this isnt actually the og x released. the leak never had strings, or a piano (until the very end for the outro). this is an edit x released. im commenting this because sometimes i see people saying "why did they remove so much of the song?? it used to be so beautiful" when the parts theyre talkijng about never existed officially
The overall final version on V2 is beautiful the hate needs to stop. Yandhi version is goated fr but the new one is still strong bro. So what’s missing on the final product to be an ALL TIME song ? Add the full 070 shake verse, Kid Cudi verse from Yandhi version and a longer outro with The Dream (I’m also quite sure that Jeremih was on it too on Yandhi). The Cyhi verse is just INSANE. And the guitar riff (fully made by Ty the GOAT is making it so cool). I was also so disappointed at first when the album came out. But I’ve patiently waited the reworked version (which was made 1 week later) but people can’t just wait a bit. It’s all about critism in this world. But we, the real ones, real YE fans knows that our GOAT is still here to deliver gems as Sky City is truly is.
played with some settings but thats it, for some reason the older version of sky city has better sounding vocals than the new one which is currently on spotify
![¥$, Kanye West & Ty Dolla $ign - City in the Sky [DEFINITIVE EDITION]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/JhH7-U4gV94/mqdefault.jpg)
the transition from the leak to the vultures 2 version makes the changes more depressing
It's cause the piano and Cudi adlibs are gone bruh. He fucked me again.
😢
this isnt actually the og x released. the leak never had strings, or a piano (until the very end for the outro). this is an edit x released. im commenting this because sometimes i see people saying "why did they remove so much of the song?? it used to be so beautiful" when the parts theyre talkijng about never existed officially
Good luck on ye recording a verse
Im really glad someone did this finally
Orchestaly insane
this is heaven :)
Damn, i've been waiting for someone to do this❤
Damn, this is fire
thanku for this bro😭
This is beautiful ❤
Peak 🙏
keep screaming in the dark, kanye
❤
The overall final version on V2 is beautiful the hate needs to stop. Yandhi version is goated fr but the new one is still strong bro. So what’s missing on the final product to be an ALL TIME song ? Add the full 070 shake verse, Kid Cudi verse from Yandhi version and a longer outro with The Dream (I’m also quite sure that Jeremih was on it too on Yandhi). The Cyhi verse is just INSANE. And the guitar riff (fully made by Ty the GOAT is making it so cool). I was also so disappointed at first when the album came out. But I’ve patiently waited the reworked version (which was made 1 week later) but people can’t just wait a bit. It’s all about critism in this world. But we, the real ones, real YE fans knows that our GOAT is still here to deliver gems as Sky City is truly is.
Not as strong as yhandi one imo
I don't hate it but I'm just disappointed
It’s just the AI Kanye verse that absolutely ruins it for me
I made my own version just because of that which is perfect
beautiful edit
great job but i dont think that kanye verse coming
could have been a GREAT verse
Fire
do you have SoundCloud link?
nah it gets taken down everytime i try and post it
we love you in pakistan saar!! my family listens to you daily, we play your music in the call centres!! pakistan love you!
Saar do not reedem it😭😭
did u mix the ai? why it sounds better
played with some settings but thats it, for some reason the older version of sky city has better sounding vocals than the new one which is currently on spotify
@@pabloballs3740it’s because those were real singing