Shamsi and Cordial Christian Discussing God's Law at Speakers Corner

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 11 жов 2024
  • Status of Jesus in Islam
    ➜ www.islamjesus.ws
    Islam on terrorism
    ➜ www.islamagains...
    Subscribe to this channel for more content like this, and please give this video a thumbs-up and share it across all social media platforms.
    Abu Hurraira narrated that The Prophet ﷺ said:
    ❝Whoever invites to guidance will be rewarded like those who follow him in guidance are rewarded, and that will not decrease the reward of those who have followed him❞.
    [Collected by Imām Muslim]
    To get in touch with a Muslim community or attend gatherings of knowledge that are local to you, email us and we will direct you in-shā Allah. We also welcome questions from non-Muslims who want to understand Islām.
    Email: admin@dusunnah.com

КОМЕНТАРІ • 122

  • @DUSDawah
    @DUSDawah  5 років тому +21

    29:04 ➜ www.shariah.ws/

    • @kitkatpleasesubscribe6720
      @kitkatpleasesubscribe6720 5 років тому

      DUS Dawah, please brother Shamsi please you should clarify.
      The bani Israili tribe (children of Israil tribe) are also Muslims and some of the people from this tribe broke the covenant (the sub tribe known as Yahudi tribe) .... and just like other tribes peoples who are Muslim from the past present and the in the future

    • @kitkatpleasesubscribe6720
      @kitkatpleasesubscribe6720 5 років тому

      DUS Dawah , brother Shamsi please you should have tell that Pagan Christian that generally the bani Israilis are Muslim other then the Yahudi tribe who generally broke the covenant

    • @muhammadibraheem3652
      @muhammadibraheem3652 5 років тому +3

      @@kitkatpleasesubscribe6720 Ahlul Kitaab are still considered Kuffaar. Bani Isra'eel (descendents of Yaqub alayhi salam) that accepted the Anbiyah at the time of Eesaa alayhi salam right up to the twelve children of Yaqub Alayhi Salam are all muslimeen. But, anyone from Ahlul Kitaab today who doesn't accept the Messenger صلى الله عليه و سلم are not Muslims. Just like the Messenger said even if my brother Musa was alive he would have no other choice but follow me (ie. the Qur'aan and my authentic Sunnah).

    • @majjsmamaysi6277
      @majjsmamaysi6277 4 роки тому

      @@kitkatpleasesubscribe6720 brother shamsi dosent read the comments. He dosent even control the channel. Dont call upon anyone except Allah. U should delete ur comment. Dont write likely he heara u because he dosent

    • @jettdorian8153
      @jettdorian8153 3 роки тому

      i dont mean to be off topic but does anybody know a way to get back into an Instagram account..?
      I somehow lost the password. I would appreciate any assistance you can offer me!

  • @Ishi79
    @Ishi79 3 роки тому +28

    It took a miracle for me to become a Christian, it took studying Christianity and the bible for me to become a Muslim.

  • @abdirahman292
    @abdirahman292 5 років тому +74

    Christianity will put shackles on your brain and intelligence that answering simple questions becomes mental gymnastics.

    • @shuhelmiah7729
      @shuhelmiah7729 3 роки тому +2

      Love this comment, what a great explanation.

  • @CallerToSalafiya
    @CallerToSalafiya 5 років тому +53

    May Allah bless you brother shamsi! And all the brothers involved at dus! And may Allah guide that Christian brother, ma sha Allah he always comes across very collected and humble

    • @mrb7935
      @mrb7935 5 років тому +1

      Please like, subscribe and share this video so others can benefit! Baarak allahu feek

  • @sofbof2408
    @sofbof2408 5 років тому +81

    Shamsi: Where are you from?
    Christian: In what sense?

    • @mrb7935
      @mrb7935 5 років тому +3

      Please like, subscribe and share this video so others can benefit! Baarak allahu feek

    • @abdulazizfareh8927
      @abdulazizfareh8927 5 років тому +2

      It could mean where were you born, where were you raised up and what nationality are you..You could be born in japan grow up in Canada and be an Indonesian

    • @ummul5397
      @ummul5397 5 років тому +8

      reminds me of a nerd or politician.. alot of gymnastics going on there

    • @Muslim_Sunni_1
      @Muslim_Sunni_1 5 років тому

      @@abdulazizfareh8927 True lol

    • @TA-vu9se
      @TA-vu9se 5 років тому +6

      Just like Paperboy. Q: Are you a Christian?
      A: So in terms of.......

  • @Leon-sq5mc
    @Leon-sq5mc 5 років тому +22

    Brother shamsi barak ALLAH feek. Luke is a gentleman. May ALLAH guide him to the right path

  • @rogue_spirit
    @rogue_spirit 5 років тому +18

    I suppose if someday I meet this gentleman and greet him "Good morning" his answer would be "In what sens, is it good for you, for me or in general?" 😂
    My friend, with easy things keep it easy, if you keep this approach you'll miss the big picture and lose valuable time, yet if you were to apply this methodology on the Bible in the first place then things would be so clear to you as they are to the brothers who were trying to show them to you.
    Keep the honesty and the sincerity in seeking the truth so that Allah/God - the one and the only true God - may guide you!

    • @abdirahman292
      @abdirahman292 5 років тому +1

      In what sense you post this comment?

  • @greenhomestead9895
    @greenhomestead9895 5 років тому +72

    The young man is scared to bring his creed forward because the foundation is verrrry shaky.

    • @Umar_1994_
      @Umar_1994_ 5 років тому +2

      I agree and disagree with you, at speakers corner people ask a surface level question, you agree or disagree to it and then they hold on to it with dear life even though you may have meant or understood something completely different. I think he's treading carefully because yes, he doesn't want to be caught out but also because he doesn't want to lie or be insincere.

    • @mrb7935
      @mrb7935 5 років тому +4

      Please like, subscribe and share this video so others can benefit! Baarak allahu feek

  • @abdullahmahmoodfahim6118
    @abdullahmahmoodfahim6118 5 років тому +15

    allahumma baarik akhuna shamsi
    awesome discussion..
    especially destroying the claim "god is a man" part.
    may Allaah give u best rewards in this life & hereafter..
    may Allaah give hidayah to the Christian man..

    • @mrb7935
      @mrb7935 5 років тому

      Please like, subscribe and share this video so others can benefit! Baarak allahu feek

    • @abdullahmahmoodfahim6118
      @abdullahmahmoodfahim6118 5 років тому

      wa feek baarakallaah

  • @kiyzFn
    @kiyzFn 5 років тому +19

    You can see this mans fitrah trying to break through when he speaks may the creator, the one true god guide him towards submission to him. I don’t think his heart believes what his tongue speaks. This man is a good man I hope to see him break the wall between him and islam

    • @mrb7935
      @mrb7935 5 років тому

      Please like, subscribe and share this video so others can benefit! Baarak allahu feek

  • @6ami94
    @6ami94 3 роки тому +2

    I like this kind of DUSes , its fully of info and good answers without shauting

  • @selfdiscipline296
    @selfdiscipline296 5 років тому +25

    This guy knew the outcome, thats why he was avoiding to answer lol

  • @BlueSkyblueseagreenland
    @BlueSkyblueseagreenland 5 років тому +15

    'It's not easy cos you got baggage' 😂
    bechara seems overwhelmed
    May Allaah guide this poor man he is very scared bless

    • @mrb7935
      @mrb7935 5 років тому +2

      Please like, subscribe and share this video so others can benefit! Baarak allahu feek

  • @7LamarOdom
    @7LamarOdom 5 років тому +31

    You either know everything at all time or you don't. Only The Creator had this ability. No one else. Not even Jesus. It's not difficult

    • @amir123786
      @amir123786 5 років тому +2

      Rollex Maximus seriously. I don’t understand why Christians don’t just accept that fact 😐

    • @7LamarOdom
      @7LamarOdom 5 років тому +2

      @@amir123786 cognitive dissonance

    • @mrb7935
      @mrb7935 5 років тому

      Please like, subscribe and share this video so others can benefit! Baarak allahu feek

  • @intekhabalam2613
    @intekhabalam2613 5 років тому +4

    Mashallah subhanallah... Bro Shamsi. May Allah keep you healthy and fit to make more videos. Ameen...
    I would ask to you to make videos on Barelvi and Deobandi.

  • @tiloshah4778
    @tiloshah4778 5 років тому +13

    Luke realises that in order to be a Christian, you have to make every simple thing very complicated and contradictory. Every Christian knows how much in reality is the quantity "One" . But Christianity has forced them to believe that 'One' can equal to 'Two' 'Three' even a 'Hundred'

  • @farhanaimdani8865
    @farhanaimdani8865 3 роки тому

    Yahh Allah ..Thank u for .give .all muslim like shamsi ..always bless him..and give him good healthy..and live so many years ....thank brod shamsi for ..u r..effort..Allah ..send u.in janna..Inshaallah

  • @christopherwells3426
    @christopherwells3426 5 років тому +4

    The verse in the Quran says that if you kill one innocent person it is as if you killed the whole of humanity. And if you save one innocent person it's if you saved the whole of humanity.

  • @Pacifica1
    @Pacifica1 5 років тому

    Glad the title shows the Christian man was cordial.....and he *was* in the video. God bless you for testifying bro Shamsi

    • @mrb7935
      @mrb7935 5 років тому

      Please like, subscribe and share this video so others can benefit!

  • @greyzstah
    @greyzstah 5 років тому +5

    He always says in principle just another diversion

    • @mrb7935
      @mrb7935 5 років тому

      Please like, subscribe and share this video so others can benefit! Baarak allahu feek

  • @aminebenabdellouahad
    @aminebenabdellouahad 4 роки тому +1

    Shamsi, I like you man; "Khiti biti" only Moroccans know it :)

  • @omaromaros7170
    @omaromaros7170 3 роки тому +1

    اللهم صل على محمد و على أزواجه و ذريته كما صليت على آل إبراهيم و بارك على محمد و على أزواجه و ذريته كما باركت على آل إبراهيم إنك حميد مجيد. و رضي الله عن الصحابة أجمعين

  • @islamislam9763
    @islamislam9763 3 роки тому +1

    Man it's like pulling a tooth trying to get Luke to answer the simple question 😅

  • @bigayhiiran4050
    @bigayhiiran4050 5 років тому +27

    Why Christian's act dumb to answer a simple question.

    • @mrb7935
      @mrb7935 5 років тому

      Please like, subscribe and share this video so others can benefit! Baarak allahu feek

    • @skdoremi6666
      @skdoremi6666 5 років тому +3

      Because its complicated and a mystery 😒😒

    • @bigayhiiran4050
      @bigayhiiran4050 5 років тому

      @@skdoremi6666 mystery loooool basically u dnt want to know about the father as the truth God....
      There is nothing mystery about that.

    • @bigayhiiran4050
      @bigayhiiran4050 5 років тому

      What is so complicated.
      Jesus is not the father, and the father is not Jesus it's so simple even child would tell u that...or u mean Christian's can't understand Jesus loool

    • @skdoremi6666
      @skdoremi6666 5 років тому +2

      @@bigayhiiran4050 ahemmmm.... am muslim😒it was a sarcastic comment since christian always answere with those two comments.

  • @mohamedmohamoud7716
    @mohamedmohamoud7716 4 роки тому +1

    I believe the mental gymnastics the Christian juggles with defending things like trinity/ inconsistincies/ contradictions is simply not wanting to accept their forefathers were upon a path and doctrine of falsehood, may Allah guide us and them, oppression is to give the rights to other than its rightful owner, worship not but God the Eternal the all Powerful

  • @TheRayanKhan
    @TheRayanKhan Рік тому +1

    Islam is the only true way!

  • @BrbZrk_G
    @BrbZrk_G 4 роки тому +6

    If someone answers "where u from" with "in what way?" then.. Jew philosophers did their job well.

  • @syedzukarnainsyedmohd3208
    @syedzukarnainsyedmohd3208 3 роки тому

    Checked sahih International can it be trust.. are there any hadith 38:5 please advise tq..

  • @Truthhurts769
    @Truthhurts769 2 роки тому

    Wallahi this guy is waffling so much. He is wasn’t interested in speaking about the core belief in Allah. He had an agenda and an excuse to get out of that conversation yet he had so much energy for his attempt to discredit and argue with one ayah. He wasn’t attempting to understand. His heart wasn’t open. Listening to him stressed me out SubhanAllah. Brother Shamsi has a lot of patience Allahuma Bariik 😭 Why is it so difficult to understand that God is perfect? Why is that conversation so philosophical? He was avoiding things because he doesn’t have an explanation for his core beliefs. Something I’ve seen a lot from these videos when Christian’s are asked to explain their core beliefs. They just simply can’t. Alhamdulilah for Islam. May Allah keep us firm on the truth.

  • @chotalks8224
    @chotalks8224 3 роки тому

    I think the question is “do you think God was merciful in the bible “Old Testament”.

  • @kebbahydara4659
    @kebbahydara4659 5 років тому

    ولا يقتلون النفس التي حرم الله الا بالحق ولا يزنون ومن يفعل ذلك يلق اثاما

  • @عبدالله-ت3ج3ي
    @عبدالله-ت3ج3ي 5 років тому +3

    Shamsi labas akhi twahachnak
    من الممكن تعطيني رقم هاتفك و الله احبك في الله

    • @ekbalhussain6121
      @ekbalhussain6121 5 років тому

      7ta Ana twa7chtu.

    • @mrb7935
      @mrb7935 5 років тому

      Please like, subscribe and share this video so others can benefit! Baarak allahu feek

    • @gandolf8637
      @gandolf8637 5 років тому +1

      ana mina ljaliya lmaghribia fi canada o7ib akhi shamsi fi lah katiran

  • @wan551
    @wan551 3 роки тому

    completed all things... simple questions.

  • @islamislam9763
    @islamislam9763 3 роки тому +1

    35:32 he went in to alzheimer's mode lol just answer a simple question bro 😄
    I really like Luke and I pray inshalah he'll guide him

  • @MoroccanARROWS
    @MoroccanARROWS 2 роки тому

    @29:45 *not up to any خيطي بيطي to do it !!!* (You killed me 🤣🤣🤣 I think only Moroccans and Algerians can get this..).
    Regarding the video itself, personally, it is difficult for me to debate secondary things when the person doesn't agree or at least have an idea about what Tawheed is. *Everything other than Tawheed is SECONDARY.*
    May Allah Guide all of us to His Straight Path and maintain us steadfast on it and show us the Truth as truth and grant us to follow it and show us the Falsehood as falsehood and grant us to avoid it. Ameen

    • @batyr123_
      @batyr123_ 8 місяців тому

      What does kheeytee-beeytee mean brother?

    • @IZIKI-399
      @IZIKI-399 4 місяці тому

      شرح ليه

  • @hussainabdulrazak2736
    @hussainabdulrazak2736 5 років тому +2

    Brother shamsi do recommend listening to د.عثمان الخميس و د.سالم الطويل thank you jazakalahu khairan

    • @mrb7935
      @mrb7935 5 років тому

      The scholars have warned against these individuals such as sheikh ubayd Al jaabiree. Better to stick to those recommended
      Please like, subscribe and share this video so others can benefit! Baarak allahu feek

    • @basheerabdullah9434
      @basheerabdullah9434 5 років тому +2

      Sheikh Saleem Altaweel is fine akhi. Whoever says otherwise needs evidence.

    • @hussainabdulrazak2736
      @hussainabdulrazak2736 5 років тому

      @@mrb7935 brother شيخ سالم الطويل studied under شيخ ابن عثيمين رحمه الله

    • @hussainabdulrazak2736
      @hussainabdulrazak2736 5 років тому +1

      @@basheerabdullah9434 I totally agree

    • @mrb7935
      @mrb7935 5 років тому

      @@hussainabdulrazak2736 okay, but what is his condition today? Also, studying under someone means nothing if your methodology isn't the same as theirs
      But regardless, the elder scholars are those whom we should go back to in affairs, and they are known

  • @chihabahmed5207
    @chihabahmed5207 3 роки тому +1

    Shamsi: How old are you?
    christian: in what sense

    • @aishax01
      @aishax01 3 роки тому

      😂😂💀💀

  • @djameldaham6291
    @djameldaham6291 4 роки тому +2

    Shamsi is From ALGERIA 🇩🇿🇩🇿🇩🇿🇩🇿🇩🇿🇩🇿🇩🇿🇩🇿

  • @tarikrafiki1790
    @tarikrafiki1790 5 років тому +12

    Christianity is illogical that's why it's dying...

  • @kitkatpleasesubscribe6720
    @kitkatpleasesubscribe6720 5 років тому

    The bani Israili tribe (children of Israil tribe) are also Muslims and some of the people from this tribe broke the covenant (the sub tribe known as Yahudi tribe) .... and just like other tribes peoples who are Muslim from the past present and the in the future

  • @EmruAlqais
    @EmruAlqais 4 роки тому

    *Cordial to reach what he wants but not sincere, turned philosophical when asked a simple question*

  • @firsttry5419
    @firsttry5419 5 років тому +4

    England is my city
    London is my country
    🤪🤪🤪🤪🤪🤪🤪

  • @nadiahulwat.1788
    @nadiahulwat.1788 4 роки тому

    35:48 please dont burden him, even 1+1+1 they dont know

  • @reasonne765
    @reasonne765 4 роки тому +1

    The christians people have habits to bileave that religion is something strange and something complicated so they cant understand a thing easy like Islam.
    Its inside their minds.
    Like phylosophie.
    Islam is very easy but them they make their din something you can understanding easy.
    So you have to talk to them like baby and slowly and with proof logically...... May Allah guide us and them

  • @sirjuju4766
    @sirjuju4766 2 роки тому +1

    Muslim: if one is all knowledgeable while the other is not, which one is all knowledgeable ?
    Christian: IN WHAT SENSE ?
    Me: This is why christians are so confused. They wish to remain in their current state of confusion.

  • @lifefordollars6656
    @lifefordollars6656 5 років тому +1

    Word became flesh.. so Jesus is flesh..
    And the flesh died on cross.. and the dead flesh did not become word again..

  • @Sir.T
    @Sir.T 4 роки тому +1

    This guy is doing to much, playing dumb 😂 finding excuses, that’s all he’s doing. - May Allah guide these lost Christians. Smh

  • @abea3396
    @abea3396 4 роки тому

    indeed, this guy worships his brain...

  • @abdellatifhmani8477
    @abdellatifhmani8477 4 роки тому

    Masha Allah 3lik Brother Shamsi

  • @The_Angry_BeEconomist
    @The_Angry_BeEconomist 5 років тому

    Shamsi's knowledge is very strong, but when it comes to political and economic issues within the Islamic context in modern day society he is not quite as strong. He continually refers to countries and governments of these countries as if they are legitimate. He should distinguish between Islamic ideas of nations versus the kafir version of nation states.

    • @hussaingani
      @hussaingani 5 років тому +3

      He doesn't need to have strong knowledge on politics and economics. He has knowledge of his religion and other religion and that suffices in calling people to the truth.

    • @The_Angry_BeEconomist
      @The_Angry_BeEconomist 5 років тому

      @@hussaingani yeah but he is wrong to refer to countries as if they are supposed to exist. Countries are a construct of ribah.

    • @BlueSkyblueseagreenland
      @BlueSkyblueseagreenland 5 років тому +1

      The Angry Economist he's calling people to the worship of Allaah alone, I think you can see where politics becomes unimportant.

    • @The_Angry_BeEconomist
      @The_Angry_BeEconomist 5 років тому

      @@BlueSkyblueseagreenland yeah then he should refrain from referring to countries as if they are normal, they are a form of ribah, and Allah has declared war on those who engage in it. So do not refer to it as if it is normal within Islam.

    • @hamzahalharbi4566
      @hamzahalharbi4566 4 роки тому +1

      The Angry Economist i smell karje though here 🙂... be careful

  • @wildmanrobsonsprinter4503
    @wildmanrobsonsprinter4503 5 років тому

    Terrible audio

    • @mrb7935
      @mrb7935 5 років тому +1

      Please like, subscribe and share this video so others can benefit! Baarak allahu feek

  • @pvreijmersdal
    @pvreijmersdal 4 роки тому +1

    Cognitive dissonance.....

  • @muslimforever6406
    @muslimforever6406 5 років тому +2

    The fool wants to talk about matters that do not affect his soul and daily life and wants to divert from the first commandment and the only one thing that really matters. Monotheism. He is trying to drive a car without a key to ignite the engine.

    • @faisalsiraj9423
      @faisalsiraj9423 5 років тому +1

      The guy is actually discrediting what Jesus Christ himself gave as the top priority subject even as per the guy's Bible.
      According to Jesus Christ there is NO commandment greater than the first commandment. The first commandment deals with the subject of God. The Christian is not even respecting the priority given by Jesus Christ himself.

    • @faisalsiraj9423
      @faisalsiraj9423 5 років тому +1

      Simply put: That Christian is not sincere. If I can recall correctly this guy has been to the park before and engaged with Muslims before and he's just full of gymnastics and evasions.

    • @mrb7935
      @mrb7935 5 років тому

      Please like, subscribe and share this video so others can benefit! Baarak allahu feek

  • @palokain
    @palokain 3 роки тому

    MAX ignorance Christian

  • @importantemail5481
    @importantemail5481 3 роки тому

    Al humdullah for Islam, I’ve realised Christianity is a very, confusing religion