without Islam.
It has certainly caused much more ruckus than the good it did and the good could have happened by teaching simple morality too.
Child marriage use to happens in india but it happen between same age kids ..which now is stopped .. not a 9 year old girl marrying 90 year old man with 10 wives
Yup, and after their marriage they weren't allowed to meet each other until they become adults,
It also thought them their responsibilities...
90 year old man? who are you talking about?
And their so called God has done that..raped a 9 yrs innocent girl. What kind of God does that.
@@silentsword1161 u know him as mhd
With ten wifes 🤣🤣🤣🤣well said
Doctor: I am a cancer specialist. ..
Darkha: You know from where I speak. ..I have piles..why only cancer why not talk about Piles too?
Doctor : What would you rather have...cancer or piles
well said Bro about pseudo reverse secularist and pseudo feminist, Barkha and her supporters are pseudo reverse hypocrate, Ayaan is Real feminist and Real Hero
😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂
😂 😂 Let's talk about butter milk 🥛.. 🔥
😄😄 burkha Is so obsessed with propagating negatives of Hindu culture which Hindus themselve evolved before the world knew it ....she quotes examples of 200 years of practice
More power to women like Ayaan hirsi Ali!
Ayaan Hirsi Ali makes a good argument with reason and poise.
this debate is worth to watch only because of Ayan
Yeah some people didnt evolve properly
Yes u are absolutely right, she is very brave & honest
woman
@@harrysaluja9890 Burkha is truly representing your sick Endian mentality ...this is what all mad and hyper Endian hosts do when they invite a guest and he happens to talk against their planted game,specially a Pakistani...!
@@tarzanbatter1556 The fu*k's wrong with you, none of'em is a Pakistani. And it's "Indian" and not "Endian", you illiterate schnook.
Who’s that?
I only watch it for Ayan
I also
Ayyan was well cautious as it is teaching of atheist to remain cool at public
Me too.
Ayaan... Go girl💕
Barkha dutt is crazy! I don't know which era she lives in! I am an indian hindu girl and I have never been stopped to enter a temple ,I come from a rural area but still never happened that!! She us crazy
You do realize that under sharia law you couldn't speak on that stage
Exactly👍
Really??? Dubai Women not Allow for Speak on Stage??
@@HarshKumar-xt6xn, not without their male owner permission.
@@bellycurious hmmm
@Eslam Saber, you're lying and you know it. What happens with gays under sharia law? And about pre-marital sex? And infidelity in mariage? Apostasy ? Please... Stop with the bullshit. We aren't dumb.
Respect is earned, not demanded.
Do something that earns respect, and I'll respect it.
I respect Ayaan.
She earned my respect.
She's talking with ease and is calm I do respect that part of her but everything she said is not completely true....So I disrespect her for lying
Women oppression isn't in our culture.. It was misinterpreted by some middle ppl...
Hats off to Ayan Ali
And this himad and barkha made everything look good in islam
We want more Leader like Ayan....
.... it seems to me that this "debate" was more about.."lets all have a pop at Ayaan Hirsi Ali".......but it backfired...because I think she stood out as superior to all of them.....
Ayyan is honest in her view but anchor is stupid intentionally dragging Hinduism in debate
The hipocryt anchor is unfortunately an Indian and does always her best to disgrace herself through her ignorance of Hinduism as well as Indian code of law
Jihadis giving money to bakra for acting against hinduism
NIA SHOULD QUESTION BAKRA DUTT IN PROPERWAY USING THIRD DEGREE. She will then womit all the truth about her anti indian activities
@@bandanasharma5356 and you don't have the rights to slaughter your own cow in India imagine
@@ALLAHISENOUGHFORPALASTINE we have lots of pigs here
Wanna eat???
There are five women on the stage and 4 of them made me feel like, These women should should never get equal treatment, at all.
Yes Woman should be educated otherwise you will get to see these kind of debate's .Though ayan was talking sense as whatever she said exists on the ground realities
Sharia is dynamic? Ok. Fine. It means it has changed over time. By *humans*. Then how the hell can it be god's law?
+sorrybhai100 Thanks for using the words from my Mind ..
+sorrybhai100 it means that it is not. simple. duh.
it means the law maker wasn't wise enough to make an appropriate law.
*Muhammed Law*
Ayan speaks with clarity and intelligence. Rest speaking in their messed up mind.
The speaker next to Ayaan made some valid points too. I felt like it was the two on the left vs two ignoramuses on the right
@@jpierce8148 barkha was against ayan too it was the three of them
@@srijanvarma9406 idk. She seemed more objective I guess and tried not to let her own emotions or narrow views affect her statements. Maybe she wasnt completely agreeing with Ayan, but it didnt seem it to me
@@jpierce8148 watch other videos of her or trust me I'm seeing her on tv since childhood she has the same mentality as that of the lady sitting right next to her
Except Ayan what others are saying ...I didn't understand..
Ayaan has the courage to speak the truth as it is.
Ayaan is a gift from God to man kind and common sense.
Ayaan Hirsi Ali is the only intelligent woman on the panel. The others are just in Denial.
universalblob Besides Ayaan all the other are as intelligent as the women described in the Qur'an, (1/2 intelligence of man)!
Disgraceful. Ayaan Hirsi Ali honestly might be the bravest person I know
i agree
She is! Muslims want to kill her for speaking out about actual experiences women are forced into every day being Muslim. So tell me that they are peaceful.
+ThePacemaker45
*If Ayaan was the bravest woman....she will go back to Somalia and show her bravery*
@@evergreenking6117 Fir wat? To get killed? Bravery is speaking against muhammad cult
The lier who was about to be stripped off her Dutch citizenship but saved by the right wing in US?
After seeing this my respect to burqa datt is going down from 0 to minus infinity ♾️
Barkha Dutt says to Ayaan " Why are you picking only on Islam ?" Isn't the topic " What is the future for women in Islam" ?🙄
Why Burkha evading Sharia Question ??
Because she is an Idiot!!
Because that may go on for Ages! 30 mins and its highly localised , when there are different and numerous dimensions.
Intolerant Infidel . Fear.
UtechS exactly...... There is no inherent problem or teaching in Hinduism justifying sati or child marriage.... Actually the started after casteism which was started after foreigners starting to invade India....
To challenge growing muslim population, Hindus started child marriages. In ancient times of Indian civilization there was no child marriages. Siddharth (Gautam Buddha) & Vardhaman (Mahavir) were married at age of 24 & 25 respectively.
In ayurveda & other Indian religious scriptures it is clearly mentioned that marriage age of man should be equal to or greater than 24 & for women it should be greater than 18.
In this interview zhahara langi says sharia is dynamic law. It changes with time.
If sharia is dynamic then why muslim say it God's law.
If sharia law is so dynamic then why muslim in India are against uniform civil code.
Islamic countries behead one who leaves islam. Behead non-muslims
if they try to convert followers of Islam to non-muslims religion. This is all done under apostasy law.
Apostasy in Islam:
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apostasy_in_Islam
Ayaan Hirsi Ali is the light that shines in the darkness. She's an angel!
I agree. she is a hope for Muslim women.
+Santanu Ghosh how can she be hope for muslim women when she's not a muslim herself, silly!! thus she has very little understanding of islam, and degrades islam. if you want to change islam, it has to come from within the respected and trusted circle, not from an outsider, thats the law of every religion. or have you forgotten that?
+ThUrT EilNo She was muslim.. suffered through it, survived the honor killing.. she definitely knows what she's talking about. And you have no clue about reform. The "enlightenment" did not come to christians from within.. it was forced upon them by the social and technological changes of the eighteen century.. people just became less ignorant and the church had no other choice than to abandon temporal power
To challenge growing muslim population & to protect Hindus from islamic invasion & mass murdering of of Hindu people, Hindus started child marriages. In ancient times of Indian civilization there was no child marriages. Siddharth (Gautam Buddha) & Vardhaman (Mahavir) were married at age of 24 & 25 respectively.
In ayurveda & other Indian religious scriptures it is clearly mentioned that marriage age of man should be equal to or greater than 24 & for women it should be greater than 18.
In this interview zhahara langi says sharia is dynamic law. It changes with time.
If sharia is dynamic then why muslim say it God's law.
If sharia law is so dynamic then why muslim in India are against uniform civil code.
Islamic countries behead one who leaves islam. Behead non-muslims
if they try to convert followers of Islam to non-muslims religion. This is all done under apostasy law.
Apostasy in Islam:
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apostasy_in_Islam
@@boshirmh007 she experienced pislamic cult
Ayaan Hirsi Ali is not "one of the most famous...." She is very much indeed "the most famous."
Ayann is truly one of the most important women of our time.
Ayaan is so bold and intelligent! I think I like her.
😍😍😍
What a total load of bosh! The only one speaking with any honesty and coherence was Ayaan Hirsi Ali.
true
Islam is not immutable but Islam is perfect. Conflicting reality? Inherent contradiction? Or Ruse?
"They want to kill me, i don't want to kill them!"
Islam does not cause violence because other religions cause it TOO.
What sort of argument is that?
An idiots supreme argument
Argument the psychiatrists use to diagnose brain dead people.
03:24 Hinduism
07:34 Hindu women
14:37 Hindu society
26:30 Hindu women again
14:37 rattled her really badly. 😂😂
29:16
Otherwise hafis saeed won't clear her cheque
No business to refer to Hindus here! The greatest culture that has modernised itself. Truly great!
Child marriage existed in India as history and as culture. But the difference is in its source and sanctions. Islam as a religion allows it not Hinduism.
*Why Allah's allowed Muhammed married 6 year old baby girl Aishah and let him to f... her when she is 9?*
*Why Muslims considered Muhammed to be their prophet thats also without any prophesy?*
*Why Allah's allowed Muhammed married 6 year old baby girl Aishah and let him to f... her when she is 9?*
*Why Muslims considered Muhammed to be their prophet thats also without any prophesy?*
So easy to say that islam gives rights to women when you live in NY city.
Der. Sisters you dont no. Islam. Der. Sisters. I. Request you.you Listening qarin surah mariem. Mary. With English and. Arobec
Barka you have proved it again that you are a hypocrite. Thanks Aayan Ali Hisrie for ripping you apart..
Tbh, the only person making any sense in this whole talk is Ayan.
Aayan : People wake up at morning.
Bakhra : (Interrupts) Even in India, Hindu men wake up at morning.
🙄🙄
Its nice to see so many people with opened eyes. They know the reality of islam😌
if this short discussion was supposed to be about women within Islam, it is clear that Ayaan is the only one interested in that topic
The only woman on this panel that "gets it" is Ayaan. The rest are still trying to justify and apologize for the doctrines of Islam.
We don't need reforms in Islam we just need to implement correct Islam as per Quran and starting point will be each Muslim own home.
It is in Hindu Religion where you view a woman as an incarnation of Goddess in the form of Lakshmi, Saraswathy, Parvati, Durga etc.
Barkha is so scared that her colors are being exposed by Ayaan so she takes a convenient Hindu turn.
Ayaan Ali litrealey supppports people that masscate muslims she is so islamphopic
Ayaan is the only one with a brain on that stage ffs.
To think perhaps they all could be like Ayaan, if only not oppressed by bad beliefs.
It's hard to imagine when watching them, but that is the thought that scares me the most about this.
Very true
The question is : where can these new generations of Muslim women, young, odd, educated and exposed, and also children, tell their stories? In modern, Western democracies and developing countries with democratic leanings, or in Sharia law Islamic countries where the texts of the Quran and the Hadiths are articles of faith ?
These are the vexed questions and this where we find, and discover the substantive expression of Islam and practice.
Bharkha said women of menstruating age are not allowed in temples in India. There is just 1 temple out of millions of temples in India. But she chose to bring that 1 temple out and create a skepticism about Hinduism.