This is very true! Working at a local gas station we had a whole section of the candy shelving dedicated to reeses and all its variations. So many good choices!
Let's be honest: Halloween candy/regular candy tournaments are just an excuse for Rhett and Link to say that Reese's peanut butter is better than everything else.
I wholeheartedly believe that seasonal and even some smaller “snack sized” candies are made differently to taste better than the regular full sized bars you get at the checkout or the gas station. That’s a theory I need tested. Blind taste test: full size, king size, fun size, snack size, holiday theme.. which tastes the best?!?
Do you have any idea who is replying to your comment right now? It's the FUNNIEST MAN ALIVE! Me funny (!!!) vids are so extremely funny, if you don't cry tears of laughter, you are allowed to thumb down me XTREMELY FUNNY vids! Do you think me funny (!!!) vids are funny, dear v
Everyone: you should just have a peanut butter category since you like it so much Also everyone: why is there even a peanut butter category we all know Reese's will win
Because if it wasnt like that we wouldnt have the true winner in each category. Also a lot of persons are just comment to make a peanut butter reese's all flavours taste test which would be really interessing
You guys should do a comparison of "normal" candy bars and their special counterparts to see which is better. Like the regular Reese's vs. Easter Egg Reese's or Christmas Tree Reese's and regular Snickers vs. PB Snickers and stuff like that
@@sammy2502 you're right, I suspect they probably use the same ingredients so very similar. Buuut personally, I really do prefer the holiday Reese's with the higher peanut butter to chocolate ratio.
The only reason why Reese’s didn’t win is because it lost to Reese’s. Imagine if there was another Reese’s… I don’t think Reese’s would have gone too far, but maybe Reese’s would fared better.
I mentally said to myself "if Mr.goodbar makes it past round 1 I'll be happy" and then I saw it was going against reese's and incredulous laughteri ensued
Nope. The next category is fruity so like skittles,starbursts,air heads etc and the 3rd is older candy. It had pixie sticks,candy corn,candy cigarettes and several others I'm blanking on.
We all know one of the Reese’s was going to win…y’all need to do the ultimate Reese’s taste test to determine the best Reese’s (ie Pieces, Christmas Tree, Easter Egg, etc.)
"If you lead a horse to water, will it float too Georgie" Emily as John Wayne Chasey, hilarious. And yes the pumpkins are better than the regular Reese's
I am frequently in the GMK comments begging for more historical meal episodes with Emily so I am overjoyed to see her in a main GMM episode!! She is the best!
Little known fact is that Reese’s cups and the pumpkin Reese’s aren’t made from the same chocolate and peanut butter. Hence why some gluten intolerant people are allowed to eat the minis and the pumpkins. 🤯
I am so angry with Link, he has said in the past that he doesn't like the other shapes of reese's better than the original because the ratio is perfect and the shapes screw that up. WHAT HAPPENED TO THAT LINK, HUH?!
@@chrishan9122 makes sense. Everyone knows that the seasonal reeses are better than the cup because they have more peanut butter than the cups. Means they are better. Who eats a reeses for the chocolate.
I wish Reese’s also made a peanut butter pumpkin with pumpkin spice flavoring. Also, PEANUT BUTTER Snickers is the only candy that could have given Reese’s some serious competition.
Now I need to hold aside a Reeses Pumpkin, Christmas Tree, Heart, & Egg. Compare all the holiday shapes side by side. I also saw a Reeses Bat this year, but I don't usually see those around here.
@@mr.peppermint9531 pretty sure it's across the country. My parents always send me one at Christmas and it takes a few days to eat. I slice it like a pie. Lol
How is it that 2 guys can almost cure my anxiety just by being themselves/ worker all night and I always have a hard time winding down but when a new episode comes on I watch and easily go to bed. Thank you Rhett and link !
@@SmartBlondeParadox I think it’s both the ratio and freshness. By virtue of their seasonality my theory is they’re made in smaller batches more often than regular cups.
I love Emily so much, shes so funny like i know shes not actually funny in this episode but the irony of her jokes being so bad is so fricken hilarious to me. Always a joy to have Emily on screen
I know they're not common, but I feel like a peanut butter twix bar could easily compete against reese's in this rather than all the standard candies that were included
Any time there’s a tournament/competition on this channel, the first place should be taken by a jar of peanut butter. Best Jerky? Peanut butter. Best Water? Peanut butter. Best Retirement Plan? Peanut Butter.
There are SO MANY kinds of Reese’s candy, y’all could probably do a full GUT CHECK REESES EPISODE! Link would be in heaven.
Imagine that stomach ache after doing an episode of that 🥴
Boost this comment!
@@masquinongy4652 Worth it!
This is very true! Working at a local gas station we had a whole section of the candy shelving dedicated to reeses and all its variations. So many good choices!
Everything's got variety these days. They should do it.
Enjoying the I-Can't-Believe-Its-Not-Chase arc
Haha yeah sad.!
@@flamecrew9atroblox958 Lp
But we need the King to return
The Prince of GMM needs to return
Where did he go
Let's be honest: Halloween candy/regular candy tournaments are just an excuse for Rhett and Link to say that Reese's peanut butter is better than everything else.
Exactly, Rhett and Link will always be Peanut Butter Partial
Agree
This is exactly why I'm glad all of the peanut butter is grouped together this year.
What makes you say that? The fact that Peanut Butter Cups are on there twice?
If you like peanut butter and chocolate, I think it's generally difficult to beat the combination.
I wholeheartedly believe that seasonal and even some smaller “snack sized” candies are made differently to taste better than the regular full sized bars you get at the checkout or the gas station. That’s a theory I need tested. Blind taste test: full size, king size, fun size, snack size, holiday theme.. which tastes the best?!?
omg this is such a good idea
King size always tastes better, then normal size.
@@daeneryseilish okay grammar 😑
@@unrequin4805 Also, I was gonna say, “king size always tastes better, then normal size, then fun/snack size”. Guess I just didn’t finish my sentence.
That's a great episode idea
The close-up on Emily's "why so serious" has me in stitches.
She looks so nervous
*Sees Reese’s in thumbnail*
Why watch the movie when you already know the ending
LOL
Do you have any idea who is replying to your comment right now? It's the FUNNIEST MAN ALIVE! Me funny (!!!) vids are so extremely funny, if you don't cry tears of laughter, you are allowed to thumb down me XTREMELY FUNNY vids! Do you think me funny (!!!) vids are funny, dear v
@@AxxLAfriku why do you lie like that?
Oh look, Craig, you have blow-up doll boy in your replies. You're getting famous, I think.
Lmao
Everyone: you should just have a peanut butter category since you like it so much
Also everyone: why is there even a peanut butter category we all know Reese's will win
Seriously 🤣 they’ll never make everyone happy
At least now other candies will have a fair shot in the next two episodes.
Because if it wasnt like that we wouldnt have the true winner in each category. Also a lot of persons are just comment to make a peanut butter reese's all flavours taste test which would be really interessing
Yes we doooo!!!!
Both statements are very true LOL
Fun fact: Peanut isnt actually a nut and is more closely related to beans. Which is probably why Rhett likes it.
yup they are legumes, which technically are a fruit.
@@markekar6021 To be fair, tree nuts are fruits as well. :)
@@deprofundis3293 I thought I was being fair!!!
All NUTS ARE FRUITS!
@@Evan-Fisherton almonds, cashews, pecans are seeds no? Part of a fruit, but not fruit..? Always kinda confused me
i appreciate rhett SO MUCH for saying he likes to separate the peanuts when eating the peanut m&ms. Its my favorite thing about them
same here
Same lol
I’m 24 and done this my entire life. Thought it was just me😂
Mine too lol I always eat them this way lol
The conversation at 16:38, followed by Emily’s deadpan delivery made this pharmacist laugh to the point of crying. Absolutely hilarious. 😂
The only thing that beat Reese’s for Rhett and Link was a Reese’s with more peanut butter 😂
Love it
Spoiler alert
@@iRunfastXC Who reads the comments first? You are literally asking to be spoiled
You guys should do a comparison of "normal" candy bars and their special counterparts to see which is better. Like the regular Reese's vs. Easter Egg Reese's or Christmas Tree Reese's and regular Snickers vs. PB Snickers and stuff like that
Ok so that’s a rly rly good idea. BUT the mostly taste the same. Just like reeceese and the pumkin ones
YES
@@sammy2502 you're right, I suspect they probably use the same ingredients so very similar. Buuut personally, I really do prefer the holiday Reese's with the higher peanut butter to chocolate ratio.
@@jubeesays716 sometimes the holiday Reese’s kinda melts a bit on that paper holder and takes on a bit of that weird paper flavour.
Personally I love almond snickers better than regular.
“if you lead a horse to water, will it float too Georgie?”
“im trying really hard at this” 🤣🤣🤣
I love her lol
Timestamp?
@@An3sth3s3a 13:10
IT Pennywise reference maybe?
@@reng223 obviously.
"There's a snake in my crawl space"
I laughed WAY too hard at that
I love watching Rhett and Link. They have a way of making you feel like a friend regardless on their knowledge of your existence.
“It’s like taking a pill and making everything better”
“Why would you say that?”
I can’t get over it 😭😭
I rewatched that like 3 times, I’m crying 🤣🤣🤣
*popping a pill* not taking a pill
Link is the best 😂😂😂
@@shelbybyrd9981 Same, gotta love Link’s innocent comments 😂
@@11rossboss popping a pill is literally slang for taking a pill
The peanut butter to chocolate ratio is imperative. I have found that the Reese’s Easter Egg variety is closest to perfection.
I like more chocolate per peanut butter, so for me reese’s hearts are best
FINALLY A CONVERSATION ABOUT THE REESTIO
Yo have you tried the Reese’s cups that’re a higher ratio? There are ones that are all peanut butter! And they’re my favorite weirdly enough!
1/2 lb Reese's are the only way to go
I agree the pumpkins get me through fall winter then I switch to eggs for spring summer
At this point they should just put a whole jar of peanut butter up for contest. It would probably win against any candy.
But the chocolate makes it so much better! (so I'm not going to be your 100th like, haha)
Nice profilepicture failerror
But all of their jars of peanut butter have a deep hole in the middle!
@@pollyesther123 oh no
Or just a whole bowl of peanuts LOL!
The only reason why Reese’s didn’t win is because it lost to Reese’s. Imagine if there was another Reese’s… I don’t think Reese’s would have gone too far, but maybe Reese’s would fared better.
What was that GEORGE COSTANZA line from SEINFELD ?? A George against itself can not stand ?? LOL Its the same idea with REESE'S here in this video.
Love these dudes
You only have 2 likes 😂
3 episodes in to this week and I'm officially calling it. Highest quality set production they have ever had. Awesome work mythical crew
Next year do a Reese's bracket only. Because we all know that Reese's is going to win against any other candy bar.
Emily is absolutely hysterical every time she gets on camera
I freaking love her so much
GM Kitchen is so fun in part because she’s so prominent. She’s great.
As someone who is allergic to, both, peanuts and tree nuts, I'll have to enjoy them vicariously through you guys.
luckily i am not allergic to tree nuts so i can still eat kinder bars happily but i am allergic to peanuts lol
@@collinclary5762 Kinder Bars look so good. I always just buy things for my dad to eat since I can't 😆
I mentally said to myself "if Mr.goodbar makes it past round 1 I'll be happy" and then I saw it was going against reese's and incredulous laughteri ensued
Finally we let Rhett and link be themselves and rate peanut butter candy.
Right? Incredible it's never happened before
We need more Emily content here and at Mythical Kitchen. She's underappreciated.
P.S. This account is not owned or operated by Emily!!
hi Emily!
Sure thing Emily
that's exactly what an account run by emily would say...
Ha! Agreed!! She's great!!
I hope caramel is the next candy ranking, Twix needs its crown.
For sure, Twix is my favorite candy bar none (pun not intended).
Nope. The next category is fruity so like skittles,starbursts,air heads etc and the 3rd is older candy. It had pixie sticks,candy corn,candy cigarettes and several others I'm blanking on.
If only 100 grand didn’t exist. Then Twix would actually be the best caramel candy.
Sadly Twix isn't even on the board, they posted the brackets in the community tab
Yes 👏 please 👏
We all know one of the Reese’s was going to win…y’all need to do the ultimate Reese’s taste test to determine the best Reese’s (ie Pieces, Christmas Tree, Easter Egg, etc.)
It's Joan Wayne Gacy... His weirder sister... Emily makes every episode that much weirder and funnier! 💜
I have only read ONE comment praising Emily. Helllloooo!!! That woman is amazing and needs a raise. She's amazeballs!
She also stands up to wipe 🥰
Ok Emily’s mom. We get it
@@tancalex oh if I was Emily's momma, I'd be flaunting it! I'm barely old enough to maybe be a young auntie. 🤣🤣🤣
She was incredibly lack luster in this episode. Not sure what she did that would deserve extra praise.
She’s a writer, correct?
6:23 "there's a snake in my crawlspace" 🤣🤣🤣 dark
I believe they should have automatically not included Reese’s products because we all already know it’s their Kryptonite.
It's everyone without a peanut allergy's kryptonite. Lol
@@KristenLikesNerds It’s also everyone with a peanut allergy’s kryptonite
It was #1 seed for a reason
@@KristenLikesNerds I prefer a snicker over a reeses
Has Link always had a tat on his arm?
"If you lead a horse to water, will it float too Georgie" Emily as John Wayne Chasey, hilarious. And yes the pumpkins are better than the regular Reese's
2:48-2:51 Link's "Let's get chocolate nuts, y'all," gave me goosebumps! Love when that southern drawl comes in!!
Thanks for letting me be a part of this R&L!
Stay Hydrated :)
You did a great job!
Thank you ☺️
OMG!!!!!! It's the stay hydrated man himself!!!!!!!!!!!!
It is I💦
@@ReallyNotThatFunnyy omg u responded!!!
Their hair journey has been one of my favorite parts of the show
Fr fr
Same lol
For sure!!!
Yes! I think about this often
Absolutely lol
Reese's PB Pumpkins literally just Reese's peanut butter cups wearing a mustache. This whole tournament was stacked from the start, haha.
Totally agree! I really thought they were going to put through butterfinger and justify not putting in the same thing to give it a fair chance!
@@jeffreyh7951 same!!
Rhett's mom sounded a little rough today
Reese's Fast Break is still KING
idk what kind of crack they put in them things, im not a huge fan of candy but them fast breaks hit something 🥴
I am frequently in the GMK comments begging for more historical meal episodes with Emily so I am overjoyed to see her in a main GMM episode!! She is the best!
Emily has to be one of the best crew members. I feel like no matter what situation she's put into, she always enhances it.
She's an incredible woman! ❤❤
Am I the only one who is absolutely in love with Emily and her shenanigans?
She is literally the best. I'd love to see her on Smosh doing a try not to laugh challenge. She should have her own Mythical show.
yes
Remember: you can lead a horse to water, but a pencil must be lead.
most pencils nowadays are graphite and clay tho 🤔
Emily had me dying, she absolutely nails every character she does 😂
I just adore Emily. She is one of my favorite GMM crew members. 😘
I love Emily! She's naturally hilarious.
Little known fact is that Reese’s cups and the pumpkin Reese’s aren’t made from the same chocolate and peanut butter. Hence why some gluten intolerant people are allowed to eat the minis and the pumpkins. 🤯
I didnt know that !!!! Thats an interesting fact !!!!
It's a dark stormy morning as we get our first noreaster of the season. I look forward to these episodes every morning. Thank you R&L and crew!
Texas?
@@GamerKing50 New England
I am so angry with Link, he has said in the past that he doesn't like the other shapes of reese's better than the original because the ratio is perfect and the shapes screw that up. WHAT HAPPENED TO THAT LINK, HUH?!
It was a honor to have you even though i fully disagree the alpha roast with a smile then savage face
We all know Reeses is gonna win so why even have a peanut butter candy bracket lol
Exactly
Mini plot twist. The reeses PUMPKINS took it.
Shh They are performing a very scientific experiment to validi-fy that Reese’s is the superior peanut butter candy. 😂
@@chrishan9122 makes sense. Everyone knows that the seasonal reeses are better than the cup because they have more peanut butter than the cups. Means they are better. Who eats a reeses for the chocolate.
@@marcushankins8171 it taste creamier to me. I like the pumpkins better
as a British person who doesn’t know most American candy, I shouldn’t be this invested
same lmao
I am German and I don’t know any of the candies except for m&m‘s
Same
same here babes
I find it weird they call chocolate candy/sweets
Emily is awesome. She did a great job
I wish Reese’s also made a peanut butter pumpkin with pumpkin spice flavoring.
Also, PEANUT BUTTER Snickers is the only candy that could have given Reese’s some serious competition.
Peanut butter snickers are my absolutely favorite candy
I love Emily. She's one of the top comediennes on the internet right now.
I’m salty about 2 slots being taken up by the same candy (Reese’s).
Well , to be fair REESE'S candies are salty too so yeah :)
Yeah like what’s the point…do you really have to stack the deck that much?
Now I need to hold aside a Reeses Pumpkin, Christmas Tree, Heart, & Egg. Compare all the holiday shapes side by side. I also saw a Reeses Bat this year, but I don't usually see those around here.
also reese’s ghost
OMG !!!! Great idea !!! Also a great video Idea LOL Maybe Ill steal this idea for one of my videos :) LOL
@@FoodTastertv This is a highly important taste test. I think the more reviews the better. lol
16:42😂 I was not expecting that to happen at all……….But it was freakin hilarious!!😂😂😅
Here in Canada during winter they make a 1/2 pound reese's cup shaped like a hockey puck, it's huge 😂
Fax
Where?
@@brngrofdeth Ontario for sure...and just in gas stations and grocery stores
If it doesn't say inglasco or Sherwood , it's fake 😆😆😆
@@mr.peppermint9531 pretty sure it's across the country. My parents always send me one at Christmas and it takes a few days to eat. I slice it like a pie. Lol
This show is the reason I don't hit snooze again
Everyone liked that.
You can always watch it later.... Snooze all you need and do a great job!
How is it that 2 guys can almost cure my anxiety just by being themselves/ worker all night and I always have a hard time winding down but when a new episode comes on I watch and easily go to bed. Thank you Rhett and link !
Im right there with you. They some how calm my damn nurves down. Maybe is all the laughing they make me do
Emily is by far the funniest person whenever she's on. That costume has me dying laughing
Peanut butter M&M’s deserve so much more love, they’re my absolute favorite. I’m with you Link!!
Same!!
False
Reese’s shapes, pumpkins, Xmas trees, Easter eggs, etc…. Are the best. Absolutely better than regular Reese cups
Also, Emily’s my favorite crew member!
Yes, any of the shapes are better than the original. The ratio’s just better
@@SmartBlondeParadox I think it’s both the ratio and freshness. By virtue of their seasonality my theory is they’re made in smaller batches more often than regular cups.
Completely disagree. The choc/pb ratio on the shapes is completely wack. Big cups / the cadbury style eggs are the ones that have it right.
All I got from this episode is that LINK HAS NEVER SEEN A WHOLE EPISODE OF THE SIMPSONS!!
This isn’t getting enough attention!
I hope the watchamacallit makes it into the tournament, most underrated candy bar by far
Oh hey! My mom used to get those all the time. I never tried one cause they seemed odd but where do you even find them now?
@@zachmathis361 I’ve only seen them at gas stations in the middle of nowhere these days haha, they’re pretty good!
@@Nick-me1ms I'll try one if I find one. That's a good GMM tournament idea, best underdog candy
Emily is my Fav Mythical staffer.. Soooo funny!
and Stevie too 😛
They should do a Christmas Candy ranking and yes, during a Halloween event.
You're one of those people who puts Mariah Carey's "All I want for Christmas" on repeat days before Halloween even begins, aren't you? :P
What we really need is chunky peanut butter M&Ms. Everyone wins.
Chase should get a raise when gets back. The show is falling apart without him 😂
Yes! Lol. I much prefer John Wayne Chacy!! He's creepier....and quiet! 🤣
@@clueless4238 I wanted to see Josh Wayne Gacy... :(
@@rynecology 🤣
@@rynecology There's still 2 more candy brackets. He may be there
I love chase but I also love Emily and Josh I don’t agree at all with your comment saying the show is falling apart without chase 😂
How is no one talking about how Link has never seen a full episode of The Simpsons?!?
That was my takeaway from the entire episode lol
Me: watched all of them up to season 10.
😳
I haven’t either unless that family guy/Simpson episode counts
Been following that water guy for a year, so happy he finally got featured
I love Emily so much, shes so funny like i know shes not actually funny in this episode but the irony of her jokes being so bad is so fricken hilarious to me. Always a joy to have Emily on screen
I know they're not common, but I feel like a peanut butter twix bar could easily compete against reese's in this rather than all the standard candies that were included
Peanut butter TWiX ?? Is that a thing ?? id love to try that in one of my taste testing videos !!!
@@FoodTastertv Oh yes its very real and you should totally look it up. They come in a red packaging just so youll know you got the right one
@@Voltaictv I wish we got it in Canada so I could try and rank it !!
@@FoodTastertv As a Canadian we do have them but they’re hard to find
Even here in the US they aren't that common, but they are in the top 3 of all time for sure
I lovvvveeeee the Halloween tournament Showdown!!! One of my favorite episodes.
Reese’s are the Simone Biles of candy. Everything else is just competing for second place.
The Emily content weve all been needing
Emily is the best part of this episode, or any episode that she's in
Best part of the episode hands down was when Emily was introduced 😂😂😂😂 like hey guys I screwed up.
Any time there’s a tournament/competition on this channel, the first place should be taken by a jar of peanut butter.
Best Jerky? Peanut butter.
Best Water? Peanut butter.
Best Retirement Plan? Peanut Butter.
I've reviewed Peanut Butter water. It's not bad!
If you lead a horse to water…you’ll float too Georgie 😂😭
Josh should make a dish with all of the candy bars that lose in the cauldron!
Melt them all down blend together freeze
All time best part of spooky season I look forward to this every year
Peanut based candy, my favorite. Also, Link's rockin' that MERCH! Can't wait for my GME shirt!
Why is no one discussing the fact that Link has never seen an episode of "The Simpsons"?
We need Twix, KitKat, Milky Way and three musketeers!
I literally just recorded a video taste testing all CARAMEL CHOCOLATES , it includes all the ones you mentioned LOL.
They changed the Butterfinger recipe a while ago, not sure when. Old recipe Butterfinger is top 4 for sure.
Really? I had no idea. What's the taste difference?
Had no idea they did. Wow!
Did they really? I haven’t had one in a few years, but they’re my favorite.
Emily is my favorite part of good mythical morning 😂
The ratio to the original pb cup is TOOOOO GOOD. the minis, the doubles, and the pumpkins are too much pb for me 😂
With how much they love Reese's and how much they love nougat I feel like a Reese's Fast Break would blow their minds.
My absolute favorite candy bar!!
Peanut Butter Snickers for the win...
Emily needs to be protected at all costs!
I love Emily. She's definitely my favorite Mythical Crew member.
I laughed way too hard at "C'mon cowpokes, why so serious?"
Emily is SO good at improv, it's not even... well. Yes, it is funny. It's very, very funny.
Good mythical morning!! Have a great day everyone :)
you too :)
You too 😃
You too!
People not allergic to nuts: Oh wow I never knew!
People allergic to nuts: *seriously*
Yeah peanut allergies are common enough that of course Reese’s isn’t number one
@@TheRetroFanatic Yep
Reese’s Pieces are my all time favorite… so nostalgic.
You can lead a horse to water, you'll float too... xD I can't with Emily lol
You can’t have Halloween without Snickers, Reese’s, and M&M’s.
Truth
The perfect ingredients to a PERFECT HALLOWEEN !!!! Thats why I included them all in my HALLOWEEN taste testing video.
Except for when those M&M's have that "I've been sitting next to a fruity candy" flavor...
The water guy is ok in my book. Only because he said peanut m&ms are better than peanut butter
Appreciate it