Ce n'est pas du progressif mais ce morceau est incroyable ! Un très bon Lukather pour un très bon solo ! Enregistré au Zénith de Paris en France en 2007 ! Vidéo en HD !
@@CarterBews 1. Use your ears, it's clearly audible. 2. Search for "Bobby Kimball - Africa live" on youtube and you'll hear what he really sounds like without post-processing
@@micharekosiewicz8660 I was first amazed by his voice then I saw the live of 5 years ago..😳 which gave me doubt..you are right and I was right...it's sad that's autotune
Joseph Williams is a fantastic singer in his own right and is the original singer on such hits as "Pamela" and "Stop Loving You". Kimball won't be coming back as his voice is completely shot as of 2018.
People don't even know how autotune works. Check this video, just to clarify what autotune does in production-wise. It won't correct totally your singing, it'll correct it to the nearest note it's sung. If the singer sings the note 1/32 steps out of key of the certain note, it'll correct it to that wanted note. It's an effect that was invented to salvage otherwise excellent performance, if there was some minor off-key twigs and mouth noises and you don't want to put the singer to sing the same part for the 100th time again and again, losing singer's motivation, voice and mental health. Autotune eases up the production work to make the excellent take sound perfect, depending how strongly you put that autotune effect into the mix. Nowadays pop music industry abuses this effect to create perfect concerts where singer's voice never cracks, never goes off-tune etc., even though it was created to be just a repairing tool to make production go a little smoother. Now people automatically think that autotune is cheating, but let me tell you that singing perfectly in absolute key is fucking impossible on stage. The mix, compression, drivers, echo and reverb etc. kind of effects make the singer sound better and cover the possible mistakes and enhances the sound, except the most obvious mistakes will be heard even with autotune. Even on the age of past 50 years, Bobby does pretty good job and is an energetic performer. And please people, let musicians have bad days sometimes. Singing is a body-instrument, everything effects on everything: sleep, eating, drinking water, warm-ups, tour fatigue, mental state etc. affects on everything. Check this video about autotune and don't spoil the fun by looking at the comments. It'll enlighten your perspective on autotune. ua-cam.com/video/uGfVNKDvJvQ/v-deo.html
Merci, NeoProgressif, pour le vid. Desolee, MrRockstar301, mais WTF?! J'ai ete chanteuse et musicienne depuis 50 annees, et je puis encore faire "the notes." In plain English, my friend, I've never used "Autotune." I don't even know--let alone care--what it is. But then, my crowd tends to be lifelong musicians and singers from Memphis, Tennessee, USA. We'd take a very dim view of a player/singer using an electronic technique to justify pitch or control. We'd probably interrupt the signal to whatever this device is simply out of disgust. As Lukather calls it, "grease" is grease. But "Autotune?" Merde! And, yes--I did cover songs as well as original stuff. I'll put myself up against you--SANS Autotune--anytime. Maybe "Dirty White Boy." That's me all over. Or "Is This Love?" I did that last one in Paris in the 6th. Never missed a lick. Alors! And it's "Bobby's," not "bobbies," the latter of which can only be a plural of the UK slang for les flics. As Richard Pryor put it, "You don't get to be old by bein' no fool." And you don't stop being able to sing just because you age. If Bobby Kimball is using this Auto-thing, so be it. I will not. I don't have to.
Auto tune.....bollocks there was,I’ve seen Toto loads of time,they don’t need Autotune.Ffs they’re all session men at the top of their game,sought after by all the best in the business.
![Toto - Africa / Hold The Line / Stop Loving You (live) [2024]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/5tppmuRLNkc/mqdefault.jpg)
![Toto - Africa / Hold The Line / Stop Loving You (live) [2024]](/img/tr.png)
Kimball's voice, is TOTO. Sklar, beyond words.
Leland 'the gandalf' Sklar: 'hei Kids...have a seat, listen and learn....this is how music should be played'😎🎹🎸🎶
Kkkk
And if you’re real good you’ll get that bike for Christmas
Damn Bobby's voice is crazy. He sounds like he's 20.
It's autotune… That's pretty sad they're doing this.
They are good
@@micharekosiewicz8660 any proof?
@@CarterBews 1. Use your ears, it's clearly audible. 2. Search for "Bobby Kimball - Africa live" on youtube and you'll hear what he really sounds like without post-processing
@@micharekosiewicz8660 I was first amazed by his voice then I saw the live of 5 years ago..😳 which gave me doubt..you are right and I was right...it's sad that's autotune
Steve Lukather is an amazing guitar player!!
Dan Benkert elo
Thank you for this beautiful song🥰👏
Man, Bobby Kimball was like 60 when he sang that, and nailed it!! damn!! I have hope on hummanity now.
AUTOTUNE
@@micharekosiewicz8660 ua-cam.com/video/649VM3sy7ek/v-deo.html
Hands down the greatest version of Hold the line no debate!!
Bobby sounds amazing here holy crap!
Don't think a man has held such raw power as the pianist did at the start
When Leland starts working the B string! Takes it to a whole different level.
Nobody sings Totosongs like Bobby👍👍👍
The greatest vocal performance of all time. Yes, the greatest.
Hold the Line, Love isnt Always on time.......Steve Lukather
Un gusto, un lujo poder ver a Steve y Bobby juntos. ❤
Man his vocals are perfect in this Performance 💯👏👏👏🥰❤❤👑
1:40 the best guitar solo i have ever seen yet
This is what Santa Claus does during the off season, plays bass with TOTO!
gta san andreas ... o gta que teve a melhor trilha sonora de todos os tempos
Que temazo "HOLD THE LINE " ❤🙌🎶🎼🎵
Steve Lukather..... Wuaaaauuuu!!!
Good stuff 👍 Drums spot on
That small staccato at 2.28 is my favourite part!
incredible! best concet ever. greetings from czech republic
Great show
oh bobby incredible even with auto tune
DANG....
Excellent. Yes.
Je vois deux pouces vers le bas... MDR
Les gars, faite un millième de ce qu'ils ont fait, et après on en reparle.
Toto, c'est LA référence !
I was always a huge fan of Toto. Thanks to Leland Sklar's UA-cam channel, My fandom has doubled !
GREATS !!!
Leland Sklar 💕
That is Lee Skar on the Bass
STEEEEVE LUKATHER!!!
Yes I was. He and I went to Rio Vista in Studio City CA together
canta bien canijo eres me gustan mucho tus canciones
Música viciante.
1:23 - 1:33 Ohhhh
Hoooo LORD
Thats not Just the voice!!!! Thats a gift!!!!!!!! "a million thanx mr Bobby kimbal!!!!!!!!
Leland is it...
Steve the best guitarist period
Just ask Eddie Van Halen!!!
This is probably the last time Bobby ever sang himself.. like for real...
Toto without Bobby? No thanks.
Joseph Williams is a fantastic singer in his own right and is the original singer on such hits as "Pamela" and "Stop Loving You". Kimball won't be coming back as his voice is completely shot as of 2018.
It was also auto tuned, helps him hit the notes i guess but either way he's a legend!! :)
Look how packed it is
CJ!!!!!
K-DST
People don't even know how autotune works. Check this video, just to clarify what autotune does in production-wise. It won't correct totally your singing, it'll correct it to the nearest note it's sung. If the singer sings the note 1/32 steps out of key of the certain note, it'll correct it to that wanted note. It's an effect that was invented to salvage otherwise excellent performance, if there was some minor off-key twigs and mouth noises and you don't want to put the singer to sing the same part for the 100th time again and again, losing singer's motivation, voice and mental health. Autotune eases up the production work to make the excellent take sound perfect, depending how strongly you put that autotune effect into the mix. Nowadays pop music industry abuses this effect to create perfect concerts where singer's voice never cracks, never goes off-tune etc., even though it was created to be just a repairing tool to make production go a little smoother. Now people automatically think that autotune is cheating, but let me tell you that singing perfectly in absolute key is fucking impossible on stage. The mix, compression, drivers, echo and reverb etc. kind of effects make the singer sound better and cover the possible mistakes and enhances the sound, except the most obvious mistakes will be heard even with autotune.
Even on the age of past 50 years, Bobby does pretty good job and is an energetic performer. And please people, let musicians have bad days sometimes. Singing is a body-instrument, everything effects on everything: sleep, eating, drinking water, warm-ups, tour fatigue, mental state etc. affects on everything.
Check this video about autotune and don't spoil the fun by looking at the comments. It'll enlighten your perspective on autotune.
ua-cam.com/video/uGfVNKDvJvQ/v-deo.html
yeahhhhhhh ou ou ou ou ou yeeeeee ahhhhhhh
Good bye
Bobby le mete mucho groove a la canción lo cual me agrada, quien hiba a decir que sería una aspiradora humana.
El cantante parece maracucho.
who's the drummer
basçı suavi mi?
You were with Steve in school?
Love kimball but the auto tune sounds odd
legit*
Jajajaja yeah 😂
Cant hear the auto tune. One of Bobbys best performances.
Fuck the auto tune men, this is awesome!!!!!
Dont criticise what you cant archive
Best performance of Hold the line I've ever seen! Bobby 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
what about Bobby Kimball's iVoice?
i knew it sounded off...
Autotune
@@micharekosiewicz8660 no.
Simon Phillips
Gandalf could play the bass
Go check out Leland Sklar's youtube channel, he just recently uploaded a bass cover of this exact version of Hold the Line!
E alla voce super mario ahahahaha
Vitor Kley na guitarra base 😂😂😂😂
Merci, NeoProgressif, pour le vid.
Desolee, MrRockstar301, mais WTF?! J'ai ete chanteuse et musicienne depuis 50 annees, et je puis encore faire "the notes." In plain English, my friend, I've never used "Autotune." I don't even know--let alone care--what it is. But then, my crowd tends to be lifelong musicians and singers from Memphis, Tennessee, USA. We'd take a very dim view of a player/singer using an electronic technique to justify pitch or control. We'd probably interrupt the signal to whatever this device is simply out of disgust. As Lukather calls it, "grease" is grease. But "Autotune?" Merde! And, yes--I did cover songs as well as original stuff. I'll put myself up against you--SANS Autotune--anytime. Maybe "Dirty White Boy." That's me all over. Or "Is This Love?" I did that last one in Paris in the 6th. Never missed a lick. Alors! And it's "Bobby's," not "bobbies," the latter of which can only be a plural of the UK slang for les flics. As Richard Pryor put it, "You don't get to be old by bein' no fool." And you don't stop being able to sing just because you age. If Bobby Kimball is using this Auto-thing, so be it. I will not. I don't have to.
please you can share the concert complete?
belchior?
Ashuashua
Pensava que só eu achava parecido.🤣🤣🤣🤣
Charlie Chaplin on Vocals...
Bobby Kimball in this looks like Cheech Marin with hair in this video.
LITERALLY THINKING THAT
what the hell. way to much auto tuned
8 ppl expected justin bieber to sing it
l'unico gruppo a cui nn gli cresce la barba....
Toto senza Bobby? No grazie...
Bobbie Kimball is the voice of Toto
Autotune actived
no es autotune xd :v
@@puppethack9228 Yes es autotune
Auto tune.....bollocks there was,I’ve seen Toto loads of time,they don’t need Autotune.Ffs they’re all session men at the top of their game,sought after by all the best in the business.
Which rather begs the question, why did they use it?
What's with the fucking autotune?
I know, it's really disappointing!
NIGGAH STOLE MAH KEYBOARD.
Their band name is the name of toilet 😂
The band name came first
Noooo too bad he was using autotune