FM Nirmala Sitharaman Faces A Googly By Audience Member At BSE I NDTV Profit
Вставка
- Опубліковано 14 тра 2024
- Nirmala Sitharaman Viral Video: Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman faced an unusual question at the BSE when one of the audience members came up with a 'funny' question. Watch what happened next
#nirmalasitharaman #brokers #news
For more videos subscribe to our channel: / @ndtvprofitindia
Visit NDTV Profit for more news: www.ndtvprofit.com/
Don't enter the stock market unaware. Read all Research Reports here: www.ndtvprofit.com/research-r...
Follow NDTV Profit here
Twitter: / ndtvprofitindia , / ndtvprofit
LinkedIn: / ndtvprofit
Instagram: / ndtvprofit
Facebook: / ndtvprofit
The question was serious and well framed.
Answer was insulting and shameful
It was insulting and shameful indeed!
There is no answer from her so giving no answer is insulting and shameful
what anyone could answer to that!! there wont be any.. its obvious!
Hindustan pvt ltd company question.
She is actually a FINANCE MINISTER who don't know any finance 😂😂😂. And think like she is a nobel laureate in enconomics...
Finance Minister with No Answer to a Basic question faced my many Indians.😢
No finance minister in the world can answer this .
Palanivel thiagarajan can even though I'm from northeast Mr ptr can answer this with no hesitation ....
@@marksangma572very true
She does not have any credentials to be an FM.
Modi just put her there to be his lackey and just sign off on whatever decisions/proposals come from above.
I am voting for bjp and because we don’t have any alternative than Modi and religion is important to me, I am not secular, if Modi doesn’t make me feel like a second class citizen because I am a Hindu I will vote for him
But I need the opposition and people to question the government like this gentleman did
Pretty sure congress would be in a worse off state but that doesn’t give bjp the right to avoid this
Middle Class should unite and demand for correction in tax system
Rich don’t pay taxes, poor people don’t as well, it’s only us middle class that pay taxes, we need our finance ministry to do better and bridge this inequality gap
18% GST on Health insurance WTF 😒. sucking the blood directly.😢
But many people are saying Modiiii moddiiiii moddiiiiii
gst is on medicines, hospital bills, etc.
Same 18% Gst in education.. why?? Constitution mehh food, shelter and education to basic needs hua naa.. I am a CS student.. and want to take admission in NiSM institute.. tell me why they are charging 18% Gst.. in education and basic necessities of life there must be tax exemption 😢
@@mnkshkhaving GST on medicines isn't a great idea
@@SQUID12 I'm saying it's already there. The government is not working for the welfare for citizens that's for sure!
Reason why modi never does press conference 😂
Ha ha ha 😂
You Caught The Nerve..😊
If you write something like this on bjp page your profile will be blocked for 21 days. That's what happened with me . Thanks to bjp IT cell.
Modi is good but FM I thing not
And you think rahul Gandhi is the best 😂.... Bhaai tu bhi na kario kabhi khud debate.
its not sleeping partner...its sleeping crocodile...
Sahi kha bhai😂
True…
😂😂😂😂
😂😂 he himself is a dallal asking questions
@@trilokyamohanchakra6351bhai question government se hi puchha jata hai.... opposition se nahi......thoda sa t socho yaar bhai pls😢
The answer is ..." I don't know the Answer ".
What a brilliant answer...
she must be thinking "no wonder feku does no press conferences".
He's not stating a problem, he's exposing day light roberry
serious Question. Careless answer. Not a laughable question. seriously ppl of the country shud file a case on taxation injustice
I was feeling angry at the end of the video. She’s not taking his questions very seriously too bad.
Look how the godi about anchor interrupts and moves to next question, even before the minister answers to the serious question asked to her!!!
What a shame!!!!!!!!!
Godi.... Godi...... Godi all the way!
Do not worry our serious people elect them again , so that they can laugh again
@@sashirkl😢
You are absolutely right sir.. Very serious question it is government should take and think on its solution rather sideline..
That was a genuine good question was waiting for a resonable answer dissapointed in the minister
Assuming that she did answer those questions, you'd still be paying those taxes tomorrow. The sad part is not the taxes, but the fact that you get next to nothing in return for what you pay. And it's unlikely to change irrespective of what party comes to power.
You are right . Do guna Lagan is a hard reality under any government or any country in the world .
@@666pss Agreed. 100%. But things will definitely be better than today if the current party is ousted. We are at a nadir. The only reasonable way, even politically speaking, is up.
@@666pss ya i will happily pay it but still will be satisfied if i knew why i was giving it and was it a good cause
She does not have any credentials to be an FM.
Modi just put her there to be his lackey and just sign off on whatever decisions/proposals come from above.
Oh God. She had clearly no answer to it. SHAMEFUL
Nirmala has no credentials of being a finance minister.... she is just existing to balance Southern States representative in the Modi govt......
Imagine FM cannot explain and making fun of a serious question.That’s pure arrogance
She is arrogant..
RIP NIRMALA DVD MUNDA 😂😂
Don't worry she won't be the next finance minister fortunately!
That's actually ignorance, arrogance is just a cover :)
@@animeshbehera6872 RIP NIRMALA MOODHEVI
Its really good question. But nirmala sitaraman MOST IDIOTIC FM ever
She does not have any credentials to be an FM.
Modi just put her there to be his lackey and just sign off on whatever decisions/proposals come from above.
True
As much as Modi is a danger and 'kalank' for India, his entire cabinet is a circus party of jokers - Nirmala (onion and garlic), Piyush (Einstein - no math), Smriti (cylinderella), ... Anyone Modi puts as a puppet is a serious clown (look at Dhankar, and even our President ... don't seem to have any credentials other than being a sycophant of Modi).
O safed kapda iske husband ne hi iski band Baja di..
@@RatreeecharOh really! That's why she told the media that she did not consume onion and garlic.
Kudos to that man! How articulate he was. Shame on Niramala.
Just think GOI is charging 18 % GST on medical insurance.
Yes man I was shocked when I made medical insurance for my family. Nerly 20% was made tax on the premium 😢
Nowadays, real struggle is joke and real joke is a struggle. Irony 😨
Real joke is living here
Hypocrisy is the way
mai tees saal ka hun, aur chalis saal maine bheek mangi hai
The most inefficient finance minister India ever got 😡
Indeed. Please spread the word and lets get her resigned.
@@potatoes1000 i don't think andhbhakts will let that happen
@@crazygameryt7982 don't be so mean to your fellow citizens by calling them names. you could try to be empathetic and kind to them, then they might listen.
@@potatoes1000 sorry'
They do have subramanian swamy in their party, still we have got her as our FM
Little man Parakala will be so happy today seeing his wife speechless 😂
That's a Good Slap on the Face of the Government. Nicely framed Question.
Nirmala tai being herself😂😂😂
Worst Finance Minister
Worst Finance minister ever..
Tai hi tho hai, aur Kuch nahi...FM namke liye hain
@@aaithubarlatu ban jaa toh 😂chapadganju
This sounds like kapuriya sir from vajiram
Simple..She doesn't eat onion... And don't invest
One real question is better than 100 spineless questions
Spot on!
You mean how to enjoy mango like Akshay Canada kumar asked feku?
This is a great question of every citizen from India. What a careless answer, she is not fit to be a Finance minister.
And this is our FM. Shame on us
the most logical question got the most illogical answer from a financially ignorant minister.
And pointed out by a Chinese paid bot or a Muslim
@@trilokyamohanchakra6351tax paying citizen
@@trilokyamohanchakra6351 Didn't you find anything wrong with FMs answer?
She is a dark stain on Modi's cabinet which otherwise has capable ministers like Gadkari, Jaishankar, Rajnath, Vaishnav, Shah etc. I don't understand why she is preferred over Goyal as FM. He was excellent as a FM for a short period of time in 2019 and presented a good budget but was unfortunately removed later to make her FM.
@@neerajgarg4273 It is impossible to answer . That's all.
People laughing as if it was some joke.
The guy asked a really good question that concerns every common citizen of this country.
Yes, and threw away an important question under the bus.
I think people were laughing because he was asking a serious question which everyone wanted to ask.
@@dostondoc23 no dear. This is what the general public has come to.
Everything is a meme or a joke
I think most people were laughing at the sad excuse of a FM.
If u watch some other videos , u’ll see how she tosses questions thrown at her with her arrogance or by giving the most stupidest answers.
Gosh knows why she’s giving out Bianca & Cibaca smiles 2day. She must have been told, elections are near so just laugh off all the questions that comes her way & she’s doing just that. When elections end & if they come back 2 power( which is most likely to happen due to all the EVM manipulation’s taking place all over the country ) u’ll see all the arrogance coming back in a jiffy & the smile leaving her face even faster than that.
To the middle class this is no laughing matter. Kudos to the person for asking this question. Double and triple taxation is slowly killing the middle class. In their 3rd term this point should be raised even more. Shame that she chose to deflect the question.
In third term you are expecting them to change what world are u living it will be worst more tax for sure
Such a serious question and she is laughing shamelessly
SHAME of a FM !!!!!!!
Bangladeshi spotted
@@trilokyamohanchakra6351Bhai , nirmala sitaraman husband interview dekho. He himself is saying modi is a joker.
Subramanian Swamy interview dekho.
@@trilokyamohanchakra6351andhbhakth spotted
@@Constitution-at-work. your name suggests you are obsessed with modi, get well soon
@@sree7465 who? Where?
Putting 28 percent tax on necessary goods and 8 percent on diamond... Nice logic😢
The old argument ...so you want smuggling to happen !! What is the volume of diamond and goods ...where was the question when vat was levied
3 percent not even 8
Because their rich friends loves buying diamonds
Isme Hasne wali kya baat hai, That person was taking about a serious matter
A man like Manmohan was our PM then to Modi. Such a disgrace happened. You can't expect any answers near future
*This govt. Is not for small people , they are only for big corporate.*
It's for the rich and poor not the middle-class who actually pay the taxes.
@@s-qc9nswhich poor are you talking. What is hunger index of the country?
@@s-qc9ns
Lol, you must be one of those bjp supporters for sneakily inserting the word "poor" into this 😂...
All governments do the same thing and tax us heavily and in this country rich poor and everyone in the middle all pay taxes in one way or another and that needs to change
@@rajrajesh1669he is correct you don't need to be a bjp supporter if you have some basic brain...😂😂
Dumbest FM
Really??? May be raga is the smartest
@@showmethemoney824yes much smarter than Feku Baba
@@showmethemoney824she is dumbest Finance minister accept the fact.
@@showmethemoney824 not sure if Raga is smart or not, but all we expect is an answer from the FM.
@@showmethemoney824 so that's your rebuttal for an incompetent FM???
What a question waow this is what we need to ask governments...
This is probably the first time she's not arrogant or dismissive or questioning his intent to question! Now we know what it takes! A clear cut finance issue!.
It's a shame being a finance minister not answering to this simple question of an indian taxpayer.
It clearly shows that The BJP government selects members not based on their skills but on their ability to become loyal followers.
Some are lucky enough to get a gifted career, there are much better finance brains in our country and are unlucky sweating in rains, because govt must have the knowledge to identify the knowledgeable person
@@ananthmysore440 like PTR
@@sarath.chander what is ptr
Well said
@@ananthmysore440 Dr. Palanivel Thiyagarajan, former finance minister of Tamilnadu.
Finally somebody says the truth!!!
There is no point in any more taxes if you are already levying an income tax.
Are you really serious . Every country has both direct and indirect taxes .
How much income tax do you pay ?
@@mamtashah-cc4vb we are so used to taxes
@@mamtashah-cc4vbEvery well functioning country also gives benefits of those taxes.. how much does GOI do?
@@mamtashah-cc4vbthis govt is looting in the name of tax.
WHat's happening in India is called Tax Terrorism !!
Salaried class is being milked till their blood oozes off !
While the Elite business men are becoming billionaires ...just a few bunch of business men growing is the real success of this BJP Union Govt !!!
Common man under BJP's rule has suffered the most , while salaried, small/medium scale business, farmer...every other middle income families have been TAXED and milked till they bleed ..in the name of GST and TAX !!
She just has another 20 days left to dishonourably discharge the duties of a Finance Minister. That being said, this is a rare occasion where she has smiled, not smirked.
Must have got instructions from higher ups due to elections .
Never ever seen her smile when such questions are directed at her .
This is a failure government, she is speechless
When you hear the laughs you can tell why we deserve the system and situation we are in. The guy is telling his issues and we the people are laughing accepting all this as normal. We deserve what we get.
You actually deserve the earlier FM who was poking fun at digital payments. There vision was limited to serve a family. BTW, all the taxes were there before 2014. I wonder why did your brain did not work at that time.
@@NoName-bz3vb my brain always work i never voted for bjp
@@NoName-bz3vb I am with you. The UPA government is to blame. They let the country down the sewage hole by serving just one family. Modi's government is helpless. They just have to keep following the diktats of the UPA regime. I wish this government had the balls to make things better. But sadly, this is a government that always plays on the back foot. Scared lot. Don't even know how to answer a question in public. ☹
@@kashan1608what’s stopping the NDA from rectifying those mistakes?
@@kashan1608anphad ho kya ji? Economics padhe ho kavi? Nationalised institutions bech diya ....airport, mines, ports, electricity sab 1-2 insaan ke hath me hai...2014 tak loan 50 lakh cr tha avi 10 saal me 200 lakh cr pohoch gaya hai...aur yaha angrezi batiya rahe ho ....jab kuch nahi kar sakte to jhooth bolkr satta me aana hi nahi chaiye tha...bandaro ki tah gaadi pr kabza kar liye par bandaro ko gaadi chalani nahi aati to dosh previous owner ki nikaal rahe ho.😂
This is the answer of finance minister of a country ..wahh modiji wahhh 😂😂😂
The toughest question she was ever been asked . Unfortunately she couldn't answer that .
Simple..She doesn't eat onion... And don't invest
That is actually an eye opening question.
We owe a response from Honourable FM.
honour my foot.
Honourable?
@@pecanpie6127she bought india from 10th to 5th largest, not like pappu, she did do hard work
@@trilokyamohanchakra6351pappu se etne fatti kyun hai tere har jagah le ata hai use obsessed ho gya hai Bhai tu
@@trilokyamohanchakra6351 haa by allowing remittances nicely it will happen, did our incomes increase did our taxes decrease? as a income tax payer are we getting anything, we are treated same like everyone.
HA HA HA. Wah amazing answer. Even paying property tax attracts a GST which is moronic. All our money is just going to politicians who do not even deserve to be paid INR 10 a day.
Well said bro
Who told you gst is levied on buying a house 😅
@@superman4264 Did u just graduated from Whatsapp University? There is 1% GST for affirdable housing and 5% GST for non- affordable housing. + all the charges and taxes while purchasing with brokers, stamp and what not. Sit down.
@@Kevin24.Have you ever paid yearly house tax to mcd its a tax and its taxed by gst toh ise kehte tax pe Tax
@@Kevin24. 😅😅😅 Pretending to be educated ehh.. i am a qualified ca
Gst is not levied if housing project is already completed and completion certificate has been issued by a competent authority
Go get some education first before embarassing yourself.
That guy asked a genuine question and our FM made a joke out of it. And kudos to NDTV for posting the video.
What a perfectly framed question! The actual problems we face in our day to day transactions.
The art of turning a serious question into comedy... to get away from it
she is actually unfit for the job. she was never fit for it. she is spewing dirt into India golden growth years. should resign out of shame.
Respect for person who asked the question which is there in everyone's mind but none had guts to ask.
Why so high taxes for government when the trader and investor is taking all the risk with his earned money on which he has already paid tax.
Lets spread this as wide as possible
Yes a very genuine question.
Yes if we lose the investment. Government won't help us if we gain they Will grab it
@@rajeshthomas3965 yeah , because of all kind of taxes maximum Indian traders are at loss.
@@rajeshthomas3965and you fools want to elect pappu and increase taxes
Laughter cannot be the answer of such a beautiful question.
He is sooo valid and correct, he spoke for each one of us who feel the same way…. We are taxed today left, right and center….
I also wanted to ask the same question to FM and the govt.
But she responded shamelessly.....
That was genuinely a good question... Middle class family is burdened with soo many taxes, I could feel the frustration in his tone itself... Very relatable
What about poor bhai?
Atleast middle class can efford to pay taxes, invest in equity and rant in front of FM about STT of rs100-200.
Poor don't even get that opportunity and middle class is thriving at cost of poor in this country. They can't even pay medical bills.
@@t--k. I don't get ur logic in saying middle class is thriving,on cost of poor, how, can u explain,poor people is vastly benefitted by government scheme,I am TN,here,poor people get free rice in ration, with other commodities like Dhal,oil sugar at cheap rate, education is free, have state government medical insurance,,gets free laptop, cycle, school commodities for free in government scheme, monthly 1000 ruppes for poor home makers,1000 ruppes for girls who persue college,free bus for transportation,all at cost of middle class tax payer,who doesn't even get a good road to travel.
No political party talks about this. Thus they are losing.
This my Finance minister, and prime minister is even worse.. What a generation to live in😂
😁👍Proud confessions that Govt is sleeping, oblivious and ignorant of woes of hard working honest tax payers😅wah Nirmala ji wah👌
"sleeping partner" is all she heard in the 2 minutes that guy took to ask question. 🤦
What a finance minister, talking our money and having no answer is a great answer
Very well said it pathetic for middle class family too
the answer is 20 carore middle class is supporting 120 carore poor and rich.. middle class is the middle child...be a poor or rich..dont be inbetween...
True..but in this govt poor people aren't getting anything as well
@@SK-zn2xg rich is getting everything
@@khedhareeswari4700Because they don't pay taxes
Compare to middle class
And you keep complaining, also keep voting for rulers installed by the rich!! 😂😂😂😂
@@VinayKumar09952 Even a pack of Parle is taxed on MRP. Let's not be anti-poor and critically acknowledge the fact that this regime only benefits the uber rich.
Listening to all of that so attentively, I taught she was gonna come back with some good reply. But she played dodge ball 🤣
Took that on her face
This is exactly how all the ministers in this current cabinet respond to a handful of serious questions received over years. The head of the cabinet has the privilege of not being asked ONE single serious question, a clear give away about their disposition.
not dodge ball.. she left the ball hit her face and shamelessly laugh hiding inability 😂
@@kashan1608why do you think aam kaisa kaatha hain, not a serious question?!! 😂😂😂
Now that's your fault, not the supreme leaders!!
WHat's happening in India is called Tax Terrorism !!
Salaried class is being milked till their blood oozes off !
While the Elite business men are becoming billionaires ...just a few bunch of business men growing is the real success of this BJP Union Govt !!!
Common man under BJP's rule has suffered the most , while salaried, small/medium scale business, farmer...every other middle income families have been TAXED and milked till they bleed ..in the name of GST and TAX !!
WTF finance minister of india , cannot answer a common man question ..... Waaaah Bhai waaah
The finance minister’s response was an absolute disaster. Hope we get a finance minister who is more responsible and accountable.
100% that this question is asked by fellow gujju bhai. Excellent!
Pain of all honest taxpayers. Taxes like European countries, social services like African countries.
Yes, many people (mainly andh bhakts) still not understanding how much high taxes we are paying. Even after paying 10% to 30% Income-tax, with that white money if we buy anything we have to pay additional 5% to 30% other taxes like GST, toll tax etc taxes. And other side Modi government waved off lakhs of thousands of crore rupees loans of corporaters (which is our tax money). Just this one reason is enough for Indian people to not to vote Modi and BJP.
disregarding such beautiful question with a silly answer is UNACCEPRTABLE!! honestly people are loosing more money to government than they earning....
It's really a bad luck to have such ministers . God bless our Country
Sabki Dil ki baat kehdi is admi ne..🔥
Very genuine query. As always remains unanswered.😏
Wowwww what a anaswer, we should make their team sleep for sometimes 😊
Govt is looting not earning.
One of the most important and legitimate questions. Sadly couldn't get an answer for it.
Thats a brilliant question. For the first time I felt Sitharaman is incompetent. She should have responded. Everything he asked was a serious and valid question which goes unnoticed by a taxpayer.
best finance minister ever … 🙏🏻… 100% attitude 0% accountability
Expected something like this from her, she never failed to disappoint
Laughing at the plight of common taxpayer.. That's our Finance minister for you
With all that extra taxes, Indian govt. is building infrastructure, hospitals, trains, airports etc. Atleast this govt. is not shipping arms and ammunition to war zones with citizen's Taxes.
Current generations' tax money is being used to build infrastructure, with inflated prices, because previous generations' tax money was either NOT used or was MISUSED. It's same like, if your parents have a house, you can start saving from next level. Now, they're starting from scratch as greenfield projects.
Very logical and good question by the gentleman. Expeted a proper answer from FM. Nirmala Tai is the most shameless, hopeless and worst finance minister.
Finally some one ask genuine question 😂
Govt is slaughtering same goat multiple times.
The expected answer was, "Why do you need an own house in Mumbai? I also live in a rented apartment and have stopped using onions."😂
That was a very serious question. Not sure what's there to laugh about.. the state of a middle income man who pays taxes is actually sad.
क्योंकि मैडम प्याज नही खाती जो प्याज खाते हैं वो जाने😂😂😂😂
Very well put. The govt is silently skimming of all the cream
He only asked that question so that FM can crack a joke.
She will say I don't have a house I stay in MP's bunglow
It is sad to see that people are laughing and clapping....
Because it is animal farm
Disappointingly, fm is unable to answer a common man's question, shows how they don't have the common people in their mind
No one is forcing you to buy shares/ house using govt infra and protection. Buy and pay at your own risk.
And once fraud happens then send your own people as police to investigate.
Make your own provisions to keep your mumbai property in your possession as your mr lodha gave you oral commitment or notary later in just 100 rs or may be in your son’ s note book note in last page as terms and condition.
This way you are just sleeping with your own partner and being a good human.
Anyways I like to pay taxes for services from govt as I dont want to manage
1- My road to go office and to secure my employment rights (income tax).
2- My stock transaction safety, manage sebi and IAS system (stt)
3- my property value and safety fee that no one can take it just by occupying it forcefully. (Registry fee and property tax )
And many more.
The man want to take bath and is looking for free soap and shampoo after paying water bill only.
And when lifeboys guys ask for soap payment he asks - are you my sleeping partner?
After seeing comment section I see he is not the only of this catagory... There is a army of illogical people here.
Sitaram gave useless answer instead she should have not said anything.
this govt is not support.. common people... only corporate people..😮💨😔😪☹😮😡
One second, is this the Kapil Sharma Show? What is happening with these so called public servants. No one is ready to take responsibility of anything or answer the common citizens problems. Is this a democracy??
The behaviour stems from their leader Modi. He is apparently only answerable to Parliment and never turns up. Nimmy has no answers to any questions and the BJP are so arrogant that they dont even have a manifesto. In other democracies the media would rip the Govt apart if there is no manifesto. They deserve to lose for their arrogance and lack of empathy with citizens.
Irrespective of the party line, we get nothing back for our taxes , no free medical which is world class or free education or old age care and not even our villages are developed
correct our budget allocation for education itself very low but govt is spending for advertisement more than 6,400 crores
our tax money is publicity money for govt
Most of the tax Money is spend on Paying high salary to the government employee their pension etc
@@wasimansari-rt5ikGovernment employees do not get much high salaries..
WHat's happening in India is called Tax Terrorism !!
Salaried class is being milked till their blood oozes off !
While the Elite business men are becoming billionaires ...just a few bunch of business men growing is the real success of this BJP Union Govt !!!
Common man under BJP's rule has suffered the most , while salaried, small/medium scale business, farmer...every other middle income families have been TAXED and milked till they bleed ..in the name of GST and TAX !!
Modi bhakts r willing to pay 70% of their salary as tax.......in case they have a job
When the FM has no clues on anything, this further reflects the state of the economy.
Cant believe it finance minister couldnt even process the questions
FM : all tax goes to Home Minister's son pocket
@@potatoes1000 andhbhakt come in defense for their PAPA🤣🤣
Every andhbhakt moment : when they don't have the proper answer they bring congress out of nowhere in the discussion
A citizen is asking question to her finance minister.. everybody is laughing..he is sharing his pain..and finance minister say I can't answer... such a shame to be a Finance minister... honestly speaking after Manmohan Singh we never had good finance minister...just think she was defence minister too...is it a joke ? One day you work in defence another day finance?
Manmohan singh made 1.4 lakh crores of oil bond. Now that debt was settled by bjp government
Superb brother… pertinent issue raised…
These should be the questions. Bravo for the attempt.