Writing Prog Metal Djent with Lydian Dominant [COMPOSITION LESSON]

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 13 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 344

  • @SignalsMusicStudio
    @SignalsMusicStudio  6 років тому +103

    01:19 - Forming Lydian b7
    02:10 - Basic Riffage
    03:07 - Powerchords in the scale
    04:12 - Indjecting the Djent
    06:29 - Using the major II chord
    07:25 - Inverting Powerchords
    09:40 - Adding vocals

  • @maccaslash
    @maccaslash 6 років тому +377

    “I threw my pick. I found it.” Nope, once dropped or thrown, picks enter another dimension.

    • @RudyAyoub
      @RudyAyoub 6 років тому +35

      maccaslash somewhere out there there is a void filled with dropped picks

    • @Cestariarts
      @Cestariarts 6 років тому +24

      Yeah, imagine a planet like Saturn, but with GUITAR PICKS rings

    • @RudyAyoub
      @RudyAyoub 6 років тому +32

      Abner Cestari concept album incoming. PICKS OF SATURN

    • @Cestariarts
      @Cestariarts 6 років тому +7

      Rudy Ayoub 10/10 would buy

    • @RudyAyoub
      @RudyAyoub 6 років тому +7

      Abner Cestari thanks, stay tuned for the release

  • @jacksonnexhip
    @jacksonnexhip 6 років тому +91

    this channel just keeps getting better and better x.x

  • @berkefiliz3410
    @berkefiliz3410 6 років тому +161

    Lydian + Different time signatures + Concept album
    It feels soo Dream Theater-ish

    • @ingreynelg
      @ingreynelg 6 років тому +3

      Berke Filiz actually reminds me of 2002's Moonbabies from Planet X. That band to me is top notch in prog-metal sometimes they even djent back in late 90's when djent was still fresh, too bad no new material since 2007.

    • @berkefiliz3410
      @berkefiliz3410 6 років тому

      I'll surely check that band as well
      Thanks!

    • @rogercruz1547
      @rogercruz1547 6 років тому +3

      But there's time travel involved, it's definetively Ayreon.

    • @moadot720
      @moadot720 5 років тому

      It's Lydian Dominant, not Lydian, AS YOU CAN CLEARLY SEE IN THE TITLE AND IN THE VIDEO, but it does sound similar.

    • @tonypeake467
      @tonypeake467 3 роки тому

      @@ingreynelg absolutely love planet x. Do you know any YT vids where Planet X is discussed. Haven't come across much

  • @sihplak
    @sihplak 6 років тому +151

    This makes me think of Dream Theater... Like, a whole lot of Dream Theater. Great vid!

    • @LouisSerieusement
      @LouisSerieusement 6 років тому +6

      this makes me think of "Liquid Tension Experiment - Another Dimension " which was before dream theater XD ; this guys were good

    • @gerben880
      @gerben880 6 років тому +20

      LTE was in 1999, DT was founded in 1985, so that song wasn't before DT at all lol

    • @LouisSerieusement
      @LouisSerieusement 6 років тому +3

      my bad ; it's confusing because it's almost the same band ; I love LTE, some synth sounds are a bit cheap nowaday, but the overall composition in awesome

    • @92Nanaki
      @92Nanaki 6 років тому +2

      LTE is where they picked up Jordan Rudess

    • @Cobalt985
      @Cobalt985 5 років тому

      Reminds me of The Count of Tuscany :)

  • @Gabrol
    @Gabrol 6 років тому +27

    do not be embarrassed by how long you've been working on your conceptual album, you're taking your time to make it sound as good as you can

  • @moistness482
    @moistness482 5 років тому +81

    Locrian - weird/creepy
    Phrygian - evil
    Aeolian/minor - sad
    Dorian - folk/funky
    Mixolydian - folk/fun
    Ionian/major - happy
    Lydian - on drugs

    • @blackcitadel37
      @blackcitadel37 3 роки тому +4

      Superlocrian: demonic invocation ritual

    • @MaimiZhang
      @MaimiZhang 3 роки тому +2

      Pop: let's make major sad, and minor happy. 😅

    • @DeathshotSociety
      @DeathshotSociety 3 роки тому +1

      @@MaimiZhang Hey There, Delilah: "You called?"

    • @yarlodek5842
      @yarlodek5842 3 роки тому +4

      Altered: I’m gonna die
      Lydian Dominant: I’m in SPAAAAACE!

    • @uroboric
      @uroboric 2 роки тому

      I wonder why minor is considered sad. It doesn't really sound sad imo

  • @jordanjamesmusic7631
    @jordanjamesmusic7631 6 років тому +30

    Commented on one of your videos a couple of months ago, saying that you deserve recognition... I have no idea you reached 42K subscribers, jeez. Congragulations man! I look foward to your videos all the time, you always put out really amazing and interesting content! Sending love from Liverpool, England! :D

    • @jordanjamesmusic7631
      @jordanjamesmusic7631 6 років тому +1

      Also: When you do those 'Inverted Power Chords' (the 5th below), I always like to add an octave, check out the intro to Sylosis - Empyreal, it's the best way to make your 6 string sound like a 7/8 string :D

  • @michaeldebecker1472
    @michaeldebecker1472 Місяць тому +1

    I just discovered this channel through this video and I immediately subscribed. What a gold mine! Clear and pedagogical. I am a bass player (mainly prog metal/djent) and very interested in improving my understanding of the topics you address in your videos! Congrats and thank you! 👍

  • @nicholasbrodersen8491
    @nicholasbrodersen8491 6 років тому +10

    I love these Songwriting Vids! I love the prog-metal stuff too! It's pretty hard to hear and understand the nuances of Prog-metal so I really appreciate Vids like this! Thanks for the knowledge!

  • @thierryvienna6144
    @thierryvienna6144 6 років тому +58

    YES! Please do Phrygian dominant, diminished and Byzantine

    • @johanribelles174
      @johanribelles174 6 років тому +3

      Go check "shades of black" if you like mixing those scales.

    • @thierryvienna6144
      @thierryvienna6144 6 років тому +1

      Thanks man, it's exactly the sound that triggers me so hard. I'm his #1 fan for sure. That Zulegmat is fucking insane. I could live the rest of my life just listening to his music

    • @Melodeath00
      @Melodeath00 6 років тому +5

      No it's really not. Same set of notes, but it's a completely different scale with a different sound and use.
      That would be like saying that E Minor and G Major are the same, which would be utter nonesense.

  • @TooSlamToGiveADamn
    @TooSlamToGiveADamn 6 років тому +3

    Great video! I learn so much from your lessons. As a self taught guitar player, it’s amazing to start to think like a musician after so many years.

  • @axehound3718
    @axehound3718 3 роки тому +1

    Bro!!!!
    I couldn’t remember what your channel was called and it’s been two years since I was subscribed to you (account got deleted).
    Just wanted to say for the way my brain works you are the best music teacher on the web. You have a great way of simplifying complex theories!
    Thanks you!!!!

  • @mikefearon3577
    @mikefearon3577 6 років тому +1

    I know you get this all the time, but you truly do have a way of making fairly complex subjects and making them accessible. You are a great teacher.

  • @gagangayari5981
    @gagangayari5981 6 років тому +4

    I really love your videos because you unleash the idea behind the song.Please keep on doing such videos

  • @CrisKRA
    @CrisKRA 4 роки тому +4

    Almost 2 years and I'm still waiting for that concept album

  • @afronprime51
    @afronprime51 6 років тому +2

    This is by far my fav music channel. thank you once again my friend it was funny, informative, and inspiring this from someone not some much into djent.

  • @TheKoryHimself
    @TheKoryHimself 6 років тому +12

    My body is ready for your album. I believe in you

    • @fuzzywumble
      @fuzzywumble 6 років тому

      the way you said that x.x i am dead now i died i'm dead

  • @brendanmobbs6808
    @brendanmobbs6808 6 років тому +1

    You're quickly becoming my favourite music channel, keep up the solid work man! More composition videos would be incredible.

  • @nicko-7749
    @nicko-7749 6 років тому +6

    Yes! I’ve been waiting for another one of these!

  • @bielanski2493
    @bielanski2493 6 років тому +16

    "Music is NOT PRESCRIPTIVE." okay, subbed forever. Your amazing diction and content notwithstanding...

  • @420Bassist
    @420Bassist 2 роки тому

    Jake, I really really appreciate you. Because of you, I understand theory much better.

  • @ryanchappell1506
    @ryanchappell1506 5 років тому

    Ive been playing for over fifteen years but I never had any lessons or music theory lessons. You make it crazy easy to understand all these modes and scales and how to apply them!

  • @marielove5606
    @marielove5606 6 років тому +1

    Whoah! Thanks for letting us see that little snip! Can't wait for release!

  • @joerandazzo2889
    @joerandazzo2889 4 роки тому

    i have to say I love your videos and have been watching for years you've helped break down basic music theory for me and have so much content like this that helps open my eyes to more ways to play. Thank you so much for these videos and keep up the great work!

  • @MrRagAndBoneMan1
    @MrRagAndBoneMan1 6 років тому

    mate,,, your videos are fantastic,, your teaching technique is fantastic... your knowledge on everything is fantastic... i have watched loads of your vids,, and i can feel the light in my head starting to light up... FANTASTIC,,,, cheers :)

  • @MrRiwi73
    @MrRiwi73 6 років тому

    I'm an intermediate guitar player, just starting to get into theory. You have helped me so much! Thank you. Keep up the great lessons!

  • @rafa_rodrigues
    @rafa_rodrigues 5 років тому

    Too Awesome, your explanation is so easy, and didatic... Just get guitar and compose with this incredible theory simplified !

  • @qwantinmoe6215
    @qwantinmoe6215 6 років тому +40

    This shit's gonna be the next Metropolis Pt.2

    • @truedarklander
      @truedarklander 6 років тому +10

      Sooooooo... Metropolis pt3?

    • @monkeybusiness673
      @monkeybusiness673 5 років тому +2

      @@truedarklander Nope, the next pt2...So Metropolis pt.2 pt.2! Or maybe "Pt.2 chapter II"?

    • @nanamacapagal8342
      @nanamacapagal8342 4 роки тому +1

      Metropolis Pt.3

    • @CrisKRA
      @CrisKRA 4 роки тому

      I'm pretty he meant that the album is gonna be as big as Metropolis Pt 2. I dont't know if he realeased anything

  • @randymarsh5150
    @randymarsh5150 6 років тому

    Man your videos are so descriptive and easy to understand,thank you

  • @omairsh8
    @omairsh8 3 роки тому

    You're the best guitar teacher on UA-cam. Keep up the great work man

  • @arthurmee
    @arthurmee 4 роки тому

    Concept album? All power to you Jake. I grew up with concept albums. A friend and I are also working on one now. Great tutorials . . . a real inspiration . . .many thanks.

  • @narpzcodm
    @narpzcodm 5 років тому

    Your videos really help me learn music easily and much easier!

  • @AgungSetiabudi
    @AgungSetiabudi 5 років тому

    Man..you are very good at explaining music theory easily. Thanks for your dedication.

  • @hazen7645
    @hazen7645 8 місяців тому

    These videos on Djent are great, wish you could do more of them.

  • @victorfox2598
    @victorfox2598 6 років тому +4

    Your vocals were as awesome the riff. Good job.

    • @chromaticswing9199
      @chromaticswing9199 6 років тому +1

      Almost resembles Tool, save for the scale. Put this in minor, and you get Lateralus!

  • @nickb7874
    @nickb7874 6 років тому

    just started watching your vids you have a good way of teaching where anyone can understand

  • @jaime_abad
    @jaime_abad 6 років тому

    This was very informative and you sound very confident and positive. You just got a new subscriber.

  • @joebloks2381
    @joebloks2381 6 років тому

    This is actually helping me to get better! Thanks Jake!

  • @DCJayhawk57
    @DCJayhawk57 6 років тому +10

    Symphony X also comes to mind with this mode.

  • @bradsmith6662
    @bradsmith6662 6 років тому

    Awesome lesson and channel! Subscribed after seeing about 2-3 videos! Keep up the good work!

  • @onevoiceinc
    @onevoiceinc 6 років тому

    I love the Lydian dominant! I actually used it in my solo in "A New Day Dawns" a couple years ago (posted on my channel). To me, it represented a kind of chaos and inbalance that can offset a typical day (which we introverts don't respond well too, lol) before resolving back to the main major feel of the overall song. It's an instrumental, but you might like it. (And maybe it'll give you some ideas in finishing your album. Looking forward to hearing it.) I like your channel and your posts. Keep up the great work as always, brother.

  • @Yusufmasron
    @Yusufmasron Рік тому

    I like your approach Jake.. Thanks for the video.

  • @CaptnP00pyP4nts
    @CaptnP00pyP4nts 6 років тому

    This is badass. Subbed and hoping to see much more in time.

  • @yoatzinpenaflor1262
    @yoatzinpenaflor1262 6 років тому +7

    3:48 "but screw that" hahahaha Excelent video!!

  • @3kzy233
    @3kzy233 6 років тому

    Awesome dude! It sounds great :) Keep up the splendid work and keep on shredding! Stay awesome!

  • @milkord
    @milkord 5 років тому

    Awsome video, clear explanation and the voice is on point

  • @bluelake2308
    @bluelake2308 4 роки тому

    Very strait forward and very useful lesson!

  • @aric7726
    @aric7726 6 років тому +9

    IT SOUNDS SO MUCH LIKE DREAM THEATER

  • @WishfulSinful1969
    @WishfulSinful1969 5 років тому

    Thank you so much for all you do!!! I am learning a lot from your videos!!

  • @haf816r
    @haf816r 6 років тому

    Dude, I'm surprised I haven't heard of your channel before! Definitely subbed, notifications- on! Great video looking forward to more content like this! Thanks!

  • @swarnimshashank2981
    @swarnimshashank2981 6 років тому +1

    Each time you said subdivisions, Rush came to my mind :)

  • @frenchiesfrankieandhenry
    @frenchiesfrankieandhenry 4 роки тому

    The fact that you found that pick after dropping it is the real magic here.

  • @desolatesoul2304
    @desolatesoul2304 5 років тому

    Really helpful instructor. Love your theory man.

  • @semanticsamuel936
    @semanticsamuel936 6 років тому

    Not only is this is a great video, but you just introduced me to Intervals - damn, Epiphany is mindblowing. I really need to practice guitar more...

  • @MsDavo123
    @MsDavo123 2 роки тому

    I just fail to grasp odd time signature concept and this video brought me one step closer very interesting also how you explained your creative process in coming up with super proggy riff thanks

  • @mahmoudkchaou1799
    @mahmoudkchaou1799 4 роки тому

    I tended to employ the dominant lydian when I'm improvising in prog style. And it was very natural to me. I was emphasising on the major 3rd and the difference between the perfect 5th and the diminished 5th and I used to focus on the minor 7th to darken the riff for example. ^^

  • @SunRavenMusic
    @SunRavenMusic 3 роки тому

    Great video. I haven't used this scale before, sounds interesting!

  • @anthiondel
    @anthiondel 6 років тому +1

    I love the tritone between I and IV in lydian...

  • @leemaples1806
    @leemaples1806 6 років тому

    Awesome lesson Jake. And please let us know when we can get a listen to your `over-the-top` prog rock thing you mentioned. The sounds like something right up my alley. Thanks!

  • @MichaelTrentColvin
    @MichaelTrentColvin 18 днів тому

    The Djent section when you start singing sounds like something RUSH would write 😎🎸

  • @Soloist1983
    @Soloist1983 4 роки тому

    Love this channel, this is a lesson I have taught, well, without graphics...
    Lydian dominant is in almost every Oingo Boingo song btw, Private Life, You Really Got Me (cover), prime examples, as well as nearly all of his scores...including the Simpsons theme 👍

  • @MrJohanGuzman
    @MrJohanGuzman 5 років тому

    I want... No, I need that futuristic song! The lyrics started so great!

  • @hyalinamusic18
    @hyalinamusic18 5 років тому

    You are one of the lucky few who have recovered their guitar picks before they enter the void.
    But in all seriousness, very cool video! I've never really thought something could be heavy in a major key, but Lydian Dominant is a very cool scale for that, Phrygian Dominant is another good scale (doesn't sound major, but has a major 1 chord lol)

  • @edgejarno7473
    @edgejarno7473 5 років тому

    Hooray..Best Songwriting Teacher on the Internet..Great Work..

  • @cartermccracken4667
    @cartermccracken4667 6 років тому

    Cannot wait for this album

  • @MikeSalopek
    @MikeSalopek 6 років тому

    Love this, it is so creative... but maybe you did not notice that while you play a 9/8 measure, your on screen bouncing display of the meter shows an 8th note, rather than a quarter to complete the full 9 as played. Well done, though.... I just discovered your channel, and I am thoroughly enjoying :)

  • @FeeLGooDGaming
    @FeeLGooDGaming 5 років тому

    I still love watching Chuck Bartowski's guitar lesson videos

  • @Downtempovibrations
    @Downtempovibrations 4 роки тому

    Loved this video, thanks for sharing

  • @musicpro26
    @musicpro26 6 років тому

    You should mention that even though the note G isn't in the key, the power chord is perfectly allowed because the 5th is the most related note(other than the octave) to the root in that power chord. To be clear, when you play the C you hear a G in it anyway(as an overtone).

  • @heiah
    @heiah 6 років тому +1

    I really like your content, you understand how to structure and display information really well, thank you for that. Now let’s get honest here for a moment: I have been searching around on UA-cam like crazy, but no one is really able to explain and giving a applicable system how powerful melodies can be written. We have all those classical devices of classic composition, for,example the video: what is a melody by Bernstein, but There is no real systemization. What intervals are used in regards to chords and scales, popular examples, how melody and lyrics are related to another, how singers come up with melodies, if they start before beat 1, what common schemes are used in popular music nowadays? I am dying to understand this, do you think it’s worth a shot to make a video about it? I’m interested what you’d come up with :)

  • @ZethKeeper
    @ZethKeeper 3 роки тому

    That snippet from your album sounds a bit like Ayreon, I like it!

  • @nebojsazbidelj1791
    @nebojsazbidelj1791 6 років тому

    Im legitimately looking forward to that album :)

  • @ToneD5150
    @ToneD5150 5 років тому

    Well done! Thanks, love your lessons....

  • @edwardmaxwell3951
    @edwardmaxwell3951 6 років тому +1

    I refuse to accept that there is such a thing as DJENT. Back in my day we just called it Palm-Mute.
    Anyway, keep em coming Jake.

  • @MaimiZhang
    @MaimiZhang 3 роки тому

    Imagine Dream Theater having Lydian Dominant, Phrygian Dominant, Harmonic Minor, Mixolydian, and most important, odd time signature. Although prog band really have those but to me, DT is really everything. And I can't be bored with Dream Theater.
    We can really explore the music theory with Proggresive rock/metal.

  • @hyalinamusic18
    @hyalinamusic18 5 років тому

    I think Overture 1928/Strange Deja Vu by Dream Theater is in Lydian Dominant for the most part. Very cool. Just got my hands on a 7-string so I might just have to experiment with some of this djenty stuff.

  • @thegoatriderfromthesands2646
    @thegoatriderfromthesands2646 10 місяців тому

    The augmented b7 still works for me, but you do you!

  • @dropdatabase2569
    @dropdatabase2569 2 роки тому

    4:05 The only issue is that adding a natural fourth makes it a mixolydian with occasional #4. Just like Day Tripper by The Beatles is in E mixolydian with occasional b3 and b6

  • @jamesleita3277
    @jamesleita3277 6 років тому +134

    More prog rock in my opinion. Not much of djent

    • @alphaenemy
      @alphaenemy 6 років тому +5

      Not with a standard tuned six string, that's for sure. Could probably pull off some cool djent stuff in Lydian dominant with a 7 string, though.

    • @Rude_i_Wredne
      @Rude_i_Wredne 5 років тому

      You need more strings for that. Open 7th is a must, even 8/9th are really helpful.

    • @johanwodzynski8637
      @johanwodzynski8637 5 років тому +21

      @@alphaenemy There's no need to get more strings to play Djent. With a six string in standard, if You know how to djent, You will djent

    • @skyleranderson1984
      @skyleranderson1984 5 років тому +1

      @@johanwodzynski8637 yes but with the example jake provided it was more prog and the idea of lydian dominant applied in the video leaned more towards prog if you ask

    • @kennethsmith5383
      @kennethsmith5383 4 роки тому +1

      Djent is all about ambient layers, and tone-heavy bass. The guitar is the centerpiece, but the rest is what guides the ears to it, framing the melody.

  • @noodle845
    @noodle845 5 років тому

    I liked your vocals over that. It's like bowie meets djent. 🤠🤘

  • @roei534
    @roei534 6 років тому

    Hay Jake, I started watching a lot of your videos lately and really enjoying it, your videos are awesome! I would really like to here your concept album ('cause that part with the vocals sounded amazing!) Is the album out yet? And if so, where can i find it?

  • @midnightmusic3485
    @midnightmusic3485 4 роки тому

    I really want to hear this concept album! :)

  • @tfwnoyandere
    @tfwnoyandere 4 роки тому

    sickest harmonic at beginning

    • @tfwnoyandere
      @tfwnoyandere 4 роки тому

      also cool song dutch from the shield

  • @TheGreaMattsby
    @TheGreaMattsby 6 років тому

    $60k in debt from getting a music composition degree and I've learned exponentially more from your channel than I ever did in school.

  • @tronlady1
    @tronlady1 6 років тому

    Amazeballs! Love it!!

  • @antonguerrero6300
    @antonguerrero6300 5 років тому +1

    sounds so dream theater

  • @pinkponyofprey1965
    @pinkponyofprey1965 3 роки тому

    Last grouping, the one with the 9, is for making people attempting dancing to prog rock to trip over! :D

  • @maxkolbl1527
    @maxkolbl1527 6 років тому +5

    Inverted power chords, aka 4ths

  • @thomasthrasher3438
    @thomasthrasher3438 4 роки тому

    Rush meets..... Periphery.... I think????.... just messin. Great video man, you do great work

  • @ishi_gho9695
    @ishi_gho9695 3 роки тому

    Hey jake when you finish that album plz share it with us, sounds awesome!

  • @ingreynelg
    @ingreynelg 6 років тому

    Man you are so great and keep growing. Love your lessons. Derek Sherinian should definetily call you for his next album, whenever that is 😂

  • @hugosilva7852
    @hugosilva7852 6 років тому

    Very good...good work dudue

  • @joesantana5704
    @joesantana5704 3 роки тому

    Jake, when you played the RIFF? And, chopped it up (sub-dividing)? I agree with the guys who commented. It sounds like Petrucci!!! Sounds cool 😎 👌

  • @GogiRegion
    @GogiRegion 6 років тому +30

    There’s a reason that prog musicians are music theory nerds. You need to know the rules to break them.

    • @monkeybusiness673
      @monkeybusiness673 5 років тому +4

      I am so going to steal that quote, mate!

    • @yarlodek5842
      @yarlodek5842 2 роки тому +1

      Music theory isn’t a set of rules, more like a set of colors in your musical palate. The more strange colors you have, the weirder your painting is going to be. That’s why prog people like music theory, we want to find the most interesting scales to make weird music.

  • @matthewramroop
    @matthewramroop 6 років тому

    1:01 I never would've known that if it weren't for you dude. Cheers

  • @flixization
    @flixization 6 років тому +3

    People mention Dream Theater and Ayreon. Scar Symmetry also explores this mode a bit (check out the song Holographic Universe). Thanks for this lesson!

  • @stipser1
    @stipser1 6 років тому

    Getting some Ayreon vibes there. Nice one

  • @hyalinamusic18
    @hyalinamusic18 4 роки тому

    As Djent on a six string in standard tuning. Periphery does six string Djent in Drop-C.

  • @chucktate12
    @chucktate12 5 років тому

    Great Melodic minor mode theory and the ubiquitous lydian dominant scale. The rhythmic patterns remind me of Frank Zappa.